Waves of Devotion

Bhakti-rasa-tarangi

Waves of Devotion A Comprehensive Study of the Nectar of Devotion

Dhanurdhara Swami

Author's Preface Waves of Devotion is a commentary on Srila Prabhupada's Nectar of Devotion. It is probably one of the last things you would expect from someone who was formerly the coach of a high school soccer team in Johnson City, NY. Suprisingly, however, the history behind the compilation of Waves of Devotion shows that being a coach was perhaps my best qualification for the work. I'm good at putting together teams. 1 i. history Nectar of Devotion is Srila Prabhupada's summary study of Srila Rupa Gosvami's Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. Since its first release in 1970, devotees eagerly studied Nectar of Devotion and were thus introduced to the basic principles and practices of devotional service, as well as to the loving sentiments of the Lord's eternal associates in Vrindaban. Most ISKCON devotees regularly study The Nectar of Devotion — I know many who proclaim it their favorite book. Still, a number of its sections remained difficult to grasp. Thus all of us were enlivened when, in January of 1988, His Holiness Tamala Krsna Maharaja joined the Vrindaban Institute for Higher Education (VIHE) and taught a course on Nectar of Devotion. Tamala Krsna Maharaja was certainly an appropriate person to teach the course. In 1985, he wrote Jagannatha-priya-natakam (the first English drama based on Sanskrit dramaturgy), which required that he deeply study Nataka-candrika, by Srila Rupa Gosvami. Nataka-candrika elaborately describes rasa-tattva — the basis of Sanskrit drama, and of the later, more difficult sections in The Nectar of Devotion. To further his realization of these difficult subjects, Tamala Krsna Maharaja also consulted with Sripad B.V. Narayana Maharaja, a devoted follower of Srila Rupa Gosvami, and an authority on his teachings. Tamala Krsna Maharaja's impressive presentation substantially deepened my knowledge and appreciation of The Nectar of Devotion. However, twenty-four lectures of only fifty minutes each was far too little time to comprehensively cover the book's fifty-one chapters. I was inspired to study in more depth. For me to learn a subject deeply, I must teach it. Thus in 1987 I began preparing a course on The Nectar of Devotion for the VIHE's Karttika semester; limiting myself to the first 19 chapters. As I expected, having to express the philosophical intricacies of The Nectar of Devotion forced me to confront my shortcomings in scholarship, and inspired me to 1

What is a "com mentary"? Nyäyakoça defi nes: Tékyate praviçyate jïäyate vänayä iti tékä — A commentary is that by which we understand a subject clearly. 1

delve deeper into the subject. When I could not manage to clearly explain a section to my class, I would consult Srila Jiva Gosvami and Srila Visvanatha Cakravarti Thakura's commentaries on Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. My access to these limitlessly valuable works was made possible by the scholarship of Sriman Navadvipa Prabhu, who teaches Hindi and writing at the Bhaktivedanta Swami International Gurukula — where, for the past nineteen years, I have been the Principal. If still more clarification was required, I would go to the head of our Sanskrit Department, Sriman Satyanarayana Prabhu, who has thoroughly studied the main works of the Six Gosvamis with renowned Vrindaban scholars. I continued the process of learning-by-lecturing whenever I got the chance; teaching several VIHE semesters, two one-week seminars at the Gita-Nagari Institute, and a one-week seminar at the VIHE in Belgium. During my summer travels, I would even give Sunday Feast lectures and "home programs" based on relevant sections of The Nectar of Devotion. 2 At the same time, His Holiness Giriraja Swami and His Grace Bhurijana Prabhu each embarked on very comprehensive studies of the book, supplemented with the many verses of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu that Srila Prabhupada translated and commented upon in his Caitanya-caritamrta. When I got the opportunity, I would attend their classes. These brilliant Vaisnavas understood many important concepts in The Nectar of Devotion far more deeply than myself, although I had been studying the book almost exclusively for several years. By hearing from them, and by discussing The Nectar of Devotion with them, I gained important insights into the text. My desire to help people clearly understand the book increased, and I felt the need for something to be written on the subject. Eventually, I decided to try writing something on The Nectar of Devotion. As I had lacked the scholarship to effectively teach The Nectar of Devotion, I lacked even more the skills to write a commentary on it. But since I was a coach, I was good at forming teams. I had formed a team of devotees to help me teach. Now I would form a team to help me write. Initially, Waves of Devotion was in the form of chapter summaries, prepared for my "Nectar of Devotion Overview" in the VIHE's Gaura Purnima semester of January 1992. Each chapter summary connected various paragraphs in The Nectar of Devotion by clarifying essential themes and adding some pertinent comments from my research. The students found the materials extremely useful. Having tasted Waves of Devotion, there was not a single student in my class who didn't implore me to finish the work. Nonetheless, considerably more work was needed before the chapter summaries could be printed as a book. If the philosophical subtleties of The Nectar of 2

Such as "Relief from M aterial Di stress" (C hapter One); "Devot ional Service in Practice" (Chapter Two); and Kåñna's 64 Transcendental Qualities (Chapters 21 - 22). 2

Devotion were to be properly expressed, Waves of Devotion would have to be substantially edited, for clarity and force. Many topics from the later sections still needed research. I needed help. To spread Krsna consciousness in Kali-Yuga, Lord Caitanya has hidden many qualified devotees, with the talents to spread Krsna consciousness, in strange forms. To assist me in writing Waves of Devotion I needed a devotee with fixed devotional practices, talent in writing, and ability to understand the subtleties of philosophy. I found such a devotee in the guise of a raging Hardcore guitarist and revolutionary Hare Krsna straight-edge leader, Vic 108! 3 Vic 108 (who took initiation from me in February of 1992, and received the name Vraja Kishor das) visits me yearly in Vrindaban. On my request, he eagerly took up the task of editing. Actually, he would do more than editing: I had significantly redrafted my chapter summaries to the point of a more complete book. Vraja Kishor would help bring it the rest of the way. This included rewriting key sections of the book after suggesting points that could be developed, creating the helpful diagrams, doing substantial editing, organizing and laying-out the text, and adding the Appendices and Sanskrit Glossary. Over the next two years I sent Vraja Kishor the drafts of further chapters. Considering I was his Guru, I was initially quite surprised how unabashedly he took to editing my words! But my tendency is to give maximum initiative and encouragement to the members of my team. When I found points that Vraja Kishor did not properly understand and express, I corrected him. But for the most part, Vraja Kishor's suggestions for improving the text were brilliant. Still, something more was required. Again I turned to Navadvipa Prabhu, who is also an excellent scholar with exceptional ability to analyse and grasp philosophy. Although by nature he keeps himself in the background, many senior ISKCON Vaisnavas consult him on various philosophical points, and request his assistance in research. Navadvipa Prabhu checked my analysis against the original commentaries, point by point. By incorporating his suggestions, I felt my presentation had become thorough. To understand many of the difficult passages in the later sections, I required translations of the original verses. Navadvipa Prabhu not only translated them, he lent me his personal copy of The Nectar of Devotion — in which he had written the original verse numbers alongside the corresponding text, allowing easy cross-reference between the two. Again, when it was necessary, he would research Srila Jiva Goswami's commentary and add pertinent comments.

3

108 is the name of his band. 3

Finally, my friend Satyaraja Prabhu (Steven Rosen), author of many books on Gauòiya Vaisnavism, offered his assistance as a copy editor, and to look over the book from the viewpoint of academia. My team, and my book, was complete. I hope this history serves to explain how one not conversant with the original language of the text, not talented in writing, nor a particularly gifted academic, could produce a commentary on The Nectar of Devotion.

4

Introduction Since The Nectar of Devotion is already the commentary of a self realized soul, what is the need to comment on it at all? Srila Prabhupada himself said that his books were written not by him, but by Krsna. Thus aren't they already perfect? The Vedas emanate directly from the Supreme Lord's breathing. Still, they are understood with the help of a teacher — acaryavan puruso veda. Like the Vedas, Srila Prabhupada's books are transcendental sound vibration (sabda brahman). Thus the same principle holds for them: they become more accessible through the aid of a teacher. Commenting on Srila Prabhupada's books is not unprecedented in ISKCON. A simple example is our daily Srimad-Bhagavatam class, which Srila Prabhupada himself instituted. Again, the principle of acaryavan puruso veda is at work: learning erudite Vaisnavas deepens our comprehension and appreciation of Srila Prabhupada's books. I'd like to briefly share my personal experience of how essential it is to learn Srila Prabhupada's books from a teacher. Every year, I teach a five-month course on Bhagavada-Gita. This rigorous course requires that I be capable of analyzing each verse in context of the various themes and sub-themes within and between each chapter. Obviously, this requires very thorough knowledge of the book. Even after studying on my own for many years, I would have never been able to teach this course without attending the classes given in 1985 by His Holiness Jagadisa Goswami, or without hearing Satyanarayana Prabhu translate the commentaries of Srila Visvanatha Cakravarti Thakura and Srila Baladeva Vidyabhusana, or without taking His Grace Bhurijana Prabhu's "Bhagavada-Gita Overview" three times. I thus remain indebted to my teachers for helping me come closer to my spiritual master, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Srila Prabhupada — by making his vani, the instructions in his books, clearer to me. Everything is in Srila Prabhupada's books, which are complete in and of themselves. A sincere and qualified follower can realize the full import of Vedic knowledge by serving Srila Prabhupada and reading his books. However, due to our own deficiencies in devotion and scholarship, we sometimes have difficulty understanding them deeply. Sometimes we even lose enthusiasm to read them. A teacher who has realized the subject can help us. What does it mean to "realize the subject"? Personal realization does not mean that one should, out of vanity, attempt to show one's own learning by trying to surpass the previous acarya. He must have full confidence in the previous acarya, and at the same time he must realize the subject matter so nicely that he can present the matter for the particular circumstances in a suitable manner. The original purpose of the text must be maintained. No obscure 5

meaning should be screwed out of it, yet it should be presented in an interesting manner for the understanding of the audience. This is called realization. [SB 1.4.1,p]

Vaisnavas who have deeply studied Srila Prabhupada's books can help us increase our understanding and appreciation of them. In fact, it is the duty of the disciple to become thoroughly conversant in the teachings of his spiritual master — and present them to others in a way which increases their interest in following them. Waves of Devotion is one such attempt. ii. "errors" and "corrections" To properly convey the import of Srila Prabhupada's words, transcribers and editors must themselves be quite learned in the intricacies of Vaisnava philosophy. When Srila Prabhupada began writing The Nectar of Devotion over twenty-five years ago, in many cases they were not. Consequently, mistakes were sometimes made. Teaching The Nectar of Devotion and writing Waves of Devotion sometimes required that I research the Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu to clarify the original statements of Srila Prabhupada. Again, this is not unprecedented. The first edition of Bhagavada-Gita As It Is was comprehensively re-edited. Transcriptional and editorial errors were corrected, and the text was thus brought closer to the original statements of Srila Prabhupada. For example, in the first edition of Bhagavada-Gita As It Is (10.29), the word pitrloka (pronounced: "pit-tree-low-kuh") was translated as "the planet of the trees." Even an elementary student of Krsna consciousness can understand that pitrloka is a Sanskrit word, not an English one, and refers to the planet (loka) of the ancestors ("pit-trees") — not to "the planet of the trees." Of course, this is a fairly crude mistake, but if we compare the final edition of Bhagavada-Gita to the one originally produced, we will find many intricacies of Srila Prabhupada's writing missed by inexperienced transcribers or editors. There are similar problems in the transcription and editing of The Nectar of Devotion, especially since it was an earlier work and more complex by nature. In clarifying Bhagavada-Gita, devotees had access to the tapes of Srila Prabhupada's original dictation. In clarifying The Nectar of Devotion, I did not. To the best of my knowledge, they no longer exist. However, I feel that my access to the original texts and commentaries of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu allowed me to, in some instances, bring the text of The Nectar of Devotion closer to Srila Prabhupada's original statements. For example: In Srimad-Bhagavatam (11.6.46), Uddhava says, “My dear Krsna, I have taken things which You have used and enjoyed, such as garlands of flowers, saintly articles, garments and ornaments... (NOD Page 74)” The phrase saintly articles should be scented oils. The Sanskrit word used here is gandha — "scents." The phonetic similarity between saintly articles and scented oils makes it obvious that the original 6

transcriber did not hear Srila Prabhupada properly. [Waves of Devotion, page ]

Another example, from the Thirty-Eighth Chapter of The Nectar of Devotion: As far as the feverish condition of the body is concerned, Uddhava once told Narada, "My dear great sage, the lotus flower that is a friend of the sun may be a cause of distress for us, the fire in the ocean may cause us some burning sensation, and Indivara, the friend of a demon, may distress us in various ways — we do not mind. But the most regrettable factor is that all of them remind us of Krsna, and this is giving us too much distress!"

The statement, "Indivara, the friend of a demon" should read, "Indivara, the friend of the moon." I surmise that Srila Prabhupada's strong accent may have led the transcribers to hear Srila Prabhupada's friend of de-moon as "friend of demon"! 4 The above two examples are clearly transcriptional errors. Still, even if all of Srila Prabhupada's words were heard and transcribed perfectly, he was expressing complex philosophical concepts in a foreign language (English) and therefore required experienced editors conversant with the subject mater. To the extent this was lacking, clarity was lost. Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu uses meticulous Sanskrit terminology, essential for understanding it's intricacies. Being conversant with neither the Sanskrit terms nor the concepts they represented, Srila Prabhupada's editors were unable to effectively emend The Nectar of Devotion for consistency in terminology. As a result, one may find it difficult to grasp some of the complex points Srila Prabhupada presented. There are many cases of this. One example concerns an ecstatic symptom (vyabhicari-bhava) called nirveda. In The Nectar of Devotion, nirveda is sometimes translated as "self-disparagement," sometimes as "disappointment," sometimes "depression," "hopelessness," "despair," "lamentation," etc. All these synonyms correctly convey the meaning of nirveda, but they also correctly convey the meaning of other vyabhicari-bhavas (visada — "depression," soka — "lamentation"). Thus, when we read, "This is an instance of lamentation in ecstatic love," exactly what does that mean? Is it an instance of nirveda, or visada, or soka? Waves of Devotion is therefore intended to give relevant comments, when necessary, to help the readers understand many of the more difficult passages of The Nectar of Devotion.

4

Indévara is not the name of a person, it is a type of blue lotus flower. The original Sanskrit for this text of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (3.2.118) i s indévaraà vidhu-suhåt. The Indévara l otus i s a fri end of t he moon because it is night-blooming. 7

iii. "summary study" The Nectar of Devotion is not a translation of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. It is a summary study. Srila Prabhupada's main intention in writing The Nectar of Devotion was not to produce an edition that would win respect among circles of academicians and Sanskrit scholars. His intention was practical: to quickly provide his very young American disciples with an essential understanding of the basic practices and ideals of Krsna consciousness, and introduce the Western world to the beauty of our devotional conceptions. He himself tells us this: “The Nectar of Devotion is specifically presented for persons who are now engaged in the Krsna consciousness movement (page xvii).” If we consider that the Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu has 2,129 verses, almost three times as many as Bhagavada-Gita; and if we consider that the verses of Bhaktirasamrta-sindhu often describe complex philosophical points and subtle nuances in rasa and are thus far more complex than Bhagavada-Gita — it becomes clear that a comprehensive commentary would have taken Srila Prabhupada several years to complete, if not more. Would that be the best use of his time, when in 1970 most of his disciples were relatively inexperienced, and thus substantial portions of Bhaktirasamrta-sindhu had little relevance to them? Was it the best use of Srila Prabhupada's time, considering that he had not yet even presented them with Bhagavada-Gita, Srimad-Bhagavatam, or Caitanya-caritamrta? Comparing The Nectar of Devotion to the verses of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu makes it evident that Srila Prabhupada gave his dictations while systematically consulting the original text and commentaries, as was his standard in translating other prominent Vaisnava scriptures. However, In The Nectar of Devotion he did not use his standard format: Sanskrit script, Roman transliteration, Sanskrit/English word-forword, English translation, and commentary for each text. Thus he could sometimes take the liberty to greatly expand the original text when he felt that his audience needed a more relevant explanation. 5 He could also drastically summarize sections he felt were not so relevant to his audience at that time. 6 In translated sections in the last division of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu he would sometimes even omit tens of verses at a stretch. To fully appreciate Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, one requires a complete translation of the texts and commentaries. Srila Prabhupada's widely acclaimed Bhagavada-Gita, Srimad-Bhagavatam, and Caitanya-caritamrta attest to his qualification for this task. If Srila Prabhupada had stayed with us longer, surely he would have given us a complete translation of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu — as he gave us Caitanya-caritamrta even after 5

His elaborate description of the yogic-siddhis and their comparison to modern science are an example of this. (See NOD, pages 11 - 12.)

6

An exam ple i s hi s bri ef summary of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé's three verses describing the practices of rägänugä-sädhana-bhakti, which are elaborately com mented on, and which Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura has even developed into a small book. (See NOD, page 126.) 8

previously publishing it's summary study, Teachings of Lord Caitanya; and as he gave us the Tenth Canto even after previously publishing it's summary study, Krsna, The Supreme Personality of Godhead. Srila Prabhupada said that Lord Caitanya could have spread Krsna consciousness all over the world, but He left something for us to do. Srila Prabhupada also told us that he had build the framework for spreading Krsna consciousness, but we, his followers, should fill in the details. He did not give us a complete translation and commentary on the Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. So Waves of Devotion attempts to take up the service left for us by Srila Prabhupada — to fill in the details. iv. too advanced? It is sometimes misunderstood that Srila Prabhupada purposely did not elaborate all the sections of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu because some of the topics were too advanced to be made publicly accessible. However, we find that Srila Prabhupada translated and widely distributed the Caitanya-caritamrta — a book that quotes major portions of the advanced topics in Srila Rupa Gosvami's Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu and Ujjvalanilamani. 7 Since Srila Prabhupada translated and commented upon these verses, it is clear that he desired to make these topics accessible. v. "waves of devotion" For the most part, Srila Prabhupada at least briefly summarized every verse in Bhaktirasamrta-sindhu. Consequently, I was able to solidly base the present book on His authoritative statements. Therefore we have entitled the book Waves of Devotion (Bhakti-rasa-tarangi): Waves are born from the ocean, heighten the ocean, and then merge within it. Similarly, the explanations in Waves of Devotion are born the statements in Nectar of Devotion. They further explain Srila Prabhupada's statements, and thus heighten or expand them. Finally, after hearing these explanations one will find the very same points in Srila Prabhupada's own statements. Waves of Devotion will thus merge in the ocean of The Nectar of Devotion. Waves are not just born from the ocean, their very existence depends upon its support. Similarly, every comment in Waves of Devotion is authorized by a corresponding statement from Srila Prabhupada's Nectar of Devotion.

7

Çréla Rüpa Gosväm é describes Ujjvala-nélamani as an even m ore advanced suppl ement t o Bhaktirasämåta-sindhu. The Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu gi ves onl y a bri ef descri ption of mädhurya-rasa. Ujjvala-nélamani, however, exclusively and extensively describes mädhurya-rasa. Kåñnadäsa Kaviräja quoted extensively from this book, and Ç réla Prabhupäda present ed these quotations in his Caitanyacaritämåta. 9

vi. faults or glories? Sometimes scholars criticise The Nectar of Devotion. They find omissions and apparent errors similar to the ones that I have pointed out. In one sense, their analysis is not unjustified — Since translations of philosophical treatises are expected to meet strict academic standards. However, Srila Prabhupada was a unique translator and commentator. Never before was spiritual teacher requested to not only enlighten the masses, but to literally transplant an entire culture — and to begin this work at the end of his life. Thus his primary concern was to quickly and effectively communicate Krsna consciousness. Academic standards were secondary. Devotees and scholars should see The Nectar of Devotion as it was intended to be seen — as a summary study of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu; which Srila Prabhupada urgently gave his young disciples, to root them in the science of bhakti-yoga, spark some devotion in their hearts, and give them a basic grasp of the spiritual practices and ideals of Krsna consciousness. Srila Prabhupada was successful. By the mass distribution of The Nectar of Devotion, thousands upon thousands of sincere spiritual seekers were, and still are, introduced to and inspired by "The Complete Science of Bhakti-Yoga." Indeed, probably more people have studied Srila Rupa Gosvami's teachings through The Nectar of Devotion than through the original text. If we judge The Nectar of Devotion in this light, its apparent shortcomings are seen as it's glory; for they reflect the urgency and boldness of an intensely compassionate Vaisnava in giving Krsna consciousness to the world. In Srimad-Bhagavatam (1.5.11) Narada Muni describes how an "imperfectly composed" scripture can be glorious: tad-vag-visargo janatagha-viplavo yasmin prati-slokam abaddhavaty api namany anantasya yaso ìkitani yat srnvanti gayanti grnanti sadhavah On the other hand, that literature which is full of descriptions of the transcendental glories of the name, fame, forms, pastimes, etc., of the unlimited Supreme Lord is a different creation, full of transcendental words directed toward bringing about a revolution in the impious lives of this world's misdirected civilization. Such transcendental literatures, even though imperfectly composed, are heard, sung and accepted by purified men who are thoroughly honest.

Srila Prabhupada appeared to fulfil the prediction of Vyasadeva and Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu, that a revolution of Krsna consciousness would be spread all over the world. To assist his mission, he distributed an ocean of Krsna consciousness (Bhaktirasamrta-sindhu). Waves of Devotion is simply an attempt to assist Srila Prabhupada by helping his followers (especially) to dive deeper into that ocean. 10

CONTENTS Author's Preface Introduction

iii vi

i Nectar of Devotion's Preface

18

Eastern Ocean: Varieties of Devotional Service First Wave: Samanya-Bhakti — Overview of Devotional Service Introduction Chapter 1 - Characteristics of Pure Devotional Service

Second Wave: Sadhana-Bhakti — Devotional Service in Practice Part 1: Vaidhi-Sadhana — Regulative Practice Chapter 2 - The First Stages of Devotion Chapter 3 - Eligibility of the Candidate Chapter 4 - Devotional Service Surpasses All Liberation Chapter 5 - The Purity of Devotional Service Chapter 6 - How to Discharge Devotional Service Chapter 7 - Evidence Regarding Devotional Principles Chapter 8 - Offences to Be Avoided Chapter 9 - Further Consideration of Devotional Principles Chapter 10 - Techniques of Hearing and Remembering Chapter 11 - Aspects of Transcendental Service Chapter 12 - Further Aspects of Transcendental Service

11

Chapter 13 - Five Potent Forms of Devotional Service Chapter 14 - Devotional Qualifications Part 2: Raganuga-Sadhana — Spontaneous Practice Chapter 15 - Spontaneous Devotional Service Chapter 16 - Spontaneous Devotion Further Described

Third Wave: Bhava-Bhakti — Devotional Service in Ecstasy Chapter 17 - Ecstatic Love Chapter 18 - Character of One in Ecstatic Love

Fourth Wave: Prema-Bhakti — Devotional Service in Pure Love of Godhead Chapter 19 - Devotional Service in Pure Love of God

12

Southern Ocean: Overview of Bhakti-Rasa First Wave: Vibhava — Ecstatic Stimulants Chapter 20 - Transcendental Mellow Chapter 21 - Qualities of Sri Krsna Chapter 22 - Qualities of Krsna Further Explained Chapter 23 - Krsna's Personality Chapter 24 - Further Traits of Sri Krsna Chapter 25 - Devotees of Krsna Chapter 26 - Stimulation for Ecstatic Love

Second Wave: Anubhava — Subsequent Ecstasy Chapter 27 - Symptoms of Ecstatic Love

Third Wave: Sattvika-Bhava — Existential Ecstasy Chapter 28 - Existential Ecstatic Love

Fourth Wave: Vyabhicari-Bhava — Transitory Ecstasies Chapter 29 - Expressions of Love for Krsna Chapter 30 - Further Features of Ecstatic Love for Krsna Chapter 31 - Additional Symptoms

Fifth Wave: Sthayi-Bhava — Constitutional Ecstasy Chapter 32 - Symptoms of Continuous Ecstasy Chapter 33 - Indirect Expressions of Ecstatic Love Chapter 34 - The Nectar of Devotion

Western Ocean: Direct Bhakti-Rasa 13

First Wave: Santa-Rasa — Neutral Affection Chapter 35 - Neutral Love of God

Second Wave: Priti-Rasa — Servitude Chapter 36 - Transcendental Affection (Servitude) Chapter 37 - Impetuses for Krsna's Service Chapter 38 - Indifference and Separation Chapter 39 - Ways of Meeting Krsna Chapter 40 - Reverential Devotion of Sons & Subordinates

Third Wave: Preyo-Rasa — Friendship Chapter 41 - Fraternal Devotion Chapter 42 - Fraternal Loving Affairs

Fourth Wave: Vatsala-Rasa — Parenthood Chapter 43 - Parenthood

Fifth Wave: Madhura-Rasa — Consorthood Chapter 44 - Devotional Service in Conjugal Love

Northern Ocean: Indirect Bhakti-Rasa First Wave: Hasya-Rasa — Laughter Chapter 45 - Laughing Ecstasy

Second & Third Waves: Adbhuta-Rasa & Vira-Rasa — Astonishment & Chivalry Chapter 46 - Astonishment & Chivalry

14

Fourth & Fifth Waves: Karuna-Rasa & Raudra-Rasa — Compassion & Anger Chapter 47 - Compassion & Anger

Sixth & Seventh Waves: Bhayananka & Vibhatsa-Rasa Dread & Ghastliness Chapter 48 - Dread & Ghastliness

Eighth Wave: Maitri-Vaira-Sthiti — Compatible & Incompatible Mixture of Mellows Chapter 49 - Mixing of Rasas Chapter 50 - Further Analysis of Mixed Rasas

Ninth Wave: Rasabhasa — Imperfect Expression of Mellows Chapter 51 - Perverted Expression of Mellows

Appendixes Glossary

15

Preface

The preface deals mainly with two subjects: (1) a brief history of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu including a biography of its author, and (2) bhakti-rasa, a primary subject of Bhakti-rasamrtasindhu.

BRIEF HISTORY Sri Krsna Caitanya Mahaprabhu is the original speaker of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. Srila Rupa Gosvami heard Him for ten days on the bank of the Gaìga — at Dasasvamedha-ghata in Prayaga. The Gosvami assimilated the Lord's instructions and systematically presented them in writing. In 1970, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada summarized Bhakti-rasamrtasindhu and gave it to the world as The Nectar of Devotion. 8

“BHAKTI-RASAMRTA-SINDHU” Bhakti-rasa is the primary subject of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. Srila Prabhupada introduces this subject by briefly commenting on the book's title.

Bhakti Srila Prabhupada says, “Bhakti means ‘devotional service’ (pg xii).” Bhakti connotes devotion or love, and love implies service — activity to please the beloved. Thus "devotional service" is an eloquent definition of bhakti. 9 Devotion is the most fundamental drive of every living entity. “The basic principle of the living condition is that we have a general propensity to love someone. No one can live without loving someone else (pg xv).” We cannot be happy without satisfying this desire to love. We will not be able to perfectly fulfil this desire without permitting its expansion to the most inclusive extent. “In the primary stage a child loves his parents, then his brothers and sisters, and as he daily grows up he begins to love his family, society, community, country, nation, or even the whole human society. But the loving propensity is not satisfied even by loving all human society; that loving propensity remains imperfectly fulfilled until we know who is the supreme beloved (pg xv).” Srila Prabhupada says that love can become all-embracing only when we understand that Krsna is the supreme beloved. He is the root of all creation. By embracing Him one successfully embraces everyone, as pouring water on the root of a tree successfully nourishes every leaf and branch. “The Nectar of Devotion teaches us the science of loving every one of the living entities perfectly by the easy method of loving Krsna (pg xv).” The loving propensity expands like a beam of light. By instructing us to love Krsna, “The Nectar of Devotion will teach us how to turn the one switch that will immediately brighten 8

Jéva Gosvämé and Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura are the two most significant commentators on Bhakti-rasämåtasindhu.

9

"Mitaà ca säraà ca vaco hi vägmitä" iti — “Essential truth spoken concisely is true eloquence.” (Cc. Adi 1.106) 16

everything, everywhere. One who does not know this method is missing the point of life (pg xvi).”

Rasa Rasa is difficult to translate. Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Maharaja translated it as "mellow." Srila Prabhupada followed in his footsteps. “The word rasa, used in the Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, is understood by different persons differently because the exact English equivalent is very difficult to find. But as we have seen our spiritual master translate this word rasa into "mellow," we shall follow in his footsteps and also translate the word in that way (pg 151).” Literally, rasa means "juice." Contextually, it means "mellow." Mellow means, "Sweet and full-flavored from ripeness, as fruit." 10 Thus "mellow" refers to the relishably sweet taste of a fruit — a taste contained in it's juice. Relationships are comparable to fruits. The pleasure we taste in these relationships is the juice, the mellow — the rasa. The taste of a fruit is what attracts us to eat it. Similarly, the force that attracts us to a certain activity or relationship is the taste we enjoy in it. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Driven by affection for his wife and children, a family man works day and night. A philanthropist works in the same way for love of the greater family, and a nationalist for the cause of his country and countrymen. That force which drives the philanthropist, the householder and the nationalist is called rasa, or a kind of mellow (relationship) whose taste is very sweet (pg xiii).” There are two kinds of tastes: (1) bhakti-rasa — the taste relished in devotional service to Krsna, and (2) mundane-"rasa" — the taste enjoyed by sense gratification. Bhakti-rasa is the incalculably superior taste. Not only is it superior to sense gratification, it is limitlessly superior even to the bliss of spiritual emancipation. Srila Rupa Gosvami describes, “If brahmananda, or the happiness of becoming one with the Supreme, is multiplied by one trillion-fold, it still cannot be compared to an atomic fraction of the happiness derived from the ocean of devotional service (pg 15).” It is impossible for us to fully understand the infinite happiness relished in bhakti because it is beyond the realm of anything we can experience in our finite existence. Srila Prabhupada, however, gives us a glimpse of bhakti-rasa by comparing it to something we are quite familiar with: mundane-rasa.

Mundane-"Rasa" Srila Prabhupada describes mundane-rasa by noting it's two qualities: (1) bhoga-tyaga — oscillation between enjoyment and renunciation, and (2) capala-sukha — flickering duration of happiness. Bhoga-Tyaga Neither enjoyment (bhoga) nor renunciation (tyaga) is the natural position of the soul. Therefore one cannot remain permanently situated in either; one will oscillate between the two, finding satisfaction in neither. 10

Random House Webster's. 17

Capala-Sukha The happiness (sukha) of mundane-rasa is always temporary and flickering (capala). Even the greatest material pleasure must end at death.

Bhakti-Rasa Srila Prabhupada illustrates the superiority of bhakti-rasa over mundane-rasa by contrasting the two. (See pg xiii.) Mundane-rasa is bhoga-tyaga. In contrast, bhakti-rasa is the natural position of the soul, and thus one can remain satisfied there perpetually, without oscillation. Mundane-rasa is capala-sukha. In contrast, the pleasure of bhakti-rasa does not flicker.

Amrta Since the pleasure of bhakti-rasa does not fade, it is amrta — deathless. “Bhakti-rasa, however, the mellow relished in the transcendental loving service of the Lord, does not finish with the end of life. It continues perpetually and is therefore called amrta, that which does not die but exists eternally (pg xiv).” Srila Prabhupada explains that the activities of devotional service are never vanquished, even by death. Amrta also means "nectar," a tasty beverage which makes one deathless. Devotional service not only bestows eternal pleasure, it is also the process of achieving eternality.

Bhakti-Rasamrta-Sindhu The nectarean pleasure derived from devotional service to Krsna is clearly superior to material sense gratification. One may sometimes manage to procure a few drops of sense pleasure, but there is an entire ocean (sindhu) of the nectar of devotion easily available to everyone, always. By understanding The Nectar of Devotion, one can dive deeply into that ocean. (See page xvi.)

18

Part One: Eastern Ocean

I: Bhagavad-Bhakti-Bheda — Varieties of Devotional Service 1: Samanya-Bhakti — Overview of Devotional Service

Introduction - Chapter One

2: Sadhana-Bhakti — Devotional Service in Practice

Chapters Two - Sixteen

3: Bhava-Bhakti — Devotional Service in Ecstasy

Chapters Seventeen & Eighteen

4: Prema-Bhakti — Devotional Service in Love of God

Chapter Nineteen

19

Eastern Ocean First Wave Samanya-Bhakti

Introduction - Chapter One

20

Introduction BRS 1.1.1 - 16

The Introduction to The Nectar of Devotion includes three topics: (1) The maìgalacaranam of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, (2) a brief description of the book's contents, and (3) an authoritative definition of pure devotional service.

MAÌGALACARANAM A maìgalacaranam is an auspicious invocation; thus Srila Prabhupada's first words in the Introduction are, “Invoking auspiciousness (pg xix).” Krsna dasa Kaviraja Gosvami explains that a maìgalacaranam accomplishes three ends: (1) define the book's objective, (2) offer obeisances, and (3) offer benedictions. 1 The first six verses of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu comprise Srila Rupa Gosvami's maìgalacaranam.

The First Verse (First Paragraph of Introduction) The first verse of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu defines the book's objective: Lord Sri Krsna. He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead because He is the reservoir of all rasas (akhila-rasamrtamurtih). Srila Prabhupada translates this verse in Caitanya-caritamrta (Madhya 8.142): akhila-rasamrta-murtih prasrmara-ruci-ruddha-taraka-palih kalita-syama-lalito radha-preyan vidhur jayati Let Krsna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, be glorified! By virtue of His expanding attractive features, He subjugated the gopis named Taraka and Pali and absorbed Syama and Lalita. He is the most attractive lover of Srimati Radharani, and is the reservoir of pleasure for all devotional mellows.

Krsna — Reservoir of all Rasa Krsna's supremacy is His all-lovable personality, not His position of majesty and authority. In the Caitanya-caritamrta (Adi 2.29), Srila Prabhupada explains this by comparing Lord Narayana to a high-court judge. The judge is a majestic and powerful figure in the courtroom, but only in the privacy of his own home is he fully manifest. At home, the judge abundantly reveals his intimate and sweet personality: To his old parents he is an obedient and faithful son, to his friends a bosom chum, and to his mate a passionate lover. Similarly, when Lord Narayana performs the creationary role of God, He reveals only His majesty and power. At home in Vrndavana, however, the fullness of His wonderfully sweet 1

Cc. Adi 1.22: "The i nvocation involves three processes: defining the objective, offering benedictions, and offeri ng obeisances." Cc. Adi 1.20: "In t he begi nning of t his narration [maìgaläcaranam], s imply b y r emembering t he spiritual master, the devotees of the Lord, and the Personality of Godhead, I have invoked their blessings." 21

personality blossoms. Therefore Srila Rupa Gosvami addresses Vrndavana-Krsna as akhilarasamrta-murti, and singles Him out as the objective of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. 2

Krsna — Attractor of the Gopis “...by His universal and transcendental attractive features He has captivated all the gopis, headed by Tarika, Palika, Syama, Lalita, and ultimately Srimati Radharani (page xix).” Srila Rupa Gosvami groups five different gopis according to the intensity of their affection for Krsna: Taraka and Palika, Syama and Lalita, and Srimati Radharani. By His radiantly attractive features Krsna "subjugates" Taraka and Palika; He controls them. Krsna "absorbs" Syama and Lalita; He takes them into His own intimate circle. Srimati Radharani is the dearest to Krsna. He becomes Her submissive lover (radha-preyan). Such is the unrivalled power of Her devotion. 3 Krsna, the lover of Srimati Radharani and reservoir of all rasa, is the object and goal of Bhaktirasamrta-sindhu.

The Second Verse (Second Paragraph) hrdi yasya preranaya pravartito'ham varaka-rupo'pi tasya hareh pada-kamalamvande caitanya-devasya Although I am the lowest of men and have no knowledge, the inspiration to write transcendental literatures about devotional service has been mercifully bestowed upon me. Therefore I am offering my obeisances at the lotus feet of Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who has given me the chance to write these books. (Cc. Madhya 19.134) Srila Rupa Gosvami offers obeisances to Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu, who personally taught him the science of bhakti-rasa and inspired him to write Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. Srila Prabhupada was instructed in Krsna consciousness by his own spiritual master. Thus The Nectar of Devotion was more directly inspired by Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Maharaja and Srila Rupa Gosvami, the original author. Therefore he adjusts his summary so that this verse offers obeisances to them. “Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of Srila Rupa Gosvami Prabhupada and of Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Gosvami Prabhupada, by whose inspiration I have been engaged in the matter of compiling this summary study of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu (pg xix).”

2

Akhila-rasämåta-mürti m eans t hat Kåñna i s t he ful l em bodiment of al l rasa. In The Nectar of Devotion , Çréla Prabhupäda translates akhila-rasämåta-mürti as "the reservoir of all rasa (pg xix)." (akhila — full, every, all; rasa-amåta — nectarean mellows; mürti — embodiment, form.)

3

Bhaviñya Puräna mentions Tärikä and Pälikä — along with Çyäm ä, Lalitä, and Çrématé Rädhäräné — as being among ten most important gopés who attended the rasa dance. See BRS 1.1.1, Jéva Gosvämé's commentary.

4 22

Keeping close to the original text, Srila Prabhupada says, “This is the sublime science of devotional service as propounded by Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu, who appeared five hundred years ago in West Bengal, India, to propagate the movement of Krsna consciousness (pg xix).”

The Third Verse (Third Paragraph) Here Srila Rupa Gosvami offers obeisances to his guru, declaring that the sole purpose of Bhaktirasamrta-sindhu is to please him. Srila Prabhupada offered obeisances to his spiritual master in the previous paragraph, so he translates this verse in the third-person: “Srila Rupa Gosvami begins his great book by offering his respectful obeisances unto Sri Sanatana Gosvami, who is his elder brother and spiritual master, and he prays that Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu may be very pleasing to him (pg xix).” 4

The Fourth Verse (Fourth Paragraph) “Let us offer our respectful obeisances to all the great devotees and acaryas (holy teachers), who are compared to sharks in the great ocean of nectar and who do not care for the various rivers of liberation (pg xix).” Srila Rupa Gosvami uses the shark analogy to glorify devotees in three ways: (1) Sharks live only in the ocean, (2) Sharks reject the rivers, (3) Sharks are never caught in the fisherman's net.

Sharks Live Only in the Ocean Sharks refuse to reside in any lesser body of water. Similarly, devotees always relish the nectarean ocean of devotion, and are never attracted to any lesser pleasure.

Sharks Reject the Rivers Impersonalists argue that the ultimate end of self-realization is to merge with the Supreme, as a river ultimately merges with the ocean. “Impersonalists are very fond of merging into the Supreme, like rivers that come down and merge into the ocean (pg xix).” The fault in their argument: they fail to accurately distinguish the path of self-realization from the person who practices it. If the path of self-realization is like a river, then the person on the path is like a fish in the river; not the river itself. The river may merge with the ocean, but the fish in that river do not. They enter the ocean and experience it's variegated forms and entities. Srila Prabhupada explains, “The impersonalists are dwelling in the river water, which eventually comes to mix with the ocean. They have no information, however, that within the ocean, as within the river, there are innumerable aquatic living entities (pg xix).”

4

Çréla Rüpa Gosväm é uses the word sanätana with a doubl e meaning. Sanätana (wh ich literally m eans "etern al") can refer either to Kåñna the eternal Lo rd, or t o Sanät ana Gosvämé. Thus the maìgaläcarana's third verse offers obeisances to Guru and Kåñna simultaneously.

5 23

The real destination of self-realization is not to merge with the Supreme, but to enter the realm of the Supreme, which is full of innumerable forms and entities. Devotees have already achieved this destination. Therefore they never take to any process of self-realization other than bhakti. “The sharks who dwell in the ocean do not care for the rivers which are gliding down into it... [They] have no business with the other processes, which are compared to the rivers that only gradually come to the ocean (pgs xix - xx).”

Sharks are Never Caught by the Fisherman's Net Because devotees swim very deep in the ocean of devotional service they are never caught by the fisherman's net — the snares of birth and death.

The Fifth Verse (Fifth Paragraph) Srila Rupa Gosvami invokes a benediction for the protection of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu from argumentative logicians. “He compares their arguments and logic to volcanic eruptions in the midst of the ocean. In the midst of the ocean, volcanic eruptions can do very little harm, and similarly, those who are against the devotional service of the Lord and who put forward many philosophical theses about the ultimate transcendental realization cannot disturb this great ocean of devotional service (pg xx).” Srila Rupa Gosvami gives his blessings by indicating that those who study this book will become freed from the misconceptions of the impersonalists.

The Sixth Verse (Sixth Paragraph) In verse two, Srila Rupa Gosvami expressed his humble sentiments and attributed all credit for Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu to Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu's inspiration. In the sixth verse he similarly describes himself as incompetent. Srila Prabhupada sums up Srila Rupa Gosvami's humility and notes that it is the proper mood of a preacher: “That should be the attitude of all preachers of the Krsna consciousness movement, following in the footsteps of Srila Rupa Gosvami. We should never think of ourselves as great preachers, but should always consider that we are simply instrumental to the previous acaryas, and simply by following in their footsteps we may be able to do something for the benefit of suffering humanity (pg xx).” Srila Rupa Gosvami explains that his eagerness to write Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu stems from the desire to please the devotees. In this way he blesses whoever reads his book to achieve transcendental happiness.

CONTENTS OF BHAKTI-RASAMRTA-SINDHU Seventh Paragraph — Verses 7 - 9

“Originally, in Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, the ocean is divided like the watery ocean into east, south, west and north, while the subsections within these different divisions are called waves... In the first part there are four waves, the first being a general description of devotional service. The second concerns the regulative principles for executing devotional service, and the third wave, devotional service in ecstasy. In the fourth is the ultimate goal, love of God (pg xx).” 6 24

Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu The Ocean of the Nectar of Devotion Eastern Side Varities of Bhakti

Southern Side Overview of Rasa

1. Overview of Devotion 2. Dev. Service in Practice 3. Dev. Service in Ecstacy 4. Dev. Service in Love of God

1. Vibhäva 2. Anubhäva 3. Sättvika-bhäva 4. Vyabhicäré-bhäva 5. Sthäyé-bhäva

Western Side Primary Rasas 1. Neutrality 2. Servitude 3. Friendship 4. Parental 5. Conjugal

Northern Side Secondary Rasas 1. Laughter 2. Astonishment 3. Chivalry 4. Compasion 5. Anger 6. Fear 7. Ghastliness 8. Incompatable Mellows 9. Distorted Mellows

DEFINITION OF PURE DEVOTIONAL SERVICE From the top of page xxi, Srila Prabhupada begins to translate and explain the definition of uttama-bhakti — pure devotional service, which is the most important verse in Bhakti-rasamrtasindhu: 5 anyabhilasita-sunyam jnana-karmady-anavrtam anukulyena krsnanusilanam bhaktir uttama When first-class devotional service develops, one must be devoid of all material desires, knowledge obtained by monistic philosophy, and fruitive actions. The devotee must constantly serve Krsna favorably, as Krsna desires. (Cc. Mad 19.167) In other words, pure devotional service is activity intended to please Krsna, without ulterior motive, and not covered by philosophical or fruitive pursuits.

Svarupa-Laksanam — Primary Characteristics 6 In The Nectar of Devotion, Srila Prabhupada translates the primary characteristics of pure devotional service: “First-class devotional service is known by one's tendency to be fully engaged in Krsna consciousness, serving the Lord favorably (pg xxi).” There are three primary characteristics: (1) devotional service is for Krsna, (2) devotional service is an active engagement, and (3) devotional service is executed with favorable intent.

"Krsna" — Devotional Service is for Krsna Pure devotional service is for Krsna, not for anyone else. Of all the primary characteristics, this is the most essential.

5

This verse is the paribhäñä-sütra — the "thesis statement" upon which the entire book is based. In Hari-nämämröa-vyäkarana, Jéva Gosvämé defines paribhäñä-sütra as: Aniyame niyama-käriné paribhäñä. "A paribhäñä-sütra implies a rule or theme where it is n ot explicitly stated." In other words, it gives the context in which to understand a series of apparently unrelated statements in a book. Çréla Prabhupäda' s expl anation of t his verse (B RS 1.1.11) draws mainly from the commentary of Jéva Gosvämé.

6

The nayäkoça defines svarüpa-lakñanam as: svarüpamera lakñanam — t hat whi ch descri bes t he fundamental nature of an object or person.

7 25

It may seem a bit too exclusive to say that devotion is only for Krsna and no one else. What about the people around us, can't we also love them? We can only love Krsna, but Krsna is not ordinary. “When we speak of ‘Krsna’ we refer to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, along with His many expansions (pg xxiii).” In other words, Krsna and His expansions are proper recipients of our pure devotion. Srila Prabhupada explains "many expansions:" “He is expanded by His plenary parts and parcels, His differentiated parts and parcels and His different energies (pg xxiii).” Plenary parts and parcels refers to all the expansions and incarnations of Godhead, such as “...Baladeva, Saìkarsana, Vasudeva, Aniruddha, Pradyumna, Rama, Nrsimha and Varaha, as well as many other incarnations and innumerable Visnu expansions (pg xxiii).” Differentiated parts and parcels refers to the living entities. Different energies refers to the material and spiritual worlds. These three categories include everything that exists. “‘Krsna,’ in other words, means everything and includes everything (pg xxiii).” Obviously, it is overly inclusive to say that anything and everything is a valid recipient of pure devotional service. Srila Prabhupada therefore explains, “Generally, however, we should understand ‘Krsna’ to mean Krsna and His personal expansions... So Krsna includes all such expansions, as well as His pure devotees. (pg xxiii).” Two paragraphs later, Srila Prabhupada also includes Krsna's paraphernalia and His transcendental abode as bona fide objects of the devotee's pure loving affection. The conclusion: Krsna is the singular target of pure devotion. As a result of this onepointed love for Krsna, one loves everything directly connected to Him. This is neither too exclusive nor too inclusive.

Anusilanam — Devotional Service is an Active Engagement Pure devotion is an active engagement of loving service to Krsna. “The particular word used by Srila Rupa Gosvami in this connection is anusilana, or cultivation by following the predecessor teachers (acaryas). As soon as we say ‘cultivation’ we refer to activity. Without activity, consciousness alone cannot help us (pg xxi).”

Anuçélanam Devotional Activities Pravåtti Positive

Nivåtti Negative

Body Mind Words

Body Mind Words

Srila Prabhupada explains that there are two aspects of anusilanam: (1) pravrtti — pursuance of activities that are favorable to Krsna consciousness, and (2) nivrtti — avoidance of activities unfavorable to Krsna consciousness. There are three ways to perform pravrtti and nivrtti: with body, mind, and words. (See pg

xxi.)

8 26

Anu-Silanam All these positive and negative devotional activities cannot connect to Krsna without the assistance of disciplic succession (guru-parampara). 7 Srila Rupa Gosvami indicates this with the prefix anu-, which means: "that which follows." Those who follow Krsna are the guru-parampara. One performs devotional activities by following a spiritual master, who himself is following the guru-parampara, which is ultimately following the dictations of Sri Krsna. In this way, one's own activities may connect to the transcendental desires of Krsna. Srila Prabhupada explains, “We can offer many services with our bodily activities. But all such activities must be in relationship with Krsna. This relationship is established by connecting oneself with the bona fide spiritual master, who is the direct representative of Krsna in disciplic succession (pg xxii).” Initiation by the spiritual master insures purity and selflessness in our service. Without this, one cannot connect with Krsna and know exactly what one should do to please the Lord. Devotional Activities are Under the Internal Energy Another point imparted by the prefix anu- is that the activities of Krsna consciousness are all spiritual. “Any activities done in devotional service, or in Krsna consciousness, are directly under the control of spiritual energy (pg xxii).” The energy and inspiration to perform devotional service follows from Krsna. It originates from Krsna's spiritual potency, flows down through the disciplic succession, and is instilled in one's heart by the spiritual master. By following a bona fide spiritual master one links his energies and activities to Krsna's internal potency. Thus they become spiritualized. Srila Prabhupada sums it up, “In other words, energy is a sort of strength, and this strength can be spiritualized by the mercy of both the bona fide spiritual master and Krsna (pg xxii).”

Anukulyena — Favorable Intention Devotional service is intended to please Krsna. An activity that only incidentally pleases Him is not devotional service. To explain this, Jiva Gosvami introduces the analogy of "the warrior and his weapons." Srila Prabhupada mentions it: “For instance, if someone says, ‘Give something to eat to the man with the weapons,’ the eating process is done by the man and not by the weapons (pg xxiii).” Srila Prabhupada treats this briefly, since it is only alluded to in a commentary and is not an integral part of Srila Rupa Gosvami's original text. However, in understanding The Nectar of Devotion it is enlivening to appreciate how both Jiva Gosvami and Srila Prabhupada employ this analogy.

7

Çréla Rüpa Gosväm é's physical placement of the Sanskrit words illustrates this point: Çélanam (activities) cannot connect to Kåñna without anu (disciplic succession): kåñna-anu-çélanaà.

9 27

The Warrior and His Weapons In Context of Jiva Gosvami Srila Rupa Gosvami already defined devotional service as ‘activities that please Krsna' (krsnaanu-silanam). What is the need for him to add that it is 'intended to please Krsna' (anukulyena)? It seems redundant. To exemplify this apparent redundancy, Jiva Gosvami introduces an analogy: "Send the warrior into battle" already implies that the warrior's weapons will accompany him to the battlefield. Since the warrior and his weapons are implicitly connected, there is no need to add, "He should take his weapons." Similarly, the intention to please Krsna is implicitly connected with the act of pleasing Him. Thus it doesn't seem that Srila Rupa Gosvami needs to add the word anukulyena. To resolve this, Jiva Gosvami employs the same analogy: It is true that the warrior and his weapons are implicitly connected, but this does not mean they should never be dealt with separately. For example, when the king says, "Feed the warrior," one does not feed his weapons. In exceptional cases, one must separate and distinguish the two. Similarly, in exceptional cases it is important to distinguish "pleasing Krsna" from "the intention to please Krsna." For example, the demons sometimes please Krsna by giving Him the opportunity to fight and protect His devotees. Thus, they are engaged in activity that pleases Krsna (krsna-anusilanam). But it would be absurd to say that demons engage in pure devotional service. That is why Srila Rupa Gosvami explicitly includes the word anukulyena (favorable intention) in his definition of bhakti. Pure devotional service is not just an activity that incidentally pleases Krsna. It must be intended to please Krsna. Otherwise it is not bhakti. Srila Prabhupada says, “...great demons like Ravana, Kamsa and Hiranyakasipu were always thinking of Krsna, but they were thinking of Him as their enemy. This sort of thinking cannot be accepted as bhakti, or Krsna consciousness (pg xxiii).” On the other hand, even an action that apparently displeases Krsna can still be pure devotional service, if the intention is loving. A perfect example is mother Yasoda's chastisement of Krsna. This shows that favorable intention (anukulyena) is of prime importance in executing devotional service. The Warrior and His Weapons In Context of Srila Prabhupada Srila Prabhupada uses the same analogy to explain that Srila Rupa Gosvami's use of the word "krsna" includes His paraphernalia and abode as well. He reasons that, as the weapons are implicitly connected with the warrior, all of Krsna's energies are implicitly connected with Krsna. (See pg xxiii - xxiv.)

10 28

Tatastha-Laksanam — Secondary Characteristics 8 The two secondary characteristics of pure devotional service are: (1) anyabhilasita-sunyam — pure devotional service is free from ulterior motive, and (2) jnana-karmady anavrttam — pure devotional service is not covered by philosophical or fruitive pursuits. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “Pure devotional service should be free from the desire for any material benefit or for sense gratification, as these desires are cultivated through fruitive activities and philosophical speculation. In order to keep the purity of such Krsna conscious activities, one must be freed from all material desires and philosophical speculation (pg xxi).” The secondary characteristics distinguish general devotional service from pure devotional service. General devotional service is activity intended to please Krsna. Additionally, pure devotional service is (1) free from ulterior motive, and (2) not covered by philosophical or fruitive pursuits.

Anyabhilasita-Sunyam — Free From Ulterior Motive Anya — other; abhilasita — integral desire, "motive"; sunyam — void. Anyabhilasita-sunyam means "void of any other desire." Srila Prabhupada says, “Any desire except for the service of the Lord is called material desire (pg xxiv).” If one says that pure devotional service is utterly void of all material desires, that could be too exclusive. Therefore Srila Rupa Gosvami modifies anyabhilasa ("material desire") by adding the suffix "-ta." Abhilasa means "desire." The suffix -ta means "-ness." Thus abhilasita literally means "desire-ness." Since "desire-ness" is a cumbersome and uncertain term, we will use another, and define it clearly. We translate abhilasa as "desire," and abhilasita as "motive." We define "motive" as a desire that is an integral part of one's nature. One can have a personal desire and still not be out of the realm of pure devotional service, as long as that desire is not an integral part of one's nature. For example, suppose a devotee who has dedicated his full energy to advancement in devotion is suddenly put in a lifethreatening situation. He may call out: "Krsna, save me!" This is not a desire for Krsna's pleasure. It is a personal desire, for self-preservation. But it not an integral part of the devotee's nature. It is a superficial, fleeting desire. It is not a motive. It is not anyabhilasita. Such non-integral desires do not exclude one from pure devotional service. 9 This gives scope to the feasibility of executing pure devotional service even in the stage of practice (sadhana-bhakti). 10

8

The nayäkoça defines tatastha-lakñanam as: yäval-lakñyakälam anavasthä-yitve sati yad vyävartakam tat — that which further distinguishes an object (or person) by describing qualities outside it's fundamental nature.

9

See BRS 1.1.11, Jéva Gosvämé.

10

See Appendix A.

11 29

Conclusion Even if there are extraneous desires, one's motive must be kept completely pure. One should desire only to please the Lord, and thus execute pure devotional service

Jnana-Karmady Anavrttam — Not Covered By Jnana or Karma As mentioned, there are two secondary characteristics (tatastha-laksanam) of pure devotional service: (1) anyabhilasita-sunyam — free from ulterior motive, and (2) jnana-karmady anavrttam — not covered by philosophical or fruitive pursuits. These secondary characteristics modify the primary characteristics, and thereby distinguish pure devotional service from general devotional service. "Freedom from ulterior motive" (anyabhilasita-sunyam) further modifies "favorable intention" (anukulyena). "Not covered by philosophical or fruitive pursuits" (jnana-karmady anavrttam) further modifies "activities" (anusilanam). Jnana — Philosophical Speculation It is not that one must completely rule out all philosophical speculation, but if one's philosophical interests become more prominent than one's concentration on simple bhakti they will cover one's devotional attitude and disqualify him from pure devotional service. “The ultimate end of philosophical speculation then must be Krsna, with the understanding the Krsna is everything, the cause of all causes, and that one should therefore surrender to Him. If this ultimate goal is reached, then philosophical advancement is favorable, but if the conclusion of philosophical speculation is voidism or impersonalism, that is not bhakti (pg xxiv).” Karma — Ritualistic Pursuits Similarly, one can engage in ordinary social and religious activities, but such engagements must not become more prominent than one's engagement in direct bhakti. If such activities overshadow one's attention to devotional activities like hearing and chanting, they cover one's devotional attitude and disqualify him from pure devotional service. “There are many persons who are very much attracted by the ritualistic activities described in the Vedas. But if one becomes attracted simply to ritualistic activities without understanding Krsna, his activities are unfavorable to Krsna consciousness (pg xxiv).” An example of ritualistic activities that do not cover devotional service are those performed simply out of social convention, such as Lord Caitanya's offering pinòa upon the death of His father. 11 An example of activity that might cover devotional service is astrology. Although it can serve some functional purpose, a devotee may gradually put more faith in the power of destiny than in the power of bhakti, and thus impede or cover his surrender to Krsna. Devotional service need only involve the nine activities of hearing, chanting, remembering, etc. Anything else is extraneous, and could become an unfavorable impediment to pure devotion. Pure devotees must therefore be on guard not to let such extraneous activities overwhelm and cover one's hearing, chanting, etc. “Actually, Krsna consciousness can be based

11

Pinòa is a type of funeral ceremony in which a son offers prasädam to his deceased father.

12 30

simply on hearing, chanting, remembering, etc... .besides which everything done is unfavorable to Krsna consciousness. Thus, one should always be guarding against falldowns (pg xxiv).” Adi — Other Pursuits We can apply the same paradigm to any other pursuit, such as renunciation, yoga, etc. One can utlilize these processes, but they must not cover bhakti. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “Many forms of so-called renunciation are also not favorable to Krsna conscious devotional service (pg xxiv).”

Review of Definition Pure devotional service is: Activity intended to please Krsna; without ulterior motive, and not covered by philosophical or fruitive pursuits. Srila Rupa Gosvami's definition of uttama-bhakti (pure devotional service) is perfect. Each word is so precise that one cannot mistake pure devotional service for anything else. His definition is not overly exclusive, nor overly inclusive. It perfectly applies to all stages of devotees — in practice, and in perfection.

References Quoted to Support this Definition Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes verses to support his definition of pure devotional service, beginning with a prominent verse from Narada Pancaratna describing unalloyed bhakti: sarvopadhivinirmuktam... Srila Prabhupada ends his introduction with a brief explanation of this verse.

13 31

Chapter One

Characteristics of Pure Devotional Service BRS 1.1.13 - 43

This chapter begins with Lord Kapiladeva stating that a pure devotee never aspires selfishly, even for the five kinds of liberation. By pointing out the desirelessness of a pure devotee, this quotation supports Srila Rupa Gosvami's assertion that pure devotional service is free from desire for sense gratification or liberation. Srila Prabhupada explains, “In the above statement by Kapiladeva from SrimadBhagavatam, the actual position of a pure devotee is described, and the primary characteristics of pure devotional service are also defined (pg 3).”

SIX CHARACTERISTICS OF PURE DEVOTIONAL SERVICE Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the six characteristics of pure devotional service: 1. Klesaghni — relief from material distress. 2. Subhada — attainment of auspiciousness. 3. Moksa-laghutakrt — pure devotional service derides even the happiness of liberation. 4. Sudurlabha — rarely achieved. 5. Sandrananda-visesatma — automatically puts one in transcendental pleasure. 1 6. Sri krsnakarsini — it is the only means to attract Krsna. The Nectar of Devotion lists these characteristics in a different order. The reason for this will become clear by describing the characteristics.

1

Sandra — highly concentrated and condensed, to the point of im penetrability; ananda — bliss; viçeña — special, distinctive; ätmä — nat ure, sel f. Thus sandränanda-viçeñätmä literally m eans: "th e distinctive nature [of prema-bhakti] is impenetrably condensed, concentrated bliss."

14

32

Klesaghni — Relief From All Distress Klesa refers to distress, and the causes of distress.

Avidyä Ignornance

Distress has three causes: (1) papam — sin, (2) bijam — material desires, and (3) avidya — ignorance, the root cause.

Béjaà Material Desire

Srila Rupa Gosvami will explain that devotional service is the best means of obtaining relief from distress, because it is the only process that can counteract all three causes.

Päpam Sinful Act Suffering

Papam — Sinful Activity Sinful actions (papam) produce two reactions: (1) prarabdha — manifest, and (2) aprarabdha — unmanifest. Srila Prabhupada describes, “...for some of our sinful activities we are awaiting distress in the future, and for others, which are mature, we are suffering at the present moment (pg 4).” Manifest Sinful Reactions (Prarabdha-Papam)

A disease caught early is curable, but is far more difficult to counteract if allowed to become chronic. Similarly, sinful reactions are more difficult to counteract once they become manifest. Devotional service, however, can remove even manifest sinful reactions and the suffering they bring. Päpam Devahuti explains that by sinful action practicing devotional service even someone born in the lowest family of Aprärabdha Prärabdha dog-eaters becomes qualified to perform unmanifest reaction manifest reaction the highest brahminical sacrifices. 2 The behavior of those born into degraded families disqualifies them from performing Vedic sacrifices. Devahuti points out that even slight engagement in devotional service can counteract the disqualifications incurred by a low birth. One's birth is a tangible result of karma — a manifest reaction (prarabdhapapam). Thus Devahuti's statement is sastric evidence that devotional service can counteract prarabdha-papam. Unmanifest Sinful Reactions (Aprarabdha-Papam) Devotional service is like a blazing fire, able to consume limitless amounts of unmanifest sinful reactions. Srila Prabhupada says, “...as the blazing fire can burn any

2

B RS 1.1.21

15

33

amount of fuel to ashes, so devotional service to the Lord in Krsna consciousness can burn up all the fuel of sinful activities (pg 5).” How Unmanifest Reactions Cause Suffering. Previously, we said that sinful activity causes two types of reaction: manifest and unmanifest. We will further clarify this statement.

Päpaà Sinful Action Aprärabdha (1) unmanifest reaction

Aprärabdha (2) unmanifest reaction

Prärabdha direct physical or emotional suffering

Küöam indirect suffering - by increased sinful proclivity

A sinful action generates two types of unmanifest reactions. One type creates direct physical or emotional suffering. The other type creates indirect suffering by increasing one's sinful proclivities.

For example, if one engages in illicit sex he receives two types of reactions. One type creates some direct physical or emotional suffering. The other type creates indirect suffering by exacerbating his proclivity for sex; thereby increasing sexual desires, impelling future illicit sex, and entangling him in a karmic cycle of suffering. When sinful desires increase, sinful activities increase. When sinful activities increase, sinful desires increase — it is a self-perpetuating cycle. The more one tries to satisfy his desires, the stronger they become. To break this cycle of bondage one must tolerate sinful desires and not endeavor to fulfil them. Not being reinforced by unmanifest reactions, they will gradually dissipate and leave the heart forever. 3 Evolution of Unmanifest Sin The cycle of unmanifest reaction goes through four stages, as explained in Padma Purana:

3

Kåñna expl ains t his pri nciple in the Bhagavad a-Gétä (7 .28): yeñäà tv anta-gataà päpaà, janänäà punya-karmanäm, te dvandva-moha-nirmuktä, bhajante mäà dåòha-vratäù. To make significant advancem ent one m ust engage i n Kåñna consci ousness wi th unwaveri ng determination. Thi s i s di fficult when one' s st ock of unm anifested react ions cont inuously generat es sinful desi res t hat di stract one from bhakti. B ut by act ing pi ously (cont rolling the senses) one avoids sinful activity, and thus does not increase his sinful proclivities. This gradually exhausts one's stock of sins, and one can engage in devotional service without distraction (dådha-vrata).

16

34

Päpam sinful action Aprärabdha unmanifest reactions

1. Aprarabdha (unmanifest reaction) — In this stage the reaction is completely unmanifest and has no perceptible effect. 2. Kutam (sinful proclivity) — In this stage the reaction evolves into a psychological disposition towards sin.

Küöaà sinful inclination

3. Bijam (sinful desire) — In this stage the sinful proclivity evolves into a specific desire to commit a particular sinful action.

Béjaà sinful desire

4. Prarabdha (manifest sinful reaction) — In this stage the sinful desire causes one to commit a sinful action and suffer the concomitant reaction. 4

Prärabdha manifest reaction

The following illustration may help clarify the subtle distinctions between these four stages: As a result of some sinful act, a man is destined to become a thief and suffer punishment. However, this reaction is not immediately felt — it is stored for a future birth (this is the stage of aprarabdha). In his next life, the reaction begins to manifest as an almost unnoticed proclivity towards dishonesty and cheating (this is the stage of kutam). This proclivity gradually intensifies and eventually manifests an explicit desire to steal (this is the stage of bijam). Finally, this desire causes the man to commit theft and undergo the consequential suffering (this is the stage of prarabdha). Devotional service eradicates all four stages of sinful reaction in chronological order — first aprarabdha, next kutam, then bijam, and finally prarabdha. (See page 6.)

Bijam — Desire Srila Rupa Gosvami described the first cause of suffering (papam) in all it's subheadings. Now he describes the second cause of suffering: bijam — sinful desire. He quotes the Visnuduttas (SB 6.2.17), who explain that many processes can neutralize the reactions of sinful activities, but only devotional service can uproot sinful desire — which is the cause of sinful activity. Srila Prabhupada elaborates by citing Ajamila. In spite of his strict performance of brahminical duties, sinful desires remained in Ajamila's heart and caused him to succumb to sinful life. Later, the simple devotional service of chanting "Narayana" uprooted all his calamities, although he was in the midst of sinful activities. (See page 6.) 4

In The Nectar of Devotion (page 6), Çréla Prabhupäda denot es t he four st ages wi th t he fol lowing terminology: aprärabdha — “the effect which is not yet fructified,” küöaà — “almost ready to produce seed, or the effect of seed,” béjaà — “The effect which is alm ost m ature,” and prärabdha — “The effect which is already mature.”

17

35

Vedic rituals like charity and austerity can neutralize sinful reactions, but they cannot neutralize sinful desire. Srila Prabhupada gives two illustrations: (1) a person may be cured of venereal disease by some painful medical treatment, but because sex desire remains in his heart he again implicates himself in suffering; (2) an elephant may carefully bathe in a lake, but upon returning to the land immediately covers himself again with dirt. (See page 7.) Devotional service can uproot even sinful desire, and is therefore the best method for attaining relief from suffering.

Avidya — Ignorance Avidyä IGNORANCE Béjaà sinful desire

Küöaà sinful disposition

Päpam sinful action

Aprärabdha unmanifest reaction

Prärabdha manifest reaction

The root cause of suffering is avidya — ignorance of one's true identity as Krsna's eternal servant. In ignorance, one acts as an enjoyer and suffers the concomitant reactions. Srila Prabhupada says, “As long as one is ignorant about his identity, he is sure to act wrongly and thereby become entangled in material contamination (pg 8).” Uprooting ignorance is the best way to uproot suffering. Only devotional service can uproot all ignorance. Srila Rupa Gosvami authenticates this by quoting Padma Purana and SrimadBhagavatam (Fourth Canto).

Srila Prabhupada's summarizes the quotation from Padma Purana, “Pure devotional service in Krsna consciousness is the highest enlightenment, and when such enlightenment is there, it is just like a blazing forest fire, killing all the inauspicious snakes of desire (page 8).” In this quotation, Srila Prabhupada expresses the Sanskrit word avidyam as "desire." One usually translates avidyam as ignorance. Accordingly, Srila Prabhupada clarifies, “Similarly, the blazing fire of Krsna consciousness is so strong that the snakes of ignorance are immediately killed (page 8).”

Suffering

Conclusion Devotional service eradicates sinful reactions, nullifies sinful desires, counteracts material proclivities, and — most importantly — uproots ignorance. Therefore it is the only efficient and effective way to achieve permanent relief from all suffering.

18

36

Subhada — All Auspiciousness The first characteristic is (relief from all suffering) and the second characteristic (allauspiciousness) are related, as suffering decreases, auspiciousness increases. These two characteristics fully manifest at the stage of nistha, "Steadiness." One should understand that he has not yet become steady in sadhana-bhakti if he is not being freed from suffering and manifesting all-auspicious qualities. Something cannot be "all-auspiciousness" without meeting four criteria: it must (1) benefit everyone, (2) attract everyone, (3) produce good qualities, and (4) bestow superior happiness. Devotional service meets all four of these criteria. No other practice can make this claim.

Benefit Everyone & Attract Everyone Srila Prabhupada highlights the all-auspiciousness of devotional service by contrasting it with the United Nations' failure to either (1) benefit or (2) attract anyone. On the other hand, Krsna consciousness is all-auspicious because, “Everyone can be attracted by the movement, and everyone can feel the result [ie. be benefited] (pg 8).” Srila Rupa Gosvami and all great acaryas thus recommend the spreading of Krsna consciousness as the highest welfare activity. Padma Purana confirms the all-attractive and all-beneficial nature of devotional service: “A person who is engaged in devotional service in full Krsna consciousness is to be understood to be doing the best service to the whole world and to be pleasing everyone in the world. In addition to human society, he is pleasing even the trees and animals, because they also become attracted by such a movement (pgs 8 - 9).” Srila Prabhupada elaborates by mentioning how Lord Caitanya attracted all the animals in Jharikhanòa Forest to dance and chant Hare Krsna, benedicting them with sublime bliss.

Development of Saintly Qualities A steady devotee develops all saintly qualities. Srila Rupa Gosvami authenticates this with the noted verse from Srimad-Bhagavatam: yasyasti bhaktir bhagavaty akincana... “Persons who have unflinching faith in Krsna and are without any duplicity can develop all the good qualities of the demigods.“ (SB 5.18.12, NOD p. 9) Many people think that modern education is auspicious and endows one with good qualities. Srila Prabhupada exposes this misconception, “A Krsna conscious boy, even if he is not very well educated, can immediately give up all illicit sex life, gambling, meat-eating, and intoxication, whereas those who are not in Krsna consciousness, although very highly educated, are often drunkards, meat-eaters, sex mongers and gamblers (pg 9).” Many people think that yoga is auspicious. Srila Prabhupada dispels this misunderstanding, “Artificially, they may sit down for so-called meditation, but 19

37

immediately after their yogic performance they will engage themselves again in such activities as illicit sex life, gambling, meat-eating, and many other nonsensical things. But a Krsna conscious person... automatically gives up all this nonsense and develops a high character (pg 10).” Neither modern education nor yoga are all-auspicious because they fail the third criteria: sad-guna — development of saintly character.

Superior Happiness There are three types of happiness: (1) that which comes from sense gratification, (2) that which comes from liberation & Brahman realization, and (3) that which comes from devotional service. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Srila Rupa Gosvami has analyzed the different sources of happiness. He has divided happiness into three categories, which are (1) happiness derived from material enjoyment, (2) happiness derived by identifying oneself with the Supreme Brahman and (3) happiness derived from Krsna consciousness (page 10).” Of these, the happiness of devotional service is superior. There are two reasons: (1) it is eternal whereas the others are temporary, and (2) it includes and excels the pleasures found in other types of happiness. Only the Happiness of Devotional Service is Eternal Neither liberation, mystic perfection, nor sense gratification can bring eternal happiness: Liberation Srila Prabhupada states that even the pleasure of liberation is not eternal, as proven by the Mayavadis who fall down and return to material activities. (See page 11.) Mystic Perfection The pleasure of yogic perfection is also not eternal. Srila Prabhupada elaborately shows how the yoga-siddhis are essentially subtle versions of modern material science. Thus the pleasure they afford is also material, temporary. (See page 11 - 12.) Sense Gratification Srila Prabhupada says, “Foolishly, people who are enamored of the glimmer of modern materialistic advancement are thinking that the Krsna consciousness movement is for less intelligent men. ‘I am better off being busy with my material comforts — maintaining a nice apartment, family and sex life.’ These people do not know that at any moment they can be kicked out of their material situation. Due to

20

38

ignorance, they do not know that real life is eternal. The temporary comforts of the body are not the goal of life... (pg 12)” The Happiness of Devotional Service Includes all Others Devotional service affords superior happiness because it includes and excels the pleasures found in the other types of happiness. Lord Siva says, “My dear wife, a person who has surrendered himself at the lotus feet of Govinda and who has thus developed pure Krsna consciousness can be very easily awarded all the perfections desired by the impersonalists; and beyond this, he can enjoy the happiness achieved by the pure devotees (pg 10).” This shows that devotional service includes the happiness of liberation. Prahlada Maharaja says, “My dear Lord, I repeatedly pray unto Your lotus feet that I may simply be stronger in devotional service. I simply pray that my Krsna consciousness may be more strong and steady, because happiness derived out of Krsna consciousness and devotional service is so powerful that with it one can have all the other perfections of religiousness, economic development, sense gratification, and even the attainment of liberation from material existence (pg 13).” Srila Prabhupada elaborates by mentioning the story of Kholaveca Sridhara. Experiencing the happiness of Krsna consciousness, he became disinterested in all other pleasures. Final Two References The final two references in this section also show that the pleasure of Krsna consciousness includes and excels all other happiness: (1) “...any person who has developed even a small amount of devotional service doesn't care a fig for any kind of happiness derived from religiousness, economic development, sense gratification or the five kinds of liberation (pg 13).” (2) “It is stated that as the personal attendants and maidservants of a queen follow the queen with all respect and obeisances, similarly the joys of religiousness, economic development, sense gratification and liberation follow the devotional service of the Lord (pg 14).”

Conclusion Only devotional service is (1) all-attractive and (2) all-beneficial, can (3) develops saintly character, and (4) bestow superior happiness. Thus only devotional service is truly “all-auspicious.“

Moksa-Laghutakrt — Derides the Happiness of Liberation At the stage of bhava, the third characteristic of pure devotional service manifests: moksa-laghutakrt. The happiness of devotional service makes even the inestimable bliss of liberation (moksa) seem insignificant (laghuta). 21

39

Srila Rupa Gosvami exemplifies moksa-laghutakrt with the previous two quotes (“A devotee doesn't care a fig for other happiness,” and “all other joys follow devotion as attendants follow a queen”), which Srila Prabhupada used to exemplify the second characteristic of devotional service (subhada). By studying these quotes, one can easily see that they are appropriate for both characteristics. We will discuss this further in the upcoming section entitled Sandrananda-Visesatma.

Sudurlabha — Difficult to Achieve There are two reasons why pure devotional service is extremely rare and difficult to achieve: (1) it is unattainable by one's own efforts, (2) Krsna is reluctant to give it.

Unattainable by One's Own Efforts Pure devotional service cannot be attained by any process of self-realization, even if carefully executed for thousands and thousands of years. Lord Siva confirms this: “My dear Sati, if one is a very fine philosopher, analyzing the different processes of knowledge, he can achieve liberation from the material entanglement. By performance of the ritualistic sacrifices recommended in the Vedas one can be elevated to the platform of pious activities and thereby enjoy the material comforts of life to the fullest extent. But all such endeavors can hardly offer anyone devotional service to the Lord, not even if one tries for it by such processes for many, many thousands of births (pg 14).” One cannot achieve pure devotional service by one's own efforts. One can obtain it only if Krsna gives it. However, Krsna is very reluctant to give pure devotional service because it has the power to control Him. Narada's comments to Yudhisthira illustrate the power of devotional service to control Krsna. Narada describes how the Panòavas' pure devotion obliged Krsna to become their menial messenger. (pg 15) This characteristic of pure devotional service manifests at the stage of bhava. Consequently, one can understand that a person cannot obtain bhava-bhakti by any path of self-realization. Even sadhana-bhakti does not directly bestow bhava — which can only be achieved by the Lord's grace. 5

5

The original text of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (1.1.35) clearly substantiates that bhäva-bhakti cannot be attained even by the practice of ordinary sädhana: sädhanaughair-anäsaìgair alabhyä suciräd-api harinä cäçvadeyeti dvidhä sä syät sudurlabhä Sädhanaughair — prolonged practice of sädhana; Anäsaìgair — without attachment. Not even prolonged and strenuous performance of sädana-bhakti can award one with bhäva, as long as that practice is not imbued with 'attachment.'"

22

40

Sandrananda-Visesatma — Incalculably Condensed Bliss At the stage of prema, the fifth characteristic of pure devotional service manifests: sandrananda-visesatma — incalculably condensed bliss (listed The Nectar of Devotion as "The Happiness of Becoming One with the Supreme"). Nothing can penetrate metal because its molecular density is so concentrated. Similarly, the happiness of prema-bhakti is so densely concentrated that nothing else can penetrate it. No other perception or thought can even momentarily register in the devotee's mind.

References Srila Rupa Gosvami is the author of the first reference: “Srila Rupa Gosvami says that if brahmananda, or the happiness of becoming one with the Supreme, is multiplied by one trillionfold, it still cannot compare to an atomic fraction of the happiness derived from the ocean of devotional service (pg 15).” The Sanskrit for "one trillionfold" is pararddha, which means, "the highest conceivable number." This reference shows that the bliss of Pure Devotional Service is incalculable. The remaining two references, found on page 15, show that the bliss of premabhakti completely eclipses the happiness desired from any other means.

Three Degrees of Happiness This is the third time Srila Rupa Gosvami discusses happiness as a characteristic of Krsna consciousness. There are three stages of pure devotional service — sadhana, bhava, and prema — each characterized by a particular type of happiness. Subhada is the happiness found in sadhana-bhakti. It is superior to sense gratification and liberation. Moksalaghutakrt is the happiness found in bhava-bhakti. It is so superior that it makes sense gratification and liberation seem insignificant. Sandrananda-visesatma is the happiness found in prema-bhakti. It is so incalculably superior that one cannot even perceive the existence of sense gratification or liberation.

Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura explains "attachment" (äsaìgair). He say s that after a long time of st renuous and repeat ed pract ice one evol ves hi s sädhana through the preliminary st ages of bhajana-kriya, anartha-nivåtti, and niñtha; and then reaches the stages of ruci and äsakti. Only th is sädhana i mbued wi th äsakti (extreme attachm ent) can reward the devotee with bhäva — since it possesses a sincerity and emotional intensity that will attract the Lord's favor.

