Provrem Finals Transcript

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

RULE 65 — CERTIORARI, PROHIBITION, MANDAMUS !"#$% '(") *$+! +,$- )"!#$.,+(

!"#$#$%& (%) *")#$%)+)$ ,-"*./0  +123456 789: 789: ;3 ,)=5?94>=4650 ,)=5?94>=4650 +/ 01234/ 546 1762346063 38 099678879 24 0/:; a.   #63? b. @4069 46 E=083FD= 93130> c. "5A3176? 7B761383/C D=93130> 46 E=083FD=93130> 5=/1234/8G +8397 564H 2I7 J062: 3/ 3/276782? 32 3/1>=978 0 263? 2I7 14=62? 46 E=083FD=93130> 5=/1234/8G (=>7 KL I0M7 0/ 7/=H760234/ 45 2I7 E=083FD=93130> 7 KL 46 7 PQ +H4/C 2I787 0C7/1378 067 2I7; RG .3M3> %76M317 .4HH38834/? SG .7/260> @4069 @4069 45 +88788H7/2 +JJ70>8? +JJ70>8? LG %71=632378 0/9 $B1I0/C7 $B1I0/C7 .4HH38834/? KG "5A317 45 2I7 O678397/2? QG ,0/9 (7C38260234/ +=2I4632:? PG %4130> %71=632: .4HH38834/? TG .3M3> +764/0=2318 +764/0=2318 @4069? @4069? UG @=670= 45 O027/28? VG #6097H06W8 0/9 #71I/4>4C: #60/8576? RXG!0234/0> $>71263A310234/ +9H3/38260234/? $/76C: (7C=>0246: @4069? RRG!0234/0> #7>714HH=/310234/8 .4HH38834/? RSG*7J062H7/2 45 +C60630/ (7546H =/976 (7J=31 +12 !4G PPQT? RLGY4M76/H7/2 %76M317 Z/8=60/17 %:827H? RKG$HJ>4:778 .4HJ7/80234/ .4HH38834/? RQG+C631=>2=60> Z/M7/234/ @4069? RPGZ/8=60/17 .4HH38834/? RTGOI3>3JJ3/7 +24H31 $/76C: .4HH38834/? RUG@4069 45 Z/M782H7/28? RVG.4/826=1234/ Z/9=826: +6=/206: 065 A9C ?=6363940 \4= I0M7 24 1>03H 2I02 2I7 263 46 45A3176 7B761383/C D=93130>] E=083F D=93130> 5=/1234/8 01279 732I76; +G N32I4=2 46 3/ 7B1788 7B1788 45 D=638931234/? 46 @G N32I C60M7 001W 46 3/ 7B1788 45 D=638931234/G

JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

*94>363945 #I767 38 /4 0JJ70>? 46 0/: J>03/? 8J779:? 0/9 097E=027 67H79: 3/ 2I7 4693/06: 14=687 45 >0NG #&E #I38 H=82 >7C79 3/ :4=6 J723234/ F=C3;3=> !=636394 #I7 +CC637M79 J062: 8I0>> A3>7 0 M763A379 J723234/ 877W3/C 2I7 0//=>H7/2 45 8= 34 *=C639C2C3 Z2 38 J64J76 24 1466712 76646 45 D=638931234/? 0/9 !"# 76646 45 D=9CH7/2 "))%) %( PQ)$-R$*#$%&

"))%) %( PQRBJ"&#

.4=62 9478 /42 I0M7 D=638931234/ 46 7B1779 328 D=638931234/

.4=62 I08 D=638931234/? =834/ 45 >0Na

(7H79: 38 *=C639C2C3 (7H79: 38 +??=2< 38 +??=2< =/976 )D=C26394 ,J)0 25 2 ?C=K C=LD3536= B)E +/ )( )_%# 79 3/C 2I7 1762346063G !4 1762346063 N3>> 79G G8MN Z/ 46976 24 C3M7 2I7 14=62 46 263 0 1I0/17 24 671235: 328 H3820W7 "O*"!#$%&-E `Z/ 2I787 3/820/178? /4 /779 24 A3>7 )(a 1.bI767 2I7 46976 38 0 J027/2 /=>>32:^ 2.bI767 2I7 388=7 603879 3/ 1762346063 I0M7 : J08879 =J4/ =234/ 45 2I7 E=78234/ 603879^ 4.bI767 H4234/ 546 6714/839760234/ N4=>9 788^ 5.bI767 J723234/76 38 97J63M79 45 9=7 J641788^ 6.bI767? 3/ 0 163H3/0> 1087? 67>375 564H 0/ 46976 45 066782 38 =6C7/2 0/9 2I7 C60/23/C 45 8=1I 67>375 14=62 38 I3CI>: 3HJ6406; bI7/ 2I767 I08 0>6709: M78 :4=6 567794HG GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 1

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

1.bI767

2I7 J6417793/C 3/ 2I7 >4N76 14=62 067 0 /=>>32: 546 >01W 45 9=7 J641788^ 2.bI767 2I7 J6417793/C N08 94/7 7BFJ0627^ 3.bI767 2I7 388=7 603879 38 4/7 J=67>: 45 >0N 46 NI767 J=31 3/276782 38 3/M4>M79G  !"#$%&'( *%#+, #$+ -%..%/0*1 2&+ !"#$%&%'"& )*! !$+" ,1.3&+(+*4+ %- 2*5 %- #$+ 1&%"*6( 2.7% 288+2.9 %& 2*5 8.20*9 (8++659 26+:"2#+ &+;+65 3.=4650 ,)=5?94>=4650 0Ga #63 3H3/06: Z/D=/1234/ H=82 4/C N32I 2I7 J723234/ 24 J67M7/2 2I7 012 9=63/C 2I7 J7/97/1: 45 2I7 1087G b32I4=2 2I38? 2I7 678J4/97/2 N3>> 14/23/=7 24 J76546H 2I7 012 :4= 877W 24 824J 2I64=CI 2I7 O723234/ 546 O64I3341 !C983H36394 O64I3378 0C03/82 WD>3I32< 9C :34356=C32< AD4I63945? AD4I63945? 7C38>023M7 0/9 7B71=23M7 5=/1234/8G 2. $BI0=8234/ 45 09H3/3826023M7 67H79378 H=82 79 45 35 2I7 ?=636394 35 2123456 24 =X=ID63Y= 9A;3I3206; \4= 10//42 54617 0/ 45A3130> 24 J76546H 328 938167234/06: 9=2: 3/ 0 176203/ H0//76G \4= 10/ 54617 0/ 45A3130> 24 J76546H 0 938167234/06: 9=2: N0:8 14HJ7> I3H 24 J76546H 0 938167234/06: 9=2: > 14HH0/9 2I7 678J4/97/2 24 94 2I7 012 67E=3679 24 3 2: NI767 328 45A3130>8 =/D=823A30: 675=87 24 J0: 2I7 D=9CH7/2? 2I7 67H79: 45 2I7 1>03H0/2 38 24 8=7 2I7 45A3130>8 546 )+!*+)_%G

G8MN @710=87 2I7 8I76355 10//42 3HJ>7H7/2 2I7 N632 45 7B71=234/ 0C03/82 2I7 C4M76/H7/2G #I38 38 7M: 46 02201I J=31 5=/98G @=2 32 38 0 H3/3827630> 9=2: 45 0 J=31 45A3130> 24 4 D=9CH7/2 2I=8 H0/90H=8 N3>> >37G "2I76N387 2I7 14HJ>03/0/2 N3>> 7 0/ 01234/ 0/9 NI767 24 A3>7 2I7 01234/G G8=4 69 ;306; #I767 067 2N4 W3/98 45 678J4/97/28 3/ J723234/8 1762346063? J64I372h8 80: 2I7 (#. D=9C7 > : 2I7 J63M027 678J4/97/2G PD>1= 25 &9:342< !2C6M #I7 D=9C7 08 J=31 678J4/97/2 38 4/>: 0 /4H3/0> J062: 0/9 I7 9478 /42 I0M7 24 0/8N76 2I7 J723234/ 45 1762346063 /42 =/>788 I7 38 67E=3679 24 0/8N76 06; %4 32h8 670>>: N64/C 546 0/ (#. D=9C7 24 0>84 0/8N76G +>2I4=CI 32 38 2I7 9713834/ 45 2I7 (#. GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 3

