Quo Warranto

 

Snpuc`gd fh tin _ig`gppglns SNMGFLB@ QSGB@ DF^SQ Hgrst Euagdgb` Snmgfl Cbmugf Dgty Crbldi 128

LBLB @F, _ntgtgflnr

Dbsn Lf.

-vnrsus_F@G QGKKF,

Hfr5 Ruf ]brrbltf Snspflanlt.

 x-------------------------------x R^F ]BSSBLQF  QIN _BSQGNT

2.

Qin _ntgtgflnr LB LBLB LB @F @F   gs fh `nmb `nmb`` bm bmn, n, Hg Hg`g `gpg pglf lf,, b

rnmgstnrna vftnr bla b rnsganlt fh Tulsigln Cug`aglm Lf. 27, Jbcglg, Cbmugf Dgty winrn tin Iflfrbc`n Dfurt‗s prfdnssns bla franrs jby cn snrvna, dfpy fh tin Xftnr‗s GA gs inrntf bttbdina bs ‐BLLNY ‐BLLNY B‚. B‚.

3. Snspflanlt _F@G _F@G   QG QGK KKF KF,, fh `nmb `nmb`` bm bmn, n, b au aub` b` dgtg dgtgzn znl l ibvglm cnnl gssun una a bl gjjgmrb rbl lt vgsb gssun una a cy tin Mfvnrljnlt fh tin ^lgtna Ttbtns fh Bjnrgdb (^TB) bla wif gs rnsganlt fh Lf. 23 Tprglm Xb``ny, Tbl Agnmf, Db`ghfrlgb, ^TB. In jby cn snrvna wgti tigs Iflfrbc`n Dfurt‗s prfdnssns bla franrs bt tin Fhhgdn fh tin Dgty Jbyfr fh Cbmugf Dgty, dfpy fh  igs ^T Mfvnrljnlt GA bttbdina inrntf bs ‐BLLNY ‐ BLLNY C‚. C‚.

LBQ^SN FH QIN _NQGQGFL

 

4.

Qigs

gs

b

vnrghgna

_ntgtgfl

hfr

quf

wbrrbltf

dflt df ltns nstg tglm lm ti tin n bs bssu sujp jptg tgfl fl fh _f _f`g `g Qgkk Qgkkf f bs jb jbyf yfrr fh  Cbmugf Dgty fl tin mrfula fh gln`gmgcg`gty. Gt gs cnglm hg`na gl bddfrabldn wgti tin prfvgsgfls fh BJ. Lf. ?=-1-2>TD, Jby 2>, 3??=.

DB^TN FH BDQGFL   SNT_FLANLQ

_F@G

QGKKF

GT

GLN@GMGC@N QF CNDFJN QIN JBWFS FH QI QIN N DG DGQW QW FH CB CBM^ M^GF GF HF HFS S QI QIN N SNBTFL _FTTNTT

QIBQ

IN

QIN

AFNT

LFQ

R^B@GHGDBQGFL

_SNTDSGCNA CW @B] 1.

Qibt Qibt ttin in n` n`n ndtg tgfl fl wb wbs s j jb ban fl Jb Jby y 2 24, 4, 3?2 3?27. Bla Bla

tibt Snspflanlt fctbglna tin igminst vftns tftb`glm tf 3=,, 9=3 vf 3= vftn tns s bjf jflm lm ti tin n db dbla laga gabt btn ns hfr hfr Jb Jbyf yfrr bs dnrtghgna cy tin Cfbra fh Db Dbl lvbssnrs gl gts 3?27 Dnrtgghgdbtn fh Dblvbss, dfps fh igs Dnr Dnrt Dnrtghgdbtn fh  Dblagabdy (DFD) inrntf bttbdina bs ‐BLLNY ‐BLLNY D-2‚ D-2‚ bla tin Dnrtghgdbtn fh Dblvbss bttbdina inrntf bs ‐BLLNY D3‚.. 3‚

>.

Qibt Snspflanlt ibs tbknl wbs prfd`bgjna bla

ibs fbti fl Euln 4?, 3?27.

8.

Qibt Snspflanlt ibs bssujna fhhgdn fl Eu`y 2,

3?27.

 

=.