23

41

Sri Krsnakarsini — Attracts Sri Krsna Prema-bhakti is so powerful that it attracts and controls even the all-attractive Supreme Controller, Sri Krsna. One is controlled by attachments. One becomes attached to that which gives him pleasure. Only self-satisfied people can remain detached and thus independent. The Lord is self-satisfied (atmarama), but He is attracted to His own pleasure potency (hladini-sakti) and thus becomes attached to and controlled by hladini-sakti. The essence of hladini-sakti is love of Godhead (prema). Therefore one who has prema can attract and control Krsna. No other process of self-realization has this potency, as confirmed by Lord Krsna's statement to Uddhava (see page 16). Narada Muni's statement to Yuddhisthira, describing Lord Krsna as the friend and messenger of the Panòavas, illustrates how the Lord becomes subservient to the love of His pure devotee. (See pages 16 - 17) 6 Srila Prabhupada adds, “So that was the position of the Panòavas; although Krsna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the greatest among all greats, He remained with those royal brothers, being attracted by their devotion, by their friendship and by their love. This is the proof of how great this process of devotional service is. It can attract even the Supreme Personality of Godhead (pg 17).”

Two Degrees of Control When Srila Rupa Gosvami described the third characteristic of devotional service (sudurlabha) he briefly mentioned that the Lord is controlled by the love of His devotee. 7 The sixth characteristic (sri krsnakarsini) also notes that the Lord is controlled by love. Since sudurlabha manifests at the stage of bhava, and sri-krsnakarsini at the stage of prema, we can understand that the devotee's love controls the Lord in both stages. At bhava the Lord bestows love of Godhead upon the devotee. Thus the devotee begins to attract the Lord. At prema the devotee verily enters the Lord's pastimes and thus attracts and controls the Lord in a personal and active relationship, as in the example of the Panòavas.

6 7

See also, Çrémad-Bhägavatam 7.10.48, 49. He did this by quoting Çrémad-Bhägavatam 5.6.18, describing how Kåñna becam e the servant of the Pänòavas.

24

42

Eastern Ocean Second Wave Sadhana-Bhakti Chapters 2 -14 — Vaidhi Chapters 15 & 16 — Raganuga

43

Chapter Two

The First Stages of Devotion BRS 1.1.44 - 1.2.15

Srila Rupa Gosvami says there are three categories of devotional service: sadhanabhakti, bhava-bhakti, and prema-bhakti. He then reveals their relationship to the six characteristics of pure devotional service discussed in Chapter One:

Prema Bhäva Sädhana

Çré-kåñëa-karñiëé Sändränanda-viçeñätmä Sudurlabha Mokña-laghutäkåt Çubhadä Kleçaghné

Each category of devotional service displays two distinguishing is characteristics. Sadhana-bhakti characterized by klesaghni and subhada. Besides these, bhava-bhakti displays moksa-laghutakrt and sudurlabha. Besides all these, prema-bhakti displays sandrananda-visesatma and srikrsnakarsini.

Srila Prabhupada explains, “Generally it is understood that in the category of devotional service in practice, there are two different qualities, devotional service in ecstasy has four qualities, and devotional service in pure love of Godhead has six qualities (pg 19).”

Qualification for Practicing Devotional Service Having described the characteristics of pure devotional service, Srila Rupa Gosvami now explains the qualification for practicing it. If one simply has an attraction to executing devotional service, he is qualified to begin practicing it. Generally, this attraction comes from devotional service executed in previous lives. This reasoning, though, seems to be Attraction for circular: One requires attraction to begin devotional service devotional service. But one requires devotional Execution of service to achieve an attraction. devotional service How, then, does devotional service begin? Devotional service begins with the causeless mercy of a devotee. By this mercy one may unknowingly execute devotional service (ajnata-sukrti), and thus develop a slight taste or attraction to bhakti. This attraction grows as one engages in more devotional service. Eventually it qualifies one for serious commitment to sadhana-bhakti. Generally, this occurs over the span of many lifetimes.

44

Attraction or "taste" is the qualification for making a commitment to the systematic cultivation of sadhana-bhakti. However, there is no qualification required for receiving causeless mercy and beginning ajnata-sukrti.

Causeless Mercy

Attraction for devotional service

Spiritual advancement is eternal. The attraction to Krsna gained from previous advancement in devotional service remains in one's heart. In a future life, it impels one to seek the association of devotees and take up the practice from where one left off. Thus we can see devotees coming to the Krsna consciousness movement who begin at different levels of advancement. Execution of devotional service

One's qualification for sadhana-bhakti depends on the strength of his taste or attraction to Krsna. The more pronounced the taste, the greater the qualification. This is why Srila Rupa Gosvami states, “The person eligible for Krsna consciousness, or devotional service, can be classified by his particular taste (pg 19).” Consequently, advancement in Krsna consciousness is not based on our intellectual abilities, but on our taste for hearing krsna-katha. Srila Prabhupada explains, “For persons who have a natural taste for understanding books like Bhagavada-Gita and Srimad-Bhagavatam, devotional service is easier than for those who are simply accustomed to mental speculation and argumentative processes (pg 19).”

Definition of Sadhana-Bhakti Srila Prabhupada begins the Second Wave of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu by summarizing Srila Rupa Gosvami's definition of sadhana-bhakti (see page 20). The original text is in Srila Prabhupada's Caitanya-caritamrta (Madhya 22.105): krti-sadhya bhavet sadhyabhava sa sadhanabhidha nitya-siddhasya bhavasya prakatyam hrdi sadhyata krti-sadhya — which is to be executed by the senses; bhavet — should be; sadhyabhava — by which love of Godhead is acquired; sa — that; sadhana-abhidha — called sadhana-bhakti, or devotional service in practice; nitya-siddhasya — which is eternally perfect; bhavasya — of love of Godhead; prakatyam — the awakening; hrdi — in the heart; sadhyata — potentiality.

45

When transcendental devotional service, by which love for Krsna is attained, is executed by the senses, it is called sadhana-bhakti, or the regulative discharge of devotional service. Such devotional service eternally exists within the heart of every living entity. The awakening of this eternal devotion is the potentiality of devotional service in practice. In other words, sadhana-bhakti is a practice executed with the senses, which brings on the manifestation of bhava-bhakti. Srila Prabhupada's comments on this definition begin at the second paragraph of page 20 and continue to the first paragraph of page 21.

Relation of Sadhana to Bhava Srila Prabhupada explains that "practice" (sadhana) means to engage the mind and senses in a particular type of work. Sadhana-bhakti means to engage our mind and senses in some work for Krsna. This work brings on the manifestation of bhava-bhakti. It is not that sadhana-bhakti mechanically generates bhava-bhakti. Bhakti is not mechanical, nor is it achieved by any mechanical process. Only bhakti causes bhakti. How does sadhana bring on the manifestation of bhava-bhakti? Adhering to the practices of sadhana purifies the heart. Gradually, a genuine longing for the Lord's service appears. When executed with genuine longing, sadhana has the potential to awaken bhava-bhakti. 1 Devotees who want to make tangible advancement must not allow their sadhana to be desireless and mechanical. They must execute their daily practices with a yearning for Krsna's service.

"Practice" Srila Prabhupada explains that the term "practice" is insufficient to fully describe the process of sadhana-bhakti. Generally, practice connotes an endeavor to acquire some skill that one does not possess. Practice of bhakti, however, uncovers something that is already in the heart. “This practice is not for developing something artificial (pg 20).” Srila Prabhupada employs his own analogy, “There are certain prescribed methods for employing our senses and mind in such a way that our dormant consciousness for loving Krsna will be invoked, as much as a child, with a little practice, can begin to walk (pg 20).” 2

1

Please see Footnot e on page fo r Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura's confirmation.

2

This analogy also illustrates the relationship between sädhana-bhakti and the manifestation of bhäva.

46

Srila Prabhupada further clarifies by explaining that the living entity in this world is insane, since he performs activities that cause his own suffering. 3 He then compares the spiritual master to a psychiatrist, who brings his patient to sanity by prescribing therapeutic behavior. The spiritual master brings out the disciple's original, sane consciousness by prescribing the practices of sadhana-bhakti.

The Essence of Sadhana-Bhakti The essence of sadhana-bhakti is to fix the mind on Krsna. In Srimad-Bhagavatam Narada Muni says, “My dear king, one has to fix his mind on Krsna by any means (pg 21).” 4 In this Bhagavatam verse, Narada further explains that Sisupala and Kamsa became liberated by fixing their mind on Krsna, even though they did so out of hatred and fear. Such is the power of remembering Krsna — If one fixes the mind on Krsna for any reason, he will be purified. Since thinking of Krsna is the essence of sadhana-bhakti, helping a disciple do so is the essential duty of a guru. “It is the duty of the acarya, the spiritual master, to find the ways and means for his disciple to fix his mind on Krsna. (pg 21)” Srila Prabhupada points out that Caitanya Mahaprabhu stressed Hare Krsna kirtana as the best type of sadhana, because it the most effective means to fix the mind on Krsna.

Two Types of Sadhana-Bhakti Srila Rupa Gosvami introduces the two types of sadhana-bhakti: (1) vaidhi —regulated devotional practice, and (2) raganuga — spontaneous devotional practice. The main distinction between them is their source of inspiration. In ragabhakti the inspiration comes from natural attraction to devotional service. In vaidhibhakti there is no such attraction and one must rely upon another source of inspiration: the orders of the spiritual master and the scriptures. Srila Prabhupada illustrates this, “In the beginning, by the order of his spiritual master, one rises early in the morning and offers arati, but then he develops real attachment. When he gets this attachment, he automatically tries to decorate the Deity and prepare different kinds of dresses and thinks of different plans to execute his devotional service nicely (pg 22).”

3

He cites Çrémad-Bhägavatam 5.5.4: nünaà pramattaù kurute vikarma... The living entity is co nsidered insane because he tries for happiness by doing things that cause bondage and suffering.

4

Tasmät kenäpyupäyena, manaù kåñne niveçayet. . . SB 7.1.32. S ee al so: Wav es o f D evotion, pa ge .

47

This clearly expresses the basic concept of raganuga and differentiates it from vaidhi. Following Srila Rupa Gosvami's own text, Srila Prabhupada treats the subject briefly. The Fifteenth and Sixteenth Chapters (BRS 1.2.270 - 309) will systematically define raganuga-bhakti and reveal many deeper details. 5

VAIDHI-SADHANA-BHAKTI BRS 1.2.2 - 269

Definition of Vaidhi-Bhakti Srila Prabhupada translates Srila Rupa Gosvami's definition of vaidhi-sadhana: “When there is no attachment or no spontaneous loving service to the Lord, or one is engaged in the service of the Lord simply out of obedience to the order of the spiritual master, or in pursuance of the scriptures, such obligatory service is called vaidhi-bhakti (pg 22).” We should not think of vaidhi-bhakti in a belittling way. Vaidhi-bhakti is an exchange of love between the devotee and the Lord; which impels a person to place himself under the order of guru and sastra. Thus vaidhi-bhakti is a division of pure devotional service.

Inspiration to Vaidhi-Bhakti When the inspiration for sadhana comes from anything other than a natural attraction to service, it is vaidhi-bhakti. Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates this with a quote from Srimad-Bhagavatam (2.1.5): Sukadeva Gosvami advised Maharaja Pariksit: “My dear King, if you want to be fearless in meeting your death next week (for actually everyone is afraid at the point of death), then you must immediately begin the process of hearing and chanting and remembering God (pg 22).” This is clearly an example of vaidhi-bhakti because the impetus to perform devotional service is not a natural attraction to Krsna, but the desire to be fearless of death. 6

5

Rägänugä is m ore than just spontaneity. It is serv ice motivated exclusively by love, untouched by any other considerations — such as a sense of etiquette arising from awareness of God's greatness. One may spontaneously lik e to serv e K åñna, but if he remains preoccupied w ith awar eness o f H is majestic Lordliness his ser vice is sti ll vaidhi-bhakti — as it is r estrained b y th e f ormal etiq uette n ecessary in dealing with the Almighty. Rägänugä-bhakti must be completely free from such restraints. Therefore it can truly be found only in Våndävana. (See Waves of Devotion, page .)

6

Çréla Prabhupäda's commentary on f earlessness comprises the next three paragraphs of The Nectar of Devotion, ending just before the quote from Padma Puräna.

48

Essence of Vaidhi-Bhakti The rules and regulations of Vedic scripture impel the vaidhi-bhakta — but the Vedas propound countless rules and regulations, many of which appear contradictory. What is the essential injunction that the vaidhi-bhakta should follow? Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes the Padma Purana: smartavyah satatam visnur vismartavyo na jatucit sarve vidhi-nisedhah syur itayor eva kinkarah “Always remember Krsna and never forget Him. All the rules and prohibitions mentioned in the sastras are servants of these two principles.” In this quotation there are two considerations: (1) vidhi — 'rules' or 'orders'; and (2) nisedha — 'prohibitions,' or 'regulations'. One must follow rules (vidhi) and avoid prohibited things (nisedha). By following rules one receives benefit. By avoiding prohibited things one avoids sinful reactions. The essence of all Vedic rules (vidhi) is to always remember Krsna. The essence of all Vedic regulations (nisedha) is to never forget Krsna. “When the order is that one should always remember Krsna, the prohibition is that one should never forget Him. Within this simple order and prohibition, all regulative principles are found complete (pg 24).” Following this single vidhi grants one the benefits of following all the vidhis. Following this single nisedha saves one from the bad reactions of all the nisedhas. This injunction applies universally. Srila Prabhupada translates, “This regulative principle is applicable to all varnas and asramas, the castes and occupations of life... The principle of remembering the Supreme Personality of Godhead constantly and not forgetting Him at any moment is meant to be followed by everyone without fail (pg 24).” If one strictly follows every rule and regulation of varna and asrama, yet fails to "always remember Krsna, never forget Him," his effort is wasted. He will receive neither benefit nor protection, and will fall from his position. In confirmation, Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes Srimad-Bhagavatam (11.5.2 - 3): “The four social orders, namely the brahmanas, the ksatriyas, the vaisyas and the sudras, have come out of the different parts of the universal form of the Supreme Lord... Similarly, the sannyasis have come out from the head, the vanaprasthas from the arms, the grhasthas from the waist and the brahmacaris from the legs... The injunction herein is that one has to act according to his position, and by such

49

activities one must either satisfy the Supreme Personality of Godhead or else fall down from one's position (pg 24 - 25).” 7 One can obtain worldly success and heavenly enjoyment by adhering to the minute details of varnasrama-dharma. Yet even if a person completely neglects every one of these rules and regulations, he can achieve all their benedictions simply by, "always remembering Krsna and never forgetting Him." Authenticating this, Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes Srimad-Bhagavatam (11.27.49): If people simply manage to worship or remember the Lord, “Then automatically they become very happy within this world, as well as in the next (pg 26).”

Utility of Other Vedic Injunctions "Always remember Krsna..." is the most important Vedic injunction. However, one should not hastily disregard the other injunctions. They may act as assistant parts of vaidhi-sadhana, if they are aimed at remembering Krsna. In such cases, these rules and regulations purify the practitioner, making it easier for him to remember Krsna and thus eventually achieve prema-bhakti. Srila Rupa Gosvami confirms this with a quote from Narada-Pancaratra: “Any activities sanctioned in the revealed scriptures and aiming at the satisfaction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead are accepted by saintly teachers as the regulative principles of devotional service. If one regularly executes such service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead under the direction of a bona fide spiritual master, then gradually he rises to the platform of serving in pure love of God (pg 27).”

7

The next four paragraphs in The Nectar of Devotion, ending just before the quote from SB 11.22.49, are Çréla Prabhupäda's comments on Çrémad-Bhägavatam (11.5.2 - 3).

50

Chapter Three

Eligibility of the Candidate for Accepting Devotional Service BRS 1.2.14 - 29

The Introduction defines pure devotional service, Chapter One describes its six characteristics, and Chapter Two describes its practice. This chapter will describe the basic qualifications for practicing devotional service. Devotional service is causeless. Consequently there are no prerequisites for taking up the practice of sadhana-bhakti. In the beginning, one does not even need knowledge and detachment. Attraction to serving Krsna is the only requirement. Srila Prabhupada writes, “One may attain a little bit of attraction to Sri Krsna, but at the same time may remain very much attached to fruitive activities and material sense enjoyment. Such a person, if he has unflinching attraction to Krsna, becomes an eligible candidate for discharging devotional service (pg 29).” Srila Rupa Gosvami substantiates this by quoting Lord Krsna's statement to Uddhava (SB 11.20.8), “My Dear Uddhava, only by exceptional fortune does someone become attracted to Me. And even if one is not completely detached from fruitive activities, or is not completely attached to devotional service, such service is quickly effective (pg 29).” In other words, even if one is still attached to material life, he can begin practicing devotional service if he simply some attraction to it.

Achieving Eligibility Attraction to Krsna is the only qualification for devotional service, but how does one get this attraction? Only by the mercy of a pure devotee. Therefore Srila Prabhupada first of all says, “On account of his association with mahatmas, or great souls one-hundred percent engaged in the devotional service of the Lord, one may attain a little bit of attraction for Sri Krsna (pg 29).” 8

8

See Waves of Devotion, page 2.

51

Renunciation, a Prerequisite? People generally think of renunciation (vairagya) as a prerequisite for beginning spiritual life, but for devotional service, it is not. In fact, it can even be an impediment to bhakti. If one is too detached from emotional and sensual activities he will not be inclined to devotional service, because devotional service entails active use of the senses and emotions.

Three Grades of Eligible Candidates As previously described, the impetus for vaidhi-bhakti is scriptural injunction. Therefore one's knowledge of and faith in the scriptures is a major consideration in determining one's eligibility to advance. A person's depth of faith and knowledge places him in one of three classes of candidates: uttama, madhyama, or kanistha.

Uttama-Adhikari The candidate with the best qualification to practice pure devotional service has very strong faith and very strong scriptural knowledge. Srila Prabhupada describes his strong knowledge: “He is very expert in the study of relevant scriptures, and he is also expert in putting forward arguments in terms of those scriptures (page 29).” Srila Prabhupada describes his faith: “He understands perfectly that the ultimate goal of life is to attain to the transcendental loving service of Krsna, and he knows that Krsna is the only object of worship and love (page 29).” 9 Succinctly put: “...he attains firm faith in the scriptures by understanding with all reason and arguments (pages 29 -30).”

Madhyama-Adhikari The candidate with medium qualification to practice pure devotional service has very strong faith but is somewhat lacking in scriptural knowledge. Srila Prabhupada describes, “he is not very expert in arguing on the strength of revealed scripture, but he has firm faith in the objective (page 30).”

Kanistha-Adhikari The candidate with the least qualification to perform regulated devotional service has weak faith and weak scriptural knowledge, and can therefore easily be swayed by superior arguments. 9

"Faith" means conviction that the goal of life is to please Kåñna, and to abandon all other desires.

52

Uttama Madhyama Kanistha

FAITH

KNOWLEDGE

Strong. Convinced, and can convince others. Strong. Convinced.

Strong. Can defeat opposing opinion. Good, but can't always defeat opposing opinion. Weak, cannot offer arguments to opposing opinion

Weak. Easily swayed.

Srila Prabhupada says, “Unlike the second-class devotee who also cannot put forward arguments and evidence from the scripture, but still has all faith in the objective, the neophyte has no firm faith in the objective. Thus he is

called the neophyte devotee (pg 30).” "Faith in the objective" means conviction that the goal of life is to please Krsna, and to abandon all other desires. If one accepts this, even without strong conviction and knowledge, he is a candidate for uttama-bhakti (pure devotional service). Stating that the kanistha-adhikari "has no firm faith in the objective" indicates that he does have some faith, but it is weak. Since he does have some faith that he should please Krsna and abandon other desires he is eligible to practice uttama-bhakti.

Those Without Faith in the Objective Bhagavada-Gita describes four types pious people who approach Krsna (exemplified by Dhruva Maharaja, the Four Kumaras, Gajendra, and the Sages of Naimisaranya). These are undoubtedly exalted souls — yet they did not posses the minimum eligibility (kanistha-adhikari) for pure devotional service because they did not understand or accept that the real objective of life is only to please of Krsna. Instead they approached the Lord for their own pleasure, and thus disqualified themselves from the practice of uttama-bhakti, which is free from all selfish motivations. Piety as Precursor to Faith in Bhakti Srila Prabhupada gives an extensive commentary on the above reference from Bhagavada-Gita, beginning at the second paragraph of page 31 and continuing to the top of page 33. He makes the following points. Although the four types of pious men are not qualified to practice uttamabhakti, they are meritorious; for they have approached Krsna. Srila Prabhupada says, “These four types of devotees have been described in the Seventh Chapter of Bhagavada-Gita and they have all been accepted as pious. Without becoming pious, no one can come to devotional service (pg 31).” Srila Prabhupada further confirms the importance of piety, “Without pious activities, if a man is in a distressed condition he becomes an agnostic, a communist,

53

or something like that. Because he does not firmly believe in God, he thinks he can adjust his distressed condition by totally disbelieving in Him (pg 31).” Bhakti is causeless and independent. It cannot be a result of ritualistic pious deeds. Therefore, the "piety" mentioned above refers to previous devotional activity (sukrti) which, done knowingly or unknowingly, awakens attraction to God. That is why Srila Prabhupada specifically equates lack of piety with lack of firm belief in God.

Wisdom, Renunciation, and Pure Devotional Service To begin practicing devotional service, the only qualification is an attraction for it. But to practice pure devotional service one must become renounced — freed from all desires except the desire to please Krsna. Srila Prabhupada comments, “It can be concluded that a person who is free from the bodily concept of life is an eligible candidate for pure devotional service (pg 32).” Thus out of the four persons mentioned in Bhagavada-Gita the wise man is best, because his inclination to approach the Lord for material, bodily benefit is nonexistent. “A wise man who becomes attached to Krsna does not want any return from Him, either in the form of relieving distress, or in gaining money. That means from the very beginning his basic principle of attachment to Krsna, more or less, is love (pg 31).” Quoting Bhagavada-Gita, Srila Prabhupada confirms that liberation from the bodily concept is essential for advancing in pure devotional service, “It is confirmed in Bhagavada-Gita (18.54) that after Brahman realization, when one is freed from material anxieties and can see every living entity on an equal level, he is eligible to enter into devotional service (pg 32).”

Liberation Comes Automatically Liberation from the bodily concept substantially deepens one's realization that the objective of life is to satisfy Krsna, not one's bodily urges. Consequently, it promotes one's adhikari — one's qualification for advancement. Liberation may therefore seem a desirable asset. However, liberation comes automatically to a devotee, as a by-product of devotional service. One should not separately endeavor for it. In fact, Srila Rupa Gosvami makes it very clear that a pure devotee must be free from desire for liberation (mukti) and sense gratification (bhukti). He compares these desires to ghosts and witches, “The material desire to enjoy the material world, and the desire to become liberated from material bondage are considered to be two witches, and they haunt one like ghosts. As long as these witches remain within the heart, how can one feel transcendental bliss? As long as these two witches remain in

54

the heart, there is no possibility of enjoying the transcendental bliss of devotional service.” 10 A haunted person is not free to act as he likes. He is forced to fulfil the desires of the ghost or witch who possesses him. Similarly, one who is haunted by desires for bhukti or mukti cannot act on the platform of bhakti. Instead, the ghost of bhukti and the witch of mukti force him to spend all his energy in pursuit of sense gratification and liberation. The desire for mukti (liberation) is verily a more severe impediment to pure devotional service than the desire for bhukti (sense gratification). In the process of becoming detached from the names, forms, qualities, and activities of the material world, one may inadvertently develop aversion to all such variegatedness, including the transcendental name, form, qualities, and activities of Krsna. Thus the desire for mukti is most diametrically opposed to pure devotional service. Srila Rupa Gosvami quoted the Bhagavada-Gita to establish that those who approach the Lord with ulterior motive lack the minimum qualification (kanistha) for vaidhi-sadhana-bhakti. The above verse from Caitanya-caritamrta confirms this, showing that any ulterior motive, whether for bhukti or for mukti, makes one ineligible to practice pure devotional service.

Conclusion 1.) The only qualification to begin devotional service is the mercy of a devotee, who enthuses one with attraction to the Supreme Lord. 2.) The qualification to advance in vaidhi-sadhana-bhakti depends upon the maturity of one's knowledge of and faith in the scriptures. 3.) The qualification for practicing pure devotional service is liberation from the bodily concept of life; characterized by the realization that one should abandon all desires (especially the desire for liberation) and endeavor only to please Krsna.

The Devotee's Staunch Rejection of Bhukti and Mukti In the verses that follow, Srila Rupa Gosvami highlights the devotee's staunch rejection of desires for bhukti and mukti. By doing this, he hopes to protect the devotee from the subtle-yet-lethal desire for mukti. “My dear son of Nanda, I do not want any material happiness in the shape of many followers, nor immense opulence in wealth, nor do I want cessation from material existence. I may take birth many times, one after another, but what I pray from You is that my devotion unto You may always remain unflinching (pg 33).” This verse of Siksastaka is the first of many excellent examples of a pure devotee's total disinterest in liberation 10

Cc. Madhya 19.176. See page 33 in The Nectar of Devotion.

55

A compilation of verses condemning the desire for liberation continue through Chapter Four. Thus Srila Prabhupada titles the next chapter, "Devotional Service Surpasses All Liberation."

56

Chapter Four

Devotional Service Surpasses All Liberation BRS 1.2.30 - 59

At the beginning of the next chapter, Srila Prabhupada will clearly describe the theme of this chapter: “All previous instructions imparted by Srila Rupa Gosvami in his broad statements can be summarized thus: as long as one is materially inclined or desirous of merging into the spiritual effulgence, one cannot enter into the realm of pure devotional service (pg 47).” Careful analysis of the verses presented here will reveal a variety of reasons why pure devotional service surpasses liberation, and will thus inspire the devotee to reject all desires for bhukti and mukti. Prthu Maharaja's prayer (top, page 37), shows that a devotee does not seek impersonal liberation because it offers no opportunity to hear the Lord's pastimes chanted by pure devotees, or to relish the delightful honey of the Lord's lotus feet. Instead of mukti, Prthu Maharaja prays for "Millions of tongues and ears" so he can constantly chant and hear the Lord's glories. In the prayer of Bharata Maharaja (bottom of page 37) we see how an uttamabhakta is ready to easily give up all material comforts. Lord Siva's statement (second paragraph, page 38) reveals the devotee's total disinterest in heaven or hell. He simply desires the Lord's service. By analyzing each verse we see countless ways that devotional service far surpasses liberation, what to speak of ordinary material opulence. One who has bhakti has no room for any other desires. This further clarifies the super-excellence of uttama-bhakti, and inspires us to eliminate anarthas that impede the awakening of our pure devotion. The "atmarama" verse (bottom page 44), which is the final reference in this series, clearly establishes the devotee's superiority over the jnani or karmi. Just as the previous verses establish the devotee's superiority over the jnani or karmi, the remaining verses establish the superiority of the Vrndavana devotees over all other devotees of the Lord. Srila Prabhupada says, “Out of the many kinds of devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the one who is attracted to the original form of the Lord, Krsna in Vrndavana, is considered to be the foremost, firstclass devotee. Such a devotee is never attracted by the opulences of Vaikuntha, or even of Dvaraka... (pgs 45 - 46)”

57

Chapter Five

The Purity of Devotional Service BRS 1.2.60 - 71

The execution and perfection of devotional service is not dependent on any material consideration. Every other process of self-realization, however, is dependent on external circumstances. Jnana-yoga requires a peaceful, renounced disposition, and highly developed intellect. Astanga-yoga demands many rigid prerequisites that only a sannyasi can even begin to adopt. Karma-kanòa is also dependent on external circumstances — a yajna cannot be successful unless the time, place, and ingredients are flawless. Only bhakti-yoga is completely pure, free from any dependence on external prerequisites. That is why Srila Prabhupada titles the Fifth Chapter, "The Purity of Devotional Service." Srila Rupa Gosvami mentions several common prerequisites for selfrealization; such as good birth, purity, and proper execution of varnasrama-dharma. He explains how bhakti is not dependent on them.

Birth Although generally considered a disqualification from the path of self-realization, low birth does not impede the execution of devotional service. Srila Prabhupada quotes Srimad-Bhagavatam (1.2.6) — devotional service has no material cause, and therefore “it cannot be checked by any material circumstances. It is open for all, without any distinction, and it is the constitutional occupation of the living entities (pg 47).” Srila Prabhupada then relates the interesting history of Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Thakura's opposition to the caste-gosvamis who claimed a birthright monopoly on pure devotional service. “There was a great hard struggle for some time, but it has turned out successfully, and it is now correctly and practically established that devotional service is not restricted to a particular class of men (pg 47).” This point is particularly relevant to the International Society for Krsna Consciousness. Srila Prabhupada writes, “Our Krsna consciousness movement in the Western world is based on the above-mentioned proposition of Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Gosvami Prabhupada, our spiritual master. On his authority, we are claiming members from all sections of the Western countries. The so-called brahmanas claim that one who is not born into a brahmana family cannot receive the sacred thread and cannot become a high-grade Vaisnava. But we do not accept such a theory, because it is not supported by Rupa Gosvami nor by the strength of the various scriptures (pg 48).”

58

By quoting Padma Purana, Skanda Purana, and Hari-bhakti-vilasa, Srila Rupa Gosvami confirms that advancement and perfection in devotional service is equally open to all people, regardless of birth. (See pages 48 - 49)

Purity Although a major pre-requisite for other processes of self-realization, purity is not a factor in determining one's eligibility to perform devotional service. Even if a devotee falls down from the standard of purity, he need not undergo any separate process of purification (prayascitta) such as karma or jnana. He can again take up devotional service immediately and be reinstated. One need not become purified before taking up devotional service. On the contrary, one becomes purified by taking up devotional service. (See page 49, first paragraph) To validate this claim Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes Srimad-Bhagavatam (11.21.2), which says that the only qualification for beginning devotional service is to follow the principles given by the acarya, there is no need for any other method of purification.

Varnasrama-Dharma Continuing the theme of bhakti's non-reliance upon purity, Srila Rupa Gosvami says that devotional service is not dependent on the proper execution of prescribed duties. It is not entirely accurate to say that one must first become purified in varnasrama, and then concentrate on bhakti. Srila Rupa Gosvami cites many sastric evidences to confirm this. Srimad-Bhagavatam (1.5.17): Narada Muni says, “Even if one does not execute his specific occupational duty, but immediately takes direct shelter of the lotus feet of Hari [Krsna], there will be no fault on his part, and in all circumstances his position is secure (pg 49).” 11 Srimad-Bhagavatam (11.11.32): “My dear Uddhava, any person who takes shelter of Me in complete surrender and follows My instructions, giving up all occupational duties, is to be considered the first-class man (pg 50).” Srimad-Bhagavatam (11.5.41): “My dear King, if someone gives up his occupational duties as they are prescribed for the different varnas and asramas, but takes complete shelter, surrendering himself unto the lotus feet of the Lord, such a person is no more a debtor... Nor has he any need to bother executing the five kinds of yajnas [sacrifices] for becoming free from sinful contamination. Simply by

11

Çréla Prabhupäda cites the Fifth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam in his commentary on this text.

59

discharging devotional service, he is freed from all kinds of obligations (pgs 50 51)." 12 Clearly, devotional service is not dependant on varnasrama-dharma. Simply by engaging in devotional service one will achieve all necessary purification. Thus, Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes Bhagavada-Gita (18.66): “Give up all your occupations and just become surrendered unto me. I give you assurance that I shall give you protection from all sinful reaction (pg 51).” Srila Prabhupada emphasises the point, “Don't hesitate. Don't consider that because you are giving up all other engagements there will be some flaw in your life. Don't think like that. I will give you all protection (pgs 51 - 52).” If any doubt remains, Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes Agastya-samhita, and SrimadBhagavatam (11.5.42).

Conclusion The conclusion is inspirational: bhakti-yoga is totally independent and self-sufficient; no material impediment should discourage one from the path of surrender.

12

Çréla Prabhupäda's commentary comprises the rest of the paragraph and the next two paragraphs in The Nectar of Devotion.

60

Chapter Six

How to Discharge Devotional Service BRS 1.2.72 - 96

Chapter Six is simply Srila Rupa Gosvami's list of 64 prominent devotional practices, compiled from Hari-bhakti-vilasa.

64 Items of Sädhana-Bhakti 20 Items of Primary Importance 1 - 10

11 - 20

Activities to Accept (pravåtti)

Activities to Avoid (nivåtti)

44 Additional Items of Service 21 - 59 Items of Sädhana

60 - 64 Five Most Effective Items

Chapter Two defined sadhana-bhakti as, "Engaging our senses in some service to Krsna." Now Srila Rupa Gosvami describes exactly how to engage our senses in Krsna's service.

Chapter Seven

Evidence Regarding Devotional Principles BRS 1.2.97 - 117

After listing the 64 main items of sadhana-bhakti, Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates and substantiates each with systematic scriptural evidence. This chapter describes the first 18 items. We will comment on a few. 1. Accepting the Shelter of a Bona Fide Spiritual Master (guru-padasraya) Srila Rupa Gosvami lists the most crucial item first. Following this one principle opens the doors to all 63 other items of sadhana, because the spiritual master will instruct one about the execution and significance of them all. The importance of this item becomes clearer by considering the evidence Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes to substantiate it: tasmad gurum prapadyeta jijnasuh sreya uttamam savde pare ca nisnatam

61

brahmany upasamasrayam Prabuddha speaks this verse (SB 11.3.21) to king Nimi immediately after he described the futility of earthly and heavenly sense gratification. According to Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Thakura's commentary on this verse, only a person who has understood the futility of material sense gratification can approach a bona fide spiritual master. Thus the first principle of devotional service is to clearly understand that the material world is a false shelter, to feel the urgent necessity of spiritual life, and to therefore seek the genuine shelter of a bona fide spiritual master. 2. Accepting Initiation from the Spiritual Master and Receiving Instructions from Him (Sri-krsna-diksadi-siksanam) Srila Rupa Gosvami again quotes Prabuddha, “My dear King, a disciple has to accept the spiritual master not only as spiritual master, but also as the representative of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the Supersoul (pg 60).” 13 In other words, after rejecting material life and taking shelter of a spiritual master, one must accept him with full faith. Diksa is the spiritual master's formal acceptance of the disciple's commitment and faith. Without this commitment a disciple cannot possess the unyielding faith required to properly assimilate the spiritual instructions of his guru. Srila Prabhupada explains, “One should learn Srimad-Bhagavatam seriously and with all respect and veneration from the spiritual master (pg 60).” 3. Serving the Spiritual Master with Faith and Confidence (visrambhena guroh seva) Concerning item #2, Prabuddha instructed, “Hearing and speaking SrimadBhagavatam is the religious process which elevates one to the platform of serving and loving the Supreme Personality of Godhead (pg 60).” Execution of item two elevates one to item three. Faithfully hearing from the spiritual master elevates one to the platform of faithful loving service to him. Srila Rupa Gosvami supports this with a famous verse in which Krsna states that the acarya should be accepted as the Lord's very self. Understanding the importance of service to the Supreme Lord, and knowing the spiritual master to be non-different from Him, the disciple must serve the guru with strong faith. 14

13 14

Tatra bhägavatän dharmän, sikñed gurv-ätma-daivataù, amäyayänuvåttyä yais, tuñyed ätmätma-do hariù — SB 11.3.22. Äcäryaà mäà vijänéyän, nävamanyeta karhicit, na martya-buddhyäsüyeta, sarva-deva-mayo guruù — SB 11.17.27.

62

4. Following in the Footsteps of Saintly Persons (sadhu-vartmanu vartanam) We must follow not only our own spiritual master, but all bona fide sadhus and acaryas in the line of disciplic succession. There should be no dissension between the guru's teachings and the teachings of guru-parampara, since the qualification of the bona-fide guru is that he presents the scriptures strictly according to guru-parampara. If he doesn't, adherence to him is not devotional service. Lord Buddha is an example. Even though he is the Personality of Godhead himself, his followers are not practicing pure devotional service because, for circumstantial reasons, Buddha did not strictly present the scriptures according to guru-parampara. In this regard, Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes a famous text from Brahma-yamala: sruti-smrti-puranadi pancaratra-vidhim vina aikantiki harer-bhaktir utpatayaiva kalpate Without faithful adherence to the rules of scripture (found in sruti, smrti, puranadi, and pancaratra), one's so-called devotional service is simply a disturbance to society. One must follow the footsteps of devotees who are strictly faithful to parampara. 5. Inquiring About Eternal Religious Principles (sad-dharma-prccha) The 64 items of sadhana-bhakti offer many practical ways to increase our devotional service. One way is to simply make note of the questions that arise during our study and contemplation of sastra, and put these questions before a senior Vaisnava. This in itself is devotional service. 15 8. Accepting Only What Is Necessary (yavad-arthanu-vartita) The reference from Naradiya Purana indicates that a devotee should accept only what is necessary for physical maintenance. Srila Prabhupada has expanded the meaning in terms of spiritual practices: “It is better if one fixes up a regulative principle according to his own ability and then follows that vow without fail. That will make him advanced in spiritual life (pg 63).” 10. Offering Respect to the Banyan Trees (dhatry asvatthadi-gauravam) The reference quoted from Skanda Purana (pg 63) reveals the scope of this devotional practice. One must respect not only the Banyan tree (asvattha), but all living entities 15

In Bhakti-sandarbha Jéva Gosväm é say s, " There are two ways to se rve the pure devotee: (1 ) by associating with, hearing from, and inquiring from, and (2) by rendering physical acts of service. (tatra mahäbhägavata-sevä dvidhä — prasanga-rüpa, paricaryä-rüpa ca. From Bhakti-sandarbha, text 238.)

63

who serve the Lord and His devotees. Such living entities include Tulasi, brahmanas, and cows. In his commentary on this text of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, Jiva Gosvami notes that Lord Gopala is pleased when the cows are nicely taken care of. He cites the Gautamiya Tantra, describing how one should gently scratch the body of the cow, offer her a handful of green grass, and reverentially circumambulate with one's right side kept towards her. 11. Giving Up the Company of Nondevotees (sri-krsna-vimukhajana-sanga-tyago) Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes two references: “...even if one is forced to live within a cage of iron or in the midst of a blazing fire, he should accept this position rather than live with nondevotees who are through and through against the supremacy of the Lord (pg 64).” And, “...one should prefer to embrace a snake, a tiger or an alligator rather than associate with persons who are worshipers of various demigods and who are impelled by material desire (pg 64).” Underscoring the importance of this item, Srila Prabhupada adds a third reference by paraphrasing a prominent Caitanya-caritamrta verse that defines a Vaisnava as one who gives up the company of non devotees. 16 12-14. Not Accepting Unfit Disciples, Constructing Many Temples, or Reading Many Books (sisyady ananuvanddhitvadi-trayam) If a person is seriously inclined to become a disciple, the sannyasi should accept him. If money comes of its own accord, a spiritual master can construct costly temples. However, one must do these things only for the sake of spreading Krsna consciousness, not for increasing one's fame and reputation. Similarly, a qualified person can study the literature of our great acaryas, but his motive must be to purify his heart, not to deliver lectures intended to impress others. False prestige is harshly opposed to bhakti. Avoiding it is an integral item of sadhana. 15, 16. Straightforwardness in Ordinary Dealings and Equilibrium in Loss and Gain (vyavahare 'py akarpanyam, and sokady avasavartita) Straightforwardness in Ordinary Dealings The first reference from Padma Purana (pg 66 - 67) is evidence for this item.

16

(Cc. Madhya 22.87): asat sanga tyäg, ei vaiñnava äcära.

64

Sometimes a devotee must deal with practical matters of dollars and cents — "ordinary dealings" that tend to bring out one's cheating propensities. Therefore, one must practice honesty in all one's dealings, always remaining Krsna conscious, pleasant, straight-forward. Equilibrium in Loss and Gain The second reference from Padma Purana (pg 67) is evidence for this item. It enjoins that anyone who wants to think of Krsna must not allow strong material emotions to overwhelm his heart.

65

Chapter Eight

Offences to be Avoided BRS 1.2.118 - 120

The nineteenth item of sadhana-bhakti is the sole subject of Chapter Eight. Sevanamaparadhanam varjanam — "One must carefully avoid the various offenses in chanting the holy name and in worshipping the Deity" Srila Rupa Gosvami makes an important point about seva-aparadha (offences to the Deity) by quoting the Padma Purana: One should not allow himself to become neglectful in Deity worship, thinking that the holy name will deliver him from his offences. Chanting the holy name will deliver one from all offences, but if one wilfully employs the name in this way he offends the name and thus neutralizes its effect. An offender to the holy name has no chance of deliverance (see pages 71 - 72). As Srila Prabhupada mentioned in the Introduction, there are two categories of devotional activities: pravrtti and nivrtti (positive and negative actions). Avoiding offences is an example of nivrtti — negation of activities that hinder our proper meditation on Krsna.

Understanding the Offences As explained in Chapter Two, the essential function of all devotional items is remembrance of Krsna. Keeping this in mind will help resolve any apparent contradictions. For example, Regulation 21 (not to eulogize or praise anyone before the Deity) and Regulation 30 (not to fail to offer praise in the presence of the spiritual master) appear to be contradictory. If the spiritual master is present before the Deity, it seems unavoidable to commit one offence or the other. However, we can easily resolve such contradictions by keeping the proper perspective, and seeing these regulations as aids for our respectful remembrance of Krsna. Out of regard for the Deity we may choose to praise the spiritual master in our minds, perhaps with discreet gestures of respect; or, we may choose to openly praise him as the Lord's servant, for the pleasure of the Deities. Neither is an offence, as they both ensure respectful remembrance of Krsna.

66

Chapter Nine

Further Consideration of Devotional Principles BRS 1.2.121 - 169

This chapter continues describing the 64 items of devotional service. 23. Accepting Flower Garlands (nirmalya-dhrtih) In Srimad-Bhagavatam (11.6.46), Uddhava says, “My dear Krsna, I have taken things which You have used and enjoyed, such as garlands of flowers, saintly articles, garments and ornaments... (pg 74)” The phrase saintly articles should be scented oils. The Sanskrit word used here is gandha — "scents." The phonetic similarity between saintly articles and scented oils makes it obvious that the original transcriber did not hear Srila Prabhupada properly. 30. Arcana (arcanam) The essential function of sadhana-bhakti is remembrance of Krsna by engaging the mind and senses in His service. Worship of the Deity is an excellent way to achieve this. This chapter lists some of the many ways that Deity worship can engage the senses in the Lord's service: 23. Accepting Flower Garlands 24. Dancing Before the Deity 25. Bowing Down in Honor of the Deity 26. Standing Up to Receive the Lord 27. Following the Deity 28. Going to the Temple... 29. Circumambulating the Temple... 31. Rendering Service to the Lord 37. Partaking of Prasadam 38. Drinking Caranamrta 39. Smelling the Incense and Flowers Offered to the Deity 40. Touching the Deity 41. Seeing the Deity 42. Observing Arati... 31. Rendering Service to the Lord (paricarya) Arcana (item 30) and Rendering Service to the Lord (item 31) are very similar. Srila Prabhupada points out the difference: Arcana means worship of the Deities in the temple. Rendering Service to the Lord means worshipping Krsna “in just the way that a king is worshipped in his palace (pg 78).”

67

Srila Prabhupada mentions that rich men can easily perform this item of devotional service by constructing costly temples or arranging for opulent Deity worship. In his commentary on Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, Sri Jiva Gosvami says that paricarya means using the same accessories one uses to serve a king. For example, when the Deity goes on procession one may hold an umbrella, carry His palanquin, fan Him with a camara whisk, etc. 33. Sankirtana (sankirtanam) According to Srila Rupa Gosvami, sankirtana refers not only to congregational chanting of the holy name, but also to loudly chanting the glories of the Lord's pastimes, qualities, etc. The first evidence (Visnu Dharma) refers to nama-sankirtana. The next evidence (Srimad-Bhagavatam 7.9.18) refers to lila-sankirtana. The last evidence (Srimad-Bhagavatam 1.5.22) refers to guna-sankirtana. 35. Submission (vijnapti) 17 "Submission" is a personal prayer that expresses one's own sentiments to Krsna. This is different from the next item (36), in which one recites notable prayers from sastra. One can express himself to the Lord in three ways: 1.

Samprarthanatmika — expressing ones heart-felt desire for spontaneous devotional service. (The first reference from Padma Purana describes this).

2.

Dainyavodhika — expressing ones insignificance before the Deity. (The second reference from Padma Purana describes this).

3.

Lalasamayi — expressing ones desire for a specific spiritual perfection. This is an advanced practice that involves some realization of one's eternal relationship with the Lord.

Samprarthanatmika is a prayer for the awakening of bhava. Lalasamayi, however, occurs at a more advanced stage, “When one realizes something of his constitutional relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead (pg 81).” It is a prayer to be reinstated in one's specific eternal service to Krsna (svarupa-siddhi). Narada Muni's prayer is the first example of lalasamayi. Overwhelmed with the mood of dasya, Narada desires to render the specific service of fanning the Lord while He rests with Laksmi. Unlike samprarthanatmika, the expression of this desire results from direct realization of his eternal mood of devotion.

17

Vijïapti — literally, the word means "an entreaty," or as Çréla Prabhupäda puts it, a "submission."

68

Developing an intense hankering for Krsna consciousness is the essence of Lord Caitanya's teachings. Ramananda Roy instructed Lord Caitanya: tatra laulyam api mulyam ekalam, Krsna consciousness “can be obtained only by paying one price — that is, intense greed to obtain it.” 18 Srila Prabhupada comments extensively on the importance of developing laulyam, or “excessive eagerness for meeting and serving the Lord in a particular way (pg 83).” “In other words, one should learn how to cry for the Lord. One should learn this small technique, and he should be very eager and actually cry to become engaged in some particular type of service. This is called laulyam, and such tears are the price for the highest perfection (pg 83).”

18

(Cc. Madhya 8.70)This is the same verse fro m which Çréla Pr abhupäda extracted t he phrase "Kåñna consciousness." kåñna-bhakti-rasa-bhävitä — b eing abso rbed in the mellows of ex ecuting d evotional service to Kåñna.

69

Chapter Ten

Techniques of Hearing and Remembering BRS 1.2.170 - 182

This chapter describes four devotional principles: hearing, expecting the Lord's mercy, remembering, and meditation. Srila Rupa Gosvami extensively discusses hearing and meditation. 43. Hearing (sravanam) There are basically three ways to perform hearing: (1) nama-sravana — hearing the name, (2) carita-sravana — hearing about the pastimes, and (3) gunadi-sravana — hearing about the qualities, etc. of Krsna. The first reference (Garuda Purana) deals with hearing the Lord's name. The second reference (Fourth Canto) deals with hearing the Lord's pastimes. The last reference (Twelfth Canto) deals with hearing “His glorification and transcendental qualities.” (See pages 89 - 90) 44. Expecting the Lord's Mercy (tat-krpeksanam) Much of our life in this world is spent suffering the results of sinful reaction. Devotional service is so practical that it can transform this into an opportunity for sadhana-bhakti. It requires only the right attitude. Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes Srimad-Bhagavatam (10.14.8) to show that there are two ways to practice Krsna consciousness in adverse situations: (1) accepting the reactions as the Lord's mercy, and (2) repeatedly offering obeisances within ones mind. “My dear Lord, any person who is constantly awaiting Your causeless mercy to be bestowed upon him, and who goes on suffering the resultant actions of his past misdeeds, offering You respectful obeisances from the core of his heart, is certainly eligible to become liberated, for it has become his rightful claim (pg 91).” 45 & 46. Remembrance and Meditation (smrtih and dhyanam) These two items are similar. Remembrance means to think of Krsna in a general way. Meditation involves deeper contemplation, which Srila Rupa Gosvami has divided into four types: (1) rupa-dhyanam — meditation on Krsna's form, (2) guna-dhyanam — meditation on Krsna's qualities, (3) krida-dhyanam — meditation on Krsna's activities, and (4) seva-dhyanam — meditation on devotional service to Krsna.

70

Chapter Eleven

Aspects of Transcendental Service BRS 1.2.183 - 203

This chapter describes the last and most advanced of the nine main processes of devotional service: dasyam, sakhyam, and atma-nivedanam. 47. Servitorship (dasyam) There are two aspects of servitorship: (1) karmarpanam — offering ones' activities to the Lord, and (2) kainkaryam — serving in the mood of a personal attendant. The Skanda Purana elaborately describes the first aspect (pg 95). The Naradiya Purana briefly alludes to the second aspect (pg 96).

Servitorship karmärpaëaà offering fruits of varëäçrama (karma)

kaiìkaryam

offering 9 main devotional activities (bhakti)

Karmarpanam Offering one's activities to the Lord (karmarpanam) has two subdivisions: (1) offering the fruits of ones prescribed duties in varnasrama, and (2) offering direct service within the nine main processes of devotional service.

Some teachers accept both subdivisions as bona fide forms of servitorship in sadhana-bhakti; our acaryas, however, do not. Pure devotional service must be free from work born of fruitive desire. Therefore, our acaryas do not accept offering the fruits of one's prescribed duties as a bona fide item of sadhana-bhakti. Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Thakura's commentary to Brahma-samhita text 61 supports this. He says that offering one's activities in varnasrama is known as gauna-dharma — subsidiary devotional activity. Such activities are not directly bhakti, although they may be indirectly conducive to devotional service. Lord Krsna confirms the same point in Srimad-Bhagavatam (11.25.23). As explained in the BBT commentary on this verse, “Ordinary work performed as an offering to God, without desire for the result, is understood to be in the mode of Goodness, whereas activities of devotional service — such as chanting and hearing the glories of the Lord — are transcendental forms of work beyond the modes of nature.” Srila Prabhupada says, “In the opinion of the karmis (fruitive workers), offering the results of karma is called servitorship. But according to Vaisnava acaryas like Srila Rupa Gosvami, servitorship means constant engagement in some kind of service to the Lord (pg 95).” Srila Prabhupada reconciles the two opinions, “Those who are engaged in fruitive activities, or prescribed duties according to the four orders of social and

71

spiritual life, are not actually pure devotees. But still, because they are offering the result to the Lord, they are accepted as devotees. When one has no such desire, but acts spontaneously out of love of God, such a person must be accepted as a pure devotee (pg 94).” Kainkaryam In the first type of servitorship, karmarpanam, one performs direct devotional service. In the second type of servitorship, kainkaryam, one performs direct devotional service in the mood of the Lord's personal attendant. The distinction lies in the attitude of the performer, not in the activities themselves. Even if one engages in the nine processes of direct devotional service, his activity is karmarpanam unless he serves with very deep concentration, in the mood of a personal attendant of the Lord. Quoting the famous verse from Naradiya Purana, Srila Rupa Gosvami describes this mood of tireless endeavor to serve Krsna with body, mind and words (see page 96): iha yasya harer dasye karmana manasa gira nikhilasvapy avasthasu jivan-mukta sa ucyate “A person acting in the service of Krsna with body, mind, intelligence and words is a liberated person even within the material world, although he may be engaged in many so-called material activities.” (Cc. Madhya 11.89) This illustrates how a devotee in kainkaryam constantly engages everything — mind, body and words — in the Lord's personal service. 48. Devotional Service in Friendship (sakhyam) There are two types of friendship: (1) visvasa — a superior well-wisher, (2) mitra — a friendly relationship with a peer. Visvasa Visvasa means to have strong faith or confidence in the Lord as one's benefactor. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “The devotee who has confidence in devotional service to the Lord systematically follows all the rules and regulations, with the faith that he will achieve the platform of transcendental life (pg 96).” Draupadi is a devotee who sees the Lord as a friend in the sense of visvasa — her well-wisher and protector.

72

In Nectar of Devotion, Srila Prabhupada adds a twist to this aspect of transcendental service. Ordinarily, the devotee sees the Lord as the well-wisher, but by preaching Krsna consciousness the devotee becomes the well-wisher of the Lord. Since visvasa refers to faith in the Lord, Srila Rupa Gosvami will discuss the topic of faith. He explains that it has two stages: (1) sraddha — preliminary faith, and (2) visvasa — mature faith. First there is sraddha, the simple faith necessary for beginning to engage in devotional service, which in time matures into visvasa, very strong faith. Srila Prabhupada describes this, “a neophyte devotee who has simply developed a slight love of Godhead is certainly a prospective candidate for devotional service. When he becomes firmly fixed in such devotional service, that assured status becomes a confidential part of his devotional service (pg 97).” Mitra The second type of friendship (mitra) occurs at an advanced stage, when a devotee begins to serve the Deity in a mood of fraternity or equality. Srila Prabhupada mentions, “Sometimes it is found that a pure devotee lies down in the temple of the Lord in order to serve Him as a confidential friend. Such friendly behavior of a devotee may be accepted as raganuga, or spontaneous. Although, according to regulative principles, no one can lie down in the temple of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, this spontaneous love of Godhead may be grouped under devotional service in friendship (page 97).” This is an example of mitra friendship. 49. Surrendering Everything to the Lord (atma-nivedanam) Srila Prabhupada comments, “According to different authorities, self is differently defined. Self is sometimes considered to refer to the spirit self, or soul, and self is sometimes considered to refer to the mind or to the body (pages 97 - 98).” Depending on the definition, the term atma-nivedanam takes on three meanings: (1) If atma refers to the body, then atma-nivedanam means full bodily surrender. (2) If atma -[refers to the mind, then atma-nivedanam means full mental surrender. (3) If atma refers to the spirit-self, then atma-nivedanam means full surrender of self-identity. The prayer of Yamunacarya is an example of atma being defined as the soul, or possessor of the body. In this case, atma-nivedanam means surrender of the egoistic attachment to the body. Such a surrendered devotee becomes unconcerned even about the bodily form of life he may be in. “My dear Lord, I may be living within some body as a human being or a demigod, but whatever mode of life, I do not mind, because these bodies are simply by-products of the three modes of material nature, and I, who am in possession of these bodies, am surrendering myself unto You (pg 98).” The reference from Hari-bhakti-viveka illustrates the principle of surrendering one's body to the Lord.

73

50. Offering a Favorite Article (nija-priyopaharanam) This simple means of performing devotional service has two aspects: (1) to offer the Lord ones own favorite articles, (2) to offer the Lord His own favorite articles, like peacock feathers, etc. 51. Performing all Endeavors for Krsna (tad-arthe 'khila-cestitam) Everyone can easily perform this aspect of sadhana-bhakti, even those who are entangled in worldly responsibilities. Srila Prabhupada explains the modern application of this item: “A devotee who has a great establishment or factory may offer the fruits of such a material possession for the service of the Lord (pg 99).” 52. Being a Surrendered Soul (saranapattih) There is a subtle distinction between atma-nivedanam ("surrendering everything to the Lord") and saranapattih ("being a surrendered soul"). Saranapattih means to consider oneself completely subservient to and protected by the Lord. Atma-nivedanam also means self-dedication, but such dedication may by with or without such feelings of subservience and dependence. Bali Maharaja is an example of atma-nivedanam without a feeling of subservient dependence on the Lord. 53. Serving Trees Such as the Tulasi (tadiyanam sevanam tulasyah) The reference quoted to substantiate this item broadens the opportunities for serving Tulasi. Simply by seeing, simply by praying to, simply by bowing before, simply by hearing about, or simply by serving the tree, there is always auspiciousness.

74

Chapter Twelve

Further Aspects of Transcendental Service BRS 1.2.207 - 237

This chapter describes the final eleven items of sadhana-bhakti. 57. Serving the Lord According to One's Position (yatha-vaisnava-mahotsavo) One should perform Vaisnava festivals as lavishly as one's financial position will allow. 58. Performing Devotional Service in Karttika (urja-vrata) As indicated in the Padma Purana, This practice is extremely powerful, especially when done in Vrndavana. In his commentary, Jiva Gosvami says if one performs karttika-vrata in Vrndavana, even without devotion, the Lord will very easily offer His personal service. 59. Observing Festivals Celebrating the Lord's Activities (sri janma-dina-yatra) On the surface this may seem almost identical to item 57 (lavishly observing Vaisnava festivals). This item, however, specifically refers to Janmastami, as can be understood from three sources: (1) its Sanskrit heading: sri janma-dina-yatra; (2) the title Srila Prabhupada gave it in the Sixth Chapter: "During Janmastami one should observe a special festival;" and (3) the evidence given from Bhavisya Purana, “My Lord Janardana [Krsna], please let us know the date when Your mother Devaki gave birth to You. If You kindly inform us about this, then we shall observe a great celebration of this date. O killer of Kesi, we are souls one hundred percent surrendered unto Your lotus feet, and we wish only to please You with our ceremonies (pg 104).”

Final Five Items The next chapter will separately describe the final five items. Srila Rupa Gosvami has already listed them as items of sadhana-bhakti, but here mentions them a second time to emphasize their superlative effectiveness in evoking devotion. Previous listings for these items are: 1)

Item 60: Serving the Deity with great devotion, and item 30: Arcana.

2)

Item 61: Recitation of Srimad-Bhagavatam among devotees, and item 54: Hearing the revealed scriptures.

3)

Item 62: Associating with advanced devotees, and item 56: Rendering service to devotees.

4)

Item 63: Chanting the holy name of the Lord, and item 33: Sankirtana.

75

5)

Item 64: Living in Mathura, and item 55: Residing in Mathura.

Some Other Apparent Repetitions Mathura-Vrndavana The following items appear to be duplications: Item 7 ("residing in a sacred place of pilgrimage like Dvaraka or Vrndavana"), Item 48 ("going to the temple of Visnu or to places of pilgrimage"), item 55 ("one should live in a sacred place like Mathura, Vrndavana or Dvaraka"), and item 64 ("one should live in the jurisdiction of Mathura"). The repeated mention of Mathura-Vrndavana emphasizes its primary importance in sadhana-bhakti. The four items are distinguishable: Item 7 refers to visiting specific holy places, which include Dvaraka, Jagannatha Puri, the Ganga, etc. Item 48 refers to briefly visiting any holy place or temple of Visnu. Item 55 refers exclusively to Mathura-Vrndavana, and specifically mentions the effects of living there and serving the place in various ways. Item 64 is indistinguishable from item 55. The Sanskrit titles for both are in the seventh case singular, which indicates that their meaning is identical.

Worshipping Sacred Trees, etc. Item 10 ("worshiping sacred trees like the banyan tree"), and item 53 ("one should pour water on the tulasi tree") can be distinguished from each other as follows: Item 10 refers to the respectful disposition one should have towards these entities. Item 53 refers to physical acts of service one should do for them.

Singing and Chanting Item 32 ("one must sing"), item 33 ("one must perform sankirtana"), item 34 ("one must chant"), and item 63 ("chanting the Hare Krsna mantra") can be distinguished from each other as follows: Item 32 (gitam) refers to singing songs written in glorification of the Lord. Item 33 (sankirtanam) refers to congregational chanting of the Lord's names, pastimes, and qualities. Item 34 (japa) refers to quiet recitation of mantra. Item 63 refers exclusively to the paramount importance of congregationally chanting the Lord's holy name. 19

19

Item 63 (çré-näma-sankértanam) is identical to the first subdivision of item 33 (näma-sankértanam).

76

Others Item 30 (arcana, serving the Deity) and item 31 (rendering service to the Deity) have been distinguished in Chapter Nine (See page 25 of this book). Item 35 (offering prayers) and item 36 (reciting notable prayers) have been distinguished in Chapter Nine (See page 26 of this book). Item 45 (remembrance) and item 46 (meditation) have been distinguished in Chapter Ten (See page 28 of this book) Item 49 (surrendering everything) and item 52 (becoming a surrendered soul) have been distinguished in Chapter Eleven (See page 32 of this book). Item 57 (lavishly observing Vaisnava festivals) and item 59 (observing festivals celebrating the Lord's activities) have been distinguished in Chapter Twelve (See page 33 of this book).

77

Chapter Thirteen

Five Potent Forms of Devotional Service BRS 1.2.238 - 247

1. Residing in Mathura (mathura-manòale sthitih) 2. Worshipping the Deity (sri-murter-anghri-sevane pritah) 3. Hearing Srimad-Bhagavatam (sri bhagavatarthasvado) 4. Chanting the Hare Krsna Mantra (sri-nama-sankirtanam) 5. Serving a Devotee (sajatiyasaya-snigdha sri-bhagavad-bhakta-sango) Srila Prabhupada says these practices “are so potent that a small attachment for any of these five items can arouse devotional ecstasy even in a neophyte (pg 109).” "Devotional ecstasy" refers to bhava-bhakti. "Neophyte," in this context, refers to one with weak attachment. Thus even a neophyte devotee with weak attachment to Krsna can quickly achieve bhava-bhakti by practicing any one of these five most potent items.

Spiritual Program for Rapid Advancement Srila Prabhupada used these five most potent items as pillars on which he built the basic spiritual program of ISKCON: chanting Hare Krsna, daily Srimad-Bhagavatam class, lavish deity worship, guru-puja (serving a devotee), and the establishment of extensive facilities in Mayapura and Vrndavana. Any one of these items can quickly arouse bhava-bhakti even in a neophyte. However, these powerful items will not bestow their effects as long as one commits offences. Thus a devotee who wants to make rapid advancement should focus on these five potent items, and very diligently avoid offences, especially offences to Vaisnavas.

EXAMPLES HOW EACH ITEM EVOKES BHAVA Worshipping the Deity Srila Rupa Gosvami composes a beautiful metaphor to illustrate the special efficacy of Deity worship, “My dear friend, if you still have any desire to enjoy the company of your friends within the material world, then don't look upon the form of Krsna, who is standing on the bank of Kesi-Ghata. He is known as Govinda, and His eyes are very enchanting. He is playing upon His flute, and on His head there is a peacock feather. And His whole body is illuminated by the moonlight in the sky (pg 109).”

78

This type of poetic metaphor condemns what it seems to praise, and praises what it seems to condemn. Thus it instructs one to see the beautiful Deity of Govinda in Vrndavana and thereby become completely indifferent to the attractions of the material world. Complete indifference is one of the nine symptoms of bhava-bhakti (namely, virakti). 20 Srila Rupa Gosvami thus shows that seeing the Deity, especially the Govinda form, can quickly evoke devotional ecstasy (bhava) even in a neophyte.

Hearing Srimad-Bhagavatam Srila Rupa Gosvami composes a similar metaphor (pg 109) calling a friend "foolish" for having heard the Tenth Canto of Srimad-Bhagavatam and thereby becoming completely indifferent to the "wonderful" activities of dharma, artha, kama, and moksa. 21 He thus poetically instructs us to hear Srimad-Bhagavatam, which is so glorious that even the four goals of human life are insignificant in comparison. Denunciation of even liberation is a characteristic of bhava-bhakti (namely, moksa-laghutakrt). 22 Srila Rupa Gosvami thus shows that hearing Srimad-Bhagavatam, especially the Tenth Canto, can quickly evoke devotional ecstasy (bhava) even in a neophyte.

Comment [VKD1]: Page: 36 This is from Mukunda däsa's commentary

Serving a Devotee Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the rich devotional sentiments of a devotee in whose heart the Lord has appeared, “It is very astonishing that since I have seen this Personality of Godhead, who is washed by the tears of my eyes, there is shivering of my body, and he has made me a failure in executing my duties. Since seeing Him, I cannot remain silently at home. I wish to go out to Him always (pg 110).” This text seems to exemplify how one can achieve bhava by seeing the form of the Lord. However, the actual purport is that association with devotees (who are enriched with the devotional symptoms mentioned above) has tremendous potency to inspire one's Krsna consciousness. Thus the verse illustrates the efficacy of serving a devotee. 23 Srila Prabhupada comments, “The purport of this statement is that as soon as one is fortunate to contact a pure devotee, one must be anxious immediately to hear

20

Chapter Eighteen will describe the nine symptoms of bhäva (See page of this book).

21

In this vers e, Çréla Rüpa Gosväm é refers to dharma, artha, and käma as "glorious" (subhadän); and mokña as "d elightful" ( sukhamaya). Thi s shows how Çrémad-Bhägavatam i s so po werful t hat it can make one indifferent to even the most wonderful and delightful activities in the world.

22

Se e page of this book.

23

B RS 1.2.241

79

about Krsna, to learn about Krsna, or, in other words, to become fully Krsna conscious (pg 110).” One who associates with advanced devotees will quickly become enriched with symptoms of devotional ecstasy (bhava) such as samutkantha — intense eagerness, and avyartha-kalatvam — executing service without a moment wasted (“Since seeing Him, I cannot remain silently at home. I wish to go out to Him always”). If simply seeing a devotee can bestow such realizations, certainly one will rapidly achieve genuine ecstatic devotion by actually serving a devotee.

Chanting the Hare Krsna Mantra “It is said that the saints have been able to hear the vibrating strings of the vina in the hands of Narada, who is always singing the glories of Lord Krsna. Now this same sound vibration has entered my ears, and I am always feeling the presence of the Supreme Personality. Gradually I am becoming bereft of all attachment for material enjoyment (pgs 110 - 111).” The sound being heard in this verse is Narada's "singing the glories of Lord Krsna" accompanied by "the vibrating strings of the vina." Hearing Narada's kirtana causes one to become "bereft of all attachment for material enjoyment." This complete detachment is a symptom of bhava (namely, virakti). Srila Rupa Gosvami thus shows that kirtana can immediately evoke devotional ecstasy (bhava), even in a neophyte.

Residing in Mathura Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the beauty of Sri Vrndavana Dhama, decorated with the Yamuna, kadamba trees, chirping birds, and the beautiful form of Syamasundara. Simply remembering this beauty evokes bhava. “I remember the Lord standing on the banks of the Yamuna River, so beautiful amid the kadamba trees, where many birds are chirping in the gardens. And these impressions are always giving me transcendental realizations of beauty and bliss (pg 111).” According to Jiva Gosvami, "transcendental realizations of beauty and bliss" (manasi kamapi bhavam kanana-sristanoti) indicates mental realization of one's eternal serving mood, svarupa-siddhi — which occurs during the stage of bhava-bhakti. Srila Rupa Gosvami thus shows that simply remembering Vrndavana can quickly evoke devotional ecstasy (bhava), even in a neophyte. If simply remembering Vrndavana can cause such powerful realizations, certainly one's transcendental feelings will immediately be aroused by actually being there. Srila Prabhupada says, “Such transcendental feelings are aroused immediately and without fail after one arrives in Mathura or Vrndavana (pg 111).”

80

The Results Srila Rupa Gosvami explains that the results of these items are not over-estimations. They are true in certain cases, and are intended to describe the item's potential for evoking bhava-bhakti when executed offencelessly. Sometimes these 64 activities are said to reward one with various worldly benedictions, but Srila Rupa Gosvami explains that this is simply a way of attracting mundane people to devotional service. The actual result of these 64 activities is bhavabhakti.

RELATION OF OTHER PRACTICES TO SADHANA Some practices (varnasrama-dharma, cultivation of jnana and renunciation, etc.) were not mentioned in the list of 64 items; are they not items of devotional service? If not, what is their relationship to sadhana-bhakti?

Varnasrama & Sadhana-Bhakti Srila Rupa Gosvami first analyzes varnasrama-dharma and concludes that it is not an item of bhakti. However, a devotee who is not yet fully attracted to unalloyed glorification of Krsna may utilize varnasrama-dharma to regulate and purify his distracting material desires. For example, marriage is certainly not one of the 64 items of devotional service. A devotee, however, may enter grhasta-asrama if necessary to avoid sinful life and stay on the progressive path. If such varnasrama activities are aimed at purification for the Lord's pleasure they can be considered a subsidiary item of devotional service. Without being aimed at eventual purification and unalloyed surrender, no aspect of varnasrama can be considered an item of devotional service. 24

24

See page 29 of this book.

81

Chapter Fourteen

Devotional Qualifications BRS 1.2.248 - 269

At the end of Chapter Thirteen, Srila Rupa Gosvami began to analyze the relation between various spiritual practices and pure devotional service. This continues in Chapter Fourteen, beginning with an analysis of jnana and vairagya.

Jnana & Vairagya Jnana (cultivation of knowledge) and vairagya (cultivation of detachment) may preliminarily help a new devotee to focus on Krsna by freeing him from distracting attraction to sense objects. However, in practicing jnana and vairagya one's mind is not directly fixed on Krsna — it is absorbed in philosophical discrimination between matter and spirit. Fixing the mind on Krsna is the most essential part of sadhana. Since jnana and vairagya fail to do so, they are not items of sadhana-bhakti. Further, they may be detrimental to the cultivation of devotion. Srila Rupa Gosvami warns that jnana and vairagya can make the heart harder and harder. A materially attached person has many emotions that impel him towards sense gratification. Vairagya involves making the heart callous and indifferent to these emotions so that one will not be moved by them. Bhakti, though, means to please the Lord by one's love for Him. To express such love requires a soft heart, easily moved by the Lord's name, form, qualities, and activities. Jnana and vairagya are not favorable to devotional service because they result in a hard, Stoic heart. Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes Srimad-Bhagavatam (11.20.31) in support of this. (See page 113) Although the processes of jnana and vairagya are unfavorable to devotional service, the qualities of knowledge (jnana) and detachment (vairagya) are necessary for devotional advancement. Without knowledge and detachment, one will be attached to the material body and tend to act for the body, not for Krsna's pleasure. Detachment can harden the heart and make it useless for devotional service, yet detachment is necessary for achieving the desirelessness required for pure devotional service. Is it possible to acquire detachment without hardening the heart?

Yukta-Vairagya In answer, Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes the Eleventh Canto (11.20.32 - 33) to show that detachment and knowledge automatically come from bhakti. He then imparts his famous yuktavairagya verse: anasaktasya visayan yatharham upayunjatah nirbandhah krsna-sambandhe yuktam-vairagyam ucyate

82

“When one is not attached to anything but at the same time accepts everything in relation to Krsna, one is rightly situated above possessiveness.” (Cc. Madhya 16.238p.) 25 Yukta-vairagya means to accept only those things that can be used in Krsna's service, and to reject everything else. It is a balanced process of detachment, by which a devotee acquires the qualities of knowledge and detachment without undergoing the heart-hardening processes jnana and vairagya. On this path, the emotions are still engaged; thus they do not atrophy. But the emotions and activities of yukta-vairagya exclusively center on Krsna, and therefore effectively extricate one from the mundane sphere and attach one to the Lord.

Phalgu-Vairagya Srila Rupa Gosvami then explains that rejecting something which could be used in Krsna's service is phalgu-vairagya — false renunciation. This is the type of renunciation that hinders the development of bhakti.

Wealth and Followers Performing devotional service through one's wealth or followers is not an item of sadhanabhakti. A wealthy person may give a large donation to build a huge temple — this is certainly devotional service. However, he should not think that the subsequent activities performed therein (worshipping the Deity, offering prasadam, etc.) are his devotional service. If he becomes carried away by this misconception, his impetus for devotional service will slacken. Similarly, a spiritual master may train disciples to worship the Deity — this is certainly devotional service. However, the worship they subsequently perform is their own devotional service, not his. If he does not understand this, his impetus for devotional service may slacken. Srila Prabhupada says, “If a spiritual master is not properly authorized and only on his own initiative becomes a spiritual master, he may be carried away by an accumulation of wealth and large number of disciples. His is not a very high grade of devotional service. If a person is carried away by such achievements, then his devotional service may become slackened (pg 116).”

Yama Yama (restraint from passions) includes activities like ahimsa (non-violence), brahmacarya (celibacy), satyam (truthfulness), etc. These restraints are not items of sadhana-bhakti because they do not impel devotion to manifest in the heart. On the contrary, practice of devotional service impels them to manifest. Srila Prabhupada writes, “A vegetarian is not necessarily a devotee, nor is a non-violent person. But a devotee is automatically both vegetarian and non-violent. We must conclude therefore, that vegetarianism or non-violence is not the cause of devotion (pg 116).” To affirm this, Srila Rupa Gosvami cites the story of the hunter who became a great devotee.

25

B RS 1.2.255

83

Ekanga & Anekanga Before concluding his description of vaidhi-sadhana-bhakti, Srila Rupa Gosvami explains that Devotional service can be practiced by concentrating primarily on one of the items (ekanga) or by concentrating equally on all the items (anekanga).

Alternate Terminology Some authorities use the phrase maryada-marga as an alternate term for vaidhi-sadhana-bhakti. “Srila Rupa Gosvami says that the regulative principles of devotional service are sometimes described by authorities as the path of serving the Lord in opulence (pg 118).”

84

Chapter Fifteen

Spontaneous Devotional Service BRS 1.2.270 - 287

The Second Wave of the Eastern Ocean deals with sadhana-bhakti, which has two divisions: vaidhi and raganuga. Chapters Two through Fourteen have described vaidhi-sadhana. Chapters Fifteen and Sixteen describe raganuga-sadhana.

RAGATMIKA-BHAKTI Raganuga-sadhana is a devotional practice that strives to cultivate the moods of Krsna's associates in Vrndavana. Thus, before describing raganuga-sadhana we must first describe the moods of devotional attachment found in Vrndavana's eternal residents. Nectar of Devotion uses the term raganuga to denote the devotional attachment of Vrndavana's residents (see page 119). In Caitanya-caritamrta, however, Srila Prabhupada directly translated the corresponding text from Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, and therein reveals the correct term to be ragatmika. 1 A ragatmika-bhakta embodies the perfection of spontaneous love for Krsna, and a raganuga-bhakta "follows in the wake" of the perfect devotees, earnestly endeavoring to achieve their perfect mood of spontaneous love. The following texts authenticate that this is the proper use of terminology.

Caitanya-Caritamrta, Madhya-Lila 22.154 virajantim abhivyaktam vraja-vasi-janadisu ragatmikam anusrta ya sa raganugocyate virajantim — shining intensely; abhivyaktam — fully expressed; vraja-vasi-jana-adisu — among the eternal inhabitants of Vrndavana; ragatmikam — devotional service consisting of spontaneous love; anusrta — following; ya — that; sa — which; raganuga — devotional service following in the wake of spontaneous love; ucyate — is said. Devotional service in spontaneous love is vividly expressed and manifested by the inhabitants of Vrndavana. Devotional service that accords with their devotional service is called raganuga-bhakti, or devotional service following in the wake of spontaneous loving service. 2

Caitanya-Caritamrta, Madhya-Lila 22.150 iste svarasiki ragah paramavistata bhavet tanmayi ya bhaved bhaktih 1 2

The phonetic similarity between "rägänugä" and "rägätmikä" makes it clear that the appa rent error originates with the transcriber of Çréla Prabhupäda's dictations. BRS 1.2.270

85

satra ragatmikodita iste — in the desired object of life; svarasiki — appropriate for one's own original aptitude of love; ragah — attachment; parama-avistata — absorption in the service of the Lord; bhavet — is; tat-mayi — consisting of that transcendental attachment; ya — which; bhavet — is; bhaktih — devotional service; sa — that; atra — here; ragatmika-udita — called ragatmika, or spontaneous devotional service. When one becomes attached to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, his natural inclination to love is fully absorbed in thoughts of the Lord. That is called transcendental attachment, and devotional service according to that attachment is called ragatmika, or spontaneous devotional service. 3

Caitanya-Caritamrta, Madhya-Lila 22.152 ragamayi-bhaktira haya 'ragatmika' nama taha suni' lubdha haya kona bhagyavan raga-mayi — consisting of attachment; bhaktira — of devotional service; haya — is; ragatmika — spontaneous love; nama — the name; taha suni' — hearing this; lubdha — covetous; haya — becomes; kona bhagyavan — some fortunate person. Thus devotional service which consists of raga [deep attachment] is called ragatmika, spontaneous loving service. If a devotee covets such a position, he is considered to be most fortunate. In the next text (Cc. Madhya 22.153), Krsnadasa Kaviraja says, lobhe vraja-vasira bhave kare anugati, sastra-yukti nahi mane — raganugara prakrti: to covet the devotional mood of the ragatmika devotees is the nature of raganuga.

Conclusion These texts clearly establish that ragatmika-bhakti is the perfect devotional attachment found in the residents of Vrndavana, and raganuga-sadhana-bhakti is the practice of a devotee who aspires to develop their devotional mood.

Meaning of Ragatmika Literally, ragatmika means one whose very essence (atma) is intense attachment for Krsna (raga). Raga also means "color." Wearing red-colored eyeglasses causes one to see red everywhere. Similarly, when one has an extremely intense attachment he sees the object of his obsession everywhere, all the time. The passions of this world are only weak and perverted reflections. Real raga is the passionate obsession with pleasing Lord Sri Krsna. The passion to serve Krsna consumes the devotee's consciousness to such an extent that they cannot even think of anything else, under any circumstance.

3

B RS 1.2.272

86

Srila Rupa Gosvami therefore defines Ragatmika-bhakti as “spontaneous attraction for something while completely absorbed in thoughts of it, with an intense desire of love (pg 119).” One can find this intense absorption only in Vrndavana (and, to some extent, in Dvaraka). The reason for this was explained in the Second Chapter of this book 4

Two Types of Ragatmika-Bhakti Srila Rupa Gosvami divides ragatmika-bhakti into two categories: (1) kamarupa — sensual attraction, and (2) sambandharupa — relationship. Kamarupa consists of devotees with intense desire to satisfy the Lord in conjugal love. Sambandharupa consists of devotees with intense desire to satisfy the Lord as His parent, friend, or intimate servant. Although conjugal love (kama) is also a type of relationship (sambandha), Srila Rupa Gosvami gives it a separate category to emphasize its preeminent position.

