Tan v Rodil Digest

TAN v RODIL ENTERPRISES December 18, 2006 | Chico- Nazario, J. J . | Petition for Review on Certiorari | Juicia! "mi##ion# "mi##ion# PETITIONER: $uciano %an RESPONDENT: Roi! &nter'ri#e# SUMMARY: "n un!awfu! etainer ca#e wa# fi!e b( Roi! &nter'ri#e# a)ain#t %an for refu#a! to 'a( renta!# an to vacate the !ea#e unit e#'ite re'eate eman#* %an mae an offer of com'romi#e in o'en court a# to the amount of un'ai renta!#* No #ett!ement wa# reache but the +e%C an C", #ub#euent!(, he! that #uch an offer con#titute an im'!ie ami##ion of %an# !iabi!it( to 'a( rent to Roi! &nt* %he .C affirme the C" eci#ion, ru!in) that %an# %an# ami##ion wa# an e/ce'tion to the )enera! ru!e of inami##ibi!it(*

DOCTRINE: %o etermine etermine the ami##ibi!it( or nonami##ibi!it( of an offer to com'romi#e, the circum#tance# of the ca#e an the intent of the 'art( main) the offer #hou! be con#iere* Thus, if a party deies the e!iste"e #f a de$t $ut #ffers t# pay the sa%e f#r the purp#se #f $uyi& pea"e ad av#idi& 'iti&ati#, the #ffer #f sett'e%et is iad%issi$'e( If i the "#urse there#f, the party %a)i& the #ffer ad%its the e!iste"e #f a ide$tedess "#%$ied *ith a pr#p#sa' t# sett'e the "'ai% a%i"a$'y, the, the ad%issi# is ad%issi$'e t# pr#ve su"h ide$tedess(

+ACTS: 1* Roi! &nter'ri#e# i# a !e##ee of e#  Racca 3ui!in) #ince 1454* %he bui!in) i# owne b( the )overnment* Roi! an the Re'ub!ic, re're#ente b( the D&NR, entere into a Renewa! of  a Contra Contract ct of $ea#e $ea#e over the bui!in bui!in) ) 18 +a( 14427* 14427* " #ub#e #ub#euen uentt .u''! .u''!eme ementa ntar( r( Contra Contract ct 25 +a( 14427 14427 wa# wa# entere into, thu# e/tenin) !ea#e unti 1 .e'tember 144* 2* %he va!iit( of #uch contract# were ue#tione* %he .C ec!are the#e contract# va!i 24 Nov 20017* Prior to thi# however, the ffice of the Pre#ient ec!are the#e contract# of no force an effect 8 9eb 144:7, a''ea!e to C" an .C,  both i#mi##e* i#mi##e* ;* P then i##ue an rer of &/ecution to which Roi! fi!e a  'etition for review on certiorari with the C"* C" annu!!e the orer an en