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

D=9C7 2I02 38 02201W79 9 /42 20W7 32 J7684/0>>:G _/976 2I7 6=>78? 2I7 D=9C7 /4 >4/C76 /7798 24 0/8N76G Z2 38 4/>: 2I7 J63M027 678J4/97/2 2I02 N3>> 0/8N76G d7 N3>> 0:? 388=78 603879 2I7673/ 067 244 =/8= 24 N0660/2 14/839760234/G Z5 =/FH76324634=8? 2I7 14=62 H0: 0N069 3/ 50M46 45 2I7 678J4/97/2 2677 14828 0C03/82 J723234/76 0/9 14=/87>G

G826 739N %C>=C 69 I9::=46 Z5 8=5A3137/2 3/ 546H 0/9 8= 14=62 H0: 67E=367 C=5?94>=46 69 I9::=46 736834 /_ >2M5 AC9: C=I=3?6 9A 68= I9?M 45 46976G %=1I 46976 8I0>> 78G #I767 38 /4N 0 J7/0>2: 546 3H3/06: 3/D=/1234/ 38 388=79? 2I7 14=62 H0: 14/23/=7 N32I 2I7 J6417793/C N32I3/ RX 90:8 564H A3>3/C 45 2I7 J723234/G *70/ )4/271>06; +8 :4= W/4N 0>6709:? 3/ J723234/ 546 1762346063 0/9 2I7 80H7 38 26=7 N32I H0/90H=8 0/9 J64I3=46 WD>1=Z AC9: I94634D341 7368 68= ?C9I==>3415 H=A9C= 36 G #I7 D=9C7 N3>> C3M7 :4= 27/ 90:8 24 871=67 2I7 #(" 46 J67>3H3/06: D=9CH7/2 564H 2I7 23H7 :4= A3>7 :4=6 J723234/ 546 1762346063G $B0HJ>7; :4= E=78234/ 2I7 6=>3/C 45 2I7 (#. 14=62? >72 =8 80: 0/ 3/276>41=246: 46976? :4= 577> 2I02 32 38 M76: =/5036? 14/8232=27 0 C60M7 07 0 J723234/ 546 1762346063 3/ 2I7 .+G '64H 2I7 23H7 :4= A3>7 J723234/ 546 1762346063 3/ 2I7 .+? 2I7 (#. N3>> 8=8J7/9 2I7 J6417793/C8 546 4/>: 27/ 90:8G Z5 :4= 067 /42 07 24 4 @: A3>3/C 0 M763A379 14HJ>03/2 3/ 14=62 `(#.a 82023/C N32I 176203/2: 2I7 63CI2 0/9 J=6J487 45 2I7 7BJ64J630234/ 0/9 978163 46 J7684/0> J64J762: 24 7 PT J63H063>: C4M76/8 7BJ64J630279 C4M76/H7/2G $BJ64J630234/ 410> C4M76/H7/2 38 C4M76/79 Y4M76/H7/2 .497 45 RVVR "46CM 9A ?=?9536 _J4/ 2I7 A3>3/C 45 2I7 14HJ>03/2 0/9 9=7 /42317 24 2I7 9757/90/2?2I7 J>03/2355 H0: 7/276 0/9 J488788 2I7 J64J762: 35 I7 97J4832 N32I 2I7 0=2I463[79 C4M76/H7/2 97J483206: 32027 2I7 01E=383234/8 45 63CI2 45 N0:? 8327 46 >410234/ 546 /0234/0> C4M76/H7/2 3/560826=12=67 J64D7128G #I38 3/1>=978 J64D7128 =/976 (G+G PVQT W/4N/ 08 @=3>9F"J76027F0/9F#60/8576 ,0NG #I38 >0N 38 977H79 24 0H7/9 0H7/9 2I7 820/9069 820/9069 45 3/3230>

JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

14HJ7/80234/ 3/ (=>7 PT AC9: 255=55=> Y2=7 820/9069 0/9 2I7 97J4832 H497 J6781637 PT 24 0JJ>:G

R=A=45=5 24> %HW=I63945E Z5 9757/90/2 I08 403/2 N32I3/ 2I7 23H7 820279 3/ 2I7 8=HH4/8G d7 H=82 82027 0>> 2I7 C64=/98 546 I38 403H? 164881>03H? 46 2I369FJ062: 14HJ>03/2 38 0>>4N79G d4N7M76? d4N7M76? 9=63/C 2I7 2630> 45 2I7 388=7 45 D=82 14HJ7/80234/? 9757/90/2 H0: J6787/2 C=390/17 08 24 2I7 0H4=/2 45 14HJ7/80234/ jBk I08 /42 0/8N7679G

•

•

%C>=C 9A "X?C9?C326394 #I38 38 388=79 05276 05276 2I7 4> 0JJ43/2 /42 H467 2I0/ 2I677 `La 14HJ727/2 0/9 9383/27678279 J7684/8 08 14HH38834/768 24 08176203/ 2I7 D=82 14HJ7/80234/G " 782027 H462C0C7 `($)a 38 0/ 01178846: 14/26012G #I7 J63/13J0> 43C0234/ 38 0 83HJ>7 >40/ 46 H=2==H 97816337/07 63CI28G .I0227> H462C0C7 45 14/8232=279 4/ H4M078G 3.)462C0C46 /779 /42 26394 :9C61219C. `062G SXUQa 4.,3032: 45 0114HH490234/ H462C0C468 7B27/98 4/>: =J 24 2I7 >40/ M0>=7 45 2I7 H462C0C79 J64J762: 0/9 /42 2I7 7/2367 >40/ 3287>5G 5.'03>=67 24 67C38276 2I7 H462C0C7 3/ 2I7 (7C3826: 45 O64J762: 9478 /42 055712 2I7 M0>3932: ?2M:=46 JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 7

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

6.(7C38260234/ 45 2I7 H462C0C7 38 /7178806: 546 2I7 J=6J487 45 03/2 3/ 01234/ 546 54671>48=67G Z/ 0/ 01234/ 546 2I7 54671>48=67 45 0 H462C0C7 46 42I76 7/1=H 782027? 2I7 14HJ>03/2 8I0>> 872 5462I 2I7 9027 0/9 9=7 7B71=234/ 45 2I7 H462C0C7^ 328 0883C/H7/28? 35 0/:^ 2I7 /0H78 0/9 678397/178 45 2I7 H462C0C46 0/9 2I7 H462C0C77^ 0 978163J234/ 45 2I7 H462C0C79 J64J762:^ 0 82027H7/2 45 2I7 9027 45 2I7 /427 46 42I76 941=H7/206: 7M397/17 45 2I7 43C0234/ 871=679 03H79 24 > J7684/8 I0M3/C 46 1>03H3/C 0/ 3/276782 3/ 2I7 J64J762: 8=976 45 2I7 H462C0C7? 0>> 45 NI4H 8I0>> 3I6394

1.$B1>=83M7 463C3/0> D=638931234/ 50>> 732I76 3/ 2I7 )#. 46 (#. 97J7/93/C 4/ 2I7 08878879 M0>=7 J5 2I7 J64J762: 3/M4>M79G 2.)#. I08 D=638931234/ 35 2I7 08878879 M0>=7 45 2I7 670> 782027 38 496 :9C= 6826 V_# %) 34 J=6C9 J243=H6 35 496 :9C= 6826 [__#Z 9C 34 J=6C9 J243> 79 N32I 2I7 (#.G 3.)#. I08 D=638931234/ 24 20W7 14C/3[0/17 45 670> 01234/8 46 2I487 0557123/C 232>7 24 670> J64J762:? 46 14/97H/0234/ 45 46 54671>48=67 35 0 H462C0C7 4/ 670> J64J762: 97J7/93/C 4/ 2I7 08878879 M0>=7  +*# [/[T !42 0JJ>3107 24 1I0227> H462C0C7

•

.4M768 4/>: 670> 782027 H462C0C7

•

+12 38 3/27/979 H767>: 24 67C=>027 2I7 =X6C2WD>3I32< 52 J4N76 46 7BJ6788 0=2I4632: 24 94 84 3/ 2I7 9779 3287>5 46 3/ 0 941=H7/2 02201IH7/2 2I76724 •

bI02 38 2I7 67H79: 45 54671>48=67f (7H79: 0M03>07 24 2I7 H462C0C77 46 7B260D=93130>

J U D I C I A L EXTRAJUDICIAL FORECLOSURE FORECLOSURE A.Governed by the a.Governed by Act ROC. 3135 as amended. A.Involves filing of a.Does not require an independent the filing of an action. action. A.E q u i t y o f a.R i g h t of re de mp ti on is redemption is recognized but no available. right of redemption ex ce pt wh en mortgagee is a banking institution. A.D e f i c i e n c y a.No judgment for a  judgment  judgm ent rendered rende red def ic ie ncy by the court in the because there is same proceeding. no ju di ci al pro cee din g though recovery of the deficiency is allowed. A.R e c o v e r y o f a.R e c o v e r y o f deficiency by mere de fi ci en cy motion for a th ro ug h an d e f i c i e n c y ind epe nde nt  judgment. action. Although nothing about re co ve ry is provided in Act 3135, there is no prohibition either.