Srimad-Bhagavatam 7.1.31 Srila Rupa Gosvami next quotes a verse from Srimad-Bhagavatam: gopyah kamad bhayat kamso dvesac caidyadayo nrpah sambandhad vrsnayah snehad yuyam bhaktya vayam vibho gopyah — the gopis; kamat — by lusty desires; bhayat — out of fear; kamsah — King Kamsa; dvesac — out of envy; caidya-adayo — Sisupala and others; nrpah — kings; sambandhat — out of kinship; vrsnayah — the Vrsnis or the Yadavas; snehat — out of affection; yuyam — you (the Panòavas); bhaktya — by devotional service; vayam — we; vibho — O great King. My dear King Yudhisthira, the gopis by their lusty desires, Kamsa by his fear, Sisupala and other kings by envy, the Yadus by their familial relationship with Krsna, you Panòavas by your great affection for Krsna, and we, the general devotees, by our devotional service, have obtained the mercy of Krsna. 5 The main point is that spontaneous devotion is the best method of absorbing the mind in Krsna. The essence of sadhana is absorption of the mind in Krsna. Spontaneous emotion does this more effectively than regulated practice. Kamsa and Sisupala feared and envied Krsna, but these emotions caused them to obsessively think about Him and thus become purified to such an extent that they achieved the same destination as the gopis.

4 5

(See footnote on page ). Çréla Prabhupäda summarizes this text in The Nectar of Devotion, on the bottom of page 119.

87

Inimical Emotions Recommended? It is not that inimical emotions towards Krsna are being recommended. 6 For example, King Vena also hated God, but, unlike Kamsa and Sisupala, his mind was not always absorbed in thought of the Lord. Therefore his hatred of God only sent him to hell. 7 Thus we clearly see that it is not envy or fear of God which Narada recommends, but total absorption of the mind in Him, even if out of envy or fear.

Categories of Ragatmika-Bhakti This text confirms Srila Rupa Gosvami's division of ragatmika-bhakti into two categories: kamarupa and sambandharupa. Narada mentions six different moods of spontaneous emotional attachment to the Lord, but only two of these are genuine types of spontaneous devotion (ragatmika-bhakti). The six moods mentioned by Narada are: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.

Lusty desire in the gopis (gopyah kamat) Fear in Kamsa (bhayat kamsah) Envy in Sisupala and other kings of Caidya (dvesac caidyadayo) Kinship in the Vrsnis or the Yadavas (sambandhat vrsnayah) Affection in the Panòavas (snehat yuyam) Devotional service in Narada (bhaktya vayam) Fear & Envy

Clearly, fear and envy are not genuine forms of spontaneous devotion. Srila Prabhupada says, “The attraction of Kamsa to Krsna in fear, and the attraction of Sisupala in envy are not accepted as devotional service, however, because their attitudes are not favorable (pg 120).” Devotional Service in Narada Narada's attachment to Krsna is called bhaktya. Jiva Gosvami explains that the Sanskrit verb tenses used here indicate that Narada's devotional service arises from a sense of duty. Thus it is vaidhi-bhakti, and cannot be counted amongst the genuine forms of ragatmika-bhakti. 8 Affection The affection of the Panòavas may or may not be ragatmika-bhakti, depending on whether or not it is mixed with awe and reverence. Generally it is mixed with a mood of reverence, which introduces restraints of formal etiquette that hinder ragatmika-bhakti. However, when this reverence sometimes subsides, their affection can be ragatmika-bhakti. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Again he analyzes the affection of the Yadus. If it is on the platform of friendship then

6

The word anukulyena in the definition of uttama-bhakti rejects any inim ical emotions from pure devotional service (For further information, see page of this book). 7 "Somehow or other, one m ust consi der t he form of Kå ñna very seri ously. Then, by one of t he fi ve di fferent processes mentioned above, one can return home, back to Godhead. Atheists like King Vena, however, being unable to think of Kåñna' s form in any of t hese five ways, cannot attain salvation. Therefore, one m ust somehow think of Kåñna, whether in a friendly way or inimically." (Çrémad-Bhägavatam 7.1.32) 8 See Jéva Gosvämé - BRS 1.2.274 & 275.

88

it is spontaneous love, but if it is on the platform of regulative principles, then it is not (pg 120).” Lusty Desire & Kinship Four of the six types of attachment — fear, envy, respectful affection, and obedient devotion — have been excluded from ragatmika-bhakti. Only the remaining two — lusty desire (kamarupa) and familial relationship (sambandharupa) — are genuine types of ragatmika-bhakti. This confirms Srila Rupa Gosvami's analysis.

“They Achieved the Same Goal” This Srimad-Bhagavatam text indicates that Kamsa, Sisupala, the Yadus, the gopis... all of them achieved the same goal of life. How could the Lord award his devotees with the same goal as He awards His enemies? To clear this doubt, Srila Rupa Gosvami cites the analogy of the sunshine (Brahman) and the sun-globe (Bhagavan). The demons and devotees both achieved the same goal: Krsna. However, the demons achieved only the Brahman aspect of Krsna, whereas the gopis achieved the highest Bhagavan realization of Krsna. Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes two references to prove that the demons achieved only impersonal liberation in Brahman (Brahmanòa Purana and Tenth Canto). (See pages 121 - 122.)

Summary Spontaneous attraction (raga) is the supreme means of concentrating the mind upon Krsna. There are six basic types of spontaneous attraction, and all of them are liberating. However, only two of the six are genuine types of ragatmika-bhakti that will award the highest goal of prema. These two are kamarupa and sambandharupa.

Kamarupa (Sensual Attraction) Kama (lust) is the intense thirst to satisfy the senses. There are two types of kama: material and spiritual. Material kama is the intense thirst to satisfy one's own senses. Spiritual kama is the intense thirst to satisfy Krsna's spiritual senses. Srila Prabhupada says, “This lust is the devotee's excessive desire to serve the Lord in a particular capacity (pg 122).”

Distinguishing Mundane Kama from Transcendental Kama The exchange of love between Krsna and the gopis resembles embracing, dancing, and so forth. This causes some difficulty in the minds of conditioned souls. The Difficulty The conditioned soul naturally tends to interpret things in the context of his own experience. In his experience, conjugal affairs such as dancing and embracing are manifestations of lust. Thus, when he hears the pastimes of Krsna and the gopis, he misinterprets everything in the context of mundane lust. However, a devotee with some genuine realization in bhakti sees the pastimes as they really are: pure exchanges of unalloyed love. He knows that the gopis' internal motivation is 89

radically different from the motivation of mundane "lovers," even though their external activities may appear similar. Material and spiritual lust are as different as iron and gold. Selfish desire is the motivation of material lust; selfless desire is the motivation of spiritual lust. In the mundane world, every action is selfish; in the spiritual world, every action is selfless — exclusively for the Supreme Lord's pleasure. Apparent Selfishness Sometimes it seems that the residents of Vrndavana act for their own happiness, but factually they act only for the Lord's pleasure. They know that Krsna takes pleasure when His devotee is pleased, and that is the only reason they sometimes seem to endeavor for their own happiness.

Kama — "Lust" Spiritual relationships are never "lusty," or selfish. When Srila Rupa Gosvami says that Krsna's relationship with the gopis is "lusty" (kamarupa) he uses the word in a figurative sense only, to aid our basic understanding. Srila Prabhupada explains, “...the gopis' ecstatic love for Krsna is sometimes described by scholars as being like the "lusty desire" of the material world, but actually this should not be taken as a literal fact. It is simply a way of trying to understand the transcendental situation (pg 123).” The gopis are consumed and obsessed by a passion to satisfy Krsna, the force of which is beyond our ability to comprehend. By comparing it to mundane lust, the single most consuming and overwhelming urge in our experience, we may catch the slightest hint of the intensity in the gopis desire to serve Krsna. We must very carefully understand that Krsna's conjugal love affairs are impeccably transcendental. Externally they may resemble mundane lust, but internally they are motivated exclusively by pure, selfless prema. Evidence for the Purity of Spiritual "Lust" As evidence of the gopis' transcendental purity, Srila Rupa Gosvami cites the great devotee Uddhava. Although completely free from all attraction to mundane love affairs, Uddhava glorified the gopis' love for Krsna. Srila Prabhupada adds the example of Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu — the strict sannyasi who also praised the gopis' love of Krsna. If the gopis were affected by mundane sex desire, these two stalwart personalities would never praise them. (See page 123.)

Transcendental Kama Mixed with Mundane Kama To further highlight the exalted purity of the gopis' love for Krsna, Srila Rupa Gosvami mentions Kubja, who's attraction to Krsna was not as pure as the gopis'. The selfish desire that slightly tinged her attraction excluded her from the category of kamarupa, and relegated her to the lesser status of kamapraya — "almost lusty desire."

90

Chapter Sixteen

Spontaneous Devotion Further Described BRS 1.1.288 - 309

This chapter continues Srila Rupa Gosvami's analysis of spontaneous devotional service. As mentioned, the spontaneous love found in the residents of Vrndavana has two divisions: (1) kamarupa — sensual attraction, and (2) sambandharupa — relationship. Chapter Fifteen ended the analysis of kamarupa. Chapter Sixteen begins with a brief analysis of sambandharupa.

Sambandharupa — Relationship Just as kamarupa (sensual attraction) is the intense attachment to service in the mood of a lover, sambandharupa (relationship) is the intense attachment to service in the mood of a parent, friend, or servant.

"No Necessity of Discussing Further" Both kamarupa and sambandharupa describe the eternal residents of Vrndavana — who possess the perfection of spontaneous devotion. The primary subject of Chapters Fifteen and Sixteen, however, is the practice of spontaneous devotion (raganugasadhana), not the perfection of spontaneous devotion (ragatmika-prema). Therefore Srila Rupa Gosvami presents the subject of ragatmika-bhakti only briefly. Srila Prabhupada says, “In the stage of devotional service where regulative principles are followed, there is no necessity of discussing this love, for it must develop of itself at a more advanced stage (pg 125).”

RAGANUGA-BHAKTI Spontaneous devotional service (raganuga-bhakti) is the practice of advanced devotees, intended to cultivate the sentiments of a particular eternal devotee (ragatmika-bhakta). Before revealing the methods of this practice, Srila Rupa Gosvami first describes the prerequisite qualifications of the practitioner.

Basic Qualification to Practice Spontaneous Devotional Service The basic qualification for raganuga-bhakti is simply a natural, spontaneous desire to serve Krsna in a specific relationship — a desire that can be evoked by hearing about the eternal residents of Vrndavana. Nectar of Devotion describes this in a simple way, “There is a gradual development of the ambition to become like a particular devotee, and this activity is called raganuga (pg 125).”

91

Srila Prabhupada's Caitanya-caritamrta more elaborately describes this verse of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu: tad-tad-bhavadi madhurye srute dhir yad apeksate natra sastram na yuktim ca tal lobhotpatti-laksanam When an advanced realized devotee hears about the affairs of the devotees of Vrndavana — in the mellows of santa, dasya, sakhya, vatsalya and madhurya — he becomes inclined in this way, and his intelligence becomes attracted. Indeed, he begins to covet that particular type of devotion. When such covetousness is awakened, one's intelligence no longer depends on the instruction of sastra (revealed scripture), logic, or argument. (Cc. Mad 22.155) The devotional service of a raganuga devotee is guided only by his intense craving to attain the service of a particular resident of Vrndavana, not by scriptural injunction. Srila Prabhupada describes, “These raganuga devotees do not follow the regulative principles of devotional service very strictly, but by spontaneous nature they become attracted to some of the eternal devotees such as Nanda or Yasoda, and they try to follow in their footsteps spontaneously (pg 125).” One point must be repeatedly stressed: That a raganuga devotee is "above the regulative principles" means that they are not dependant on scriptural injunction for their inspiration to serve and surrender. Their inspiration comes from their own spontaneous affection. This does not mean that a raganuga-bhakta does not follow the regulative principles, it means that their motivation is love (raga), not just obligation (vidhi). 9

Achieving This Qualification The basic qualification for raganuga-bhakti is simply eagerness (lobha) to achieve the service of a particular ragatmika devotee, but this eagerness is not cheap or easy to come by. Lobha (intense covetousness) refers to the state where one's sole and overwhelming desire is to please Krsna in a particular way. As long as there is some other desire in one's heart, the required intensity of focus cannot manifest. Therefore generally lobha cannot awaken until the devotee achieves steadiness at the completion of anartha-nivrtti. After having thoroughly heard SrimadBhagavatam and being freed from all unwanted desires, generally it is only then that one possesses the qualification to practice genuine raganuga-bhakti. 9

Also, in "above t he regulative principles" the term regulative principles refers to either the injunctions of Vedic dharma or to the 64 aìgas of sädhana-bhakti, not the "four regul ative principles:" no m eateating, no intoxication, no illicit sex, and no gambling. 92

Srila Prabhupada thus states, “We must always remember, however, that such eagerness to follow in the footsteps of the denizens of Vraja (Vrndavana) is not possible unless one is freed from material contamination.” He defines freedom from material contamination, “There is a stage called anartha-nivrtti, which means the disappearance of all material contamination (pg 126).”

Raganuga is Within the Realm of Sadhana Upon completing anartha-nivrtti, one becomes qualified for raganuga-bhakti. Anarthanivrtti occurs within the stage of sadhana, before bhava or prema. We must therefore conclude that raganuga-sadhana, although a very advanced platform of spiritual development, is still within the realm of sadhana. It is not bhava or prema. Freedom from anarthas comes at the stage of nistha. However, it is true that slight traces of anartha remain until one attains the stage of prema. Thus, in an extended sense, it may be said that anartha-nivrtti is not actually complete until the stage of prema. 10 Srila Rupa Gosvami and Srila Prabhupada, however, do not use the term in this extended sense. The following will make this point clear: Raganuga-bhakti is discussed in the Second Wave of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. The Second Wave deals exclusively with sadhana-bhakti, the Third Wave with bhavabhakti, and the Fourth Wave with prema-bhakti. Thus, by its location in the text we can clearly understand that raganuga-bhakti is an element of sadhana, not of bhava or prema. The same fact is also clear from Nectar of Instruction (text eight, purport). There, Srila Prabhupada translates Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu 1.2.295: “In the transcendental realm of Vraja (Vraja-Dhama) one should serve the Supreme Lord, Sri Krsna, with a feeling similar to that of His associates, and one should place himself under the direct guidance of a particular associate of Krsna and should follow in his footsteps. This method is applicable both in the method of sadhana (spiritual practices executed while in the stage of bondage) and in the stage of sadhya (God realization), when one is a siddha-purusa, or spiritually perfect soul.” [Emphasis added]

Summary The basic qualification for spontaneous devotional service is lobha (the strong desire to serve Krsna in a specific relationship) which generally manifests only when one is "freed from material contamination."

10

Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura' s Mädhurya-kadambiné (third shower) explains all th ese details of anartha-nivåtti. 93

Practices of Spontaneous Devotional Service Three texts in Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu describe the actual practices of raganuga-bhakti. Srila Prabhupada summarizes these in Nectar of Devotion, from the third paragraph of page 126 to the subheading "conjugal love."

Verse One (BRS 1.2.294) krsnam smaran janam casya prestham nija-samihitam tat-tat-katha-ratas casau kuryad vasam vraje sada krsnam — Lord Krsna; smaran — thinking of; janam — a devotee; ca — also; asya — of His; prestham — very dear; nija-samihitam — chosen by oneself; tat-tat-katha — to those respective topics; ratah — attached; ca — and; asau — that; kuryat — should do; vasam — living; vraje — in Vrndavana; sada — always. The devotee should always think of Krsna within himself, and one should choose a very dear devotee who is a servitor of Krsna in Vrndavana. One should constantly engage in topics about that servitor and his loving relationship to Krsna, and one should live in Vrndavana. However, if one is physically unable to go to Vrndavana, he should mentally live there. (Cc Mad 22.160) The first practice of raganuga-bhakti is to meditate on the relationship of service between Krsna and His dear devotee. The specific relationship and devotee one meditates upon depends on one's devotional aspiration. For example, one who desires to serve with conjugal affection may meditate on the mood and service of a specific gopi for Kisora Krsna. One who desires to serve with parental affection may meditate on the mood and service of Mother Yasoda for Kumara Krsna. A person who aspires to constantly remember Krsna and His eternal devotees is advised to take shelter of Vrndavana. One should physically live in Vrndavana, and mentally live there by constantly remembering the exchanges between Krsna and His devotees there. Mental residence in Vrndavana is more essential than physical residence, although they are both important. Srila Prabhupada says, “if one is physically unable to go to Vrndavana, he should mentally live there (pg 126).” Srila Prabhupada summarizes these instructions of Srila Rupa Gosvami, “When one is actually liberated from material contamination, he can always remember an eternal devotee in Vrndavana in order to love Krsna in the same capacity. And developing such an aptitude, one will always live in Vrndavana, even within his mind (pg 126).”

94

Verse Two (BRS 1.2.295) seva sadhaka-rupena siddha-rupena catra hi tad-bhava-lipsuna karya vraja-lokanusaratah seva — service; sadhaka-rupena — with the external body as a devotee practicing regulative devotional service; siddha-rupena — with a body suitable for eternal, selfrealized service; ca — also; atra — in this connection; hi — certainly; tad — of that; bhava — mood; lipsuna — desiring to obtain; karya — to be executed; vraja-loka — of the particular servant of Krsna in Vrndavana; anusaratah — by following in the footsteps. The advanced devotee who is inclined to spontaneous loving service should follow the activities of a particular associate of Krsna in Vrndavana. He should execute service externally as a regulative devotee as well as internally from his self-realized position. Thus he should perform devotional service both externally and internally. (Cc. Mad 22.158) The first verse instructed the raganuga-bhakta to always think about an eternal devotee of Vrndavana. The present verse elaborates on this, instructing how to think of this Vrndavana devotee and absorb oneself in his or her loving service-mood. We should first note that the residents of Goloka Vrndavana simultaneously exist in two manifestations, as sadhakas and as siddhas. For example, Srila Rupa simultaneously exists in Gaura-lila as Srila Rupa Gosvami (a sadhaka), and in Krsnalila as Srila Rupa Manjari (a siddha). Since the residents of Vraja have two manifestations, there are two ways to meditate upon them. The first is externally and the second is internally. Externally The word sadhaka-rupena instructs one to be absorbed in thought of an eternal resident of Vrndavana by externally following the activities of their sadhaka form. For example, one who desires to achieve the service and mood of Srila Rupa would follow in the footsteps of Srila Rupa Gosvami's sadhana — nicely described by Srinivasa Acarya in Saò Goswamy-astaka. 11 11

saìkhyä-pürvaka-näma-gäna-natibhiù kälävasäné-kåtau nidrähära-vihärakädi-vijitau cätyanta-dénau ca yau rädhä-kåñna-guna-småter madhurimänandena sammohitau vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau "I offer my respect ful obei sances unt o t he Si x Gosvämés. . . who were engaged i n chant ing t he hol y names of the Lord and bowing d own in a sch eduled m easurement. In th is way th ey u tilized th eir 95

Srila Prabhupada says, “A devotee who is actually advanced in Krsna consciousness, who is constantly engaged in devotional service, should not manifest himself, even though he has attained perfection. The idea is that he should always continue to act as a neophyte devotee as long as his material body is there. Activities in devotional service under regulative principles must be followed even by the pure devotee (pg 126).” 12 Internally The word siddha-rupena instructs one to be absorbed in thought of an eternal resident of Vrndavana by internally (mentally) following the behavior of their siddha form. For example, one who desires to achieve the service and mood of Srila Rupa would internally meditate on the activities of Srila Rupa Manjari — nicely described by Raghunatha dasa Gosvami in Vraja-vilasa-stava. 13 Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “But when he realizes his actual position in relationship with the Lord, he can, along with the discharging of regulative service, think within himself of the Lord, under the guidance of a particular associate of the Lord, and develop his transcendental sentiments in following that associate (pgs 126 127).” Siddha-Pranali — A Fallacious Interpretation Srila Prabhupada warns us to be careful of the so-called siddha-pranali process. This process is based on an interpretation of the current sloka of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu that is deviant in two ways. 14 The first deviation is to prematurely imagine one's eternally perfect spiritual form (siddha-rupa). Srila Prabhupada says, “They imagine that they have become associates of the Lord simply by thinking of themselves like that (pg 127).”

12

13

14

valuable lives, and in executing these devotional activities they conquered over eating and sleeping and were always meek and humble, enchanted by remembering the transcendental qualities of the Lord." Random House W ebster's di ctionary defi nes neophyte as "a begi nner or a novi ce." In cont ext of t he three phases of bhakti — sädhana, bhäva, and prema — "neophyte" refers to sädhana. The idea here is this: regardl ess of how advanced one act ually i s, he shoul d al ways ext ernally behave as a person diligently practicing to cultivate devotion. tambülärpana-päda-mardana-payo-dänäbhisärädibhir våndäranya-maheçvarim priyatayä yas toñayanti priyaù präna-preñöhä-sahké-kuläd api kiläsankocitä bhümikäù keli-bhümiñu rüpa-maïjaré-mukhas tä däsikä saàçraye "By offering Her betel nuts, by massaging Her feet, by bringing Her water, by arranging for Her secret meeting wi th Lord Kåñna, and by perform ing m any ot her servi ces, many gopé maidservants affectionately please Çré Rädhä, who i s more dear than life. I take shelter of those gopé maidservants, who have Çréla Rüpa Maïjaré as their leader." Siddha-pranälé ori ginates wi th R üpa Kaviräja, a deviant disciple o f Hem aliné Öhäkurané, Çrénivasa Äcärya's daughter. 96

According to acaryas, realization of one's siddha-rupa develops gradually by the purified desire of the heart. The second deviation is their proposal that the word vraja-loka (residents of Vrndavana) refers exclusively to the residents of Vrndavana in Krsna-lila such as Srila Rupa Manjari, and not to the residents of Vrndavana in their Gaura-lila such as Srila Rupa Gosvami. Thus they wrongly interpret seva sadhaka-rupena, siddha-rupena catra hi to mean that one should imitate the activities of the gopis, both as one's external sadhana and as one's internal meditation. One can see such men dressed in saris, jewellery, etc.; not worshipping guru or Tulasi; and making a show of imitating the behavior of the gopis, even though they are not yet purified of basic material desires. Srila Prabhupada succinctly states, “Their external behavior is not at all according to the regulative principles (pg 127).”

Verse Three (BRS 1.2.296) sravanot-kirtanadini vaidha-bhakty uditani tu yanyaìgani ca tanyatra vijneyani manisibhih Learned acaryas know that the 64 practices of vaidhi-bhakti — headed by hearing and chanting — are also useful in raganuga-bhakti. Raganuga-sadhana does not entail a rejection of vaidhi, but a more focused concentration upon particular aspects that are conducive to the individual devotee's particular mood of service. For example, the raganuga devotee does not abandon regular hearing and chanting, but focuses his hearing and chanting upon particular topics that specifically nourish his particular serving mood. Deity worship is another example. The raganuga devotee does not reject this aspect of vaidhi-sadhana. He may continue to worship the Deity, but in a way conducive to his devotional mood. Later in the chapter Srila Rupa Gosvami will illustrate this with the story of an old man who developed the aspiration to love Krsna in a paternal mood. Narada Muni advised him to worship the Deity as his own beloved son, following the footsteps of Nanda Maharaja. Srila Prabhupada extracts the essence of this third instruction from Bhaktirasamrta-sindhu, “Learned acaryas recommend that we follow the regulative principles even after the development of spontaneous love for Krsna... one should specifically engage himself in the type of devotional service for which he has a natural aptitude... In this way, everyone should act according to his particular taste (pg 127).”

97

Two Types of Raganuga-Bhakti There are two categories of raganuga-bhakti: (1) kamanuga, and (2) sambandhanuga. Kamanuga is a devotional practice that strives for the mood of the kamarupa Kamanuga Kamarupa ragatmikas (the gopis of Vrndavana or Sambandhanuga Sambandharupa the queens of Dvaraka). Sambandhanuga is a devotional practice that strives for the mood of the sambandharupa ragatmikas (The devotee of Vrndavana in parental, friendly, or servile love). Raganuga-bhakti Ragatmika-bhakti

Kamanuga — Conjugal Love The Nectar of Devotion begins to describe Kamanuga-sadhana-bhakti on page 127, at the subheading "Conjugal Love." There are two divisions of kamanuga: (1) sambhoga icchamayi — striving to serve Krsna as do those who directly meet Him in conjugal love, and (2) tat-tadbhava-icchatmika — striving not to directly meet with Krsna, but to assist the Supreme Heroine, Srimati Rägänugä-Bhakti Radharani and thus directly experience Her loving mood, Kämänugä Sambandhänugä Conjugal love Friendship and parenthood through service and appreciation. Sambhoga-icchämayé Tat-tat-bhäva-icchätmikä Mood of the Mood of the Heroine Eligibility for Heroine's maid Kamanuga One gradually becomes eligible for kamanuga-sadhana-bhakti by developing a natural attraction to serving Krsna in conjugal love. One achieves this mainly by worshipping Deities of Radha-Krsna and hearing Krsna's pastimes with the gopis. Srila Prabhupada explains, “This development of conjugal love can be possible only with those who are already engaged in following the regulative principles of devotional service, specifically in worship of Radha and Krsna in the temple. Such devotees gradually develop a spontaneous love for the Deity, and by hearing of the Lord's exchange of loving affairs with the gopis, they gradually become attracted to these pastimes (pg 128).” Eligibility in Males Since conjugal love of Krsna entails feminine sentiments on behalf of the devotee, one may have the impression only females can properly aspire for it. To dispel this misconception — and establish that our transcendental relationship with Krsna has 98

nothing to do with the material body — Srila Rupa Gosvami cites the sages of Danòakaranya. Although they were all men, when they saw Lord Ramacandra their conjugal love for Krsna blossomed. They took their next birth as daughters of gopis and got the direct association of Lord Krsna. (See page 128) Two Further Classifications There are two moods in conjugal love: (1) parakiya — unwedded, and (2) svakiya — wedded. Parakiya is practiced by those who follow in the footsteps of the gopis of Vrndavana. One who perfects this sentiment will be elevated to Goloka Vrndavana, “to associate with the gopis and enjoy loving affairs with Krsna there (pg 129).” Svakiya is practiced by those who follow in the footsteps of Krsna's wedded wives in Dvaraka. One who perfects this sentiment will be elevated to Dvaraka, “where the devotee becomes a queen of the Lord (pg 129).” The reference from Maha Kurma Purana is an example of this. 15

Sambandhanuga (Parenthood or Friendship) This chapter ends with a summary of Srila Rupa Gosvami's instructions on developing spontaneous attachment to Krsna in parental or friendly moods. Like conjugal love, parenthood and friendship have two categories. The first aspires for direct parenthood or friendship with Krsna; the second aspires for service and appreciation of Krsna's parents and friends. Srila Prabhupada explains, “In the development of becoming either the father or friend of Lord, there are two varieties. One method is that one may try to become the father of the Lord directly, and the other is that one may follow Nanda Maharaja and cherish the ideal of being Krsna's father (pg 129).” Srila Rupa Gosvami warns of the danger in aspiring for direct relationship, especially concerning parenthood. In desiring to directly become the father of Krsna, one may inadvertently develop the desire to become Nanda Maharaja himself. This is no less mayavada than desiring to be Krsna. If one becomes contaminated by such mayavada implications, whatever advancement he has made is obliterated. 16 Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of sambandhanuga-sadhana-bhakti, “In the Skanda Purana there is a story of an old man residing in Hastinapura, capital of the

15

16

BRS 1.2.303 — Jéva Gosväm é and Vi çvanätha C akravarté Öhäkura expl ain t hat i f one desires the mood of conjugal servi ce t o Kåñna, y et t he desi re i s not st rong enough t o overpower hi s fear of neglecting proper et iquette i n servi ce t o t he Lord (i e. he does not ri se above t he pl atform of vaidhibhakti) then his conjugal attraction will grant him the attainment of svakéya, or servitorship amongst the Queens of Dvärakä. For further clarification of this point, refer to the following: The Nectar of Devotion, pages 129 - 130 & page 206; Waves of Devotion, page . 99

kingdom of the Panòus, who desired Krsna as his beloved son. This old man was instructed by Narada to follow in the footsteps of Nanda Maharaja, and thus he achieved success (pg 130).”

Alternate Terminology Srila Rupa Gosvami closes the discussion of raganuga-sadhana-bhakti by mentioning that some people (the Vallabha-sampradaya) use the term pusti-marga to indicate raganuga-sadhana. Srila Prabhupada says, "This process of devotional service is sometimes called pusti-marga (pg 130).”

100

Eastern Ocean Third Wave Bhava-Bhakti

Chapters 17 & 18

101

Chapter Seventeen Ecstatic Love BRS 1.3.1 - 24

Chapter Seventeen begins Srila Prabhupada's summary study of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu's Third Wave, dealing with bhava-bhakti. As mentioned in Chapter Two, the purpose of sadhana-bhakti is to awaken bhava. Thus Srila Prabhupada explains, “...in the previous chapters the symptoms of devotional service were explained along with instructions as to how we may execute devotional service with our present senses and gradually rise to the platform of ecstasy in spontaneous love (pg 131).” Clearly, bhava is the goal (sadhya) of our devotional practice (sadhana). Srila Prabhupada says, “Within the stage of the regulative principles of devotional service there are two divisions, namely executive and effective. The effective portion of devotional service is called bhava, or ecstasy (pg 131).” Sadhana is "executive" because it involves execution of devotional practice. Bhava is "effective" because it is the effect of practice. Srila Prabhupada says that both sadhana and bhava are "within the stage of the regulative principles of devotional service." The phrase regulative principles of devotional service is a translation of cestarupa, not vaidhi-sadhana. The next paragraph will explain this.

Uttama-Bhakti ceñöärüpä

bhävarüpä

by endeavors

by emotions

sädhana

sädhya

endeavors which endeavors which are cause bhäva the effect of bhäva

There are two divisions of pure devotional service: (1) cestarupa — devotional service executed with one's endeavors, and (2) bhavarupa — devotional service executed with one's emotions. "Within the stage of the regulative principles of devotional service there are two

102

divisions, namely executive and effective." This indicates that there are two subdivisions of cestarupa: (1) "executive" — endeavors that cause bhava, and (2) "effective" — endeavors that result from bhava. 1

Definition and Characteristics of Bhava-Bhakti Srila Rupa Gosvami defines bhava-bhakti as follows (see NOD 131, paragraph 1): suddha-sattva-visesatma prema-suryamsu-samya-bhak rucibhis citta-masrnyakrd asau bhava ucyate suddha-sattva — by unadulterated goodness; visesa — distinguished; atma — whose nature; prema — of love of Godhead; surya — like the sun; amsu — a ray; samyabhak — which is similar to; rucibhih — by different tastes; citta — of the heart; masrnya — softness; krt — which causes; asau — that softness; bhavah — emotion; ucyate — is called. When devotional service is situated on the transcendental platform of pure goodness, it is like a ray of the sunlight of love for Krsna. At such a time, devotional service causes the heart to be softened by various tastes, and it is called bhava [emotion]. (Cc. Mad 23.5)

Primary Characteristic The primary characteristic of bhava is suddha-sattva-visesatma; it is the stage wherein suddha-sattva enters the devotee's heart. Suddha-sattva is not the material mode of goodness, but the Lord's internal potency — whose function is to revive the living entity's dormant love for Krsna. A dormant seed cannot grow without being touched by the sun's energy of heat and light. Similarly, love of Godhead (prema) is like a seed lying dormant in the heart of every living entity. It cannot grow without the touch of the Lord's own devotional energy, suddha-sattva. When a person eagerly wants to serve the Lord, the suddha-sattva potency may enter his heart through the mercy of a pure devotee. When suddha-sattva touches the heart, it energizes the seed of prema and causes it to sprout (ankura). Consequently, Srila Rupa Gosvami describes bhava as premankura ("the first sprout of prema").

1

Endeavors that cause bhäva (ceñöärüpä, sädhana) are heari ng, chanting, worshipping, etc. Endeavors that result from bhäva (ceñöärüpä, sädhya) are anubhäva, and will be extensively described in Chapter Twenty (see page in this book). In brief, anubhäva is an endeavor that results from stimulation of one' s affection for Kåñna. For example, when a friend' s love is stim ulated, the anubhäva may be that he endeavors to play with Kåñna. 103

Bhava is prema, but in a preliminary, budding state. This is also indicated by the term prema-suryamsu — "a ray of the sun of prema." Bhava is the sun-ray. Prema is the sun itself. The sun and the sun-rays are qualitatively non-different, but there is a distinction in quantitative intensity. Bhava is the onset of prema, as dawn is the onset of day. When the first rays of dawn appear, one can be sure that the full light of the sun will soon rise. Similarly, when one achieves bhava the full light of prema will manifest very quickly. How Suddha-Sattva Descends According to Srila Rupa Gosvami, suddha-sattva is composed of the samvit and hladini potencies of the Lord. Samvit is the cognitive or knowledge-giving potency. Hladini is the devotional potency. Samvit-sakti, the Lord's own cognitive potency, descends into the heart and empowers one to perceive and know Krsna. The Lord's devotional potency (hladinisakti) also descends into the devotee's heart, empowering one to fully manifest blissful love of Godhead. When the divine potencies of cognition and affection (samvit and hladini) combine in the heart, one can begin to fully relish Krsna as the supreme object of love. This is bhava-bhakti — the awakening of love of Godhead. 2

Secondary Characteristics The secondary characteristics of bhava are: (1) it softens the heart, and (2) it gives rise to various tastes. Softening of the Heart A soft heart is one easily moved or changed by emotion. The Srimad-Bhagavatam (2.3.24) describes this, “Certainly that heart is steel-framed which, in spite of chanting the holy name with concentration, does not change when ecstasy takes place and tears fill the eyes and hairs stand on end.” Srila Prabhupada explains, “In this connection there is a statement in the Tantras that ecstasy is the first symptom of pure love for the Personality of Godhead, and in that state one is sometimes found shedding tears or shivering (pg 131).” In this quote, Srila Prabhupada first defines the primary characteristic of bhava by saying that ecstasy (bhava) is the first symptom of pure love of Godhead (prema). He then defines its secondary characteristic by saying that one's heart softens to such an extent that he is often found to be visibly moved by emotions. In brief, the characteristic of a devotee on the platform of bhava is that his heart is very easily moved by Krsna conscious stimulation. 2

The combination of saàvit and hlädiné is called çuddha-sattva. W hen o ne is in contact with çuddhasattva, one si multaneously feel s nouri shment (puñti) and sat isfaction (tuñti). The saàvit potency nourishes one by cognition of Kåñna, and the hlädiné potency satisfies one by devotion for Kåñna. 104

Giving Rise to Various Tastes There are three kinds of "tastes" or devotional desires that blossom when one achieves the stage of bhava: (1) prapti-abhilasa — desire to achieve Krsna, (2) anukulyaabhilasa — desire to please Krsna with various services, (3) sauharda-abhilasa — desire to be close at heart with Krsna. 3

Nature of Bhava When bhava appears, it permeates one's consciousness to such an extent that it appears to become one with the mind — just as an iron rod placed in fire eventually becomes permeated by the qualities of fire to such an extent that they appear to become one. This condition is called tad-atmaka. Srila Prabhupada describes this state as samadhi, “After the outward appearance of these ecstatic symptoms, they stay within the mind, and continuation of the ecstasy is called samadhi (pg 131 - 132).” Bhava is relishable by nature, and it also causes one to taste and realize the sweet pastimes of the Lord. Srila Prabhupada thus states, “This stage of appreciation becomes the cause of future exchanges of loving affairs with the Lord (pg 132).”

Achieving Bhava According to Srila Rupa Gosvami, there are two ways to achieve bhava: (1) by ardent spiritual practice, and (2) by the special mercy of Krsna or His devotee. “Elevation to this stage of ecstasy can be possible in two ways. One way is by constant association with pure devotees. The other way is by the special mercy of Krsna or by the mercy of a pure devotee of Krsna (pg 132).” Srila Prabhupada uses the term "association with pure devotees" synonymously with "executing the practices of devotional service." A pure devotee has no business other than hearing and chanting about Krsna. Therefore, associating with a pure devotee automatically implies practicing devotional service. Srila Prabhupada states, “It is essential, therefore, that one constantly associate with pure devotees who are engaged morning and evening in chanting the Hare Krsna mantra. In this way one will get the chance to purify his heart and develop this ecstatic pure love for Krsna (pg 133).”

3

This information comes from Jéva Gosvämé's commentary on BRS 1.3.1. 105

Bhava Achieved By Practice (Sadhana) Bhäva by Practice by Vaidhi

by Mercy

Bhava achieved by practice has two further subdivisions: (1) bhava attained through vaidhisadhana, and (2) bhava attained through raganuga-sadhana.

by Rägänugä

By Vaidhi-Sadhana Narada Muni's life story is an example of someone who achieves bhava by way of vaidhi-sadhana. Narada's service to the Bhaktivedantas may be considered vaidhi because it was motivated not by his specific attraction to Krsna, but by obligation to the injunction of sastra. Serving these great souls, he got the opportunity to regularly hear krsna-katha from their lips, and by this regulated hearing he achieved the level of bhava. Again it is apparent that vaidhi-bhakti is not something to be made light of. We find that vaidhi-bhakti also leads to a type of bhava, and even the most exalted Narada Muni practices it. The example of Narada Muni confirms that bhava is a precursor to prema. Srila Prabhupada explains, “This ecstatic love is prior to pure love of Krsna, because in the next verse Narada confirms that by the gradual process of hearing from the great sages he developed love of Godhead (pg 132).” To further support that one can achieve bhava by repeatedly listening to the discourses of pure devotees, Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes Lord Kapiladeva. Srila Prabhupada sums up the essence of this quote, “...when a realized soul who is engaged in the service of the Lord is speaking, he has the potency to inject spiritual life within the audience. One should, therefore, seek the association of such pure, unalloyed devotees, and by such association and service a neophyte devotee will certainly develop attachment, love and devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead (pg 133).” 4 By Raganuga-Sadhana The quote from Padma Purana is an example of bhava attained through raganugasadhana. In this story, a lady named Candrakanti saw the Deity of Krsna, which

4

(SB 3.25.25) The last line of t his verse ("çraddhä ratir bhaktir anukramiñyati") proves that a vaidhisädhaka m ay achieve çraddha (which devel ops up t o äsakti, "attachment."), then rati (rati is synonymous with bhäva), and finally, bhakti (bhakti is analogous to prema). Çréla Prabhupäda indicates th is, “...and by such associati on and service a neophy te devotee [vaidhi-sädhaka] will certain ly d evelop attach ment [çraddha-äsakti], l ove [ bhäva] and devot ion [prema] for the Supreme Personality of Godhead (pg 133).” See BRS 1.3.12, com: Mukunda Däsa; and BRS 1.3.13. 106

aroused her desire to dance with Krsna throughout the night. Her dancing is an example of raganuga-sadhana-bhakti because she desired to develop the sentiments of the ragatmikas, namely the gopis of Vraja. By this raganuga-sadhana she achieved bhava, evidenced by the fact that she remained dancing all night, without wasting a moment on rest. This reluctance to waste time is a symptom of bhava known as avyartha-kalatvam.

By Mercy Achieving bhava solely by mercy is not common. Srila Prabhupada says that one who expects to achieve bhava by mercy alone is like one who expects to complete college not by studying hard, but by getting an honorary degree.

Bhäva by Practice Words

by Mercy

Glances

Good wishes

There are three ways of receiving Krsna's mercy: (1) vacika — by a verbal blessing, (2) darsana-dana — blessing by appearing in person to the devotee, and (3) harda — by a heartfelt, unspoken blessing. Srila Prabhupada translates these as: “simply by speaking, simply by glancing and simply by good wishes (pg 133).”

Vacika — Verbal Blessing Naradiya Purana illustrates a devotee achieving mercy through a verbal blessing. Krsna blesses Narada to achieve bhava-bhakti (devotional service full of transcendental bliss): “O best of the brahmanas [Narada], I wish that you may develop unalloyed devotional service to Me, which is full of transcendental bliss and all auspiciousness (pg 133).” Darsana-Dana — Blessing by Personal Appearance Skanda Purana illustrates a devotee achieving mercy through the Lord's personal appearance: “When the inhabitants of the Jangala Province saw the Personality of Godhead, Krsna, they were so stricken with feeling that they could not withdraw their glance from Him (pg 134).” The Inhabitants of Jangala were not qualified to see the Lord, but out of His causeless mercy He gave them His darsan. When they glanced upon Him they became stricken with feeling (bhava) and could not look away from the Lord for a moment. Harda — Heartfelt Blessings Krsna or His devotee may bestow heartfelt blessings. Suka-samhita illustrates heartfelt blessings from Krsna. While still within the womb of his mother, Sukadeva Gosvami achieved bhava. Since he had not yet come out of the womb to see or hear the Lord, one can surmise that he attained this perfection by the Lord's heartfelt blessings. 107

Chapter 17 finishes with two examples of achieving bhava by the heartfelt good wishes of a devotee. The first example is Prahlada Maharaja, who received the good wishes of Narada while within the womb of his mother. The second example is Mrgrari the Hunter, who became an exalted devotee simply by the good wishes of Narada Muni. The Southern Division of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu (Chapters 20-34 of Nectar of Devotion) gives a more detailed analysis of the transcendental symptoms of bhava. Srila Prabhupada therefore states, “This ecstatic love for Krsna can be divided into five divisions, which will be described by Srila Rupa Gosvami later on (pg 134).”

108

Chapter Eighteen

Character of One in Ecstatic Love BRS 1.3.25 - 61

Chapter Eighteen continues Srila Rupa Gosvami's description of bhava-bhakti.

Symptoms of Bhava One characteristic of bhava is citta-masrnya — a soft heart, sensitive to Krsna conscious emotions. Various emotional reactions like crying, shivering, faltering of the voice, etc. symptomize such softness of disposition. 5 Any actor or actress can imitate tears, shivering, etc. — it does not mean they have bhava-bhakti. Furthermore, sometimes a devotee who really does have bhava may purposely conceal these emotional symptoms and remain undetected. Therefore, external symptoms are not sufficient evidence to ascertain that a devotee has achieved bhava-bhakti. In Srimad-Bhagavatam (2.3.24), Srila Prabhupada explains, “Srila Visvanatha Cakravarti Thakura has very critically discussed all these bhava displays in connection with some unscrupulous neophyte's imitating the above symptoms for cheap adoration. Not only Visvanatha Cakravarti but also Srila Rupa Gosvami treats them very critically. Sometimes all the above eight symptoms of ecstasy are imitated by mundane devotees... Therefore real, steady bhava is definitely displayed in the mater of cessation of material desires (ksanti), utilization of every moment in the transcendental loving service of the Lord (avyartha-kalatvam), eagerness for glorifying the Lord constantly (nama-gane sada ruci), attraction for living in the land of the Lord (pritis tad-vasanti sthale), complete detachment from material happiness (virakti), and pridelessness (mana-sunyata). One who has developed all these transcendental qualities is really possessed of the bhava stage, as distinguished from the stone hearted imitator or mundane devotee.” 6

Nine Reliable Symptoms Srila Rupa Gosvami gives a list of nine character traits possessed by a genuine bhava-bhakta. A person can neither imitate nor conceal these nine symptoms, and thus they are excellent standards for ascertaining the achievement of bhava. 1. Avyartha-kalatvam — Utilization of time. Constant engagement in devotional service, twenty-four hours a day. 2. Ksanti — Perseverance. To remain tolerant and patient, even amid great disturbance. 3. Virakti — Detachment. Complete indifference to objects of sense gratification. 7 4. Mana-sunyata — Pridelessness. One feels humble, even though he is extremely elevated. 5 6 7

Chapter Twenty-Eight will fully describe these emotional reactions. The reader is encouraged to read Çrémad-Bhägavatam 2.3.24 in its entirety. There are two types of detachm ent: vairägya and virakti. Before one achieves the stage of bhäva, he may be able to manifest vairägya; he can keep him self forcibly separated from the objects of sense grat ification, and t hus control his senses. At the stage of bhäva, however, one m anifests a superi or type of detachment. This superior detachment is virakti, wherein one completely looses all taste fo r th e o bjects of the senses. Thus his senses rem ain entirely controlled, even if he is directly in the midst of sense objects. 109

5. Asa-bandha — Hope against hope. Firm faith that Krsna will deliver one to the highest perfection, even though one feels low and utterly unqualified to achieve it on his own. 8 6. Samutkantha — Intense eagerness for achieving pure loving service. 7. Nama-gane sada ruci — Constant attraction to chanting Hare Krsna. 8. Asaktis tad-gunakhyane — Addiction to glorifying Krsna's qualities. 9. Pritis tad-vasati sthale — Love for living in the Lord's Dhama. After listing the nine characteristics, Srila Rupa Gosvami separately defines and illustrates each one with sastric examples. (See Nectar of Devotion pages 135 - 139).

Ecstatic Symptoms in Neophyte or Non-Devotees Sometimes non-devotees may seem to exhibit signs of ecstasy. This is simply an external display of mundane emotion. Genuine ecstatic symptoms are the private domain of advanced devotees with strong and exclusive attachment for Krsna. They can never appear in people attached to sense gratification or liberation. “It is said by Rupa Gosvami that the attachment exhibited by pure devotees for Krsna cannot possibly be perfected in the hearts of fruitive workers or mental speculators (pg 139)." Even those who arduously execute sadhana-bhakti may not attain bhava, so what to speak of a non-devotee? Srila Prabhupada says, "This attachment is very confidentially kept by Krsna and is bestowed only upon pure devotees. Even ordinary devotees cannot have such pure attachment for Krsna. Therefore, how is it possible for success to be achieved by persons whose hearts are contaminated by the actions and reactions of fruitive activities and who are entangled by various types of mental speculation? (pg 139)" When neophyte or non-devotees display emotions that resemble the symptoms of bhava it is known as raty-abhasa: a mere reflection of bhava. There are two types of raty-abhasa: (1) prati-bimba — "reflective," and (2) chaya — "shadow."

Reflective Attachment — Prati-Bimba Raty-Abhasa Someone may execute devotional service with an ulterior motive for fruitive gain or liberation. In this case, although the motive is corrupt, the practice is usually quite intense. While performing devotional activities in the association of advanced devotees such a person may experience symptoms that resemble ecstasy, because the genuine ecstasy of advanced devotees are reflecting upon the mirror of his heart. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Sometimes it is found that a person actually attached to material enjoyment or salvation has the good fortune to associate with pure devotees while they are engaged in chanting the holy name of the Lord. By the good grace of the Lord one may also cooperate and join in the chanting. At that time, simply by the association of such pure

8

Due to self-realization, one becomes fully aware of how insignificant and helpless one is: It is impossible for him to achieve anything on his own, not to mention achieving the highest, most rare thing: kåñna-prema. Thus the devotee becomes despondent. However, self-realization also causes one t o unders tand the omnipotence of t he Lord, and the unfathomable affection He has for all living entities. Therefore, although one is completely unable to achieve anything on his own, he is sure that Kåñna will help him. Thus he becomes fully confident of achieving the highest success, in spite of his disqualifications. 110

devotees, the moonlike rays from their hearts reflect on him, and by the influence of the pure devotees he may show some likeness of attachment... (pg 140)”

Shadow Attachment — Chaya Raty-Abhasa Sometime a person may execute devotional service out of social convention or vague curiosity. Compared to reflective attachment, this devotional service is less intense, but the motive is not nearly as corrupt. Such people may exhibit a slight resemblance of ecstatic symptoms, especially when they join kirtana, attend big festivals, visit the holy Dhama, or get the occasional association of saintly devotees. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Such shadow attachment or para attachment can develop if one associates with a pure devotee or visits holy places like Vrndavana or Mathura, and if an ordinary man develops such attachment for Krsna and fortunately performs devotional activities in the association of pure devotees, he can also rise to the platform of pure devotional service (pg 140).” The previous type of raty-abhasa (prati-bimba) more intensely reflects bhava — it is like an image reflected in a mirror. However, in chaya raty-abhasa the symptoms are not as clearly reflected — it is more like a shadow cast on the ground, there is only a vague semblance to the original object. Therefore Srila Prabhupada translates chaya raty-abhasa as "shadow attachment," and prati-bimba raty-abhasa as "reflective attachment." Srila Prabhupada describes shadow attachment (chaya) as para — transcendental. Even though it is less intense, shadow attachment (chaya) is better than reflective attachment (pratibimba) because there is less ulterior motive.

Transforming Raty-Abhasa Into Genuine Bhava The power of the devotees is the only cause of both semblances of ecstasy. If one serves these devotees, his imitative attachment can transform into genuine attachment. Srila Prabhupada explains, “...If such attachment is seen manifested even in some common man, by the association of a pure devotee it can bring one to the perfectional stage. But such attachment for Krsna cannot be invoked in a person without his being sufficiently blessed by the association of pure devotees (pg 140).” In other words, the only way that one can transform his imitative emotions into genuine bhava is by receiving the mercy of a pure devotee. This mercy is attained by service, and blocked by offences. If someone offends a devotee, whatever attachment he has achieved — real or imagined — will wane away to nothing. Srila Prabhupada explains, “As attachment can be invoked by the association of pure devotees, so attachment can also be extinguished by offences committed at the lotus feet of pure devotees. To be more clear, by the association of pure devotees, attachment for Krsna can be aroused, but if one commits an offence at the lotus feet of a devotee, one's shadow attachment or para attachment can be extinguished... If the offence is very serious, then one's attachment becomes almost nil, and if the offence is not very serious, one's attachment becomes second class or third class (pg 141).” The most offensive mentality is impersonalism. If one even associates with an impersonalist, his devotional ecstasy will wane and be extinguished. Srila Prabhupada explains, “If someone becomes attached to the principles of salvation or to merging into the existence of

111

the brahmajyoti, his ecstasies gradually diminish into shadow and para attachment or else transform into the principles of ahangrahopasana (pg 141).” 9 The person who associates with impersonalists becomes contaminated by the notion, "I am God." Srila Prabhupada says, “it is his view that by worshipping himself he is worshipping the supreme whole... Sometimes it is found that a neophyte is taking part in chanting and dancing very enthusiastically, but within himself he is under the impression that he has become the supreme whole (pg 141).” This offensive mentality undermines any hope for advancement to genuine bhava-bhakti.

Apparently Causeless Bhava If a person who apparently has not undergone serious devotional practices suddenly manifests symptoms of ecstasy, one should not automatically assume that he is pretending or exhibiting one of the varieties of raty-abhasa. His ecstasy may be genuine. “...if it is seen that a person has developed a high standard of devotion without having undergone even the regulative principles, it is to be understood that his status of devotional service was achieved in a former life (pg 141).”

Attitude Towards "Faults" In Devotees If a person on the platform of bhava appears to have some fault, how should we understand this? Srila Rupa Gosvami explains that although bhava has arisen, it has not yet completely destroyed all sinful reactions. One should disregard such "faults," understanding that the devotee will soon become completely perfect by the glorious force of his devotion. Srila Prabhupada says, “The example is given that on the full moon there are some spots which may appear to be pockmarks. Still, the illumination spread by the full moon cannot be checked. Similarly, a little fault in the midst of volumes of devotional service is not at all to be counted as a fault (pg 142).”

9

The term ahangrahopäsanä refers to self-worship

112

Eastern Ocean Fourth Wave Prema-Bhakti

Chapter 19

113

Chapter Nineteen

Devotional Service in Pure Love of God BRS 1.4.1 - 21

Chapter Nineteen covers prema-bhakti — the Fourth Wave of the Eastern Ocean. The philosophical discussion of prema is quite brief because prema is simply the mature state of bhava, and Srila Rupa Gosvami has already extensively described bhava. Bhava softens the heart. Prema softens the heart completely. When bhava deepens to the maximum it is called prema. Srila Rupa Gosvami described bhava as a ray of prema. Both the sun and the sun-ray possess light, but there is a difference of intensity. Similarly, both bhava and prema possess ecstatic love of God, but it is not as intense in bhava as it becomes at the stage of prema.

Definition of Prema samyan masrnita-svanto mamatvatisayankitah bhavah sa eva sandratma budhaih prema nigadyate samyak — completely; masrnita-svantah — which makes the heart soft; mamatva — a sense of ownership; atisaya-ankitah — marked with an abundance; bhava — emotion; sah — that; eva — certainly; sandratma — whose nature is very condensed; budhaih — by learned persons; prema — love of Godhead; nigadyate — is described. When that bhava softens the heart completely, becomes endowed with a great feeling of possessiveness in relation to the Lord and becomes very much condensed and intensified, it is called prema [love of Godhead] by learned scholars. (Cc Madhya 23.7) This is Srila Rupa Gosvami's definition of prema-bhakti, which he confirms with the following quote: “In the Narada-pancaratra it is clearly stated that when lust is transferred to he Supreme Godhead and the concept of kinship is completely reposed in Him, such is accepted as pure love of God by great authorities like Bhisma, Prahlada, Uddhava and Narada (pg 143).” He explains further, “Great authorities like Bhisma have explained that love of Godhead means completely giving up all so-called love for any other person. According to Bhisma, love means reposing one's affection completely upon one person, withdrawing all affinities for any other person (pg 143).”

Primary and Secondary Characteristics The primary characteristic of prema is: bhavah sa eva sandratma — it is the intensified (sandra) state of bhava. The secondary characteristics of prema are: (1) samyan masrnita-svanto — it completely softens the heart, and (2) mamatva-atisayankitah — it is marked by highly possessive ownership of Sri Krsna. 114

Mamatva — Highly Possessive Ownership of Krsna Ordinary devotional service has the mood of tadiya — "I am Krsna's." Prema-bhakti, however, has the mood of mamatva —"Krsna is mine!" In bhava-bhakti one gets vision of the Lord and understands his eternal relationship with Krsna. However, in prema-bhakti one actually enters the Lord's pastimes in one's eternal spiritual identity, overwhelmed with the mood that "Krsna is my son," or "Krsna is my friend," or "Krsna is my lover."

Achieving Prema There are two ways to achieve prema: (1) by the maturation of bhava, and (2) by the Lord's extraordinary mercy.

Prema Bhäva Vaidhi

Mercy

Rägänugä

Prema Arising from Maturation of Bhava There are two subdivisions of prema arising from bhava: (1) vaidha-bhavottho — prema arising from bhava achieved through vaidhi-sadhana, and (2) raganugiya-bhavattho — prema arising from bhava achieved through raganuga-sadhana. Prema Arising From Bhava Achieved Through Vaidhi-Sadhana

“A devotee, in the course of executing the regulative principles of devotional service, develops his natural Krsna consciousness, and being thus softened at heart he chants and dances like a madman. While performing chanting of the holy name of the Lord, he sometimes cries, sometimes talks wildly, sometimes sings, and sometimes — without caring for any outsider — dances like a madman (pg 144).” This verse (SB 11.2.40) shows that constantly practicing the regulative principles of devotional service (vaidhi) can arouse bhava. Prema Arising From Bhava Achieved Through Raganuga-Sadhana Srila Rupa Gosvami cites the story of Candrakanti, from Padma Purana. Candrakanti practiced raganuga-sadhana, striving to develop the mood of the ragatmikas of Vrndavana, specifically the gopis. By this practice she achieved bhava, at which point she decided to accept no one else besides Krsna as her husband. This complete indifference to anyone other than Krsna is one of the nine symptoms of bhava, namely virakti. By maturation of her bhava-bhakti, she began to constantly engage in meditation on Krsna's form with the concept "Krsna is my lover." This indicates mamatva — a symptom of prema. Thus she achieved prema by maturation of the bhava she achieved through raganugasadhana. 1

Prema Achieved by the Extraordinary Mercy of Krsna Srimad-Bhagavatam 11.12.7 exemplifies this, “Lord Krsna tells Uddhava, ‘the gopis of Vrndavana did not study the Vedas to achieve Me. Nor had they ever been in holy places of pilgrimage. Nor did they ever devoutly execute any regulative principle. Nor did they undergo any kind of 1

See Jéva Gosvämé & Mukunda däsa BRS 1.4.7 - 8.

115

austerity. It is simply by My association that they have attained the highest perfection of devotional service’ (pg 144).”

Two Types of Prema There are two types of prema-bhakti: (1) mahatmya-jnana — prema mixed with knowledge of the Lord's majesty, and (2) kevala — unmixed, pure prema. Srila Prabhupada says that prema “...can be placed under two headings: one is profound veneration for the greatness of the Lord, and the other is one's being automatically attracted to Krsna without any extraneous consideration (pg 145).”

Mahatmya-Jnana-Prema Narada-pancatratra illustrates prema imbued with knowledge of the Lord's greatness: “...if on account of profound veneration for the greatness of the Supreme Lord one attains a great affection and steady love for Him, one is certainly assured of achieving the four kinds of Vaisnava liberation... (pg 145)” Devotees who achieved bhava from vaidhi-sadhana can attain mahatmya-jnana-prema.

Kevala-Prema Kevala-prema, pure and one-pointed prema, is not even slightly mixed with any other aspiration or interest — such as aspiration for Vaikuntha liberation, or interest in the Lord's profound power and opulence. A devotee with one-pointed love (kevala-prema) always lovingly fixes his mind upon Sri Krsna without the slightest deviation to any other topic. Srila Rupa Gosvami explains this with a quote from Narada-pancaratra, “If a devotee is continuously in love with Lord Krsna and his mind mähätmya-jïäna kevala is always fixed upon Him, that devotional attitude prema will prove to be the only means of attracting the attention of the Lord. In other words, a Vaisnava who is always thinking of the form of Lord Krsna vaidha-bhävottho rägänugéya-bhävottho is to be known as a pure Vaisnava (pg 145).” bhäva Devotees who achieved bhava from raganuga-sadhana can attain kevala-prema. vaidhi rägänugä sädhana mercy

Evolution to Prema

Generally, one attains prema only by persistent, ardent practice — not by a sudden stroke of mercy. Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the gradual evolution from sraddha to prema: adau sraddha tatah sadhusango 'tha bhajana-kriya tato 'nartha-nivrtti syat tato nistha rucis tatah athasaktis tato bhavas tatah premabhy udancati sadhakanamayam premnah 116

pradurbhave bhavet kramah In the beginning there must be faith. Then one becomes interested in associating with pure devotees. Thereafter one is initiated by the spiritual master and executes the regulative principles under his orders. Thus one is freed from all unwanted habits and becomes firmly fixed in devotional service. Thereafter, one develops taste and attachment. This is the way of sadhana-bhakti, the execution of devotional service according to the regulative principles. Gradually emotions intensify, and finally there is an awakening of love. This is the Gradual development of love of Godhead for the devotee interested in Krsna consciousness. (Cc. Madhya 23.14-15) Srila Prabhupada summarizes these verses in Nectar of Devotion, page 146, first paragraph.

Difficulty of Understanding Prema Usually, we judge a person's level of success by how happy he has become. This standard becomes useless when applied to a prema-bhakta. A devotee in prema is so inundated in waves of transcendental emotion that he cannot even perceive external happiness or distress. Consequently, attempting to measure success by conventional standards is fruitless, and misses the point. “'My dear supreme goddess, you may know from me that anyone who has developed the ecstasy of love for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and who is always merged in transcendental bliss on account of this love, cannot even perceive the material distress or happiness coming from the body or mind (pg 146).”

Further Information on Prema Srila Rupa Gosvami refers the reader to Brhad-bhagavatamrta by Sri Sanatana Gosvami for a more detailed description of the affections and dealings of prema-bhakti. He ends the Eastern Division by offering obeisances to his guru — Sanatana Gosvami, and other prominent Gosvamis.

117

Part Two: Southern Ocean

II: Samanya-Bhagavad-Bhakti-Rasa — Overview of Transcendental Mellows 1: Vibhava — Ecstatic Excitants

Chapters 20 - 26

2: Anubhava — Ecstatic Expressions

Chapter 27

3: Sattvika-Bhava — Involuntary Ecstatic Expressions

Chapter 28

4: Vyabhicari-Bhava — Transient Ecstatic Disturbances Chapters 29 - 31

5: Sthayi-Bhava — Permanent Ecstatic Mood

Chapters 32 - 34

118

Southern Ocean First Wave Vibhava

Chapters 20 - 26

119

Chapter 20

Transcendental Mellow BRS 2.1.1 - 18

Mangalacarana To inaugurate the Southern Ocean of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, Srila Rupa Gosvami offers his respectful obeisances unto "Sanatana." This can indicate either Sri Krsna Himself (sanatana = Eternal Lord) or Sanatana Gosvami, who is Rupa Gosvami's elder brother and spiritual master. Srila Prabhupada explains, “This Sanatana can be interpreted as either Sri Krsna Himself or as Sanatana Gosvami, the elder brother and spiritual master of Rupa Gosvami (page 151).” Srila Rupa Gosvami says that "Sanatana" is agha-damano. This glorifies Krsna as the 'killer of Aghasura' — and it simultaneously glorifies Sanatana Gosvami as the 'destroyer of sins' (agha). Srila Prabhupada explains, “In the case where ‘Sanatana’ is accepted to mean Sri Krsna, the obeisances are offered to Krsna because He is naturally so beautiful and because He is the killer of the demon Agha. If it is interpreted to mean Sanatana Gosvami, then it is because he is so greatly favored by Rupa Gosvami, being always served by him, and because he is the annihilator of all kinds of sinful activities (page 151).”

OVERVIEW of the SOUTHERN OCEAN The Southern Division of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu describes how a devotee relishes rasa, transcendental mellow. Rasa is not simply one's eternal relationship with Krsna. Instead, rasa occurs when one's affectionate relationship is intensified and stimulated to a relishable crescendo. There are five components of rasa: the eternal affection, and four types of emotional experiences which intensify that affection. Each of the five waves in the Southern Division will discuss one component in detail. Srila Rupa Gosvami first gives a brief summary of each:

The First Wave — Vibhava Chapters 20-26 The first wave describes the first component of rasa — vibhava. Vibhava is that which stimulates one's eternal affection for Krsna, heightening it to the point of relishable intensity. 120

We can grasp the basic concept of vibhava with help from a simple example: A mother has constant affection for her child, but sometimes it is in the background of her thoughts. To relish that affection requires some stimulus. Seeing her child's beautiful face, for example, can heighten her motherly affection to a relishable crescendo. Her child's face corresponds to vibhava — it simulates her basic motherly affection to the point of relishable intensity. In The Nectar of Devotion, Srila Prabhupada defines vibhava as, "causes of ecstasy (page 151).”

The Second Wave — Anubhava Chapter 27 The second wave describes the second component of rasa — anubhava. Anubhava is an action that results from heightened affection for Krsna, which serves to further enhance that affection. We can return to the same example: When a mother's affection is stimulated, loving emotions swell up in the heart and must be expressed. Perhaps she will embrace her child. This corresponds to anubhava. It results from heightened affection and serves to further enhance that affection. Anu means "to follow," in a chronological and/or ontological sense. Anubhava is an outward result that follows from one's heightened affection. Therefore, Srila Prabhupada translates anubhava as "subsequent ecstasy." 1

The Third Wave — Sattvika-Bhava Chapter 28 The third wave describes the third component of rasa — sattvika-bhava. Sattvika-bhava is an involuntary reaction that results from heightened affection for Krsna, which serves to further enhance that affection. Both anubhava and sattvika-bhava are expressions that result from heightened affection for Krsna, but they are distinct in an important way: Anubhava involves a conscious decision how to suitably express one's ecstasy. Sattvika-bhava, however, is an unpremeditated, involuntary expression arising directly from the spiritually surcharged consciousness. There are eight sattvika-bhavas, such as hair standing on end, becoming stunned, crying, etc.

1

W ebster's defines subsequent: (1) occurri ng or com ing l ater or aft er. (2) fol lowing i n order or succession; succeeding. 121

These symptoms are called sattvika because the arise directly from the suddhasattva enriched soul — which is the constitutional nature of the living entity. Consequently. Srila Prabhupada defines sattvika-bhava as "constitutional or existential ecstasy." 2

The Fourth Wave — Vyabhicari-Bhava Chapters 29 - 31 The fourth wave describes the fourth component of rasa — vyabhicari-bhava. Vyabhicari-bhava is an emotional experience that results from intensified affection for Krsna, which serves to embellish and further stimulate that affection. We can grasp the basic concept of vyabhicari-bhava by returning to our original example: Seeing her baby precariously crawling on the edge of a cliff, a mother's affection intensifies drastically, embellished by the flavor of extreme anxiety. This intense emotional experience corresponds to vyabhicari-bhava — transitory emotions that result from intensified affection, which embellish and further stimulate that affection. A transcendental example: When Mother Yasoda saw Krsna enwrapped in the deadly coils of Kaliya her love for Him intensified drastically, causing acute motherly distress. This distress is a vyabhicari-bhava that further stimulated her worriful motherly affection for Krsna. Vyabhicari-bhavas arise like waves from the ocean of one's heightened affection for Krsna, embellish and flavor it, and then return into that ocean to heighten it even further. Srila Prabhupada defines vyabhicari-bhava as "aggressive ecstasy." 3

The Fifth Wave — Sthayi-Bhava Chapters 32 - 34 The fifth wave describes the fifth and final component of rasa — sthayi-bhava. Sthayi-bhava is one's eternal mood of affection for Krsna (as a passive admirer, servant, friend, parent, etc.). Srila Prabhupada defines sthayi-bhava as "continuous ecstasy." Another term for sthayi-bhava is rati.

2

W ebster's defines constitution: (1) t he way i n whi ch a t hing i s com posed or m ade up; m akeup; composition. A liv ing en tity is co mposed o f brahman, sp irit. Th us, th e liv ing en tity's co nstitution is spirit-soul. Ecstasy th at arises d irectly fro m th e çuddha-sattva enriched soul is sättvika-bhäva: "constitutional ecstasy." 3 Another term for vyabhicäré-bhäva is saïcari-bhäva. The two are entirely synonymous. 122

Rasa Rasa commonly indicates one's eternal relationship with Krsna. Strictly speaking, this is inaccurate. Rati, not rasa, is the correct term. Rasa occurs when the above-mentioned bhavas stimulate rati and heighten it to an unprecedented intensity. When these five bhavas properly combine, one can taste rasa. Srila Prabhupada explains, “The different types of rasa, when combined together, help one to taste the mellow of devotional service in the highest degree of transcendental ecstasy (page 151). . . Without some mixture of these five ecstatic principles, one cannot relish transcendental bliss (page 153).” 4 Srila Rupa Gosvami says the taste of rasa is so astonishing that it always remains apurvata: unprecedented, eternally fresh and new, as if being experienced for the very first time. Thus Srila Prabhupada says, “Such a position, although entirely transcendental to our experience, will be explained in this section as far as possible, following in the footsteps of Srila Rupa Gosvami (page 151).” Srila Prabhupada, wanting to help us appreciate the transcendental position, explains it in a way we can relate to. He compares the extraordinary taste relished in our eternal relationship with Krsna to the taste we can find in our devotional practices (sadhana). “Generally this mellow is experienced by chanting, hearing, worshipping in the temple, and being engaged in the service of the lord (page 152).” This also gives a clue to how one may achieve the transcendental experience of rasa.

Achieving Rasa Previously, Srila Rupa Gosvami made a point about sadhana, “No one can take to devotional service unless he has had a previous connection with it (page 19).” Yet Srila Prabhupada notes in his commentary: “. . .even if there is no continuity, if only by chance one takes interest in a pure devotee's instruction, he can be accepted and can advance in devotional service (page 19).” In this chapter, Srila Rupa Gosvami reiterates his point, in the context of rasa: “This relishing of transcendental mellow in discharging devotional service cannot be experienced by all classes of men, because this sweet loving mood is developed only from one's previous life's' activities. . . (page 152)” 5

4 5

In this quotation, Çréla Prabhupäda uses the term rasa to indicate the five different types of bhävas. By perfect execution of sädhana one m ay achieve the stage of bhäva. In th e n ext life, that bhäva is given proper facility to mature into rasa. 123

Again, Srila Prabhupada notes that tasting rasa is also possible by the mercy of a pure devotee. “In other words, this transcendental bliss is not to be enjoyed by any common man unless he is so extraordinarily fortunate as to be in association with devotees or to be continuing his previous birth's devotional activities (page 152).” Rasa Attained by Sadhana Srila Rupa Gosvami states that one can achieve the platform of rasa by discharge of sadhana-bhakti, particularly by hearing the Srimad-Bhagavatam and associating with rasika Vaisnavas. 6 Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “This joyous life is attained by one's reaction to reading Bhagavada-Gita or Srimad-Bhagavatam, or else from associating with persons who are very interested in the spiritual life of Krsna consciousness — specifically those who have made the determination to achieve the favor of Govinda by being engaged in transcendental loving service at His lotus feet (page 152).” By hearing and chanting, one achieves the blissful experience of rasa. To confirm this Srila Prabhupada quotes the First Canto: “The beginning is to hear about Lord Krsna in the association of devotees who have themselves cleansed their hearts by association. Hearing about the transcendental activities of the Lord will result in one's feeling transcendental bliss always (page 152).” 7 Srila Prabhupada further confirms this with a quotation from Bhagavada-gita. 8

Relation of Rasa and Sadhana Although sadhana cannot directly bestow rasa, there is a definite link between them. By faithful adherence to sadhana one may please the Lord and thereby attract suddhasattva into his purified heart, which will cause the awakening of devotional ecstasy — bhava. This bhava matures into rasa only when "encouraged" or stimulated by various "principles of compelling force" (varieties of vibhava). Srila Prabhupada explains, “Being encouraged by such a feeling, one who is constantly engaged in discharging the regulative principles of devotional service in such a way as to please the Supreme Personality of Godhead develops two principles of compelling force, which come under the heading of vibhava. Thus one enjoys transcendental bliss (page 152).” Srila Rupa Gosvami summarily described the process of achieving rasa. He now reveals the finer details, beginning with its first component:

6 7

8

Rasika Vaiñnava — one who is accomplished in relishing rasa. This i s a t ranslation of Ç rémad-Bhägavatam 1.2.18 & 19: nañöa-präyeñv abhadreñu, nityaà bhägavata-sevayä, bhagavaty uttama-çloke, bhaktir bhavati naiñöhiké; and tadä rajas-tamo-bhäväù, käma-lobhädayaç ca ye, ceta etair anäviddhaà, sthitam sattve prasédati. This is a translation of Bhagavada-gétä 18.54: brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä. . . 124

VIBHAVA Definition of Vibhava Srila Rupa Gosvami defines vibhava as that which stimulates one's eternal affection for Krsna, heightening it to the point of relishable intensity. Srila Prabhupada summarizes this definition: “The cause or basis for relishing transcendental mellow is exactly what we mean by vibhava (page 153).”

Overview of It's Subdivisions Vibhava has two subdivisions: (1) alambana — basic, and (2) uddipana — impelling. To validate this, Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes Agni Purana: “The basis from which ecstatic love is born is called vibhava, which is divided into two — basic and impelling (page 153).” "Basic" Excitants "Basic" excitants (vibhava-alambana) are subjects in which rati (affection) is tasted. There are two subjects who relish the taste of affection: Krsna, and Krsna's devotees. Chapters 21 through 25 will elaborately discuss this. "Impelling" Excitants "Impelling excitants" (vibhava-uddipana) are objects by which rati is tasted. There are many objects that impel Krsna and His devotee to relish the taste of affection: Krsna's flute, His footprints, His prasadam, etc. Srila Prabhupada says, “Impelling ecstatic love, then, is that love which develops when one sees an object which reminds him of Krsna (page 153).” Chapter 26 will elaborately discuss this.

Vibhäva

Devotional Excitents Alambana "Basic" Viñaya Kåñëa

Uddépan "Impelling" ex: flute äçraya Devotee

Srila Prabhupada's Summary of Vibhava's Subdivisions “There are several origins or causes for this compulsive love of Krsna, such as Krsna Himself [visaya], the devotees of Krsna [asraya], and Krsna's playing on the flute [uddipana] (page 153).”

All the Bhavas Stimulate Ecstatic Love Although vibhava is the primary stimulant that transforms rati into rasa, it is not the only stimulant involved in this transformation. The heightening of rati into rasa is a 125

cooperative effort, accomplished by interaction of all five emotional components — vibhava, anubhava, sattvika, vyabhicari, and sthayi-bhavas. Srila Prabhupada states, “There are eight transcendental symptoms found in the body during ecstasy, and all of them are possible only by a mixture of the above mentioned five ecstatic divisions. Without some mixture of these five ecstatic principles, one cannot relish transcendental bliss (page 153).”

Vibhava-Alambana — Basic Excitants

Vibhäva

Devotional Excitents Alambana "Basic" Viñaya Kåñëa

Uddépan "Impelling" ex: flute äçraya Devotee

Vibhava-alambana (subjects in which rati is tasted) has two subdivisions: (1) visaya, and (2) asraya. The word visaya literally means "object." Krsna is the object of affection. The word asraya literally means "shelter." Krsna's devotee is the shelter wherein love of Godhead resides. In context, asraya often translates into "reservoir." As a reservoir is the source of one's water, a devotee is the

source of love of Godhead. In Waves of Devotion, we use the phrase "object of affection" to indicate visaya, and "reservoir of affection" to indicate asraya. Succinctly put, asraya is the lover and visaya is the beloved.

Visaya — Krsna as a Stimulus for Ecstatic Love Krsna has different ages and forms that stimulate different devotees in different ways. Srila Rupa Gosvami first mentions anya-rupa: Krsna taking an entirely different form to stimulate the devotee's love for Him. An example is Brahma-vimohana-lila, when Krsna took the forms of so many cows and cowherd boys, and thus stimulated Balarama's ecstatic love for Him (see last paragraph of page 153).

126

Chapters 21 & 22 Qualities of Sri Krsna BRS 2.1.19 - 128

The end of Chapter 20 described anya-rupa, wherein Krsna takes an entirely different form to stimulate His devotee's affection. Anya-rupa is the first of many ways in which Krsna stimulates ecstatic love. Chapter 21 begins by describing the second way He does so:

Sva-Rupa

Vibhäva

Devotional Excitents Uddépan "Basic"

Alambana "Impelling" Viñaya Kåñëa

Sva-Rüpa His own form

Äçraya Devotee

Anya-Rüpa A different form

Prakaöa-Rüpa Ävåta-Rupa Kåñëa as HimselfKåñëa in disguise

In sva-rupa, Krsna's own form stimulates the devotee's love. Sva-rupa has two subdivisions: (1) avrta-rupa (covered, disguised), and (2) prakata-rupa (fully manifested). Srila Prabhupada explains, “Personal features can be divided into two: one feature is covered, and the other is manifested (page 155).” Avrta-Rupa — Krsna in

Disguise In avrta-svarupa, Krsna covers Himself in a disguise. Srila Prabhupada says, “When Krsna is covered by different kinds of dress, His personal feature is called covered (page 155).” Srimad-Bhagavatam illustrates this: “Uddhava said, ‘How wonderful it is that this woman is attracting my ecstatic love exactly as Lord Krsna does. I think she must be Krsna covered by the dress of a woman!’ (page 155)” There is a difference between anya-rupa (another form) and avrta-svarupa (a disguised form). Anya-rupa is a completely different expansion of Krsna. Avrta-svarupa is Krsna's own form, superficially disguised to look like someone else. Prakata-Rupa — Krsna, as He is In prakata-svarupa, Krsna's own form, undisguised, stimulates the devotee's affection. For example, “One devotee praised the bodily features of Krsna when he saw the Lord in His personal manifest feature [prakata-svarupa]. He exclaimed, ‘How wonderful is the personal feature of Lord Krsna! How His neck is just like a conch 127

shell! His eyes are so beautiful, as though they themselves were encountering the beauty of a lotus flower. . .’ (page 155)”

Krsna's 64 Qualities Srila Rupa Gosvami includes Krsna's 64 qualities in the Second Wave (vibhava) because they stimulate the devotee's affection for Him.

