salesdigestvtableofcontents

San Beda College College of Law Mendiola, Manila

Case Digest in SALES and LEASE

Submitted by:

MASAHUD, Mariam Genevieve A. 2L

Submitted to:

Dean Jose R. Sundiang

1

20 September 2010

TABLE OF CONTENTS CASE DOCTRINES

PAGE

Sales Lease

i

CASE DIGESTS

PAGE

***SALES I.

Absolute and Conditional Dignos vs. Court of Appeals 158 SCRA 375, 29 February 1988 Bidin, J.

II.

Object of a Contract of Sale Artates vs. Urbi 37 SCRA 395, 30 January 1971 Reyes, J.B.L.

Heirs of Enrique Zambales vs. Court of Appeals 120 SCRA 897, 28 February 1983 Melncio-Herrera, J. III.

Contract of Sale vs. Agency to Sell Quiroga vs. Parsons Hardware 38 PHIL 501, 23 August 1918 Avancena, J.

IV.

Contract of Sale vs. Contract for a Piece of Work Concrete Aggregates vs. Court of Tax Appeals 185 SCRA 461, 18 May 1990 Regalado, J.

V.

Contract of sale vs. Contract to Sell Ursal vs. Court of Appeals 473 SCRA 53, 14 October 2005 Austria-Martines, J.

VI.

Perfection of a Contract of Sale People’s Homesite & Housing Corporation vs. Court of Appeals 133 SCRA 777, 2 December 1984 Aquino, J.

Toyota Shaw, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals 244 SCRA 320, 23 May 1995 Davide, Jr., J. 2

1

Limketkai Sons Milling, Inc. Vs Court of Appeals 250 SCRA 523, 23 May 1995 Davide, Jr., J. Motion for Reconsideration of  Limketkai Sons Milling, Inc. Vs Court of Appeals 255 SCRA 626, 29 March 1996 Francisco, J. Promise to Buy and Sell vs. Accepted Promise to Buy or to Sell (Articles 1479 and 1324)

VII.

Southwestern Sugar and Molasses Co. vs. Atlantic Gulf and Pacific Co. 97 PHIL 247, 29 June 1955 Baustista Angelo, J. Atkins Kroll & Co. vs. Cua Hian Tek 102 PHIL 948, 31 January 1958 Bengzon, J. Sanchez vs. Rigos 45 SCRA 368, 14 June 1972 Concepcion, J. Natino vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 197 SCRA 323, 23 May 1991 Davide, Jr., J. Serra vs. Court of Appeals 299 SCRA 60, 4 January 1994 Nocon, J. Who Bears the Risk of Loss Roman vs Grimalt 6 PHIL 96, 11 April 1906 Torres, J.

VIII.

Norkis Distributors, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals 193 SCRA 694, 7 February 1991 Grino-Aquino, J. IX.

Recto Law Southern Motors, Inc. vs. Moscoso 2 SCRA 168, 30 May 1961 Paredes, J.

Pascual vs. Universal Motors Corp. 61 SCRA 121, 20 November 1974 Makalintal, J. Filinvest Credit Corp. vs. Court of Appeals 178 SCRA 188, 29 September 1989 3

Sarmiento, J. X.

Delivery as a Mode of Transferring Ownership Addison vs. Felix 38 PHIL 404, 3 August 1918 Fisher, J.

Sampaguita Pictures, Inc. vs. Jalwindor Manufacturing, Inc. 43 SCRA 420, 11 October 1979 De Castro, J. XI.

Transfer of Ownership Ilao-Quianay vs. mapile 474 SCRA 246, 25 October 2005 Tinga, J.

XII.

Article 1491 Fiestan vs. Court of Appeals 185 SCRA 751, 28 May 1990 Fernan, C.J. Articles 1506 and 559 Dizon vs. Suntay 47 SCRA 160, 29 September 1972 Fernando, J.

XIII.

EDCA Publishing & Distributing Corp. vs. Santos 184 SCRA 614, 26 April 1990 Cruz, J. Double Sale (Article 1544) Carbonell vs. Court of Appeals 69 SCRA 99, 26 January 1976 Makalintal, J.

XIV.

Dagupan Trading vs. Macam 14 SCRA 170, 31 May 1965 Dizon, J. Tañedo vs. Court of Appeals 252 SCRA 80, 22 January 1996 Panganiban, J. Radiowealth Finance Co. vs. Palileo 197 SCRA 245, 20 May 1991 Gancayco, J. Nuguid vs. Court of Appeals 171 SCRA 213, 13 March 1989 Sarmiento, J. Cruz vs. Cabana 129 SCRA 656, 22 June 1984 4

Teehankee, J. Caram vs. Laureta 103 SCRA 7, 24 February 1981 Fernandez, J. Valdez vs. Court of Appeals 194 SCRA 360, 25 February 1991 Gancayco, J. Gabriel vs. Mabanta 399 SCRA 573, 26 March 2003 Sandoval-Gutierrez, J. Consolidated Rural Bank (Cagayan Valley) vs. Court of Appeals G.R. No. 132161, 17 January 2005 Tinga, J. Express Credit Financing Corp. vs. Velasco 473 SCRA 570, 20 October 2005 Quisumbing, J. Ulep vs. Court of Appeals 472 SCRA 241, 11 October 2005 Garcia, J. XV.

Breach of Warranty Goodyear Philippines, Inc. vs. Sy 474 SCRA 427, 9 November 2005 Panganiban, J.

Villostas Vs. Court of Appeals 210 SCRA 490, 26 June 1992 Paras, J. Moles vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 169 SCRA 777, 31 January 1989 Regalado, J. XVI.

Right of Redemption Flores vs. So 162 SCRA 117, 26 June 1988 Yap, C.J.

Etcuban vs. Court of Appeals 148 SCRA 507, 16 March 1987 Paras, J. Ramos vs. Court of Appeals 180 SCRA 365, 29 December 1989 Regalado, J. De Leon vs. Salvador 5

36 SCRA 567, 28 December 1970 Teehankee, J. Alonzo vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 150 SCRA 259, 28 May 1987 Cruz, J. Lee Chuy Realty Corp. vs. Court of Appeals 250 SCRA 596, 4 December 1995 Bellosilo, J. Guzman & Bocaling & Co. vs. Bonnevie 206 SCRA 668, 2 March 1992 Cruz, J.

***LEASE Yek Seng Co. vs. Court of Appeals 205 SCRA 305, 29 January 1992 Cruz, J. Clutario vs. Court of Appeals 216 SCRA 314, 11 December 1992 Romero, J. Yap vs. Cruz 208 SCRA 692, 8 May 1992 Medialdea, J. United Realty Corp. vs. Court of Appeals 183 SCRA 725, 27 March 1990 Gancayco, J. Legar Management & Realty Corp. vs. Court of Appeals 252 SCRA 335, 24 January 1996 Puno, J. Allied Banking Corporation vs. Court of Appeals 283 SCRA 357, 16 January 1998 Bellosilo, J. Heirs of Fausta Dimaculangan vs. Intermediate Appellate Court 170 SCRA 393, 20 February 1989 Fernan, C.J. Inductivo vs. Court of Appeals 229 SCRA 380, 19 January 1994 Vitug, J. Ang Yu Asuncion vs. Court of Appeals 238 SCRA 603, 2 December 1994 Vitug, J. Equatorial Realty Development Bank vs. Mayfair Theater, Inc. 6

264 SCRA 483, 21 November 1996 Hermosisima, Jr. J.

7

SALES

8

Absolute and Conditional

9