+OO,Z.+#Z"! "' $-#(+g_*Z.Z+, '"($.,"%_($ "' )"(#Y+Y$ Z% Y"e$(!$* @\ %. ($%",_#Z"! "' *$.$)@$( RK? RVVV Z! +*)Z!Z%#(+#Ze$ )+##$( !"G VVFRXFXQ ($; O(".$*_($ Z! $-#(+g_*Z.Z+, '"($.,"%_($ "' )"(#Y+Y$ +% +))$!*$* @\ #d$ ($%",_#Z"!% *+#$* g+!_+(\ LX? SXXR +!* +_Y_%# T? SXXRG !2I6D: I9::359C3D:j 496 Y2 21C==:=46

1.+ 823J=>0234/ 7HJ4N763/C 16793246 24 0JJ64J63027 2I7 2I3/C8 08 C=060/2: 546 2I7 5=>A3>>H7/2 45 2I7 43C0234/ 3/ 2I7 7M7/2 2I7 43C46 503>8 24 >3M7 =J 24 I38 =/97620W3/C8 N32I4=2 5=62I76 J6417793/C8 J6417793/C8 0/9 0 J=31 80>7G 2.+62G SXUU 7BJ6788>: J64I30234/ 24 2I7 14/2606: 38 /=>> 0/9 M439G

JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 8

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

_/976 +6231>7 RXPS 45 2I7 ..? 2I7 14/26012 45 80>7 N3>> >: 3/097E=027^

2I0/ 4/7 I=/9679 2N7/2: `RSXa 90:8 564H 2I7 7/26: 45 D=9CH7/2? 0/9 2I02 3/ 9750=>2 45 8=1I J0:H7/2 2I7 J64J762: 8I0>> 9 02 J=31 0=1234/ 24 802385: 2I7 D=9CH7/2G i_$%#Z"!%;

2.bI7/ 2I7 M7/946 67H03/8 3/ J48878834/ 08 0 >78877 46 42I76N387^

1.bI02 8I0>> 2I7 14=628 94 35 32 A3/98 2I7 50128 3/ 2I7 14HJ>03/2 24 48=67f `24 0JJ70>a

4.bI7/ 2I7 J=61I0876 67203/8 546 I3H87>5 0 J062 45 2I7 J=61I087 M0>=7^ 5.bI7/ 2I7 M7/946 5 24 J0: 2I7 20B78 4/ 2I7 2I3/C8 84>9^ 6.Z/ 0/: 42I76 Bl1087 NI767 32 H0: : 3/576679 2I02 2I7 670> 3/27/234/ 45 2I7 J062378 38 2I02 2I7 260/801234/ 8I0>> 871=67 2I7 J0:H7/2 45 0 970234/ 24 2I7 14/2606: 38 /=>> 0/9 M439G +62G SXUU? ..a 2.bI02 067 2I7 67H79378 0M03>07 24 0 16793246 48=67 45 2I7 H462C0C7? 83HJ>7 01234/ 546 14>>71234/ 45 8=H N32I 02201IH7/2 =J4/ J64J76 05A390M32 2I02 2I7 M0>=7 45 2I7 H462C0C79 J64J762: 38 3/8=5A3137/2 24 14M76 2I7 9748=67 2I02 2I7 J64J762: 38 3/ 90/C76 45 >: 3/D=679 0/9 328 M0>=7 38 3/8=5A3137/2 45 2I7 J062378 I0M7 84 823J=>0279 3/ 2I7 14/26012a 3.bI02 38 2I7 67H79: 45 0 16793246 3/ 0 J0124 97 67264 80>7? 14/8397679 08 7E=3207 H462C0C7? 3/ 46976 24 14>>712 I38 1679328f `0M03> I3H87>5 45 54671>48=67 J6417793/C8a %71G SG g=9CH7/2 4/ 54671>48=67 546 J0:H7/2 46 80>7G Z5 =J4/ 2I7 2630> 3/ 8=1I 01234/ 2I7 14=62 8I0>> A3/9 2I7 50128 872 5462I 3/ 2I7 14HJ>03/2 24 > 08176203/ 2I7 0H4=/2 9=7 24 2I7 J>03/2355 =J4/ 2I7 H462C0C7 97=93/C 3/276782 0/9 42I76 1I06C78 08 0JJ64M79 > 67/976 D=9CH7/2 546 2I7 8=H 84 54=/9 9=7 0/9 46976 2I02 2I7 80H7 788 2I0/ /3/72: `VXa 90:8 /46 H467 JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

3.d4N 8I0>> 2I7 J76349 J76349 24 J0: 2I7 D=9CH7/2 45 54671>48=67 788 2I0/ VX* /46 H467 2I0/ RSX* 564H 2I7 7/26: 45 D=9CH7/2 0/9 2I02 3/ 9750=>2 45 8=1I J0:H7/2 2I7 J64J762: 8I0>> 9 02 J=31 0=1234/ 24 802385: D=9CH7/2a

%71G LG %0>7 45 H462C0C79 J64J762:^ 755712G bI7/ 2I7 9757/90/2? 05276 8 24 J0: 2I7 0H4=/2 45 2I7 D=9CH7/2 N32I3/ 2I7 J76349 8J713A379 2I7673/? 2I7 14=62? =J4/ H4234/? 8I0>> 46976 2I7 J64J762: 24 9 3/ 2I7 H0//76 0/9 =/976 2I7 J64M3834/8 45 (=>7 LV 0/9 42I76 67C=>0234/8 C4M76/3/C 80>78 45 670> 782027 =/976 7B71=234/G %=1I 80>7 8I0>> /42 055712 2I7 63CI28 45 J7684/8 I4>93/C J6346 7/1=H> 4J76027 24 93M782 2I7 63CI28 3/ 2I7 J64J762: 45 0>> 2I7 J062378 24 2I7 01234/ 0/9 24 M782 2I736 63CI28 3/ 2I7 J=61I0876? 8=4N79 0NG

_J4/ 2I7 A3/0>32: 45 2I7 46976 45 14/A36H0234/ 46 =J4/ 2I7 7BJ360234/ 45 2I7 J76349 45 6797HJ234/ NI7/ 0>>4N79 0N? 2I7 J=61I0876 02 2I7 0=1234/ 80>7 46 >082 6797HJ234/76? 35 0/:? 8I0>> 79 24 2I7 J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64J762: =/>788 0 2I369 J062: 38 012=0>>: I4>93/C 2I7 80H7 09M7687>: 24 2I7 D=9CH7/2 43C46G #I7 8039 J=61I0876 46 >082 6797HJ234/76 H0: 871=67 0 N632 45 J48878834/? =J4/ H4234/? 564H 2I7 14=62 NI31I 4697679 2I7 54671>48=67G i=78234/8;

1.bI02 38 7E=32: 45 6797HJ234/f `2I7 63CI2 45 9757/90/2 24 7B23/C=38I 2I7 H462C0C7 0/9 67203/ 4N/768I3J 3/ 2I7 J64J762: 48=67 80>7 0234/ 24 0 GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 9

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

H462C0C7 38 63CI2 C60/279 24 2I7 97 16793246 46 D=9CH7/2 9737/ 4/ 2I7 J64J762: 8=9 24 67977H 2I7 J64J762: N32I3/ 0 J76349 45 4/7 :706 564H 2I7 67C38260234/ 45 2I7 %I76355h8 17623A31027 45 54671>48=67 80>7? 0/9 8=1I 6797HJ234/ 38 C4M76/79 7 LVa

