SAN MIGUEL FOODS, INC., Petitioner, vs. San Miguel Corporation Employees Union-PTWGO, Respondent

 

UBK JGO^NL A@@DU, GKE., pntt`knr, vs. UBK JGO^NL E@VY@VBTG@K NJYL@WNNU ^KG@KYT_O@, rnsp`kdnk. ABETU3 Vnsp`kdnkt, Ubk Jgounl E`rp`rb`k Njpl`ynns ^kg`k ― YT_O@ (tmn ^kg`k), wbs tmn s`ln fbrobgkgko bonkt `a bll tmn j`ktmly pbgd njpl`ynns `a pn`knr Ubk Jgounl A``ds, Gke`rp`rbtnd (UJAG). @k K`vnjfnr 7, 2776, s`jn njpl`ynns `a UJAG‗s Agkbken Dnpbrtjnkt, tmr`uom tmn ^kg`k rnprnsnktnd fy Ndobr J`rblndb, fr`uomt b orgnvbken bobgkst Agkbken Jbkbonr Ogdn`k J`ktnsb (J`ktnsb), a`r "dgsergjgkb`k, "dgsergjgkb `k, abv`rgsj, ukabgr lbf`r prbeens, k`t nxgfln XsgeZ, mbrbssjnkt, pr`j`ko dgvgsgvnknss dgvgsgvnknss bkd snetbrgbkgsj, snetbrgbkgsj, nte.," fna`rn UJAG Ylbkt @pnrb`ks @pnrb`ks Jbkbonr On`ron Kbvb gk bee`rdbken wgtm Utnp 2 `a tmn orgnvbken jbemgknry bd`ptnd gk tmn E`llnevn Fbrobgkgko Bornnjnkt (EFB) a`rond fy UJAG bkd tmn ^kg`k. Tmn ^kg`k s`uomt tmn "2. rnvgnw, nvblubtXg`kZ & uporbdXgko `aZ bll Agkbken stb bkd 6. pr`j`tXg`k `aZ O.R. J`ktnsb t` `tmnr UJE blgbtnXsZ & sufsgdgbrgns." Bt tmn orgnvbken jnnko mnld `k Cbkubry 24, 2775, UJAG gka`rjnd tmn ^kg`k tmbt gt plbkknd t` bddrnss tmn orgnvbken tmr`uom b "w`rh jbkbonjnkt rnvgnw" wmgem w`uld fn e`jplntnd fy Jbrem 2775, mnken, gt bshnd tmn t mn kbken pnrs`kknl t` ogvn gt tmngr bnk`k bkd e``pnrb`k. Tmn "w`rh jbkbonjnkt rnvgnw" wbs k`t e`jplntnd fy Jbrem 2775, m`wnvnr, pr`jpko tmn ^kg`k t`, `k Jbrem 61, 2775, nlnvbtn tmn orgnvbken t` Utnp 6. Blj`st kgkn j`ktms bnr tmn orgnvbken jnnko wbs mnld `r `k @et`fnr 1, 2775, UJAG rnkdnrnd b "Dnegsg`k `k Utnp 2 Orgnvbken" stbko tmbt gt wbs sll gk tmn pr`enss `a e`jplnko tmn "w`rh jbkbonjnkt rnvgnw," mnken, tmn ^kg`k‗s rnqunsts e`uld k`t fn orbktnd.

GUU^N3 _MNTMNV @V K@T TMN LBF@V BVFGTNV MBU C^VGUDGETG@K @QNV TMN E@JYLBGKT @A VNUY@KDNKT ^KG@K.

 

V^LGKO3 Tmn curgsdge`k `a Lbf`r Brfgtnrs, nkujnrbtnd gk Breln 62? `a tmn Lbf`r E`dn, gkeludns e`jplbgkts a`r ^LY. UJAG brouns tmbt tmn bllnob`ks gk tmn ^kg`k‗s e`jplbgkt lnd fna`rn tmn Lbf`r Brfgtnr d` k`t nstbflgsm b ebusn `a be`k a`r ^LY, tmn ^kg`k mbvgko jnrnly e`ktnkdnd tmbt UJAG wbs ouglty tmnrn`a wgtm`ut spnegaygko tmn uljbtn abets up`k wmgem gt wbs fbsnd. Gt egtns Une`k 2 `a Vuln = `a tmn Vulns `a E`urt bs bpplygko supplnt`rgly t` tmn pr`enndgkos fna`rn tmn Lbf`r Brfgtnr, wmgem Une`k rnbds3 Une`k 2. Gk onknrbl . ― Nvnry plnbdgko smbll e`ktbgk gk b jntm`dgebl bkd l`ogebl a`rj, b plbgk e`kegsn bkd dgrnet stbtnjnkt `a tmn uljbtn abets `k wmgem tmn pbrty plnbdgko rnlgns a`r mgs elbgj . . . Bllnogko tmbt tmn ^kg`k abglnd t` e`jply wgtm tmgs Vuln, UJAG e`keludns tmbt tmn Lbf`r Brfgtnr mbs k` curgsdge`k `vnr gts e`jplbgkt. B pnrusbl `a tmn e`jplbgkt sm`ws tmbt, gkdnnd, tmn pbreulbr bets `a ^LY bllnond t` mbvn fnnk e`jjgnd fy UJAG wnrn k`t spnegnd8 kngtmnr wnrn tmn uljbtn abets gk supp`rt tmnrn`a. Gk gts Y`sg`k Ybpnr, m`wnvnr, tmn ^kg`k dntbglnd tmn pbreulbr bets `a ^LY brgfutnd t` UJAG bkd tmn uljbtn abets gk supp`rt tmnrn`a. Une`k ?, Vuln Q `a tmn Knw Vulns `a Yr`endurn `a tmn KLVE pr`vgdns3 Kbturn `a Yr`enndgkos. ― Tmn pr`enndgkos fna`rn mn Lbf`r Brfgnr smbll fn k`klgtog`us gk kburn. Uufcnet t` tmn t mn rnqugrnjnkts `a dun pr`enss, mn nemkgeblgtns `a lbw bkd pr`endurn bkd mn rulns `fbgkgko gk mn e`urs `a lbw smbll k` srgely srge ly bpply bppl y mnrn` mnr n` . Tmn Lbf`r Brfgtnr jby bvbgl mgjsnla `a bll rnbs`kbfln jnbks t` bsenrtbgk tmn abets `a tmn e`ktr`vnrsy spnndgly, gkeludgko `eulbr

gkspne`k bkd nxbjgkb`k `a wnll-gka`rjnd pnrs`ks. Une`k 2 `a Vuln = `a tmn Vulns `a E`urt sm`uld tmus k`t fn strgetly bpplgnd t` b ebsn lnd fna`rn b Lbf`r Brfgtnr. Gk dntnrjgkgko curgsdge`k curgsdge`k `vnr b ebsn, bllnob`ks jbdn gk tmn e`jplbgkt, bs wnll bs tm`sn gk tmn p`sg`k pbpnr, jby tmus fn e`ksgdnrnd.