San Miguel Corp. vs. Mandaue Packing Products Plants Union, Digest

SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION (MANDAUE PACKAGING PRODUCTS PLANTS),  petitioner,  petitioner, vs. MANDAUE PACKING PRODUCTS PLANTS-SAN PACKAGING PRODUCTS  –SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION MONTHLIES RANK-AND-FILE RANK-AND-FILE UNION – FFW (MPPPSMPP-SMAMRFU-FFW), respondent. Facts: On ! "#n$ %%&, '$sn*$nt, +*$nt++n. +ts$/ as an a+/+at$  F$*$'at+n  F'$$ W'0$'s (FFW), +/$* a $t+t+n ' c$'t++cat+n $/$ct+n 1+t2 t2$ DOLE R$.+na/ O+c$ N3 4 II3 In t2$  $t+t+n, '$sn*$nt stat$* t2at +t s#.2t t 5$ c$'t++$* an* t '$'$s$nt t2$ $'6an$nt $'6an$nt 'an0-an*+/$ 6nt2/ a+* $6/$$s  t2$ $t+t+n$'3 T2$ //1+n. *c#6$nts 1$'$ attac2$* t t2$  $t+t+n: () a C2a't$' C$'t++cat$ C$'t++cat$ +ss#$* 5 FFW n ! "#n$ %%& c$'t++n. t2at '$sn*$nt as  t2at *at$ 1as *#/ c$'t++$* as a /ca/ ' c2at$'  FFW7 (8) a c  t2$ cnst+t#t+n  '$sn*$nt '$a'$* 5 +ts S$c'$ta' an* att$st$* 5 +ts P'$s+*$nt7 (9) a /+st  '$sn*$nts +c$'s an* t2$+' '$s$ct+;$ a**'$ss$s7 (at+ns 5as$* n t2$ c$'t++cat+n +ss#$* 5 t2$ O+c$'-In-C2a'.$, R$.+na/ D+'$ct'  t2$ DOLE R$.+na/ O+c$ N3 4II, Att3 "$s#s @3 Ga5', n 8< "#/ %%&3 On 8 A#.#st %%&, $t+t+n$' +/$* a $t+t+n t canc$/ t2$ #n+n '$.+st'at+n  '$sn*$nt3 H1$;$', t2+s $t+t+n 1as *$n+$*, an* s#c2 *$n+a/ 1as s#5s$B#$nt/ a+'6$* 5 t2$ C#'t  A$a/s +n a *$c+s+n t2at 2as s+nc$ 5$c6$ +na/3 R$sn*$nt '6t/ a$a/$* t2$ ! S$t$65$' %%& Order t t2$ DOLE3 On 88 F$5'#a' %%%, DOLE Un*$'s$c'$ta' '$n*$'$* a Decision a Decision '$;$'s+n.  '$;$'s+n. t2$ Order 3 Iss#$: WON t2$ Un+n acB#+'$* /$.a/ $'sna/+t3 H$/*: $s3 S$ct+n 9, R#/$ 4I  D$a't6$nt O'*$' N3 % ';+*$s 12$n t2$ /ca/c2at$' acB#+'$s /$.a/  $'sna/+t3 S$ct+n 93 AcB#+s+t+n  /$.a/ $'sna/+t 5 /ca/ c2at$'3 – A /ca/c2at$' cnst+t#t$* +n acc'*anc$ 1+t2 S$ct+n   t2+s R#/$ s2a// acB#+'$ /$.a/ $'sna/+t '6 t2$ *at$  +/+n.  t2$ c6/$t$ *c#6$nts $n#6$'at$* t2$'$+n3 Un c6/+anc$ 1+t2 a// t2$ *c#6$nta'

'$B#+'$6$nts, t2$ R$.+na/ O+c$ ' @#'$a# s2a// +ss#$ +n a;'  t2$ /ca/c2at$' a c$'t++cat$ +n*+cat+n. t2at +t +s +nc/#*$* +n t2$ 'st$'  /$.+t+6at$ /a5' '.an+>at+ns3 It +s $;+*$nt 5as$* n t2+s '#/$ t2at t2$ /ca/c2at$' acB#+'$s /$.a/ $'sna/+t '6 t2$ *at$  t2$ +/+n.  t2$ c6/$t$ *c#6$nta' '$B#+'$6$nts, an* nt '6 t2$ +ss#anc$  a c$'t++cat+n t s#c2 $$ct 5 t2$ R$.+na/ R$.+na/ O+c$ ' @#'$a#3 On t2$ t2$' 2an*, a /a5' '.an+>at+n '.an+>at+n +s *$$6$* t 2a;$ acB#+'$* /$.a/ $'sna/+t n/ n t2$ *at$  +ss#anc$  +ts c$'t++cat$  '$.+st'at+n, 12+c2 ta0$s /ac$ n/ at$' t2$ @#'$a#  La5' R$/at+ns ' +ts R$.+na/ O+c$s 2as #n*$'ta0$n an $;a/#at+n 'c$ss  'c$ss /ast+n. # #nt+/ t2+'t (9) *as, 1+t2+n 12+c2 $'+* +t a';$s ' *$n+$s t2$ a/+cat+n3 In cnt'ast, n s#c2 $'+*  $;a/#at+n +s ';+*$* +n D$a't6$nt O'*$' N3 % ' t2$ a/+cat+n  a /ca/c2at$', an* 6'$ +6'tant/, #n*$' #n* $' +t s#c2 /ca/c2at$' +s *$$6$* t acB#+'$ /$.a/ $'sna/+t '6 t2$ *at$  +/+n.  t2$ *c#6$nts $n#6$'at$* #n*$' S$ct+n , R#/$ 4I, @0 43