Kåñëa 1 - 64 Näräyaëa 1 - 60 Brahmä & Çiva 1 - 55 Jévas 1 - 50

Out of Krsna's 64 qualities, ordinary living entities can possess the first 50 "in minute quantities," Siva and Brahma can "partially manifest" the first 55 qualities, and Narayana can "manifest" the first 60 qualities, but only Krsna can posses any one of these qualities to an infinite extent, "wonderfully manifest," and "in fullness as deep as the ocean." Moreover, Krsna exclusively possesses four unique qualities, not found in anyone else: (1) lila-madhurya — uniquely sweet pastimes, (2) prema-madhurya — uniquely sweet devotees, (3) venu-madhurya — uniquely sweet all-attractive flute, and (4) rupa-madhurya — uniquely sweet beauty. Lila-Madhurya — Uniquely Sweet Pastimes

What makes a person sweet is his submission to those who love Him. No other form of Godhead has pastimes as sweet as Krsna's, because in no other pastimes is the Lord so completely submissive to the love of His devotees. Thus, among all the Lord's pastimes, Vrndavana-lila is the sweetest. And among all the Vrndavana pastimes, rasalila is the sweetest; because in rasa-lila Krsna submits to His devotee's love to the fullest extent. One devotee said, “I know about Narayana, the husband of the goddess of fortune, and I also know about many other incarnations of the Lord. Certainly all the pastimes of such incarnations are exciting to my mind, but still the pastimes of the rasa-lila performed by Lord Krsna Himself are wonderfully increasing my transcendental pleasure (page 191).” Prema-Madhurya — Uniquely Sweet Devotees As a jewel becomes more beautiful when set in a golden ring, a person becomes more enchanting when surrounded by those who adore him. The Vrajavasi's love for Krsna is unparalleled. Surrounded by them, Krsna shines most brightly as the zenith of enchanting sweetness. Among all devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Vrajavasi's love is the deepest. Among all the Vrajavasis, the gopi's love is best. Thus Sri Krsna is the most attractive form of the Lord, with Srimati Radharani at His left.

128

Srila Rupa Gosvami helps us appreciate the gopis' intense love by quoting two slokas from Srimad-Bhagavatam. One of them reads: “. . .the gopis lament, ‘My dear Krsna, during the daytime when You go out into the forest of Vrndavana with Your cows, we consider one moment to be twelve years. . . And again when You come back at the end of the day, by seeing Your beautiful face we are so much attracted that we are unable to stop looking upon You constantly. At these times, when there is occasional blinking of our eyelids, we condemn the creator, Brahma, as a dunce, because he does not know how to make perfect eyes!’ (page 191)” Venu-Madhurya — Uniquely Sweet All-Attractive Flute No being in this world can compare to Krsna's musical expertise. Even the great demigods cannot understand it. Indra, the king of heaven, is a connoisseur of the finest things in the universe. Siva and Brahma are the originators of all musical skills. Yet neither Indra, Brahma, nor Siva can even comprehend the fascinating musicianship that Krsna joyfully displays when playing His flute. In Srimad-Bhagavatam, the gopis tell mother Yasoda, “When your son plays on His flute, Lord Siva, Lord Brahma and Indra — although they are supposed to be the greatest learned scholars and personalities — all become bewildered. Although they are all very great personalities, by hearing the sound of Krsna's flute they humbly bow down and become grave from studying the sound vibrated (page 192).” Krsna's musical excellence, expressed through the melodies of His flute, stimulates everyone to engage in His devotional service. Rupa-Madhurya — Uniquely Sweet Beauty In this world, beautiful people use jewellery, clothing and other ornaments to enhance their charm. Krsna, however, is bhusana-bhusanangam: He beautifies His ornaments, not visa-versa. 9 Thus, Krsna is far more beautiful than anyone. Even amongst all expansions and incarnations of Godhead, Krsna's beauty is supreme. Krsna's sweet beauty attracts everyone, even Krsna Himself, to taste the bliss of His devotional service. “One day Krsna happened to see the shadow of His beautiful form reflected on the jewelled foreground. Upon seeing this bodily reflection, He expressed His feelings: ‘How wonderful it is that I have never seen such a beautiful form! Although it is My own form, still, like Radharani, I am trying to embrace this form and enjoy celestial bliss’ (page 193).” Conclusion Krsna's wonderful pastimes, devotees, flute-playing, and beauty make Him the supremely attractive entity. Thus even among all expansions of Godhead, He is the supreme stimulus (vibhava-visaya) for ecstatic love. 9

Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.2.12. 129

130

Chapter 23

Krsna's Personality BRS 2.1.220 - 250

Continuing the description of vibhava-visaya (Krsna as the object of loving stimulation), Srila Rupa Gosvami explains that Krsna manifests His sweetly stimulating qualities in three gradations of fullness, “. . .when He is in Goloka Vrndavana His transcendental qualities are exhibited as most perfect, when He is in Dvaraka He exhibits His qualities as very perfect, and when He is in Mathura He exhibits His qualities as perfect (page 195).”

Krsna's Four Personality Traits Besides His 64 qualities, another stimulus of ecstatic love is Krsna's personality. Srila Rupa Gosvami defines and illustrates the four classical types of heroic personalities, all perfectly found in Krsna: (1) dhirodatta — noble, (2) dhira-lalita — romantic, (3) dhira-prasanta — peaceful, and (4) dhiroddhata — haughty. 10 These may appear to be contradictory traits. How can one be humble and haughty, noble and proud? Srila Rupa Gosvami explains that Krsna is the reservoir of all qualities, and by His inconceivable potency He can reconcile all contradictory qualities and personality traits. One should never consider Krsna's haughtiness, etc. to be impure. All His characteristics are wonderfully attractive and pure; for He is completely free from mundane inebrieties like illusion, fatigue, errors, roughness, etc. (See page 198.)

Chapter 24

Further Traits of Sri Krsna BRS 2.1.251 - 270

Chapter 24 concludes Srila Rupa Gosvami's description of Krsna as the stimulus of ecstatic love (vibhava, visaya-alambana) by defining and illustrating eight prominent excellences in Krsna's character: 1. Decorated — Sobha

10

4. Dependable — Mangalya

2. Enjoying — Vilasa

5. Steady — Stairya

3. Pleasing — Madhurya

6. Predominating — Teja

In all four, the word dhéra ("firmly") is common.

131

7. Meticulous Dresser — Lalita

8. Magnanimous — Audaryam

132

Chapter 25

Devotees of Krsna BRS 2.1.271 - 300

Chapters 20 through 24 concern visaya (Krsna as a stimulus for ecstatic love). Chapter 25 concerns asraya (The devotee as a stimulus for ecstatic love).

Asraya — The Devotee as a Stimulus for Ecstatic Love There are two subdivisions of devotees who stimulate ecstatic love for Krsna: (1) sadhaka — the practicing devotee; (2) siddha — the perfect devotee. Srila Prabhupada says, “The devotees of Krsna can be classified into two groups: those who are cultivating devotional service in order to enter into the transcendental kingdom, and those who are already in the perfectional stage of devotional service (page 203).”

Sadhaka - The Practicing Devotee A sadhaka is an advanced devotee, not just any practitioner. Only one who is full of ecstaticy love can stimulate that love to arise in others. Therefore, in this context, sadhaka refers to devotees on the platform of rati, attraction for Krsna; in other words, bhava-bhakti. 11 Srila Prabhupada says, “A person who has attained attraction for Krsna and who is not freed from the material impasse, but who has qualified himself to enter into the kingdom of God, is called a sadhaka. Sadhaka means one who is cultivating devotion in Krsna consciousness (page 203).” Since a sadhaka is at the stage of bhava, he is qualified to periodically recieve direct darsana of Krsna. However, since he has not yet attained prema, he is not quite out of the "material impasse." An example of this is Bilvamangala Thakura (who began to manifest sattvika-bhava in the process of attaining perfection). If even a sadhaka can stimulate ecstatic love, what to speak of the perfected souls (siddha).

11

Thus a sädhaka must at least be a madhyama-adhikäri. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé quotes a prominent verse from the Eleventh Canto that describes a madhyama-adhikäri as one who has at least begun to develop love for the Lord: éçvare tad-adhineñu, bäliçeñu dviñatsu ca, prema-maitri-kåpokekña, yaù karoti sa madhyamaù. "An i ntermediate or second-cl ass devot ee, cal led madhyama-adhikäri, offers hi s love to the Suprem e personality of Godhead, is a sincere fri end to all devotees of the Lord, shows m ercy to people who are in nocent an d d isregards th ose wh o are en vious o f th e Su preme Perso nality o f Godhead." (SB 11.2.46) 133

Siddha - The Perfected Devotee A devotee at the stage of bhava is a sadhaka-asraya-alambana. A devotee at the stage of prema is a siddha-asraya-alambana. Srila Rupa Gosvami defines the siddha as one who never experiences any material distress, who always takes shelter of Krsna, who completely offers all his activities for the Lord's pleasure, and who always tastes the happiness of uninterupted prema. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “When a devotee is never tired of executing devotional service and is always engaged in Krsna Conscious activities, constantly relishing the transcendental mellows in relationship with Krsna, he is called perfect (page 203).” There are two categories of siddhas (perfect devotees): (1) nitya-siddha — those who are always perfect, and (2) those who become perfect.

Äçraya Devotees who Stimulate Ecstatic Love Sädhaka Practicing

Siddha Perfect

There are two subNitya-Siddha Saàpräpta-Siddhiù categories of those who Became Perfect Eternally Perfect become perfect: (1) sadhanasiddha — those who become Sädhana-Siddha Kåpä-Siddha perfect by practice, and (2) Perfect by Practice Perfect by Mercy krpa-siddha — those who become perfect by causeless mercy. Sadhana-Siddha — Perfect by Practice Srila Rupa Gosvami gives two examples of devotees who have achieved perfection by practice (sadhana-siddhas): (1) SB. 3.15.25, and (2) the example of Markendeya Rsi: “Learned sages like Markendeya Rsi attained perfection in devotional service by executing such regulative principles of service (page 204).” Krpa-Siddha — Perfect by Mercy Srila Rupa Gosvami gives two examples of devotees who have achieved perfection by the Lord's causeless mercy (krpa-siddha): (1) The dvija-patnis (wives of the yajnic brahmanas), and (2) Sukadeva Gosvami. Dvija-Patnis Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes their husbands, who praised them for receiving the favor of the Lord without executing reformatory practices. (page 204)

134

Sukadeva Gosvami Narada praised him thus: “My dear Sukadeva Gosvami, you never took the trouble to reside under the care of a spiritual master, yet you have attained such a great status of transcendental knowledge. You never took the trouble to undergo severe austerities, and still, how wonderful it is that you have been situated in the most perfect stage of love of Godhead (page 205).”

Nitya-siddha — Eternally Perfect Devotees who are never separated from Krsna are called nitya-siddha — eternally perfect. Nitya-siddhas are on the same platform as Sri Krsna, since they, like He, are never touched by maya. “Persons who have achieved eternal blissful life exactly on the level of Sri Krsna, and who are able to attract Lord Krsna by their transcendental loving service, are called eternally perfect (page 205).” In the Padma Purana the Lord tells Satyabhama, “My dear wife, you should not consider that My associates are ever separated from Me (page 205).” This is confirmed in a later reference from the same Purana: “When the Supreme Lord returns to His eternal abode, His associates return with Him to their respective places. As such, these ever liberated Vaisnavas are never bound by the material laws of birth and death (page 206).” Quoting Bhagavada-Gita, Srila Prabhupada points out that the birth, deeds, and activities of nitya-siddha devotees are as transcendental as the Lord's. 12 Eternal Individuality of Nitya-Siddhas Just as the post of God is eternally filled by Krsna, the various nitya-siddhas are also eternally situated in their respective posts. Thus, “. . .as it is an offence to consider oneself Krsna, so it is offensive to consider oneself to be Yasoda, Nanda or any other associate of the Lord (page 206).” Nitya-Siddhas Possess 55 of Krsna's Qualities As previously described, Krsna possesses 64 qualities, and a pure devotee can possess the first 50 (in minute quantity). The nitya-siddhas, however, posses 55 qualities, “all of the ever liberated souls who accompany the Lord have the first fifty-five of the qualities, without any doubt (page 206).”

12

The verse Çréla Prabhupäda paraphrases is BG 4.9: Janma karma ca me divyam. . .

135

Chapter 26

Stimulation for Ecstatic Love BRS 2.1.301 - 384

Chapters 20 - 25 concern alambana (Krsna or Krsna's devotee as a stimulus for ecstatic love). Chapter 26 concerns uddipana (Objects related to Krsna or His devotee, which stimulate ecstatic love). There are four categories of uddipana (objects that stimulate love of Krsna): (1) guna — the Lord's qualities, (2) cesta — His adventures, (3) prasadhana — His embellishments and attire, and (4) prakirna — miscellaneous stimulants.

Guna — Qualities There are three categories of Krsna's qualities: (1) Krsna's bodily qualities, (2) His mental qualities, and (3) His vocal qualities. Srila Prabhupada says, “As far as Krsna's transcendental qualities are concerned, they can be divided into three groups: qualities pertaining to His transcendental body, qualities pertaining to His transcendental speech and qualities pertaining to His transcendental mind (page 209).” Alambana or Uddipana? A question arises: Vibhava-alambana refers to Krsna as the stimulus for ecstatic love. Krsna's body, mind, and words are non-different from Him, so why does Srila Rupa Gosvami separately categorize them as uddipana? The Nectar of Devotion gives the answer: “There is no difference between Krsna and His body, and therefore the transcendental features pertaining to His body are the same as Krsna Himself. But because these qualities stimulate the devotee's ecstatic love, they have been analyzed as separate causes of that love. . . In technical Sanskrit terms, such qualities as Krsna's name and fame are accepted both as reservoirs of and as stimulations for love of Krsna (pages 209 - 210).” Krsna's body, mind, and words are both alambana and uddipana; and may be described as either, depending on the point of view. If considered non-different from His personality, they are alambana. If considered distinct entities (for the sake of more detailed analysis), they are uddipana. Bodily Qualities (Guna) Srila Rupa Gosvami has already described Krsna's mind and speech in the section on visaya-alambana (Chapters 21 & 22). Therefore, he now only discusses the qualities of Krsna's body. 136

Krsna's bodily qualities are of four types: (1) age, (2) beauty, (3) ornaments, and (4) softness.

Age Srila Rupa Gosvami describes three distinct age periods in Krsna's pastimes: (1) kaumara — 1-5 years old; (2) pauganda — 6-10 years old; and (3) kaisora — 11-15 years old. Different ages stimulate different relationships with Krsna. Srila Prabhupada explains, “His Guëa Ceñöä Rüpa Prakérëa affectionate pastimes with His parents are exhibited in His Body Mind Words kaumara age. His friendship with the cowherd boys is exhibited Age Beauty Ornaments Softness during the pauganda period. And His friendship with the gopis is exhibited during the age of kaisora. Kumära Pauguëòa Kaiçora Krsna's pastimes at Vrndavana are finished by the end of His fifteenth year, and then He is transferred to Mathura and Dvaraka, where all other pastimes are performed (page 210).”

Uddépana

Kaisora — Adolescence Srila Rupa Gosvami divides kaisora into three parts: (1) adya kaisora — early adolescence; (2) madhya kaisora — mid-adolescence; and (3) antya kaisora — late adolescence. Adya-Kaisora — 11 to 12

Kåñëa's Age kumära 1-5

pauguëòa 6 - 10

kiçora 11-15

adya 11-12

madhya 13-14

antya 15

At this age, “The luster of His body becomes so bright that it becomes an impetus for ecstatic love. Similarly, there are reddish borders around His eyes, and a growth of soft hairs around His body (page 210).” A gopi named Kundalata describes Adya-Kisora-Krsna, “My dear friend, I have just seen an extraordinary beauty appearing in the person of Krsna. His blackish bodily hue appears just like the indranila jewel. There are reddish signs on His eyes, and small soft hairs are coming out of His body. The appearance of these symptoms has made Him extraordinarily beautiful (page 210).”

137

Madhya-Kaisora — 13 to 14 At this age, Krsna's body manifests in a more developed way. “When Krsna attained thirteen years of age, His two thighs were challenging the trunks of elephants, His rising chest was trying to come with peace talks with doors of jewels, and His two arms were minimizing the value of the bolts found on doors. Who can describe the wonderful beauty of these features of Krsna (page 211)?” Srila Rupa Gosvami describes, “The special beauty of Krsna's body was His mild smiling, His restless eyes and His world-enchanting songs. These are the special features of this age (page 211).” Special pastimes characterize madhya kaisora. “At this age Krsna enjoyed the rasa-lila, exhibiting His power of joking with the cowherd girls and enjoying their company in the bushes of the gardens by the bank of the Yamuna (page 212).” Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the special sights in Vrndavana caused by Krsna's madhya-kaisora pastimes with the gopis. He then describes the powerful effect of Krsna mid-adolescent features on the minds of the gopis (See page 212).

Krsna's ages and their attractions:

Adya-Kaisora beautiful bodily luster, reddish edges around the eyes, soft new bodily hairs

Antya-Kaisora Srila Rupa Gosvami gives a similar analysis and description antya-kaisora, which begins at the age of fifteen (see the end of page 212 to the first paragraph of page 213).

Madhya-Kaisora mild smiling, restless eyes, worldenchanting flute songs, rasa-lila Antya-Kaisora all the above qualities reach full maturity.

Nava-Yauvana After antya kaisora (at the age of 16), the features of Krsna's body are nava-yauvana. He continuously manifests this age throughout the remainder of His pastimes. Descriptions of nava-yauvana begin from the first paragraph of page 213.

Beauty After age, beauty is the second category of Krsna's bodily qualities that stimulate ecstatic love (uddipana). Srila Rupa Gosvami says, “Krsna was beautiful because every part of His body was perfectly arranged without any defect (page 213).”

Ornaments Krsna's ornaments are the third category of bodily qualities that stimulate ecstatic love. Srila Rupa Gosvami describes this in an interesting way. “The ornaments on the

138

body of Krsna were not actually enhancing His beauty, but just the reverse — the ornaments were beautified by Krsna (page 214).” Srila Rupa Gosvami only briefly describes Krsna's ornaments; there is an extensive description in the upcoming sections.

Softness The softness of Krsna's body (mrduta) is the fourth category of qualities that stimulate ecstatic love for Him. Srila Rupa Gosvami describes, “A person is called mild when he cannot bear the touch of the most soft thing. It is described that every part of Krsna's body was so soft that even at the touch of newly grown leaves, the color of the touched part of His skin would change (page 214).”

Cesta - Adventures Srila Rupa Gosvami has finished an extensive description of Krsna's guna (qualities). Now he briefly mentions Krsna's cesta (adventures, or "endeavors") such as rasa-lila and dusta-vadha (slaying the wicked). “Krsna's endeavors were always bent towards arranging the rasa dance, as well as towards killing the demons in the forest of Vrndavana (page 214).” These adventures stimulate the devotee's love for Krsna.

Prasadana - Attire The third category of uddipana is prasadana (attire). Krsna has three categories of attire: (1) vasana — dress, (2) akalpa — natural decorations, and (3) mandana — jewellery and ornaments.

Vasana — Dress

Uddépana Guëa

Ceñöa

Prasadana Attire

Misc.

Vaçana Clothes

Äkalpa Natural ornaments

Mandana Jewery

2 piece 4 piece Many

Hairstyle Ointments Garlands Face paintings Tiloka Toy-lotus

Crown Earrings Anklet Necklace Etc.

Srila Rupa Gosvami describes Krsna's three types of dress: (1) yuga — two-piece outfit of upper and lower garments, (2) catuska — four-piece outfit, and (3) bhuyistha — elaborate, festive outfit of many garments.

Srila Prabhupada summarizes by describing His four-piece outfit. “Generally, there are four kinds of garments on the body of Krsna: His shirt, turban, belt, and wearing garments. In Vrndavana, He used to put on reddish 139

garments, with a golden shirt on His body and an orange colored turban on His head (page 214).”

Akalpa — Natural Decorations Krsna has six types of natural decorations: (1) kesa-bandha — hair style, (2) alepa — ointments smeared on His body, (3) mala — flower garlands, (4) citra — face painting, (5) visesaka — decorative tilaka, and (6) keli-padma — toy lotus. Srila Prabhupada summarizes this list, “Akalpa refers to the texture of Krsna's hair, His nicely dressed body anointed with sandalwood pulp and decorated with flower garlands, His tilaka, and His chewing pan (page 214).” Kesa-Bandha — Hair Style Srila Rupa Gosvami describes several subdivisions of hairstyles, which Srila Prabhupada summarizes: “Krsna's hair was sometimes decorated with flowers placed on the middle of His head, or else it was reaching down to His back (page 214).” Alepa — Ointments “As for the ointment on His body, the pulp of sandalwood generally appeared to be white, and when it was mixed with saffron dye it appeared to be yellow (page 214).” Mala — Garlands Srila Rupa Gosvami describes various types of garlands, the most prominent being the Vaijayanti. “This vaijayanti garland is made of flowers of at least five different colors. Such a garland was always long enough to touch Krsna's knees or feet (page 214).” Citra — Face Painting “Artistic paintings with sandalwood pulp and colored sandalwood were also to be found on the body of Krsna (page 215).” All these aspects of Krsna's natural decorations evoke ecstatic love. Srila Rupa Gosvami describes an instance of this, “One gopi addressed her friend and began to praise the bodily features of Krsna. She praised His blackish complexion, the reddish color of chewing pan enhancing His beauty hundreds of times, the curling hair on His head, the kumkum red spots on His body and the tilaka on His forehead (page 215).”

Mandana — Jewellery and Ornaments Srila Rupa Gosvami lists some of Krsna's jewellery and ornaments: kirita — crown, kundala — earring, hara — necklace, catusiki — another type of necklace, valaya — bracelet, anguliyaka — ring, keyura — armlet, and nupura — anklet. 140

Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “Krsna, the enemy of Agha, always looked beautiful with His incomparable helmet, His earrings made of diamonds, His necklace of pearls, His bangles, His embroidered garments, and the beautiful rings on His fingers (page 215).” All these ornaments can stimulate a devotee's ecstatic love. Vana-Mali Vana-mali means one who extensively decorates Himself with flowers from the forest (flower crowns, flower bracelets, etc.). “Krsna was dressed like this not only in Vrndavana but also on the Battlefield of Kuruksetra. Seeing such colorful dress and the garlands of different flowers, some great sages prayed 'Lord Krsna is going to the Battlefield of Kuruksetra not to fight, but to grace all the devotees with His presence’ (page 215).”

Miscellaneous Items such as Krsna's flute, buffalo horn, footprints, etc. comprise the fourth category of uddipana. The remainder of Chapter 26, beginning with the section on Krsna's flute, lists each item and illustrates it poetically.

141

Southern Ocean Second Wave Anubhava

Chapter 27

142

Chapter 27

Symptoms of Ecstatic Love BRS 2.2.1 - 21 Chapter 27 begins the Second Wave of the Southern Ocean, describing anubhava. Anubhava is an action that results from heightened affection for Krsna, which serves to further enhance that affection. The Sanskrit word has two components, anu and bhava. Srila Prabhupada says, “The bodily symptoms manifested by a devotee in expressing ecstatic love for Krsna are called anubhava (page 219).” When one's eternal affection for Krsna heightens, it must be expressed in various activities such as dancing, laughing, etc. For example, a servant's ecstatic love heightens by seeing his master, and outwardly expresses itself by his offering obeisances. Offering obeisances not only expresses the servant's affection, it further intensifies and confirms it. Thus, anubhava is not merely a physical action but an emotional component of itself — which both relieves and reinforces the excessive ecstatic love built up in the devotee's heart. Srila Prabhupada says, “When there is an extraordinary excess of ecstatic love, with all these bodily symptoms manifested, one feels relieved transcendentally (page 219).”

Categories of Anubhava There are two categories of anubhava: (1) sita — without strong bodily movement, and (2) ksepana — with strong bodily movement. 1 Srila Prabhupada explains, “These symptoms are divided into two parts: one is called sita, and the other is called ksepana. When there is yawning, the symptoms are called sita, and when there is dancing they are called ksepana (page 219).” The remainder of chapter 27 defines and illustrates the thirteen main anubhavas, citing sastric evidence. There are two additional sita-anubhavas that this chapter does not describe: (1) raktodgam — bleeding, and (2) utphulla — swelling of the limbs. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Sometimes trembling of the whole body and hemorrhaging from some part of the body are also manifested in response to ecstatic love for Krsna, but such symptoms are very rare, and therefore Srila Rupa Gosvami does not discuss any further on this point (page 222).”

Anubhava Sita — Manifest without great bodily motion

1

Ksepana — Manifest with great bodily motion

1. Gita — singing loudly

1. Nrtya — dancing

2. Jimbhanam — yawning

2. Viluhita — rolling on the ground

Literal translations: çéta — cold, kñepana — tossing, throwing. 143

3. Svasa bhuma — breathing heavily

3. Tanu-motana — stretching the body

4. Loka anapeksita — neglecting the presence of others

4. Krosanam — crying loudly

5. Lalasrava — Foaming at the mouth ("drooling")

5. Atha hasa — laughing like a madman

6. Hunkara — roaring 2

6. Ghurna — staggering ("wheeling of the head")

7. Raktogam — bleeding

7. Hikka — hiccups ("belching")

8. Utphulla — swelling of the limbs

2

The Nectar of Devotion includes the reference for hunkära under Crying Loudly: "By heari ng t he vibration of Kåñna's flute, Lord Çiva becom es very puzzled and begins to cry so loudly in to outer space that the dem ons become vanquished and the devotees become overwhelmed with joy." (page 220) 144

Southern Ocean Third Wave Sattvika-Bhava

Chapter 28

145

Chapter 28

Existential Ecstatic Love BRS 2.3.1 - 96

"Existential ecstatic love" is Srila Prabhupada's translation of sattvika-bhava. In this context, the word sattva does not refer to the mode of goodness but to suddha-sattva, the Lord's internal potency. As described in Chapter Seventeen, the Lord's suddhasattva descends into the heart at the stage of bhava and energizes one's dormant love of Godhead. Sattvika-bhavas are ecstatic symptoms that arise directly from the suddhasattva enriched soul.

Distinguishing Sattvika-Bhava From Anubhava Sattvika-bhava can also be considered anubhava because both are expressions which result from heightened affection for Krsna. However, the two are distinct in an important way: Anubhava involves a conscious decision how to suitably express one's ecstasy. Sattvika-bhava, however, is an unpremeditated, involuntary expression arising directly from the spiritually surcharged consciousness. In anubhava one experiences devotional ecstasy and thinks "let me dance," or "let me sing" — the expression is wilful and voluntary. In sattvika-bhava, however, the expression is involuntary. It occurs when one's heightened affection overrides the intelligence and directly causes involuntary physical symptoms such as paralysis, standing of the hairs, perspiration, tears, etc.

Definition of Sattvika-Bhava Sattvika-bhava is an involuntary physical symptom, occurring when emotions in the primary or secondary mellows intensely overpower the heart (citta). Srila Prabhupada explains, "When a devotee is always intensely affected by love for Krsna in a direct relationship with Him — or even a little apart from Him — his status is called existential ecstatic love (page 223)." This quote establishes two things: (1) sattvika-bhava is a uniquely "intense" anubhava, and (2) sattvika-bhava may arise from emotions in one of the five direct relationships ("in a direct relationship with Him"), or it may arise from emotions in one of the seven indirect relationships ("or even a little apart from Him").

Three Types of Sattvika-Bhava "The symptoms originating from such existential ecstatic love are divided into three headings — namely moist, burnt, and dried-up (page 223)."

146

Causes of Sättvika-Bhäva Sättvika-Bhäva Snigdha

Digdha

Mukhya Gauna Primary Secondary

Rukña

1) Snigdha — "moist." Ecstatic symptoms in persons who love Krsna, instigated by emotions arising from either the direct or indirect mellows. 2) Digdha — "burnt." Ecstatic symptoms in persons who love Krsna, not instigated by the direct or indirect mellows.

3) Ruksa — "dried-up." symptoms that seem to appear in those with no love for Krsna. 1

Ecstatic

Snigdha-Sattvika-Bhava — Moist Existential Ecstasy There are two subdivisions of snigdha sattvika-bhava ("moist existential ecstasy"): (1) mukhya-snigdha — direct-moist, and (2) gauna-snigdha — indirect-moist. Mukhyasnigdha, occurs when a direct mellow (neutrality, servitude, etc.) causes the emotions that overpower the mind. Gauna-snigdha occurs when an indirect mellow (laughter, astonishment, etc.) causes the emotions that overpower the mind. Mukhya-Snigdha — Direct Moist “Radharani was weaving a garland of kunda flowers, and upon hearing the vibration of Krsna's flute, She immediately stopped Her work (page 223).” "Stopped Her work" indicates the sattvika-bhava called stambha (becoming stunned). This ecstatic symptom was caused by the flute, which is an uddipana of the direct mellow called madhurya-rati. Radharani's ecstasy exemplifies the mukhyasnigdha type of sattvika-bhava because it manifested due to emotions arising from one of the direct mellows. Gauna-Snigdha — Indirect Moist Srila Rupa Gosvami describes how Mother Yasoda vehemently rebuked Nanda Maharaja when he took Krsna to Mathura. Out of extreme anger, she chastised her husband so severely that her voice began to falter. Faltering voice is a sattvika-bhava known as svarabheda. This ecstatic symptom manifested from emotions in one of the seven indirect mellows (krodha — anger). Therefore Mother Yasoda's ecstasy exemplifies the gauna-snigdha type of sattvikabhava.

1

Literal translations: snigdha — oily, tender, affectionate ("moist"); digdha — smeared ("burnt"); rukña — dried-up. 147

Burnt Existential Ecstasy — Digdha-Sattvika-Bhava Burnt existential ecstasy (digdha) are ecstatic symptoms in persons who love Krsna, that are instigated by neither the direct nor indirect mellows. For example: once, at the end of the night, Sri Yasoda dreamt that Putana was lying on the ground in a most dreadfully fearful form. Upon seeing her, Yasoda awoke, trembling. Her mind being very agitated, she began to search out her son, Sri Krsna. (See page 223) Fear in relation to Krsna is an indirect mellow. Yasoda's fear, however, was in relation to Putana, not Krsna. Consequently it is not an indirect mellow. Yet because her maternal affection for Krsna is so deep, she naturally dovetails her every emotion to her relationship with Krsna. The fear initially instigated by Putana was immediately dovetailed to her affection for Krsna, and caused her to tremble out of ecstatic motherly concern for His safety. Her trembling (kampa) is therefore an example of digdha-sattvika-bhava.

"Dried-Up Existential Ecstasy" — Ruksa-Sattvika-Bhava The first two types of sattvika-bhava (snigdha and digdha) are exhibited by devotees with genuine affection for Krsna. Ruksa-sattvika-bhava, however, occurs when ecstatic symptoms appear in persons devoid of genuine affection for Krsna. These symptoms are very similar to raty-abhasa. 2 For example, an impersonalist may hear that those who practice devotional service easily achieve liberation, and may therefore join a kirtana party. Jubilantly dancing with hairs standing on end, he thinks, "Now I will achieve liberation! Now I will achieve liberation!!" Affection for Krsna is not the cause of these symptoms. Therefore they are ruksa-sattvika-bhava ("dried-up"). Another example is the trembling and standing-hairs of the sannyasis who witnessed Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu delivering Prakasananda Sarasvati. Because they had no rati, their bodily symptoms were ruksa-sattvika-bhava.

Astika-Sattvika-Bhava — Eight Bodily Symptoms of Overwhelming Emotion Srila Rupa Gosvami described three different causes of ecstatic symptoms (snigdha, digdha, and ruksa). He will now describe the symptoms themselves. There are eight:

2

1) Stambha — stunned

3) Romanca — standing hairs

2) Sveda — perspiration

4) Svarabheda — faltering voice

See page in this book. 148

5) Kampa — trembling

7) Asru — tears

6) Vaivarnya — changing color 8) Pralaya — devastation Srila Prabhupada lists them, "There are eight symptoms of existential ecstatic love: becoming stunned, perspiring, standing of the hairs on the body, faltering of the voice, trembling of the body, changing of bodily colors, shedding of tears, and devastation (page 223)."

How Spiritual Emotions Produce Physical Effects Sattva Surcharged Consciousness Citta Mind Präëa Life-air Bhüta Elements of the Body

Srila Rupa Gosvami explains how sattvika-bhava is produced. First, a particularly strong Krsna conscious emotion agitates the heart (citta) very markedly. Then, the strongly agitated mind disturbs the life air. Next, the dislodged life air contacts and disturbs various physical elements in the body (earth, water, etc.). These disturbed elements cause a physical symptom of spiritual ecstasy. Depending on which element the life air contacts, a specific symptom will be produced. For example, one sheds tears when the life-air contacts the body's water element. One perspires when the life-air contacts the body's fire element. Srila Prabhupada describes this in detail. (See pages 223 - 224)

Sättvika-Bhäva Ecstatic Symptom

Always Existing, Sometimes Manifesting Ecstasy always exists in a pure devotee, but he only sometimes manifests them as external symptoms. Srila Prabhupada explains, Agitated Life “These symptoms are air Contacts Resultant Physical Symptom manifested internally and Earth Stunned (stambha) sometimes externally. The Water Shedding tears (asru) pure devotee always feels such symptomatic Fire Perspiration (sveda) expressions within himself, Fire Change of bodily color (vaivarnya) but being afraid of outsiders Air Standing of hairs (pulaka) he does not generally Air Faltering voice (svarabheda) manifest them externally Air Trembling (kampa) (page 224).” Ether, "Sky" Devastation (pralaya) 3

3

The di stinction bet ween stambha (Stunned) and pralaya (d evastation): Stambha involves paralysis of the body and speech; pralaya involves paralysis of the body, speech, and the mind. 149

Specific Causes and Effects of Specific Ecstatic Symptoms Each ecstatic symptom has specific emotions that cause it. For example, “The symptom of being stunned is caused by ecstatic tribulation, fearfulness, astonishment, lamentation, and anger (page 224).” Each ecstatic symptom has specific characteristic effects. For example, “This symptom [stunned] is exhibited by a stoppage of talking, a stoppage of movement, a feeling of voidness, and an extreme feeling of separation (page 224).” Srila Rupa Gosvami separately describes each ecstatic symptom, listing its causal emotions and characteristic effects, with references from sastra.

Stambha — Becoming Stunned Causes: tribulation, fearfulness, astonishment, lamentation, and anger. Effects: stoppage of talking, stoppage of movement, feeling of voidness, and an extreme feeling of separation. Stambha Caused by Astonishment “There is an example of the astonishment of Lord Brahma. It is explained in the Tenth Canto, Thirteenth Chapter, verse 56 of Srimad-Bhagavatam that when Brahma understood that this cowherd boy was the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself, he became stunned. All of his sensory activities stopped when he saw all the cowherd boys again, along with Krsna. Lord Brahma was so stunned that he appeared to be a golden statue with four heads (page 224).” “Also, when the residents of Vraja found that Krsna had lifted Govardhana Hill with His left hand, they became stunned (page 224).” Although not explicitly stated in this translation, it is obvious that astonishment is what caused the Vrajavasis to become stunned. Stambha Caused by Lamentation “Astonishment caused by lamentation was exemplified when Krsna was entering into the belly of the Bakasura demon and all the demigods from the higher planets became stunned with lamentation (page 225).”

The Remaining Sattvika-Bhavas Srila Rupa Gosvami similarly illustrates each cause of stambha. Srila Prabhupada has included many of these verses in his summary study (See pages 225 - 229). We have discussed only one symptom (stambha). By applying this paradigm to each of the seven remaining ecstatic symptoms, the reader can appreciate them all.

150

Restating the Distinction Between Anubhava and Sattvika-Bhava Srila Rupa Gosvami again stresses the distinction between anubhava and sattvikabhava: Anubhava is an ecstatic symptom that results from heightened affection for Krsna. Sattvika-bhava is an involuntarily ecstatic symptom expressed without any involvement of will or intellect, which occurs when suddha-sattva agitates the heart to a particularly significant degree. 4 Srila Prabhupada explains this very simply, “Out of the many ecstatic symptoms, the symptom of being stunned is especially significant (page 229).” Stambha ("being stunned"), and the other sattvika-bhavas are uniquely "significant" or intense ecstatic symptoms, and this is what distinguishes them from anubhava.

Various Intensities of Sattvika-Bhava If the emotion for Krsna is slight, the mind will be overpowered by a small degree of sattva (transcendental ecstasy). The mildly overpowered mind will only gently agitate the life airs, which will lightly disturb various bodily elements and thus produce a slight manifestation of sattvika-bhava. If the emotion for Krsna is intense, the significantly overpowered mind will strongly agitate the life airs, which will markedly disturb various bodily elements and produce an intense manifestation of sattvika-bhava. Thus each sattvika-bhava can manifest different degrees of intensity. Srila Prabhupada explains, “According to the degree of being stunned, the vital force within the body becomes agitated, and due to such a state, the other ecstatic symptoms become altered (page 229).” 5

Four Categories of Intensity “These transcendental ecstatic symptoms gradually develop, and in the course of such development they are sometimes called smoky, sometimes called blazing, and sometimes called shining. . . .when various symptoms become manifest very prominently, the devotee's condition may be called the brightest (pages 229 - 230).” Thus there are four degrees of intensity: 1) Dhumayita — smouldering ("smoky") 2) Jvalita — flaming ("blazing")

4 5

Çuddha-sattva causes both anubhäva and sättvika-bhäva. In sättvika-bhäva, however, it directly causes the symptom. In anubhäva, it indirectly causes the symptom through the agency of volition. In t his quot e, Prabhupäda' s use of t he word "st unned" does not refer t o t he specific sättvika-bhäva called stambha. Inst ead "degree of bei ng st unned" refers t o t he i ntensity of sättva (ecstatic emotion) which overpowers the mind. 151

3) Dipta — burning ("shining") 4) Uddipta — brightly burning ("brightest") Criteria for Placement Within These Categories There are three criteria that place an ecstatic symptom in one of the above four categories: (1) duration — for example, one may tremble briefly or for a very long time, (2) pervasiveness — for example, only the hands may tremble, or the entire body may tremble, and (3) intensity — for example, the hands or body may tremble slightly, or profoundly. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “The three degrees are experienced for many, many years and they extend to different parts of the body (page 229).” The phrase "many, many years" indicates the first criterion (duration). "Extend to different parts of the body" indicates the second criterion (pervasiveness). Srila Prabhupada implies the third criterion (multiplicity) in upcoming paragraphs. 6 Exceptions The ecstatic symptoms of faltering voice and crying are localized by nature. Only the voice can falter. Only the eyes can cry. Thus one cannot measure their intensity by how extensively they pervade the body. One must apply a substitute criterion. With crying, the substitute criterion for pervasiveness is the extent to which the eyes become swollen and blurry. Srila Prabhupada explains, “The shedding of tears, however, sometimes makes the eyes become swollen and whitish, and sometimes the eyes become differently focused (page 229).” With faltering of the voice, the substitute criterion for pervasiveness is the extent to which the throat becomes altered. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Faltering of the voice may cause choking in the throat and extreme anxiety (page 229).” All Symptoms are Based on Affection All the ecstatic symptoms, and all the stages of their intensity, are based on rati or strong affection for Krishna. “None of the above symptoms can be manifested without the basic principle of strong attachment for Krsna (page 229).”

6

Çréla Prabhupäda implies the third criteria by describing an increasing multiplicity of symptoms in each category of intensity. For exam ple, "When several such ecst atic symptoms are vi sible. . .," and "W hen the ecst atic sy mptoms cannot be checked and t hey si multaneously appear i n four or fi ve di fferent categories. . ." 152

Definitions of the Four Categories Dhumayita — Smouldering: The ecstatic symptom is only slightly manifest, and thus can be concealed. Srila Prabhupada explains, “In the smoky condition of such ecstatic expression, the symptoms could otherwise be hidden (page 229).” Gargamuni exemplifies this (page 229-230). Jvalit — Flaming: Two or three ecstatic symptoms manifest simultaneously, and are very difficult to conceal. “When several such ecstatic symptoms are visible, the condition is called blazing (page 230).” The following example illustrates jvalit's increased multiplicity of symptoms: “One of Krsna's friends told Him, ‘My dear friend, as soon as I heard the sound of Your flute within the forest, my hands became almost motionless, and my eyes became full of tears — so much so, in fact, that I could not recognize your peacock feather. My thighs became almost completely stunned so that I could not move even an inch. Therefore, my dear friend, I must acknowledge the wonderful vibration of your transcendental flute’ (page 230).” This example shows the difficulty of concealing jvalit ecstatic symptoms: A gopi addresses her friend, “My dear friend, when I heard the sound of Krsna's flute, I tried to hide myself from the reaction of the vibration. But still I could not check the trembling of my body, and therefore all of my friends in the house could detect my attachment for Krsna without any doubt (page 230).” Dipta — Burning: Four or five ecstatic symptoms manifest simultaneously, and are impossible to conceal. “When the ecstatic symptoms cannot be checked and they appear simultaneously in four or five categories, this stage of ecstatic love is called shining (page 230).” Srila Rupa Gosvami gives two examples, one of Narada and one of Srimati Radharani. The second: “Dear Friend, You are blaming the aroma of the flowers for the tears in Your eyes. You are rebuking the air for the standing of the hairs on Your body. And You are cursing Your walking in the forest for your thighs' being stunned. But Your faltering voice reveals the cause to be different: it is just Your attachment for Krsna! (page 230)” This illustrates the multiplicity of symptoms and impossibility of concealment that occurs at dipta Uddipta — Brightly Burning: Five or more ecstatic symptoms manifest simultaneously and very powerfully. The residents of Vrndavana exemplified this (“My dear Pitambara...” page 230-31).

153

Suddipta — The Most Bright: This level is unattainable by ordinary souls. Suddipta occurs when all the eight sattvika-bhavas manifest simultaneously, with the highest possible degree of intensity. This can happen only in the mahabhava of Srimati Radharani and Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu. Srila Prabhupada mentions, “when the symptoms of ecstatic love become the most bright, that stage is accepted as mahabhava (page 231).”

Intensity of Ecstatic Symptoms in Non-Devotees The ecstatic symptoms of a non-devotee can achieve no more than the minimal intensity (dhumayita — smoky). Srila Prabhupada expresses this, “All these symptoms are listed under the dried-up existential condition known as smoky, and they are exhibited in different ways (page 229).” There is one exception: in a devotional festival amidst dancing devotees, a nondevotee may sometimes exhibit sattvika-bhavas which radiate up to the intensity of jvalita ("blazing"). Srila Prabhupada says, “Sometimes while participating in ceremonies celebrating Krsna's pastimes, or in a society of devotees, there is dancing ecstasy. Such sentiments are called blazing (page 229).”

Sattvika-Abhasa When ecstatic symptoms seem to appear in a person who has no genuine affection for Krsna, they are called sattvika-abhasa — a semblance (abhasa) of real ecstasy. There are four types of sattvika-abhasa. “Srila Rupa Gosvami further analyzes the ecstatic loving expression into four divisions which are called sattvikabhasa (page 231).” 1)

Raty-abhasa — "Ecstatic symptoms" caused by proximity to a genuine ecstatic devotee.

2)

Sattvika-abhasa — "Ecstatic symptoms" caused by a soft-hearted emotional disposition.

3)

Pratipa — "Ecstatic symptoms" in a hard-hearted person, caused by the powerful influence of krsna-katha.

4)

Nisattva — "Ecstatic symptoms" that are simply a forced, theatrical display.

Raty-Abhasa Raty-abhasa occurs when the genuine rati (affection) of a pure devotee reflects in the heart of a neophyte or non-devotee. A genuine devotee's heart radiates ecstatic affection for Krsna as brilliantly as the sun. This may reflect into the dark hearts of non-devotees like impersonalists and 154

cause them to experience a glimmer of ecstatic symptoms. The section on bhavabhakti has already extensively described this. 7 Srila Prabhupada says, “. . .even if the reactions to chanting are manifest in an impersonalist's body, they should not be considered to be symptoms of actual attachment, but reflections only, just like the sun reflected in a dark room through some polished glass (page 231).”

Sattvika-Abhasa Raty-abhasa is a reflection of genuine ecstatic love. Sattvika-abhasa, however, has no connection with transcendental ecstatic love, reflected or otherwise. It is simply a softhearted emotional disposition that causes the semblance of ecstasy. Krsna's name or pastimes may by chance strike a chord in the heart of those who are naturally sensitive and emotional, and thus cause them to cry, etc.

Pratipa If a non-devotee appears to be exhibiting ecstatic symptoms, it may be due to the influence of a genuine devotee (raty-abhasa). If there is no such influence, it may be due to the persons naturally emotional nature (sattvika-abhasa). However, if the person is quite cold and hard hearted, like the staunch logicians and analytical philosophers, how can the "ecstatic symptoms" be explained? Pratipa is the term for appearance of "ecstatic symptoms" in a cold, stoichearted person. That even such barren people may sometimes be able to exhibit a semblance of ecstasy simply testifies to the overwhelming potency of krsna-katha. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Such non-devotees are not actually melted, they are hardhearted. But the influence of the glories of the Lord is so great that even the nondevotees sometimes shed tears (page 231).”

Nisattva Sometimes a person with no rati (affection for Krsna), and also without any of the above abhasas may display symptoms of ecstasy. They are simply actors and who can display emotions by practice. Physical displays like crying and shivering are not necessarily transcendental symptoms of ecstasy, they can even manifest in people who are outright opposed to Krsna. “Sometimes it is found that a non-devotee who has practically no taste for Krsna and who follows no rules or regulations, can, by practice, make a show of devotional symptoms, even crying in an assembly of devotees (page 232).”

7

References: The Nectar of Devotion , page 139; W aves of Devot ion, page . 155

Reason for Discussing Sattvika-Abhasa Srila Rupa Gosvami describes these varieties of pseudo-ecstasy so one can distinguish between the real thing and the imitation. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Although there is no need to describe these reflections of ecstatic love, Srila Rupa Gosvami gives some instances where there is no actual devotional service and such expressions are manifested (page 232).”

156

Southern Ocean Fourth Wave Vyabhicari-Bhava

Chapters 29 - 31

157

Chapter 29

Expressions of Love for Krsna BRS 2.4.1 - 93

Vyabhicari-bhava is an extremely technical subject. In the next three chapters Srila Prabhupada will explain many of its intricacies. He begins by stating, “There are some bodily symptoms which express overwhelming ecstatic love (vyabhicari-bhava) (page 233).” Vyabhicari-bhava is an emotional experience that results from intensified affection for Krsna, which serves to embellish and further stimulate that affection. We can grasp the basic concept of vyabhicari-bhava with a simple example: Seeing her baby precariously crawling on the edge of a cliff, a mother's affection intensifies drastically, embellished by the flavor of extreme anxiety. This intense emotional experience corresponds to vyabhicari-bhava — transitory emotions that result from intensified affection, which embellish and further stimulate that affection. A transcendental example: When Mother Yasoda saw Krsna enwrapped in the deadly coils of Kaliya her love for Him intensified drastically, causing acute motherly distress. This distress is a vyabhicari-bhava that further stimulated her worriful motherly affection for Krsna. Vyabhicari-bhavas arise like waves from the ocean of one's heightened affection for Krsna, embellish and flavor it, and then return into that ocean to heighten it even further. 1

Thirty-Three Vyabhicari-Bhavas Srila Rupa Gosvami lists thirty-three emotional experiences in the category of vyabhicari-bhava. Each emotion has various causesand effects, which Srila Rupa Gosvami describes and authenticates with elaborate sastric references.

Nirveda — Self-Disparagement ("Disappointment") There are four principle causes of self-disparagement (nirveda): (1) maha-duhkha — great distress, (2) viprayoga — separation, (3) irsa — jealousy, and (4) sad-viveka — recognition of one's failure to live up to his duty, or admission of one's commision of a forbiddin action. 2

1

Just as waves cause the ocean to m ove and enlarge, vyabhicäré-bhäva moves and hei ghtens one' s relationship wi th Kåñna ( sthäyé-bhäva). Thus a sy nonym for vyabhicäré-bhäva is saïcäri-bhäva (literally, "that which moves"). 2 B RS 2.4.7 158

Srila Prabhupada traslates sad-viveka, the fourth cause of nirveda: “When one is forced to act in a way which is forbidden, or to refrain from acting in a way which is proper, he becomes regretful and thinks himself dishonored. At that time, there is a sense fo disappointment (pg. 233).” Srila Rupa Gosvami mentions the effects of nirveda: “In this kind of disappointment one becomes full of anxiety, sheds tears, changes bodily color, feels humility and breathes heavily (pg. 233).” Self-Disparagement Caused by Great Distress Mother Yasoda experienced great distress when Krsna was in the clutches of Kaliya. This caused self-disparagement, she condemned her "sinful" existence and desired to enter the deadly lake. (See pg. 233.) Self-Disparagement Caused by Separation When Krsna left Vrndavana, Subala condemned his residence there. (See pg. 233.) Srimati Radharani felt that, if She could not see or hear Krsna, the Her vision and hearing were condemned. She said, “My dear friend, if I cannot hear of the glorious activities of Krsna, it is better for Me to become deaf. And because I am now unable to see Him, it would be good for me to be a blind woman (pg. 234).” Self-Disparagement Caused by Jeaulousy Satyabhama, Krsna's queen, condemned herself due to jealousy of Rukmini, Krsna's chief queen. (See pg. 234.) Self Disparagement Caused by Recognition of One's Wrongdoing “My dear Krsna, I cannot say that it is only other people who are implicated in material ecistence, because I too am much entangled with the bodily concept of life... And because I have been so maddened by this material atmosphere, I am thinking now that my life has been simply spoiled (pg. 234).” Srila Rupa Gosvami describes all thirty-three vyabhicari-bhavas using this same systematic procedure. Srila Prabhupada summarizes this description on pages 233 - 262 in Nectar of Devotion (BRS 2.4.7 - 2.4.291). As we see from these examples, vyabhicari-bhava is a temporary, transient emotional experience that results from and further stimulates one's heightened affection for Krsna. In each example the devotee's self-disparagement has a different flavor, because each is based on a different type of affection for Krsna. For example, conjugal 159

affection flavored Srimati Radharani's self-disparagement; while friendship flavored Subala's self-disparagement. This clarifies that one's relationship with Krsna is like an ocean, and vyabhicari-bhava is a beautiful wave which rises from that ocean, transforms and heightens it in wonderful ways, and again subsides within it.

Ecstatic Symptom

Standard Translation

Other Translations

1. Nirveda 2. Visada 3. Dainya 4. Glani 5. Srama 6. Mada 7. Garva 8. Saìka 9. Trasa 10. Avega 11. Unmada 12. Apasmrti 13. Vyadhi 14. Moha 15. Mrti 16. Alasya 17. Jadata 18. Vrida 19. Avahittha 20. Smrti 21. Vitaska 22. Cinta 23. Mati 24. Dhrti 25. Harsa 26. Utsukata 27. Ugrata

Self-disparagement Despair Humility Depression Weariness Intoxication Pride Alarm Fear Agitation Madness Forgetfulness Sickness Bewilderment Death Laziness Inertness Shame Concealment Remembrance Doubt Anxiety Thoughtfulness Forbearance Jubilation Eagerness Ferocity

Disappointment, indifference... Frustration, lamentation... Guilt... Fatigue...

Doubt, apprehension... Apprehension... Intense emotion...

Disease... Confusion, illusion...

Bashfulness... (Hiding one's feelings) Argumentativeness

Endurance... Happiness, joy... Violence... 160

28. Amarsa 29. Asuya 30. Capalata 31. Nidra 32. Supti 33. Bodha

3

Haughtiness Envy Restlessness Drowsiness Sleep Wakefulness

Indignation... Jealousy, malice... Impudence, unsteadiness... "Dizziness" 3 Altertness, restlessness...

The phonetic similarity between "drowsiness" and "dizziness" leads one to suspect a mistake on behalf of the original transcriber. With this in mind, it is p leasant to read the examples given for "dizziness," on pages 258 - 259 in The Nectar of Devotion. 161

Chapter 30

Further Features of Ecstatic Love BRS 2.4.94 - 190

The previous chapter described the first thirteen vyabhicari-bhavas. This chapter describes the remaining twenty.

Chapter 31

Additional Symptoms BRS 2.4.191 - 270

One can classify vyabhicari-bhavas as uttama, madhyama, or kanistha according to the level of ecstatic love they invoke. Srila Prabhupada mentions this, “These symptoms, however, can be divided into three groups: first class, second class and third (page 263).”

Thirteen "Additional" Emotions After describing the thirty-three vyabhicari-bhavas in detail, Srila Rupa Gosvami introduces thirteen more. Srila Prabhupada lists them, “There are many disturbing symptoms in ecstatic love, such as envy, anxiety, pride, jealousy, conclusion, cowardliness, forgiveness, impatience, hankering, regret, doubtfulness and impudence (page 263).” 4 These are not truly "additional" because they can be included within the original thirtythree. Srila Prabhupada explains, “These are included in the thirty-three conditions of ecstatic love (page 263).”

How the Thirteen are Included in the Thirty-Three Jiva Gosvami's commentary points out exactly how the thirteen additional emotions are included in the original thirty-three. 5 For example: Matsarya (malice 6 ) is one of the thirteen "additional" emotions. Asuya (envy) is one of the thirty-three main emotions. Envy includes malice, so there is no need to consider malice a separate emotion. Srila Prabhupada explains, “When one becomes malicious upon seeing another's advancement of life, his state of mind is generally called envy (page 263).” Another example: avahittha (concealment), one of the thirty-three main emotions, includes the "additional" emotion called dambha (pride or conceit). Srila Prabhupada explains, “One's desire to hide his real mentality is called avahittha, or concealment, and a desire to exhibit superiority is called pride. Both of these may be classified under pretension. In a pretentious attitude both avahittha and pride are to be found (page 263).” To conceal (avahittha) one's real feelings, one must employ pretension; he must pretend to feel differently then he truly does. Similarly, pride (dambha) involves concealing one's real status and pretending to be something greater. Thus concealment implicitly includes pride. 4 5 6

Viveka (reason), the thirteenth "additional" emotion, is omitted in The Nectar of Devotion. BRS 2.4.192 - 193, Jéva Gosvämé. In the list of thirteen additional emotions given in Chapter 31, Çréla Prabhupäda translates matsarya as "envy."

162

Jiva Gosvami continues describing how the original thirty-three vyabhicari-bhavas include all the thirteen "additional" symptoms (NOD, middle page 263 to page 264).

Vibhava and Anubhava within Vyabhicari-Bhava "All of these symptoms are transcendental, and they are exhibited in different ways, acting and interacting under different circumstances (page 264)." There is an intricate inter-relationship between the vyabhicari-bhavas, in which some symptoms take on the character of vibhava (stimulant), and others take on the character of anubhava (result of the stimulant). For example: Envy and disgust are vyabhicari-bhavas, but they possess qualities of vibhava and anubhava in relation to each other. Envy can instigate disgust and thus take the quality of vibhava (stimulant) in relation to disgust. Similarly, disgust can be an expression that results from envy, and thus take the quality of anubhava (sub-sequent ecstasy) in relation to envy. Both envy and disgust are vyabhicari-bhavas — but relative to each other they exhibit qualities of vibhava and anubhava. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “When a person is envious or defamed, there may be a change in the color of the body. This may be classified as vibhava, or subecstasy. Sometimes illusion, collapse and strong anxiety are also considered to be vibhava (page 264).”

Divisions of Vyabhicari-Bhava A vyabhicari-bhava may be (1) paratantra — dependent, or (2) svatantra — independent. A paratantra (dependent) vyabhicari-bhava is born from affection for Krsna. A svatantra (independent) vyabhicari-bhava is not directly born from affection for Krsna. 7

Paratantra — Dependant Vyabhicäré-Bhäva Paratantra Born of affection for Kåñëa

Svatantra Not born of affection for Kåñëa

Vara Avara Nourishes rati Doesn't nourish rati Säkñät Nourishes primary rati

Vyavahita Nourishes secondary rati

There are two types of paratantra (dependent) vyabhicari-bhavas: (1) vara — superior, and (2) avara — inferior. A vyabhicari-bhava is vara when it nourishes one's affection for Krsna. It is avara when it does not nourish one's affection for Krsna. 8 Vara (superior) has two further subdivisions: (1) saksat — direct, and (2) vyavahita — indirect. Saksat occurs when the vyabhicaribhava nourishes a primary rati. Vyavahita occurs when the

vyabhicari-bhava nourishes a secondary rati. Srila Prabhupada explains this: “Dependence is also grouped under ecstatic love, and this can be divided into superior dependence and inferior dependence. The direct differentiations between superior and inferior dependence are ascertained by Srila Rupa Gosvami and will be explained in due course (page 264).” 7 8

B RS 2.4.205 B RS 2.4.206

163

Vara Saksat-Vara Vyabhicari-Bhavas that Nourish Primary Rati “Oh, I cannot see the district of Mathura! Even though by simply hearing the name of Mathura the hairs of my body are standing up, I cannot see the place. So what are the use of my eyes? (page 264).” This nirveda (self-disparagement) is born from strong attachment to Krsna and nourishes the devotee's direct affection for Krsna (mukhya-rati). Therefore it is saksat-vara. Vyavahita-Vara Vyabhicari-Bhavas that Nourish Secondary Rati Bhima began to murmur, “My arms are just like thunderbolts, but despite these arms I could not smash Sisupala while he was blaspheming Krsna. Therefore, of what use are these strong arms (page 265)?” This nirveda nourishes Bhima's anger, an indirect affection for Krsna (gauna-rati). Therefore it is vyavahita-vara. Avara Vyabhicari-Bhavas that do not Nourish Rati “When Arjuna witnessed the universal form of Krsna, whose dazzling teeth were practically devouring the very existence of the universe, Arjuna's mouth became dried up. At that time Arjuna forgot himself and could not understand that he was Arjuna, Krsna's friend, although he was always dependent on Krsna's mercy. This is an example of inferior dependence (page 265).” Arjuna experienced the vyabhicari-bhava known as moha (bewilderment). Although born of affection for Krsna (paratantra), Arjuna's bewilderment did not heighten his friendly affection for Krsna. On the contrary, it diminished his sakhya-rasa, and is therefore avara paratantra.

Svatantra — Independent Svatantra refers to vyabhicari-bhavas that are not born from Paratantra Svatantra affection for Krsna. Born of affection Not born of affection There are three types: for Kåñëa for Kåñëa (1) rati-sunya — void of affection (rati) for Rati-gandhi Rati-çunya Raty-anusparçana Krsna, (2) ratyDevoid of affection Subsequent affection Trace of affection anusparsana — emotions not originally born from affection for Krsna but which later contact affection for Krsna, and (3) rati-gandhi — slight trace of rati. 9

Vyabhicäré-Bhäva

9

B RS 2.4.217

164

Ratisunya Vyabhicari-Bhavas Completely Void of Affection for Krsna The self-disparagement of the yajnic brahmanas exemplifies this. Their nirveda was born from realization of their own abominable condition, not from affection for Krsna. By their own admission, they were completely devoid of affection for Krsna — thus their lamentation is ratisunya. Raty-Anusparsana Vyabhicari-Bhavas that Become Connected with Affection for Krsna Rati-anusparsana literally means "that which subsequently (anu) touches or contacts (sparsa) affection for Krsna (rati).” The gopis exemplify this, “When the bull demon attacked the damsels of Vraja, they began to cry out, ‘Dear Krsna — please save us! We are now gone!’ (page 265)” Their trasa (fear) was born from apprehension of their own distress, not Krsna's. But due to the gopis deep love for Him, everything they experience or express becomes dovetailed with krsna-rati. Even though their fear of the bull demon arose of an independent cause, it subsequently came into direct contact with krsna-rati. Rati-Gandhi Vyabhicari-Bhavas that have a Slight Trace of Affection for Krsna Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of rati-gandhi: Srimati Radharani's grandmother said, “Radha! I recognize that yellow clothing you are wearing. Don't try to hide it!” Hearing this, Srimati Radharani immediately lowered Her head in shame and covered Her face with Her veil. 10 Jiva Gosvami explains: In this quotation, Srimati Radharani experiences the vyabhicaribhava called vrida (shame). This shame does not come from Her affection for Krsna, but from embarasment that Her respected gradmother discovered Krsna's yellow clothing on Her body. Therefore it is svatantra (independent). Although independant of Her specific madhurya-rati for Krsna, Sri Radha's shame does has a trace of rati, because it is only due to Her madhurya-rati that Krsna's yellow clothing was on Her body. Because of this slight connection to Her madhurya-rati, Srila Rupa Gosvami classifies this shame as rati-gandha. Carefully analyzing all the svatantra vyabhicari-bhavas, one finds that only rati-sunya is truly independent of affection for Krsna. Raty-anusparsana and rati-gandha are actually connected to krsna-rati, and are therefore dependent (paratantra). Thus only rati-sunya is fully svatantra. Srila Rupa Gosvami explains that the others may be seen as independant: just as a goverment tax collector seems to be collecting money himself, be he is actually dependant upon the goverment's authorization. 11

10 11

B RS 2.4.223 B RS 2.4.216

165

Vyabhicary-Abhasa Vyabhicary-abhasa are emotions that only externally resemble vyabhicari-bhava. There are two types: (1) pratikulya — unfavorable, and (2) anaucitya — improper. Praticulya occurs in persons who are inimical towards Krsna. Anaucitya occurs when a devotee imagines vyabhicaribhava in persons who are not actually feeling that emotion. 12

Pratikulya-Vyabhicary-Abhasa Semblance of Vyabhicari-Bhava in Hostile Persons After Krsna killed the Kesi demon, Kamsa said, “Kesi-daitya was as dear to me as my own life, but he has been killed by some cowherd boy who is crude, uneducated, and ignorant in fighting. Even though I have defeated the King of heaven without difficulty, still I do not know the value of life (page 265).” Kamsa appears to exhibit nirveda (self-disparagement, or "hopelessness"). However, his emotion is born from a hostile (pratikula) attitude towards Krsna and therefore is not an actual vyabhicari-bhava. Another example of vyabhicary-abhasa in persons hostile to Krsna: Kamsa told Akrura, “You are such a fool that you are accepting a cowherd boy to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead simply because He has defeated some harmless water snake! The boy may have lifted one pebble called Govardhana Hill, but what is more surprising than that is your statement that this boy is the Personality of Godhead! (page 266)” Kamsa appears to exhibit asuya (envy, or "maliciousness") but his emotion is born from a hostile attitude towards Krsna and is therefore pratikulya-vyabhicary-abhasa.

Anaucitya-Vyabhicary-Abhasa Semblance of Vyabhicari-Bhava in Inappropriate Persons Anaucitya-vyabhicary-abhasa occurs when a devotee imagines vyabhicari-bhava where it does not really exist. There are two types: (1) asatyatvam — non-existence, and (2) ayogyatvam — incapability. In asatyatvam, a Vyabhicäry-Abhäsa devotee imagines vyabhicari-bhava to be present in a subject in whom it does not exist (generally an inert Prätikülya Anaucitya Hostile persons Inappropriate persons living entity). In ayogyatvam, the devotee imagines vyabhicari-bhava to be present in a subject who is Asatyatvam Ayogyatvam Inert living entites Animals incapable of fully experiencing it (generally an animal). 13 Asatyatvam A devotee tried to console a kadamba tree, which was lamenting because Krsna had not even touched its shadow. “My dear kadamba tree, do not be worried. Just after defeating the Kaliya snake in the Yamuna River, Krsna will come and satisfy your desire (page 266).”

12 13

BRS 2.4.224-225 B RS 2.4.228

166

The devotee imagines that the tree is experiencing nirveda (self-disparagement). 14 In truth the nirveda exists only in the devotee's mind, and he projects it onto the tree. The tree may be experiencing some type of ecstatic love for Krsna, but not the specific emotion the devotee perceives. This is asatyatvam-anaucitya — projection of vyabhicari-bhava onto a subject in whom the emotion does not exist. Ayogyatvam This type of vyabhicary-abhasa usually occurs with animals, who are incapable of properly experiencing the intricacies of vyabhicari-bhava. It is exemplified in connection with Garuda (see page 266). 15 Trees and Animals are Incapable of Ecstasy? Both cases presume that the trees and animals can not properly experience bhava. But the trees, peacocks, etc. of Vraja are not ordinary birds and trees, they are eternal associates of Sri Krsna. How can their emotions be asatyatvam (non-existent) or ayogyatvam (incapable)? Jiva Gosvami and Visvanatha Cakravarti Thakura explain: it is a fact that the apparently unintelligent life forms in Vraja are liberated souls with full love for Krsna. Due to this ecstatic love, they take on the role of His trees and animals, fully assuming the appropriate characteristics of intelligence and behavior. They do so to facilitate Krsna's pastimes. If the animals and foliage manifested their full intelligence, their presence would pose a hindrance to the confidential amorous pastimes of the Lord. In this light, one might consider their vyabhicari-bhavas to be asatyatvam or ayogyatvam.

Conditions of Vyabhicari-Bhava “The symptoms of ecstatic love are grouped under four headings — namely generation, conjunction, aggregation, and satisfaction (page 266).” 1) Utpatti — "generation." The beginning of an emotion. 2) Sandhi — "conjunction." When two or more emotions unite. 3) Savalya — "aggregation." When one emotion supplants another. 4) Santi — "satisfaction." When a disturbing emotion is resolved.

Utpatti — Generation This is the most basic condition of vyabhicari-bhava. Every vyabhicari-bhava must first undergo generation before any other condition is possible. The example of Srimati Radharani knitting Her eyebrows in response to Krsna's joking (page 266) exemplifies the generation of matsarya (malice).

14 15

Here Çréla Prabhupäda translates nirveda as "lamentation" and "hopelessness." The original text (BRS 2.4.230) gives additional details that may help clarify ayogyatvam: A devotee sees the peacock feather in Kåñna's turban and imagines that the peacock must be thinking: "Today, leaving aside even the wings of Garuda, Ç ré Kåñna has he ld my sanctified feathers on His head. Therefore, what other bird can be a match for me?" Here the devotee is superimposing the vyabhicäré-bhäva known as garva (pride) unto an animal who is actually unable to properly experience such emotion. 167

Sandhi — Conjunction In this condition, two or more vyabhicari-bhavas unite to create a single emotional experience. There are five types of conjunctions: 1)

One emotion from two causes

2)

Two emotions from one cause

3)

Two emotions from two causes

4)

Several emotions from one cause

5)

Several emotions from several causes One Emotion from Two Causes

Mother Yasoda became stunned with bliss when she saw that her child was safe on the lap of Putana's dead body. At the same time, she became stunned with anxiety due to the dangerous demon. Two causes (happiness over the safety of her child, and fear of demoniac calamity) produced one effect (stunned). (See page 266.) Two Emotions from One Cause When Mother Yasoda saw that her child had learned to walk, she became simultaneously happy and fearful. One cause (Krsna's walking) produced two effects (happiness for her child's maturity, and fear for the child's safety). (See page 267.) Two Emotions from Two Causes “When Devaki, the mother of Krsna, saw her son very jubilant in the presence of the wrestlers in Kamsa's arena, two kinds of tears were simultaneously gliding down her cheeks: sometimes the tears were warm, and sometimes they were cold. This is an instance of conjunction of jubilation and lamentation due to different causes of ecstatic love (page 267).” Two causes (her jubilant son, and the powerful wrestlers) produced two distinct effects (harsa-happiness, and visada-despair). Seeing her jubilant son caused great happiness (symptomized by cold tears), but seeing the powerful wrestlers caused great despair (symptomized by hot tears). Several Emotions from One Cause Srimati Radharani's reaction to Krsna's aggressiveness illustrates this. The cause was one: Krsna. The effect was many different emotions. “This is an instance of exhibiting varying feelings in ecstatic love, although the cause is one only — Krsna (page 267).” Several Emotions from Several Causes “Sometimes there were great festivals in the house of Nanda Maharaja, and all of the inhabitants of Vrndavana would assemble for these festivals. During one such festival, Srimati Radharani was seen wearing a golden necklace given Her by Krsna. This was immediately detected by mother Yasoda as well as by Radharani's mother, because the necklace was too long for Radharani's neck. At the same time Radharani could see Krsna nearby, as well as Her own husband, Abhimanyu. So all of these things combined to make Radharani feel very much ashamed, and with Her face shrivelled She began to look very beautiful. In this case there was a combination of bashfulness, anger, jubilation and lamentation (page 267).” 168

Many different causes — Krsna, Abhimanyu, Yasoda, etc. — produced many different emotions — bashfulness, anger, jubilation and lamentation.

Savalya — Aggregation Both sandhi (conjunction) and savalya (aggregation) involve combinations of multiple emotions. In sandhi, however, the emotions exist simultaneously. In savalya the succeeding emotion supplants the preceding one. For example, “Kamsa once said, ‘What harm can this boy do to me? He has no power.’” Here Kamsa exhibits garva (pride). “The next moment he was informed that all of his friends had been killed by the boy. Then Kamsa began to think in perplexity, ‘Shall I go immediately and surrender unto Him? But how can a great warrior do this?’” Here, Kamsa's previous garva aggregated with visada (lamentation) In other words, lamentation supplanted the pride (page 268). The householder devotee's self-analysis is an example of seven successive savalya aggregations (page 268).

Santi — Satisfaction “Once the cowherd boys in Vrndavana were vainly searching after Krsna for a long time, and for that reason their faces became blackened, and their complexions appeared faded. Just then they could hear on the hill a faint vibration from Krsna's flute. Immediately all of them became very much gladdened. This is an instance of satisfaction in the midst of disappointment (page 268).” First the cowherd boys were experiencing visad (despair), but that despair was later "satisfied" or pacified by harsa (jubilation). Santi occurs when the preceding emotion is pacified and resolved by the succeeding one. Srila Prabhupada adds a significant point in his commentary. He quotes a Sanskrit proverb, "Disappointment gives rise to the greatest satisfaction," and says that the experience of Krsna conscious joy is most relishable during the satisfaction of a disturbing emotion.

Citta Vrtti — Internal Disposition Vyabhicari-bhavas arise from the devotees internal disposition (citta vrtti). Internal disposition is determined by one's eternal affection for Krsna, one's individual characteristics, and various stimulating factors one is exposed to in any given situation. The rise of emotions in a devotee is thus under the control of many variables. Srila Prabhupada explains, “. . .attachment for Krsna is one, but because there exist different kinds of devotees, such attachment is manifested in many varieties. . . In fact, all the different humors and mellows of the devotees produce various specific feelings within the mind. And according to these differences, the symptoms of ecstatic love appear in different forms and degrees (page 269).” Srila Rupa Gosvami will now elaborately categorize the various internal dispositions.

169

Determining Factors The first paragraph of page 269 mentions forty-one emotions that combine to make up a devotee's internal disposition. These include the thirty-three vyabhicari-bhavas, as well as eight sthayi-bhavas (seven secondary + one primary). 16 Srila Prabhupada explains, “All of them can be accepted as different feelings of the heart. Sometimes some of the feelings are quite natural. Sometimes some of the feelings are just temporary appearances. Those symptoms which are very natural always remain, both within and without the devotee (page 269).” "Natural feelings" refers to sthayi-bhava, which is permanent. "Temporary feelings" refers to vyabhicari-bhava, which is transitory. Srila Rupa Gosvami mentions these forty-one characteristics to show that there is a cyclic relationship between vyabhicari-bhava and the devotee's internal disposition. Vyabhicaribhavas manifest from the devotee's internal disposition; but at the same time one's internal disposition is a composition of forty-one elements, which include the vyabhicari-bhavas. These 44 factors produce different dispositions in a devotee's heart depending on how they combine.

Various Dispositions of the Heart In Terms of Ability to Conceal Emotion Srila Rupa Gosvami categorizes the disposition of the heart as either karkasa (hard) or komal (soft). Karkasa does not indicate "hard-heartedness" or a lack of ability to feel emotion. The "hardness" or "softness" of the heart, in this context, refers to the devotee's ability to conceal his emotional ardour from the eyes of others. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Actually, people cannot generally understand such different qualities of mentality, but when one's heart is very soft or gentle, these symptoms become very easily visible, and one can understand them very clearly (page 269).” A devotee with a karkasa (hard) disposition can conceal the emotions he experiences. However, even the slightest uprise of emotion will visibly agitate a devotee with a komal (soft) disposition. Srila Rupa Gosvami uses three adjectives to describe the karkasa (hard) disposition: (1) Garistha — "heavy," one's heart is hard like metal (gold); (2) Gambhira — "grave," one's heart is deep like the ocean; (3) Mahistha — one's heart is "big" like a great city. There are three varieties of komal (soft) disposition: (1) Laghistha — one's heart is "light" like cotton; (2) Uttana — one's heart is "shallow" like a small puddle; (3) Ksodistha — one's heart is "tiny" like a small cottage.

Garistha (heavy) vs. Laghistha (light) Srila Rupa Gosvami compares the karkasa heart to heavy gold; the komal heart to cotton. Strong wind does not move a gold brick, but even a slight breeze will toss the cotton. Similarly, strong ecstasy is not easily detected in a karkasa devotee, because his heart is heavy like gold

16

The sthäyé-bhävas are not counted as twelve because each devotee may posses only one primary rasa. Thus, there is one pri mary sthäyé-bhäva, seven secondary sthäyé-bhävas, an d thirty-three vyabhicäré-bhävas whi ch make up one's internal disposition. 170

(garistha), but even a slight breeze of emotion is noticeable in a komal devotee, because his heart is light like cotton (laghistha). “The heart of one who is highly elevated and grave is compared to gold. If one's heart is soft and gentle, his heart is compared to a cotton swab. When there is an ecstatic sensation within the mind, the golden heart or grave heart is not agitated, but the soft heart immediately becomes agitated (page 269).”

Gambhira (deep) vs. Uttana (shallow) Srila Rupa Gosvami compares the karkasa heart to the deep ocean, the komal heart to a shallow puddle. The ocean can hide great mountains underneath its waters, but a shallow puddle cannot hide even a tiny pebble. Similarly, a karkasa devotee is deep like the ocean (gambhira) and can thus conceal the most powerful vyabhicari-bhavas; but even the smallest emotion visibly agitates a komal devotee, whose heart is shallow like a puddle (uttana).

Mahistha (big) vs. Ksodistha (tiny) “To offer another example, a grave, magnanimous heart is compared to a great city, and a soft heart to an insignificant cottage. There may be many lights, or even great elephants in the big city, but no one will take particular notice of them. But when such lights or elephants are seen near a small cottage, everyone can distinctly point them out (page 269).”

Various Dispositions of the Heart In Terms of Ability to be Moved by Emotion Previously, Srila Rupa Gosvami categorized the heart as karkasa or komal (“hard" or "soft") in terms of its ability to conceal emotion. Now, he will analyze the heart in terms of its ability to experience emotion. Emotions melt the heart. Consequently, Srila Rupa Gosvami compares them to heat. Various hearts have various melting points, and vyabhicari-bhavas can manifest different intensities of heat. A karkasa (hard) heart melts only in the intense heat of fire. A komal (soft) heart melts even in the sunlight.

"Hard" Hearts He uses three adjectives to illustrate the karkasa hearts: lightning, gold, and shellac. Lightning-Heart “The lightning bolt is very strong and never becomes soft. Similarly, the hearts of those who are engaged in severe austerities and penances do not become very easily softened (page 270).” No degree of emotion can move a person with this disposition, just as no intensity of fire can melt a lightning bolt. Gold-Heart “The golden heart becomes melted at a high temperature. . . (page 270)” Unlike the thunderbolt, gold can melt, but only in a very hot fire. Similarly, only extremely intense emotions can move a person with this disposition. 171

Shellac-Heart “The shellac heart is very easily melted in slight temperature (page 270).” Even a little fire will melt shellac. Similarly, a strong emotion can move a person with this disposition.

"Soft" Hearts “A soft heart is compared to honey, to butter and to nectar. And the condition of the mind is compared to sunshine. As honey and butter become melted in even slight sunshine, softhearted persons become easily melted. Nectar, however, is by nature always liquid. And the hearts of those who are in pure ecstatic love with Krsna are by nature always liquefied, just like nectar (page 270).” The hearts of pure devotees may posses differing dispositions towards different vyabhicaribhavas. “A pure devotee of Krsna is always specifically qualified with nectarean qualifications and sometimes with the qualifications of butter and honey (page 270).” 17 If the emotion from a very powerful vyabhicari-bhava is extremely strong it will melt any heart, regardless of its hardness. “On the whole, the heart in any of the different conditions mentioned above can be melted under certain circumstances, just as a hard diamond is sometimes melted by a combination of certain chemicals (page 270).” Srila Rupa Gosvami cites Dana-keli Kaumudi as evidence for this.

17

A pure devotee can possess all these varities of internal dispositions, depending on the circumstances.

172

Southern Ocean Fifth Wave Sthayi-Bhava

Chapters 32 - 34

173

Chapter 32

Symptoms of Continuous Ecstasy BRS 2.5.1 - 44

One relishes rasa when various emotional components heighten and churn one's affection for Krsna. Affection for Krsna is the subject of Chapters 32 - 34 in The Nectar of Devotion. Sthayi-bhava denotes one's permanent mood of affection for Krsna. 1 Therefore, Srila Prabhupada translates sthayi-bhava as "permanent," or "continuous ecstasy."

Comment [VKD1]: Page: 2 This opening section I found to be very complex and difficult to understand clearly. It has been changed extensively.

King of Bhavas Sthayi-bhava is the king of bhavas, for two reasons: (1) it is the most essential element of rasa, and (2) all other emotions are under its dominion.

