SPACE Analysis - Strategic Position and Action Evaluation Matrix

 

Home About Differentiation Strategy Strategic Planning Models Strategy Consultant Archives Contact Me Free Reports

SPACE Analysis – Strategic Position and Action Evaluation Matrix by Paul Simister on September 1, 2011 The Strategic Position and Action Evaluation Matrix or Matrix or SPACE analysis mat matrix rix is  is a super technique for evaluating the sense and wisdom in a particular strategic plan. It was developed by strategy academics Alan Rowe, Richard Mason, Karl Dickel, Richard Mann and Robert Mockler and I don’t understand why it isn’t hugely popular.

Introduction To The Strategic Position and Action Evaluation Matrix aka SPACE Analysis The Strategic Position and ACtion Evaluation (SPACE) analysis framework is a very useful but not well known tool to develop and review a company’s strategy. It can be used at The beginning of the exercise to predict the overall key themes . As a check at the end of the process. . It can also be used to evaluate individual strategic options generated by using a tool like the Ansoff Growth Matri Matrix x. SPACE Analysis is a systematic appraisal of four key issues that balance the external and internal factors that should determine the general theme of  the strategy: External Industry Attractiveness Environmental Stability Internal Competitive Competit ive Advantage Financial Strength By combining ratings on each dimension on one SPACE matrix diagram, the framework guides the strategic agenda. The dimensions are combined in a way that seems strange at first but makes sense because two sets of factors are assessed as strengths (financial strength and industry strength) and rated positive while the other two (competitive advantage and environmental stability) are assessed as potential weaknesses and rated negatively. The logic is that financial strength is needed to compensate for environmental instability. The more difficult the future environment is thought to be, the more important it is to have strong financials. Industry attractiveness and competitive advantage are seen as potentially alternative sources of superior profit. and indeed there are treated as such in my five pathways to profit in my Profit Tipping Point Point report.  report. If both favour the business, then results should be very good, if both are unfavourable, then the business is in trouble.

The SPACE Analysis Matrix Diagram

A very strong position in the SPACE matrix This diagram shows that the firm is in a very favourable position and is able to take an aggressive growth strategy. It is operating in an attractive and stable industry and has major competitive advantages backed up by significant financial strength.

Assessing Asses sing the SPACE SPAC E Analysis An alysis Scores

Each factor in the Strategic Position and Action Evaluation matrix can be quickly judged but there are benefits for exploring each in detail. There are a large number of factors that can be considered and each industry will have its own key features which should be included in the detailed SPACE evaluati evaluation. on. A few factors to be considered to give you a flavour of what to include in your SPACE analysis are listed below.

SPACE Analysis Factors For Financial Strength Return on Sales  

 

Return on Assets Cash Flow Gearing Working Capital Intensity Strength rength In The SPACE SPAC E Matrix Financial Strength is scored 6 great to 1 poor in the SPACE Analysis Matrix – for more details see Financial St

SPACE Analysis Factors For Competitive Advantage Market Share Quality Customer Loyalty Cost Levels Product Range Competitive ive Advantage In The SPA CE Matri Matrix x Competitive advantage is scored -1 (minus 1) great to –6 (minus 6) poor – for more details see Competit

SPACE Analysis Factors For Industry Ind ustry Attractivenes Attractivenesss Growth Potenti Potential al Life Stage EntryCycle Barriers Customer Power Substitutes Industry attractiveness is scored 6 great and 1 poor in the SPACE analysis matrix – for more details see Industr Industry y Attractiveness Attractiveness In The T he SPAC E Matrix

SPACE Analysis Factors For Environmental Stability Political Uncertainty Interest Rates Technology Cyclical Environmental Issues Environmental stability is scored –1 (minus 1) great to –6 (minus 6) poor – for more details see Environmental Stability In The SPACE Matrix Scores switch between positive and negative so that the combined position can be assessed. A firm operating with major competitive advantages in an unattractive industry will have a similar net score (and profitability potential) to another firm with little competitive advantage in an attractive industry. e.g. Attractiveness of industry 5 (very strong) Competitive advantage -4 (weak – the business has more disadvantages than advantages) Net SPACE score on this dimensi dimension on = 1 or Attractiveness of industry 2 (weak – things look difficult) Competitive advantage -1 (the company has powerful competitive advantages over all the competitors) Net SPACE score on this dimensi dimension on = 1 The financial strength and environmental stability combination works the same way.