3.Z8 2I767 0 63CI2 45 6797HJ234/ 3/ D=93130> 54671>48=67 45 0 H462C0C7f `/4G =/>788 2I7 H462C0C77 38 0 48=67 35 H462C0C77 38 2I7 Y%Z%f `Y( /4 48=67 80>7f `/4G 6797HJ234/ 38 0/ 3HJ>379 09H38834/ 45 2I7 67C=>0632: 45 2I7 80>7 0/9 7824J8 2I7 J723234/76 564H >0276 4/ 3HJ=C/3/C 328 M0>3932:a 7.*478 2I7 A3>3/C 45 0/ 01234/ 546 0//=>H7/2 45 H462C0C7 24>> 2I7 J76349 45 6797HJ234/G !" 8.Z5 2I7 H462C0C46 3/83828 4/ 2I7 /=>>32: 45 H462C0C7? 10/ I7 60387 2I7 63CI2 24 67977H 546 2I7 R82  23H7 4/ 0JJ70>f !" 9.bI4 H0: 7B761387 63CI2 45 6797HJ234/f `35 4/7 I08 J63M32: 3/ 2I7 232>7 N32I 2I7 H462C0C46? 0/9 I7 I08 8=1I 0/ 3/276782 2I02 I7 N4=>9 4876 48=67? I7 H0: 67977HGa 10.bI02 38 2I7 0H4=/2 24 7 PUf `D=9CH7/2 977 =/976 6=>7 LVf O=61I0876h8 J6317 12.(7 /4G RRG (797HJ234/ 45 J64J762378 H462C0C79 N32I O!@ 0/9 *@O 0/9 54671>4879 732I76 D=93130>>: 46 7B260D=93130>>: 067 C4M76/79 >0N8 NI31I J64M3979 546 2I7 J0:H7/2 45 0>> 0H4=/28 4N79 7/93/C 3/8232=234/8 01234/a 13.*478 503>=67 24 C3M7 /42317 45 H4234/ 055712 2I7 M0>3932: 45 2I7 54671>48=67 80>7f `/4? H4234/ 38 /42 45 0 >323C07 /02=67G "6976 H0:7 45 J64J762: 4/ 7B71=234/ 8I0>> 06 /4G U? H0: RQ? RVUTa

15.*478 2I7 J=61I0876 0>6709: I0M7 0 63CI2 24 2I7 J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64J762: 54671>4879f `/4? 232>7 24 2I7 H462C0C79 J64J762: 9478 /42 M782 3/ 2I7 J=61I0876 =/23> 05276 2I7 14/A36H0234/ 45 80>7a 16.Z8 2I767 0 63CI2 45 6797HJ234/ 05276 2I7 D=93130> 80>7 38 14/A36H79f `/4? 2I767 38 /4 63CI2 45 6797HJ234/ 05276 D=93130> 80>7 38 14/A36H79 m? 232>7 M7828 =J4/ 2I7 J=61I0876 3/ 54671>48=67 80>7 0/9 2I7 14/A36H0234/ 672640128 24 2I7 9027 45 2I7 80>7G 17.Z8 0/ 46976 45 14/A36H0234/ 3/ 14=62 54671>48=67 J6417793/C8 0/ 3/276>41=246: 46976f `/4G 32 38 2I7 A3/0> 46976 564H NI31I 0JJ70> H0: 54671>48=67 J6417793/C8a 18.*478 2I7 J=61I0876 I0M7 2I7 63CI2 24 2I7 388=0/17 45 N632 45 J48878834/f `:78? 2I7 14=62 I08 2I7 J4N76 24 C3M7 J48878834/ 24 2I7 J=61I0876? 0/9 2I7 J=61I0876 N3>> /42 0N 24 448=67 J6417793/C8 0/ 7B71=234/ 45 D=9CH7/2f `/4G H767>: H3/3827630> 0/9 14HJ>3H7/206: 9=2: 45 2I7 14=62 24 J=2 0/ 7/9 24 >323C0234/a 20.#I7 D=9CH7/2 38 0>6709: A3/0> 0/9 7B71=246:G #I7 J64J762378 H462C0C79 I0M7 9 41=246: 9=2: 0/9 24 H0W7 2I7 =>23H027 J=61I0876 3/ 2I7 J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64Ja 21.$557128 45 14/A36H0234/ 45 80>7 Ti t l e to the mortgaged real property does not vest in the purchaser until after confirmation of the sale. Prior to conf irm ati on, purchaser has no right to possession of pr op er ty. Purchaser has no legal cause of complaint against the defendants who r e m ai n in p o s s e s s i o n exercising the rights of ownership.

Mortgagors have no means of compelling the purchaser to comply with the terms of the sale until after confirmation. If mortgagor attempt to compel a purchaser to pay, an a ns w e r by purchaser that the sale had not been confirmed would be sufficient.

22.*355767/17 45 N632 45 J48878834/ 564H D=9CH7/2 45 54671>48=67 GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 10

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

Ju dg me nt of foreclosure: 1.L o s e s executory force by the lapse of 5yrs. 2.Under the Gen Banking Act, there is a right of redemption within one year from sale. 3.J u d i c i a l foreclosure must be confirmed in a hearing with notice to the mort gage e, debtor, creditor, purchaser at auction sale. 4.P r i o r to confirmation of auction sale, court may grant debtor sufficient time to redeem mortgage estate even if bidder sold property to a third person.

Writ of possession: 1.A f t e r t h e property is sold pursuant to  ju  j u d g m e n t a n d confirmed by the court, purchaser is entitled to writ of possession.

23.bI7/ H0: 0 N632 45 J48878834/ 388=7 3/ 54671>48=67f `NI7/ 80>7 38 M0>39>: 14/A36H79G _/23> 2I7 80>7 38 M0>39>: 14/A36H79? 2I7 J=61I0876 38 /42I3/C H467 2I0/ 0 J67576679 7f `J=61I0876 I0M7 0 63CI2 24 J48878834/ 45 J64J762: 7M7/ 9=63/C 2I7 4/7 :706 6797HJ234/ J76349 J64M3979 I7 A3>78 3/97H/32: 7G #I7 0H4=/2 670>3[79 564H 2I7 54671>48=67 80>7 45 2I7 H462C0C79 J64J762: 8I0>>? 05276 979=123/C 2I7 14828 45 2I7 80>7? 483/C 2I7 H462C0C7? 0/9 NI7/ 2I767 8I0>> 7f `/4G 2I7 M34>0234/ 83HJ>: C3M78 2I7 H462C0C46 0 10=87 45 01234/ 24 6714M76 8=6J>=8a 2.Z/ 8=3/C 546 2I7 672=6/ 45 8=6J>=8 J6417798? 38 2I7 H462C0C46 977H79 24 I0M7 05A36H79 2I7 M0>3932: 45 2I7 80>7f `:78? 83/17 /42I3/C 38 9=7 35 /4 M0>39 80>7 I08 7 24 J641779 3/ 1087 2I7 97> 9=7G Z5 2I7 97> 9=7 08 J64M3979 3/ 2I7 D=9CH7/2? 08 844/ 08 0 8=5A3137/2 J46234/ 45 2I7 J64J762: I08 9 24 J0: 2I7 2420> 0H4=/2 0/9 2I7 14828 9=7? 2I7 80>7 8I0>> 276H3/027^ 0/9 05276N0698? 08 4527/ 08 H467 46 3/276782 0/9 42I76 M0>39 1I06C78? 2I7 14=62 H0:? 4/ H4234/? 46976 H467 24 9G @=2 35 2I7 J64J762: 10//42 9 3/ J46234/8 N32I4=2 J67D=9317 24 2I7 J062378? 2I7 NI4>7 8I0>> 7 7? 2I7 14=62? =J4/ H4234/? 8I0>> 67/976 D=9CH7/2 0C03/82 2I7 9757/90/2 546 0/: 8=1I 0/17 546 NI31I? : >307 24 2I7 J>03/2355? =J4/ NI31I 7B71=234/ H0: 388=7 3HH793027>: 35 2I7 0/17 38 0>> 9=7 02 2I7 23H7 45 2I7 67/93234/ 45 2I7 D=9CH7/2^ 42I76N387? 2I7 J>03/2355 8I0>> 79 24 7B71=234/ 02 8=1I 23H7 08 2I7 0/17 67H03/3/C 14/26012? NI31I 23H7 8I0>> 7 0/9 05276 32 7 8I0>> 7 3/ 2I7 /0H7 45 2I7 H462C0C46 8I0>> GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 11