Most Essential Element of Rasa One's mood of affection for Krsna is the permanent foundation of one's heart, and is therefore the most important element of rasa. To explain this we offer the following analogy: Rasa consists of an interaction among five bhavas. Similarly, the ocean consists of an interaction between sea-water, wind, waves, tides, etc. Sthayi-bhava is comparable to the sea-water, and the other four bhavas are comparable to wind, waves, tides, etc. All these elements are essential parts of the ocean — without waves the ocean seems incomplete, and without the winds and tides there can be no waves. Nonetheless, the sea-water is by far the most important element of the ocean, because it is the permanent foundation upon which the other elements interact. Similarly, sthayi-bhava is the permanent foundation upon which the other bhavas interact and is therefore the most essential element of rasa.

Dominator of All Other Emotions Sthayi-bhava is the king, and all other emotions of rasa are dominated by it. Sthayibhava subdues and puts them under its dominion. In a kingdom, all the subjects cooperatively serve the king. Similarly, all the emotions of rasa cooperate to enhance the sthayi-bhava.

1

T hus sthäyé-bhäva and rati are synonymous.

174

Srila Prabhupada's Summary Srila Prabhupada summarizes all this: “The continuous ecstasy of love can remain like a powerful king, subduing all temporary manifestations of love as well as any opposing elements of anger (page 271).” 2

Two Varieties of Sthayi-Bhava Sthäyé-Bhäva Mukhya-Rati Neutral Servitude Friendship Parental Conjugal

Gauëa-Rati Laughter Astonishment Chivalry Lamentation Anger Fear Dread

Sthayi-bhava is of two varieties: (1) mukhyarati — direct, and (2) gauna-rati — indirect. Srila Prabhupada mentions this, “It can be exhibited directly or indirectly, and thus ecstatic love can be described as direct or indirect (page 271).”

Since rati is synonymous with bhava we can understand that neither variety of sthayi-bhava can manifest until the devotee attains the platform of bhava. Therefore, Srila Prabhupada says, “These symptoms of ecstatic love are possible only when one is fully situated in a transcendental position (page 271).”

Mukhya-Rati Mukhya-rati exhibits two natures: (1) svartha — self-nourishing," and (2) prarartha — nourishment-giving. Srila Prabhupada says, “Direct ecstatic love can be divided into two groups - namely, selfish and selfless (page 271).” Svartha indicates one who works for his own interests. When one's permanent affection for Krsna is "svartha" it takes nourishment from other emotions. Prarartha indicates one who works in the interest of others. When one's permanent affection for Krsna is "prarartha" it gives nourishment to other emotions. This will become more clear in the next chapter. 3

2

3

"continuous ecstasy of l ove" — sthäyé-bhäva; "temporary m anifestations of l ove" — o ther bhävas, (vibhäva, etc.); "opposing el ements of an ger" — gauna-sthäyé-bhävas su ch as ghastliness, anger, chivalry, etc. (See page 7.) Thus Çrél a Prabhupäda sa ys, sthäyé-bhäva can remain l ike a pow erful ki ng, subduing all other bhävas and ind irect mellows (gauna-rati). The term "remain" summarizes the perm anency of sthäyébhäva. "Subduing. . ." summarizes the dominion of sthäyé-bhäva. See Waves of Devotion, page 8.

175

Neutrality — Suddha-Rati The first type of sthayi-bhava is suddha-rati, neutral affection. There are three subdivisions of neutral affection for Krsna: (1) samanya — general, (2) svaccha — transparent, and (3) santi — peaceful. “Neutrality can be further subdivided into general, transparent, and peaceful (page 271).” Anubhavas of Suddha-Rati Srila Prabhupada summarizes the anubhavas of suddha-rati: “It can be manifest sometimes in trembling of the body and changing of the color of the eyes (to red, white, etc.), although there is no symptom of any particular affection (page 271).”

Samanya-Rati — General Affection Samanya-rati occurs when one's affection for Krsna has not yet matured into a specific relationship. Srila Prabhupada explains, “An attraction for Krsna by the people in general or by children cannot take any specific or satisfactory position (page 271).” Examples “One old man was told by a young man, ‘Just see how this child — only three years old — is so jubilant! Simply by seeing Krsna he is running so swiftly, making a tumultuous sound. Just see!’ (page 271)” Due to the young age of the child, his affection has not yet matured into any specific sentiment. Srila Prabhupada thus comments, “This is an instance of neutral ecstatic love in the heart of a child, without any specific subdivision.” Another example is the young girls of Vraja. Their specific conjugal affection for Krsna cannot satisfactorily manifest before the age of maturity. In time they will grow up to become gopis, but before maturity their affection for Krsna is in no specific category; it is "general," samanya. 4

Svaccha-Rati — Transparent Affection Svaccha-rati occurs in a devotee who does not yet possess any specific affection for Krsna, but who sometimes reflects the affections of various devotees — like a transparent crystal reflecting the color of any object placed in its proximity. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Their symptoms are manifested transparently, just like jewels (page 272).”

4

B RS 2.5.9

176

Example “It is said that a great devotee brahmana would sometimes address the Supreme Personality of Godhead as master and sometimes joke with the Lord, using different kinds of familiar words. Sometimes he would protect the Lord with a filial affection, sometimes he would cry out to the Lord, addressing the Lord as his beloved, and sometimes he would meditate on the Lord as the Supersoul (page 272).”

Santa-Rati — Peaceful Affection Santa-rati occurs in those who are completely detached from sense gratification, but have no inclination for an active relationship with the Lord. In other words, santabhaktas are liberated personalists who lack the more advanced sentiment that, "Krsna is mine" — my master, my friend, my child, etc. Mamata-buddhi is the term for this sense of "Krsna is mine." 5 Examples Two examples of santa-bhaktas: The Four Kumaras, and brahma-nista devotees whose desire to see the Lord is awakened by the association of devotees. (See page 272).

Pure and Mixed Flavors Santa-bhaktas do not possess mamata-buddhi, but there are three groups of devotees who do: (1) dasya or priti — servants, (2) sakhya — friends, and (3) vatsalya — parents. 6 Srila Prabhupada says, “One group consists of devotees who are completely dependent on the merciful affection of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, another group consists of those who are dealing with Krsna on friendly terms, and the third group consists of those who are dealing with Krsna as His superiors, with parental affection (page 272).” Mamata-buddhi can be either kevala (unmixed, or "pure") or sankula (mixed). One finds "unmixed possessiveness" (kevala) in a devotee whose service mood is exclusively servitude, friendship, or parental affection. One finds "mixed possessiveness" (sankula) in a devotee whose service mood is a blend of servitude, friendship, or parental affection. For example, Uddhava's mood is sankula, servitude mixed with friendship.

5 6

Liter ally, mamata-buddhi means, "conception of mine-ness." Conjugal love also has mamatä-buddhi, but to such an intense degree that it is catego rized separately from däsya, sakhya, and vatsalya.

177

Servitorship — Dasya-Rati Srila Prabhupada describes dasya-rati (or prita-rati) in the section entitled "Subordinate Ecstatic Love." The essence of dasya-rati is a feeling of inferiority to Krsna, and therefore a sense of dependence upon His favor and kindness. The quotation from Mukunda-mala-stotra is a prayer for the kind favor of the Lord upon the dependent devotee, so that he may be able to remember the Lord's lotus feet at the time of death. This exemplifies the mood of dasya-rati (See page 273).

Friendship — Sakhya-Rati The main characteristic of sakhya-rati is a feeling of equality with the Lord, "He is one of us." This type of affection is therefore devoid of shyness; characterized by prankish, humorous behavior. Srila Rupa Gosvami gives two examples of these uninhibited sakhya dealings (see page 274).

Parenthood — Vatsalya-Rati The essence of vatsalya-rati is a sense of seniority or protective superiority to Krsna. Contrast dasya-rati with vatsalya-rati: In dasya the devotee is the object of Krsna's mercy. In vatsalya, Krsna is the object of the devotees' mercy. Indeed, those in vatsalya-rati always shower Krsna with their kind, affectionate favors. One finds vatsalya-rati in devotees who are Krsna's elders. Krsna derives bliss by honoring and worshipping these great souls. Srila Rupa Gosvami gives two examples of vatsalya-rati (see page 274).

Conjugal Love — Madhurya-Rati Next, Srila Rupa Gosvami describes priyata-rati, or madhurya-rati — conjugal love. He briefly describes its characteristics: “The Lord and the young gopis exhibit this in different ways — glancing, moving the eyebrows, speaking very sweet words and exchanging smiles (page 274).” The quotation from Govinda-vilasa is an example of madhurya-rati.

Comment [VKD2]: Page: 6 There are many confusing senates in this section which have been left undeveloped, how will people understand these if they are not expanded here?

178

Chapter 33

Indirect Expressions of Ecstatic Love BRS 2.5.54 - 80

The previous chapter described mukhya-rati (the five direct forms of affection). This chapter will describe gauna-rati (the seven indirect forms of affection).

Gauna-Rati The seven secondary emotions are not transcendental in and of themselves, because they are not inherently connected to krsna-rati (transcendental affection for Krsna). There is nothing intrinsicaly transcendental about laughter, astonishment, anger, etc. However, these emotions become transcendental when connected with a direct affection (mukhya-rati). For instance, laughter is not transcendental affection for Krsna, but when a cowherd boy jokes with Krsna the laughter becomes saturated in a transcendental mood of friendship. Another example, if a gopi begins joking with Krsna, their laughter is imbued with the mood of conjugal love. Thus the laughter indirectly attains the status of rati — transcendental affection. Laughter (hasya) by itself is only laughter (hasya), but when connected with sakhya-rati the laughter becomes "laughing ecstasy" (hasya-rati). The mukhya-rati transmits its quality of rati to the gauna emotion. Emotions such as laughter are therefore called indirect affection (gauna-rati).

An Example to Clarify Jiva Gosvami gives the following example: Sometimes people at a concert may say, "The stage is raising quite a noise!" In truth, the noise comes from the musicians on stage, not the stage itself. Being in such close contact with the musicians, however, the stage becomes indirectly imbued with noisiness. Similarly, emotions such as laughter become imbued with transcendental affection for Krsna when connected to one of the five mukhya-rati.

179

Distinction Between Mukhya-Rati, Gauna-Rati, & Vyabhicari-Bhava The five direct forms of affection for Krsna (mukhya-rati) are eternal, but the seven indirect affections (gauna-rati) appear and disappear in various situations. Although they sometimes disappear, the secondary affections leave a lasting impression (samskara) on the heart. Thus gaunaMukhya-rati -Permanent emotions rati does possess a degree of Gauna-rati -Temporary emotions permanency, and is therefore that leave permanent classified as sthayi-bhava, distinct impressions from vyabhicari-bhava — which Vyabhicari-bhava -Temporary emotions comes and goes without any trace (samskara).

Seven Types of Gauna-Rati 1. Hasya-rati — Laughter

5. Krodha-rati — Anger

2. Vismaya-rati — Astonishment 3. Utsaha-rati — Valorous Enthusiasm

6. Bhaya-rati — Fear 7. Jugupsa-rati — Disgust

4. Soka-rati — Lamentation After listing the seven gauna emotions, Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates them with examples from sastra (constituting Chapter 33 in The Nectar of Devotion), which clarify how gauna-rati is transcendentalized by contact with mukhya-rati. The first example is this chapter shows the friends of Srimati Radharani responding in great laughter to Krsna's joking words. This laughter is a result of their madhurya-rati, thus its connection to madhurya-rati promotes the laughter to hasyarati. Another example: Mother Yasoda said, “Krsna is now entrapped within the hoods of the Kaliya snake, and yet I am not tattered to pieces! (page 277)” This lamentation arises from her motherly love, thus its connection to vatsalya-rati promotes the lamentation to soka-rati.

Svartha and Parartha Understanding the relationship between gauna and mukhya-rati helps to clarify the idea of svartha (self-nourishing) and prarartha (nourishment-giving), presented in the previous chapter. When a mukhya-rati is svartha it draws nourishment from various emotions. When a mukhya-rati is prarartha it gives nourishment to other emotions. In the above

180

examples, the gopis madhurya-rasa was prarartha, nourishing the laughter; mother Yasoda's vatsalya-rati was also prarartha, nourishing the lamentation.

181

Chapter 34

The Nectar of Devotion BRS 2.5.81 - 132

Chapter 34, the last section in the Southern Ocean, describes additional points concerning sthayibhava.

Vibhava Vibhava is that which stimulates and awakens the sthayi-bhava, causing the devotee to relish a particular type of ecstatic loving affection for Krsna. Srila Prabhupada says, “The particular type of ecstatic loving sentiment that develops within the heart of a particular devotee is considered to be vibhava (page 279).”

Anubhava, Etc. When vibhava stimulates sthayi-bhava there are various effects called anubhava (such as dancing, moving the eyebrows, etc.). Sattvika (crying, standing of hairs, etc.) and vyabhicari-bhavas (fear, astonishment, etc.) are types of anubhavas. Srila Prabhupada says, “And the resultant manifestations such as moving of the eyebrows, fear, astonishment and smiling, which have been explained hereinbefore, are called anubhava (page 279).”

Experience of Rasa is Made Possible by Sthayi-Bhava Ordinary artisans of poetry and drama believe that one experiences rasa by listening to poetry or seeing drama. Srila Rupa Gosvami, however, says that affection for Krsna (krsna-rati, or sthayibhava) is the essential foundation required to experience genuine transcendental rasa. (See page 279).

Full Understanding of Rasa is Made Possible by Sthayi-Bhava Transcendental affection for Krsna is a manifestation of hladini-sakti — the Lord's own pleasure potency, which is inconceivable by nature. Consequently, rasa is inconceivable by logic and argument. Srila Prabhupada says, “No one, while remaining on the material platform, should discuss these different descriptions of bhava and anubhava by quoting different statements of transcendental literatures. Such manifestations are displays of the transcendental pleasure potency of the Lord. . . In the Mahabharata, Udyama-parva, it is warned that things which are inconceivable should not be subjected to arguments (page 279).” One may achieve some understanding by studying various scriptures, but, until one directly experiences it, rasa will remain largely theoretical. Direct experience of rasa can occur only after one achieves bhava-bhakti — characterized by decent of the Lord's pleasure potency into the heart (suddha-sattva visesatma). 7 At this stage, one leaves the material platform and develops sthayi-bhava.

7

Se e page

of this book.

182

Srila Prabhupada explains all this: “Actually, the transactions of the spiritual world are inconceivable to us in our present state of life. Great liberated souls like Rupa Gosvami and others have tried to give us some hints of transcendental activities in the spiritual world, but on the whole these transactions will remain inconceivable to us at the present moment. Understanding the exchanges of transcendental loving service with Krsna is possible only when one is actually in touch with the pleasure potency of the Supreme Lord (page 279).”

Two Types of Rasa From Two Types of Sthayi-Bhava Rasa is the relishing of one's heightened rati. Since there are two types of rati (mukhya and gauna), there are also two types of rasa: mukhya (direct) and gauna (indirect). Srila Prabhupada thus states, "Transcendental pleasure derived from devotional service can be divided into two groups: direct devotional service and indirect devotional service (page 280)." One relishes mukhya-rasa when a mukhya-rati is stimulated. One relishes gauna-rasa when a gauna-rati is stimulated.

Colors and Predominating Deities of the 12 Sthayi-Bhavas

Neutrality Servitude Friendship Parenthood Conjugal Laughter Astonishment Chivalry Tragedy Anger Fear Ghastliness

8 9

Color

Deity

sveta-white citramulticolored aruna-reddish brown sona-deep red syamablaksih blue pandarawhite-yellow pingala-yellow gauraoff-whitish dhumrasmoky raktablood red kala-black Nila-blue

Kapila Madhava Upendra Nrsimha Nanda-Nandana Balarama Kurma Kalki Ramacandra Parasurama

Srila Rupa Gosvami associates each sthayi-bhava with a particular color. “Devotional service can therefore be divided into twelve types, each of which has a different color (page 280).” Jiva Gosvami says the association of sthayibhava with different colors is similar to the poets association of various qualities with different colors. 8 Each sthayi-bhava has a particular presiding Deity. Srila Prabhupada explains, “The twelve different kinds of transcendental humors are controlled by different incarnations of God, such as Kapila, Madhava, Upendra, Nrsimha, Nanda-nandana, Balarama, Kurma, Kalki, Raghava, Bhargava, Varaha and Matsya (page 280)” 9

Varaha Matsya

The classic example is white representing the "good guy" and black representing the "bad guy." Jéva Gosvämé says that these 12 forms of Godhead are Predominating Deities (adhiñöhätré devatä) of the 12 rasas, just as the mood is the predominating deity of the mind. Mukunda däsa, however, describes the 12 De ities as personified forms of the 12 rasas. He cites SB 10.13.53 to illustrate what he means by "personified forms." Viçvanätha Ca kravarté Öhäkura allo ws th at it m ay be agreeable fo r the 12 rasas to ha ve personified forms, since hlädiné-çakti has a personified form (Çré Rädhä).

183

Five Symptoms of Relishing Sthayi-Bhava There are five symptoms of relishing sthayi-bhava: (1) purti — fulfilment, (2) vikasa — manifestation, (3) vistara — expansion, (4) viksepa — dispersion, and (5) ksobha — agitation, Srila Prabhupada states, “Sustenance, manifestation, expansion, reflection, and lamentation are the five visible symptoms in exchanges of ecstatic love (page 280).” Different sthayi-bhavas manifest different symptoms when relished. One can understand a devotee's sthayi-bhava by observing which of the five symptoms he manifests when relishing transcendental pleasure. For example, purti (sustained sense of fulfilment) is a symptom of relishing suddha-rasa (neutral affection). Srila Prabhupada explains, “In the devotional service of neutrality there is sustenance. . . in angry devotional service there is lamentation, and so on (page 280).”

Who is Qualified to Understand Rasa Rasa-sastra lists different persons according to their capability to understand rasa. Only qualified persons can understand how secondary rasas like tragedy (karuna) and fear (bhayanaka) are composed of intense spiritual bliss, although externally appearing distressful. Srila Prabhupada says, “An apparently pitiable condition in devotional service may appear distressing to the inexperienced student, but the feelings of the devotee in this pitiable condition are considered to be ecstatic by expert devotees (page 280).” To explain this, Srila Rupa Gosvami cites the Ramayana, using very clear and simple logic, “All of these subjects in the Ramayana seem very pitiable, and they may appear very distressing to the reciter, but actually they are not. Otherwise, why would Hanuman, the great devotee of Lord Ramacandra, read daily about the activities of Lord Ramacandra, as described in the Ramayana itself? (page 281)” If the "tragedies" of the Lord's pastimes were truly distressing, devotees would not desire to repeatedly hear about them. Since devotees do want to hear these pastimes again and again they must not be sources of pain but sources of joy. Everything in devotional service is blissful, regardless of whether it externally appears "happy" or "sad." “The fact is that in any of the above-mentioned twelve transcendental humors of devotional service, everything is transcendentally pleasing (page 281).”

Those Who Are Disqualified “Srila Rupa Gosvami mourns in this connection for persons who are in the fire of false renunciation, the dry speculative habit, and who neglect devotional service. Persons who are attached to the ritualistic ceremonies recommended in the Vedas and to the impersonal Brahman cannot relish the transcendental pleasure of devotional service (page 281).”

Guarding the Nectar of Devotion Srila Rupa Gosvami further warns that those who are eligible for tasting bhakti-rasa should carefully keep it hidden from those who are unqualified or antagonistic to devotional service. “Srila Rupa Gosvami advises, therefore, that devotees who have already tasted the nectar of devotion be very careful to protect devotional service from such dry speculators, formal ritualistic elevationists and impersonal salvationists. Devotees should protect their valuable jewel of spiritual love from the clutches of thieves and burglars (page 281).”

184

Two Important Qualifications The chapter ends with two important points about the qualification to understand and relish rasa: (1) Bhakti-rasa is incomprehensible to non-devotees, “Only persons who have dedicated their lives unto the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead can relish the real nectar of devotion (page 281).” (2) Only in bhava-bhakti can one actually relish rasa. “When one transcends the status of ecstatic love and thus becomes situated on the highest platform of pure goodness, one is understood to have cleansed the heart of all material contamination. In that pure stage of life, one can taste this nectar, and this tasting capacity is technically called rasa, or transcendental mood (page 281).” [Emphasis added].

185

Western Ocean First Wave Santa-Rasa

Chapter 35

186

Chapter 35

Neutral Love of God BRS 3.1.1 - 47

Maìgalacarana To inaugurate the Western Ocean of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, Srila Rupa Gosvami offers a mangalacarana. As previously, Sri Rupa Gosvami uses the word sanatana to indicate: (1) Krsna — the Eternal Lord, and/or (2) Sanatana Gosvami, his spiritual master. By addressing this prayer to "Sanatana," Sri Rupa Gosvami simultaneously seeks the blessings of both Krsna and his spiritual master. Srila Prabhupada translates the maìgalacarana: “Sri Rupa Gosvami offers his respectful prayers to the eternal Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is always so beautiful and for whom the pure devotees are always engaged in loving transcendental service (pg. 285).” It can also be translated: "I offer my respectful prayers unto Sanatana Gosvami, whose devotion for the Supreme Lord is beautifully resplendent, and who has great love for the Vaisnavas." 1 Still another interpretation describes Sanatana as, "He who bears the extremely heavy weight of thinking about the material and spiritual welfare of the author, who is ignorant." Sri Rupa Gosvami describes himself as helpless, ignorant, and utterly dependant upon the support and protection of Sanatana.

Overview of the Western Ocean The Southern Ocean described five elements of rasa: vibhava, anubhava, sattvika-bhava, vyabhicari-bhava, and sthayi-bhava. In the section on Southern Ocean sthayi-bhava, Sri Rupa Gosvami introduced five direct Wave 1: Vibhäva moods of affection for Krsna: santa, dasya, sakhya, Western Ocean Wave 2: Wave 1:Çänta-rasa vatasla, and madhura. Anuhäva The Western Ocean has five waves. The First Wave describes the vibhava, anubhava, sattvika-bhava, and vyabhicari-bhava that heighten santa-rati to santarasa. The Second Wave does the same for dasya-rasa. The Third Wave for sakhya-rasa. The Fourth Wave for vatsalya-rasa. The Fifth Wave, madhurya-rasa.

Wave 3: Sättvika-bhäva Wave 4: Vyabhicäré-bhäva Wave 5: Sthäyé-bhäva

Vibhäva Anuhäva Sättvika-bhäva Vyabhicäré-bhäva Sthäyé-bhäva

1) Çänta-rati 2) Däsya-rati 3) Sakhya-rati 4) Valtsala-rati 5) Madhura-rati

SANTA-RASA When one can maintain a transcendental position of neutrality, or indifference to external sense objects, one becomes qualified to achieve love of Godhead at the stage of neutrality (santa-rasa). Srila Prabhupada explains, “When one is actually able to maintain the transcendental position, his stage is called neutrality in devotional service (pg. 285).”

1

B RS 3.1.1

187

There are two types of souls in the transcendental position. Both are free from material desires, but one is inclined to appreciate the impersonal Absolute, while the other is inclined to appreciate the personal Absolute. Impersonalist “Some great sages have attained this neutral position by practicing austerity, penance and meditation to control the senses. Such sages are generally called mystic yogis, and in most cases they are inclined to appreciate the spiritual pleasure of the impersonal feature of the Absolute Truth (pg. 285).” Personalist A personalist is far more fortunate than the impersonalist, because he is inclined to appreciate the Lord's form. The happiness derived from direct perception of the Lord's form is far greater than the happiness derived from impersonal Brahman; because without the Lord's form there is no possibility of relishing rasa. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Actually the transcendental pleasure derived in association with the Supreme Person is far greater that the pleasure derived from impersonal Brahman realization, because of the direct meeting with the eternal form of the Lord (pg. 285).” Although neutral devotees may be qualified to achieve darsana of the Lord's form, they are not qualified to experience His pastimes. Until one has dasya-bhava, one cannot achieve this qualification.

Vibhava Visaya-Alambana Krsna as a Stimulus for Neutral Devotion Srila Rupa Gosvami mentions two ways that the Lord stimulates neutral affection: (1) the fourarmed form of Visnu, and (2) the transcendental qualities of Visnu. Form of Visnu “For those great sages situated in the position of transcendental neutrality, the beginning should be to take shelter of Lord Visnu, the four-handed eternal form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead (pg. 286).” Srila Prabhupada confirms this by citing three Vedic references. 2 Qualities of Visnu “He is also appreciated as being completely peaceful, completely controlled and pure, merciful to the devotees and untouched by any material condition.”

2

Bhagavada-Gétä 18.54 (brahma-bhüta prasannätmä), the Åg Veda Bhägavatam 7.5.31 (na te viduù svärtha gatià hi viñnuà.)

(oà tad viñnu parama), and Çrém ad188

Asraya-Alambana The Devotee as a Stimulus for Neutral Devotion Srila Rupa Gosvami mentions two types of devotees who stimulate santa-bhakti: (1) atmaramas — self-realized souls, and (2) tapasvis — those who undergo penance and austerities. Atmaramas and tapasvis are usually impersonalists, but they can develop faith in visnubhakti if they are fortunate enough to contact a pure devotee. This faith promotes them from impersonalism to the status of neutral devotees. Srila Prabhupada explains, “After Brahman realization, when a liberated soul comes in contact with a pure devotee of Lord Krsna and submissively accepts the teachings of Lord Krsna without misinterpretation, he becomes situated in this neutral stage of devotional service (pg. 287).” Atmaramas The best atmaramas are the Four Kumaras. Srila Rupa Gosvami describes their appearance and devotional mood. Their Form: They appear like naked young children, four or five years old, with fair complexions and bright effulgences. These four brothers usually stay together. Their Devotional Mood: Srila Rupa Gosvami includes a statement by the Four Kumara's that indicates their mood of devotion: “O Lord Mukunda. . . only so long as one does not happen to see your eternal form of bliss and knowledge. . . can the impersonal feature of the Absolute Truth, known as Brahman, be very pleasing to a saintly person (pg. 287).” Tapasvis A tapasvi takes up devotional service because he knows liberation can be obtained only through bhakti. Srila Prabhupada says, “A saintly person is one who understands fully that simply by discharging devotional service he can become confident of liberation (pg. 287 - 288).” Srila Rupa Gosvami does not mention the form of a tapasvi because there is no foremost tapasvi to describe. Devotional Mood: “A saintly person thinks like this: ‘When shall I be able to live alone in the caves of the mountains? When shall I be dressed simply with undergarments? When shall I be satisfied simply by eating a little fruit and vegetables? When will it be possible for me to think always of the lotus feet of Mukunda, who is the source of the Brahman effulgence? When, in such a spiritual condition of life, shall I fully understand my days and nights to be insignificant moments in eternal time?’ (pg. 288)”

Uddipana Objects That Impel Neutral Devotion There are two subdivisions of uddipana: (1) asadharan — "unique," and (2) sadharana — "shared." Unique uddipanas are objects that impel devotees of one specific rasa. Shared uddipanas (sadharana) are objects that impel devotees of many different rasas. Asadharana Uddipana — Unique Impetuses Srila Rupa Gosvami lists the impetuses unique to santa-rasa: “The impulse of a saintly person is to be engaged in the study of the Vedas, especially the Upanisadic portions, to live always in a place where there is no disturbance from the common people, to think always of the eternal 189

form of Krsna, to be ready to consider and understand the Absolute Truth, to be always prominent in exhibiting knowledge, to see the Supreme Lord in His universal form (visva-rupa), to associate always with learned devotees and to discuss the conclusion of the Vedas with similarly elevated persons (pg. 288).” Example of "Hearing the Upanisads" Hearing the Upanisads in Lord Brahma's assembly impelled the neutral affection of learned yogis, causing them to relish santa-rasa. (See pg. 288.) Sadharana Uddipana — Shared Impetuses Srila Rupa Gosvami lists the impetuses of santa-rasa that may impel devotees of other rasas as well: “. . .smelling the tulasi offered at the lotus feet of the Lord, by hearing the sound of His conchshell, by seeing a sanctified place in some mountain or hill, by observing a forest like the ones in Vrndavana, by going to a place of pilgrimage, by visiting the course of the Ganges River, by being victorious over the dictations of bodily demands (ie. eating, sleeping, mating and defending), by understanding the devastation of eternal time and by constantly associating with devotees engaged in Krsna consciousness (pgs. 288 - 289).” Example of Smelling Tulasi Sri Rupa Gosvami quotes the Third Canto, describing how the Four Kumaras achieved and relished santa-rasa by smelling the aroma of tulasi leaves mixed with saffron and offered to Lord Visnu's lotus feet.

Anubhava Asadharan-Anubhava Manifestations of Ecstasy Unique to Santa-Rasa Srila Rupa Gosvami lists the anubhavas unique to santa-rasa: “. . .They concentrate their eyesight on the tip of the nose, and they behave just like an avadhuta... Another symptom is that such persons are very careful to step forward when giving speeches. When they speak, they join together the forefinger and the thumb...” The list continues to the paragraph's end, on page 289. Example of Concentrating Eyesight on Tip of Nose “This great sage is concentrating his eyesight on the tip of his nose, and from this it appears that he has already realized the eternal form of the Lord within himself (pg. 289).”

Sadharana-Anubhava Manifestations of Ecstasy Shared with Other Rasas Srila Rupa Gosvami lists the anubhavas that santa shares with other rasas: “Sometimes a devotee in santa-rasa yawns, stretches his limbs, instructs on devotional service, offers respectful obeisances unto the form of the Lord, offers nice prayers to the Lord and has a desire to give direct service with his body. These are some of the common symptoms [sadharana-anubhava] of the devotee who is situated in neutrality (pg. 290).”

190

Example of Yawning “My dear mystic, I think that within your heart there is some ecstatic devotional love which is causing you to yawn (pg. 290).”

Sattvika-Bhava “It is sometimes found that a devotee in the santa-rasa falls down on the ground, his hairs stand up on his body, and he trembles all over. In this way, different symptoms of ecstatic trance are exhibited automatically by such devotees (pg. 290).” Example of Hairs Standing Up “. . .when Lord Krsna was blowing His conchshell known as Pancajanya, many great sages who were living in the caves of the mountains immediately reacted, being awakened from their trance of meditation. They immediately saw that the hairs of their bodies were standing (pg. 290).”

Vyabhicari-Bhava “Sometimes devotees in santa-rasa become stunned, 3 peaceful, jubilant, deliberate, reflective, anxious, dexterous and argumentative. These symptoms indicate continuous ecstasy, or established emotion 4 (pg. 290).” Example of Nirveda — Self-Disparagement “Once a great sage was lamenting that the Supreme Lord Krsna was living in Dvaraka but that he was unable to take advantage of seeing Him. After thinking this, the sage immediately became stunned (pg. 290).”

Sthayi-Bhava Obviously, a conditioned soul has not developed his sthayi-bhava; and when one becomes a liberated soul — still it is not developed. If a liberated soul is fortunate, the Lord arranges to uproot the impersonal impressions in his heart (jnana-samskara) and gradually the sthayi-bhava known as santa-rati manifests. This promotes him from impersonalism to personalism. If he is extremely fortunate, this Brahman-realized personalist can achieve darsana of the Lord's form. When the Lord's form (vibhava) stimulates his santa-rati, he can for the first time experience santa-rasa — which is infinitely more pleasurable than any impersonal realization. An Example of Elevation to Sthayi-Bhava and Santa-Rasa “My dear friend, do you think that after I perfect the eightfold yoga performance I shall be able to see the eternal form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead? (pg. 290)” This illustrates the mood of a devotee who has achieved santa-rati. He desires to achieve darsana of the Lord's form and thus make further advancement to santa-rasa. 3 4

"Stunned" refers t o t he vyabhicäri-bhäva called nirveda (self-disparagem ent), not to the sättvika-bhäva called stambha. "Established emotion" refers t o sthäyé-bhäva. The presence of these vyabhicäri-bhävas indicates that one' s sthäyébhäva is çänta-rati. 191

Two Types of Santa-Rasa There are two ways that a Brahman-realized devotee may finally achieve the Lord's darsana: indirectly, or directly. Two types of santa-rasa are thus produced: (1)paroksa — indirect, and (2) saksaka — direct.

Indirect Santa-Rasa Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of indirect (paroksa) santa-rasa: When some yogis saw the bodily effulgence of Krsna and Balarama they almost forgot the pleasure derived from impersonal Brahman realization. (See pg. 291) Their santa-rasa was not evoked directly by the Lord's form, but indirectly — by the effulgence emanating from the Lord's form. Thus the rasa they experience is indirect (paroksa).

Direct Santa-Rasa “When a great mystic was once awakened from his meditative trance by hearing the vibration of Krsna's Pancajanya conchshell, the mystic became overpowered — so much so, in fact, that he began to bash his head on the ground, and with eyes full of tears of ecstatic love, he violated all the rules and regulations of his yoga performances. Thus he at once neglected the process of Brahman realization (pg. 291).” The sage snapped out of his impersonal meditation when he heard the sound of Krsna's conchshell. Opening his eyes, he directly beheld the beautiful blackish color of the Lord's form, and impersonalism immediately became distasteful. Lamenting his waste of time, he harshly disregarded all impersonalist yoga and became a santa-bhakta of the Lord. 5

Grades of Mercy An impersonalist who gets the Lord's mercy achieves santa-rati and indirectly perceives the Lord's form via the Brahman effulgence that emanates from it. The rasa he derives from this indirect stimulus is also indirect, and causes him to "almost forget" his impersonalism. An impersonalist who gets more substantial mercy achieves santa-rati and directly perceives the Lord's form. As a result, he tastes full santa-rasa — which causes him to harshly reject His previous impersonalism. Srila Rupa Gosvami next describes what can happen if an impersonalist receives the highest mercy of the Lord.

The Highest Mercy Upon Impersonalists If the Lord is most merciful, an impersonalist can be promoted to the highest realization: madhurya-rasa. Srila Rupa Gosvami cites the wonderful example of Bilvamaìgala Thakura, who wrote in his Krsna-karnamrta, “Let the impersonalists be engaged in the process of transcendental realization by worshiping the impersonal Brahman. Although I was also initiated into that path of Brahman realization, I have now become misled by a naughty boy — one who is very cunning, who is very much attached to the gopis and who has made me His maidservant. So I have now forgotten the process of Brahman realization (pg. 291).”

5

B RS 3.1.42

192

One receives a different degree of mercy depending on the manifestation of Krsna who bestows it. If Visnu bestows His mercy, one may achieve a certain level of appreciation for the Lord's form in Vaikuntha. Bilvamaìgala Thakura, however, received mercy from Vrajendranandana Krsna and was thus able to attain Vraja Prema. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Bilvamaìgala Thakura was first spiritually initiated for impersonal realization of the Absolute Truth, but later on, by his association with Krsna in Vrndavana, he became an experienced devotee (pg. 291).”

Is Neutral Devotion a Genuine Rasa? “According to some authorities, this condition [santa] cannot be accepted as one of the transcendental humors, or rasas (pg. 291).” To experience rasa, various stimuli must heighten one's rati. Santa-rati, however, is indifferent and neutral towards external stimulation. Because of this, some authorities say that santa-rati cannot be stimulated into genuine rasa. Vaisnava scholars generally disagree. They point out that santa-rati is neutral only towards material stimulation. Therefore, santa-rati can be stimulated by the Lord's transcendental form and be heightened to genuine rasa. Consequently, Vaisnavas generally accept santa as a genuine rasa, or at least as the preliminary requirement for genuine rasa. Santa as a Prerequisite for Rasa The extent one is inclined towards sense gratification is the extent one will be disinclined towards devotional service (bhakti-rasa). Therefore santa (indifference and neutrality towards material desires) is a prerequisite for rasa. Srila Prabhupada says, “Even if one does not accept [santa] as a transcendental humor, one must still accept it as the beginning position of devotional service (pg. 291).” When one achieves indifference to material desires, his mind becomes free to exhibit its original tendency towards ananda-svarupa-brahman — the bliss relished by active devotional service. Thus santa-rasa can lead the devotee to servitude (dasya-rasa), which all authorities accept as a genuine rasa. Srila Prabhupada mentions this: “However, if one is not further raised to the platform of actual service to the Lord, he is not considered to be on the platform of transcendental mellow (pgs. 291 - 292).”

Sastric Confirmation of These Points To recapitulate: (1) Santa is a genuine rasa, called santa-rasa. (2) Even if it is not accepted as a genuine rasa, it is the beginning position of transcendental rasa. (3) Achieving santa (neutrality towards material desires) leads one towards the stage of actual service. Lord Krsna confirms all these points in the Eleventh Canto: “The state of being established in My personal form is called santa-rasa, and without being situated in this position, no one can advance to actual pure devotional service (pg. 292).”

193

Western Ocean Second Wave Dasya-Rasa

Chapters 36 - 40

194

Chapter 36

Transcendental Affection (Servitude) BRS 3.2.1 - 56

Three Different Authorities Srila Rupa Gosvami begins his description of dasya-rasa by quoting three personalities who define it in different ways. Sridhara Svami According to him, when a person in santa-rati develops strong affection (priti) for the Lord he becomes inclined towards actual service (dasya-rasa). He does not consider santa a perfectional stage. His says, however, that the element of affection transforms santa into the perfectional stage, dasya-rasa. Srila Prabhupada mentions this: “The transcendental mellow of affection has been accepted by authorities like Sridhara Svami. as a perfectional stage of devotion. It is just above the humor of neutrality and is a requisite for the development of the serving humor (pg. 293).” Nama-Kaumudi This book defines priti (affection) as the sthayi-bhava of dasya-rasa. Srila Prabhupada says, “In literature such as Nama-kaumudi this state of existence is accepted as continuous affection for or attraction to Krsna (pg. 293).” Sudeva Gosvami 1 He says that even santa-rasa possesses priti. As Srila Prabhupada says, he “considers this stage of affection to be in the neutral stage. . . (pg. 293).”

Resolving Apparent Differences Sridhara Svami says that priti comes between santa and dasya. Nama-kaumudi says priti comes at dasya. Sudeva Gosvami says it is in santa. One may resolve these apparent differences of opinion by noting that priti (affection for Krsna) is in every mellow, but is not strong enough to make its presence felt until one achieves dasya. Consequently, even though all rasas contain priti, Srila Rupa Gosvami singles out servitude as priti-rasa because it is the first stage in which one feels the effect of priti (active service). Srila Prabhupada summarizes this: “. . .but in any case this affection is relished by the devotees in different transcendental tastes, and therefore the general name for this state is affection, or pure affection for Krsna (page 293).”

1

The Nectar of Devotion refers to this personality as "Çukadeva Gosvämé." BRS 3.2.3 lists him as Sudeva-Gosvämé. The transcriber misunderstood Çréla Prabhupäda. 195

Two Moods of Dasya Dasya-rasa has two divisions: (1) sambhrama-priti — servitude with awe and reverence, and (2) gaurava-priti — servitude in a more intimate mood, as a son or person similarly dependant on Krsna.

SAMBHRAMA-PRITI (Reverential Servitude) “Devotees engaged in servitude are attached to Krsna in the affection of reverence (page 293).”

Vibhava Visaya-Alambana Krsna as a Stimulus for Reverential Servitude Srila Rupa Gosvami describes how Krsna's form and qualities stimulate reverential servitude. Krsna's Form “The inhabitants of Vrndavana used to say, ‘Krsna is always manifest before us with a complexion like a blackish cloud. He holds His wonderful flute in His lotus hands. He is dressed in yellow silks and bedecked with peacock feather on His head...’ (pg. 293).” Sometimes Visnu's form can also be a stimulus for sambhrama-priti-rasa. But Daruka's statement in Lalita-madhava informs us that Krsna's form is a far more powerful stimulant. Qualities The qualities of Krsna that stimulate reverential servitude: “Another devotee once said, ‘This Supreme Personality of Godhead from whose bodily pores come millions of universes, permanently rising, who is the ocean of mercy, who is the owner of inconceivable energies...’ (page 294).”

Asraya-Alambana The Devotee as a Stimulus for Reverential Servitude The devotees who stimulate reverential servitude are called dasas, servants. They have the following character traits: Prasrita — they are humble, modest souls who always glance downward and bend over in repectful deference. Nirdesa vasa vartti — they are naturally inclined to engage their specific abilities in carrying out Krsna's orders. Visvasta bhakta — they are trustworthy and faithful. Vinamrta buddhi — they are always fully aware that Krsna is their master. 2

Four Types of Dasas 1.) Adhikrta dasa — demigods appointed to specific services in the material world. 2.) Asrita dasa — devotees who have taken shelter of the Lord's protection.

2

B RS 3.2.16

196

3.) Parisada dasa — intimate ministers who render various personal services. 4.) Anuga dasa — intimate followers of the Lord in Vraja and Dvaraka. Srila Prabhupada explains, “The devotees of the Lord in servitude are divided into four classes: appointed servants (such as Lord Brahma and Lord Siva, who are appointed to control the material modes of passion and ignorance), devotees in servitude who are protected by the Lord, devotees who are always associates and devotees who are simply following in the footsteps of the Lord (pg. 294).”

Adhikrta Dasa — Appointed Servants Adhikrta dasa are devotees whom Krsna appoints to serve as demigods. The conversation between Jambavati and Kalindi points out the various adhikrta-dasas. (See pg. 294.)

Asrita Dasa — Devotees Under the Lord's Protection "My dear Krsna, O pleasure of Vrndavana! Being afraid of this material existence, we have taken shelter of You, for You can completely protect us! We are well aware of your greatness. As such, we have given up our desire for liberation and have take shelter under Your lotus feet. Since we have heard about Your ever-increasing transcendental love, we have voluntarily engaged ourselves in Your transcendental service (pg. 295).” This quotation establishes three types of asrita dasa (devotees under the Lord's protection): 1. Sarangata — those who take shelter of the Lord's protection due to fear of material existence. ("Being afraid of this material existence, we have taken shelter of You, for You can completely protect us!") 2. Jnanicari — those who have realized Brahman, but give up the desire for moksa and take shelter of Krsna, knowing Him to be the origin of Brahman. ("We are well aware of your greatness. As such, we have given up our desire for liberation and have take shelter under Your lotus feet.") 3. Seva-nistha — those who simply love Krsna, and therefore have fixed desire to serve Him. ("Since we have heard about Your ever-increasing transcendental love, we have voluntarily engaged ourselves in Your transcendental service.")

Sarangata — Those Who Take Shelter out of Fear A sarangata servant is (1) afraid of material existence, and (2) is convinced that the Lord can protect Him. Srila Rupa Gosvami gives two examples of sarangata. The first is a prayer of Kaliyaserpent, whose fear of imminent death caused him to surrender to the Lord. The second is from Aparadha-bhanjana: “My dear Lord, I am ashamed to admit before You that I have carried out the orders of my masters named lust, anger, avarice, illusion and envy. Sometimes I have carried out their orders in a way most abominable. Yet in spite of my serving them so faithfully, they are not satisfied, nor are they kind enough to give me relief from their service. They are not even ashamed of taking service from me in that way. My dear Lord, O head of the Yadu dynasty, now I have come to my senses, and I am therefore taking shelter of Your lotus feet. Please engage me in Your service (pg. 295 - 296).” 197

Jnanicari — Those Who Take Shelter Out of Knowledge A jnanicari servant: (1) is Brahman-realized, and (2) knows that the Lord is the origin of Brahman, and therefore renounces the desire for moksa and takes shelter of the Lord. As Srila Prabhupada says, "There are many instances in the various Vedic writings of persons who were aspiring after liberation by speculative knowledge but gave up this process in order to take complete shelter under the lotus feet of Krsna (pg. 296)." Srila Rupa Gosvami gives two examples. The first is sages of Naimisaranya, who gave up their impersonal realization by hearing knowledge about the glories of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The second example is from Padyavali, in which a former impersonalist describes his attachment to Krsna. (See page 296.)

Seva-Nistha — Those Who Take Shelter Out of Love A sarangata was engaged in sense gratification, a jnanicari was engaged in processes of liberation, but a seva-nistha is attached to the Lord's service right from the beginning. Srila Prabhupada says, “Those who are from the very beginning of their self-realization attached to devotional service are called seva-nistha (pg. 296).” Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example: “My dear Lord, Your transcendental qualities attract even the liberated souls and carry them to the assembly of devotees where your glories are constantly chanted... And, observing all your transcendental qualities, I have also become attracted and have decided to dedicate my life to Your loving service (pg. 296).” Seeing how the Lord attracts even the liberated souls, the seva-nistha immediately dedicates his life to the Lord's service. The principal seva-nisthas: “Lord Siva, King Indra, King Bahulasva, King Iksvaku, Srutadeva and Pundarika (pg. 296).” 3

Parisada Dasa — Personal Servants The parisada dasa are the Lord's ministers, who also perform intimate personal services appropriate to their particular situation, such as carrying messages, fanning the Lord, etc.

Principal Parisada Dasas “In the city of Dvaraka the following devotees are known as Krsna's close associates: Uddhava, Daruka, Satyaki, Srutadeva, 4 Satrujit, Nanda, Upananda and Bhadra.” And, “Among the Kuru dynasty, Bhisma, Maharaja Pariksit and Vidura are also known as close associates of Lord Krsna (pg. 297).”

3

4

Çréla Rüpa Gosväm é lists Lord Çiva as both adhikåta (an appoi nted servant ) and sevä-niñöha (one who t akes shelter of the Lord's protection out of love). One may understood this as follows: Out of love for Kåñna, Çiva takes shelter of His protection and surrenders to His service (seva-niñöha). The specific service which Kåñna awards Çiva is that of an appointed demigod (adhikåta). Çréla Rüpa Gosväm é lists Çrutadeva as both seva-niñöha and pariñad. Thus he, l ike Ç iva, appears t o be in two categories. One m ay understand this as fol lows: Out of l ove for Kåñna, Çrutadeva takes shelter of Hi s protection and surrenders to His service (seva-niñöha). The specific service Kåñna awards hi m is that of a personal minister (pariñad). 198

Their Form “All the associates of Lord Krsna have lustrous bodily features, and their eyes are just like lotus flowers. They have sufficient power to defeat the strength of the demigods, and the specific feature of their persons is that they are always decorated with valuable ornaments (pg. 297).” Their Devotional Mood “My dear Lord, Your personal associates, headed by Uddhava, are always awaiting Your order by standing at the entrance gate of Dvaraka. They are mostly looking on with tears in their eyes, and in the enthusiasm of their service they are not afraid even of the devastating fire generated by Lord Siva. They are souls simply surrendered unto Your lotus feet (pg. 297).”

Uddhava, The Foremost Parisada Dasa His Form “His body is blackish like the color of the Yamuna River, and it is similarly as cool. He is always decorated with flower garlands first used by Lord Krsna... (pg. 297)” His Devotional Mood “Lord Sri Krsna, who is our master and worshipable Deity, the controller of Lord Siva and Lord Brahma, and the controller of the whole universe as well, accepts the controlling orders of Ugrasena, His grandfather. He is the proprietor of millions of universes, but still He begged a little land from the ocean. And although He is just like an ocean of wisdom, He sometimes consults me. He is so great and magnanimous, yet He is engaged in His different activities just like an ordinary person (pg. 297).”

Anuga Dasa — Intimate Followers The anuga dasa are the most intimate personal servants of the Lord.

Principal Anuga Dasas of Dvaraka They are, “Sucandra, Mandana, Stamba and Sutamba (pg. 298).” Their Form “They are dressed and ornamented like the other associates (pg. 298).” Their Devotional Mood “The specific services entrusted to the anuga dasas is varied. Mandana always bears the umbrella over the head of Lord Krsna. Sucandra is engaged in fanning with the white camara bunch of hair, and Sutamba is engaged in supplying betel nuts... (pg. 298).”

Principle Anuga Dasas of Vraja They are, “Raktaka, Patraka, Patri, Madhukantha, Madhuvrata, Rasala, Suvilasa, Premakanda, Marandaka, Ananda, Candrahasa, Payoda, Bakula, Rasada and Sarada (pg. 298).”

199

Their Form “...They always stay in Vrndavana, and their bodies are decorated with garlands of pearls and with bangles and bracelets of gold. Their colors are just like black bees and the golden moon, and they are dressed just to suit their particular special bodily features (pg. 298).” Their Devotional Mood “Their specific duties can be understood from a statement by Mother Yasoda, who said, ‘Bakula, please cleanse the yellowish dress of Krsna. Varika, you just flavor the bathing water with aguru scent. And Rasala, you just prepare the betel nuts. You can all see that Krsna is approaching. There is dust overhead, and the cows can be seen very distinctly.’ (pg. 298).”

Raktaka, The Foremost Anuga Dasa His Form “He wears yellow clothing, and his bodily color is just like newly grown grass.” His Devotional Mood Raktaka said, “Just hear me! Please place me so that I may always be engaged in the service of Lord Krsna, who has now become famous as the lifter of Govardhana Hill (pg. 298).”

Three Types of Parisada and Anuga The intimate servants of the Lord (parisada and anuga) have three mentalities: dhurya, dhira, and vira. Srila Prabhupada says, “According to expert analytical studies of the direct associates of the Lord, Srila Rupa Gosvami has divided these into three classes — namely dhurya, dhira and vira (page 299).”

Dhurya Dhurya are those who express love towards Krsna, towards the lovers of Krsna, and towards those who serve the lovers of Krsna. Raktaka epitomises this mentality: “Not only is Krsna my worshipable and servable Lord, but also the girl friends of Krsna, the gopis, are equally worshipable and servable by me. And not only the gopis, but anyone who is engaged in the service of the Lord is also worshipable and servable by me. I know that I must be very careful not to become overly proud that I am one of the servitors and devotees of the Lord (page 299).”

Dhira Dhira are those who do not have a specific service for the Lord, but are firmly situated in the shelter of a dear devotee. The son of Satyabhama's nurse exemplifies this. He achieved the Lord's mercy not exactly by executing service, but by being in the shelter of the Lord's dear devotee. 5

5

See pg. 299; also BRS 3.2.52

200

Vira Vira are those who do not take shelter of anyone besides Sri Krsna. A vira devotee once declared, “Lord Baladeva may be a great enemy of Pralambasura, but I have nothing to worry about from Him. And as far as Pradyumna is concerned, I have nothing to take from him, because he is simply a boy. Therefore I do not expect anything from anyone else. I simply expect the favorable glance of Krsna upon me, and so I am not even afraid of Satyabhama, who is so dear to Krsna (page 299).”

Grades of Servants As mentioned in Chapter 25, all of Krsna's servants come into three categories: sadhaka (neophyte), sadhana-siddha (perfect), and nitya-siddha (eternally perfect). Srila Prabhupada says, “Devotees attached to the transcendental loving service of the Lord may be described either as surrendered souls [asrita], as souls advanced in devotional knowledge [parisada], or as souls completely engaged in transcendental loving service [anuga]. Such devotees are called (respectively) neophyte, perfect and eternally perfect (page 300).”

201

Chapter 37

Impetuses for Krsna's Service BRS 3.2.57 - 103

Chapter 37 describes the vibhava-uddipana of sambhrama-priti-rasa, and is therefore titled, “Impetuses for Krsna's Service.”

Vibhava (continued) Asadharana-Uddipana Impetuses Unique to Reverential Servitude “The causeless mercy of Krsna, the dust of His lotus feet, His prasada and association with His devotees are some impetuses toward a devotee's engagement in transcendental loving service to the Lord (page 301).” Example of Causeless Mercy Bhismadeva said, “My dear Krpacarya, just see the wonderful causeless mercy of Lord Krsna! ...I have so many disqualifications, and yet the Lord is still so kind that He has come to see me at the last point of my life... He is so merciful that He has come to see an abominable person like me (page 301).”

Sadharana-Uddipana Impetuses That Also Stimulate Devotees of Other Rasas “Sometimes the vibration of Lord Krsna's flute, His bugling, His smiling, His footmarks on the ground, the transcendental fragrance of His body and the appearance of a new cloud in the sky also become impetuses for ecstatic love of Him (page 301).” Example of Flute “When Krsna was playing on His flute, Baladeva very anxiously declared, ‘Just see how, after hearing the transcendental sound of Krsna's flute, Indra, the King of heaven, is crying in his heavenly kingdom! And from his teardrops falling on the ground, Vrndavana appears to have become a celestial residence for the demigods.’”

Anubhava Asadharana-Anubhava Manifestations of Ecstasy Unique to Reverential Servitude “Ecstatic love for Krsna, which is known as anubhava, is symptomized by the following signs: one becomes engaged exclusively in the service of the Lord, being attentive to carry out the orders of the Lord faithfully; one becomes undisturbed and nonenvious in full transcendental loving service to the Lord; and one makes friendship with the devotees of the Lord who are situated in faithful service to Him (page 302).”

202

Example of Exclusive, Attentive Service While fanning Krsna, Daruka condemned his ecstatic tears, because they interfered with his service.

Sadharana-Anubhava Manifestations of Ecstasy Shared with Other Rasas Dancing (nrtyam) is one anubhava that sambhrama-priti-rasa shares with other rasas. Srila Rupa Gosvami gives two examples of dancing: the first is Srutadeva, who became so overwhelmed with the joy of seeing Krsna that he began dancing with both arms raised above his head. (See page 302). The next paragraph in The Nectar of Devotion gives the second example.

Sattvika-Bhava All eight sattvika-bhavas can manifest in reverential servitude. Srila Prabhupada mentions an example for tears (asru) and faltering voice (svarabheda): “...after surrendering everything unto the lotus feet of Vamanadeva, Bali Maharaja immediately caught hold of the lotus feet of the Lord and pressed them to his heart. Being overwhelmed with joy, he manifested all the symptoms of ecstatic love, with tears in his eyes and a faltering voice (page 302).”

Vyabhicari-Bhava Srila Rupa Gosvami lists 24 vyabhicari-bhavas appropriate for reverential servitude. One will find this list at the bottom of page 302 in The Nectar of Devotion.

Vyabhicari-Bhavas in Meeting and in Separation Some of the 24 vyabhicari-bhavas are appropriate when meeting with Krsna. Others are appropriate when in separation from Krsna. Srila Prabhupada explains, “When a devotee meets Krsna, there are symptoms of jubilation, pride and perseverance, and when he is feeling great separation from Krsna, the symptoms of ghastliness, disease and signs of death become prominent (page 303).” Examples of Jubilation in Meeting “...when Lord Krsna returned from the Battlefield of Kuruksetra to His home at Dvaraka, all the residents of Dvaraka began to talk with Him, as a child talks lovingly to his father after the father's return from foreign countries (page 303).” King Bahulasva (next paragraph in The Nectar of Devotion) is also an example of jubilation in meeting. Examples of Depression and Disparagement in Separation “My dear Lord, as the sun evaporates all the water on the ground by its scorching heat, so my mental state has dried away the luster of my face and body, due to separation from You (page 303).” This is an example of depression (visada). Indra said, “My dear sun-god, your sunshine is very glorious because it reaches unto the lotus feet of Lord Krsna, the master of the Yadu dynasty. I have thousands of eyes, but they have 203

proved to be useless because not even for a moment are they able to see the lotus feet of the Lord (page 303).” This is an example of self-disparagement (nirveda)

Sthayi-Bhava Sambhrama-priti-rati is the sthayi-bhava of reverential servitude. It has two components: (1) awareness of Krsna's supremacy, and (2) anxious eagerness to serve Him. 6 Awareness of Krsna's Supremacy causes the devotee to develop respectful humility, the main character trait of a reverential servant. Prabhuta-jnana is the Sanskrit term for this awareness that, "Krsna is my Lord and master." Anxious Eagerness to Serve Krsna causes one to think, "How shall I serve Krsna? How shall I utilize everything in His service?" These two elements combine to produce sambhrama-priti-rati, which mixed with the appropriate bhavas and heightens into relishable sambhrama-priti-rasa.

Examples of Sambhrama-Priti-Rati The first example illustrates both principles of sambhrama-priti-rati — awareness of Krsna's supremacy, and eagerness to see Him and serve Him. “Akrura says, ‘Because I am going to see Lord Krsna today, all symptoms of inauspiciousness have already been killed. My life is now successful, because I shall be able to offer my respects unto the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead!’ (page 303).” The second example is similar. (See next paragraph in The Nectar of Devotion.)

Stages of Prema in Reverential Servitude Prema has different characteristic stages: prema, sneha, raga, pranaya, and so forth. Sambhramapriti-rati can heighten to prema, sneha, and raga, but cannot go past raga. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Reverential devotion for the Lord gradually increases and transforms itself into ecstatic love [prema], then affection [sneha] and then attachment [raga] (page 303).”

Prema When one attains prema, one's love for Krsna never wavers or diminishes for an instant, even if it has good reason to do so. Srila Prabhupada explains: “When there is no diminishing of this ecstatic love and when it is freed from all kinds of doubt, the devotee has reached the stage called steady love for Krsna (page 304).” Examples of Prema Bali Maharaja said, “My dear Lord... Whether You give me the opportunity to enjoy all the yogic perfections or You put me into the most abominable condition of hellish life, I shall never be disturbed (page 304).” This illustrates how prema never diminishes in any condition. Lord Krsna told Uddhava, “My dear friend, how can I express the glorious characteristics of Bali Maharaja, the son of Virocana? Although the King of the suras [demigods] was cursed by 6

B RS 3.2.76.

204

this son of Virocana, and although I cheated him in My incarnation as Vamana, taking away his dominions throughout the universe, and although I still criticised him for not fulfilling his promise, I have just now seen him in his kingdom, and he feelingly expressed his love for Me (page 304).” In spite of all the trouble Krsna put him through, Bali Maharaja still loved Krsna without the slightest wavering or diminishing of intensity. That is the character of prema.

Sneha The distinguishing characteristics of sneha are: (1) the heart melts, and (2) one cannot withstand even a moment of separation from Krsna. Srila Prabhupada says, “When such a feeling of love becomes intensified, it is called affection. In that affectional stage, one cannot bear separation from Krsna even for a moment (page 304).” Examples of Sneha “My dear Daruka, when you become like wood because of your separation from Krsna, it is not so wonderful... (page 304).” This sneha's second characteristic: inability to withstand even a moment of separation. “When he saw Lord Krsna his eyes filled with tears and created a river which flowed down toward the sea of Krsna to offer tribute, as a wife offers tribute to her husband. When his body erupted with goose pimples, he appeared like the kadamba flower (pages 304 - 305).” This illustrates sneha's first characteristic: a melted heart.

Raga Srila Prabhupada translated Srila Rupa Gosvami's definition of raga in Caitanya-caritamrta: “That stage at which affection for the beloved converts unhappiness into happiness is called raga, or attachment. When one has such attraction for Krsna, he can give up his own life to satisfy his beloved Krsna.” 7 Meeting with Krsna converts even the greatest distress into happiness. Separation from Krsna converts even the greatest happiness into distress, and one is prepared to give up his life. These are the characteristics of raga. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “When affection is symptomized by direct happiness and distress, it is called attraction [raga]. In such an attracted state of ecstatic love, one can face all kinds of disadvantages calmly. Even at the risk of death such a devotee is never bereft of the transcendental loving service of the Lord (page 305).” Examples of Raga The conditions surrounding Maharaja Pariksit's impending death were all distressful, but meeting with the Lord through the hearing process converted all this distress into joy. Srila Prabhupada explains, “A glorious example of this ecstatic love was exhibited by King Pariksit when he was at the point of death. Although he was bereft of his entire kingdom, which spread over all the world, and although he was accepting not even a drop of water in the

7

Madhya 19.178, purport.

205

seven days remaining to him, because he was engaged in hearing the transcendental pastimes of the Lord from Sukadeva Gosvami he was not in the least distressed. On the contrary, he was feeling direct transcendental ecstatic joy in association with Sukadeva Gosvami (page 305).” Another example: “If a drop of Lord Krsna's mercy can be bestowed upon me, then I shall feel completely carefree, even in the midst of a fire or an ocean. But if I become bereft of His causeless mercy, then even if I became the King of Dvaraka, I would be simply an object for pinpricks (page 305).”

Various Stages Achieved by Various Servants The four types of reverential servants (adhikrta, asrita, parisada, and anuga) can attain different levels of prema. The adhikrta (demigod) and asrita (surrendered soul) can achieve up to prema. The parisada (personal minister) and anuga (intimate follower) can achieve up to the level of raga. 8 At raga, a trace of friendship (sakhya) can appear in the devotee's reverential servitude. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Devotees such as Maharaja Pariksit and Uddhava are all situated in ecstatic attraction on the basis of affection, and in that state of affection a feeling of friendship becomes manifest (page 305).”

Reverential Servitude in Meeting and Separation Reverential servitude has two divisions: “Such ecstatic love has been divided by great scholars into two groups — addition and subtraction. ” The Sanskrit for "addition" and "subtraction" is yoga and ayoga, which can also be translated as "meeting" and "separation." Both meeting and separation have their own characteristic anubhavas and vyabhicari-bhavas.

Reverential Servitude in Separation The anubhavas of reverential servitude in separation: “In this state of love, one is constantly fixed with his mind at the lotus feet of the Lord. A devotee in this state becomes very eager to learn of the transcendental qualities of the Lord. The most important business of such a devotee is attaining the association of the Lord (page 305.”

Two Types of Separation According to Sanskrit poetics, there are two types of separation: (1) utkanthitva, and (2) viyoga. Utkanthitva is a longing to meet Krsna for the first time. Viyoga is a desire for reunion with the Lord. Utkanthitva — Longing Longing to see the Lord, King Iksvaku becomes attached to anything that resembles Krsna, such as the black cloud (whose color resembles Krsna's), the black deer (whose name — krsna-sara — resembles Krsna's), and to the lotus flower (whose beauty resembles Krsna's eyes).

8

BRS 3.2.90 - 91

206

Another example of utkanthitva is Akrura, who desired to perfect his eyes by seeing Krsna for the first time. (See page 306). Eight vyabhicari-bhavas are appropriate for reverential servitude in utkanthitva: Autsarya — Eagerness “In the Krsna-karnamrta, written by Bilvamaìgala Thakura, there is this expression of eagerness in ecstatic love: ‘How miserable it is, my dear Krsna, O friend of the hopeless! O merciful Lord, how can I pass these thankless days without seeing You?’ (page 306).” “A similar sentiment was expressed by Uddhava when he wrote a letter to Krsna (page 306).” Dainya — Humility “My dear Lord, You are the ocean of mercy. With my arms placed upon my head, I am bowing down before You with all humility and sincerity. I am praying unto You, my Lord. Would You be pleased just to sprinkle a little of the water of Your glance upon me? That will be a great satisfaction (pg. 306).” The next quotation on page 306 also exemplifies dainya. The vyabhicari-bhavas of utkanthitva is reverential servitude continue into the next chapter.

207

Chapter 38

Indifference and Separation BRS 3.2.104 - 127

This chapter continues describing the vyabhicari-bhavas of separation in reverential devotion.

Eight Vyabhicari-Bhavas of Utkanthitva (continued) Nirveda — Self Disparagement “Uddhava once wrote a letter to Krsna, ‘My dear Krsna, I have just finished the study of all kinds of philosophical books and Vedic verses about the goal of life, and so now I have a little reputation for my studies. But still, in spite of my reputation, my knowledge is condemned, because although enjoying the effulgence of Vedic knowledge, I could not appreciate the effulgence emanating from the nails of Your toes. Therefore, the sooner my pride and Vedic knowledge are finished, the better it will be!’ (pg. 307).” Cinta — Anxiety “My mind is very flickering, so I cannot concentrate it upon Your lotus feet. And seeing this inefficiency in myself I become ashamed, and the whole night I am unable to sleep because I am exasperated by my great inability (page 307).” Capalya —Restlessness Krsna-karnamrta illustrates restlessness or unsteadiness, “My dear Lord, Your naughtiness in boyhood is the most wonderful thing in the three worlds. And You Yourself know what this naughtiness is. As such, You can very easily understand my flickering mind. This is known to You and me. Therefore, I am simply yearning to know how I can fix my mind on Your lotus feet (page 307).” The next paragraph in The Nectar of Devotion also illustrates capalya. Jadata —Inertness Srimad-Bhagavatam (7.4.37) depicts Prahlada's inertness in childish play, which is a vyabhicaribhava resulting from reverential longing to see the Lord for the first time. (See page 307). Another example is the brahmana who simply stared upward, hoping to see Krsna. (See page 308). Unmada —Madness Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates madness with two examples. The first is Prahlada Maharaja's ecstatic dancing like a shameless madman. The second is Narada Muni's dancing naked, and similar symptoms of insanity. Moha — Bewilderment Prahlada Maharaja felt unfit to approach the Lord, so he lay down and cried, almost unconsciousness from bewilderment. 208

Another example: “The students of a great devotee once talked among themselves in this way: ‘My dear Godbrothers, our spiritual master, after seeing the lotus feet of the Lord, has thrown himself into the fire of lamentation, and because of this fire the water of his life has almost dried away. Let us now pour the nectar of the holy name through his ears, and by our doing so the swan of his life may again show signs of life.’ (page 308).” This loss of consciousness, or loss of vital signs, is a vyabhicari-bhava of reverential longing to see the Lord's lotus feet.

Viyoga — Absence The second type of separation from Krsna is viyoga, feeling the Lord's absence after having previously had His association. Uddhava exemplifies this mood: When Krsna left Dvaraka, Uddhava was almost completely stunned into unconsciousness. Srila Rupa Gosvami now describes ten vyabhicari-bhavas of viyoga.

Tapa — Fever Uddhava's statement to Narada illustrates tapa. (See page 309).

Krsata — Emaciation (Withering of the Limbs) Some devotees went to see Krsna in Dvaraka, but were detained at the gate. They prayed, “My dear Krsna, O friend of the Pandus, as the swan loves to dive into the water among the lily flowers and would die if taken from the water, so we wish only to be with You. Our limbs are shrinking and fading because You have been taken away from us (page 309).”

Jagarana — Sleeplessness “The King of Bahula, although very comfortably situated in his palace, began to think the nights very long and distressing because of his separation from Krsna (page 309).”

Alambana-Sunyata — Inability to Find Shelter “King Yudhisthira once said, ‘Krsna, the chariot driver of Arjuna, is the only relative of mine within the three worlds. Therefore, my mind is becoming maddened day and night with separation from His lotus feet, and I do not know how to situate myself or where I shall go to attain any steadiness of mind’ (page 309).” Yudhisthira's mind could find no shelter from his feelings of separation in Krsna's absence. Because his mind was thus afflicted day and night, this reference may also illustrate sleeplessness.

Adhrti — Nonattachment Raktaka exemplifies complete nonattachment to all external objects. “Simply because he saw a peacock feather, he is now closing his eyes and is no longer attentive to pasturing the cows (page 309).”

209

Jadata — Inertness This is illustrated by Uddhava, When Krsna left Dvaraka for Hastinapura. (See pages 309 - 310).

Vyadhi & Unmada —Disease & Madness When Krsna left Dvaraka to seek out the Syamantaka jewel, Uddhava manifested symptoms of disease and madness. (See page 310).

Murcchita — Unconsciousness “Uddhava informed Krsna, ‘My dear leader of the Yadu dynasty, Your servants in Vrndavana cannot sleep at night thinking of You, so now they are all lying down on the bank of the Yamuna almost paralyzed. And it appears that they are almost dead, because their breathing is very slow’ (page 310).”

Mrti — Death The final paragraph of Chapter Thirty-Eight illustrates mrti (death). Devotees do not allow themselves to actually die, because they know that their ensuing absence from Krsna's future pastimes would cause Him displeasure. Consequently, mrti is not actual death, but it displays external symptoms similar to death. 9 “Krsna was once informed, ‘You are the life and soul of all the inhabitants of Vrndavana. So because You have left Vrndavana, all of the servitors of Your lotus feet there are suffering. It is as if the lakes filled with lotus flowers have dried up from the scorching heat of separation from You’ (page 310)” Srila Prabhupada explains that this verse compares the residents of Vrndavana to lakes, the lotus flowers are their souls, the swans are their life-air, and the scorching heat is their separation from Krsna. The scorching heat of separation from Krsna had dried up their souls, and thus the swan of their life-air seemed to be leaving the lakes of their bodies.

9

B RS 3.2.128

210

Chapter 39

Ways of Meeting Krsna BRS 3.2.129 - 147

Srila Rupa Gosvami has completed his description of reverential servitude in separation (ayoga). Chapter Thirty-Nine begins his description of reverential servitude in meeting (yoga).

Reverential Servitude in Meeting “When Krsna and His devotees meet, the meeting is technically called yoga, or linking up with the Lord (page 311).” There are three ways of meeting Krsna: (1) siddhi — perfection, (2) tusti — satisfaction, and (3) sthiti — steadiness. Srila Prabhupada says, “Such meetings between Krsna and His devotees can be divided into three classes — namely perfection, satisfaction and steadiness (page 311).” Siddhi — In utkanthitva, the devotee longs to meet Krsna for the first time. Siddhi (perfection) occurs when he finally does meet Krsna. Tusti — In viyoga, the devotee suffers from the Krsna's absence. When the Lord finally returns, the devotee experiences tusti (satisfaction). Sthiti — This occurs when the meeting with Krsna is steady and constant, not prefaced by any type of separation.

Siddhi — Perfectional Meeting “My dear King, as soon as Akrura the chariot driver saw Lord Krsna and His elder brother Balarama in Vrndavana, he immediately got down from the chariot and, being greatly afflicted by affection for the transcendental Lord, fell down upon His lotus feet to offer respectful obeisances (page 311).” This illustrates siddhi because it is the first time that Akrura met Krsna.

Tusti — Meeting in Satisfaction “When Lord Krsna returned to His capital, Dvaraka, the inhabitants said, ‘Dear Lord, if You remain in foreign countries for so long, we shall certainly be bereft of seeing Your smiling face! Upon observing Your face, we, Your eternal servitors, become greatly satisfied. All the anxieties of our existence are immediately mitigated. If we cannot see You because You are long absent from Dvaraka, then it will be impossible for us to live anymore’ (pg. 311).” This illustrates tusti because it is a reunion with Krsna. When Krsna returned to Dvaraka, out of ecstasy His servant Daruka forgot to offer Him respects. This is another example of tusti.

Sthiti — Steady Meeting Those who steadily experience the association of Krsna for extended periods are enjoying sthiti — steady meeting. Srila Prabhupada says, “When a devotee is ultimately situated in association with Krsna, his position is called steadiness in devotional service (page 312).” 211

Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates sthiti with a verse from his book, Hamsaduta. This book describes how Srimati Radharani feels faint in separation from Krsna. Her friend Lalita-Devi hurries to the Yamuna for fresh water. Arriving there, she sees a beautiful swan travelling downstream towards Mathura — Krsna's newfound home. She asks the swan to take a message to Krsna informing Him of Srimati Radharani's plight. The swan wants to know how to recognise Krsna, so Lalita-devi describes that He is always surrounded by certain devotees, especially Akrura (who would be talking to the Lord) and Uddhava (who would be massaging His feet). Thus the Hamsaduta shows Akrura and Uddhava as examples of devotees enjoying sthiti — constant association with Krsna.

Anubhavas of Reverential Servitude in Meeting Srila Prabhupada mentions two anubhavas of reverential servitude in meeting: (1) “Devotees situated in the transcendental rasa of servitorship render their particular service whenever there is an opportunity,” and (2) “Sometimes they sit down in front of Krsna to receive orders (page 312).”

Is Reverential Servitude a Genuine Rasa? Some say that reverential servitude is not a genuine rasa. They say the sthayi-bhava of reverential servitude cannot be stimulated to rasa because there is a lack of appropriate vibhava, etc. 10 Srila Prabhupada mentions this, “Some persons are reluctant to accept this level of devotional service as actual bhakti-yoga... (page 312).” This opinion is faulty. Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes two texts from Srimad-Bhagavatam which clearly depict reverential servants experiencing all varieties of vibhava, etc. (See page 312).

GAURAVA-PRITI (FAMILIAL SERVITUDE) As mentioned in the beginning of this wave, there are two moods of dasya-rasa: (1) sambhramapriti, and (2) gaurava-priti. Srila Rupa Gosvami now treats the subject of gaurava-priti. Gaurava-priti is more intimate than sambhrama-priti, because the gaurava-priti devotee sees Krsna as his personal protector and maintainer, like a parent. The devotees in this mood feel utterly dependent on Krsna's mercy, like a son feels dependent on the mercy of his father. Indeed, often the gaurava-priti devotee is one of Krsna's sons. 11

Vibhava Visaya-Alambana Krsna as a Stimulus for Familial Servitude Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the form and qualities of Krsna that stimulate familial servitude.

10 11

BRS 3.2.139 - 140 Dependence on Kåñna' s protection is one of t he symptoms of gaurava-préti. It is also one of t he six symptoms of surrender mentioned in Bhaktivinode Öhäkura's Çaranagati. Therefore, Çréla Prabhupäda comments extensively on the six processes of surrender. 212

Krsna's Form “When Krsna was residing in Dvaraka, some of the elderly members of the Yadu family would occasionally put some important matter before Him. At such a time, Krsna would carefully give attention to those matters. And if there were some humorous topics mentioned, Krsna would immediately respond with a smiling face. Sometimes when Krsna was executing His duties in the assembly known as Sudharma, He would ask the elderly members for good advice (page 313).” Krsna's Qualities “...He is manifest as the supreme spiritual master, the supreme executive head, the superior intelligence and the supreme power, protector and maintainer (page 313).”

213

Chapter 40

Reverential Devotion of Sons and Other Subordinates BRS 3.2.148 - 178

Srila Rupa Gosvami's description of gaurava-priti continues from the previous chapter.

Vibhava (continued) Asraya-Alambana The Devotee as a Stimulus for Familial Servitude There are two types of gaurava-priti devotees: (1) kanistha — those who feel intimately subordinate to Krsna, and (2) putra — those who feel subordinate to Krsna in the mood of a son, or similar family member. Srila Prabhupada says, “True reverential devotion is exhibited by persons who think themselves subordinate to Krsna and by persons who think themselves sons of Krsna (page 315).” Principal Gaurava-Priti Devotees The principal intimate subordinates are, “Sarana, Gada and Subhadra (page 315).” principal sons and relatives are, “Pradyumna, Carudesna and Samba (page 315). ”

The

Their Bhakti Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the devotional mood of Krsna's sons: “When Krsna's sons dined with Him, they would sometimes open their mouths for Krsna to feed them. Sometimes when Krsna would pat one of His sons, the son would sit on Krsna's lap, and while Krsna was blessing the son's head by smelling it, the others would shed tears, thinking how many pious activities he must have performed in his previous life (page 315).” The Foremost Gaurava-Priti Devotee “Out of Krsna's many sons, Pradyumna, a son of Krsna's chief queen, Rukmini, is considered the leader (page 315).” Pradyumna's Form “Pradyumna's bodily features resemble Krsna's exactly. Pure devotees of Krsna glorify Pradyumna because he is so fortunate: like father like son (315).” Pradyumna's Mood of Devotion “My dear Prabhavati, just look at the head of our family, Sri Krsna. He is Visnu Himself, the supreme driver of Garuda, and He is our supreme master. Because we have become so proud and confident of His protecting us, we sometimes do not even care about fighting with Tripurari [Lord Siva] (page 315).”

214

A Subtle Distinction There are gaurava-priti devotees in Dvaraka and Vrndavana. Awareness of the Lord's opulence captivates the gaurava-priti devotees in Dvaraka. Consequently, they are somewhat more distant than the gaurava-priti devotees in Vrndavana. Srila Prabhupada explains, “The servitors in the abode of Dvaraka always worship Krsna as the most respectable and revered Personality of Godhead. They are captivated by Krsna because of His superexcellent opulences (page 316).”

Anubhava The basic anubhava of gaurava-priti-rasa is an expression of subordination to Krsna. Srila Prabhupada mentions, “These feelings of subordination... are sometimes manifested as anubhava (page 316).” 12 The basic anubhava of gaurava-priti is an expression of subordination. This can take many forms: Sitting at a lower level than Krsna, Following the instructions of the Guru, Accepting the burden of responsibility for Krsna's daily activities, renouncing activity that displeases Krsna, and displaying gravity in front of one's superiors. Example of Sitting at a Lower Level “When the demigods came before Krsna, the sons, instead of sitting on golden chairs, sat down on the floor, which was covered with deerskin (page 316).” [Emphasis added.] Srila Rupa Gosvami mentions some additional anubhavas: “...the sons used to offer their obeisances, they were silent, submissive and gentle... (page 316).” Srila Rupa Gosvami marks an interesting anubhava of gaurava-priti: such devotees “never discussed Krsna's pastimes in conjugal love (page 316).” Srila Prabhupada elaborately comments on this. (Last paragraph, page 316). 13

Sattvika-Bhava Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates sattvika-bhava in gaurava-priti by citing Cupid. Upon seeing Krsna, Cupid manifested ecstatic perspiration (sveda) and became stunned (stambha). “My dear Cupid, because you have been so fortunate as to have placed your eyesight on the lotus feet of Krsna, the drops of perspiration on your body have become frozen, and they resemble kantaki fruits [a kind of small fruit found in thorny bushes] (page 317).” The beauty of Krsna's lotus feet stunned Cupid so much that his entire body froze up, even his perspiration.