Interpreting the SPACE Analysis Matrix Diagram The arrow indicating the strategic thrust can be drawn from the origin by calculating the net result on each axis and plotting this net position.

The alternative strategic thrusts in the SPACE matrix  Aggressive posture The Aggressive The  posture in the SPACE Analysis Matrix occurs when all the dimensions are positive. The implicit strategy is to aggressively grow the business raising the stakes for all competitors. The main danger is complacency. For more details see Aggressive Strat Strategy egy In SPAC E. The Competitive Competitive posture  posture arises when a firm has strong advantages in an attractive industry but its financial strength is insufficient to compensate for environmental instability. The immediate strategy is to improve its financial strength (raising capital, improving profitability, merging with a cash rich Competitive ive Strategy In SPACE SPA CE.. parent) whilst maintaining its competitive position. For more details see Competit The Conservative Conservative posture  posture arises when the firm is financially strong but is unlikely to make significant returns from the business. The strategy is to SPAC E. look for diversification opportunities in more attractive competitive situations. For more details see Conservative Conservative Strategy In SPACE The Defensive Defensive posture  posture in the SPACE matrix occurs when all the dimensions are scored poorly. Firms in this position are very weak and heading for failure unless the external environment becomes more favourable. The firm will need to retreat from all but its strongest segments so that it can concentrate its limited resources on a turnaround. Fore more information see Defensive Strategies

Uncertain situations in SPACE Analysis Sometimes the axis scores cancel each other out and the overall position falls between segments. However by examining the four dimensions the strategic imperatives can be established – the internal dimensions are easier to change but the external dimensions indicate whether it is likely to be worthwhile. For example if the Financial Strength is weak but the Environment Stability high then raising capital is appropriate but if the scores were the other  

 

way around then the business should be seeking to use its financial strength elsewhere.

Why Isn’t SPACE Analysis More Popular? The first time I came across the SPACE analysis matrix when I was doing my MBA strategy course at the Manchester Business School and by then I’d read quite a few strategy textbooks and since then, many more books on strategy but SPACE analysis is hardly ever mentioned. While the Strategic Position and Action Evaluation Matrix is a bit of a mouthful, it does describe the tool perfectly and SPACE is a great acronym. I like SPACE analysis because it can be applied at many different levels. You can do the detailed analysis for each of the four SPACE dimensions and come up with a subjectively objective rating and crank out the numbers to find which posture is most suitable. Or you can do a quick and dirty SPACE analysis based on a feel for the factors and quickly know the big issues the business g=faces and which direction its strategy should be taking.

The SPACE Matrix And The Six Step Profit Formula It can be difficult to understand how various strategic planning models can help you to increase profit in your business which is why I use the Six Step Profit Formula as Formula as my model for profit improvement. As well as helping you to think through the development of your starving crowd with the environmental stability and industry attractiveness dimensions in the SPACE Matrix, the competitive advantage dimension looks at your irresistible promise promise and  and whether you can reliably deliver it. While the Six the Six Step Profit Formula provides Formula provides a roadmap for improving any business, the SPACE analysis assessment indicates whether the pay-off is likely to be enough reward for the time, energy and money invested.

The SPACE Matrix & Other Strategic Plann Pl anning ing Models The SPA CE analysi analysiss matrix is one of my favouri favourite te strategic planning models which models which can help you to organise your thoughts and conclusions from the other strategy models. model.. Your thinking on competitive advantage Environmental stability and industry attractiveness draw on PEST Analysis and Analysis and Porter’s Five Forces model disciplines,, the value chain chain and  and customer value management management.. can be guided by the generic strategies, strategies, value disciplines

Have You Used SPACE Analysis -The Strategic Position and Action Evaluation Matrix? If you’ve used SPACE, either in your academic studies of business strategy or in practice, I’d like to hear about your thoughts and experience so please leave a comment.