Qi Qibt bt ti tin n _n _ntg tgtg tgfl fl wb wbs s hg` hg`na na fl Eu Eu`y `y >, 3?27 3?27..

9.

Qibt tin _ntgtgfl gs prfpnr hfr tin rnbsfl tibt

Tndtgfl 9 fh BJ. Lf. ?=-1-2>-TD prfvgans tibt5

‐Qin ‐Q in n` n`nd ndtg tgfl fl prft prftns nstt fr pn pntg tgtg tgfl fl hf hfrr quf  quf  wbrrb wb rrblt ltf f si sib` b``` cn hg hg`n `na a wg wgti tigl gl tin tin lf lfl-  l-  nxtnlagc`n pnrgfa fh tnl abys hf``fwglm tin  abtn fh prfd`bjbtgfl.‚  

7.

Qibt tin Snspflanlt gs lft b dgtgznl fh tin

_ig`gppglns _ig`gp pglns hfr ibvglm cnnl gssuna bl gjjgmrblt gjjgmrblt vgsb cy  tin Mfvnrljnlt fh tin ^lgtna Ttbtns fh Bjnrgdb dfpgns fh  sudi bttbdina inrntf bs ‐BLLNY ‐ BLLNY A‚. A‚.

2?.

Qibt tin Snspflanlt prgfr tf tin hg`glm fh igs

dbla db laggabdy abdy,, ib ibs s cn cnnl nl `g `gvg vglm lm gl ti tin n ^lg lgtn tna a Ttbtn tbtns s fh  Bjnrgdb (^TB) hfr bt `nbst 44 ynbrs.

22.

Qib Qibtt Sn Snspf spflan lanlt lt rrnsg nsgana ana bla dfl dfltgl tgluna una tf rrnsg nsgan an ggl l

Lf. 23 Tprglm Xb``ny, Tbl Agnmf, Db`ghfrlgb, ^TB. 23.. 23

Qi Qibt bt Sn Snsp spf fla lanl nltt Tn Tndt dtgf gfl l 47 fh S. S.B. B. =2 =28? 8?,, fr ti tin n

@fdb` Mfvnrljnlt Dfan prfvgans5 (b)

Bl n`ndtgvn `fdb` fhhgdgb` just cn b

dgtgznl fh tin _ig`gppglns; _ig`gppglns; b rnmgstnrna vftnr gl tin cbrblmby, julgdgpb`gty, dgty, fr prfvgldn fr, gl tin dbsn fh b jnjcnr fh  tin

sblmmulgblm

pbl`b`bwgmbl,

sblmmulgblm pbl`ulmsfa, fr sblmmulgblm cbybl, tin agstrgdt winrn in gltnlas tf cn `n `ndt dtna na;; b rn rnsg sgan anlt lt ti tinr nrng ngl l hf hfrr bt `n `nbs bstt

 

fln (2) ynbr gjjnagbtn`y prndnaglm tin aby fh tin n`ndtgfl; n`ndtgfl; bla bc`n tf rnba bla wrgtn Hg`gpglf fr bly ftinr `fdb` `blmubmn fr agb`ndt.

 xxx.

24.. 24

]i ]inr nrnb nbs, s, Tn Tndt dtgf gfl l1 1? ?p prf rfvg vgan ans s tib tibt5 t5 Qin Qi n hf hf`` ``fw fwgl glm m pn pnrs rsfl fls s brn brn ag agsq squb ub`g `ghg hgna  na   hrfj

rullglm

hfr

bly

n`ndtgvn

`fdb` 

 pfsgtgfl5 

xxx.

(a) Qifsn wgti aub` dgtgznlsigp;

xxx 

(h)

_nrjblnlt

rnsganlts

gl

b

hfrngml 

dfultry fr tifsn wif ibvn bdqugrna tin  rg rgmi mitt tf rnsg rnsgan an bc bcrf rfba ba bl bla a dfl fltg tglu lun n tf  bvbg` fh tin sbjn rgmit bhtnr tin nhhndtgvgty  fh tigs Dfan   28.. Qi 28 Qibt bt Sn Snsp spfl flan anlt lt ib ibs s df dflt ltgl glun una a tf us usn n ig igs s Bj Bjnr nrgd gdbl bl _bsspfrt. 2=.. Qi 2= Qibt bt gl ti tin n db dbsn sn fh Jb Jbqu qug` g`gl glm m v. DF DFJN JN@N @ND, D, M. M.S. S. Lf Lf.. 27>817, Bprg` 28, 3?24, tin Tuprnjn Dfurt in`a tibt5 Qin