Vyabhicari-Bhava All the Vyabhicari-bhavas mentioned for sambhrama-priti-rasa also apply in gaurava-priti-rasa. 12

13

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé illustrates th is with a referen ce to "Balaräm a." Referrin g to th e o riginal tex t in Bhaktirasämåta-sindhu (3.2.157) is helpful. The Sanskrit agraja ("elder brother") refers to Kåñna. A person called Gada is Kåñna's y ounger brot her (he i s t he son of Väsudeva by anot her wi fe). Seei ng hi s elder brot her Kåñna, Gada becomes overwhelmed with gaurava-préti and begi ns offering prostrated obeisances to His lotus feet. (Gada also means "club.") Jéva Gosvämé explains that this anubhäva applies to sädhakas (practitioners) of gaurava-préti-rasa. Those who are eternally perfect in gaurava-préti-rasa never have any inclination to discuss the Lord's conjugal pastimes. Therefore restraining from topics of conjugal pastimes is an anubhäva which has no possibility of arising in them. 215

The Yadu princes are an example of jubilations (harsa). (See page 317). Pradyumna is an example of self disparagement (nirveda). He said, “My dear Samba, you are such a glorified personality! I have seen that once when you were playing on the ground, your body became covered with dust; yet our father, Lord Krsna, still took you up on His lap. But I am so unfortunate that I could never get such love from our father! (page 317).” When Pradyumna was young he was taken away from home, not to return until his adulthood. He laments having thus missed the opportunity for intimate childhood exchanges with his father, Lord Krsna.

Sthayi-Bhava “To regard Krsna as one's superior is called reverential feeling, and when, in addition to this, a devotee feels that Krsna is his protector, his transcendental love for Krsna is increased, and his combined feelings are called reverential devotion (page 317).” "Regarding Krsna as one's superior" is sambhrama-priti-rati. When this is augmented by the more intimate conception of personal dependence on the Lord for maintenance and protection, it evolves to gaurava-priti-rati. Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates the sthayi-bhava of gaurava-priti: “In this reverential devotional attitude, Pradyumna never talked to his father in a loud voice. In fact, he never so much as unlocked the lips of his mouth, nor did he ever show his face filled with tears. He would always glance only at the lotus feet of his father (page 317).”

Stages of Prema in Gaurava-Priti Gaurava-priti-rati can heighten to prema, sneha, and finally raga. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “When this steady reverential devotion increases further, it is called love of Godhead in reverential devotion. Attraction and affection are two prominent symptoms of this stage (page 317).” 14

Prema At the level of prema, one's love for Krsna never diminishes or wavers, even if there is justification for it to do so. Krsna's younger sister, Subhadra, illustrates this. She was informed that Krsna had failed to protect her beloved son Abhimanyu from death on the battlefield of Kuruksetra. Still, her deep love for Krsna never wavered or diminished for a moment. Arjuna, her husband, told Krsna, “Although Abhimanyu was killed almost in Your presence, Subhadra's love for You is not agitated at all, nor has it even slightly changed its original color (page 318).”

Sneha Sneha has two characteristics: (1) a melted heart, and (2) inability to withstand a moment of absence from Krsna. Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates gaurava-priti-rasa at sneha by citing Pradyumna, who once approached Krsna very bashfully, with tears in his eyes (a symptom of a melted heart). (See page 318).

14

"Steady reverent ial devot ion" i ndicates gaurava-préti-rati. When that rati "increases further" by encouragem ent from the appropriate bhävas, it heightens to "love of Godhead" — prema, "attraction" — räga, and "affect ion" — sneha. 216

Raga Raga is love that transforms happiness into distress, and distress into happiness. “Whenever [Pradyumna] was ordered by his father to execute something, he would immediately execute the order, taking the task as nectarean even though it may have been poison. Similarly, whenever he would find something to be disapproved of by his father, he would immediately reject it as poison, even though it may have been nectarean (page 318).”

Separation and Meeting The conditions of yoga and ayoga also apply in gaurava-priti-rasa. Srila Rupa Gosvami gives a few examples:

Ayoga — Separation Utkanthitva in Gaurava-Priti-Rasa Pradyumna said to his wife Rati, “The enemy, Sambara, is already killed. Now I am very anxious to see my father, who is my spiritual master and who always carries the conchshell known as Pancajanya (page 318).” As previously mentioned, Pradyumna was taken from his father at infancy. In this statement, he has grown to adulthood and is on the verge of being reunited with his long-lost father. Thus Pradyumna exemplifies a gaurava-priti bhakta who longs to see Krsna for the first time (utkanthitva). Viyoga in Gaurava-Priti-Rasa When his father was away at the battle of Kuruksetra, Pradyumna said, “Since my father has left Dvaraka, I do not take much pleasure in practicing fighting, nor am I interested in any kind of sporting pastimes. And what need is there to speak of these things? I do not even wish to stay at Dvaraka in the absence of my father (page 318).”

Yoga — Meeting Siddhi — Perfectional Meeting After killing Sambarasura and returning to Dvaraka, Pradyumna achieved the perfection of his long-cherished desire to be reunited with his father. (See page 318). Tusti — Meeting in Satisfaction After Krsna returned from Kuruksetra, the joy of tusti overwhelmed all His sons in Dvaraka. “...when Krsna returned from the Battlefield of Kuruksetra to His home at Dvaraka. All of His sons were so overjoyed that out of ecstasy they repeatedly made many mistakes (page 318).” Sthiti —Constant Meeting “Every day Pradyumna looked over Krsna's lotus feet with tears in his eyes.” [Emphasis added.] Srila Rupa Gosvami will not explicitly describe all the vyabhicari-bhavas for each facet of union and separation. He has already extensively described the topic in connection with sambhramapriti. The intelligent reader can simply apply the same paradigm to gaurava-priti. Srila 217

Prabhupada summarizes, “These signs of reverential devotion on the part of Pradyumna may be described in the same way they have been described in the cases of other devotees (page 318).”

218

Western Ocean Third Wave Sakhya-Rasa Chapters 41 & 42

219

Chapter 41

Fraternal Devotion BRS 3.3.1 - 56

"When a devotee is permanently situated in devotional service, and by different symptoms of ecstasy he has developed and matured a fraternal mellow or flavor in relationship with the Personality of Godhead, his feeling is called fraternal love of Godhead." (pg. 319) 1 In other words, when fraternal affection (sakhya-rati) is stimulated by the appropriate bhavas it develops and matures into sakhya-rasa. Srila Rupa Gosvami will now describe the appropriate vibhavas, etc., for sakhya-rasa.

Vibhava Visaya-Alambana Krsna as a Stimulus for Friendship Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the form and qualities of Krsna that specifically stimulate sakhyarasa. Krsna's Form The form that stimulates sakhya-rasa in the residents of Vrndavana: “The Lord, Hari, whose bodily hue is like the indranila jewel, whose smiling is as beautiful as the kunda flower, whose silk dress is as yellow as golden autumn foliage, whose chest is beautified with garlands of flowers and who is always playing upon His flute — this enemy of the Agha demon is always attracting our hearts by wandering about Vrndavana (pg. 319).” The form that stimulates sakhya-rasa of devotees outside Vrndavana: “When the sons of Pandu, headed by Maharaja Yudhisthira, saw Krsna in His four-handed form on the Battlefield of Kuruksetra, holding His conchshell, disc, club, and lotus flower, they completely forgot themselves and became merged in the ocean of nectarean happiness (pg. 319).” Krsna's Qualities “...Krsna's nice dress, His strongly built body, the all-auspicious symptoms on His body, His knowledge of different languages, His learned teachings in Bhagavada-Gita, His uncommon genius in all fields of endeavor, His exhibition of expert knowledge, His mercy, His chivalry, His behavior as a conjugal lover, His intelligence, His forgiveness, His attraction for all kinds of men, His opulence and His happiness — all provoke fraternal love (pgs. 319 - 320).”

Asraya-Alambana The Devotee as a Stimulus for Friendship The devotees who can stimulate friendly devotional sentiments are, naturally, Krsna's friends.

1

"Permanently situated in devotional service" refers to sakhya-rati, the sthäyé-bhäva of fraternal devotion. When "different symptoms of ecstasy" (the four bhävas) stimulate this rati it develops into a mature "fraternal mellow or flavor" (sakhya-rasa).

220

Srila Prabhupada describes, “The impetus to fraternal love upon seeing the associates of Krsna in Vrndavana is also very natural, for their personal bodily features, their qualities and their dress are all equal to Krsna's. These associates are always happy in their service to Krsna, and they are generally known as vayasyas, or friends of the same age (pg. 320).” 2

Varieties of Friends There are two types of vayasyas: (1) vraja-sakhas — friends in Vrndavana, and (2) pura-vyasyas — friends living outside Vrndavana, in larger towns and cities. Srila Prabhupada explains, “Such eternal vayasyas are also found beyond the jurisdiction of Vrndavana, in places such as Dvaraka and Hastinapura. Except for Vrndavana, all the places of Krsna's pastimes are called puras (towns) (page 320).”

Pura-Vyasyas — Friends Living Outside Vrndavana Principal Pura-Vyasyas “Personalities like Arjuna, Bhima, Draupadi and Sudama Brahamana are counted among Krsna's fraternal devotees in the puras (pg. 320).” Their Bhakti “‘When Sri Krsna arrived in Indraprastha, the capital of the Kurus, Maharaja Yudhisthira immediately came out to smell the flavor of Krsna's head.’ It is the Vedic custom that a superior smells the heads of his subordinates when the subordinates offer respect to the superior by touching his feet. Similarly, Arjuna and Bhima embraced Krsna with great jubilation, and the two younger brothers, namely Nakula and Sahadeva, touched the lotus feet of Krsna with tears in their eyes and offered their respects. In this way all the five Pandava brothers enjoyed the fraternal friendship of Krsna in transcendental mellow.” (pg. 320)

The Foremost Pura-Vyasya Arjuna is the foremost friendly devotee outside Vrndavana. “Of the five Pandavas, Arjuna is the most intimately connected with Krsna (pg. 320).” Arjuna's form “He has a nice bow called Gandiva in his hand. His thighs are compared to the trunks of elephants, and his eyes are always reddish... (pg. 320).” Arjuna's Bhakti “It is said that once Arjuna was lying on his bed with his head upon Krsna's lap and was talking and joking with Krsna in great relaxation, enjoying Krsna's company with smiling and great satisfaction (page 320).”

2

The terms vayasya and sakha are synonymous.

221

Vraja-Sakhas — Friends in Vrndavana Among all of Krsna's friends, the vraja-sakhas have the strongest devotion, evidenced by their inability to tolerate separation from Him. “As far as the vayasyas (friends) in Vrndavana are concerned, they become greatly distressed when they cannot see Krsna even for a moment (pgs. 320 - 321).”

Their Forms “All glories to Krsna's vayasyas, who are just like Krsna in their age, qualities, pastimes, dress and beauty. They are accustomed to playing on their flutes made of palm leaves, and they all have buffalo-horn bugles ornamented like Krsna's with jewels such as indranila and with gold and coral. They are always jubilant like Krsna. May these glorious companions of Krsna always protect us!" (pg. 321)

Their Bhakti When Krsna lifted Govardhana Hill, His friends said: “Dear friend, You have been standing for the last seven days and nights without any rest. This is very troublesome for us, because we see that You have undertaken a severely laborious task. We think, therefore, that You need not continue to stand in that way holding the hill. You can just transfer it onto Sudama's hand. We are very much aggrieved to see You in this position. If you think that Sudama is not able to support Govardhana Hill, then at least You should change hands. Instead of supporting it with Your left hand, please transfer it to Your right hand, so that we can give Your left hand a massage (page 321).” Srila Prabhupada comments, “This is an instance of intimacy, showing how much the vayasyas considered themselves equal to Krsna (pg. 321).” Srimad-Bhagavatam (10.12.11) further describes the vraja-sakhas' mood of friendly equality. Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates Krsna's special affection for the vraja-sakhas. “[Krsna] once said to Balarama, ‘My dear brother, when My companions were being devoured by Aghasura, hot tears poured down from My eyes. And as they were washing My cheeks, My dear elder brother, for at least one moment I completely lost Myself’ (pg. 321).”

Four Types of Vraja-Sakhas Krsna has four types of friends in Vrndavana: 1.) Suhrt — well-wishers 2.) Sakhas — friends 3.) Priya-sakhas — confidential friends 4.) Priya-narma-sakhas — most intimate friends Srila Prabhupada explains, “Within Gokula, Krsna's vayasyas are generally divided into four groups: (1) well-wishers, (2) friends, (3) confidential friends, and (4) intimate friends (pg. 322).”

222

Suhrt — Well-Wishers “Krsna's well-wisher friends are a little bit older than Krsna, and they have some parental affection for Him. Because of their being older than Krsna, they always try to protect Him from any harm. As such, they sometimes bear weapons so that they can chastise any mischievous persons who want to do harm to Krsna (pg. 322).” Principal Suhrts “Counted among the well-wisher friends are Subhadra, Mandalibhadra, Bhadravardhana, Gobhata, Yaksa, Indrabhata, Bhadraìga, Virabhadra, Mahaguna, Vijaya and Balabhadra (pg. 322).” Their Bhakti “My dear Mandalibhadra, why are you wielding a shining sword as though you were running toward Aristasura to kill him? My dear Baladeva, why are You unnecessarily bearing that heavy plough? My dear Vijaya, don't be unnecessarily agitated. My dear Bhadravardhana, there is no need to make these threatening motions. If you will all look more closely you will see that it is only a thundercloud upon Govardhana Hill; it is not the Aristasura in the shape of a bull, as you have imagined (pg. 322).” The Foremost Suhrts “Among the well-wisher friends, Mandalibhadra and Balabhadra are the chiefs (pg. 322).” Mandalibhadra's Form “His complexion is yellowish, and his dress is very attractive. He always carries a stick of various colors. He wears a peacock feather on his head and always looks very beautiful (pg. 322).” Mandalibhadra's Bhakti “My dear friends, our beloved Krsna is now very tired from working with the cows in the pasturing grounds... I can see that He is very fatigued. Let me massage His head silently while He is taking rest in His house. And you, Subala — you just massage His thighs (pg. 322).” Balabhadra's form “Let me take shelter of the lotus feet of Balarama, whose beauty is enhanced by the earrings touching His cheeks. His face is decorated with tilaka made from kasturi [musk], and His broad chest is decorated with a garland of gunja [small conchshells]. His complexion is as white as an autumn cloud... (pg. 322 - 323).” Balabhadra's Bhakti Balarama's statement to Subala describes His mood of devotion. (See page 323.)

Sakha — Friends “Friends who are younger than Krsna, who are always attached to Him and who give Him all kinds of service are called ordinary friends, or, simply, friends (page 323).” 223

Principal Sahkas “The names of some sakhas are Visala, Vrsabha, Ojasvi, Devaprastha, Varuthapa, Maranda, Kusumapida, Manibandha and Karandhama (page 323).” Because the sakhas are younger than Krsna, they have a trace of servitude. They greatly enjoy helping to dress Krsna, keeping Krsna informed about the whereabouts of His cows, and other relishable tasks like fanning and massaging Him. (See second full paragraph of page 323.) The Foremost Sakha The foremost of all sakhas is Devaprastha. Devaprastha's Form “He is very strong, a ready scholar, and is very expert in playing ball. He wears a white dress, and he ties his hair into a bunch with a rope... (pg. 324).” Devaprastha's Bhakti Krsna began to recline and, “taking this opportunity, Devaprastha, out of his strong affection for Krsna, immediately began to massage His legs (pg. 324).”

Priya-Sakhas — Confidential Friends “The more confidential friends are called priya-sakhas and are almost Krsna's age. Because of their very confidential friendship, their behavior is only on the basis of pure friendship. The behavior of other friends is on the ground of parental love or servitude, but the basic principle of the confidential friends is simply friendship on an equal level (pg. 324).” Suhrts are older than Krsna. Consequently, parental love mixes with their friendship. Sakhas are younger than Krsna. Thus, servitude mixes with their friendship. Priya-sakhas, however, are the same age as Krsna. Their friendship is perfectly on the level of equality. It is pure friendship without any influence of parental affection or servitude. Principal Priya-Sakhas “Sridama, Sudama, Dama, Vasudama, Kiìkini, Stoka-krsna, Amsu, Bhadrasena, Vilasi, Pundarika, Vitaìka and Kalaviìka (page 324).” Their Bhakti Srimati Radharani's friend describes their devotional mood. (See pg. 324.) Srila Rupa Gosvami gives a second description: “Sometimes a confidential friend would come before Krsna and embrace Him with great affection and love. Another friend would then come up from the rear and cover Krsna's eyes with his hands. Krsna would always feel very happy by such dealings with His confidential friends (pg. 325).” Srila Prabhupada adds his own commentary, further illustrating the devotional mood of the priya-sakhas by describing Krsna's laddu-stealing friend, Madhumaìgala. (See pg. 325) The Foremost Priya-Sakha “Out of all these confidential friends, Sridama is considered to be the chief (pg. 325).” 224

Sridama's Form: “Sridama used to put on a yellow-colored dress. He would carry a buffalo horn, and his turban was of reddish, copper color. His bodily complexion was blackish, and around his neck there was a nice garland... (pg. 325).” Sridama's Bhakti He once told Krsna, “Oh, You are so cruel that You left us alone on the bank of the Yamuna, and we were all mad from not seeing You there! Now it is our great fortune that we are able to see You here. If You want to pacify us, You must embrace each one of us with Your arms... (pg. 325).”

Priya-Narma-Sakhas — Most Intimate Friends “There are other friends who are still more confidential. They are called priya-narma, or intimate friends (pg. 325).” The priya-narma are the most intimate and exalted of all devotees in the sakhya mood, because Krsna engages them in the very confidential service of arranging His meetings with the gopis. Principal Priya-Narmas “Counted among the priya-narma friends are Subala, Arjuna, Gandharva, Vasanta and Ujjvala (pg. 325).” Their Bhakti A gopi tells Srimati Radharani, “My dear Krsaìgi [delicate one], just see how Subala is whispering Your message into Krsna's ear, how he is delivering the confidential letter of Syamadasi silently into Krsna's hand, how he is delivering the betel nuts prepared by Palika into Krsna's mouth, and how he is decorating Krsna with garland prepared by Taraka. Did you know, my dear friend, that all these most intimate friends of Krsna are always engaged in His service in this way? (pgs. 325 - 326).” The Foremost Priya-Narma “Out of the many intimate priya-narmas, Subala and Ujjvala are considered to be the most prominent (pg. 326).” Subala's Form (Subala is slightly superior to Ujjvala): “His complexion is just like molten gold. He is very, very dear to Krsna. He always has a garland around his neck, and he wears yellow clothing. His eyes are just like lotus flower petals... (pg. 326).” Subala's Bhakti When Krsna would speak to Subala no one else could understand what they were saying; not even the assembly of sakhis who are expert in understanding Krsna's subtle gestures and movements. Subala's superior intimacy would thus become evident. Srila Prabhupada says, “The degree of intimacy shared by Krsna and Subala can be understood by the fact that the talks 225

between them were so confidential that no one else could understand what they were saying (pg. 326).” Ujjvala's Form “Ujjvala always wears some garment of orange color, and the movements of his eyes are always very restless. He likes to decorate himself with all kinds of flowers, his bodily hue is almost like Krsna's, and on his neck there is always a necklace of pearls (pg. 326).” Ujjvala's Bhakti Srimati Radharani said, “My dear friend it is impossible for Me to keep My prestige! I wanted to avoid talking to Krsna anymore — but just see! There again is His friend Ujjvala, coming to Me with his canvassing work. His entreaties are so powerful that it is very difficult for a gopi to resist her love for Krsna... (page 326).” Ujjvala always desires to glorify Krsna's very confidential love for the gopis. The last paragraph of page 326 illustrates this.

Pramana — Evidence There are different ways to ascertain who the intimate friends of Lord Krsna are, how they dress, etc. One way is by the descriptions given in sastra, another is by local lore and oral tradition. “Among the groups of different friends of Krsna, some are well known from various scriptures, and some are well known by popular tradition (pg. 327).”

Three Types of People Who Become Krsna's Friends There are three types of people who become Krsna's friends: (1) some are eternally perfect friends, (2) some are elevated demigods who become Krsna's friends, and (3) some are devotees who have achieved intimate friendship with Krsna by executing sadhana. Srila Prabhupada says, “There are three divisions among Krsna's friends: some are eternally in friendship with Krsna, some are elevated demigods, and some are perfected devotees (pg. 327).”

Services Performed by Krsna's Friends Each individual friend renders service according to his inherent personality: "In all of these groups there are some who by nature are fixed in Krsna's service and are always engaged in giving council; some of them are very fond of joking and naturally cause Krsna to smile by their words; some of them are by nature very simple, and by their simplicity they please Lord Krsna... (page 327).”

226

Chapter 42

Fraternal Loving Affairs BRS 3.3.57 - 136

Vibhava (continued) Uddipana Objects Which Impel Fraternal Love “Krsna's age, His beauty, His bugle, His flute, His conchshell and His pleasing attitude all provoke love in friendship for Him. His exceptional joking abilities, exhibited sometimes by His pretending to be a royal prince, or even the Supreme Personality of Godhead, also give impetus to devotees developing love for Krsna in friendship (pg. 329).”

Krsna's Age Krsna has three age periods: (1) kaumara — birth to 5 years old, (2) pauganda — 6 to 10 years old, (3) kaisora — 11 to the end of 15 years old. Srila Prabhupada says, “Learned scholars have divided Krsna's age into three periods: the age up through five years is called kaumara, the age from the sixth to the tenth year is called pauganda, and the age from the eleventh through fifteenth year is called kaisora (pg. 329).”

Kaumara — up to Five Years Old Srimad-Bhagavatam (10.13.11) describes Krsna in His kaumara age — flute tucked in His belt, enjoying a festive picnic with His young boyfriends.

Pauganda — Six to Ten Years Old “Krsna's pauganda age can be further divided into three periods — namely the beginning [adya], middle [madhya] and end [sesa] (pg. 330).” Adya Pauganda (6 - 7) Beauty of this Age “In the beginning of the pauganda age there is a very nice reddish luster on His lips, His abdomen is very thin, and on His neck are circles like those on a conchshell (pg. 330).” Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of how this beauty can impel ecstatic friendship. “Sometimes, some outside visitors would return to Vrndavana to see Krsna and, upon seeing Him again, would exclaim, ‘My dear Mukunda, Your beauty is gradually increasing, just like the leaf on a banyan tree! ...I am sure that Your beautiful bodily development is now giving much pleasure to Your friends’ (pg. 330).” Dress of this Age “At this age Krsna was garlanded with various kinds of flowers. He used to put on a silk dress, colored with various kinds of dye (pg. 330).” 227

Activities of this Age “Sometimes He would wrestle there with His different friends, and sometimes they would all dance together in the forest (pg. 330).” Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of how these activities can impel ecstatic friendship. The cowherd boys said, “Dear Krsna... when You pretend, just like an actor, to be fighting with us, You give us unlimited transcendental bliss (pg. 330).” Madhya-Pauganda (8 - 9) Beauty of this Age “When Krsna is more grown up, in the middle age of pauganda, His nails become finely sharp, and His chubby cheeks become lustrous and round. On the two sides of His waist above His belt there are three distinct lines of folded skin, called trivali (pg. 330).” Dress of this Age “In this age Krsna wore a silk dress that glittered like lightening, His head was decorated with a silk turban covered with gold lace, and in His hand He carried a stick about fifty-six inches long (pgs. 330 - 331).” Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of how this dress can impel ecstatic friendship. One of Krsna's friends said, “My dear friend, just look at Krsna! See how He is carrying in His hand a stick which is bound up and down with golden rings, how His turban with golden lace is showing such a beautiful luster, and how His dress is giving His friends the highest transcendental pleasure! (pg. 331).” Sesa Pauganda (10 years) Beauty of this Age “At the end of Krsna's pauganda age, Krsna's hair sometimes hangs down to His hips, and sometimes it becomes scattered. In this age His two shoulders become higher and broader, and His face is always decorated with marks of tilaka. When His beautiful hair scatters over His shoulders, it appears to be a goddess of fortune embracing Him, and this embracing is highly relished by His friends (pg. 331).” Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of how this beauty can impel ecstatic friendship. “My dear Kesava... all of Your beautiful bodily features are defeating me today, although I am usually stronger than You or any of our friends. Since this is so, I do not know how these features of Your body can fail to defeat the pride of all the young girls of Vrndavana. When I am so defeated by this beauty, what chance is there for those who are naturally very simple and flexible? (pg. 331).” Activities of this Age The sesa pauganda period borders directly upon Krsna's kaisora period (in which His pastimes with the gopis become prominent). Thus one can see the dawning of Krsna's conjugal affairs within the activities of this age. “At this age Krsna took pleasure in whispering into the ears of His friends, and the subject of His talks was the beauty of the gopis, who were just tarrying before them (pg. 331).” Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of how these activities can impel ecstatic friendship. Subala said, “My dear Krsna, You are very cunning. You can understand the 228

thoughts of others; therefore I am whispering within Your ear that all of these five gopis, who are most beautiful, have been attracted by Your dress. And I believe Cupid has entrusted them with the responsibility of conquering You (pg. 331).”

Kaisora — 11 to 15 Years Old 3 All the devotees in Vrndavana — servants, friends, parents, and consorts — find the age of kaisora to be the most pleasing of all. Therefore Krsna never ages beyond kaisora. As such there is no description of Krsna's yauvanam given in Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “And it is at this age that devotees generally most appreciate Krsna. Krsna with Radharani is worshipped as Kisora-kisori. Krsna does not increase His age beyond this form of kaisora... (pgs. 331 - 332).”

Krsna's Beauty After age, the next uddipana is beauty. Srila Rupa Gosvami describes how the cowherd boys appreciate Krsna's beauty. “Dear Krsna, You need not decorate Your body with so many ornaments. Your transcendental features are themselves so beautiful that You do not require any ornamentation (pg. 332).”

Miscellaneous Objects Krsna's Flute Krsna's flute can impel fraternal love. “Whenever Krsna begins to vibrate His flute early in the morning, all of His friends immediately get up from bed just to join Him in going to the pasturing grounds (page 332).” An example: “One of the friends once said, ‘My dear cowherd friends, the sound of Krsna's flute from above Govardhana Hill is telling us that we need not go to search Him out on the bank of the Yamuna.’”

Krsna's Conchshell The statement of Parvati to Siva illustrates how the conchshell gives enthusiasm to Krsna's friends. (See pg. 332.)

Krsna's Humor (Vinode) The story of Krsna dressing Himself up like Srimati Radharani, "just to create fun among His friends," is an illustration of how Krsna increases the fraternal devotion of His friends by doing various funny things.

Anubhava Srila Rupa Gosvami mentions various expressions of fraternal devotion. “Krsna played with His intimate friends sometimes by fighting or wrestling with their arms, sometimes by playing ball 3

Previously, Çré Rüpa Goswämé elaborately described all three divisions (adya, madhya, and çeña) of Kåñna's kaiçora age. see The Nectar of Devotion, page 210; Waves of Devotion, page .

229

and sometimes by playing chess. Sometimes they carried one another on their shoulders, and sometimes they exhibited their expertness at whirling logs [sticks]... by joking together, and by swimming in the pool. All these activities are called anubhava. Whenever all the friends would assemble in the company of Krsna, they would immediately engage in all these functions, especially in dancing together (pg. 332).” Example of Wrestling “My dear friend, O killer of the Agha demon, You are very proudly wandering among Your friends trying to exhibit Your arms as very strong. Is it that You are envious of me? I know that You cannot defeat me in wrestling, and I also know that You were sitting idly for a long time because You were hopeless of defeating me (page 333).” Different types of friends have different types of anubhavas.

Anubhavas of Pura-Vayasyas “All the friends were very daring and would risk any difficulty, because they were confident that Krsna would help them to be victorious in all adventures (pg. 333).”

Anubhavas of Suhrts (Older Friends) Krsna's older friends express their devotion by instructing Krsna on what is to be done and what is not to be done. “They used to sit together and advise one another what to do, sometimes inducing one another to be engaged in welfare work (pg. 333).” The phrase "inducing one another to be engaged in welfare work" means that they advised Krsna to engage in auspicious activities.

Anubhavas of Sakhas (Younger Friends) “Sometimes they would offer betel nuts to one another, decorate one another's faces with tilaka or smear pulp of candana on one another's bodies. Sometimes, for the sake of amusement, they used to decorate their faces in strange ways (pg. 333).”

Anubhavas of Priya-Sakhas (Peers) “Another business of the friends was that each of them wanted to defeat Krsna. Sometimes they used to snatch His clothing or snatch away the flowers from His hands. Sometimes one would try to induce another to decorate his body for him, and failing this, they were always ready to fight, challenging one another to combat in wrestling (pg. 333).”

Anubhavas of Priya-Narma-Sakhas (Confidential Friends) “...they served as messengers to and from the gopis; they introduced the gopis to Krsna and canvassed for Krsna. When the gopis were in disagreement with Krsna, these friends would support Krsna's side in His presence — but when Krsna was not present, they would support the side of the gopis.” In other words, they engaged in highly diplomatic behavior to reconcile Krsna and the gopis. “In this way, sometimes supporting one side, sometimes the other, they would talk very privately, with much whispering in the ears, although none of the business was very serious (pg. 333).” 230

Sadharana (Common) Anubhavas of Sakhya-Rasa Described above are the anubhavas highly specific to each type of friend. There are also anubhavas that are common to all types of friends: “The servants of Krsna were sometimes engaged in collecting flowers, decorating His body with valuable ornaments and trinkets, dancing before Him, singing, helping Him herd the cows, massaging His body, preparing flower garlands and sometimes fanning His body (pg. 333).”

Sattvika-Bhava All eight sattvika-bhavas are appropriate to sakhya-bhava.

Stambha — Stunned “When Krsna came out from the Yamuna after chastising the Kaliya-naga, Sridama wanted to embrace Him first, but he could not raise his arms because of his great feeling of respect (pg. 333).” When Sridama saw Krsna entangled in the Kaliya serpent he became stunned. When Krsna came out victoriously from the lake, he could not raise his still-stunned arms to embrace Krsna.

Sveda — perspiration “When Krsna's flute roared like a thundercloud under the Svati constellation, the resulting perspiration on Sridama's body appeared to be just like pearls (pg. 334).”

Romanca — Standing of the Hairs In Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu the quotation about Subala embracing Krsna illustrates romanca. When Subala embraced Sri Krsna, the hairs on his arms were standing in ecstasy. In The Nectar of Devotion, Srila Prabhupada uses the same quotation to highlight the sentiments of Srimati Radharani.

Four Sattvika-Bhavas The following quotation exemplifies four other sattvika-bhavas in fraternal ecstasy: (1) svarabheda — faltering or distortion of the voice, (2) vaivarnya — changing of bodily color, (3) pralaya — loss of consciousness, and (4) kampa — trembling. “When Krsna entered the lake of Kaliya, His intimate friends became so perturbed that their bodily colors faded [vaivarnya], and they all produced horrible gurgling sounds [svarabheda]. At that time all of them fell down on the ground as if unconscious [pralaya] (pg. 334).” Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu mentions that they were also trembling [kampa].

Asru — Tears “Similarly, when there was a forest fire, all of Krsna's friends neglected their own protection and surrounded Krsna on all sides to protect Him from the flames (pg. 334).” Bhakti-rasamrtasindhu describes that floods of tears were pouring from the eyes of these boys as they lovingly protected their friend Krsna.

231

Vyabhicari-Bhava “In vyabhicari ecstatic love for Krsna there is sometimes madness, dexterity, fear, laziness, jubilation, pride, dizziness, meditation, disease, forgetfulness and humbleness (pg. 334).” This is a partial list of the vyabhicari-bhavas that manifest in sakhya-rasa. Srila Prabhupada says, “These are some of the common symptoms in the stage of vyabhicari ecstatic love for Krsna (pg. 334).” 4

Sthayi-Bhava The permanent ecstasy of fraternal love has one essential ingredient: the devotee deals with Krsna on an equal level, as a peer. Srila Prabhupada says, “When there are dealings between Krsna and His friends which are completely devoid of any feelings of respect and they all treat one another on an equal level, such ecstatic love in friendship is called sthayi (pg. 334).” “An example of sthayi was exhibited when Arjuna [the cowherd boy] told Akrura, 'My dear son of Gandini, please ask Krsna when I shall be able to embrace Him in my arms (pg. 334).” This illustrates the basic mood (sthayi-bhava) of intimate friendship in sakhya-rasa.

Stages of Prema in Friendship Sakhya-rati can heighten to: (1) pranaya — attraction, (2) prema — affection, (3) sneha — affinity, (4) raga — attachment. 5 Srila Prabhupada explains, “When one is situated in this confidential friendly relationship with Krsna, one shows symptoms of love such as attraction [pranaya], affection [prema], affinity [sneha] and attachment [raga] (pg. 334).” 6

Sakhya-rati at Pranaya Devotees have full knowledge of the Lord's supremacy. But when their affection is extremely intense it outshines this knowledge, and causes them to relate with Krsna purely on friendly terms, free from formalities of respect. This is the characteristic of pranaya. Srila Prabhupada explains, “When there is full knowledge of Krsna's superiority and yet in dealings with Him on friendly terms respectfulness is completely absent, that stage is called affection (page 335).” Example “There is one brilliant example of this affection. When the demigods, headed by Lord Siva, were offering respectful prayers to Krsna, describing the glorious opulences of the Lord, Arjuna [the cowherd boy] stood before Him with his hand on His shoulders and brushed the dust from His peacock feather (pg. 335).”

4 5 6

See Appendix B for full list of vybhicäré-bhäva in sakhya-rasa. Rasas progress through the levels of prema in different orders. In däsya-rasa the progression is prema, sneha, räga. In sakhya-rasa, however, the progression is first pranaya, then prema, sneha, and räga. The term "confidential" refers to viçrambha — friendly relationship on an entirely equal level. 232

This wonderfully illustrates the quality of pranaya: an unchecked predominance of pure love, devoid of formality.

Sakhya-Rati at Prema The Pandavas illustrate the level of prema (unchanging, never-diminishing love) in friendship. Despite all the troubles Krsna put them through, their friendly love for Him never even slightly diminished. (See pg. 335.)

Sakhya-Rati at Sneha In sneha, one's heart melts, and he cannot withstand a moment of separation. This example illustrates the first quality: “In the pasturing ground Krsna felt a little tired and wanted to take rest, so He lay down on the ground. At that time, many cowherd boys assembled there and with great affection began to sing suitable songs so that Krsna would rest very nicely (pg. 335).” [Emphasis added.]

Sakhya-Rati at Raga In raga, Krsna's association transforms distress into happiness. Arjuna, pierced with showers of arrows during the Kuruksetra war, exemplifies this. “At that time, although Arjuna was being harmed by those arrows, he felt an ecstatic love for Krsna, and the arrows appeared to him like showers of flowers (pg. 335).” A second example of sakhya-rasa at the level of raga: “Once when a cowherd boy named Vrsabha was collecting flowers from the forest to prepare a garland to be offered to Krsna, the sun reached it's zenith, and although the sunshine was scorching hot, Vrsabha felt it to be like the moonshine.” Srila Prabhupada adds, “That is the way of rendering transcendental loving service to the Lord; when the devotees are put into great difficulties — like the Pandavas, as described above — they feel all their miserable conditions to be great facilities for serving the Lord (pg. 326).”

Meeting and Separation Sakhya-Rasa in Separation (Ayoga) Utkanthitva — Longing Narada told Krsna, “When Arjuna was learning the art of shooting arrows, he could not see You for so many days. But when You arrived there, he stopped all his activities and immediately embraced You (pg. 336).” Young Arjuna was longing to meet Krsna for the first time. Consequently, he exemplifies fraternal devotion in utkanthitva.

Viyoga — Absence Patri addressed Krsna thus, “My dear Lord, You protected the cowherd boys from the hunger of the Aghasura demon, and You protected them from the poisonous effects of the Kaliya snake. And You also saved them from the fierce forest fire. But I am suffering from Your separation, 233

which is more severe than the hunger of Aghasura, the poison of Lake Kaliya and the burning of the forest fire. So why should You not protect me from the pangs of separation? (pg. 336.)” Ten Emotions of Viyoga Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates the vyabhicari-bhavas that are appropriate for sakhya-rasa in viyoga. Tapa — Fever or Heat “Another friend once told Krsna, ‘My dear enemy of Kamsa, since You have left us, the heat of separation has become extraordinary. And this heat is felt more severely when we understand that in Bhandiravana You are being refreshed by the waves of the cooling river known as Bhanutanaya [Radharani].’ The purport is that when Krsna was engaged with Radharani, the cowherd boys headed by Subala were feeling great separation, and that was unbearable for them (pg. 336).” Krsata — Emaciation (Withering of the Limbs) “My dear Krsna, O killer of Aghasura, when You left Vrndavana to kill King Kamsa in Mathura, all the cowherd boys became bereft of their four bhutas [the elements earth, water, fire and space]. And the fifth bhuta, the air, was flowing very rapidly within their nostrils (pg. 336).” Jagarana — Sleeplessness “When one of Your friends was feeling much separation from You, there were tears covering his lotus eyes, and so the black drones of sleep became discouraged from entering his eyes and left that place (pg. 337).” Bumblebees collect honey from lotus flowers, but if the flowers are filled with water the bees cannot do their work. The lotus eyes of Krsna's friends became filled with tears, and thus the bumblebees of sleep could not do their work. The boys remained sleepless, crying in separation from their dear Krsna. Alambana-Sunyata — Helplessness, Unable to Find Shelter “Due to Krsna's departure from Vrndavana to Mathura, Krsna's dearest cowherd boys felt as mentally light as possible. They were like fragments of cotton, lighter than the air, and were all floating in the air without any shelter (pg. 337).” Adhrti — Nonattachment “Out of the sorrow of separation, all these boys forgot to take care of their cowherding and tried to forget all the melodious songs they used to sing in the pasturing ground. At last they had no desire to live anymore, being separated from Krsna (pg. 337).” In the absence of Krsna, the boys had no attachment to cowherding, to the songs they previously sung, nor even to life itself. Jadata — Inertness When Krsna left Vrndavana for Mathura, all the cowherd boys became inert and still, “like leafless trees on the tops of hills (pg. 337).” 234

Vyadhi — Disease “Sometimes they felt diseased from their separation from Krsna, and being so greatly disappointed, they were aimlessly wandering on the banks of the Yamuna (pg. 337).” Unmada — Madness “When Krsna was absent from Vrndavana, all the cowherd boys became bewildered... they appeared to be mad and forgot all their regular business... (pgs. 337 - 338).” Murcchita — Unconsciousness “My dear Lord, You have become the King of Mathura after killing Kamsa, and that is very good news for us. But at Vrndavana all the residents have become blind from their continuous crying over Your absence... (pg. 338).” Becoming 'blind' refers to loosing their consciousness. Mrti — Death “My dear enemy of Kamsa, because of their separation from You, the cowherd boys are suffering too much, and they are now lying down in the valleys, breathing only slightly... (pg. 338).”

Krsna's Friends are Never Separated From Him "In the Mathura-khanda chapter of the Skanda Purana, there is a description of Krsna and Balarama, surrounded by all the cowherd boys, always engaging in taking care of the cows and calves." (pg. 338) Jiva Gosvami explains: Skanda Purana uses the word sada, "always" — which literally means "without ending." Krsna is always in Vrndavana, tending the cows with His friends. In the eternal spiritual world, Krsna and his friends are never significantly separated, although the experience of such emotions certainly exists in a subjective sense. Gerenally, the cowherd boys experience physical separation only in Gokula Vrndavana (Vrndavana manifest on the earth).

Sakhya-Rasa in Meeting (Yoga) Siddhi — Perfection “When Krsna was met by Arjuna at a potter's shop in the city of Drupada-nagara, because of the similarity of their bodily features they made intimate friendship (pg. 338).” This was the first time that Arjuna ever saw Krsna; thus it exemplifies siddhi.

Tusti — Satisfaction Tusti occurs when the devotee meets Krsna after a long absence. Bhima meeting Krsna in Indraprastha (described in Srimad-Bhagavatam 10.71.27), and the cowherd boys meeting Krsna again at Kuruksetra are examples of tusti. (See page 338).

Sthiti — Steady Association Sthiti is a type of meeting not predicated by any separation. Srimad-Bhagavatam 10.12.12 illustrating this. The cowherd boys are superior even to great yogis. The yogis are unable to see 235

so much as the dust of Krsna's lotus feet, even after arduous struggle. The cowherd boys, on the other hand, perform no penance whatsoever, yet constantly see the beautiful Lord face to face. This constant vision of Krsna is an example of sthiti.

Speciality of Fraternal Devotion Sakhya-rasa has a special sweetness not found in dasya or vatsalya. In dasya the devotee loves the Lord as his master, and the Lord loves the devotee as His servant. In vatsalya the devotee loves the Lord as his son, and the Lord loves the devotee as His parent. In sakhya, however, the feelings of Krsna and the devotee are exactly mutual — the devotee loves the Lord as his friend, and the Lord loves the devotee as His friend. Fraternal love and conjugal love are the only relationships in which the Lord and the devotee feel exactly the same way towards each other. Therefore, Srila Prabhupada states, “The friendly relationship of the cowherd boys with Krsna is a particular type of spiritual ecstasy almost similar to the ecstasy of conjugal love (pg. 339).” Thus there is a special type of sweetness nourished by fraternal devotion. “Great expert devotees like Rupa Gosvami express their astonishment at the inconceivable feelings which are in Krsna and His cowherd boyfriends (pg. 339).”

236

Western Ocean Fourth Wave Vatsalya-Rasa Chapter 43

237

Chapter 43 Parenthood BRS 3.4.1 - 83

Definition When vatsalya-rati is nourished by appropriate bhavas, it heightens into vatsalya-rasa. Srila Prabhupada says, “When ecstatic love develops into the relationship of parenthood and becomes steadily established, the relationship is called vatsalya-rasa (page 341).”

Main Characteristic of Parental Love Anugraha (compassion and mercy towards Krsna) is the main characteristic of parental affection. Anugraha flows from a senior towards a junior. Consequently, parental devotees maintain a mood of seniority to Krsna. Srila Prabhupada says, “The exhibition of this vatsalya-rasa standard of devotional service can be found in the dealings of Krsna with His devotees who represent themselves as superior personalities like father, mother and teacher (page 341).”

COMPONENTS OF VATSALYA-RASA Vibhava Visaya-Alambana Krsna as a Stimulus for Parental Affection Krsna's Form “The Supreme Personality of Godhead, whose bodily complexion is just like a bluish, newgrown lotus flower, whose body is very delicate and whose lotus eyes are surrounded by scattered hair as black as bees... (page 341).” Krsna's Qualities “...His blackish bodily hue... His all-auspicious bodily features, His mildness, His sweet words, His simplicity, His shyness, His humility, His constant readiness to offer respect to the elderly and His charity. All of these qualities are considered ecstatic provocations for parental love (page 341).” Lordly Qualities Qualities that reveal Krsna's supremacy do not stimulate vatsalya-rasa, because they interfere with the devotee's mood of seniority. Consequently, parental devotees do not give much credence to displays of Krsna's opulence. 1

1

To authenticate this, Çréla Rüpa Go svämé quotes SB 10.8.45:“...m other Yaçodä accepted Lord Kåñna as her son, although He is accepted in the Vedas as the King of heav en, in the Upaniñads as the im personal Brahm an, in 238

Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates this, “Once mother Yasoda addressed one of her friends in this way: ‘Nanda Maharaja, the leader of the cowherd men, worshiped Lord Visnu, along with me, and as a result of this worship, Krsna has been saved from the clutches of Putana and other demons. The twin arjuna trees were, of course, broken due to a strong wind, and although Krsna appeared to have lifted Govardhana Hill along with Balarama, I think that Nanda Maharaja actually held the mountain. Otherwise how could it have been possible for a little boy to lift such a great hill?’ (pages 341 - 342).”

Asraya-Alambana The Devotee as a Stimulus for Parental Affection The devotee who has anugraha is a stimulus for vatsalya-rasa. In this connection, Srila Rupa Gosvami quotes, “Let me take shelter of the elderly parental devotees of Lord Krsna. They are always anxious to serve Krsna and to maintain Him, and they are always so kind to Him. Let us offer our respectful obeisances unto them for being so kind to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is the parent of the whole universe! (page 342).” In his commentary, Srila Prabhupada writes, “There is a similar prayer by a brahmana who says, "Let others worship the Vedas and the Upanisads, and let others worship the Mahabharata if they are afraid of material existence and want to become liberated from that condition. But as far as I am concerned, I wish only to worship Maharaja Nanda, because the supreme absolute Personality of Godhead, Krsna, is crawling in his courtyard as his own child (page 342).” Principal Parental Devotees “Following is a list of respectful personalities who enjoy parental affection toward Krsna: (1) mother Yasoda, the Queen of Vraja, (2) Maharaja Nanda, the King of Vraja, (3) mother Rohini, the mother of Balarama, (4) all the elderly gopis whose sons were taken away by Lord Brahma, (5) Devaki, the wife of Vasudeva, (6) the other fifteen wives of Vasudeva, (7) Kunti, the mother of Arjuna, (8) Vasudeva, the real father of Krsna and (9) Sandipani Muni, Krsna's teacher (page 342).” 2 Foremost Parental Devotees Yasoda and Nanda are the foremost parental devotees. Yasoda's Form “My dear King, the wide hips of mother Yasoda were surrounded by silk and linen clothes, and her breasts were flowing with milk because of her affection...(page 342).” 3 Srila Rupa Gosvami gives a second description: “Let me be given protection by mother Yasoda, whose curly hairs are bound with thread, whose hair is very brightly beautified by the vermilion placed in the part and whose bodily frame derides all her ornaments... (page 343).”

2 3

philosophy as the suprem e male, by the yogis as the Supe rsoul and by the devotees as the Suprem e Personality of Godhead (NOD, page 341).” This shows how mother Yaçodä ignored the Lordly features of Kåñna. This list is in order of importance. Çrémad-Bhägavatam 10.9.3. 239

Yasoda's Bhakti “After rising early in the morning, mother Yasoda first of all offered her breast milk to Krsna, and then she began to chant various mantras for His protection... (page 343).” Nanda's Form “The hairs on his head are generally black, but some of them are gray. His garments are of greenish color, like the new-grown leaves of a banyan tree. His belly is fatty, his complexion is exactly like the full moon, and he has a beautiful mustache (page 343).” Nanda's Bhakti “When Krsna was a baby, one day He was walking in the courtyard, capturing the finger of His father, and because He could not walk steadily He appeared to be almost falling down. While Nanda Maharaja was giving protection to His transcendental son in this way, all of a sudden there were drops of tears in his eyes, and he became overwhelmed with joy... (page 343)”

Uddipana Objects that Impel Parental Love “Childhood age, childish dress, movements by the child, sweet words spoken by the child, nice smiling and various forms of childish play are considered provocations for increasing parental love for Krsna (page 343).”

Kaumara — Childhood Age Kaumara (birth through five years old) is the age most conducive to parental love. “The childhood ages of Krsna are divided into three periods: the beginning of kaumara age, the middle of kaumara age and the end of kaumara age (page 343).” Adya Kaumara Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the form, activities, and ornaments of Krsna's adya-kaumara (birth through one year old). Rupa — form “During the beginning and middle of the kaumara age, Krsna's thighs are fatty, and the inner part of His eyes are whitish. There are signs of teeth coming out, and He is very mild and gentle.” Srila Rupa Gosvami cites an example of how this beautiful form impels parental affection: “When Krsna had only three or four teeth coming out of His gums, His thighs were fatty, His body was very, very short, and He began to enhance the parental love of Nanda Maharaja and mother Yasoda with the activities of His childish body. (pages 343 - 344).” 4

4

The last phrase in this quotation should read: "and He bega n to enhance t he parental love of Nanda M ahäräja and mother Yaçodä with the beauty of His childish body." Instead of "beauty," Çréla Prabhupäda says "activities." This is because his summary study is beginning to introduce the next subject: ceñöa— activities. 240

Cesta — Exploits “He began to enhance the parental love of Nanda Maharaja and mother Yasoda with the activities of His childish body. He was sometimes stepping with His legs again and again, sometimes crying, sometimes smiling, sometimes sucking His thumb and sometimes lying down flat. These are some of the different activities of the child Krsna (page 344).” Srila Rupa Gosvami cites an example of how these activities impel parental affection: “When Krsna was lying down flat, sometimes sucking the toes of His feet, sometimes throwing His legs upward, sometimes crying and sometimes smiling, mother Yasoda, seeing her son in such pastimes, did not show any sign of restricting Him, but rather began to watch her child with eagerness, enjoying these childhood pastimes.” Mandana — Ornaments “In the beginning of Krsna's kaumara age, the nails of tigers were set in a golden necklace about His neck. There was protective tilaka on His forehead, black mascara around His eyes and silk thread around His waist (page 344).” Srila Rupa Gosvami cites an example of how these ornaments impel parental affection: “When Nanda Maharaja saw the beauty of child Krsna, with tiger nails on His chest... he never became satiated by the child's beauty (page 344).” Madhya-Kaumara Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the form and ornaments of Krsna's madhyama-kaumara (two through three years old). Rupa — Form Srila Rupa Gosvami describes Krsna's form in madhyama-kaumara, then cites an example of how this form impels parental ecstasy: “His scattered hairs were touching His eyebrows, and His eyes were restless, but He could not express His feelings with proper words; still, when He was talking, His talk was so nice and sweet to hear. When mother Yasoda looked at His little ears and saw Him naked, trying to run very quickly with His little legs, she was merged into the ocean of nectar (page 344).” Mandana — Ornaments Srila Rupa Gosvami describes Krsna's ornaments at this age, then cites an example of how these ornaments impel parental ecstasy: “...when mother Yasoda saw that the child was moving, ringing the bells on His waist, smiling at her with a pearl between His nostrils and with butter on His hands, she became wonderfully pleased to see her little child in that fashion (pages 344 345).” Sesa-Kaumara Srila Rupa Gosvami similarly describes the form, ornaments, and activities of sesa-kaumara (four through five years old). Rupa — Form “While Krsna was in the [end] of His kaumara age, His waist became thinner, His chest became broader, and His head was decorated with His curly hairs, resembling the falling of the wings of 241

a crow. These wonderful features of Krsna's body never failed to astonish mother Yasoda (page 345).” 5 Mandana — Ornaments “At the end of His kaumara age, Krsna carried a small stick in His hand, His clothing was a little longer, and He had a knot around His waist, resembling the hood of a snake (page 345).” Cesta — Activities “...He used to take care of the calves near the house, and sometimes He played with cowherd boys of about the same age. He had a slender flute and a buffalo-horn bugle, and sometimes He played on a flute made from the leaves of trees (page 345).” As Krsna grew up a little, His cowherding would wander farther away from home. Sometimes He would return a little late, impelling great anxiety to overwhelm His parents. (See page 345). Other Ages Krsna's kaumara age is the primary uddipana for parental affection. However, even when Krsna is in pauganda or kaisora, parental devotees still see Him as their baby and thus feel an impetus to parental devotion. “When Krsna, the beloved son of Nanda Maharaja, steps into His kaisora age, although He becomes more beautiful, His parents still consider Him to be in the pauganda age — even though He is between the ages of ten and fifteen (pages 345 - 346).” The devotee sees through the eyes of love. The color of that love tints one's vision, causing one to perceive Krsna in the way most suitable to one's loving relationship with Him. Thus, Pauganda-Krsna can still stimulate parental affection in a devotee who has that mood. Srila Rupa Gosvami gives the following example: “Mother Yasoda would then address Nanda Maharaja, ‘See my dear son, whose eyes are white, who has a turban on His head, a wrapper on His body and leg bells which tinkle very sweetly on His feet. He is coming near, along with His surabhi calves, and just see how He is wandering upon the sacred land of Vrndavana!’ (page 345).” White eyes, turban, chaddar, and ankle bells are symptoms of pauganda. Even Kaisora-Krsna can stimulate parental affection: “...Maharaja Nanda would address his wife, ‘My dear Yasoda, just look at your offspring, Krsna! See His blackish bodily luster, His eyes tinged with red color, His broad chest and His nice golden necklace! How wonderful He looks, and how He is increasing my transcendental bliss more and more!’ (page 345).” Dark complexion, reddish eyes, broad chest, and gold necklace are symptoms of kaisora.

Saisava Capalya — Childish Movements Previously, Srila Prabhupada listed the uddipanas for vatsalya-rasa: “Childhood age, childish dress, movements by the child, sweet words spoken by the child, nice smiling and various forms of childish play are considered provocations for increasing parental love for Krsna (page 343).”

5

The sentence, “While Kåñna was in the beginning of His kaumära age...” should read: “While Kåñna was in the end of His kaumära age...” (See BRS 3.4.30) 242

Having finished his elaborate description of "childhood age," Srila Rupa Gosvami now describes "childish movements" — saisava capalya. “When Krsna performs His childish pastimes, His general practice is to break the milk and yogurt pots, throw the yogurt in the courtyard and steal the cream from the milk... (page 346).” Srila Rupa Gosvami cites an example of how this activity impels parental ecstasy: Mother Yasoda said, “Just look at Krsna looking stealthily toward all sides and slowly stepping forward from the bushes. It appears that He is coming just to steal the butter. Don't expose yourself or He may understand that we are looking toward Him. I want to enjoy the sight of His eyebrows moving in this cunning way, and I want to see His fearful eyes and beautiful face (page 346).”

Anubhava Asadharana-Anubhava Manifestations of Ecstasy Unique to Parental Affection “...mother Yasoda experienced the ecstasy of maternal love by smelling His head, sometimes patting His body with her hand, sometimes offering blessings, sometimes ordering Him, sometimes gazing at Him, sometimes maintaining Him and sometimes giving Him good instructions not to become a thief (page 346).” Srila Prabhupada adds, “An important point to be observed in this connection is that the childish propensity of stealing is there even in the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and therefore this propensity is not artificial. However, in the spiritual relationship there is no inebriety to this stealing propensity, as there is in the material world (page 346).” Example of "Smelling Krsna's Head" Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates this with two examples. The first is Srimad-Bhagavatam (10.13.33). The second: “In their childhood pastimes, all these cowherd boys joined with Krsna in stealing butter. But rather than become angry, mother Yasoda became wet from the milk flowing out of her breasts. Out of her affection for Krsna, she began to smell His head repeatedly (Page 346).”

Sadharana-Anubhava Manifestations of Ecstasy Shared with Other Rasas “The general activities of all the mothers of the cowherd boys were to kiss them, to embrace them, to call them by their names and sometimes to chastise them mildly for their stealing habits (page 346).”

Sattvika-Bhava All eight sattvika-bhavas can fully manifest in vatsalya-rasa. “These manifestations of parental love are called sattvika ecstasy, wherein manifestations of eight kinds of ecstatic symptoms are visible in full (page 347).”

243

Asadharana-Sattvika-Bhava There is an additional symptom found exclusively in motherly devotees: milk flowing from the breasts. Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates this with two examples (Srimad-Bhagavatam and Lalitamadhava). (See pg. 347.) Srila Prabhupada comments on the verse from Lalita-madhava. “It is the custom in the temples of Deities that if there have been some impure activities, the Deity has to be washed with milk. Krsna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and He was washed by the milk from the breast of mother Yasoda, which purified Him from the dust covering (page 347).”

Example of Stambha Srila Rupa Gosvami also illustrates stambha (stunned): When mother Yasoda saw her son lifting Govardhana Hill, she “hesitated to embrace Him and became stunned... (page 347).”

Vyabhicari-Bhava All thirty-three vyabhicari-bhavas are appropriate in vatsalya-rasa.

Example of Harsa — Jubilation “Mother Yasoda sometimes enjoyed transcendental ecstasy in happiness when her child was saved from a dangerous situation, such as being attacked by Putana or some other demon (page 347).” Srila Rupa Gosvami cites instances of such jubilation from Srimad-Bhagavatam (10.17.19) and Vidagdha-madhava. (See pages 347 - 348).

Sthayi-Bhava Vatsalya-rati is the sthayi-bhava of vatsalya-rasa. The main characteristic of vatsalya-rati is anugraha — protective compassion and mercy towards Krsna, free from all restraints of formal reverence. Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates vatsalya-rati with two quotes. The first is SrimadBhagavatam 10.6.43. The second: “A similar statement is there in connection with mother Yasoda when she was too anxious to hear the sound of Krsna's flute, expecting Him back from the pasturing ground. Because she thought that it was getting very late, her anxiety to hear the sound of Krsna's flute became doubled, and milk began to flow from her breast. In that condition she was sometimes going within the house, sometimes coming out of the house. She was constantly looking to see if Govinda was coming back along the road (page 348).”

Stages of Prema in Vatsalya-Rasa Vatsalya-rati can heighten to prema, sneha, and raga. Srila Prabhupada explains, “The parental love of mother Yasoda for Krsna steadily increases, and her love and ecstasy are sometimes described as intense affection and sometimes as overwhelming attachment (page 348).” 6 6

In this quote, Çréla Prabhupäda utilizes the following terminology: "parental love" — prema; "intense affection" — sneha; "overwhelming attachment" — räga. 244

Prema “When many very great sages were offering prayers to Lord Krsna, glorifying His activities, the Queen of Gokula, mother Yasoda, entered the Battlefield of Kuruksetra, wetting the lower part of her sari with the milk flowing from her breast (page 348).” 7 At prema, one's love for Krsna never wavers, even if there is sufficient cause. The presence of Krsna in His royal mode, surrounded by great sages offering respectful panegyric, invokes profound awe and reverence. This certainly interferes with the mood of anugraha and thus causes parental affection to diminish. However, despite these unfavorable circumstances, mother Yasoda's maternal love did not waver or diminish even a fraction of an inch, as evidenced by the milk flowing from her breast. Another example: when Krsna arrived in Kuruksetra, everyone jubilantly announced that the son of Devaki and Vasudeva had arrived. Hearing Krsna proclaimed to be someone else's son would certainly put a damper on Nanda and Yasoda's parental love. However, their love did not even slightly waver or diminish. Instead, they became overwhelmed with parental affection and expressed great pleasure. (See pages 348 - 349).

Sneha “My dear Queen [Yasoda], the milk flowing out of your breast-mountain has already whitened the River Ganges, and the tears from your eyes, mixed with black mascara, have already blackened the color of the Yamuna. And as you are standing just between the two rivers, I think that there is no need for your anxiety to see your son's face. Your parental affection has already been exhibited to Him by these two rivers! (page 349).” Yasoda-devi had decided to visit Krsna at Kuruksetra, but her friend tried to dissuade her: "You want to express your affection to your son, but you need not go to Kuruksetra to accomplish this. It has already been accomplished. The milk flowing from your breast has whitened the Ganges, and your tears have blackened the Yamuna with the mascara washed from your eyes. These two rivers mix together and flow to Krsna's lotus feet in Kuruksetra, expressing your affection to Him." Mother Yasoda's affection is in sneha — which is characterized by: (1) inability to withstand separation, and (2) melting of the heart. Profuse tears and flowing milk are indications of a melted heart.

Raga In raga, meeting with Krsna transforms distress into happiness, and separation from Krsna transforms happiness into distress. If mother Yasoda could see Krsna's face, then even scorching fire would seem as pleasantly cooling as Himalayan ice. If she could not see Krsna's face, even the ocean of nectar would seem like an ocean of arsenic. (See pg. 349.)

Separation and Meeting

7

Çréla Prabhupäda com ments, “This entrance of m other Yaçodä at Kurukñetra was not during the Battle of Kurukñetra. At other times Kåñna went to Kurukñetra from His paternal home (Dvärakä) during the solar eclipse, and at these times the residents of Våndävana also went to see Him there (page 348).” 245

Ayoga — Separation Utkanthitva — Longing Queen Kunti's statement to Akrura occurred before Krsna had left Vrndavana for Dvaraka. Therefore, it exemplifies the longing to see Krsna for the first time. (See pg. 349.)

Viyoga — Absence Srimad-Bhagavatam 10.46.28 exemplifies viyoga in vatsalya-rasa. Another example: “...when Krsna went to Mathura mother Yasoda was looking at Krsna's makeup utensils, and she fell down on the ground almost unconscious, with a great sound. When she was rolling over on the ground, there were many scratches on her body, and in that piteous condition she began to cry, ‘O my dear son! My dear son!’ And she slapped her breasts with her two hands (page 349).” Ten Emotions of Viyoga There are ten vyabhicari-bhavas appropriate to vatsalya-rasa in viyoga: “...great anxiety, lamentation, frustration, being stunned, humility, restlessness, madness and illusion (page 349).” Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates them. Cinta — Anxiety “Yasoda, I think your movements have been slackened, and I see that you are full of anxieties... All these conditions prove that out of separation from your son you have a severe headache (page 350).” Visada — Lamentation When Akrura told Yasoda that Krsna had married so many queens in Dvaraka, she lamented. If she could have married Krsna to a nice Vrndavana girl, Krsna would have stayed nearby. Therefore, upon hearing Akrura's news, she exclaimed, “My dear Akrura, you are simply throwing thunderbolts on my head! (page 350).” Nirveda — Self Disparagement Mother Yasoda had so much opulence. But since her son had left for Dvaraka, she was unable to use it in His service. Therefore she condemned her useless opulence. (See page 350). Jadata — Inertness When Yasoda sees the walking stick Krsna used when He was in Vrndavana, she becomes motionless (jadata) with feelings of separation. (See page 350) Dainya — Humility “In separation from Krsna, mother Yasoda became so humble that she prayed to the creator of the universe, Lord Brahma, with tears in her eyes, ‘My dear creator, won't you kindly bring my dear son Krsna back to me so that I can see Him at least for a moment?’ (page 350).”

246

Capalya — Restlessness “Sometimes, in restlessness like a madwoman, mother Yasoda used to accuse Nanda Maharaja, ‘What are you doing in the palace? You shameless man! Why do people call you the King of Vraja? It is very astonishing that while being separated from your dear son Krsna, you are still living within Vrndavana as a hardhearted father!’ (page 350).” Unmada — Madness Mother Yasoda used to wander all over Vrndavana asking the trees and birds about Krsna. (See page 351) Moha — Illusion In the illusion caused by separation, Nanda Maharaja imagined that Krsna was standing right in front of him. “When Nanda Maharaja was accused by mother Yasoda of being "hardhearted," he replied, My dear Yasoda, why are you becoming so agitated? Kindly look more carefully. Just see, your son Krsna is standing before you! Don't become a madwoman like this. Please keep my home peaceful (page 351)."

Yoga — Meeting Siddhi — Perfectional Meeting Siddhi occurs when the devotee meets Krsna for the first time. When Krsna appeared in the arena of Kamsa, it was the first time that the other wives of Vasudeva got the opportunity to see Him. (See page 351)

Tusti — Satisfaction Tusti occurs when the devotee is reunited with Krsna after a long absence. “When Krsna entered Dvaraka after finishing the Battle of Kuruksetra, He first of all saw His mother and all His different stepmothers and offered His respectful obeisances unto their feet... (page 351).” The quotation from Lalita-madhava illustrates mother Yasoda's joy upon being reunited with her son.

Sthiti — Constant Meeting “My dear Mukunda, just after seeing Your face, which was full with the scent of the lotus flower, mother Yasoda, being attracted by the moonlight of Your face, became so overjoyed in her affection that immediately from the nipples of her waterpotlike breasts, milk began to flow (pages 351 - 352).” This reference illustrates sthiti (constant association) in a very interesting way. Jiva Gosvami explains: After living in Dvaraka for many years, Krsna killed Dantavakra and then returned to Mathura. There he rested at Visrama-Ghata, laid down His kingly attire, and returned to Vrndavana. 8 After 44 years of separation, mother Yasoda's love for Krsna was as intense as it had been the day He left — evidenced by the milk that continually flowed from her breast. Yasoda-devi's 8

See BRS 3.4.76, com: Jéva Gosvämé.

247

maternal love was constant (sthiti), and afforded her the constant association of Krsna (sthitiyoga) even in His apparent absence.

Summary of Sthayi-Bhava The characteristic of vatsalya-rati is a feeling that Krsna is one's helplessly dependant child. Srila Prabhupada says, “Symptoms of ecstatic love in parental affection are expressed when Krsna is accepted as the son. These constant transcendental emotions for Krsna are called steady ecstasy in parental love (page 352).”

Combinations of Vatsalya, Sakhya, and Dasya The remainder of the chapter illustrates a variety ways that these three mellows combine in different devotees. Balarama and Yudhisthira are friends — but this friendship is combined with parental affection (due to their seniority), and servitude (due to their awareness of Krsna's Godhood). Ugrasena, Krsna's grandfather, has the mood of servitude — but it is combined with parental affection. The elderly gopis have parental love, combined with servitude and friendship. Nakula, Sahadeva, and Narada have fraternal love, combined with servitorship. Siva, Garuda, and Uddhava are servants — but their mood is combined with a touch of friendship.

248

Western Ocean Fifth Wave Madhurya-Rasa Chapter 44

249

Chapter 44

Devotional Service in Conjugal Love BRS 3.5.1 - 37

Definition When madhurya-rati is nourished by the appropriate bhavas, it heightens to madhurya-rasa. Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “A pure devotee's attraction to Krsna in conjugal love is called devotional service in conjugal love (page 353).”

Brief Description of Madurya-Rasa Madhurya-rasa is a very lengthy subject, but Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu describes it only briefly. Srila Rupa Gosvami reasons that non-devotees attached to sense gratification will pollute their understanding of madhurya-rasa with lusty material associations. Srila Prabhupada says, “Although such conjugal feelings are not at all material, there is some similarity between this spiritual love and material activities. Therefore, persons who are interested only in material activities are unable to understand this spiritual conjugal love... (page 353).” Madhurya-rasa is a confidential and mysterious subject. Consequently, it is not discussed very openly. “...these devotional reciprocations appear very mysterious to them. Rupa Gosvami therefore describes conjugal love very briefly (page 353).” Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu gives only a brief description of madhurya-rasa because it is an advanced subject, easily misunderstood by common people. Srila Rupa Gosvami wrote a separate book, Ujjvala-nilamani, for those who are qualified to understand these topics.

Vibhava In madhurya-rasa, Sri Krsna is visaya-alambana and the gopis are asraya-alambana. Srila Prabhupada explains, “The impetuses of conjugal love are Krsna and His very dear consorts, such as Radharani and Her immediate associates (page 353).”

Visaya-Alambana Krsna as a Stimulus for Conjugal Attraction Krsna's Form “Lord Krsna has no rival; no one is equal to Him, and no one is greater than Him. His beauty is also without any rival, and because He excels all others in the pastimes of conjugal love, He is the original object of all conjugal love (page 353).” Krsna's Qualities “In the Gita-govinda, by Jayadeva Gosvami, one gopi tells her friend, ‘Krsna is the reservoir of all pleasure within this universe. His body is as soft as the lotus flower. And His free behavior with the gopis, which appears exactly like a young boy's attraction to a young girl, is a subject matter of transcendental conjugal love.’ (page 353).”

250

Asraya-Alambana The Devotee as a Stimulus for Conjugal Attraction “A pure devotee follows in the footsteps of the gopis and worships the gopis as follows: ‘Let me offer my respectful obeisances to all the young cowherd girls, whose bodily features are so attractive. Simply by their beautiful attractive features they are worshiping the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krsna.’ (page 353).” The Best Devotee in Madhurya-Rasa “Out of all the young gopis, Srimati Radharani is the most prominent (page 353).” Srimati Radharani's Beautiful Form “Her eyes defeat the attractive features of the eyes of the cakori bird. When one sees the face of Radharani, he immediately hates the beauty of the moon. Her bodily complexion defeats the beauty of gold. Thus, let us all look upon the transcendental beauty of Srimati Radharani (pages 353 - 354).” Srimati Radharani's Bhakti “Krsna's attraction for Radharani is described by Krsna Himself thus: ‘When I create some joking phrases in order to enjoy the beauty of Radharani, Radharani hears these joking words with great attention; but by Her bodily features and counterwords She neglects Me. And I even possess unlimited pleasure by Her neglect of Me, for She becomes so beautiful that She increases My pleasure one hundred times.’ (page 354).” Krsna's Devotion for Srimati Radharani “A similar statement can be found in Gita-govinda, wherein it is said that when the enemy of Kamsa, Sri Krsna, embraces Srimati Radharani, He immediately becomes entangled in a loving condition and gives up the company of all other gopis (page 354).”

Uddipana Objects that Impel Conjugal Love Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of Krsna's flute as an uddipana for madurya-rasa: “In the Padyavali of Rupa Gosvami it is stated that when the gopis hear the sound of Krsna's flute, they immediately forget all rebukes offered by the elderly members of their families. They forget their defamation and the harsh behavior of their husbands. Their only thought is to go out in search of Krsna (page 354).” 1

Anubhava “When the gopis meet Krsna, the display of their exchanging glances as well as their joking and laughing behavior is called anubhava, or subecstasy in conjugal love (page 354).” Example: “In the Lalita-madhava, Rupa Gosvami explains that the movements of Krsna's eyebrows are just like the Yamuna and that the smiling of Radharani is just like the moonshine. 1

Anot her uddépana for mädhurya-rasa is Kåñna's kaiçora age. For an extensive description see Waves of Devotion, page . 251

When the Yamuna and the moonshine come in contact on the bank of the river, the water tastes just like nectar, and drinking it gives great satisfaction. It is as cooling as piles of snow (page 354).”

Sattvika-Bhava “Similarly, in the Padyavali, one constant companion of Radharani says, ‘My dear moon-faced Radharani, Your whole body appears very content, yet there are signs of tears in Your eyes. Your speech is faltering, and Your chest is also heaving. By all these signs I can understand that You must have heard the blowing of Krsna's flute, and as a result of this, Your heart is now melting.’ (page 354).”

Vyabhicari-Bhava Srila Rupa Gosvami explains that all thirty-three vyabhicari-bhavas are appropriate in madhuryarasa, with the exception of two: alasya (laziness) and ugrata (ferocity). However, there are some cases when even laziness and violence may become appropriate. Laziness may be present at the end of conjugal pastimes. Ferocity may be present when there is interference to the association of Radha and Krsna. Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates two of the vyabhicari-bhavas for madhurya-rasa:

Nirveda — Self Disparagement “Srimati Radharani said, ‘Dear Mr. Cupid, please do not excite Me by throwing your arrows at My body. Dear Mr. Air, please do not arouse Me with the fragrance of flowers. I am now bereft of Krsna's loving attitude, and so, under the circumstances, what is the use of My sustaining this useless body? There is no need for such a body by any living entity.’ (page 354).”

Harsa — Jubilation Srimati Radharani says, “This clever boy of the forest has the beauty of a bluish lotus flower, and He can attract all the young girls of the universe. Now, after giving Me a taste of His transcendental body, He has enthused Me, and it is more than I can tolerate. I am now feeling like a female elephant who has been enthused by a male elephant! (page 355).”

Sthayi-Bhava Previously, in the Southern Ocean, Srila Rupa Gosvami described that Madhurya-rati is the sthayi-bhava of madhurya-rasa. 2 The characteristic of madhurya-rati is that it incites eight kinds of desires for union with Krsna (sambhoga). Srila Prabhupada mentions this: “The steady ecstasy of conjugal love is the original cause of bodily enjoyment (page 355).” 3

2 3

BRS 2.5.36. See Waves of Devotion, page . Çréla Prabhupäda uses the following terminology here: "Steady ecstasy of conjugal love" — mädhurya-rati; "bodily enjoyment" — sambhoga. For a descri ption of t he eight varieties of sambhoga, see foot note 5, on page 6 of t his chapter. 252

Example of Madhurya-Rati Srimati Radharani said, “My dear friend, who is this boy whose eyelids, dancing constantly, have increased the beauty of His face and attracted My desire for conjugal love? His ears are decorated with buds of asoka flowers, and He has dressed Himself in yellow robes. By the sound of His flute, this boy has already made Me impatient (page 355).” This illustrates how madhurya-rati incites sambhoga — the impatient desire to meet with Krsna in conjugal love. 4

Unshakeability of Madhurya-Rati “The conjugal love of Radha-Krsna is never disturbed by any personal consideration (page 355).” Some circumstances are favorable to conjugal love (sajatiya). Others are unfavorable (vijatiya). Regardless of whether the circumstance is favorable or unfavorable, conjugal affection cannot be subdued. For example: “Just a little distance away from Krsna was mother Yasoda, and Krsna was surrounded by all of His friends. In front of His eyes was Candravali, and, at the same time, on a chunk of stone in front of the entrance to Vraja stood the demon known as Vrsasura. But even in such circumstances, when Krsna saw Radharani standing just behind a bush of many creepers, immediately His beautiful eyebrows moved just like lightning toward Her (page 355).” This scene presents many unfavorable elements (vijatiya): (1) Mother Yasoda's presence invokes vatsalya-rasa — an obstacle to conjugal love. (2) Krsna's friends invoke sakhya-rasa — on obstacle to conjugal love. (3) Candravali-gopi is Srimati Radharani's arch-rival — another obstacle to Radha and Krsna's conjugal love. (4) Vrsasura the demon invokes bhayanaka-rasa (fear) — another obstacle to conjugal love. Despite all these opposing elements, Krsna's love for Srimati Radharani could not be subdued for even a moment. It immediately manifested in His loving glances towards Her. Srila Rupa Gosvami further highlights the unshakeability of madhurya-rati with a beautiful poetic analogy: “On one side of the courtyard the dead body of Saìkhasura was lying, surrounded by many jackals. On another side were many learned brahmanas who were all selfcontrolled. They were offering nice prayers, which were as soothing as the cool breeze in summer. In front of Krsna, Lord Baladeva was standing, causing a cooling effect (page 355).” In Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu 3.5.23, the Sanskrit word for "jackal" also indicates "inauspicious night," the prayers of the brahmanas are like snow, and Balarama is like the cooling moon. A day-blooming lotus flower withers in the presence of the night, the snow, and the moon. Similarly the lotus of Radha and Krsna's love should wither in the presence of a dead demon (who invokes fear), Vedic brahmanas (who invoke reverence), and Krsna's elder brother (who invokes proper behavior). “But even amid all these different circumstances of soothing and disturbing effects, the lotus flower of ecstatic conjugal love that Krsna felt for Radharani could not wither (page 355).”

Separation and Meeting

4

For a description of the eight varieties of sambhoga, see footnote 5, on page 6 of this chapter.

253

Srila Rupa Gosvami classifies separation and meeting in madhurya-rasa somewhat differently than the other rasas. “Conjugal love is divided into two portions: vipralambha, or conjugal love in separation, and sambhoga, or conjugal love in direct contact (page 355).”

Vipralambha — Separation “Vipralambha, separation, has three subdivisions, known as (1) purva-raga, or preliminary attraction, (2) mana, or seeming anger, and (3) pravasa, or separation by distance (page 355).”

Purva-Raga — Separation Prior to First Meeting Purva-raga is similar to utkanthitva. “When the lover and the beloved have a distinct feeling of not meeting each other, that stage is called purva-raga, or preliminary attraction (page 356).” An example of purva-raga is Radha and Krsna's preliminary meeting. Srimati Radharani said, “My dear friend, I was just going to the bank of the Yamuna, and all of a sudden a very nice boy whose complexion is like a dark blue cloud became visible in front of My eyes. He glanced over Me in a way that I cannot describe. But since this has occurred, I am sorry that I can no longer engage My mind in the duties of My household affairs (page 356).” Srimad-Bhagavatam 10.53.2 is another example of purva-raga, this time between Krsna and Rukmini.

Mana — Self-Imposed Separation Due to Anger “When Srimati Radharani saw Krsna enjoying Himself in the company of several other gopis, She became a little jealous because Her special prestige was being dimmed. Therefore, She immediately left the scene and took shelter in a nice flower bush where the black drones were humming. Then, hiding Herself behind the creepers, She began to express Her sorrow to one of Her consorts (page 356).”

Pravasa — Separation Caused by Physical Distance Pravasa separation occurs when the beloved is in a far away place. The Padyavali illustrates Srimati Radharani's pravasa separation from Krsna: “Since the inauspicious day when Krsna left for Mathura, Srimati Radharani has been pressing Her head on one of Her hands and constantly shedding tears. Her face is always wet now, and therefore there is no chance of Her sleeping even for a moment (page 356).” Prahlada-samhita illustrates Krsna's pravasa separation from Srimati Radharani: “The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Govinda, painstricken due to being pierced by the arrows of Cupid, is always thinking of you [the gopis], and He is not even accepting His regular lunch. Nor is He getting any proper rest (page 356).”

