Survey and Analysis Techniques in Urban Design

Principles of Urban Design LECTURE 3

Abhishek K. Venkitaraman Iyer Assistant Professor Faculty of Architecture, MIT

Contents OVERVIEW OF TECHNIQUES OF ANALYSIS  Morphology and Typology in urban design  Surveys- Data Collection Techniques, types of survey, questionnaire preparation, analytical and projection techniques

THE PROCESS Collection of data

Assessment of existing conditions Analysis Projections of future requirements Planning, design and assessment

Data Collection – Preliminary listing • The WHAT and the WHY – – – – –

A checklist of major topics for study Division of these topics into subtopics / clusters A list of information needed for each of these The use of each for analysis Rating these in terms of priority / importance

• The HOW – List sources of these information – various secondary sources for ready primary data – Frame methodology of collecting data by primary means • Visual surveys and site studies • Questionnaire interviews, expert opinion surveys, public meetings, etc.

Types of Data: Primary Data : Data collected on the site through surveys, questionnaires etc. Secondary Data: Secondary data is data that is collected from the primary sources which can be used in the current research study. The following are some ways of collecting secondary data: Books Records Biographies Newspapers Published censuses or other statistical data Data archives Internet articles Research articles by other researchers (journals) Databases

Criteria for Evaluating Secondary Data Specifications: Methodology Used to Collect the Data Error Accuracy of the Data Currency When the Data Were Collected Objective(s) The Purpose for Which the Data Were Collected Nature: The Content of the Data Dependability: Overall, How Dependable Are the Data

Mapping • • • • •

Overlay mapping GIS Mapping Aerial Photographs Digital Elevation model Digital terrain model

Urban morphology • • • •

Figure-ground mapping Typological analysis Materials and components analysis Walk-through analysis

What it is:

Analysis techniques used to study the present and past historical patterns of urban structure, form, land use and patterns. Provides an understanding of the existing physical form and structure of the urban environment at different scales, from individual buildings, lots, street patterns and blocks.

What it’s useful for:

Defining urban patterns and characteristics that create a unique sense of place. It helps in the appraisal of successful and unsuccessful urban form, and can examine the processes that shaped past change, or features that persist in the present urban fabric. It can define urban boundaries, inform development controls, and form the basis for design guidelines for character and heritage areas.

How it’s done:

Characteristics of an urban area, such as it buildings, lots, blocks, street patterns, open space, land-use activities and building details, are recorded, measured, mapped and analysed using existing and/or historical information. ‘figure-ground mapping’ is where the building footprint is blacked out, with open space left blank on a plan. With this technique, the open space and other character features of the site can be analysed. A ‘typological analysis’ classifies buildings, lots, streets, blocks or open space into typical or atypical types. Type is defined by a combination of plan, dimension and use characteristics. This information can be used in character studies, design development and urban design policy. A ‘materials and components analysis’ is a detailed urban morphology study recording building and material details. This can define the character of an urban area, and inform design selection of future colours, materials and components for the elements within an area.

Figure Ground Map of a part of Rome

Figure Ground Map of Ghaziabad Old City

Figure Ground Map of Oststadt, Karlsruhe

Typology of the built form

Building age analysis

Walk Through Analysis What it is: An assessment of urban qualities and design issues done by walking through an area and recording observations and impressions along the way. It uses mainly graphic methods for recording observations. What it’s useful for: A walk-through gives an overview of the design issues, and is often the first stage of a more intensive appraisal that involves both qualitative and quantitative methods. This technique helps establish the extent of the design issues and identifies further work required. How it’s done: Observational analysis of place that records the main features, both successful and unsuccessful, in a preliminary urban design assessment. Key findings are often recorded by graphic means, such as photographs or annotated sketches and plans. Checklists are typically used to ensure consistency when appraising a number of buildings, streets or areas.

