Senator Francis "Kiko" Pangilinan v. Alan Peter S. Cayetano G.R. No. 238875 March 16, 2021 Leonen, J

 

XG@JNAN@G@ v. EG^BVG@K J.T. @k. 45==:2 Cgrem 7, g "Tbskautnk` Bxprbssn`j Bxprbssn`j tmb Ub`sb kl tmb Ub`gtb tmgt Vbrcn`gtnk` kl, kr Zntmfrgwga lrkc, Vrbgtnbs g`f N`tbr`gtnk`ga Gjrbbcb`ts Ek`eurrbf n` dy tmb Ub`gtb smgaa db \ganf g`f

Bllbetnvb K`ay `kt Rpk` Ek`eurrb`eb tmb Ub`gtb." Tbskautnk` wgs `ktbf tk mgvb dbb` egab`fgrbf dy lkr gjb`fg n` tmbVmb Ub`gtb. -  Cbg`wmnab, tmb Xmnanppn`b Ekgantnk` lkr tmb Bstgdansmcb`t kl tmb N`tbr`gtnk`ga Erncn`ga Ekurt (XENEE), (XENEE), g`f nts cbcdbrs gask lnabf g Xbtntnk` lkr Ebrtnkrgrn g`f Cg`fgcus. -  Lkaakwn`j tmbrbtk, tmb N`tbjrgtbf Dgr kl tmb Xmnanppn`bs (NDX) lnabf nts kw` Xbtntnk`, g`f g` Kc`ndus Bx-Xgrtb Cktnk` lkr Ek`skanfgtnk` g`f lkr N`eausnk` n` tmb Krga Grjucb`ts. Grjucb`ts? Xbtntnk`brs-sb`gtkrs Xbtntnk`brs-sb` gtkrs grjub tmgt? 7.  Gs g trbgty tmgt tmb Xmnanppn`bs vganfay b`tbrbf, tmb Tkcb Utgtutb "mgs tmb sgcb stgtus gs g` b`getcb`t kl Ek`jrbss," gs "g agw n` tmb Xmnanppn`bs." Vmby eagnc tmgt tmb Xrbsnfb`t "eg``kt rbpbga g agw."

Lrg`ensek, Cgri Db`bfnet U. | 4848-8465 Ek`stntutnk`ga Agw Tbvnbw | Gtty. Ug`fkvga | Uu`fgy 7-2pc

4

 

XG@JNAN@G@ v. EG^BVG@K J.T. @k. 45==:2 Cgrem 7 mgs dbb` prbsb`tbf tk dut tmus lgr, `bvbr gfkptbf dy tmb Ub`gtb.

-  K` tmb ktmbr mg`f, pbrsk`s n`vkin`j tmbnr rnjmts gs entnzb`s cust sgtnsly tmb lkaakwn`j rbqunsntbs tk lnab g sunt? (7) tmby cust mgvb "pbrsk`gaay sullbrbf skcb getuga kr tmrbgtb`bf n`oury dbegusb kl tmb gaabjbfay naabjga ek`fuet kl jkvbr`cb`t"'9 (4) "tmb n`oury ns lgnray trgebgdab tk tmb emgaab`jbf getnk`"9 g`f (5) "tmb n`oury ns anibay tk db rbfrbssbf dy g lgvkrgdab getnk`.– Lrg`ensek, Cgri Db`bfnet U. | 4848-8465 Ek`stntutnk`ga Agw Tbvnbw | Gtty. Ug`fkvga | Uu`fgy 7-2pc

76

 

XG@JNAN@G@ v. EG^BVG@K J.T. @k. 45==:2 Cgrem 7=27? k  TG>=27 fbln`bs tkrturb gs "tmb n`tb`tnk`ga n`lanetnk` kl sbvbrb pgn` kr sullbrn`j, wmbtmbr pmysnega, cb`tga, kr psyemkakjnega, upk` g pbrsk` n` tmb eustkfy kr u`fbr tmb ek`trka kl tmb geeusbf9 bxebpt tmgt tkrturb smgaa `kt n`eaufb pgn` kr sullbrn`j grnsn`j k`ay lrkc, n`mbrb`t n` kr n`enfb`tga tk, agwlua sg`etnk`s." Cbg`wmnab, psyemkakjnega cbg`s kl tkrturb grb `kt ekvbrbf dy tmb Tkcb Utgtutb. eaustbrbf wgr erncbs kr erncbs gjgn`st n`tbr`gtnk`ga k  TG>=27 mucg`ntgrng` agw n`tk tmrbb egtbjkrnbs? (7) g` n`tbr`gtnk`ga grcbf ek`lanet9 (4) g `k`-n`tbr`gtnk`ga `k`-n`tbr`gtnk`ga grcbf ek`lanet9 g`f (5) ktmbr sbrnkus vnkagtnk`s kl agws g`f eustkcs gppanegdab n` grcbf ek`lanet. Nt tmb`

Lrg`ensek, Cgri Db`bfnet U. | 4848-8465 Ek`stntutnk`ga Agw Tbvnbw | Gtty. Ug`fkvga | Uu`fgy 7-2pc

7:

 

XG@JNAN@G@ v. EG^BVG@K J.T. @k. 45==:2 Cgrem 7=27. k  R`anib tmb Tkcb Utgtutb, TG>=27 gask gffs kr n`eaufbs gck`j ktmbr erncbs gjgn`st mucg`nty pbrsbeutnk` gjgn`st g`y n`fnvnfuga, jrkup, kr ekaabetnvnty dgsbf k` tmbnr sbxuga krnb`tgtnk`.

  B`lkrebf kr "n`vkau`tgry fnsgppbgrg`eb kl pbrsk`s" ns gask g

k

pu`nsmgdab erncb gjgn`st mucg`nty. -  Gaa tkaf, tmb ckrb rbstrnetnvb Tkcb Utgtutb cgy mgvb bvb` wbgib`bf tmb sudstg`tnvb prktbetnk`s prktbetnk`s garbgfy prbvnkusay gllkrfbf dy TG>=27. N` suem g egsb, nt cgy wbaa db db`blnenga tk rbckvb tmb ek`lusnk` drkujmt gdkut dy cgn`tgn`n`j g trbgty wmksb ek`tb`ts grb n`ek`snstb`t wntm g`tbebfb`t stgtutkry prkvnsnk`s. Ek`eausnk`

-  Vmb pbtntnk`s grb fnscnssbf lkr dbn`j ckkt

Lrg`ensek, Cgri Db`bfnet U. | 4848-8465 Ek`stntutnk`ga Agw Tbvnbw | Gtty. Ug`fkvga | Uu`fgy 7-2pc

7=