usn

fh

hfrngml

pbsspfrt

bhtnr 

rnlful rnl fuldgl dglm m fln fln‗s ‗s hfr hfrngm ngml l dgt dgtgzn gznlsi lsigp gp gs b   pfsgtgvn

bla

vf`ultbry

bdt

fh 

rnprnsnltb rnprn snltbtgfl tgfl bs tf fln‗ fln‗s s lbtgflb`gty lbtgflb`gty bla 

 

dg dgtg tgzn znls lsig igp; p; gt af afns ns lf lftt ag agvn vnst st Hg Hg`g `gpg pglf  lf  dgtgznlsigp rnmbglna cy rnpbtrgbtgfl cut gt  rndblts rndbl ts tin Fbti fh Snlul Snluldgbtg dgbtgfl fl rnqugrna  rnqugrna  tf qub`ghy fln tf rul hfr bl n`ndtgvn   pfsgtgfl. 29. Jfrnfvnr, gl tibt dbsn fh Diub v. DFJN@ND, M.S. Lf. 3288?=, Bprg` >, 3?28, tin Dfurt in`a tibt5 Aub` dgtgznls brn agsqub`ghgna hrfj rullglm   hfr bly n`ndtgvn `fdb` pfsgtgfl. Qiny dbllft  suddnsshu``y

rul

bla

bssujn

fhhgd hgdn 

cndb cn dbus usn n ti ting ngrr gl gln` n`gm gmgc gcg` g`gt gty y gs gl glin inrn rnlt lt gl  tinj ti nj,, nx nxgs gstgl tglm m pr prgf gfrr tf tin tin hg`g hg`glm lm fh ting tingr  r  dnrtghgdbtns fh dblagabdy. Qingr dnrtghgdbtns  fh dblagabdy brn vfga bc glgtgf, bla vftns  dbst

hf r

t in j

wg ` `

cn

agsrnmbrana.

Dflsnq Dfl snqunl unlt`y t`y,, wifnvn wifnvnrr mbr mbrlnr lnrs s tin lnxt  lnxt  igminst lujcnr fh vftns bjflm tin n`gmgc`n  dblagabtns gs tin pnrsfl `nmb``y nltgt`na tf  tin pfsgtgfl.

_SBWNST

]INSNH ]IN SNHFSN FSN,, prn prnjgs jgsns ns dfl dflsga sganrn nrna, a, pntgtg pntgtgfln flnrr rns rnspnd pndthu thu``y  ``y  prbys prb ys ti tibt bt ti tigs gs Iflf Iflfrb rbc` c`n n Df Dfur urt, t, bh bhtn tnrr in inbr brgl glm, m, agsq agsqub ub`g `ghy  hy  rnspflanlt _f`g Qgkkf bs tin Jbyfr fh tin Dgty fh Cbmugf.

Ftinr

hfrjs

fh

rn`gnh,

eust

bla

dgrdujstbldns brn `gknwgsn prbyna hfr

Cbmugf Dgty, Eu`y >, 3?27.

nqugtbc`n

ulanr

tin

 

LBLB U. @F _ntgtgflnr XNSGHGDBQGFL BLA DNSQGHGDBQN FH LFL-HFS^J TIF___GLM

G, LB LBLB LB U. @F @F,, fh `n `nmb mb`` bmn, bmn, b rn rnsg sgan anlt lt fh Tu Tuls lsig igln ln Cug`aglm Lf. 27, Jbcglg, Cbmugf Dgty, Hg`gpglf, sglm`n, bhtnr ibvglm cnnl au`y swfrl tf gl bddfrabldn wgti `bw, inrncy, anpfsn bla sby5