Behavior Observation • Behavior Mapping • Activity mapping

Activity Mapping

Activity Mapping

http://www.intechopen.com/source/html/40505/media/image10.png

Activity Mapping

Active Frontages Active frontages: It is important that buildings present active frontages to the public spaces of the city as far as possible. By active frontages we mean ground floor shop windows or transparent frontages so that the activity within the building is visible from the street.

Ped-shed Analysis What it is:

A mapping technique that calculates the population catchment within a five or 10 minute walk from an activity, transport stop or node.

What it’s useful for:

Providing ‘walkability analysis’ of important destinations (for example, town centres or transport nodes) within neighbourhoods, and how evenly these destinations are distributed and dispersed through a town or city.

How it’s used:

A fixed-diameter circle is overlaid on a map with the centre placed on the destination point. Circle radii are usually based on an average person walking 400 metres in five minutes. A second radius of 800 metres indicates a 10 minute walk. The population density within this radius can then be calculated to determine the number of people within easy walking distance of the destination. A ped-shed analysis can be refined further by mapping linkages and obstacles that may decrease or increase travel distance or time to give a more accurate population figure.

Demarcation of a walking influence zone in case of a Metro corridor

Location of facilities within the walkable range in the residential sectors of Auroville

Historical Analysis The richness of the urban realm is the product of a long process of historical development. If the site has an ancient history the study may include a detailed archaeological investigation. More simply, it may identify those buildings, trees and other structures which have been listed for protection, including sites of scientific or ecological interest. The analysis of the site and its history would conclude with a study of more recent pressures on the urban structure, which would include an analysis of recent planning documents in order to determine those policies which currently affect development on the site.

Evolution map of Hebri

Collecting and analyzing a wide range of historical data contained in, for example, institutional, corporate or public records.

Archive research provides historical information about the past environment, activities and structures. Archive research provides invaluable primary and secondary source material where it is not possible to observe, interview or survey the past community. It allows the analysis of the past heritage, character and context for projects where maintaining an authentic sense of place is important. Collections of maps, drawings and photographs are particularly useful for urban design and heritage-related research.

Visual Analysis The visual analysis has three main parts: a study of a three dimensional public space, a study of the two dimensional surfaces which enclose public space, and a study of architectural details which give an area its special character. The most common tools for recording spatial composition are the camera and the threedimensional perspective drawn from the normal eye level.

1

5

2

3

4

Surveys • • • • • • • •

Public Satisfaction surveys 3+, 3- surveys Three questions surveys Visual preference surveys Placecheck Post – occupancy evaluation Design quality indicators Benchmarking

Surveys What it is: A systematic way of determining the views and opinions of a large number of people on a particular topic through the use of interviews with structured questions or a standardised questionnaire. What it’s useful for: Surveys can be used to gather large amounts of comparable and easily quantifiable data, and to provide an objective basis for planning and future action.

Surveys can provide both qualitative and quantitative data. A structured interview will uncover qualitative data on people’s values and perceptions that can be quantitatively tabulated. A professionally produced survey is a useful means of accurately and objectively assessing community opinion on high-profile and controversial community projects.

Public Satisfaction surveys 3+, 3- surveys ‘Three questions surveys’ are common in open space and neighbourhood improvement projects. They ask people to identify three things they like and three things they dislike about the current environment, and note their suggestions for changes.

Placecheck ‘Placecheck’ (http://www.placecheck.info/) is a specific urban design questionnaire for the community, developed by the UK Urban Design Alliance, that reveals where improvements are needed and focuses on how to achieve them. 1. Choose an area to Placecheck. 2. Spend an hour or so on a walkabout. 3. Ask: What do we like about this place? What do we dislike about it? What do we need to work on? 4. Think about why the place is as it is. Discuss how to make your ideas happen, and who needs to be involved.

5.

Make a note of what you have decided.

6.

Follow up with action:

A further survey method is the ‘post-occupancy evaluation’, a systematic survey and study of how occupants respond to a new or existing building or environment once it is operational.

Questionnaire preparation

Thank You !