Sambhoga — Meeting “When the lover and beloved come together and enjoy one another by direct contact, this stage is called sambhoga (page 356).” 5 5

Ujjvala-nélamani, Chapter 15, describes sambhoga. There are four vari eties of meeting with Kåñna: 1. Sankñipt — Meeting i s bri ef due t o fear or shyness (comes after pürva-räga separation). 2. Saìkérna — Meeting is slig htly hindered by previous anger between Kåñna and R ädhäräné (comes after mäna separation). 3. Sampanna — Warm 254

Padyavali illustrates this: “Krsna embraced Srimati Radharani in such an expert manner that He appeared to be celebrating the dancing ceremony of the peacocks (page 357).”

Closing “Sri Rupa Gosvami thus ends the fifth wave of his Ocean of the Nectar of Devotion. He offers his respectful obeisances to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who appeared as Gopala, the eternal form of the Lord (page 357).”

loving meeting (comes after are bri efly separated by a short distance, "düra-praväsa"). 4. Samåddhimäna — Fully enriched meeting (comes after the lovers are separated for a long time by great distance, "sudüra praväsa"). These four meetings can occur while awake (mukhya) or whi le dreaming (gauna). Thus, altogether there are eight vari eties of sambhoga, meeting wi th Kåñna i n conjugal l ove. Duri ng t hese m eetings, t here are charm ing pastimes which include glancing, conversing, riding in a boat, playing in Yamunä, stealing Kåñna's flute, playing hide and seek in the forest, etc. 255

Part Four: Northern Ocean IV: Gauna-Bhakti-Rasa — Indirect Loving Relationships 1. Hasya-rasa — Laughing Ecstasy

Chapter 45

2. Adbhuta-bhakti-rasa — Astonishment

Chapter 46

3. Vira-bhakti-rasa — Chivalry

Chapter 46

4. Karuna-bhakti-rasa — Compassion

Chapter 47

5. Raudra-bhakti-rasa — Anger

Chapter 47

6. Bhayanaka-bhakti-rasa — Dread

Chapter 48

7. Vibhatsa-bhakti-rasa — Ghastliness

Chapter 48

8. Maitri-vaira-sthiti — Compatible and incompatible mixing of mellows

Chapter 49 & 50

9. Rasabhasa — Incomplete expression of mellows

Chapter 51 256

Northern Ocean First Wave Hasya-Rasa

Chapter 45

257

Chapter 45

Laughing Ecstasy BRS 4.1.1 - 29

Maìgalacarana To inaugurate the Northern Ocean of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, Srila Rupa Gosvami offers a mangalacarana. Again, he uses the word sanatana to indicate both Krsna and Sanatana Gosvami. If sanatana refers to Krsna: he prays that Sri Krsna always be pleased with him, and says that the super-excellent bhakti of the Vraja-vasis compels Lord Krsna to accept eternal residence in Sri Vrndavana. If sanatana refers to Sanatana Gosvami: he prays that Sanatana Gosvami always be pleased with him, and says that Sanatana Gosvami has developed attachment for living in Sri Vrndavana due to his super-excellent bhakti. 1

Overview of Northern Ocean The Northern Ocean has nine waves. The first seven describe the seven indirect mellows of devotional service (gauna-rati). “In the fourth division of Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu, Srila Rupa Gosvami has described seven kinds of indirect ecstasies of devotional service, known as laughing, astonishment, chivalry, compassion, anger, dread and ghastliness (page 361).” The Eighth Wave describes tasteful and distasteful mixing of rasas. “In this portion, Srila Rupa Gosvami further describes these ecstasies of devotional feelings, some being compatible and others incompatible with one another (page 361).” The Ninth Wave describes rasabhasa — conditions that distort genuine rasa. “When one kind of ecstatic devotional service overlaps with another in a conflicting way, this state of affairs is called rasabhasa, or a perverted presentation of mellows (page 361).” Having summarised the contents of the Northern ocean, Srila Rupa Gosvami briefly reiterates the main difference between direct and indirect mellows: Direct mellows can be permanent, whereas indirect mellows are always transitory. 2

LAUGHING ECSTASY When one's humorous attitude (hasya-rati) is nourished within the heart of a devotee by appropriate vibhava, etc, it transforms into laughing ecstasy (hasya-rasa).

1 2

B RS 4.1.1 BRS 4.1.5 - 6. For further information on direct and indirect mellows see Southern Ocean, Fifth Wave, Chapter 33 of the present book. 258

Vibhava Asraya-Alambana Srila Rupa Gosvami gives a list of those who experience laughter (asraya-alambana): “Expert learned scholars say that laughing is generally found among youngsters or in the combination of old persons and young children (page 361).” There are exceptions: “This ecstatic loving laughing is sometimes also found in persons who are very grave by nature (page 361).”

Visaya-Alambana There are two possible causes of ecstatic laughter: (1) Krsna or (2) other people who interact with Krsna. Krsna as the Cause of Laughter In the example of the old mendicant at mother Yasoda's door, Krsna made funny statements that caused the mendicant to laugh in ecstasy. Thus, “In this instance, Krsna Himself is the object of laughing affairs (page 361).” Others as the Cause of Laughter Generally, Sri Krsna is the object of rasa, but someone else may also take that position, if their activities are connected to Krsna. Tad-anvayi-alambana is the term for this. 3 Srila Rupa Gosvami gives two examples. In the first, Krsna's friends laugh when someone tricks Him into eating a bitter flower instead of sugar candy. The person who tricked Lord Krsna became a cause of ecstatic laughter, because his humorous activities were connected with Krsna. In the second example, Nanda Maharaja inquires from a palmist about the future wellbeing of his son. The palmist finds these questions quite amusing because Nanda's son is the husband of the Goddess of Fortune — There is no need for a fortune teller! Nanda Maharaja became a cause of ecstatic laughter because his humorous inquiries were connected with Krsna. 4

Uddipana Srila Prabhupada summarises the uddipanas of ecstatic laughter: “In such a laughing ecstasy of love, Krsna or matters pertaining to Krsna are the cause of the laughter (page 362).” Specifically, Krsna's behavior and Krsna's parents are uddipanas of ecstatic laughter. 5

Anubhava Vibration of the nostrils, lips, cheeks and so on are the anubhavas of ecstatic laughter. 6

3 4

B RS 4.1.9 These examples are found on pages 361 - 362 in The Nectar of Devotion.

5

B RS 4.1.12

6

B RS 4.1.12 259

Vyabhicari-Bhava “In such laughing devotional service, there are symptoms of jubilation, laziness, concealed feelings and similar other seemingly disturbing elements (page 362).”

Sthayi-Bhava Hasya-rati is the sthayi-bhava of hasya-rasa. 7

Intensities of Ecstatic Laughter “According to Srila Rupa Gosvami's calculation, laughter in ecstatic love can be broken down into six divisions. These divisions, according to different degrees of smiling, are called in the Sanskrit language smita, hasita, vihasita, avahasita, apahasita and atihasita (page 362).” Srila Rupa Gosvami groups these six kinds of laughter in two subdivisions: elder ("major") and younger ("minor"). “These six classes of smiling can be classified as major and minor. The major division includes smita, hasita and vihasita smiling, and the minor division includes avahasita, apahasita and atihasita smiling (page 362).” The chart at right clearly illustrates this. Srila Rupa Gosvami defines the six intensities of laughter and gives examples for each (see The Nectar of Devotion, middle of page 362 to middle of page 364).

"Major" Manifested in elderly Smita — smiling mouth Hasita — Smile, with teeth slightly visible Vihasita — Smile, with teeth distinctly visible

"Minor" Manifested in youths Avahasita — Smiling which squints the eyes Apahasita — Smiling with tears & shaking Atihasita — Smiling with clapping & leaping

Implied Laughter Implied laughter occurs when hasya-rasa produces no overt manifestations. For example, “My dear Kutila, daughter of Jatila, your breasts are as long as string beans — simply dry and long. Your nose is so gorgeous that it defies the beauty of the noses of frogs. And your eyes are more beautiful than the eyes of dogs. Your lips defy the flaming cinders of fire, and your abdomen is as beautiful as a big drum. Therefore, my dear beautiful Kutila, you are the most beautiful of all the cowherd girls of Vrndavana, and because of your extraordinary beauty, I think you must be beyond the attraction of the sweet blowing of Krsna's flute! (page 364)” There is no mention of any smiling or laughing in this quotation, yet it is obvious that the gopis are tasting ecstatic laughter. Implied laughter usually occurs when one employs sarcasm in cleverly poking fun at others.

7

B RS 4.1.13 260

Northern Ocean Second & Third Waves Adbhuta-bhakti-rasa Vira-bhakti-rasa

Chapter 46

261

Chapter 46

Astonishment and Chivalry BRS 4.2.1 - 4.3.61

ASTONISHMENT BRS 4.2.1 - 13 In The Nectar of Devotion, Srila Prabhupada describes only the essential elements of adbhutabhakti-rasa (astonishment). 1

Two Types of Astonishment There are two ways to experience ecstatic astonishment: (1) saksat — by direct perception, or (2) anuman — by inference. Saksad adbhuta (direct astonishment) occurs when one directly perceives Krsna's wondrous activities, qualities, etc. Anuman adbhuta (inferred astonishment) occurs when one infers that Krsna has performed some astonishing act, although one does not directly perceive it.

Saksad Adbhuta — Direct Astonishment There are three subdivisions of saksad adbhuta: 1) astonishment by seeing, 2) astonishment by hearing, and 3) astonishment by speaking. 2

Adbhuta-Bhakti-Rasa Ecstatic Astonishment Säkñät Directly Percieved

Anumän Inferred

By Seeing

The Nectar of Devotion gives two examples: In the first, Narada becomes astonished by seeing Krsna simultaneously present in 16,108 palaces, engaged in completely different activities. In the next example, a friend of mother Yasoda became astonished when she saw Krsna lift Govardhana Hill as though it was a toy (See page 365).

By Seeing By Hearing By Speaking

By Hearing Maharaja Pariksit became astonished when he heard about how Krsna killed Narakasura. Although he did not witness the astonishing event, his adbhuta-rasa is still "direct." The cause of his astonishment was Sukadeva Gosvami's narration of the event, which he directly

1

Elem ents of Adbhuta-rasa not described in NOD: a definition of adbhuta-rasa, and a description of its vibhäva, anubhäva, sättvika-bhäva, vyabhicäré-bhäva, and sthäyé-bhäva. For these details, see BRS 4.2.1-4 2 B RS 4.2.5

262

perceived with his own ears. Consequently, this is an example of ecstatic astonishment arising from direct aural perception. 3 By Speaking When Lord Brahma returned to Satyaloka he informed the residents about his stealing the cowherd boys and calves. By speaking this news to them, Brahma became overwhelmed with astonishment. This exemplifies astonishment arising from speech. Although Lord Brahma is not directly witnessing the astonishing event, he is directly witnessing his own narration of the pastime. Consequently, he is an example of ecstatic astonishment arising from direct verbal perception. 4

Anuman-Adbhuta — Inferred Astonishment After Krsna swallowed the forest fire, the cowherd boys opened their eyes and saw that the forest was saved (page 366). They inferred that Krsna must have performed some wonderful activity. They did not witness Krsna's amazing act; they inferred it. Consequently, they exemplify ecstatic astonishment arising from inference.

Astonishment (Adbhuta-Rasa) is dependant on Love (Priti) Without love (priti) there can be no rasa. Srila Rupa Gosvami thus concludes: “The activities of a person, even if they are not very extraordinary, create an impression of wonder in the heart and mind of the person's friends. But even very wonderful activities performed by a person who is not one's friend will not create any impression. It is because of love that one's wonderful activities create an impression in the mind (page 366).”

CHIVALRY BRS 4.3.1 - 61 When the mood of valorous enthusiasm (utsah-rati) is nourished within the heart of a devotee by appropriate vibhava, etc, it transforms into ecstatic chivalry (vira-rasa). Srila Prabhupada explains, “When on account of love and devotional service for the Lord there is special valorous enthusiasm, the resultant activities are called chivalrous (page 366).”

Types of Chivalry There are four types of chivalrous heroes: (1) yuddha-vira — a hero in fighting, (2) dana-vira — a hero in giving charity, (3) daya-vira — a hero in performing acts of compassion, and (4) dharma-vira — a hero in abiding by religious principles. Srila Prabhupada explains, “These chivalrous activities can be manifested in the acts of mock-fighting, giving charity, showing mercy and executing religious principles. By performing chivalrous activities in fighting, one is 3

According to BRS 4.2.9, the last paragraph on page 365 should read: First sentence — "An instance of astonishment by direct perception." Last sentence — "This instance is an example of astonishment in devotional service by direct perception through aural reception." 4 According to BRS 4.2.10, the first sentence on page 366 should read: "There is another example of direct astonishment."

263

called yuddha-vira. By charitable activities one is called dana-vira. By showing extraordinary mercy one is called daya-vira. And when one is munificent in executing religious rites, he is called dharma-vira (pages 366 - 367).” Devotees who posses these four moods are the four types of asraya-alambana for virabhakti-rasa. Krsna is the visaya-alambana of all types of chivalry. Srila Prabhupada therefore says, “In all such different chivalrous activities, Krsna is the object (page 367).” Srila Rupa Gosvami separately discusses each type of chivalry.

Yuddha-Vira — Chivalrous Fighting Vibhava Visaya-Alambana Krsna is the object of chivalrous fighting. He enjoys this rasa in two ways: (1) by directly fighting, or (2) by being a spectator. Srila Prabhupada explains, "When a friend wants to satisfy Krsna by performing some chivalrous activities, the friend becomes the opponent; or else Krsna may give audience to the fighting, and by His desire another friend becomes the opponent (page 367).” Krsna as the Opponent “A friend once challenged Krsna thus: ‘My dear Madhava, You are very restless because You think that no one can defeat You. But if You do not flee from here, then I shall show You how I can defeat You. And my friends will be very satisfied to see this!’ (page 367)” Another example: “Krsna and Sridama were very intimate friends, yet Sridama, out of anger with Krsna, challenged Him. When both of them began to fight, all the friends on the bank of the Yamuna enjoyed the wonderful fighting of the two friends (page 367).” Krsna as the Spectator Srila Rupa Gosvami describes that Krsna's hair stood on end as He witnessed the heroic fighting skills of Sridama, who dexterously whirled a pole to deflect the arrows being shot at him. 5 This is an example of Krsna enjoying yuddha-vira-rasa as a spectator. Srila Prabhupada says, “Such mock-fighting generally takes place among chivalrous persons and creates wonderful excitement for all viewers (page 367).” Additional Point on Chivalry: Chivalrous devotees are jubilant and enthusiastic to fight, sometimes even with members of their own group. “There is a statement in the Hari-vamsa that sometimes Arjuna and Krsna fought in the presence of Kunti, and Arjuna would be defeated by Krsna (page 367).”

5

BRS 4.3.8

264

Uddipana Srila Rupa Gosvami lists things that impel the ecstatic fighting spirit: “...bragging, complacence, pride, power, taking to weapons, challenging and standing as an opponent. All of these symptoms become impetuses to chivalrous devotional service (page 367).” Example of Bragging as an Uddipana “My dear Damodara, You are an expert only in eating... You have advertised Yourself as a serpent, and I am the peacock who will now defeat You (page 367).”

Anubhava The anubhavas of yuddha-vira-rasa are very similar to the uddipanas. We can clarify this by means of a hypothetical situation: "Person A" is not in a fighting mood, but "Person B" challenges him by bragging, taking up weapons, etc. These activities impel the fighting spirit to rise up in "Person A." Consequently, they act as uddipana. From another angle: "Person B" was in the fighting mood, which caused him to challenge "Person A" by bragging, taking up weapons, etc. Consequently, these activities were anubhavas for "Person B" because they resulted from his fighting mood. When something impels the fighting spirit it is an uddipana. When something results from an already evoked fighting spirit, it is an anubhava. Srila Prabhupada mentions this, “In such fighting between friends, when the selfadvertisement becomes personal, learned scholars say that it is subecstasy (page 367).” 6 Bragging is an anubhava when it results from one's fighting spirit and is used to challenge others. On the other hand, bragging is an uddipana when it impels one's fighting spirit, coming as a challenge from someone else. This is true for each uddipana of yuddha-vira-rasa. For example, taking up weapons to challenge an opponent is an anubhava, but it is an uddipana when someone else takes up weapons and challenges one to battle. In addition to these uddipana/anubhavas, there are some things which are exclusively anubhava: enthusiasm in fighting, roaring like a lion, being enthusiastic to fight in spite of being alone, to never withdraw from battle, to instil fearlessness in persons who are afraid, etc.

Example of Bragging as an Anubhava “One friend addressed Krsna in this manner: ‘My dear Madhusudana, You know my strength, yet You are encouraging Bhadrasena, and not me, to challenge mighty Baladeva. By this action You are simply insulting me, because my arms are as strong as the bolts of the gate!’ (page 368)” This bragging is as an anubhava, because it is a result of one's own yuddha-utsah-rati. It is one's own self-provoked challenge.

6

In the above quotation, Çréla Prabhupäda uses the following terminology: Self-advertisement —bragging; personal — it arises from one's own fighting spirit, not from someone else's fighting spirit; and subecstasy — subsequent ecstasy (anubhäva). Thus: “In such fighting between friends, when bragging arises from one's own fighting spirit, learned scholars say that it is anubhäva.”

265

Example of Roaring Like a Lion “A devotee once said, ‘My dear Lord Krsna, may Your challenger Sridama become glorious for his chivalrous activities, such as vibrating like a thundercloud and roaring like a lion. May all glories go to Sridama's chivalrous activities!’ (page 368)”

Sattvika-Bhava & Vyabhicari-Bhava Sattvika-bhava: “Chivalrous activities in the matter of fighting, charity, mercy and execution of religious rituals are called constitutional... (page 368)” Vyabhicari-bhava: “Expressions of pride, emotion, endurance, kindness, determination, jubilation, enthusiasm, jealousy and remembrance are called unconstitutional (page 368).” "Constitutional ecstasy" is Srila Prabhupada's "Unconstitutional ecstasy" refers to vyabhicari-bhava.

translation

of

sattvika-bhava.

Sthayi-Bhava The sthayi-bhava of yuddha-vira-rasa is called yuddha-utsaha-rati — "enthusiasm to fight.” This enthusiasm manifests in four ways. 7 1.

One fights by himself, after being challenged by an opponent.

2.

One fights by himself, and he starts the fight.

3.

One fights in a team, after being challenged by an opponent, or encouraged by an ally.

4.

One fights in a team, and he starts the fight.

Example of First Yuddha-Utsaha-Rati (He fights by himself, after being challenged) After being chastised by His father, Stoka-krsna stopped fighting with Krsna... “But Krsna continued to challenge him, and thus, in order to meet the challenge, Stoka-krsna took his pole and began to display his dexterity by whirling it (page 368).” Stoka-krsna fought by himself, after being challenged by Krsna.

Example of Second Yuddha-Utsaha-Rati (He fights by himself, and he starts the fight) “Once Sridama challenged Bhadrasena and said to him, ‘My dear friend, you needn't be afraid of me yet. I shall first of all defeat our brother Balarama, then I shall beat Krsna, and then I shall come to you...’ (page 368)” Sridama is starting the fight, and he wants to fight each person "one-on-one".

Examples of Third Yuddha-Utsaha-Rati (He fights in a team, after being challenged or encouraged)

7

BRS 4.3.18

266

See example beginning “Bhadrasena therefore left the party of Balarama and joined Krsna (page 368).” After being challenged by Sridama, Bhadrasena teamed up with Krsna to defeat Sridama and his friends. Another example, “Once Krsna challenged all His friends and said... (page 368)” In this example, Varuthapa teamed up with his friends, after being challenged by Krsna.

Example of Fourth Yuddha-Utsaha-Rati (He fights in a team, and he starts the fight) “One of the friends once remarked, ‘Sudama is trying his best to see Damodara defeated, and I think that if our powerful Subala joins him, they will be a very beautiful combination, like a valuable jewel bedecked with gold’ (page 368).” Sudama started the fight against Damodara, and he will team up with his ally, Subala.

Ecstatic Fighting is not Possible Without Love (Priti) “In these chivalrous activities, only Krsna's friends can be the opponents. Krsna's enemies can never actually be His opponents. Therefore, this challenging by Krsna's friends is called devotional service in chivalrous activities (page 368).”

Dana-Vira — Chivalrous Charity “Dana-vira, or chivalry in giving charity, may be divided into two parts: munificence and renunciation (page 369).” Munificence means giving charity to others. Renunciation means receiving charity from Krsna, but renouncing it (a devotee shows heroism or chivalry by never accepting anything from Krsna except pure devotional service). 8

Munificence “A person who can sacrifice everything for the satisfaction of Krsna is called munificent (page 369).”

Uddipana Seeing a fit recipient of charity is an uddipana of dana-vira. 9 Another uddipana for charity is Krsna. Seeing Krsna impels one's good and charitable sentiments, and thus one desires to please the Lord by helping others. “When a person desires to make a sacrifice because of seeing Krsna, Krsna is called the impetus of the munificent activity (page 369).” 10 8

See BRS 4.2.25 & 43. BRS 4.3.27 10 Other points from Bhakti-Rasämåta-Sindhu helpful in understanding däna-véra-rasa: 1) Anubhäva: Giving more than is deserved, conversing with laughter, firmness or steadiness, cleverness and skill, patience. (BRS 4.3.27) 2) Vyabhicäré-bhäva: Vitaska ("counter-arguments"), utsukatä (enthusiasm), harña (jubilation)... (BRS 4.3.28) 3) Sthäyé-bhäva: "Däna-utsaha-rati"— enthusiasm to give charity (BRS 4.3.29) 4) Vibhäva: The person who gives charity is the äçraya alambana. Çré Kåñna, as either the recipient of charity or the recipient of the auspicious benefit accrued by giving charity, is the viñaya alambana. 9

267

Two Types of Munificence Munificence (giving charity for the Lord's pleasure) is of two types: (1) Abhudayika — giving charity to a brahmana, to create auspiciousness for Krsna, and (2) tat sampradanaka — giving charity directly to the Lord. 11 Abhudayika Abhudayika is the desire to invoke auspiciousness for Krsna by giving charity to others, as Nanda Maharaja did by giving charity to the brahmanas at Krsna's birth. (See page 369) Tat-Sampradanaka Tat-sampradanaka involves giving charity directly to Krsna. “When a person knows the glories of the Lord completely and is prepared to sacrifice everything for the Lord, he is called sampradanaka, or one who gives everything in charity for the sake of Krsna (page 369).” Tat-sampradanaka also of two kinds: 12

Däna-Véra Renunciation of charity given by Lord

Munificence Giving to the Lord Abhyudäyika Giving to others for Lord's pleasure

Tat-sampradänaka Giving directly to Lord Prétidäna Giving to Kåñëa out of affection

Püjädäna Giving to Lord in worship

is

1) Pritidana — Charity given to Krsna in a loving, friendly mood. 2) Pujadana —Charity given to Krsna in a worshipful mood. Pritidana-Tat-Sampradanaka

See example beginning “When Maharaja Yudhisthira went with Krsna in the arena of the Rajasuya sacrifice... (page 369)” Out of deep friendship for Lord Krsna, Maharaja Yudhisthira gave Him all his possessions, and became disturbed when he finally had nothing else to give. This is pritidana because his intimate friendship inspired him to give to the Lord. Pujadana Tat-Sampradanaka See example beginning with “Similarly, Maharaja Bali once told his priest, Sukracarya... (page 369)” This is pujadana; Maharaja Bali feels that Lord Vamana is the Supreme Lord, the most worshipable object and worthy recipient of charity.

Renunciation In "munificence," the devotee is the giver and the Lord is the recipient. In "renunciation," the Lord is the giver and the devotee is the recipient. The devotee, however, displays heroic purity by renouncing anything offered by the Lord, even liberation.

11 12

BRS 4.3.30 BRS 4.3.34

268

Srila Prabhupada explains, “A person who wants to give everything in charity to Krsna but does not want anything in return is considered the real renouncer. Thus, a devotee will refuse to accept any kind of liberation, even if it is offered by the Lord (pages 369 - 370).”

Sthayi-Bhava The sthayi-bhava of renunciation is tyaga-utsaha-rati — enthusiasm for renunciation of everything besides the Lord's service (a very powerful aversion to accept even the five types of liberation). 13 Dhruva Maharaja's statement from the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya is an example of tyagautsaha-rati — the chivalry of renunciation. Even though various types of opulence were present before him, he was prepared to renounce them all. Srimad Bhagavatam 3.15.48 is also an example of tyaga-utsaha-rati.

Daya-Vira — Chivalrous Mercy Definition Daya-vira is a mood of compassion (daya) for Krsna, which inspires the devotee to perform heroic and chivalrous (vira) acts of charity. The devotee's powerful mood of compassion makes him willing to do anything that may benefit the Lord, even if it requires him to cleave his own body in two. 14 Thus daya-vira is a mood of heroism that arises from compassion for the Lord. 15 Example of Daya-Vira Rasa “One devotee has described his feelings about the charity exhibited by King Mayuradhvaja... (page 370)” Krsna once disguised himself as a brahmana beggar and asked Maharaja Mayuradhvaja for half his body, to be sawed off by his wife and children. Because the king felt such strong compassion for Krsna (in the disguise of this brahmana), he did not hesitate to fulfil his every request, even though it required him to cleave his body in half. 16

Compassion for the Supreme Godhead? Daya-vira is heroism motivated by compassion and pity. Compassion and pity are emotions felt for those in need. Since the Supreme Godhead can never be in need or in difficulty, how could a devotee feel compassion or pity for Him? 13

BRS 4.3.43 B RS 4.3.47 15 Other points from BRS helpful in understanding dayä-véra-rasa: 1. Vibhäva: Kåñna in a disguised form is the viñaya (such as Vämana-deva). The compassionate devotee is the äçraya (BRS 4.3.47). 2. Uddépana: Things that display the distress of the person whom compassion is being shown. (BRS 4.3.48). 3. Anubhäva: Giving one's life; protecting the distressed person; speaking comforting, soothing words; exhibiting steadiness, etc. (BRS 4.3.49). 4. Vyabhicäré-bhäva: Utsukatä (enthusiasm), mati (thoughtfulness), and harña (jubilation)... (BRS 4.3.50) 5. Sthäyé-bhäva: Dayä-utsaha-rati — enthusiasm characterised by an abundance of compassion (BRS 4.3.50). 16 The first full sentence on page 371 should thus read, "He is known as the perfect dayä-véra renouncer" (pg. 371) 14

269

To facilitate the exchange of loving emotions such as pity and compassion, the Lord's supremacy must be covered. Therefore daya-vira-rasa can only manifest when the Lord conceals His divinity and appears in a disguised form. 17

Dana-Vira or Daya-Vira? Both dana-vira and daya-vira involve heroic acts of charity for the Lord. Dana-vira occurs when one is aware of the Lord's supremacy. Daya-vira, on the other hand, occurs when one is unaware of the Lord's identity. Charity given in Dana-vira is motivated by a sense of worship, or a sense of friendship. Charity given in daya-vira is motivated by a sense of pity and compassion for the Lord. 18

Dharma-Vira — Heroic Religiosity Dharma-vira is the chivalrous mood of being always engaged in dharma for Krsna's pleasure. “Any person who is always ready to satisfy Krsna and who is always dexterous in executing devotional service is called dharma-vira, or chivalrous in executing religious rituals (page 371).”

Uddipana and Anubhava Uddipana: Hearing the scriptures is the impetus to becoming dharma-vira, a hero of religiosity. Anubhava: Moral conduct, tolerance, and sense control are the results of becoming dharmavira. 19 Srila Prabhupada summarizes, “Dharma-viras are produced after going through the authoritative scriptures, following moral principles, being faithful and tolerant and controlling the senses (page 371).”

Example of Dharma-Vira See example beginning “The best example of dharma-vira is Maharaja Yudhisthira (page 371).” This example describes how Maharaja Yuddhisthira performed many yajnas to the demigods for Krsna's pleasure. Therefore, the section ends by explaining how it is possible to worship the Lord by performing sacrifice to the demigods.

17

18 19

Jéva Gosvämé explains in his commentaries to BRS 4.3.52 - 53: The Lord's supremacy may be covered either, (1) by a disguise, or (2) by the devotee's spontaneous love. In dayä-véra-rasa the Lord is covered by a disguise. In karuna-rasa the Lord is covered by love (karuna-rasa is the subject of the next wave). Dayä-véra-rasa is specifically for devotees in the reverent däsya mood, since they cannot feel pity for the Lord unless He disguises Himself. Karuna-rasa is specifically for devotee's in higher rasas. They can constantly exchange feelings of compassion and mercy with the Lord because their spontaneous affection always covers His majesty and supremacy. BRS 4.3.52 - 53 BRS 4.3.56

270

Northern Ocean Fourth & Fifth Wave Karuna-bhakti-rasa Raudra-bhakti-rasa

Chapter 47

271

Chapter 47

Compassion and Anger BRS 4.4.1 - 4.5.33

COMPASSION BRS 4.4.1 - 16 When lamentation (soka-rati) is nourished within the heart of a devotee by appropriate vibhava, etc, it transforms into tragic compassion in devotional service (karuna-rasa). Srila Prabhupada explains “When the ecstasy of devotional service produces some kind of lamentation in connection with Krsna, it is called devotional service in compassion (page 373).”

Karuna — “Compassion” Karuna-rasa is the Sanskrit term for "devotional service in compassion." According to Sanskrit poetics, karuna means "tragedy." When the devotee sees Krsna in a tragic situation, he or she feels lamentation and compassion. Consequently, Srila Prabhupada translates karuna as "compassion," and sometimes as "lamentation."

Vibhava Visaya-Alambana There are three objects of kaurna-rasa: (1) Krsna, (2) His dear associates, and (3) the relatives of Krsna's associates. 1

Asraya-Alambana There are three: (1) those who witness Krsna in a tragic situation, (2) those who witness Krsna's dear associates in a tragic situation, and (3) those who witness the relatives of Krsna's dear associates in a tragic situation. 2

Uddipana “The impetuses for this devotional service are Krsna's transcendental quality, form and activity (page 373).” How can these wonderful aspects of Krsna stimulate tragic lamentation? If Yasoda-devi sees Krsna in an extremely dangerous situation her memory will suddenly flood with memories of His lovable qualities, form, and activities. This increases her affection for Him, which increases her lamentation over the calamitous tragedy now befalling the object of her love. Thus Krsna's form, qualities, and pastimes can be uddipanas for karuna-rasa. 3

1 2 3

BRS 4.4.3 BRS 4.4.4 For a pastime that illustrates this, see page .

272

Anubhava “In this ecstasy of devotional service there are sometimes symptoms like regret, heavy breathing, crying, falling on the ground and beating upon one's chest (page 373).”

Vyabhicari-Bhava “Sometimes symptoms like laziness, frustration, defamation, humility, anxiety, moroseness, eagerness, restlessness, madness, death, forgetfulness, disease and illusion are also visible (page 373).”

Sthayi-Bhava Soka-rati (bereavement or lamentation) is the sthayi-bhava of karuna-bhakti-rasa. “When in the heart of the devotee there is expectation of some mishap to Krsna, it is called devotional service in bereavement. Such bereavement is another symptom of this devotional service in compassion (page 373).”

Examples of Karuna-Rasa As mentioned earlier, there are three objects of kaurna-rasa: (1) Krsna, (2) His dear associates, and (3) the relatives of Krsna's associates. Srila Rupa Gosvami now illustrates each.

Krsna as the Object of Compassion One can experience karuna-rasa as a result of Krsna being put in a tragic calamity. Srimad-Bhagavatam 10.16.10 shows Krsna wrapped in the coils of the Kaliya serpent. His cowherd friends who witness the Lord's apparent tragedy are the reservoirs (asraya-alambana) of compassionate lamentation (karuna-rasa). Srila Rupa Gosvami cites another example. “When Krsna entered the Yamuna river, which had become very poisonous from the presence of Kaliya, mother Yasoda feared all kinds of mishaps, and she was breathing hotly. Tears from her eyes were soaking her clothes, and she was almost collapsing (page 373).” Krsna is the object of compassion (visaya-alambana), and Mother Yasoda is the reservoir of compassion (asraya-alambana).

Krsna's Associates as Objects of Compassion One can also experience karuna-rasa as a result of Krsna's dear devotees being put in a tragic calamity. For example, “...when the Saìkhasura demon was attacking Krsna's queens one after another, Lord Baladeva become more and more bluish (page 374).” Here the visaya-alambana is Krsna's queens, and the asraya-alambana is Lord Baladeva. 4

Relatives of Krsna's Associates as Objects of Compassion One can also experience karuna-rasa as a result of the relatives of Krsna's dear devotees being put in a tragic calamity. 4

Those familiar with this lélä can understand that "Kåñna's queens" refers to Våndävaneçvaré and the gopés.

273

The reference from Hamsaduta (page 374) describes Krsna's footprints. When Lord Brahma sees them he bows down. When Narada Muni sees them he becomes very ecstatic. Narada then becomes overwhelmed with compassion for the liberated sages; who have achieved impersonal liberation and are thus bereft of the opportunity to see the wonderful footprints of the Supreme Personality. Narada is a muni, and the liberated sages are also in the family of munis. Thus the liberated sages are relatives of Krsna's associate, Narada. The munis are visaya-alambana. Narada is asraya-alambana. 5 Compassion towards a relative is more evident in the next example: “There is an instance when Sahadeva, the younger brother of Nakula, became greatly gladdened at seeing the effulgent glowing of Krsna's footprints. He began to cry and call out, ‘Mother Madri! Where are you now? Father Pandu! Where are you now? I am very sorry that you are not here to see these footprints of Krsna!’ (page 374)” Sahadeva's mother and father are the objects of his compassion, because they are deprived of seeing Krsna's footprints. His mother and father are visaya-alambana. He is asrayaalambana.

Advanced Nature of Karuna-Rasa “In devotional service without strong attraction to the Lord there may sometimes be smiling and other symptoms, but never the stress or lamentation that are symptoms of devotional service in compassion (page 374).” Laughter, etc. can sometimes arise even in a devotee who has not yet developed his rati. However, lamentation and compassion for Krsna can never arise without rati.

Love Covers Krsna's Supremacy Since Krsna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead there can be no real threat to His welfare. Yet unless one perceives a threat to Krsna's welfare there is no possibility of karuna-rasa. Therefore, the Lord's supremacy and omnipotence must be covered. In karuna-rasa the devotee's intoxicating love covers his awareness of the Lord's supremacy. 6 Srila Prabhupada explains, “The apprehension of some mishap to Krsna or to His beloved queens, as exhibited by Baladeva and Yudhisthira, has been explained above. This apprehension is due not exactly to their ignorance of the inconceivable potencies of Krsna but to their intense love for Him (page 374).”

Even Tragedy is Blissful “This kind of apprehension of some mishap to Krsna first of all becomes manifested as an object of lamentation, but gradually it develops into such compassionate loving ecstasy that it turns to another channel and gives transcendental pleasure (page 374).” We must not equate karuna-rasa with ordinary material lamentation. Material emotions can bring only misery, since they focus on the temporary platform. When our emotions focus on Krsna, they can result only in bliss. Thus even "tragedy" is blissful in Krsna consciousness.

5 6

BRS 4.4.11 See Chapter 46, footnote .

274

ANGER BRS 4.5.1 - 33 When anger (krodha-rati) is nourished within the heart of a devotee by its corresponding vibhava, etc. it transforms into ecstatic fury (raudra-bhakti-rasa). 7

Vibhava Visaya-Alambana There are three objects of ecstatic anger; (1) Krsna, (2) Krsna's well-wishers, and (3) enemies. 8

Asraya-Alambana If the object is Krsna, the asraya may be either the sakhis or elderly gopis. If the object is Krsna's well-wishers or His enemies, any devotee can be the asraya. 9 Anger of Sakhis Towards Krsna The sakhis become angry at Krsna when He mistreats Radharani. 10 “Lalita-gopi expressed her anger, which was caused by Krsna, when she addressed Srimati Radharani thus: ‘My dear friend, my inner desires have been polluted. Therefore I shall go to the place of Yamaraja. But I am sorry to see that Krsna has still not given up His smiling over cheating You. I do not know how You could repose all Your loving propensities upon this lusty young boy from the neighborhood of the cowherds’ (pages 374 -375).” 11 Anger of Elderly Gopis Towards Krsna “After seeing Krsna, Jarati sometimes said ... (page 375)” The elderly gopis become angry at Krsna for His libertine connection with their chaste young daughters. They worry that such improper behavior will cast infamy and irreligiously upon Him. In his commentary on this verse, Jiva Gosvami describes that their anger is therefore an expression of their love. 12 Anger Towards Krsna's Well-Wishers There are three reasons for becoming angry at Krsna's well-wishers: 13 1.

Anavahita - "inattentive," they are inattentive in protecting Krsna.

2.

Sahasi - "bold," they rashly take Krsna into danger.

7

B RS 4.5.1 B RS 4.5.2 9 B RS 4.5.2 10 B RS 4.5.3 11 This verse illustrates several components of ecstatic anger: Vibhäva viñaya: Kåñna. Vibhäva äçraya: Lalitä-Sakhé. Vibhäva uddépana: Kåñna's indifference to Çré Rädhä's suffering. Anubhäva: The desire to die ("I sh all go to the place of Yamaräja"). Vyabhicäré-bhäva: Extreme agitation 12 It is interesting to note that jaraté is not the name of a particular gopé. Jaraté is a generic term meaning, "old lady." 13 BRS 4.5.8 275 8

3.

Irsyu - "envious," they have unnecessary anger towards Krsna, due to jealous love. Anavahita — Inattentive

Srila Rupa Gosvami defines anavahita: Even though entrusted with Krsna's safety and maintenance, one becomes inattentive to Krsna's protection due to being too absorbed in collecting articles for His service. 14 Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates this by citing Rohini's anger towards Yasoda-devi after the twin Arjuna trees fell. “You may be very expert in giving lessons to your son by binding Him with rope, but don't you look to see if your son is in a dangerous spot? The trees are falling on the ground, and He is simply loitering there! (page 375)” Sahasi — Rash Srila Rupa Gosvami defines sahasi as one who rashly and foolhardily persuades Krsna to enter a dangerous, fearful place. 15 Mother Yasoda's anger at the cowherd boys for sending Krsna “alone into such danger in the Talavana Forest (page 375)” is an example of ecstatic anger towards a foolhardy well-wisher of Krsna. Irsyu — Jealous Lover Srila Rupa Gosvami defines irsyu as anger towards a well-wisher whose jealous love causes her to unnecessarily remain dissatisfied with Krsna. 16 For example, “When Objects of Anger Radharani was dissatisfied Krsna Sakhis mad at Him for wronging Sri Radha with the behavior of Krsna Elderly gopis mad at His scandalous behavior and had stopped talking with Him, Krsna was very Krsna's Anavahita — inattentive to protecting Krsna sorry for Radharani's great well-wishers Sahasi — Inconsiderate of Krsna's safety dissatisfaction, and in order (When they are:) Irsyu — Unnecessarily mad at Krsna to beg forgiveness, He fell down at Her lotus feet. But Enemies Nija ahita-kari — Those who interfere with one's relationship to Krsna even after this, Radharani Sri Krsna ahita-kari — Enemies of Krsna was not satisfied, and She did not talk with Krsna. At that time, one of Her friends chastised Her in the following words: ‘My dear friend, You are allowing Yourself to be churned by the rod of dissatisfaction, so what can I say unto You?...’ (page 375)” In this example, Srimati Radharani is the object of anger (visaya-alambana) and Her friend is the reservoir of anger (asraya-alambana). Anger Towards Enemies There are two kinds of enemies: 17

14 15 16 17

BRS 4.5.9 BRS 4.5.11 BRS 4.5.13 BRS 4.5.15

276

1)

Nija ahita-kari — one's own enemy.

2)

Krsna ahita-kari — Krsna's enemy. Nija ahita-kari

Srila Rupa Gosvami defines nija ahita-kari as someone who creates impediments in one's relationship with Krsna. 18 The gopis' anger towards Akrura for taking Krsna out of Vrndavana is an example of this. (See page 376, 2nd full paragraph) Krsna ahita-kari The Pandavas' anger towards Sisupala after he insulted Krsna in rajasuya yajna is an example of ecstatic anger towards one who wants to harm Krsna. (See page 376, 3rd full paragraph)

Uddipana “In such a transcendental angry mood sometimes sarcastic remarks, unfavorable glances and insulting words are exhibited (page 376).” These things can spark transcendental anger.

Anubhavas The results of ecstatic anger: “Sometimes there are other symptoms, like rubbing of the two hands, clacking of the teeth, clamping the lips, moving of the eyebrows, scratching of the arms, lowering of the head, rapid breathing, uttering of strong words, nodding of the head, yellowishness at the corners of the eyes, and trembling lips. Sometimes the eyes turn red, and sometimes they fade. And there are sometimes chastisement and silence (page 376).”

Sattvika-Bhava & Vyabhicari-Bhava Raudra-bhakti-rasa exhibits all the standard sattvika- and vyabhicari-bhavas. “Sometimes great emotion, bewilderment, pride, frustration, illusion, impotence, jealousy, dexterity, negligence, and signs of hard labor are also manifest as unconstitutional [vyabhicari] symptoms (page 376).” Sattvika-bhava: ecstatic anger exhibits all eight. Vyabhicari-bhava: great emotion, bewilderment, pride, etc.

Sthayi-Bhava Anger is the steady ecstasy of ecstatic fury (krodha is the sthayi-bhava of raudra-rasa). Srila Prabhupada says, “In all these humors of ecstatic love, the feeling of anger is accepted as the steady factor (page 376).” There are three kinds of krodha-rati: 19 1) Kopa — anger exhibited towards the enemy 2) Manyu — anger towards a relative

18 19

BRS 4.5.16 BRS 4.5.26

277

3) Rusa — anger towards the beloved

Kopa — Anger Towards Krsna's Enemy “When Jarasandha angrily attacked the city of Mathura, he looked at Krsna with sarcastic glances. At that time Baladeva took up His plough weapon and gazed upon Jarasandha with colored eyes (page 376).” Here Sri Baladeva exhibits kopa-rati, anger towards the enemy.

Manyu — Anger Towards Krsna's Well-Wisher There are three kinds of anger towards a well-wisher: 20 1) Manyu pujya — anger towards superior well-wishers. 2) Manyu samana — anger towards well-wishers who are one's equals. 3) Manyu chote — anger towards junior well-wishers. Anger Towards a Superior — Manyu-Pujya “There is a statement in the Vidagdha-madhava wherein Srimati Radharani, in an angry mood, addressed Her mother, Paurnamasi, after she had accused Radharani of going to Krsna... (pages 376 - 377)” Anger Towards an Equal — Manyu-Samana “Sometimes among contemporary personalities there are signs of ecstasy in anger because of love for Krsna. An example of such anger was exhibited in a quarrel between Jatila and Mukhara (page 377).” Both Jatila and Mukhara are senior family members. Thus their anger at each other exemplifies manyu-samana. Anger Towards a Junior — Manyu Chote "Once, when Radharani was taking off the necklace given to Her by Krsna, Jatila, her mother-inlaw, told a friend, ‘My dear friend, just see the beautiful necklace that Krsna has presented to Radharani. She is now holding it, but still She wants to tell us that She has no connection with Krsna. This girl's activities have disgraced our whole family!’ (page 377)”

Ecstatic Anger is not Possible Without Love The anger of Krsna's enemies can never attain to bhakti-rasa. “Natural jealousy of Krsna by persons like Sisupala cannot be accepted as ecstatic love in anger with Krsna (page 377).”

20

BRS 4.5.26

278

Northern Ocean Sixth & Seventh Waves Bhayanaka-bhakti-rasa Vibhatsa-bhakti-rasa

Chapter 48

279

Chapter 48

Dread and Ghastliness BRS 4.6.1 - 4.7.14

ECSTATIC DREAD BRS 4.6.1 - 16 When fear (bhaya-rati) is nourished within the heart of a devotee by its corresponding vibhava, etc. it transforms into ecstatic dread (bhayanaka-bhakti-rasa). 1

Vibhava The devotee who experiences dread is the asraya-alambana, and the person or thing which is the cause of that dreadful fear is the visaya-alambana.

Visaya-Alambana There are two possible objects (visaya) that cause ecstatic fear: (1) Krsna Himself, or (2) a demon (who creates a dreadful situation for Krsna). “In ecstatic love for Krsna in dread, there are two causes of fear: either Krsna Himself or some dreadful situation for Krsna (page 379).”

Asraya-Alambana There are two types of persons who experience ecstatic fear: (1) if the object of fear is Krsna Himself, the asraya-alambana is a devotee who committed an offence; (2) if the object of fear is a demon, the asraya-alambana is a very intimate devotee who fears for Krsna's safety. “When a devotee feels himself to be an offender at Krsna's lotus feet, Krsna Himself becomes the object of dreadful ecstatic love. And when, out of ecstatic love, friends and wellwishers of Krsna apprehend some danger for Him, that situation becomes the object of their dread (page 379).”

Examples of Krsna as the Object of Fear When Rksaraja realizes that the person he is fighting is the Supreme Lord, he fears having offended Him. Krsna is the visaya-alambana. Rksaraja is asraya-alambana. (See page 379.) Another example: after Krsna sufficiently chastised Kaliya, the serpent said, “...I did not know Your actual position, and out of ignorance I have committed such horrible offences (page 379).” When Kaliya understood Krsna's supreme position he feared having offended Him. Krsna is the visaya-alambana. Kaliya is the asraya-alambana.

Examples of Demons as Objects of Fear. There are three ways in which a demon can be the cause (visaya-alambana) of ecstatic fear: (1) by seeing the demon, (2) by hearing about it, and (3) by remembering it.

1

BRS 4.6.1

280

Objects of Fear By Seeing the Demon

Kåñëa

Demon

By seeing the huge form of Kesi, and witnessing some of the recent disturbances Seeing Hearing about Remembering caused by him, Yasoda-mayi became very fearful about Krsna's safety. (See pages 379 - 380.) Seeing Kesi is the visaya-alambana. Yasoda is the asraya-alambana. By Hearing About the Demon “When it was learned that the demon was entering Gokula in an angry mood, mother Yasoda became so anxious to protect her child that her face dried up and there were tears in her eyes (page 380).” 2 Hearing about Kesi's angry entrance into Vraja is the visaya-alambana. Yasoda is the asraya-alambana. By Remembering the Demon “After the Putana witch had been killed, some friends of mother Yasoda inquired from her about the incident. Mother Yasoda at once requested her friends, ‘Please stop! Please stop! Don't bring up the incident of Putana. I become distressed just by remembering this incident...’ (page 380)” Remembering Putana is the visaya-alambana. Yasoda-devi is the asraya-alambana.

Anubhava “In the ecstasy of devotional service in dread, the unconstitutional symptoms are drying up of the mouth, exuberance, glancing behind oneself, concealing oneself, bewilderment, searching after the endangered lovable object and crying very loudly (page 380).”

Vyabhicari-Bhava “Some other unconstitutional symptoms are illusion, forgetfulness and expectation of danger (page 380).” Other prominent vyabhicari-bhavas for bhayanaka-bhakti-rasa are fear, death, unsteadiness, nervousness, despondency, depression and agitation. 3

Sthayi-Bhava Bhaya-rati (fear), is the sthayi-bhava of bhayanaka-bhakti-rasa. It arises from an offence or a fearful asura. “Such dread is caused either by offences committed or by dreadful circumstances (page 380).”

Other Objects of Dread There is another possible visaya-alambana for bhayanaka-rasa: Anyone who is powerful may be an object of dread and fear. Such persons strike fear into the heart in three ways: (1) by their fearsome form, (2) by their devious nature, and (3) by their awesome power. Srila Prabhupada mentions, “When dread is caused by a fearful object, this fearful object is generally a person who is fearsome in his features, nature and influence (page 380).” 2 3

The original text (BRS 4.6.7) also describes one of the prominent uddépanas for ecstatic dread — the raising of the demon's eyebrows. BRS 4.6.11 281

Fearsome Form Putana invokes ecstatic dread by her fearsome form. “An example of an object which caused ecstatic dread is the Putana witch (page 380).”

Devious Nature Kamsa and other wicked kings are examples of devious, mischievous natures that can invoke ecstatic dread. “Dread may be caused by mischievous demonic characters, such as King Kamsa (page 380).”

Awesome Power Great demigods like Saìkara or Indra are examples of great powers who may cause ecstatic dread: “...and it may be caused by great powerful demigods, such as Indra or Saìkara (page 380).”

Ecstatic Dread is not Possible Without Love Only devotees with love for Krsna can experience bhayanaka-bhakti-rasa (ecstatic dread). “Demons like Kamsa feared Krsna, but their feelings cannot be described as ecstatic dread in devotional service (page 380).”

GHASTLINESS BRS 4.7.1 - 14 When disgust (jigupsa-rati) is nourished within the heart of a devotee by its corresponding vibhava, etc. it transforms into ecstatic ghastliness (vibhatsa-bhakti-rasa). 4 “It is understood from authoritative sources that an attachment for Krsna because of feelings of disgust sometimes presents a ghastly ecstasy in devotional service (page 380).”

Vibhava Visaya-Alambana Krsna is akhila-rasamrta-mutih. He is the object of all rasa — including ecstatic ghastliness. But Krsna is not disgusting. How can He be the cause of ghastliness and disgust? Jiva Gosvami describes that He does not directly cause disgust. Things like the material world, objects of sense gratification, and the material body are immediate or direct causes (bahir-visaya) of ghastly rasa. Krsna is the indirect or root cause (mula-visaya) of ghastly rasa. Without Krsna at its root, emotion is not transcendental. Simply being disgusted with sex life is not transcendental mellow. But it is transcendental mellow if that disgust is linked with one's affection for Krsna. Thus there are two types of visaya for ecstatic ghastliness: the root object and the superficial object.

4

BRS 4.7.1

282

Asraya-Alambana A devotee who feels a heightened mood of disgust for the material world is the asraya-alambana of ghastly-mellow. This disgust towards sense gratification is a trademark of devotees in the neutral stage. Thus, “The person experiencing such ecstatic love for Krsna is almost always in the neutral stage of devotional service, or santa-rasa (page 381).” 5 Srila Rupa Gosvami gives an example of ecstatic ghastliness, which describes an advanced devotee's genuine disgust toward sex life. 6

Anubhava & Sattvika-Bhava Anubhava: “In this mellow of devotional service in ghastliness, the subecstatic symptoms are spitting upon the consideration of one's past life, contorting the face, covering the nose and washing the hands (page 381).” Sattvika-bhava: “There is also trembling of the body, forcible twisting of the body, and perspiration (page 381).”

Vyabhicari-Bhava “Other symptoms which may be present are shame, exhaustion, madness, illusion, frustration, humility, self-pity, restlessness, eagerness and stunning of the body (page 381).”

Sthayi-Bhava The sthayi-bhava of ecstatic ghastliness is jigupsa-rati (disgust), which is of two types: (1) vivekja — disgust arising from intelligence, and (2) prayiki — disgust arising from direct experience of material nature's abominable qualities.

Vivek-ja Due to an awakening of true knowledge one becomes disgusted with sense gratification and laments his previous absorption in it. Srila Prabhupada explains, “When a devotee, lamenting for his past abominable activities, shows special symptoms on his body, his feeling is called ecstasy in devotional service in ghastliness. This is caused by the awakening of his Krsna consciousness (page 381).” “In this connection there is the following statement: ‘How can a person take pleasure in the enjoyment of sex life in this body, which is a bag of skin and bones...’ (page 381)” This is an example of intellectual discrimination that causes disgust (jigupsa-rati) towards sex life. Srila Prabhupada comments on vivek-ja: “This perception is possible only for one who is awakened to Krsna consciousness and who has become fully cognizant of the abominable nature of this material body (page 381).”

5 6

Specifically, çänta-bhaktas and açrita-däsa (those who take shelter of the Lord 's service because of fear of the material world) are the äçraya for vibhatsa-bhakti-rasa. (See BRS 4.7.2) See The Nectar of Devotion , page 381: “A description of ecstatic l ove caused by ghastliness is found in the following statement...”

283

Prayiki Prayiki refers to the direct experience of the abominable qualities of material nature. This causes the devotee to lament his fallen condition and remember the Lord. To illustrate this, Srila Rupa Gosvami describes the disgust a child experiences in the womb, and his consequent yearning for devotional service (See page 381). Another example, “My dear Lord, Yamaraja has placed me in a situation which is full of filthy and obnoxious smells. There are so many insects and worms, surrounded by the stools left by different kinds of diseased persons... I have fallen into this hell, but I shall try to remember Your holy name always (page 381).” The rest of the chapter is Srila Prabhupada's commentary on prayiki.

284

Northern Ocean Eighth Wave Maitri-vaira-sthiti

Chapters 49 & 50

285

Chapter 49

Mixing of Rasas BRS 4.8.1 - 52

“Very often, in addition to one's regular rasa, there is found the presence of some other rasa, and the mixture of these loving humors is sometimes compatible, or palatable, and sometimes incompatible, or unpalatable. The following is a scientific analysis of the compatibility and incompatibility of the mixtures of these various rasas, or loving moods (page 383).” Each individual is eternally situated in one primary rasa, which interacts with all the other rasas in many complex and interesting ways. Some rasas are incompatible — they subtract from the flavor of the main rasa. Other rasas are compatible — they augment the flavor of the main rasa. Still others are neutral, neither augmenting nor subtracting from the main rasa. Srila Rupa Gosvami will list each of the rasas, along with its compatible and incompatible rasas.

Santa-Rasa — Neutrality Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

dasya (servitude)

madhurya (conjugal love)

sakhya (friendship)

vibhatsa (ghastliness)

yuddha-vira (chivalrous fighting)

vatsalya (parental)

dharma-vira (heroic religiosity) adbhuta

(astonishment) 1

“When in the rasa of neutral love (santa-rasa) there are found traces of ghastliness or astonishment, the result is compatible (page 383).”

1

raudra (anger) bhayanaka (fear)

hasya (laughter) karuna (compassion)

“When with this neutral love there are manifestations of conjugal love, chivalry, anger or dread, the result is incompatible (page 383).”

BRS 4.8.2-3. Çré Rüpa Gosvämé explains that adbhuta is compatible with all the primary rasas. 286

Dasya-Rasa — Servitorship Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

vibhatsa (dread)

madhurya (conjugal)

sakhya (friendship)

santa (neutrality)

yuddha-vira (Chivalrous fighting ) 2

vatsalya (parenthood)

dharma & dana vira (heroic religiosity and charity)

raudra

(anger) 3

hasya (laughter) karuna (compassion) bhayanaka (fear)

adbhuta (astonishment)

vibhatsa (ghastliness)

“When in the ecstasy of a serving humor there are manifestations of dread, neutral love or chivalry (such as dharma-vira and dana-vira), the result is compatible (page 383).”

“The ecstasy of devotional service in chivalry (yuddha-vira) and anger are directly produced by Krsna Himself (page 383).”

Sakhya-Rasa — Friendship Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

madhurya (conjugal)

vatsalya (parenthood)

santa(neutral)

hasya (laughter)

vibhatsa (ghastliness)

dasya (servitorship)

yuddha-vira (chivalrous fighting)

raudra (anger)

karuna (compassion)

adbhuta (astonishment) “With the ecstasy of fraternal love a mixture of conjugal love, laughter or chivalry is highly compatible (page 383).”

2 3 4

bhayanaka (fear) 4 “With the same fraternal love, a mixture of dread or parental love is most incompatible.” Ghastliness and anger are also listed in BRS 4.8.5.

Yuddha-véra is incompatible with däsya only if it involves fighting with Kåñna. See BRS 4.8.4 Raudra is incompatible with dsya only when the anger is directed at Kåñna. See BRS 4.8.4 Bhayänaka is incompatible with sakhya only if Kåñna is the object of fear. 287

Vatsalya-Rasa — Parenthood Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

hasya (laughter)

madhurya (conjugal)

santa (neutral)

karuna (compassion)

dasya (servitorship)

sakhya (friendship)

bhayanaka (fear) 5

yuddha-vira (chivalrous fighting)

vibhatsa (ghastliness)

adbhuta (astonishment)

raudra (anger) 6 “Although there are gulfs of differences between them, with the ecstasy of parental affection, a mixture of laughter, compassion or dread is compatible (page 383).”

“With the ecstasy of parental love a mixture of conjugal love, chivalry or anger is incompatible (page 384).” Servitude is also listed in BRS 4.8.6.

Madhurya-Rasa — Conjugal Love Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

hasya (laughter)

vatsalya (parental)

dasya (servitorship)

sakhya (friendship)

vibhatsa (ghastliness)

karuna (compassion)

adbhuta (astonishment)

santa (neutral)

vira (chivalry)

bhayanaka (fear)

raudra (anger)

“With the ecstasy of devotion in conjugal love a mixture of laughter or fraternity is compatible (page 384).”

See BRS 4.8.7.

There are other opinions of which rasas are compatible with madhurya, “According to certain expert opinions, in the ecstasy of conjugal love the feelings of chivalry known 5 6

Bhayänaka is compatible with vätsalya only when the demons are the object of fear. Däsya is in compatible with vätsalya onl y when Kåñna i s t he object of service. Yuddha-véra is incompatible with vätsalya only if it involves fighting directly with Kåñna. Raudra is incompatible with vätsalya only when directed at Kåñna. See BRS 4.8.6 288

as yuddha-vira and dharma-vira are the only compatible additions. According to this view, except for these two humors, all other manifestations are taken as incompatible with conjugal love (page 384).” This is not the opinion of Srila Rupa Gosvami.

Hasya-Rasa — Laughter Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

vibhatsa (ghastliness) 7

karuna (tragedy)

santa (neutral)

madhurya (conjugal)

bhayanaka (fear)

dasya (servitorship)

vatsalya (parental)

sakhya (friendship) adbhuta (astonishment) vira (chivalry) raudra (anger)

“With the ecstasy of devotional laughter a mixture of dread, conjugal love or parental love is compatible (page 384).”

7

“A mixture of compassion or ghastliness is incompatible (page 384).”

Jéva Gosvämé says that vébhatsa's co mpatibility with häsya (laughter) refers to a devotee putting on ghastly cost umes, or exhi biting ghast ly gest ures t hat cause feel ings of hum orous di sgust. It does not imply th e d isgust ex perienced b y seein g a v ery g hastly th ing, o r realisin g th e g hastliness o f m aterial existence.

289

Adbhuta-Rasa — Astonishment Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

vira (chivalry)

raudra (anger)

hasya (laughter)

santa (neutral)

vibhatsa (ghastliness)

karuna (tragedy)

dasya (servitorship)

bhayanaka (fear)

sakhya (friendship) 8 vatsalya (parental) madhurya (conjugal) “With the ecstasy of devotion in astonishment a mixture of chivalry or neutral love is compatible (page 384).”

“A mixture of anger or dread is always incompatible (page 384).”

Vira-Rasa — Chivalry Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

adbhuta (astonishment)

bhayanaka (fear)

vatsalya (parental)

hasya (laughter)

madhurya (conjugal) 9

karuna (tragedy)

sakhya (friendship)

santa (neutral)

raudra (anger)

dasya (servitorship) “With the ecstasy of devotional chivalry a mixture of astonishment, laughter or servitude is compatible (page 384).”

8 9 10

vibhatsa (ghastliness) “A mixture of dread or conjugal love is incompatible (page 384).” 10

BRS 4.8.10 mentions that sakhya is compatible with adbhuta. (See also footnote 1, this chapter.) Only according to some authorities are madhurya and véra incompatible. The l ast sent ence, si xth paragraph, page 384 s hould read: "Accordi ng t o som e expert opinions the ecstasy of neutral love is always incompatible with devotional service in chivalry." See BRS 4.8.10 290

Karuna-Rasa — Tragic Compassion Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

raudra (anger)

hasya (laughter)

dasya (servitorship)

vatsalya (parental)

adbhuta (astonishment)

sakhya (friendship)

bhayanaka (fear) 11

madhurya (conjugal) 12

santa (neutral) vira (chivalry) vibhatsa (ghastliness)

“With the ecstasy of compassion in devotional service a mixture of anger or parental love is compatible (page 384).”

“A mixture of laughter, conjugal love or astonishment is always incompatible (page 384).”

Raudra-Rasa — Anger Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

karuna (tragedy)

hasya (laughter)

santa (neutral)

vira (chivalry)

madhurya (conjugal)

vatsalya (parental)

bhayanaka (fear)

adbhuta (astonishment) dasya (servitorship) sakhya (friendship) vibhatsa (ghastliness)

“With the ecstasy of anger in devotional service a mixture of compassion or chivalry is compatible (page 384).”

11 12

“A mixture of laughter, conjugal union or dread is completely incompatible (page 384).”

See BRS 4.8.13 Lamentation (karuna-rasa) is in compatible with Madhurya-rasa onl y when t here i s reuni on of the lovers; when there is separation, lamentation is quite compatible with madhurya-rasa. See BRS 4.8.11 291

Bhayanaka-Rasa — Fear Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

vibhatsa (ghastliness)

vira (chivalry)

santa (neutral)

karuna (tragedy)

madhurya (conjugal)

dasya (servitorship)

hasya (laughter)

sakhya (friendship)

raudra (anger)

vatsalya (parental) adbhuta (astonishment)

“With the ecstasy of dread in devotional service a mixture of ghastliness or compassion is compatible (page 384).”

“With the ecstasy of chivalry in devotional service a mixture of conjugal love, laughter or anger is always incompatible (page 384).” 13

Vibhatsa-Rasa — Ghastliness Compatible

Incompatible

Neutral

santa (neutral)

madhurya (conjugal)

vatsalya (parental)

dasya (servitorship)

sakhya (friendship)

vira (chivalry)

hasya (laughter)

karuna (tragedy) adbhuta (astonishment) raudra (anger) vibhatsa (ghastliness)

“In the ecstasy of ghastliness in devotional service, feelings of neutral love, laughter or servitude are compatible (page 384).”

13

“Feelings of conjugal union and fraternity are incompatible (page 384).”

This sentence should read, "With the ecstasy of dread, a mixture of chivalry, conjugal union, laughter or anger is always incompatible." 292

Mixing of Rasas — It's Importance in Pleasing the Lord Srila Prabhupada discusses the importance of understanding tasteful and distasteful mixing of rasa by describing how Lord Caitanya's secretary, Svarupa Damodara, would carefully check all poetry brought before Lord Caitanya for incompatible mixing of rasas. If there was a trace of distasteful mixture, Svarupa Damodara would reject it, and Lord Caitanya would never even see the offering. (See pages 384 - 385.)

Compatible Rasas When compatible rasas combine the result is very relishable, like the meeting of two friends. “When a friend meets another friend, the mellow produced out of that meeting is generally taken as very palatable (page 385).” Srila Prabhupada comments, “But actually with such meetings between two friends, there are so many feelings involved that it is difficult to ascertain when these feelings are actually becoming compatible and when they are becoming incompatible (page 385).”

Rasas: "Whole" and "Part" When compatible rasas mix, one of them predominates and the others cooperate with and nourish it. Aìgi-rasa is the term for predominating mellow. Aìga-rasa is the term for cooperative mellows. Aìgi means "that which possesses limbs." Aìga means "limbs." Srila Prabhupada thus translates aìgi as the "whole" and aìga as the "part," because the limbs and parts (aìga) of the body serve and nourish the whole body (aìgi). “Expert literary scholars have analyzed the rasas which are compatible with one another by contrasting the various rasas in a particular mixture under the names whole and part. According to this method, the prominent feeling is called the whole, and the subordinate feeling is called the part (page 385).” In the tables previously given, the rasa listed in the table's heading is the aìgirasa, while the rasas listed in the "compatible" column are its aìga-rasas. For example:

293

The aìgi-rasa is santa-rasa. The rasas listed in the "compatible" column are aìga-rasas — they act as the parts (aìga) which serve the whole (aìgi). The incompatible rasas cause Santa-Rasa — Neutrality distaste. They do not serve the whole and thus Compatible Incompatible are not aìga-rasas. dasya (servitude) madhurya (conjugal love) One can analyse vibhatsa (ghastliness) yuddha-vira (chivalry) the rest of the tables in the same way. adbhuta (astonishment) raudra (anger) dharma-vira (religiosity)

bhayanaka (fear)

Examples of Aìgi and Aìga

Santa-Rasa Servitude Nourishes Neutrality “All living entities are just like sparks from the supreme fire, and as such, I do not know if I, a tiny spark, shall be able to engage myself in the transcendental loving service of this supreme fire, Lord Krsna (page 385).” We will first establish that two rasas are present: santa and dasya. Santa-rasa: By referring to the original verse (BRS 4.8.20) one can understand that "supreme fire" is a translation of Parambrahman. Thus the devotee in this verse sees the Lord primarily as Parambrahman, not Krsna. 14 Parambrahman is the visaya of santa-rasa. Consequently, there is an element of santa-rasa in this verse. Dasya-rasa: The devotee desires to engage in the loving service of Parambrahman. Consequently, there is an element of dasya-rasa in this verse. We will now establish that santa-rasa predominates over dasya-rasa. The speaker of this text possesses acute awareness of the Lord's overwhelming, infinite majesty and opulence (aisvarya-jnana). This shows in his stress on the point that he is extremely minute and insignificant in comparison to the Lord — a "tiny spark" compared to the "supreme fire." Although a desire for active service does arise, aisvarya-jnana causes him to hesitate, become shy, and finally desist from stepping forward to engage in intimate service. He can simply wonder if he will someday be able to serve the Lord. Thus santa is clearly the predominating mood (aìgi-rasa), nourished by dasya (the aìga-rasa). 14

As Çréla Prabhupäda's personal mood of affect ion is well beyond çänta-rasa, his sum mary includes a mention that Kåñna is the ultimate source of Parambrahman. 294

Ghastliness Nourishes Neutrality “Alas, I am still trying to relish different pleasurable states from this body, which is simply some skin covering mucus, semen and blood... (page 385)” The ghastliness serves to nourish the neutrality (ie detachment from the material world), thus santa is the aìgi-rasa, and vibhatsa is the aìga-rasa. Servitude, Astonishment, and Ghastliness Nourish Neutrality “I shall now begin my service of fanning the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Krsna [servitude], who is seated on a golden throne [astonishment]. He is the supreme Parambrahma [santa] in His eternal transcendental form of a cloudy blackish complexion. Now I shall give up my affection for my material body, which is nothing but a bunch of flesh and blood [ghastliness] (pages 385 - 386).” This is an example of three rasas simultaneously nourishing the santa-rasa.

Aìgi: Dasya-Rasa Neutrality Nourishes Servitude “When shall I be freed from the mode of ignorance? And being thus purified, when shall I attain the stage of serving Krsna eternally? Only then shall I be able to worship Him, always observing His lotus eyes and beautiful face (page 386).” Dasya is the aìgi-rasa, and santa (symptomized by the desire for purification of existence) is the aìga-rasa. Ghastliness Nourishes Servitude “Please look at this devotee of the Lord who is dancing just from remembering the lotus feet of Krsna. Simply by observing his dance you will lose all interest in even the most beautiful women! (page 386)” Ghastliness, Neutrality, and Chivalry Nourish Servitude “One devotee boldly [chivalry] said, ‘My dear Lord, now I am turning my face from any thought of association with young girls [ghastliness]. As far as Brahman realization is concerned [neutrality]...’ (page 386)”

Aìgi: Sakhya-Rasa Conjugal Love Nourishes Friendship “My dear Subala, the damsels of Vrndavana who had the opportunity of enjoying Krsna's kissing must be the foremost of all the fortunate women in the world (page 386).” Topics of conjugal love often nourish friendship by becoming the topic of friendly conversation.

295

Laughter Nourishes Friendship “While Krsna was joking in this way... Subala was also on the scene, and he began to look at Krsna with wide and laughing eyes (page 386).” The laughter nourishes Subala's friendly relationship with Krsna. Conjugal Love and Laughter Nourish Friendship “When Krsna saw that Subala, in the dress of Radharani, was silently hiding under the shade of a beautiful asoka tree on the bank of the Yamuna, He immediately arose from His seat in surprise. Upon seeing Krsna, Subala tried to hide his laughter by covering his cheeks (page 387).”

Aìgi: Vatsalya-Rasa Compassion Nourishes Parental Love “When mother Yasoda was thinking that her son was walking in the forest without any umbrella or shoes, she became greatly perturbed to think of how much difficulty Krsna must have been feeling (page 387).” Laughter Nourishes Parental Love “My dear Yasoda, your son has very cunningly stolen a lump of butter from my home. And to make me blame my own son for His mischief, He has smeared some of the butter on my son's face while he was sleeping! (page 387)” Fear, Astonishment, Laughter, Compassion Nourish Parental Love “When Krsna was holding up Govardhana Hill with His left hand, His hair became scattered all over His shoulders, and He appeared to be perspiring. When mother Yasoda saw this scene, she began to tremble [fear]. Then, as she stared at the scene with broadened eyes [astonishment], she saw Krsna begin to exhibit varieties of facial caricatures. Mother Yasoda then became very happy and began to smile [laughter]. Then again, when she thought that Krsna was holding up the hill for such an extremely long time [compassion], her clothes became soaked with perspiration (page 387).”

Aìgi: Madhurya-Rasa Friendship Nourishes Conjugal Love Srimati Radharani said, “My dear friends, just see how Krsna is resting His hand on the shoulder of Subala, who is dressed up just like a young girl! I think He must be sending some message to Me through Subala (page 387).”

296

Laughter Nourishes Conjugal Love “Krsna, in the dress of a young girl, told Radharani, ‘Oh, You hardhearted girl! Don't You know that I am Your sister? Why are You unable to recognize Me? Be merciful upon Me and please capture My shoulders and embrace Me with love...’ But because She was in front of many of Her superiors, She simply smiled and did not say anything (page 388).” Friendship and Chivalry Nourish Conjugal Love See paragraph beginning, “The following illustrates a mixture of several feelings... (page 388)”

Examples of Gauna-Rasas as Aìgi The common idea that indirect rasa is always subordinate to direct rasa is a misconception, as will become clear from these examples.

Laughter Nourished by Conjugal Love “When Kubja caught hold of Krsna's yellow garment because she was feeling almost lusty with sex urge, Krsna simply bowed down His head with His cheeks glowing in front of the many people who were standing there and laughing (page 388).” The main mood here is laughter. Kubja's uncontrolled public display of lust nourishes the humorous scene.

Chivalry Nourished by Friendship “Visala... was addressed by another cowherd boy as follows: ‘Why are you attempting to show your chivalrous spirit before me?...’ (page 388)”

Anger Nourished by Friendship and Chivalry “Sisupala was habituated to calling Krsna ill names... The Pandavas [sakhya] therefore equipped themselves with all kinds of weapons to kill Sisupala [vira] (page 389).”

Astonishment Nourished by Friendship, Chivalry, and Laughter “When Krsna saw Balarama finally defeated by Sridama [friendship], who was using only a small stick [chivalry], Krsna became filled with pleasure [laughter] and began to look upon Sridama with great wonder (page 389).”

Alternate Terminology There are two alternate terms to indicate predominant and subordinate mellows: sthayi and vyabhicari. Sthayi refers to aìgi-rasa (predominant mellow); vyabhicari refers to aìga-rasa (subordinate mellow). 297

Sthayi “Expert analysts of these various kinds of mellows instruct us that when different mellows overlap one another, the mellow which is the whole, or the prominent humor, is called the permanent ecstasy. It is confirmed in the Visnu-dharmottara that when there are many mellows of devotional ecstasy mixed together, the prominent one, or the whole, is called the steady ecstasy of devotional service (page 389).” "Permanent" or "steady" ecstasy is Srila Prabhupada's translation of sthayi.

Vyabhicari “Although the subordinate mellow may be manifested for a certain time, at length it will become merged into the prominent whole. Thus it is called an unconstitutional ecstasy of devotional service (page 389).” The phrase "unconstitutional ecstasy" is Srila Prabhupada's translation of vyabhicari. “When an unconstitutional ecstasy of devotional service manifested prominently at a certain time, it is still accepted as the part (page 389).” In summary, sthayi refers to aìgi-rasa, and vyabhicari refers to aìga-rasa. They do not refer to sthayi-bhava and vyabhicari-bhava. 15

Criteria of Subordinate Mellows A mellow cannot be considered aìga-rasa unless it substantially affects the predominant mellow. “If it is not very prominently manifested, it appears only slightly and merges quickly back into the whole. At such times of slight appearance, no consideration is given to it; when one is eating some palatable dishes, if one also eats a small blade of grass he will not taste it, nor will he care to distinguish what its taste is like (page 390).”

15

The rel ationship bet ween aìgé and aìga is similar to th e relatio nship b etween sthäyé-bhäva and vyabhicäré-bhäva. Vyabhicäré-bhävas nourish t he sthäyé-bhäva, and are t hen envel oped wi thin i t. Likewise, aìga-rasas nourish t he aìgé-rasa and then becom e m erged into the aìgé. Du e to th is similarity, the terminology is borrowed. 298

Chapter 50

Further Analysis of Mixed Rasas BRS 4.8.53 - 85

Virasata — Distaste from Incompatible Mellows When compatible mellows mix they increase the relishability of the aìgi-rasa. However, when incompatible mellows mix they diminish the aìgi-rasa and cause distaste (virasata). “As already described, if certain kinds of mellows become mixed and there is a joining of opposite mellows, then the situation is called incompatible.” Srila Prabhupada comments, “When one is eating sweet rice and something salty or sour is mixed in, the mixture is not very tasteful, and it is called incompatible (page 391).” Srila Rupa Gosvami gives some examples of distasteful situations.

Santa-Rasa With Madhurya-Rasa A young lady said, “For a long time my mind has been uselessly engaged in samadhi upon impersonal Brahman, thus I have not obtained darsan of Sri Krsna, the personification of transcendental bliss.” Santa-rasa and madhurya-rasa are incompatible. Mixing them causes virasata (distaste). Srila Prabhupada comments on this verse: Just as it is incompatible to mix madhurya with santa, it is incompatible for a neophyte devotee to artificially try to attain higher sentiments in devotional service. He says, “Sometimes it is found in places like Vrndavana that a person with a slight devotional attitude of neutral love for Krsna may immediately and artificially try to attain to the platform of conjugal love. But because of the incompatibility of neutrality and conjugal love, the person is found to fall from the standard of devotional service (page 391).”

Dasya-Rasa With Madhurya-Rasa “I am very anxious to see Krsna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is many millions of times more affectionate than the Pitas (Forefathers) in the Pitrloka and who is always worshiped by the great demigods and sages [servitude]. I am a little surprised, however, that although Krsna is the husband of the goddess of fortune, His body is often marked with the nail pricks of ordinary society girls! [conjugal] (page 391)”

Sakhya-Rasa With Vatsalya-Rasa “There is the following statement by a gopi... (page 391)” According to BRS 4.8.56, this statement is spoken by a gopa, not a gopi, and may be read as follows, “O friend — sakhe! please embrace me with your powerful arms, as sturdy as the bolts of a door. O Krsna, smelling your head, I will play with you!” In Vedic culture, the father smells the head of his son to show affection — it is an activity of vatsalya-rasa. The rest of the statement is strongly in sakhya-rasa (“he sakhe! Let's

299

play together!”). Parental love is incompatible with friendship, and their mixing causes virasata (distaste). 16

Vatsalya-Rasa With Dasya-Rasa “One devotee said, ‘My dear Krsna, how can I address You as my son when You are addressed by the great Vedantists as the Absolute Truth and by the Vaisnavas who follow the principles of Narada-pancaratra as the Supreme Personality of Godhead?...’ (page 392)” Krsna's parents are entrusted with His protection and maintenance; thus it is incompatible for them to think of Him as the source of all maintenance, possessor of all opulence, and supreme object of reverential worship. Mixing vatsalya and dasya causes virasata.

Madhurya-Rasa With Santa-Rasa “My dear friend, my youthful beauty is as temporary as lightning in the sky, and therefore my possessing attractive bodily features is unimportant [neutrality]. I have never met Krsna, so I request you to please arrange for my meeting Him immediately [conjugal] (page 392).” Youthful beauty is important in conjugal mellows. Therefore mixing santa-rasa with madhurya causes distaste. With Vastsalya-Rasa “A lusty woman in Kailasa once told Krsna, ‘My dear Krsna, may You have a long life!’ Then, after saying this, she embraced Krsna (page 392).” Giving blessings indicates vatsalya-rasa. Obviously, mixing parental love with conjugal love causes distaste. With Vibhatsa-Rasa (Ghastliness) “My dear boy, I know that my body is just a composition of flesh and blood and can never be enjoyable to You. But still, I have been so attracted by Your beauty that I wish that You accept me as Your conjugal lover (page 392).” It is clear how these ghastly realizations would put a damper on the mood of conjugal enjoyment. Mixing ghastliness with conjugal love causes virasata.