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

>79? 0/9 0 /7N 4/7 388=79 3/ 2I7 /0H7 45 2I7 J=61I0876G

2I7 J=61I0876 05276 2I7 4N/76h8 9=J>31027 45 17623A31027 I08 : 97>3M7679 0/9 10/17>>79G i=78234/8;

bI767 0 63CI2 45 6797HJ234/ 7B3828? 2I7 17623A31027 45 232>7 3/ 2I7 /0H7 45 2I7 H462C0C46 8I0>> /42 >79? 7 0/9 2I7 46976 14/A36H3/C 2I7 80>7 8I0>> 9779 45 80>7 7B71=279 48=67 80>7 8I0>> 7 3/ 2I7 /0H7 45 2I7 H462C0C46 H462C0C46 8I0>> >79 0/9 0 /7N 4/7 388=79 3/ 2I7 /0H7 45 2I7 J=61I0876G O* !"G RQSV `O("O$(#\ ($YZ%#(+#Z"! *$.($$a %71G PLG '4671>48=67 45 H462C0C7F `0a 35 2I7 J64J762: N08 54671>4879 D=93130>>:? 0 17623A379 14J: 45 2I7 A3/0> 46976 45 2I7 14=62 14/A36H3/C 2I7 80>7 8I0>> 7 45 H462C0C46 8I0>> >79? /7N 17623A31027 38 388=79 3/ 2I7 /0H7 45 J=61I0876G bI767 63CI2 45 6797HJ234/ 7B3828? 2I7 17623A31027 45 232>7 45 2I7 H462C0C46 8I0>> /42 >79 7 0/9 46976 14/A36H3/C 2I7 80>7 8I0>> 7 8I0>> 7 3/ 2I7 /0H7 45 2I7 H462C0C46 H462C0C46 8I0>> >79 0/9 0 /7N 4/7 388=79 3/ 2I7 /0H7 45 2I7 J=61I0876G `4879 =X6C2WD>3I32> 79 N32I 2I7 67C382606 45 97798 NI4 8I0>> H0W7 0 7G %714/9 J060C60JI 0JJ>378 3/ 2I7 7M7/2 45 6797HJ234/ 48=67 80>7 8I0>> A3>7 N32I 2I7 67C382606 45 97798? 732I76 0 A3/0> 9779 45 80>7 7B71=279 7 3/ 50M46 45 JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

1..0/ 2I7 14=62 823>> C60/2 2I7 D=9CH7/2 977 45 H462C0C79 J64J762: 0/9 8I76355h8 80>7 38 14/A36H79? D=9CH7/2 97 80>7f `/4G 232>7 38 M78279 =J4/ 2I7 J=61I0876 3/ 2I7 54671>48=67 80>7G .4/A36H0234/ 672640128 24 2I7 9027 45 80W7G (3CI2 45 2I7 H462C0C46 0/9 J7684/ I4>93/C =/976 I3H 067 1=2 455 7 =J4/ 14/A36H0234/? 0/9 N32I 2I7H 2I7 7E=32: 45 6797HJ234/a 3.Z/ D=93130> 54671>48=67 =/976 Y7/760> 7G + D=93130> 54671>48=67 H=82 93/C 0 1>03H 0C03/82 2I7 782027 871=679 >02760> 871=632:f `003H 3/ 2I7 J64 93826348=67 I38 H462C0C7 0/9 67>: 4/ I38 871=632: 7? A3>7 0 1>03H 3/ 2I7 3/ 2I7 782027 546 8=1I 97A3137/1: =/976 871G Q 45 6=>7 QP^ 46 67>: =J4/ I38 H462C0C7 0/9 54671>487 2I7 80H7 02 0/:23H7 N32I3/ 2I7 8202=27 45 >3H320234/8G 5.*478 2I7 H462C0C7 16793246 3/ 54671>48=67 I0M7 2I7 80H7 820/93/C 0/9 7/D4: 2I7 80H7 63CI28 08 2I7 H462C0C7 16793246 3/ 09H3/38260234/ J6417793/C8f `\$%a 6..0/ 2I767 48=67 05276 971>060234/ 45 3/84>M7/1: 0/9 2I7 3/84>M7/1: 14=62 I08 01E=3679 14/264> 45 I38 782027f `!4G =/>788 2I7 3/84>M7/2 14=62 C3M78 14/87/2a 7.bI02 38 2I7 755712 =J4/ 2I7 971>060234/ 45 /=>>32: 45 24667/8 232>7 NI767 2I7 J64J762: 2I7674/ N08 C3M7/ 08 871=632: 24 0 40/f `9478 /42 0=2I463[7 2I7 10/17>>0234/ 45 2I7 H462C0C7 63CI2 45 2I7 2 3/ J0:H7/2 45 0/: 3/820>>0234/ 45 0 97>H7/28 N32I4=2 N0323/C 546 2I7 H02=632: 45 2I7 NI4>7 9748=67 8=32f `J7684/8 43C0279 24 J0: H462C0C7 97 2I7 H462C0C79 J67H3878 46 D=/346 7/1=H03H3/C 63CI2 46 3/276782 3/ 2I7 J64J762: 8=9 =979 24 802385: 2I7 97A3137/1: D=9CH7/2a 10.bI02 38 2I7 755712 45 503>=67 24 3HJ>709 8714/9 H462C0C77f `54671>48=67 3/7557123M7 0C03/82 I3H? 0 8=37/ I4>976? N32I 2I7 678=>2 2I02 2I767 67H03/8 0/ =/54671>4879 7E=32: 45 6797HJ234/Ga 11.bI02 38 2I7 67H79: 3/ 2I7 J671793/C E=78234/f ` 67E=367 2I7 8714/9 H462C0C77 24 67977H 2I7 R 82  H462C0C7 N32I3/ L H4/2I8 =/976 J7/0>2: 45 48=67 8=32f `09M7687 1>03H0/28 0887623/C 232>7 0/20C4/38231 24 2I7 H462C0C46 067 /732I76 /7178806: 46 J64J76 J062378? =/>788 2I7: 067 0887623/C 63CI28 46 3/276782 01E=3679 48=67 45 1I0227> H462C0C7f `:78G +119/C 24 D=82317 57660 2I7 6=>7 38 /4N >3H3279 24 D=93130> 54671>48=67 45 1I0227> H462C0C7 38 97>7279 564H 2I7 J6787/2 6=>7? 32 H0: 379 24 D=93130> 54671>48=67 45 1I0227> H462C0C7 8= H462C0C7 >0Na 15.*478 2I7 6=>7 J671>=97 2I7 7B260D=93130> 54671>48=67 =/976 871G RK 012 RQXUf !" 16.bI02 38 2I7 67H79: 35 2I7 J64J762: 38 3/ 2I7 H462C0C46h8 J48878834/f (7J>7M3/ 17..0/ 80>7 45 J64J762: 0234/Ga %71G UG +JJ>31032: 45 42I76 J64M3834/8G #I7 J64M3834/8 45 871234/8 LR? LS 0/9 LK 45 (=>7 LV 8I0>> 3107 24 2I7 D=93130> 54671>48=67 45 670> 782027 H462C0C78 =/976 2I38 (=>7 3/84506 08 2I7 546H76 067 /42 3/14/83827/2 N32I 46 H0: 876M7 24 8=JJ>7H7/2 2I7 J64M3834/8 45 2I7 >02276G

R)+B&"# *a+Q-" %) @a+&k"# J%)#B+B" *a+Q-" ,@+) V_/V0 JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