2. Qibt G bj tin pnt pntgtgfl gtgflnr nr gl tin bcfvn bcfvn-nltgt -nltgt`na `na dbs dbsn n bla ibvn dbusna tigs pntgtgfl tf cn prnpbrna; 3. Qibt G rnba b bla la ulanrs ulanrstffa tffa gts d dfltnl fltnlts ts wigdi wigdi brn trun bla bl a df dfrrn rrndt dt fh jy fw fwl l pn pnrs rsfl flb` b` kl klfw fw`n `nam amn n bl bla/ a/fr fr cbsna fl butinltgd rndfras. 4. Qib Qibtt G ibvn lft dfjjn dfjjnldn ldna a bly bdt bdtgfl gfl fh prfdn prfdnnag naglm lm glvf`vglm tin sbjn gssun gl tin Tuprnjn Dfurt, tin Dfurt fh Bppnb`s fr bly ftinr trgculb` fr bmnldy; tibt tf tin cnst fh jy klfw`namn, lf sudi bdtgfl fr prfdnnaglm gs pnlaglm gl tin Tuprnjn Dfurt, tin Dfurt fh Bppnb`s fr bly trgculb` fr bmnldy, bla tibt, gh G sifu si fu`a `a `nb nbrl rl ti tin nrn rnbh bhtn tnrr ti tibt bt b sgj gjg` g`b br bd bdtg tgfl fl fr prfdnnaglm ibs cnnl hg`na fr gs pnlaglm cnhfrn tinsn dfurts fh trgculb` fr bmnldy, G ulanrtbkn tf rnpfrt tibt tin hbdt tf tin Dfurt wgtigl hgvn (>) abys tinrnhrfj.

GL ]GQLNTT ]INSNHFS, G ibvn inrnultf snt jy ibla tigs >ti aby fh Eu`y, 3?27.

LBLB U. @F

 

 QGL #279349 Bhhgblt T^CTDSGCNA BLA T]FSL tf cnhfrn jn tigs > ti aby fh Eu`y, 3?27. G inrncy dnrtghy tibt tin bhhgblt nxndutna bla ulanrstffa tin bcfvn, tin bhhgblt pnrsflb``y bppnbrglm bla klfwl tf jn tf cn tin cnst pnrsfl wif nxndu nxndutna tna tin hfrnm hfrnmfglm fglm pntgtgf pntgtgfl l bla nxigcgtglm tf jn igs Qbx Ganltghgdbtgfl wgti b lujcnr 279349 gssuna fl Jby 2, 3?27 bla wigdi nxpgrns fl Jby 2, 3?33.

Btty. Efil @nstnr J. Cb`bmft GC_ Lf 77???? Sf`` Lf. 7?7???/Jbrdi 3?33 _QS Lf. 293 JD@N Dfjp`gbldn Lf. 2749 `jcb`bmftOmjbg`.dfj Sffj #27 BCD Cug`aglm, ^ppnr Mnlnrb` @ulb, Cbmugf

 

Dfpy hurlgsina5

DIF@F Dfulsn` _FDIF@F hfr tin _`bgltghh  S2?1 @bpnrb` Cug`aglm DIF@F _FDIF@F Tnssgfl Sfba, Cbmugf Dgty  Sf`` Lf. ?2>8=> GC_ Lf. 289>-?8/39/29 _QS Lf. 389>179-?8-39-3?29 JD@N Dfj Lf. G-4187>9, ?8-39-3?29 ultg` ?1-21-3?31

S2?1 @bpnrb` Cug`aglm, Tnssgfl Sfba, Cbmugf Dgty

33

QIN D@NSK FH DF^SQ Snmgflb` Qrgb` Dfurt Crbldi 4 Cbmugf Dgty  NY_@BLBQGFL  Qin ulanrsgmlna wg`` sucjgt tin hfrnmfglm Jftgfl tf Agsjgss hfr inbrglm hfr tin dflsganrbtgfl bla bpprfvb` fh tin Iflfrbc`n Dfurt fl Hrgaby, Eu`y 7, 3?27 bt 35?? f‗d`fdk gl tin bhtnrlffl fr sffl tinrnbhtnr bs dfulsn` jby cn inbra.

 

Btty.

Cb`bmft

Ef Efil

@n @nstnr

J. J.

 

‐BLLNY B‚

LBLB U. @F

Tulsigln Cug`aglm Lf. 27, Jbcglg, Cbmugf Dgty

 

‐BLLNY C‚

 

‐BLLNY D-2‚

 

‐BLLNY D-3‚

 

‐BLLNY A‚