Finding Out More About SPACE Analysis I had to go back to the original book “Strategic Management – A Methodical Approach”, Rowe, Mason, Dickel, Mann and Mockler. Published by Addison Wesley. The book is hard to find and expensive when new. In my copy of the fourth edition, the Strategic Position and Analysis Evaluation matrix is only covered on pages 255 through to 265. The good news new s is that there are a few second hand copies available available from Amazon when I checked. Paul Simister is a business strategy coach coach in  in the UK who helps small business owners to profit from differentiating their businesses, by being distinctive in the eyes of their customers and standing out in a crowded marketplace…. in other words, by building a business to be proud of. tipping g point  (free  (free report) by answering the seven the seven big questions of business success (mp3) success (mp3) You too can move past your profi your profitt tippin  

7

0

0 Share Share

0

Like

Search terms that have found this page include: space analysis, space analysis matrix, space matrix analysis, space matrix strategy, space matrix, Strategic Position and Action Evaluation, strength of SPACE matrix Tagged as: SPACE Matrix { 1 comment comment… … read it below or add one } one }  Cmoe  Cmoe September 21, 2011 at 2:34 am This type of analysis really is effective. And If used in conjunction with the SWOT analysis, you can net a pretty good idea of how you can approach a business well. Reply Leave a Comment C omment

Name * E-mail * Website

 CAPTCHA Code * Submit

 Confirm you are NOT a spamm spammer er This blog uses premium CommentLuv CommentLuv which allows you to put your keywords keyw ords with your name if you have had 3 approved comm comments. ents. Use your real name and then @ your keywords (maximum of 3) Previous post: Bowman’s Strategy Clock – Your Strategic Options Next post: Value Chain Videos

Subscr Sub scribe ibe to Differenti Differentiate ate Your You r Business Bu siness  

 

Subscribe in a reader

Why You Need To Read “The Profit Tipping Point”

About Me – Paul Simister I believe you need to differentiate your business to be successful in these super-competitive times when it can be tough to get attention, let alone action from potential customers and clients. I've worked as a business strategy coach and consultant for SME's in the UK since 1995 using my strategy, finance, marketing and process improvement skills. I'm a Chartered Accountant, have a Masters In Business Administration (MBA) from the Manchester Business School and I'm a Certified Guerrilla Marketing Marketi ng Coach. If you own or manage an SME in the UK and you want to move from tactical improvements to strategic business improvement, then I'd love to hear from you. I can be contacted on 0121 554 4057 or email me at [email protected]

Does Your Marketing “Dazzle” Like A Zebra? A zebra look stunning on its own but a group of zebras is called a dazzle because they all merge into one to protect them from lions. It's like many businesses. Individually the marketing looks good and a strong case is made for buying the generic product or service but it doesn't differentiate and create buyer preference.

Our task is to make sure your business stands out like the blue zebra and gets the attention it deserves by being different in ways that matter to the customers.

Popular Popu lar Articles Articles Ansoff Growth Matri Matrix x Balanced Scorecard Bowman's Strategy Clock Business Health Check Core Competenc C ompetencee Five Forces Analysis McKinsey 7 S PEST Analysis Scenario Planning SPACE Matrix Strategy Strateg y Canvas Success Factors SWOT Analysis Unique Selling Point Value Chain Analysis

Recommended Products Business Growth System Digital Marketer Ryan Deiss

There are over 200 pages about business strategy and differentiation on this blog. To search, search, type type and hi

Who I Work With  

 

  e p ow owne ners rs o sm smaa an me um s ze the customers. More details of Who I Work With

us ne ness sses es to cr crea eatte

er eren entt at on w c se sets ts t e r us ne ness sses es apar apartt rom comp compet et tor orss n ways ways t at matt atter to

Typical Client Challenges This varies depending on how long the client has been in business. For more details see Typical Client Challenges Business Start-Ups Young Business B usinesses es  - less than 12 months old Established Businesses

My Services I provide business strategy coaching, consultancy and mentoring based on what you need to move your business forward successfully. For more details see My Services Copyright 2011 - Differentiate Your Business Business..