1.+ J64M3834/ 3/ 2I7 H462C0C7 14/26012 3/ NI31I 2I7 H462C0C7 38 0 871=632: 546 J082? J6787/2 0/9 5=2=67 3/970=87 463C3/0279 564H +H76310/ D=638J6=97/17G 2.e0>39 0/9 >7C0> 14/260128G 3."J760278 08 0 14/M7/37/17 0/9 0114HH490234/ 24 2I7 07 0993234/0> 5=/98 N32I4=2 2I736 I0M3/C 24 7B71=27 0993234/0> 871=632: 941=H7/28? 2I38 80M3/C 23H7G #60M7> >40/ 1>483/C 14828? 1482 45 7B260 >7C0> 876M3178? 721G 4.bI3>7 ($) H0: 7B17J234/0>>: 871=67 5=2=67 >40/8 46 09M0/17H7/28? 2I787 5=2=67 9732: 45 2I7 46976 45 14/A36H0234/ 46 =J4/ 2I7 7BJ360234/ 45 2I7 J76349 45 6797HJ234/ NI7/ 0>>4N79 0N? 2I7 J=61I0876 02 2I7 0=1234/ 80>7 46 >082 6797HJ234/76? 35 0/:? 8I0>> 79 24 2I7 J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64J762: =/>788 0 2I369 J062: 38 012=0>>: I4>93/C 2I7 80H7 09M7687>: 24 2I7 D=9CH7/2 43C46G #I7 8039 J=61I0876 46 >082 6797HJ234/76 H0: 871=67 0 N632 45 J48878834/? =J4/ H4234/? 564H 2I7 14=62 NI31I 4697679 2I7 54671>48=67G PD>1:=46 94 A9C=I2M5 69 ?2M0 %71G SF SF Z5 =J4/ 2I7 2630> 3/ 8=1I 01234/ 2I7 14=62 8I0>> A3/9 2I7 50128 872 5462I 3/ 2I7 14HJ>03/2 24 > 08176203/ 2I7 0H4=/2 9=7 24 2I7 J>03/2355 =J4/ 2I7 H462C0C7 97=93/C 3/276782 0/9 42I76 1I06C78 08 0JJ64M79 > 67/976 D=9CH7/2 546 2I7 8=H 84 54=/9 9=7 0/9 46976 2I02 2I7 80H7 788 2I0/ /3/72: `VXa 90:8 /46 H467 2I0/ 4/7 I=/9679 2N7/2: `RSXa 90:8 564H 2I7 7/26: 45 D=9CH7/2? 0/9 2I02 3/ 9750=>2 45 8=1I J0:H7/2 2I7 J64J762: 8I0>> 9 02 J=31 0=1234/ 24 802385: 2I7 D=9CH7/2 JD3I32< (9C=IM7 2I7 14F4N/768I3J 546 I3H 24 C72 I38 4N/ 8I067 3/ 2I7 14F4N/79 J64J762:G '46 2I7 14F4N/76 24 C72 I38 46 I76 8I067? I7 46 8I7 H=82 A3>7 0 14HJ>03/2 546 J0623234/G *9:?: 35 2I7 14F4N/768 10//42 0C677 4/ I4N 24 J0623234/ 8I4=>9 2I7: C4 24 14=62G U97 I9::=4I=>mG8=C= 69 (3 !C9I==>3415 O0623234/ 38 14HH7/179 3/C 45 0 M763A379 14HJ>03/2 3/ 2I7 (#. 45 2I7 J>017 NI767 2I7 670> J64J762: J64J762: 38 >410279G #I7 4/7 NI4 A3>79 `2I7 14F4N/76a H=82 3HJ>709 0>> 2I7 42I76 14F 4N/768 83/17 2I7: 067 0>> 14/8397679 08 3/938J7/807 J062378G Z5 7M7/ 4/7 14F4N/76 38 /42 3HJ>70979? 8=1I 38 5020> 24 2I7 14HJ>03/2 83/17 32 38 0 C64=/9 24 938H388 2I7 1087 546 503>=67 24 3HJ>709 0>> 3/938J7/807 J062378G "/17 A3>79? 2I7 8=HH4/8 N3>> 7 +/8N768G +5276 2I7 >02276? 2I7 14=62 N3>> 14/9=12 I7063/C 24 97276H3/7 NI72I76 46 /42 2I7 J>03/2355 I08 0 M0>39 10=87 45 01234/; 35 2I7 J>03/2355 38 0 14F4N/76 46 /42G Z5 2I7 14=62 38 14/M3/179 45 2I7 J>03/2355h8 63CI2 08 0 14F4N/76? 2I7 14=62 N3>> 67/976 D=9CH7/2 NI31I N3>> > C3M7 2I7 J062378 0 1I0/17 24 J0623234/ 32 2I7H87>M78 `0 8714/9 1I0/17 08397 564H 2I7 7B260D=93130> J0623234/aG Z5 2I7 14F4N/768 10/ 0C677 08 24 I4N 2I7 J0623234/ 38 H097? 2I736 0C677H7/2 8I0>> > 0JJ43/2 14HH38834/768G 14HH38834/768G  +??9346:=46 9A 9A *9::355394=C5 *9::355394=C5 #I7 14=62 8I0>> 0JJ43/2 /42 H467 2I0/ L 14HH38834/768 35 2I7 14F 4N/768 10//42 0C677 08 24 2I7 H0//76 45 2I7 J0623234/G #I7 14HH38834/768 N3>> > 94 2I7 012=0> J0623234/ 45 2I7 J64J762:G +8 4JJ4879 24 (=>7 LS NI7673/ 0JJ43/2H7/2 45 14HH38834/768 38 938167234/06: =J4/ 2I7 14=62? 3/ J0623234/ 0/9 7BJ64J630234/ 2I7 0JJ43/2H7/2 38 /42 0 H02276 45 938167234/ D63=5 9A I9::355394=C5 )=82 20W7 2I736 402I > 14/9=12 0 I7063/C 24 I706 2I7 9757/90/28 24 97276H3/7 I4N 2I7 J64J762: 38 24 46 3HJ48837 24 J0623234/? 2I7 14HH38834/768 8I0>> 08W NI4 0H4/C82 2I7 14F4N/768 38 N3>>3/C 24 > 67/976 0 D=9CH7/2 45 J0623234/ NI31I 8I0>> 06 %4 3/ 2I7 J0623234/ 45 2I7 J64J762:? 2I7 H7278 0/9 : 978163 7 3/24 87M760> 232>78a 0/9 2I7 (* N3>> 388=7 /7N 232>78 978163J234/ 45 2I7 J64J762: 09D=9310279 24 701I 45 2I7 14F4N/768G %4 2I7 D=9CH7/2 4/ J0623234/? H=82 82027 8J713A310>>: 2I7 H7278 0/9 5 9A ?955=559CM 2I63945 9A C=2< ?C9?=C6MN +/8; 0G  +.0 +1134/ Z/27693120> n `$D712H7/2a F 2I7 4/>: 388=7 38 H027630> 46 JI:8310> J48878834/^ 7M7/ 35 388=7 4/ 4N/768I3J 38 603879? =/976 2I7 /7N 6=>78? 2I7 )#. 10/ 0>6709: J08879 =J4/ 2I7 388=7 4/ 4N/768I3J : 546 J=6J4878 45 97276H3/3/C J48878834/

F 2I7 97276H3/0234/ 45 4N/768I3J >: 6784>M7 2I7 388=7 45 NI4 38 670>>: 2I7 4N/76^ 9478 /42 670>>: 971>067 4/7 08 2I7 4N/76G F 2I7 97276H3/0234/ 45 4N/768I3J 38 4/>: 546 J=6J4878 45 0393/C 2I7 14=62 3/ 97276H3/3/C 2I7 388=7 45 J48878834/G  @.0 +1134/ O=3130/0 n 6714M76: 45 2I7 670> 63CI2 45 J48878834/ 0/9 38 0 J>7/06: 01234/ 3/ 0/ 4693/06: 13M3> J6417793/C 3/ 2I7 (#. *.0 +1134/ (73M3/931024630 n 877W8 2I7 6714M76: 4N/768I3J c J48878834/ ` D=8 =27/93 0/9 D=8 56=7/93a 2I38 38 0>84 =C 68= =XI3I6394 9A 68= J#*5 D4>=C )+ dS^/N !427; (+ TPVR 7BJ0/98 2I7 D=638931234/ 45 2I7 )#. NI31I 067 /4N M78279 N32I 7B1>=83M7 463C3/0> D=638931234/ 4M76 42I76 670> 01234/8 NI767 2I7 08878879 M0>=7 9478 /42 7B1779 O SX?XXX 0/9 O QX?XXX 3/ )7264 )0/3>0G +/8; +1134/ O=3130/0 0/9 +1134/ (73/M3/931024630 NI767 2I7 08878879 M0>=7 45 2I7 J64J762: *"$% !"# 7B1779 2I7 H7/234/79 0H4=/28G LG .0/ 6714M76: 45 J48878834/ ] 4N/768I3J 45 J=31 >0/9 79 N32I 2I7 67C=>06 14=628 NI3>7 0 80>78 0JJ>310234/ 546 8039 J0617> 38 J7/93/C 09D=9310234/ 06 14=628 067 /42 93M78279 45 2I736 D=638931234/ 4M76 J48878846: 01234/8 3/8232=279 310/28 24 J642712 2I736 J48878834/G KG bI4 H0: A3>7 01234/f +/8; 0G Z/ '46137 7/26: F 2I7 J7684/ 97J63M79 45 J48878834/ 2I 0N5=> 97203/76 F 0/9>469? M7/946 46 M7/977 46 42I76 J7684/ 0C03/82 NI4H J48878834/ 45 >0/9 46 93/C 38 =/>0N5=>>: N32II7>9 ? >7C0> 67J6787/2023M7 46 0883C/77 45 0/: >0/9>469 ? M7/946 46 M7/977 46 42I76 J7684/G #!; 0 J=61I0876 NI4 I08 14/84>390279 232>7 H0: A3>7 0/ 7D712H7/2 1087 46 b632 45 J48878834/ 7M7/ 35 2I767 38 0 J7/93/C 01234/ 546 0//=>H7/2 45 H462C0C7 46 54671>48=67G QG *3823/C=38I ? @=2 >0276 4/? 2I7 J48878834/ 45 2I7 9757/90/2 0N5=> n>3W7 NI7/ 2I7 14/26012 45 >7087 I08 0>6709: 7BJ3679G bI7/ 2I7 14/26012 45 >7087 I08 0>6709: 7BJ3679? 2I7 4N/76 45 2I7 J64J762:? 2I7 >78846? I08 2I7 63CI2 24 6714M76 2I7 J64J762:G Z5 2I7 9757/90/2 N3>> C=AD5= 69 C=6DC4 ?955=55394 9A 68= ?C9?=C6M? ?C9?=C6M ? 2I7/ 2I02 38 NI7/ 2I7 01234/ 546 _/>0N5=> *7203/76 N3>> >37G : A3>7 2I7 1087 546 546137 7/26: N32I4=2 H0W3/C 97H0/9 QRK 97H0/9 QRK 97H0/9 38 D=638931234/0> ? 83/17 J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64J762: 0N5=> 02 A3682 32 4/>: GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 16