A Warning “Srila Rupa Gosvami warns devotees to not commit such incompatibilities in their writings or in their dealings. The presence of such contradictory feelings is called rasabhasa. When there is rasabhasa in any book of Krsna consciousness, no learned scholar or devotee will accept it (page 392).” 17

16 17

Friendship exists on the platform of equality. Parental love requires a distinction between parent and child, senior and junior. Thus the two are incompatible. Çréla Prabhupäda and Çré Rüpa Gosvämé use the term "rasäbhäsa" where we may expect to find the term virasatä. We will an alyse the validity of this usage, as well as th e subtle distinction between virasatä and rasäbhäsa in our Ninth Wave. (See ch. 51) 300

Incompatible Mellows That Do Not Cause Distaste There are six cases were incompatible mellows can combine without distaste: 1. When one uses an incompatible mellow to logically reinforce the predominant rasa. 2. When the incompatible mellows do not exist simultaneously, as when one of the mellows is remembered. 3. When one uses incompatible mellows to highlight the excellence of the predominant rasa. 4. When either the asraya or visaya of the incompatible rasas is different. 5. When incompatible aìga-rasa cooperatively nourish the aìgi-rasa. 6. When Krsna is either the visaya or asraya of all the mellows.

1) Used in Logical Argument to Reinforce the Predominant Rasa When one uses an incompatible mellow to logically reinforce the predominant rasa it does not create distaste. For example Paurnamasi says that great mystics try very hard to situate Krsna within their hearts, therefore what a mistake it would be for the gopis to neglect Krsna and try to force Him out of their hearts (See page 392). Santa-rasa is usually incompatible with madhurya-rasa, but in this case it is used as a tool to logically reinforce the mood of madhurya and thus does not cause virasata (distaste).

2) Non-Simultaneous Existence Mixing of incompatible mellows does not cause distaste if the rasas do not exist simultaneously, as when one of the rasas is remembered. For example, a devotee saw Krsna in the coils of Kaliya and began remembering how Krsna's joking words gave pleasure to all the Vraja-vasis. Hasya-rasa (laughter) is usually incompatible with karuna-rasa (lamentation), but in this case karuna-rasa arises from remembrance of hasya-rasa and therefore the mixture does not cause distaste. 18

3) Glorification of the Predominant Rasa by Comparison One may say, "Your face is like the moon." This does not mean that you have a spherical, pockmarked face; it means your face is effulgent and beautiful. Comparisons entail only the compatible characteristics, implicitly excluding the incompatible ones. Radharani is compared to a bramanandi, “Your tranquil mood makes You appear to be completely merged in Brahman realization (page 393).” This does not mean that Srimati Radharani is a rigid ascetic. It means the unwavering meditation of great self-realized sages is the only thing that can possibly compare to the steadiness of Her love for Krsna. Elements of santa are incompatible with madhurya, but a comparison implicitly excludes these incompatible elements. Thus it does not cause distaste.

18

This also illustrates how Kåñna's fo rm, q ualities, an d p astimes are an uddépana for karuna-rasa (see W aves of Devotion, page ). 301

Another example: Lord Krsna compared His meditation on Srimati Radharani to a santa-bhakta, since it caused Him not to sleep, remain in a meditative mood, and take up residence in the caves of mountains. “This is an example of conjugal love mixed with neutral love, but there is no incompatibility (page 393).”

4) Different Asraya and Visaya Another circumstance where incompatible rasas can mix without distaste is when the rasas have a different asraya or visaya. Srila Rupa Gosvami gives three examples: Different Visaya (Towards Krsna) “Rukmini-devi said, ‘My dear husband, a woman who has no taste for the transcendental pleasure available from Your personal contact must be inclined to accept as her husband somebody who is externally a combination of moustache, beard, body hairs, fingernails and some head hair. And within him there are muscles, bones, blood, intestinal worms, stools, mucus, bile and similar things...’ (page 394)” vibatsa (ghastliness) is usually incompatible with madhurya (conjugal love), but in this case the two rasas have different objects (visaya) and thus do not cause distaste. Krsna is the object of the conjugal sentiments; while an ordinary man is the object of ghastliness. Different Visaya (Towards Radharani) Krsna says, “My dear friend, what a wonderful thing it is that since I have seen the beautiful lotus eyes of Srimati Radharani, I have developed a tendency to spit on the moon and the lotus flower! (page 394)” Although vibatsa is usually incompatible with madhurya, there is no virasata here because Radharani is the object of the conjugal sentiments, while the moon and lotus flower are the objects of ghastliness. Different Asraya The third example describes Krsna in the wrestling arena of Kamsa. When Krsna was victorious, the cowherd boys experienced vira-rasa (chivalry), but the demons felt bhayanaka-rasa (fear). Chivalry and fear usually cause distaste when mixed, but in this case there is no virasata because the reservoirs (asraya) of the incompatible rasas are different. The cowherd boys are the asraya of chivalry. The demons are the asraya of fear. An Exception In the first example, chivalry mixed with fear — chivalry is a gauna-rasa, and fear is a gaunarasa. In the second and third examples, conjugal love mixed with ghastliness — conjugal love is a mukhya-rasa, and ghastliness is a gauna-rasa. In all three examples, virasata did not occur. However, if two incompatible mukhya-rasas mix, virasata will occur, even if the visaya or asraya is different. For example, a young lady asked her father to lock up the house and take her to Mathura to find Krsna, whom she had fallen madly in love with. This is a distasteful combination of

302

madhurya and dasya (two mukhya-rasas), even though the visayas are different (the object of dasya is her father, and the object of madhurya is Krsna). 19 Another example: A brahmanandi impersonalist said, “When shall I be able to see that supreme absolute Personality of Godhead who is eternal bliss and knowledge and whose chest has become smeared with red kumkum powder by touching the breast of Rukmini? (page 395)” This is a distasteful combination of santa and madhurya, even though the asrayas are different (Rukmini for madhurya, and the brahmanandi for santa). 20

5) Incompatible Aìga-Rasas Cooperatively Nourish the Aìgi-Rasa When two inimical disciples cooperate to serve their common master, they forget their differences. Similarly, when two subordinate mellows (aìga-rasas) work cooperatively to serve the predominant mellow (aìgi-rasa) there is no distaste, even if the subordinate mellows are normally incompatible. For example, “Nanda Maharaja told his wife, ‘My dear Yasoda, although your son, Krsna, is as delicate and soft as the mallika flower, He has gone to kill the Kesi demon, who is as strong as a mountain. Therefore I have become a little disturbed. But never mind, all auspiciousness to my son! I shall raise this hand, which is as strong as a pillar, and I shall kill the Kesi demon, just to give freedom from all anxieties to the inhabitants of Vraja-mandala!’ (page 395)” Nanda Maharaja first expresses fear of the demon (bhayanaka), then a chivalrous attitude to protect his son (yuddha-vira). Generally bhayanaka is incompatible with yuddha-vira, but in this case the combination does not cause distaste, because the inimical rasas work cooperatively to serve the predominant mellow.

6) When Krsna is the Asraya or Visaya of all the Mellows A mixture of incompatible rasa will not cause distaste if Krsna is the common visaya or asraya of them all. Krsna as the Common Visaya When many different people see Krsna in different ways, the contrast of rasas is tasteful. For example: “‘After Krsna's arrival in Kamsa's arena, Kamsa's priest looked at Krsna with a detestful expression. [vibhatsa-rasa] The entire arena was filled with dread on the part of Kamsa and his priest [bhayanaka-rasa] and restless expressions of pleasure on the cheeks of Krsna's friends [sakhya-rasa]. Frustration was felt by His envious rivals [raudra]. The great sages meditated [santa]. Hot tears were in the eyes of Devaki and other motherly ladies [karuna], and hairs stood on the bodies of the expert warriors [vira]. There was astonishment in the hearts of demigods such as Indra [adbhuta]. The servants danced [dasya], and the restless eyes of all the young girls glanced about [madhurya].’ In this statement there is a description of a combination of different mellows, but there is no incompatibility (page 395).”

19 20

Thus the last sentence on page 394 of NOD shoul d read, "In this incident there is a m ixture of conjugal love and parental love, which causes incompatible distaste." Some devotees who are attached to the jïäna-marg do not accept that çänta and madhurya cause virasatä even when there are different äçrayas. This is not the opinion of Çré Rüpa Gosvämé. 303

Krsna as the Common Asraya “A similar statement, which is free from incompatibility, is in the Lalita-madhava, wherein the author blesses all the readers of the book in the following manner: ‘Although the Supreme Personality of Godhead is able to lift a mountain with a finger of His left hand, He is always humble and meek. He is always very kind to His loving devotees. He has frustrated Indra's attempt at vengeance by refusing him the sacrifice of Indra-yajna. He is the cause of all pleasure to all young girls. May He be ever compassionate upon you all! (page 395).’”

304

Northern Ocean Ninth Wave Rasabhasa

Chapter 51

305

Chapter 51

Perverted Expression of Mellows BRS 4.9.1 - 41

Five emotional elements compose rasa. If one of these elements is inappropriate or missing, a distortion or perversion manifests in the rasa, called rasabhasa. To illustrate this principle, Jiva Gosvami compares rasa to sweet rice — which is also composed of five elements (milk, sugar, rice, cardamom, and fire) and cannot properly manifest if one of these ingredients is inappropriate or missing. If the cook mistakes salt for sugar, for example, or if he forgets to light the stove, the result will be payas-abhasa (payas means sweet rice) — something that appears similar to sweet rice, but tastes distorted. When a compositional element of rasa is inappropriate or distorted, the result is rasabhasa — it appears similar to rasa, but the taste is distorted.

Clarification of Terminology In the final two waves of Bhakti-Rasamrta-Sindhu Srila Rupa Gosvami uses very specific terminology, which we should briefly clarify here. Vaira — incompatible rasas. Virasata — distaste arising from mixture of incompatible rasas. Rasabhasa — defective rasa caused by a deficiency or incompatibility in its five compositional elements. Virasata occurs when two fully matured rasas clash and cause distaste. Rasabhasa occurs when one rasa cannot fully mature, because of a defect in one or more of its components. In The Nectar of Devotion, Srila Prabhupada seems to use the term rasabhasa synonymously with virasata. This is not unjustified, as Srila Rupa Gosvami himself asserts in BRS 4.8.62, and as we will now demonstrate. 1 Let us imagine a devotee whose sthayi-bhava is madhurya-rati. If this devotee meets the Four-armed Narayana, her madhurya-rati will not be able to properly mature and express itself. Lordly Narayana is an inappropriate visaya for madhurya-rasa. He is the proper visaya for santarasa. From one angle, distortion of rasa occurs because the vibhava is deficient and incompatible with the sthayi-bhava (this is rasabhasa). From another angle, distortion of rasa occurs because elements of santa-rasa contacted elements of madhurya-rasa — which are incompatible rasas (this is virasata). Depending on the angle of vision, the same phenomena may be viewed as either virasata or rasabhasa. To thoroughly comprehend the subject, however, one should clearly understand the distinction between terms. Virasata occurs when two fully matured rasas clash and cause distaste. Rasabhasa occurs when one rasa cannot fully mature, because of a defect in one or more of its components.

1

BRS 4.8.62: Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says, “Incompatibility of rasa (virasatä) practically culminates in rasäbhäsa."

306

Varieties of Rasabhasa “Rasabhasa, or incompatible mixtures of mellows, may be classified as uparasa (false expression), anurasa (imitation) and aparasa (perverted or misrepresented mellows) (page 397).” Of all varieties of rasabhasa, uparasa is uttama — it most closely resembles genuine rasa; anurasa is madhyama — it less closely resembles genuine rasa; aparasa is kanistha — it least resembles genuine rasa. 2

Uparasa — Distortion of Rasa When one of the five compositional elements of rasa is deficient, the effect generated is a perverted or distorted mellow called uparasa. 3

Santa-Uparasa Three things cause santa-uparasa: 4 1) When seeing the Lord, one focuses on His undifferentiated oneness with everything. 2) When seeing the world, one focuses on its undifferentiated oneness with God. 3) One has undue disgust for the material body, and dwells too much on distinguishing matter and spirit. God's Oneness with Everything “When a person has passed completely from all contamination of material existence, he relishes a transcendental bliss of being established in trance. But as soon as I saw You, the original Personality of Godhead, I experienced the same bliss (page 397).” The speaker of this verse equates the bliss of Lord's personal darsan with the bliss experienced by realising the undifferentiated oneness of the Absolute. This equation is false. It exemplifies an inappropriate expression that demotes santa-rasa to santa-uparasa. Oneness of Everything with God “Wherever I am glancing I simply see Your personality. Therefore I know that You are the uncontaminated Brahman effulgence... (page 397)” In santa-rasa one focuses on Parambrahman, but if that focus leans too much towards nirvisesa brahman it demotes santa-rasa to santauparasa.

Dasya-Uparasa Four things cause dasya-uparasa: 5 1. Displaying impudence before Krsna. 2. Disrespecting Krsna's devotees. 2 3 4 5

BRS 4.9.2 BRS 4.9.3 BRS 4.9.4 BRS 4.9.7

307

3. Seeing greater excellence in a devata other then one's own worshipable Lord. 4. Overstepping the boundaries of social etiquette. Displaying Impudence Before Krsna “When Madhumaìgala, an intimate friend of Krsna, was dancing before Krsna in a joking manner... (page 397)” By referring to the original text (BRS 4.9.8) one can understand that a brahmana boy was dancing wildly in front of a Deity of Krsna, despite the admonishment of his elders. By not following their orders, the boy was impudent. This distorted his service attitude (which is built upon meekness and humility) and barred it from properly maturing into true dasya-rasa.

Sakhya-Uparasa When friendship is not mutual there is sakhya-uparasa. 6 Krsna once addressed a king, "O friend." In response the king trembled in fear. The Lord then joked with him, but in response the king offered prayers. Finally Krsna tried to embrace him, but the king fell to the ground offering prostrated obeisances. Consequently, sakhya-rasa could not properly develop. 7

Vatsalya-Uparasa If Krsna's elder has too much awareness of His power, and therefore does not carefully endeavor for Krsna's protection and maintenance, vatsalya-rasa degrades to uparasa. 8 “My dear sister, having seen your dear son Krsna, I think that He is so strong that He can kill even wrestlers as strong as the mountains. So I will have no more anxieties about Him, even if He is engaged in a terrible fight (page 397).” A co-wife of Devaki spoke this. She had maternal affection for Krsna, but excessive awareness of Krsna's power disrupted the protective nature of motherly-love. Thus vatsalya-rasa cannot properly manifest. 9

Madhurya-Uparasa Three things cause madhurya-uparasa: 10 1) Defect in the sthayi-bhava (sthayi-bhava virupata). 2) Defect in the vibhava (vibhava-virupata). 3) Defect in the anubhava (anubhava-virupata).

6 7 8 9

10

BRS 4.9.9 BRS 4.9.10 BRS 4.9.11 BRS 4.9.12. The fi rst sent ence, l ast paragraph, page 397 shoul d read, "One of t he co-wi ves of Devaké, once addressed her as follows." The word for "sister" is bhayané, an affectionate term, just as one may call a good friend his "brother." BRS 4.9.13 308

Sthayi-Bhava Virupata There are two causes of defect in the sthayi-bhava: (1) When conjugal attraction is not mutual. (2) When the heroine has affection Mädhurya-Uparasa for more than one lover. Defect in Sthäyé-Bhäva Defect in Vibhäva Defect in Anubhäva

Non-Mutual Attraction

Vulgarity

Non-Mutual Attraction

Impudence

“The wives of the yajnika brahmanas were all young girls, and they were attracted to Krsna in the same way as the gopis of Vrndavana. Out of their attraction, they distributed food to Krsna (pages 397 - 398).” The Dvija-patnis had conjugal attraction to Krsna, but Krsna would only show them respect — since they were brahmana's wives. 11

Affection for More than One Lover

Affection for More than One Lover See reference beginning “One of the friends of Srimati Radharani told Her... (page 398)” Srimati Radharani appears to have rati towards more than one lover at the same time. In the original text it describes her love being divided into two parts by Kamadeva, seeing Kamaphala (name of Baladeva) playing before her, and hearing the venu of Mukunda. 12 Other Causes of Sthayi-Bhava-Virupata “According to some expert learned scholars, the feelings between lover and beloved create perverted reflections of mellows in many ways (page 398).” Some say there are other conditions that cause sthayi-bhava-virupata, such as when the hero (Krsna) has equal intensity of love for all his heroines (gopis), not properly recognising the gradations of their devotion to Him. Vibhava-Virupata A defect in the vibhava is caused if the lover is deficient in vidagdhata (cleverness) and/or ujjvalata (radiant beauty). This occurs when conjugal sentiments are expressed by animals, creepers, and unfit or elderly ladies. All of them are deficient in cleverness and/or beauty. 13 Example of Creepers “The gopis have become purified by Krsna's glance. . (page 398).” Only part of this verse appears in The Nectar of Devotion. The full text (BRS 4.9.19) describes the gopis speaking amongst 11

Even though the Dvéja-patnés had conjugal affection for Kåñna, they didn't have t he proper bodi es to relate with Kåñna — Kåñna woul d never ha ve conjugal relations with brähmana ladies. Thus there is virüpatä (distortion) of the äçraya. The original text describes that Kåñna withdrew His natural mild smiling and hid the natural restlessness of His eyes when He saw t he blossoming of C upid's fire in the Dvija-patnés. In ot her words, al though mädhuryarati existed in the ladies, Kåñna would not reciprocate th eir conjugal sentim ents, because they were improper äçrayas for mädhurya-rasa. 12 This seems to be an example of rasäbhäsa occurring due to quoting a wrong description of lélä. Çrématé Rädhäräné loves Kåñna exclusively. 13 BRS 4.9.18 309

themselves about how the buds of the creepers were blooming in ecstasy upon receiving the sidelong glance of Krsna and hearing the sound of His flute. This implies that the creepers were experiencing conjugal love, since Krsna's sidelong glance and flute are uddipanas of madhuryarasa. Creepers, however, are deficient in vidagdhata (cleverness). When placed in the position of asraya (lover), they cause a defect in the proper presentation of rasa. 14 The gopis see everything through the eyes of madhurya, and thus imagine the trees, creepers, animals, etc. are experiencing madhurya-rasa. This does not cause a defect in their taste of rasa. Trees and creepers themselves, however, cannot experience full madhurya-rasa. They may possess madhurya-rati, but because they are unfit asrayas this rati cannot develop into perfect rasa.

Anubhava-Virupata There are three causes of anubhava-virupata: (1) inappropriate behavior, (2) vulgarity, and (3) impudence. 15 Inappropriate Behavior Specific behavior is appropriate for specific situations. If one is not expert, she will behave inappropriately and thus cause a defect in anubhava. 16 For example, if Krsna cheats His lover by meeting another girl, the cheated girl should angrily chastise Him — that is the appropriate behavior for the circumstance. If she doesn't, then the rasa develops a defect due to her inappropriate behavior. Srila Rupa Gosvami illustrates this: A young lady once said to Krsna: “Even if your chest is marked with the nails of some other lover, please don't be embarrassed or shy. Just please accept me as your maidservant, and grant me the mercy of your sidelong glance.” 17 This young lady should have chastised Krsna. He would have then smiled mildly and the madhurya-rasa would nicely escalate. Instead of becoming angry, however, this girl offered humble prayers. This defective response is anubhava-virupata, which demotes madhurya-rasa to madhurya-uparasa. Vulgarity There are two types of vulgarity that cause anubhava-virupata in madhurya-rasa: (1) using the word bala (little boy) to address Krsna and (2) uncultured statements or behavior.

14

15 16 17

In NOD, Çrél a Prabhupäda t ranslates one reference for vibhäva-virüpatä. A bri ef sum mary of som e of the other references follows: Vibhäva-virüpatä in animals: (BRS 4.9.20) The gopés describe the deer as gazi ng upon Kåñna wi th cupidity after seeing his sidelong glance. Vibhäva-virüpatä in unfit la dies: BRS 4.9.21 descri bes the pulindés (aborigine girls) with lusty desires after seeing Kåñna's restless eyes. Vibhäva-virüpatä in elderly gopés: BRS 4.9.22 descri bes an el derly gopé trying to make herself look young and casting sidelong glances at Kåñna. B RS 4.9.23 descri bes that this elderly gopés does have genui ne madhuryarati, but due to vibhäva-virüpatä the rati cannot evolve into rasa, only uparasa. BRS 4.9.25 BRS 4.9.26 BRS 4.9.27 310

Addressing Krsna as Bala “After Krsna chastised the Kaliya-naga in the Yamuna River... (page 398)” Kaliya's wives address Krsna as gopal balak, "Dear boy". Conjugal relations are not proper with young children; thus addressing Krsna as a young child (bala) is vulgar and causes uparasa. Uncultured Statements or Behavior Uncultured statements occur when one is too blatant in her requests for sambhoga service (conjugal union). 18 For example, “One devotee said, ‘My dear Govinda, here is a nice flowery bush in Kailasa. I am a young girl, and You are a young poetic boy. After this, what more can I say? You just consider.’ (page 398)” Uncultured behavior (gramyatva — village behavior) includes unattractive activities such as scratching of the loins, etc. 19

Anurasa — Imitation of Rasa Genuine rasa always focuses on Krsna. If someone other than Krsna becomes the focus, rasa degrades to anurasa. 20 For example: “When Narada Muni was passing through Vrndavana... (page 398)” Narada saw a pair of parrots discussing Vedanta and, struck with wonder, he began to exhibit the symptoms of adbhuta-rasa. Yet, because his wonder centred on someone other than Krsna, it is anurasa (an imitation of real Krsna-centred rasa).

Aparasa (False Rasa) Only Krsna's loving devotees can experience true rasa. His enemies can never experience rasa. If they appear to manifest behavior similar to rasa, one must know that it is aparasa —false rasa. 21 For example, “When Krsna was fleeing from the battlefield, from a distant place Jarasandha was watching Him with restless eyes and was feeling very proud. Being thus puffed up with his conquest, he was repeatedly laughing (page 399).” Jarasandha's laughter is hasyaaparasa — false ecstatic laughter. 22

Usefulness of Rasabhasa Rasabhasa does have some utility in evoking ecstatic love of Krsna. It is useful for achieving certain effects in Krsna-lila and in dramatic presentations. “Everything in connection with Krsna is called ecstatic devotional love, although it may be exhibited in different ways: sometimes in right order and sometimes as a perverted reflection. According to the opinion of all expert devotees, anything that will arouse ecstatic love for Krsna is to be taken as an impetus for transcendental mellow (page 399).”

18 19 20 21 22

BRS 4.9.30 BRS 4.9.28 BRS 4.9.33 BRS 4.9.38 Jéva Gosväm é comments: if a devotee sees the demon laughing at Kåñna and t hus begins to laugh at his stupidity, the devotee may experience true häsya-rasa. (This paradigm cannot be applied to mellows other than häsya). 311

Concluding Words “Srila Rupa Gosvami concludes by saying that Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu is very difficult for ordinary men to understand, yet he hopes that Lord Krsna, the eternal Supreme Personality of Godhead, will be pleased with his presentation of this book (page 401).”

312

Important Sanskrit Terms in

Bhakti-Rasamrta-Sindhu In Contextual and Alphabetical Order, With Brief Definitions How to Use this Glossary Example: "Adhikrta dasa" Find adhikrta dasa in the alphabetical listing. (Diacritics are given no concern. Thus, "a" is the same as "a", "i" the same as "i", etc.) The alphabetical listing says: "Adhikrta dasa (west2)." This indicates that the term adhikrta dasa is discussed in the Western Ocean, Second Wave. Go now to the contextual list, and locate the Western Ocean, Second Wave. There you will find a succinct definition of adhikrta dasa, and a note of the page on which the topic is discussed. The advantage of the contextual listing is that one finds the term as it appears in the original text, surrounded by relevant and related terms.

Alphabetical Listing Asa-bandha (east3) Asraya (south1) Asrita dasa (west2) Asru (south3) Adhikrta dasa (west2) Anga-rasa (north8) Angi-rasa (north8) Akalpa (south1) Akhila-rasamrta-murti (intro) Alambana (south1) Amrta (pre) Anaucitya (south4) Anavahita (north5) Anubhava (south2) Anusilana (intro)

A

Anuga dasa (west2) Anukampa (west4) Anukulyena (intro) Anuman adbhuta (north2) Anurasa (north9) Anya-rupa (south1) Anyabhilasita-sunyam (intro) Aparasa (north9) Aprarabdha (east1) Apurvata (south1) Asadharana uddipana (west1) Asaktis tad-gunakhyane (east3) Asatyatvam (south4) Atha hasa (south2) Atmarama (west1) Avara (south4)

Avrta-svarupa (south1) Avidya (east1) Avyartha-kalatvam (east3) Ayoga (west2) Ayogyatvam (south4) Bhakti (pre) Bhakti-rasa (pre) Bhavarupa (east3) Bhavah sa eva sandratma

B

(east4)

Bhaya-rati (south5) Bhoga-tyaga (pre) Bhukti (east2) Bhuyistha (south1) Bijam (east1) 313

Capala-sukha (pre) Catuska (south1) Cesta (south1) Cestarupa (east3) Chaya (east3) Citta (east3) Citta vrtti (south4) Citta-masrnya (east3) Dainyavodhika (east2) Dana-vira (north3) Darsana-dana (east3) Dasya-rati (south5) Daya-vira (north3) Dharma-vira (north3) Dhira (west2) Dhira-lalita (south1) Dhira-prasanta (south1) Dhirodatta (south1) Dhiroddhata (south1) Dhumayita (south3) Dhurya (west2) Digdha (south3) Dipta (south3) Gauna-rati (south5) Gauna-snigdha (south3) Gaurava-priti-rati (west2) Ghurna (south2) Gita (south2) Guna (south1) Guru-padasraya (east2) Harda (east3) Hasya-rati (south5) Hikka (south2) Hladini (east3) Hunkara (south2) Irsyu (north5) Jimbhanam (south2) Jnana (east2) Jnana-karmady-anavrtam

C

D

G

H

Lalasamayi (east2) Lalasrava (south2) Laulyam (east2) Lila-madhurya (south1) Lobha (east2) Loka anapeksita (south2) Madhurya-rati (south5) Madhyama-adhikari (east2) Mahatmya-jnana-prema (east4)

Maitri (north8) Mamata-buddhi (south5) Mamatva-atisayankitah (east4)

I J

(intro)

Jnanicari (west2) Jugupsa-rati (south5) Jvalit (south3) Kaisora (south1)

Kama (east2) Kamanuga (east2) Kamapraya (east2) Kamarupa (east2) Kampa (south3) Kanistha-adhikari (east2) Karkasa (south4) Kaumara (south1) Kevala (south5) Kevala-prema (east4) Klesa (east1) Klesaghni (east1) Komal (south4) Kopa (north5) Krosanam (south2) Krodha-rati (north5) Krodha-rati (south5) Krpa-siddha (south1) Krsna ahita-kari (north5) Ksanti (east3) Ksepana (south2) Ksobha (south5) Kutam (east1)

Mana (west5) Mana-sunyata (east3) Manòana (south1) Mangalacarana (intro) Manyu (north5) Manyu chote (north5) Manyu pujya (north5) Manyu samana (north5) Maryada-marga (east2) Mathura-manòale sthitih

Moksa-laghutakrt (east1) Nama-gane sada ruci (east3) Nava-yauvana (south1) Nija ahita-kari (north5) Nirdesa-esa vartipi (west2) Nisattva (south3) Nisedha (east2) Nitya-siddha (south1) Nivrtti (intro) Nrtya (south2)

L

M

Papam (east1) Parakiya (east2) Paratantra (south4) Parisada dasa (west2) Paroksa santa-rasa (west1) Pauganòa (south1) Phalgu-vairagya (east2) Prapti-abhilasa (east3) Prarabdha (east1) Prayascitta (east2) Prabhuta-jnana (west2) Prakata-svarupa (south1) Prakirna (south1) Pralaya (south3) Pranaya (west3) Prarartha (south5) Prasadana (south1) Prati-bimba (east3) Pratikulya (south4) Pratipa (south3) Pravasa (west5) Pravrtti (intro) Prayiki (north7) Prema (west2) Prema-madhurya (south1) Prema-suryamsu (east3) Premankura (east3) Priti (west2) Pritis tad-vasati sthale (east3) Priyata-rati (south5) Priya-narma-sakhas (west3) Priya-sakhas (west3) Pura-vyasyas (west3) Purti (south5) Purva-raga (west5) Pusti-marga (east2)

(east2)

K

Mukhya-rati (south5) Mukhya-snigdha (south3) Mukti (east2)

Raga (east2) Raga (west2) Raganuga-bhakti (east2)

N

P

R

314

(east2)

Raganugiya-bhavattho-prema (east4)

Ragatmika-bhakti (east2) Raktogam (south2) Rasa (south1) Rasa (pre) Rasabhasa (north9) Rati (south5) Rati (south5) Rati-sunya (south4) Raty-abhasa (east3) Raty-abhasa (south3) Raty-anusparsana (south4) Romanca (south3) Rupa-madhurya (south1) Ruksa (south3) Rusa (north5) Samvit (east3) Sadhaka (south1) Sadhaka-rupena (east2) Sadhana (east3) Sadhana-bhakti (east2) Sadhana-siddha (south1) Sadharana uddipana (west1) Sadhya (east3) Sahasi (north5) Sajatiya (west5) Sajatiyasaya-snigdha sribhagavad-bhakta-sango (east2) Sakhas (west3) Sakhya-rati (south5) Saksad adbhuta (north2) Saksaka santa-rasa (west1) Saksat (south4) Samanya-rati (south5) Sambandhanuga (east2) Sambandharupa (east2) Sambhoga (west5) Sambhoga icchamayi (east2) Sambhrama-priti-rati (west2) Samprarthanatmika (east2) Samutkantha (east3) Samyan masrnita-svanto (east4)

Sandhi (south4) Sandrananda-visesatma (east1) Sankula (south5) Santa-rati (south5) Santi (south4) Sarangata (west2) Sattvika-abhasa (south3)

Utkanthitva (west2) Utpatti (south4) Utphulla (south2) Utsaha-rati (south5) Uttama-adhikari (east2) Uttama-bhakti (intro)

Sattvika-bhava (south3) Sattvikabhasa (south3) Sauharda-abhilasa (east3) Savalya (south4) Sita (south2) Seva-nistha (west2) Siddha (south1) Siddha-rupena (east2) Siddhi (west2) Sindhu (pre) Sneha (west2) Snigdha (south3) Soka-rati (south5) Sri bhagavatarthasvado (east2) Sri krsnakarsini (east1) Sri-krsna-diksadi-siksanam

Raganuga-sadhana-bhakti

Vacika (east3) Vaidha-bhavottho-prema (east4)

(east2)

S

Sri-murter-anghri-sevane pritah (east2) Sri-nama-sankirtanam (east2) Stambha (south3) Sthayi-bhava (south5) Sthiti (west2) Subhada (east1) Suddipta (south3) Suddha-rati (south5) Suddha-sattva (east3) Sudurlabha (east1) Suhrt (west3) Sva-rupa (south1) Svaccha-rati (south5) Svakiya (east2) Svarabheda (south3) Svartha (south5) Svarupa-laksanam (intro) Svarupa-siddhi (east2) Svasa bhuma (south2) Svatantra (south4) Sveda (south3) Tad-anvayi-alambana (north 1) Tad-atmaka (east3) Tanu-motana (south2) Tapasvi (west1) Tat-tad-bhava-icchatmika

T

Vaidhi-bhakti (east2) Vaira (north8) Vairagya (east2) Vaivarnya (south3) Vara (south4) Vasana (south1) Vatsalya-rati (south5) Venu-madhurya (south1) Vibhava (south1) Vidhi (east2) Vijatiya (west5) Vijnapti (east2) Vikasa (south5) Viksepa (south5) Viluhita (south2) Vinamrta-buddhi (west2) Vipralambha (west5) Virakti (east3) Virasata (north8) Vismaya-rati (south5) Vistara (south5) Visrambhena guroh seva (east2) Visvastha (west2) Vivek-ja (north7) Viyoga (west2) Visaya (south1) Vira (west2) Vraja-sakhas (west3) Vyabhicari-bhava (south4) Vyabhicaryabhasa (south4) Vyavahita (south4) Yoga (west2) Yuddha-vira (north3) Yuga (south1) Yukta-vairagya (east2)

(east2)

Tatastha-laksanam (intro) Trasrt (west2) Tusti (west2) Uddipana (south1) Uddipta (south3) Uparasa (north9)

V

Y

U

315

316

Eastern Ocean: Varieties of Devotional Service Preface

Bhakti — devotional service Rasa — mellow, juice; the relishable taste derived from a relationship Bhakti-rasa — The relishable taste derived from devotional service Amrta — deathless, nectar (a beverage that brings immortality); indicates that the pleasure of devotional service is eternal Sindhu — ocean; indicates that the pleasure of devotional service is unlimited Bhoga-tyaga — indicates that mundane pleasure requires oscillation between enjoyment and renunciation Capala-sukha — flickering happiness; indicates that mundane pleasure is short-lived

First Wave: Samanya-Bhakti — Overview of Devotional Service Mangalacarana — auspicious invocation; prefaces any Vaisnava endeavor, especially literary; it defines the objective, offers obeisances, and gives benedictions Akhila-rasamrta-murti — Krsna, the complete embodiment of all mellows DEFINITION OF PURE DEVOTIONAL SERVICE Uttama-bhakti — pure, super-excellent devotional service Svarupa-laksanam — intrinsic characteristics; defines the fundamental nature of an object or person Tatastha-laksanam — extrinsic characteristics; further defines and distinguishes an object (or person) by describing qualities outside it's fundamental nature Anusilana — activities (silanam) guided by the disciplic succession (anu-) Pravrtti — pursuance of favorable activities Nivrtti — avoidance of unfavorable activities Anukulyena — favorable intention. Anyabhilasita-sunyam — completely free from ulterior motive Jnana-karmady-anavrtam — not covered by non-devotional activities, such as philosophical speculation and ritualistic pursuits SIX CHARACTERISTICS OF PURE DEVOTIONAL SERVICE Klesa — suffering, and the causes of suffering Klesaghni — relief from suffering (in sadhana-bhakti) Papam — sinful actions Prarabdha — manifest reactions 317

Aprarabdha — unmanifest reaction. Bijam — seed (of suffering): sinful desire Kutam — precursor of desire: sinful proclivity Avidya — ignorance; root of suffering Subhada — attainment of all-auspiciousness (in sadhana-bhakti) Moksa-laghutakrt — derides even the happiness of liberation (in bhava-bhakti) Sudurlabha — is rarely achieved (in bhava-bhakti) Sandrananda-visesatma — incalculably intense bliss (in prema-bhakti) Sri Krsnakarsini — is the only means to attract Sri Krsna (in prema-bhakti)

Second Wave: Sadhana-Bhakti — Devotional Service in Practice Sadhana-bhakti — practice executed by the senses, with the potential to bring on the manifestation of one's dormant love of Godhead (bhava-bhakti). Vaidhi-bhakti — devotional service predominantly inspired by obligation to guru and sastra. Raganuga-bhakti — devotional service inspired simply by natural, spontaneous attraction to a particular mood of service. PART 1: VAIDHI-BHAKTI — REGULATIVE PRACTICE Uttama-adhikari — candidate with highest eligibility for sadhana-bhakti. Very strong faith, and very strong scriptural knowledge Madhyama-adhikari — candidate with medium eligibility for sadhana-bhakti. Very strong faith, somewhat lacking in scriptural knowledge Kanistha-adhikari — candidate with the least eligibility for sadhana-bhakti. Weak faith and weak scriptural knowledge. Easily swayed by superior arguments Vidhi — rule, order Nisedha — regulation, prohibition Bhukti — desire for material enjoyment Mukti — desire for liberation Prayascitta — ritual process of purification 64 ITEMS OF SADHANA-BHAKTI Guru-padasraya — accepting the shelter of a bona fide spiritual master Sri-krsna-diksadi-siksanam — accepting initiation from the spiritual master and receiving instructions from him Visrambhena guroh seva — serving the spiritual master with faith and confidence Vijnapti — entreaty, submission 318

Samprarthanatmika — expressing ones heart-felt desire for spontaneous devotional service Dainyavodhika — expressing ones insignificance before the Deity Lalasamayi — expressing ones desire for a specific spiritual perfection. This is an advanced practice that involves some realization of one's eternal relationship with the Lord Svarupa-siddhi — the living entity's perfectional form and service Laulyam — excessive eagerness for meeting and serving the Lord in a particular way Mathura-manòale sthitih — residing in Mathura Sri-murter-anghri-sevane pritah — worshipping the Deity Sri bhagavatarthasvado — hearing Srimad-Bhagavatam Sri-nama-sankirtanam — chanting the Hare Krsna mantra Sajatiyasaya-snigdha sri-bhagavad-bhakta-sango — serving a devotee ITEMS RELATED TO SADHANA-BHAKTI Jnana — knowledge. A process of self-realization through cultivation of knowledge Vairagya — renunciation. A process of self-realization through cultivation of renunciation Yukta-vairagya — balanced renunciation. To accept only those things that can be used in Krsna's service, and to reject everything else Phalgu-vairagya — false renunciation. To reject things that can be used in Krsna's service Maryada-marga — an alternate term for vaidhi-sadhana-bhakti PART 2: RAGANUGA-SADHANA — SPONTANEOUS PRACTICE Raga — attraction Ragatmika-bhakti — the perfect devotional attachment found in the residents of Vrndavana Sambandharupa — perfect devotees with intense desire to serve Krsna in the mood of His parent, friend, or intimate servant Kamarupa — perfect devotees with intense desire to serve Krsna in the mood of conjugal love Raganuga-sadhana-bhakti — practice that aspires to develop the devotional mood of a ragatmika Sambandhanuga — practice that aspires to develop the mood of the sambandharupa ragatmikas Kamanuga — practice that strives for the mood of the kamarupa ragatmikas Sambhoga icchamayi — striving for the mood of those who directly meet Krsna in conjugal love

319

Tat-tad-bhava-icchatmika — striving for the mood of those who do not directly meet with Krsna, but assist Srimati Radharani and thus directly experience Her loving mood through service and appreciation Svakiya — wedded mood Parakiya — unwedded mood Kamapraya — Kubja's attraction for Krsna. "Almost lusty." Kama — lust. Lobha — intense covetousness for a particular mood of service. Basic qualification for raganuga-sadhana. Sadhaka-rupena — externally emulating the activities of one's ragatmika in his or her form as a sadhaka in gaura-lila. Siddha-rupena — internally emulating the activities of one's ragatmika in his or her form as a siddha in krsna-lila. Pusti-marga — an alternate term for raganuga-sadhana (used mainly by the Vallabhasampradaya).

320

Third Wave: Bhava-Bhakti — Devotional Service in Ecstasy Cestarupa — performing devotional service through one's endeavors Sadhana — endeavors that impel bhava to manifest; practice; "effective" Sadhya — endeavors that result from bhava; perfection; "effective" Bhavarupa — performing devotional service through one's emotions Citta — heart-mind; consciousness Suddha-sattva — the Lord's internal potency, who revives the living entity's dormant love for Krsna Samvit — cognitive, knowledge-giving aspect of the internal potency Hladini — devotional, pleasure-giving aspect of the internal potency Tad-atmaka — the condition wherein suddha-sattva permeates one's citta to such an extent that it appears to become one with the consciousness Premankura — term describing bhava as "the first sprout of prema" Prema-suryamsu — term describing bhava as "a ray of the sun of prema" Citta-masrnya — a soft heart, sensitive to Krsna conscious emotions "TASTES" OR DESIRES THAT AWAKEN AT BHAVA Prapti-abhilasa — desire to achieve Krsna Anukulya-abhilasa — desire to please Krsna with various services Sauharda-abhilasa — desire to be close at heart with Krsna BHAVA ACHIEVED BY THREE TYPES OF MERCY: Vacika — by a verbal blessing. Darsana-dana — blessing by appearing in person to the devotee. Harda — by heartfelt, unspoken blessing. NINE CHARACTER TRAITS OF BHAVA-BHAKTI Avyartha-kalatvam — scrupulous utilization of time Ksanti — perseverance Virakti — complete detachment, even in the midst of sense objects Mana-sunyata — pridelessness, even though one is highly elevated Asa-bandha — hope against hope; faith that Krsna will deliver one Samutkantha — intense enthusiasm Nama-gane sada ruci — constant attraction to chanting Hare Krsna Asaktis tad-gunakhyane — addiction to glorifying Krsna's qualities 321

Pritis tad-vasati sthale — love for living in the Lord's dhama Raty-abhasa — when neophyte or non-devotees display emotions that resemble the symptoms of bhava Prati-bimba — reflective attachment; relatively intense semblance of devotional ecstasy caused by engagement in bhakti with ulterior desires Chaya — shadow attachment; semblance of devotional ecstasy caused by engagement in bhakti out of curiosity. Less intense but also less offensive than prati-bimba, and therefore the superior of the two

Fourth Wave: Prema-Bhakti — Devotional Service in Pure Love of Godhead CHARACTERISTICS OF PREMA Bhavah sa eva sandratma — the intensified state of bhava Samyan masrnita-svanto — complete softening of the heart Mamatva-atisayankitah — intense possessiveness of Sri Krsna Vaidha-bhavottho-prema — prema arising from bhava achieved through vaidhi-sadhana Mahatmya-jnana-prema — love mixed with knowledge of the Lord's majesty Raganugiya-bhavattho-prema — prema arising from bhava achieved through raganuga-sadhana Kevala-prema — unmixed, one-pointed love

Southern Ocean: Overview of Bhakti-Rasa First Wave: Vibhava — Ecstatic Stimulants

Rasa — when various emotional components heighten one's affection for Krsna to a relishable intensity Apurvata — the astonishing, unprecedented, eternally new taste of rasa Vibhava — "causes of ecstasy;" that which stimulates one's affection for Krsna, heightening it to the point of relishable intensity Alambana — "basic" excitants; subjects in which affection is tasted Asraya — reservoir of affection; lover; generally the devotee Visaya — object of affection; beloved; generally Krsna Anya-rupa — Krsna in an entirely different form Sva-rupa — Krsna's in His own form Avrta-svarupa — Krsna's form in disguise Prakata-svarupa — Krsna's form, undisguised Uddipana — "impelling" excitants; objects by which rati is tasted (ie. flute, etc.) 322

VISAYA — KRSNA AS A STIMULUS FOR ECSTATIC LOVE Qualities of Sri Krsna Lila-madhurya — uniquely sweet pastimes Prema-madhurya — uniquely sweet devotees Venu-madhurya — uniquely sweet all-attractive flute Rupa-madhurya — uniquely sweet beauty Krsna's Personality Traits Dhirodatta — noble Dhira-lalita — romantic Dhira-prasanta — peaceful Dhiroddhata — haughty ASRAYA — THE DEVOTEE AS A STIMULUS FOR ECSTATIC LOVE Sadhaka — practicing devotee Siddha — perfect devotee Nitya-siddha — eternally perfect Sadhana-siddha — those who become perfect by practice Krpa-siddha — those who become perfect by causeless mercy UDDIPANA — OBJECTS THAT STIMULATE ECSTATIC LOVE Guna — Krsna's qualities (body, mind, and speech) Kaumara — childhood; 1-5 years old Pauganòa — boyhood; 6-10 years old Kaisora — adolescence; 11-15 years old Nava-yauvana — eternal youth; 16 years old Cesta — Krsna's adventures Prasadana — Krsna's attire Vasana — clothing Yuga — two-piece outfit of upper and lower garments Catuska — four-piece outfit Bhuyistha — elaborate, festive outfit of many garments Akalpa — natural decorations Manòana — jewellery Prakirna — miscellaneous stimulants

323

Second Wave: Anubhava — Subsequent Ecstasy Anubhava — "subsequent ecstasy;" an action that results from heightened affection for Krsna, which further enhances that affection Sita — actions that do not involve strong bodily movement Gita — singing loudly Jimbhanam — yawning Svasa bhuma — breathing heavily Loka anapeksita — neglecting the presence of others Lalasrava — Foaming at the mouth ("drooling") Hunkara — roaring Raktogam — bleeding (found only in mahabhava) Utphulla — swelling of the limbs (found only in mahabhava) Ksepana — actions that involve strong bodily movement Nrtya — dancing Viluhita — rolling on the ground Tanu-motana — stretching the body Krosanam — crying loudly Atha hasa — laughing like a madman Ghurna — staggering Hikka — hiccups ("belching")

Third Wave: Sattvika-Bhava — Existential Ecstasy Sattvika-bhava — "constitutional" or "existential ecstasy;" an involuntary reaction that arises directly from the suddha-sattva-enriched soul Snigdha — moist; ecstatic symptoms in persons who love Krsna, instigated by emotions arising from either the direct or indirect mellows Mukhya-snigdha — direct-moist; when a direct mellow instigates the emotions that cause ecstasy Gauna-snigdha — indirect-moist; when an indirect mellow instigates the emotions that cause ecstasy Digdha — smeared ("burnt"); ecstatic symptoms in persons who love Krsna, not instigated by the direct or indirect mellows Ruksa — dried-up; ecstatic symptoms that seem to appear in those with no love for Krsna ASTIKA-SATTVIKA-BHAVA Stambha — being stunned 324

Sveda — perspiration Romanca — standing hairs Svarabheda — faltering voice Kampa — trembling Vaivarnya — changing bodily color Asru — tears Pralaya — devastation INTENSITIES OF ECSTATIC SYMPTOMS Dhumayita — smouldering; the ecstatic symptom is only slightly manifest, and can be concealed Jvalit — flaming; two or three ecstatic symptoms manifest simultaneously, very difficult to conceal Dipta — burning; four or five ecstatic symptoms manifest simultaneously, impossible to conceal Uddipta — brightly burning; five or more ecstatic symptoms manifest simultaneously and very powerfully Suddipta — most bright; attainable only in the mahabhava of Srimati Radharani and Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu; all eight sattvika-bhavas manifest simultaneously, with the highest possible degree of intensity SATVIKA-ABHASA Satvikabhasa — "ecstatic symptoms" in persons without genuine affection for Krsna. Raty-abhasa — caused by proximity to a genuine ecstatic devotee. Satvika-abhasa — caused by a soft-hearted emotional disposition. Pratipa — in a hard-hearted person, caused by the powerful influence of krsna-katha. Nisattva — a forced, theatrical display.

Fourth Wave: Vyabhicari-Bhava — Transitory Ecstasy Vyabhicari-bhava — "transitory ecstasy;" an emotional experience resulting from intensified affection for Krsna, that embellishes and further stimulates the affection Paratantra — dependent; ecstatic emotions born from affection for Krsna Avara — ecstatic emotions that do not nourish one's affection for Krsna Vara — ecstatic emotions that nourish one's affection for Krsna Saksat — ecstatic emotions that nourish a primary rasa Vyavahita — ecstatic emotions that nourish a secondary rasa Svatantra — independent; ecstatic emotions not directly born from affection for Krsna 325

Rati-sunya — emotions void of affection for Krsna Raty-anusparsana — emotions not originally born from affection for Krsna, but which subsequently dovetail with affection VYBHICARY-ABHASA Vyabhicaryabhasa — semblance of ecstatic emotions Pratikulya — "ecstatic emotions" in persons who are inimical to Krsna Anaucitya — ecstatic emotions imagined to exist in those who are not actually feeling the emotion Asatyatvam — ecstatic emotions imagined in a subject in whom they do not exist (generally an inert living entity) Ayogyatvam — ecstatic emotions imagined in a subject who is incapable of fully experiencing them (generally an animal) CONDITIONS OF VYABHICARI-BHAVA Utpatti — generation; the beginning of an emotion Sandhi — conjunction; two or more emotions unite Savalya — aggregation; one emotion supplants another Santi — satisfaction; a disturbing emotion is resolved Citta vrtti — internal disposition Karkasa — hard disposition; (1) can conceal emotions, (2) not easily moved by emotions Komal — soft disposition; (1) cannot conceal emotions, (2) easily moved by emotions

Fifth Wave: Sthayi-Bhava — Constitutional Ecstasy Sthayi-bhava — one's eternal mood of affection for Krsna (as a passive admirer, servant, friend, parent, etc.). Svartha — selfish; when one's mood of affection takes nourishment from other emotions Prarartha — selfless; when one's mood of affection gives nourishment to other emotions MUKHYA-RATI Mukhya-rati— five moods of direct loving relationship with Krsna Suddha-rati — neutral affection Samanya-rati — general affection; affection that has not yet matured into a specific relationship 326

Svaccha-Rati — transparent affection; occurs in one who does not yet possess any specific affection for Krsna, but who reflects the affections of various devotees, like a transparent crystal reflecting the color of any object placed in its proximity Santa-Rati — peaceful affection; occurs in one who is completely detached from sense gratification, but has no inclination for an active relationship with the Lord Mamata-buddhi — mine-ness; a sense of "possessing" Krsna in a personal relationship Kevala — unmixed possessiveness; a relationship of exclusive servitude, friendship, or parental affection Sankula — mixed possessiveness; a relationship that blends servitude, friendship, and parental affection Dasya-rati — servitorship; characterized by inferiority to Krsna, which results in a sense of dependence upon His favor and kindness Sakhya-rati — friendship; characterized by equality with the Lord, which results in absence of any timidity or shyness, and a predominance of prankish, humorous behavior Vatsalya-rati — parenthood; characterized by superiority and seniority to Krsna, which results in a sense of protective, merciful compassion towards the Lord Madhurya-rati or priyata-rati — conjugal love; characterized by intimate infatuation with the Lord, which gives rise to eight kinds of conjugal enjoyments (sambhoga) and many affectionate exchanges GAUNA-RATI Gauna-rati — seven moods of indirect loving relationship with Krsna Hasya-rati — laughter Vismaya-rati — astonishment Utsaha-rati — valorous enthusiasm Soka-rati — lamentation Krodha-rati — anger Bhaya-rati — fear Jugupsa-rati — disgust SYMPTOMS OF RELISHING STHAYI-BHAVA Purti — fulfilment Vikasa — manifestation Vistara — expansion Viksepa — dispersion Ksobha — agitation

Western Ocean: Mukhya-Bhakti-Rasa 327

First Wave: Santa-Rasa — Neutral Affection Paroksa santa-rasa — indirect neutral affection; evoked not directly by the Lord's form, but indirectly by the effulgence emanating from the Lord's form Saksaka santa-rasa — direct neutral affection; evoked by direct perception of the Lord's form Atmaramas — self-realized souls Tapasvis — those who undergo penance and austerities Asadharana uddipana — unique impetuses; objects that impel devotees of one specific rasa Sadharana uddipanas — shared impetuses; objects that impel devotees of many rasas

Second Wave: Priti-Rasa — Servitude Sambhrama-priti-rati— reverential servitude; characterized by awareness of Krsna's supremacy and anxious eagerness to serve Him; respectful humility is the main character trait of a reverential servant Gaurava-priti-rati — servitude with the intimate mood of a son or similar dependant Prabhuta-jnana — awareness that, "Krsna is my Lord and master" Priti — affection DASAS Their Character Traits Prasrt — psychological disposition of asrita dasa; they are meek and humble, always keeping their glance downward Visvastha — psychological disposition of anuga dasa; they are faithful and fearless of carrying out very intimate services Nirdesa-esa vartipi — psychological disposition of parisada dasa; they have a natural taste for carrying out Krsna's direct orders in accordance with their particular service Vinamrta-buddhi — psychological disposition of adhikrta dasa; they are explicitly aware of Krsna's position as Prabhu and Master Four Dasas Adhikrta dasa — demigods appointed to specific services in the material world Asrita dasa — devotees who have taken shelter of the Lord's protection Sarangata — those who take shelter of the Lord's protection due to fear of material existence Jnanicari — those who have realized Brahman, but give up the desire for moksa and take shelter of Krsna, knowing Him to be the origin of Brahman. Seva-nistha — those who simply love Krsna, and therefore have fixed desire to serve Him Parisada dasa — intimate ministers who render various personal services 328

Anuga dasa — intimate followers of the Lord in Vraja and Dvaraka Three moods Dhurya — those who express love towards Krsna, the lovers of Krsna, and those who serve the lovers of Krsna Dhira — those who do not have a specific service for the Lord, but are firmly situated in the shelter of a dear devotee Vira — those who do not take shelter of anyone besides Sri Krsna STAGES OF PREMA Prema — one's love for Krsna never wavers or diminishes for an instant, even if it has good reason to do so Sneha — the heart melts, and one cannot withstand even a moment of separation from Krsna Raga — meeting with Krsna converts even the greatest distress into happiness; separation from Krsna converts even the greatest happiness into distress, and one is prepared to give up his life MEETING AND SEPARATION Ayoga — Separation Utkanthitva — longing to meet Krsna for the first time Viyoga — desire for reunion with the Lord Yoga — Meeting Siddhi — perfection; meeting Krsna for the first time Tusti — satisfaction; being reunited with Krsna Sthiti — steadiness; constant meeting

Third Wave: Preyo-Rasa — Friendship Pura-vyasyas — friends living outside Vrndavana, in larger towns and cities Vraja-sakhas — friends in Vrndavana Suhrt — well-wishers; a little older than Krsna; trace of parental affection Sakhas — friends; younger than Krsna; trace of servitude Priya-sakhas — confidential friends; same age as Krsna; pure friendship Priya-narma-sakhas — most intimate friends; most intimate and exalted devotees of sakhya, Krsna engages them in the very confidential service of arranging His meetings with the gopis STAGES OF PREMA Pranaya — one's love impels him to relate with Krsna on the platform of affection and friendship, free from formalities 329

Fourth Wave: Vatsala-Rasa — Parenthood Anukampa — a protective mood of compassion and mercy towards Krsna; the main characteristic of vatsalya-rati

Fifth Wave: Madhura-Rasa — Consorthood Sajatiya — circumstances favorable to conjugal love Vijatiya — are opposing conjugal love Vipralambha — separation Purva-raga — separation prior to first meeting Mana — self-imposed separation due to anger Pravasa — separation caused by physical distance Sambhoga — meeting

Northern Ocean: Indirect Bhakti-Rasa First Wave: Hasya-Rasa — Laughter

Tad-anvayi-alambana — one who takes the position of visaya-alambana due to his or her connection with Krsna

Second Wave: Adbhuta-Rasa — Astonishment Saksad adbhuta — astonishment caused by direct perception Anuman adbhuta — astonishment caused by inference

Third Wave: Vira-Rasa — Chivalry, Heroism Yuddha-vira — heroic fighting Dana-vira — heroic charity Daya-vira — heroic compassion Dharma-vira — heroic adherence to religious principles

Fourth & Fifth Waves: Karuna-Rasa & Raudra-Rasa — Compassion & Fury Krodha-rati — sthayi-bhava of raudra-rasa. "Anger" Anavahita — inattentive; they are inattentive in protecting Krsna 330

Sahasi — bold; they rashly take Krsna into danger Irsyu — envious; they have unnecessary anger towards Krsna, due to jealous love Nija ahita-kari — one's own enemy Krsna ahita-kari — Krsna's enemy VARIETIES OF KRODHA-RATI Kopa — anger exhibited towards the enemy Manyu — anger towards Krsna's well-wisher Manyu pujya — anger towards superior well-wishers Manyu samana — anger towards well-wishers who are one's equals Manyu chote — anger towards junior well-wishers Rusa — anger towards the beloved

Sixth & Seventh Waves: Bhayananka-Rasa & Vibhatsa-Rasa — Dread & Ghastliness Vivek-ja — disgust arising from intelligence Prayiki — disgust arising from experience

Eighth Wave: Maitri-Vaira-Sthiti — Compatible & Incompatible Mixture of Mellows Maitri — compatible rasas Angi-rasa — in a mixture of rasa, that rasa which is served and nourished by the others Anga-rasa — in a mixture of rasa, that rasa which serves and nourishes the angi-rasa Vaira — incompatible rasas Virasata — distasteful mixture of rasa

Ninth Wave: Rasabhasa — Imperfect Expression of Mellows Rasabhasa — imperfect rasa Uparasa — distorted rasa Anurasa — imitation rasa Aparasa — false rasa

331

Appendix A: A Perfect Defintion of Pure Devotional Service anyabhilasita-sunyam jnana-karmady-anavrtam anukulyena krsnanusilanam bhaktir uttama Pure devotional service is: Empowered activity intended to please Krsna; without ulterior motive, and not covered by philosophical or fruitive pursuits. Here are three reasons why this is the perfect definition of pure devotional service: (1) It is so precise that one cannot mistake pure devotional service for anything else. (2) It is neither overly exclusive, nor overly inclusive. (3) It perfectly applies in all circumstances, to stages of devotees — in practice, and in perfection.

1. Unmistakably Distinct A good definition clearly distinguishes it's object. For example, one may define chair as "something with four legs." This is not so precise, since animals also have four legs. To better distinguish a chair, one may say, "it is an object with four legs." But tables also fit that description. To clarify even further: "a chair is an object that people sit on, which has four supporting legs." Still, benches fit this description. Finally, one may define chair as "an object that one person sits on, which has four supporting legs." In a similar way, each word of Srila Rupa Gosvami's definition further clarifies the subject, negating all misconceptions and making pure devotion unmistakably distinct.

Silanam One may wrongly think that uttama-bhakti ("pure devotion") is an idle emotion: "Love," in a docile sense of the word. Silanam negates this misunderstanding by defining pure devotion as active love.

Krsna Yes, pure devotion is active love, but for whom. Many people think that the ultimate expression of devotion is to love your neighbors, your spouse, your family, your "fellow man," the world, mother nature, etc. The word krsna negates this misunderstanding by defining pure devotion as active love for Krsna.

Anukulyena Another misconception: "He may not explicitly dedicate his life to God, but he performs no evil actions, so he is a good man, pleasing to the Lord." 332

The person described above is not sinful, but it is wrong to think that he is on an equal platform with those who explicitly try to please God. The word anukulyena negates this misunderstanding by indicating that devotional service is not merely incidentally pleasing to the Lord, it must be intended to please Him. Demons such as Kamsa incidentally pleased Krsna, but this does not make them devotees.

Anu The next misconception: Yes, Pure devotion is active love intended for Krsna's pleasure. I am doing that, "in my own way." Different people have different conceptions of what pleases God. Some conceive of simple piety as the summit of devotion. Others imagine that illicit sex is somehow "spiritual." The prefix anu- negates this misunderstanding by establishing that one can please God in whatever way one so desires or imagines — our activities can actually please God only when we find out what he wants from us by connecting with a bona-fide spiritual master.

Anyabhilasita-Sunyam A pious person may go to the temple and perform authorized activities that are intended to please Krsna. But what is their motive? They may be praying for a house, a TV, a good job... The words anyabhilasita-sunyam (without ulterior motive) negate the misconception that this type of worship is devotional service.

Jnana-Karmady Anavrtam Finally, a person may engaged in authorized activities intended for Krsna's pleasure, and without an ulterior motive — but pure devotional service is not only apratihata (unmotivated), it must also be ahaituki (uninterrupted). The words jnana-karmady anavrtam make it clear that pure devotional service must not be covered, or interrupted, by any other activities, such as philosophical speculation, and fruitive pursuits.

2. Not Overly Inclusive or Exclusive Each word of Srila Rupa Gosvami's definition corrects the over-inclusiveness caused by a particular misconception, as described above. However, Srila Rupa Gosvami uses his words carefully, and thus avoids being overly exclusive.

Anu-Silanam Docile love is an overly inclusive concept of bhakti, so Srila Rupa Gosvami defines it as anusilanam: activities. At the same time, he avoids over-exclusiveness by implying that the word anu-silanam refers not only to bodily activities, but also to activities of the mind and words. 1

1

Further, Çréla Prabhupäda poi nts out in The Nect ar of Devot ion th at th e mental activ ities o f Kåñ na consciousness are, in many ways, the most important. "Thinking, feeling, and willing..." W hat we think about eventually manifests in what we do. Therefore the "mental culture" of Kåñna consciousness is most important. 333

Krsna Thinking that anyone can be the object of pure devotion is overly inclusive, so Srila Rupa Gosvami defines that pure devotion is exclusively for Krsna. At the same time, he avoids overexclusiveness by implying that "krsna" refers to Krsna and all His energies in their connection with Him.

Anukulyena "Pure devotional service is activity that pleases Krsna." Demons sometimes inadvertently please Krsna. Since this definition includes their activities as devotional service, it is overly inclusive. Devotees sometimes seem to displease Krsna (like mother Yasoda in damodara-lila). Since this definition would not include their activities as devotional service, it is overly exclusive. Therefore, Srila Rupa Gosvami introduces the word anukulyena: the intention behind the action is of utmost importance. Demons don't have favorable intentions. Thus their actions are not devotional service. Devotees do have favorable intentions. Thus their actions are pure devotional service. In this way, the word anukulyena makes the definition neither overly exclusive nor overly inclusive.

Anyabhilasita-Sunyam Srila Rupa Gosvami says that pure devotional service must be devoid of all material desire. At the same time, he avoids over-exclusiveness by adding the suffix -ta.

Jnana-Karmady Anavrtam Srila Rupa Gosvami also says that pure devotional service must not be interrupted by other activities. He avoids over-exclusiveness by saying anavrtam.

3. Applies in all Circumstances Srila Rupa Gosvami describes uttama-bhakti, the highest devotional service, in such a way that it is applicable to all stages of devotees, both in practice and in perfection. In the Second Wave he describes exactly how this definition applies to the stage of practice (sadhana-bhakti). In the Third Wave, to bhava-bhakti. And in the Fourth Wave, premabhakti.

334

Appendix B

The Twelve Rasas and their Components MUKHYA-RATI Santa Rasa — Neutrality I. Vibhava Visaya — Four-handed Narayana Asraya — Atmaramas (self-realized sages), and Tapasvis (renunciates). Uddipana — Asadharana: Hearing Upanisads, living in solitude, meditation, knowledge, seeing material objects in relation to the universal form, study of Vedanta... Sadharana: Smelling tulasi offered to the Lord, going on pilgrimage, conquering the senses...

II. Anubhava Asadharana: Behave like an avadhuta, concentrate eyesight on tip of nose, give discourses on Absolute Truth, use of hand-mudras. Sadharana: Yawn, stretch, offer prayers...

III. Sattvika-bhava Stambha (stunned), romanca (hairs standing on end), sveda (prespiration), kampa (shivering)...

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Nirveda (self-disparagement), mati (thoughtfulness), harsa (jubilation), dhrti (forebearance), smrti (rememberance), cinta (anxiety), vitaska (argumentativeness).

V. Sthayi-bhava Suddha krsna-visaya rati. Sama, mental perception of Krsna's form. Sandra, sensory perception of Krsna's form.

Dasya-Rasa (sambhrama-priti) — Reverential Servitude I. Vibhava Visaya — Visnu, or Krsna Asraya — Four types of servants: adhikrta (demigods), asrita (surrendered souls), parisada (personal ministers), and anuga (intimate servants). 335

Uddipana — Asadharana: Krsna's mercy, the dust from His feet, His prasadam... Sadharana: Krsna's flute, bugle, smile, footprints...

II. Anubhava Asadharana: 100% engagement in service, attentive to service, non-envious of others, making friendship with dasas... Sadharana: Dancing...

III. Sattvika-bhava All eight.

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava All thirty-three, except: srama (weariness), mada (intoxication), trasa (fear), apasmrti (forgetfulness), alasya (laziness), ugrata (ferocity), amarsa (haughtiness), asuya (envy), nidra (drowsiness), and "?".

V. Sthayi-bhava Sambhrama-priti-rati.

Dasya-Rasa (gaurava-priti) — Familial Servitude I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna (mainly in Dvaraka) Asraya — lalaniyas (subordinates): a) Kanistha: subordinate relatives. b) Putra: sons. Uddipana — Krsna's fondness, His smile...

336

II. Anubhava Sitting at a lower level, following orders, Managing Krsna's daily affairs, offering obeisances, humility, renunciation of displeasing behavior...

III. Sattvika-bhava All eight

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Same as in sambhrama-priti-rasa

V. Sthayi-bhava Gaurava-priti-rati

Sakhya-Rasa — Friendship I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna, both inside and outside of Vrindaban Asraya — Krsna's friends Pura-vyasya — friends outside Vrindaban Vraja-sakha — friends in Vrindaban: (1) suhrt, elder well-wishing friends, (2) sakha — slightly younger friends, (3) priya-sakha — friends of the same age, and (4) priyanarma-sakha — most confidential friends Uddipana — Pauganòa age, His beauty, bugle, flute...

II. Anubhava Wrestling, playing ball, playing chess, "piggy-back" riding, baton-twirling, resting together, playing on swings, jokings, swimming in pools...

III. Sattvika-bhava All eight

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava All except: trasa (fear), alasya (laziness), and ugrata (ferocity). In separation, these five also cannot manifest: mada (intoxication), harsa (jubilation), garva (pride), nidra (drowsiness), dhrti (forebearance) In meeting, these previous five can manifest, but these five cannot: mrti (death), srama (weariness), vyadhi (disease), apasmrti (forgetfulness), dainya (humility)

V. Sthayi-bhava Sakhya-rati

Vatsalya-Rasa — Parenthood 337

I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna Asraya — Krsna's elders, who have anukampa (a sense of protective compassion and mercy towards Krsna) Uddipana — Kaumara age, childhood dress, childish restlessness, childish words...

II. Anubhava Smelling Krsna's head, patting Krsna, blessing, ordering, gazing at child, seeing to His maintainence, chastizing and correcting improper behavior...

III. Sattvika-bhava All eight. One Additional asadharana-sattvika-bhava: Milk flowing from breasts

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava All thirty-three.

V. Sthayi-bhava Vatsalya-rati

Madhurya-Rasa — Conjugal Love I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna Asraya — Gopis, and others. Uddipana — Flute...

II. Anubhava Exchange of sidelong glances, exchange of smiles, joking...

III. Sattvika-bhava All eight

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava All except ugrata (ferocity) and alasya (laziness). However, alasya (laziness) can manifest after conjugal pastimes. Ugrata (ferocity) can manifest towards those who pose impediments to the meeting of Radha and Krsna.

V. Sthayi-bhava Madhurya-rati Characterized by desire to meet Krsna in eight ways (See footnote , page ). 338

GAUNA-RATI Hasya-Rasa — Ecstatic Laughter I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna Tad-anvayi: others, whose funny behavior is connected with Krsna. Asraya — All types of devotees. Young people, combinations of young and old people, and sometimes even very grave and serious people. Uddipana — The words and behavior of Krsna, or his parents...

II. Anubhava Vibration of the nostrils, lips, cheeks...

III. Sattvika-bhava ?

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Harsa (jubilation), alasya (laziness), avahita (concealed feelings)...

V. Sthayi-bhava Hasya-rati (affection in laughter)

Adbhuta-Rasa — Ecstatic Astonishment I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna Asraya — All types of devotees Uddipana — Krsna's astonishing activities

II. Anubhava Becoming astonished and apprehensive...

339

III. Sattvika-bhava Stambha (stunned), asru (weeping), romanca (standing of hairs on end)...

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Cinta (anxiety), harsa (jubilation)...

V. Sthayi-bhava Vsmaiya-rati (affection in wonder) a) saksat (arises from direct perception of wonderous act) b) anumana (arises from inferal of wondrous act)

Vira-Rasa (Yuddha) — Ecstatic Fighting I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna, as a participant in or spectator of fighting Asraya — Yuddha-vira, the heroic fighter. Uddipana — When an opponent chalenges one by bragging; slapping his thighs as a gesture of defiance; takeing up weapons; exhibiting rivalry, valour, and heroism...

II. Anubhava In response to the opponents challenge, when one braggs; exhibits defiance; takes up weapons; exhibits rivalry, valour, and heroism. Also: displaying manliness, roaring like a lion out of pride in one's prowess, using angry words, assuming various fighting postures, being enthusiastic to fight inspite of being alone, never retreating from battle, instilling fearlessness in persons who are afraid...

III. Sattvika-bhava All eight

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Garva (pride), avega (agitation), dhrti (forebearance), harsa (jubilation), utsukata (eagerness), asuya (envy), smrti (rememberance)...

V. Sthayi-bhava Yuddha-utsaha-rati (enthusiasm for battle)

Vira-Rasa (Dana) — Heroic Charity I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna, either as the direct recipient of charity, or as the recipient of the auspicious beneficts acrued by giving in charity.

340

Asraya — Dana-vira (the hero of charity) a) Munificent: heroicly gives everything in charity b) Renunciate: heroicly declines to accept any charity from the Lord Uddipana — Seeing fit recipient of charity. Sometimes, Krsna also impels charity.

II. Anubhava Giving more than is deserved, conversing with laughter, firmness or steadiness, cleverness and skill, patience.

III. Sattvika-bhava ?

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Vitaska ("counter-arguments"), utsukata (enthusiasm), harsa (jubilation)...

V. Sthayi-bhava Dana-utsaha-rati (enthusiasm to give charity)

Vira-Rasa (Daya) — Heroic Charity I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna in a disguised form (such as Vamana-deva) Asraya — Daya-vira (the hero of compassion) Uddipana — Things that display the distress of the object of compassion

II. Anubhava Giving one's life; protecting the distressed person; speaking comforting, soothing words; exhibiting steadiness...

III. Sattvika-bhava ?

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Utsukata (enthusiasm), mati (thoughtfulness), and harsa (jubilation)...

V. Sthayi-bhava Daya-utsaha-rati (enthusiasm for compassion).

Vira-Rasa (Dharma) — Heroic Religiousity I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna

341

Asraya — Dharma-Vira (the hero of religiousity) Uddipana — Hearing the scriptures

II. Anubhava Moral conduct, tolerance, sense control...

III. Sattvika-bhava IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Smrti (rememberance), mati (thoughtfulness).

V. Sthayi-bhava Dharma-utsaha-rati (enthusiasm for religiousity)

Karuna-Rasa — Compassion in Tragedy I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna, Krsna's devotees, or relatives of Krsna's devotees Asraya — Those who witness any of the above in a tragic situation Uddipana — Krsna's qualities, form, and activities...

II. Anubhava Regret, heavy breathing, crying, falling on the ground, beating upon one's chest...

III. Sattvika-bhava IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Alasya (laziness), nirveda (self-disparagement), glani (guilt), dainya (humility), cinta (anxiety), visada (depression), utsukata (eagerness), capalata ("restlessness"), unmada (madness), mrti (death), apasmrti (forgetfulness), vyadhi (disease), moha (bewilderment)

V. Sthayi-bhava Soka-rati (affection in lamentation)

Raudra-Rasa — Ecstatic Fury I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna, Krsna's well-wishers, Krsna's enemies Asraya — Any devotee (however, generally only the gopis and sakhis become angry with Krsna) 342

Uddipana — Sarcastic remarks, unfavorable glances, insulting words.

II. Anubhava Rubbing the hands; clacking the teeth; clamping the lips; knitting the yebrows; scratching the arms; lowering the head; breathing rapidly; using strong words; nodding of the head; yellowing, reddening, or fading of the eyes; trembling of the lips; chastisement; silence

III. Sattvika-bhava All eight

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava All thirty-three

V. Sthayi-bhava Krodha-rati (affection in anger) a) Kopa-krodha-rati: anger towards Krsna b) Manyu-krodha-rati: anger towards Krsna's well-wisher i) Manyu-pujya-krodha-rati: anger towards senior well-wisher ii) Manyu-samana-krodha-rati: anger towards peer well-wisher iii) Manyu-chote-krodha-rati: anger towards junior well-wisher c) Rusa-krodha-rati: anger towards Krsna's jealous lover

Bhayanaka-Rasa — Ecstatic Dread I. Vibhava Visaya — Krsna or a demon Asraya — One who has offended Krsna, or one who fears that a demon will harm Krsna Uddipana — Movements of the demons eyebrows...

II. Anubhava ? (4.6.9-10)

III. Sattvika-bhava All eight, except asru (tears).

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Trasa (fear), mrti (death), capalata (restlessness), avega (agitation), glani (depression), visada (despair), moha (bewilderment), apasmrti (forgetfulness), sanka (alarm)...

V. Sthayi-bhava Bhaya-rati (affection in fear) 343

Vibhatsa-Rasa — Ecstatic Ghastliness I. Vibhava Visaya — mula-visaya (root object): Krsna, bahir-visaya (imediate object): the material world, objects of sense gratification... Asraya — Usually a santa-bhakta, or asrita dasa. Uddipana — Various distasteful objects or situations

II. Anubhava Spitting on thoughts of one's past deeds, contorting the face, covering the nose, washing the hands...

III. Sattvika-bhava Kampa (trembling), romanca (hairs standing on end), sveda (perspiration)... and contortion of the body.

IV. Vyabhicari-bhava Vrida (shame), srama (weariness), unmada (madness), moha (bewilderment), visada (depression), dainya (humility), glani (guilt, "self-pity"), capalata (restlessness), utsukata (eagerness) and jaòata (inertness)

V. Sthayi-bhava Jigupsa-rati (affection in disgust)

344

Appendix C Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu Texts & The Nectar of Devotion Bhakti - rasamrta - sindhu (2,129 texts) Eastern Ocean — Varities of Devotional Service (437 texts) Wave One — Overview of Deovtional Service (46 texts): Introduction - BRS 1.1.1-12; Chapter One - BRS 1.1.13-43.

Wave Two — Sadhana-Bhakti (309 texts):

345

Chapter Two - BRS 1.1.44-1.2.13 Chapter Three - BRS 1.2.14-29 Chapter Four - BRS 1.2.30-59 Chapter Five - BRS 1.2.60-71 Chapter Six - BRS 1.2.72-96 Chapter Seven - BRS 1.2.97-117 Chapter Eight - BRS 1.2.118-120 Chapter Nine - BRS 1.2.121-169

Chapter Ten - BRS 1.2.170-182 Chapter Eleven - BRS 1.2.183-203 Chapter Twelve - BRS 1.2.207-237 Chapter Thirteen - BRS 1.2.238-247 Chapter Fourteen - BRS 1.2.248-269 Chapter Fifteen - BRS 1.2.270-287 Chapter Sixteen - BRS 1.1.288-309

Wave Three — Bhava-Bhakti (61 texts): Chapter Seventeen-BRS 1.3.1-24; Chapter Eighteen-BRS 1.3.25-61

Wave Four — prema-bhakti (21 texts): Chapter Nineteen-BRS 1.4.1-21

Southern Ocean — Bhagavad - Bhakti - Rasa (903 texts) Wave One — Vibhava (384 texts): Chapter 20 BRS 2.1.1-18; Chapters 21 & 22 BRS 2.1.19-128; Chapter 23 - BRS 2.1.220-250; Chapter 24 - BRS 2.1.251-270; Chapter 25 - BRS 2.1.271-300; Chapter 26 - BRS 2.1. 301-384

Wave Two — Anubhava (21 texts): Chapter 27 - BRS 2.2.1-21

Wave Three — Sattvika-bhava (96 texts): Chapter 28 - BRS 2.3.1-96

Wave Four — Vyabhicari-bhava (270 texts): Chapter 29 - BRS 2.4.1-93; Chapter 30 - BRS 2.4.94-190; Chapter 31 - BRS 2.4.191270

Wave Five — Sthayi-bhava (132 texts): Chapter 32 - BRS 2.5.1-44; Chapter 33 - BRS 2.5.54-80; Chapter 34 - BRS 2.5.81-132

Western Ocean — Mukhya - Bhakti - Rasa (481 texts) Wave One — Santa-rasa (47 texts): Chapter 35 - BRS 3.1.1-47

Wave Two — Dasya-rasa (178 texts): Chapter 36 - BRS 3.2.1-56; Chapter 37 - BRS 3.2.57-103; Chapter 38 - BRS 3.2.104127; Chapter 39 - BRS 3.2.129-147; Chapter 40 - BRS 3.2.148-178.

Wave Three — Sakhya-rasa (136 texts): Chapter 41 - BRS 3.3.1-56; Chapter 42 - BRS 3.3.57-136.

Wave Four — Vatsalya-rasa (83 texts): 346

Chapter 43 - BRS 3.4.1-83.

Wave Five — Madhurya-rasa (37 texts): Chapter 44 - BRS 3.5.1-37.

Northern Ocean — Gauna - Bhakti - Rasa (308 texts) Wave One — Hasya-rasa (29 texts): Chapter 45 - BRS 4.1.1-29

Wave Two — Adbhuta-rasa (13 texts): Chapter 46 - BRS 4.2.1-13

Wave Three — Vira-rasa (63 texts): BRS 4.3.1-61

Wave Four — Karuna-rasa (16 texts): Chapter 47 - BRS 4.4.1-16

Wave Five — Raudra-rasa (33 texts): BRS 4.5.1-33

Wave Six — Bhayanaka-rasa (16 texts): Chapter 48 - BRS 4.6.1-16

Wave Seven — Vibhatsa-rasa (14 texts): BRS 4.7.1-14

Wave Eight — Maitri-vaira-sthiti (85 texts): Chapter 49 - BRS 4.8.1-52; Chapter 50 - BRS 4.8.53-85

Wave Nine — Rasabhasa (41 texts): Chapter 51 - BRS 4.9.1-41

347