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

0N5=> >0276

=:?6394 9C ?C39C ?DCI825= 9A ?C=:35=5N

#!; 97H0/9 H=82 0/9 24 M01027 24 0: 938J483234/ 45 2I7 7D712H7/2 J6417793/CG

1G O6346 OI:8310> J48878834/ 45 2I7 J67H3878 ("K =/>0N5=> ("K =/>0N5=> 564H 2I7 M76: 0N5=> 02 2I7 564H 2I7 7BJ360234/ 45 >7087 9G "/7 \706 J76349 564H 9027 46 012=0> 7/26: ] >082 97H0/9 ("K n A3>7 2I7 1087 N32I3/ R :706 564H 938J48878834/ 46 n  R :706 564H W/4N>79C7 45 938J48878834/ ` 35 2I 46 826027C: a QRK R :706 N3>> 82062 564H /42317 24 M01027 !"#$; Z5 4/7 :706 J76349 I08 0>6709: 7BJ3679 564H 2I7 23H7 :4= N767 938J48878879 46 564H 2I7 23H7 :4= 97H0/979 24 M01027? 2I7/ 2I7 01234/ :4= N3>> A3>7 8I0>> J64J762: 46 0/: 3/276782 2I7673/? 03H ? 7/1=H: M0>39 46 7557123M7 39? 3/7557123M7? M43907 46 =/7/5461707 0/9 H0: 24 839 232>7? 0/ 01234/ H0: 7G ` +62G KTP !..a H. bI7/ 2I7 14/26012 ? 3/826=H7/2 46 42I76 43C0234/ I08 03/2355 H=82 I0M7 >7C0> 46 d. U97 35 WDC35>3I6394 >=6=C:34=>N G9D 255=C6394 9A 974=C583? HM >=A=4>246 9C 6=424IM C=3I6394N ,490  +45E g=638931234/ 38 97276H3/79 03/2 ? 0/9 H767 08876234/ 45 4N/768I3J 0234/8I3J 9478 /42 4=82 2I7 14=62 45 328 D=638931234/G ]. -89D 68= D4=6234=C 5D365 H= 2H26=> HM 68= 2I63945 ;3 34 68= )#* HM ?=636394=C5 341 6826 68=M 2C= =4636 69 2 C3186 9A ?C=K JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

R9=5 24 34WD4I6394 5D36 34 68= )#* 345636D6=> HM >=A=4>246 34 =W=I6:=46 2Y26 68= *" !"# 002276^ 0/9 /732I76 94 J6417793/C8 4/ 14/83C/0234/ 45 67/20>8G /_. *24496 2H26= =W=I6:=46 2I63945 E FO6417793/C8 14/83C/0234/ F01134/ J=3130/0 9478 /42 8=8J7/9 0/ 7D712H7/2 8=32 0C03/82 J>03/2355 3/ 2I7 546H76 ` (0H367[ M8 @>7[0a Fb632 45 J48878834/ 1087 F+1234/ 546 E=3723/C 45 232>7 F %=328 546 8J713A31 J76546H0/17 24 14HJ7> 67/7N0> 45 >7087 N32I 90H0C78 F+1234/ 546 67546H0234/ 45 3/826=H7/2 564H 0 9779 45 0=27 80>7 24 4/7 45 80>7 N32I J0124 97 67264 F+1234/ 546 6714/M7:0/17 46 01134/ 673/93M3102463 F%=328 546 0//=>H7/2 45 80>7? 46 232>7 46 941=H7/2 0557123/C J64J762: 24 4J76027 //. )=2594 ,A9C 4D: ^ 0  +45E #I7 =/976>:3/C 67084/8 546 2I7 03/C8 N767 2I02 2I7 01234/8 3/ 2I7 (#. 939 /42 3/M4>M7 JI:8310> 46 97 50124 J48878834/ 0/9 4/ /42 0 57N 41108834/8? 2I02 2I7 1087 3/ 2I7 (#. N08 H767>: 0 J>4: 24 97>0: 938J483234/ 45 2I7 7D712H7/2 J6417793/C ? 46 2I02 2I7 388=78 J6787/279 3/ 2I7 546H76 14=>9 E=327 08 7083>: M79G /V. $5 68= 69 HC341 ;3C56 24 2I6394 A9C C=5I355394 N ,"56=C4 -83??341 a34=5 Y *20 +/8; !4? NI7/ 2I7 67>0234/8I3J 78846 0/9 >78877 38 782038I79 3/ 0/ =/>0N5=> 97203/76 1087? 0/: 0227HJ2 24 3/D712 2I7 E=78234/ 45 4N/768I3J 3/24 2I7 1087 38 5=23>7 ? 7B17J2 08 H3CI2 2I64N >3CI2 4/ 2I7 63CI2 45 J48878834/G /[. *24 68= J#* C=59>7C0> ? 2I767 0N J6481630234/ 24 7B260D=93130>>: 67813/9 14/20612 0/9 6714M76 J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64762: 3/ 1087 45 0234/ 7HJ4N768 2I7 >78846 24 67J488788 2I7 0J062H7/2 7B260D=93130>>:G .G .>0635:3/C 2I7 6=>7 F %1 82678879 2I02 2I7 0JJ>310234/ 45 2I7 J64M3834/ 38 >3H3279 24 832=0234/8 NI767 2I7 276H 45 2I7 >7087 I08 7BJ3679 0/9 2I7 >4C31 3/ 0>>4N3/C 2I7 >78846 24 938J488788 2I7 27/0/2 NI4 I08 J09>41W79 2I7 J67H3878 24 J67M7/2 67F7/26: 7087 .+!!"# @$ +%%+Z,$*G [_. R. )=59C6 69 I9DC65 :2M H= 4=I=552CM 78=4 68= C3186 34Y9 J48878834/ 45 0 >0/9 46 93/C I08 QR :=24N +/8; !42I3/C H467 2I0/ JI:8310> J48878834/ ? !"# ,$Y+, J48878834/ 14/27HJ>0279 3/ 13M3> >0N^ H=82 >3W7N387 8I4N J634632: 3/ 23H7G $4 I25= 9A p56=2 69 H= I9D46=>N  +45E A 46H 46H 2I7 23H7 2I7 J>03/2355 >706/79 2I76745 G826 35 56=2: 46 1>0/97823/7 012 24 0M439 93814M76: 0/9 24 C03/ 7/260/17 3/24 46 67H03/ N32I3/ 678397/17 45 0/42I76 N32I4=2 J76H38834/G O>03/2355 H=82 782038I NI7/ 0/9 I4N 2I7 0>>7C79 7/26: N08 H097 4/ 2I7 J46234/ 45 2I736 >42 24 J64M7 2I02 9757/90/28 7/16401I79 =J4/ 2I736 J64J762: 2I64=CI 8270>2IG G826 35 68= M 78=C= 2>9H= 72 9Y=C8241 734>97 1C3M78 J48878834/ 4M76 2I7 670> J64J762: Fb08 2I7 J48878846 4=8279 564H N32I3/ 4/7 :706 546H 2I7 A3>3/C 45 2I7 14HJ>03/2 2I ?2I6702 ? F*478 J>03/2355 08W 546 2I7 6782460234/ 45 I38 J48878834/ G826 35 68= ?C9?=C C=:=>M 2123456 2 ?=C594 789 9IID?3=5 68= 9A 24968=C 26 68= M01027 =J4/ 97H0/9G G25 68=C= 69 C=462 >2:21=5 .q +A6=C 2=I246 H= 9C>=C=> 69 Y2I26= Z ?2M H2I\ C=462 3CC3126394 A==5 24> :9C2< 24> =X=:?2:21=5 24> =C 68= J#* WDC35>3I3694N  +45E !4? 1087 939 /42 14/176/ H767>: 2I7 388=7 45 J48878834/ 7087 14/2601279 0234/8I3J 14/2601279 3M76 J67H3878 ? J0: =/J039 67/20>8 ? 90H0C78 0/9 3/1397/20> 5778G

G826 2C= 68= LD=563945 69 H= C=59 34 24 2I6394 A9C ("N JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 19

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

G826 35 68= I25= 69 ;3N

-!" $%& '()&*+,& !- './0

-!- 31'3&1 $' *'83&/ /&--'1

1&-$'12+'. 1&-$'12+'. '" 3'--&--!'. &,&. !" $%&1& !- 2.'$%&1 *2-&

$' 3&1"'18 321$ '" *'.$12*$ $' 82!.$2!. /&--&& !.

"'1 1&-2/& '" 31'3&1$0 '" 4&"&.42.$

3&2*&"9/ &.)'08&.$ '" $%& /&2-& "'1 $%& 4912+'. '"

$A 2A6=C 68= >=A=4>246 ;3 835 2457=C 34 24 2I6394 A9C QR Z 8= Y2I26=5 68= ?C9?=C6M 24> 35 49 9=5 68= I25= C=:234 69 24 QR 24> 496 A9C I9 :2>= HM 68= : =J4/ 27/0/2 `H0: a 03/2 M=>/7607 24 938H3880> 4/ 2I7 C64=/9 45 >01W 45 10=87 45 01234/ 46 J67H02=632:G [. U97 582 I9D46=> AC9: =:24> 69 H= 346=C?C=6=>N  +45E .0/ 0116=7 NI7/ 2I7 8714/9 97H0/9 546 67/28 0/9 546 8=667/976 45 J48878834/ N08 /42 14HJ>379 N32IG #I767 38 2I7 088=HJ234/ 2I02 05276 2I7 A3682 97H0/9? 2I7 >78846 `I08 2I7 J63M3>7C7 24 a N03M7 `9a 2I7 63CI2 24 >4N79 >78877 24 14/23/=7 3/ I38 411=J0234/ =/23> 2I7 8714/9 97H0/9 38 N03M79G

 +45E Z2 38 2I7 4N/76h8 97H0/9 546 2I7 27/0/2 546 2I7 27/0/2 24 M01027 2I7 J67H3878? NI7/ 2I7 27/0/2 I08 503>79 24 J0: 2I7 67/28 4/ 23H7 ? 0/9 2I7 27/0/2h8 675=80> 46 503>=67 24 M01027 ? NI31I H0W7 _/>0N5=> N32II4>93/C 45 J48878834/G ]. #8= 974=C 4963;3=> 68= 6=42465 69 ?2M C=46 24> A239 59Z 2 I25= 9A =W=I6:=46 79D H= ;3 2123456 68=: . R9=5 68= 4963I= :2\= 2 >=:24> D?94 68=: 69 Y2I26= 68= ?C=:35=5N  +45E bI7/ 2I7 >78846 97H0/979 J0:H7/2 45 2I7 9=7 0/9 =/J039 67/20>8 46 0 1087 45 7D712H7/2 N4=>9 79 0C03/82 2I7H ? 2I7 4N/76 N08 C3M3/C 8264/C /42317 2I02 o:4= 732I76 J0: :4=6 =/J039 67/20>8 46 Z N3>> A3>7 0 14=62 1087 24 I0M7 :4= 2I64N/ 4=2 45 H: J64J762:p ^. R9=5 2II=?624I= HM 68= : N32I 2I7 276H8 45 14/26012 0/9 24 672=6/ J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64J762:^ 27/0/2 503>79 24 802385: 97H0/9 N32I3/ RQFQ 90:8 a 3/1087 45 93/C8a 1G .4HJ>03/2 A3>79 N32I3/ 4/7 :706 564H 9027 45 97H0/9 S. R9=5 A2378 2I7 >78846 24 0279 3/ 2I38 J64M3834/ 38 /42 0 97H0/9 24 M01027 469 =J4/ I38 27/0/2 546 2I7 >02276 24 J0: 67/28 9=7 46 14HJ>: 14/93234/8 45 I38 >7087 N32I3/ RQFQ 90:8GGa d. G826 :2\=5 68= 736889341 9A ?955=55394 D4 69 Y2I26= 34 :9468K69 :9468 I946C2I6 K#I7 6=>7 38 0JJ>3107 4/>: NI767 2I767 38 0 >78846F >78877 67>0234/8I3J 0/9 NI767 2I7 C64=/98 67>379 =J4/ 546 7D712H7/2 067 /4/J0:H7/2 45 67/20>8 46 M34>0234/ 45 2I7 14/93234/8 45 2I7 >7087? 7087 69 Y2I26= 35 69 :2\= 6=C:3426394 =AA=I63Y= K Z2 N4=>9 877H 2I02 2I7 /42317 0/9 97H0/9 24 M01027 67E=3679 4/ 0 >7087 4/ 0 H4/2IF24FH4/2I J76349 38 24 67/976 7557123M7 2I7 276H3/0234/ 45 2I7 >7087 =J4/ 2I7 7BJ360234/ 45 2I7 H4/2I? 0/9 J67M7/2 0/ 3HJ>379 67/7N0> 45 2I7 >7087G F97H0/9 24 M01027 38 /42 67E=3679 NI7/ 2I7 01234/ 38 24 276H3/027 2I7 >7087 >: N32II4>93/C 2I7 J64J762:G /T. !97=C 69 =X6=4> 7087 I08 /42 78877 I08 411=J379 2I7 J67H3878 546 4M76 0 :706 /S. %68=C I25=5 /d. !DCI825=C 26 ?DH48=67 80>7? 2I7 J=61I0876 02 J=31 0=1234/ 38 7/232>79 24 J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64J762: G /]. &94K?2M:=46 9A C=462 A9C =W=I6:=46 =Y=4 3A I9:?5 7G +/: J64/4=/17H7/2 0557123/C 4N/76I83J 38 H767>: J64M3834/0> 0/9 9478 /42 J67D=9317 0/ 01234/ M3/C 232>7 24 2I7 >0/9G

 J29>3.=D0 X Z5 05276 2630> 2I7 14=62 A3/98 2I02 -"*. /d. J29>3.=D0 X 2I7 0>>7C0234/8 45 2I7 14HJ>03/2 067 26=7? 32 8I0>> 67/976 D=9CH7/2 3/ 50M46 45 2I7 J>03/2355 546 2I7 678232=234/ 45 2I7 J67H3878? 2I7 8=H D=82>: 9=7 08 0667068 45 67/2 46 08 67084/07 14HJ7/80234/ 14HJ7/80234/ 546 2I7 =87 0/9 411=J0234/ 45 2I7 J67H3878? 02246/7:q8 5778 0/9 14828G Z5 32 A3/98 2I02 8039 0>>7C0234/8 067 /42 26=7? 32 8I0>> 67/976 D=9CH7/2 546 2I7 9757/90/2 24 6714M76 I38 14828G Z5 0 14=/2761>03H 38 782038I79? 2I7 14=62 8I0>> 67/976 D=9CH7/2 546 2I7 8=H 54=/9 3/ 0667068 564H 732I76 J062: 0/9 0N069 14828 08 D=82317 67E=3678G `P0a

/. $5 2 I9D46=CI =X=:?2:21=5 ?=C:3553H: 90H0C7 2I02 H0: 0N5=> 97203/76 10878 38 2I7 5036 67/20> M0>=7 46 2I7 67084/07 14HJ7/80234/ 546 2I7 =87 0/9 411=J0234/ 45 2I7 >70879 J64J762:G + 90H0C7 42I76 2I0/ 67084/07 67/20>8 46 5036 67/20> JUSTICE YAP / DEAN MONTECLAR

V. *24 26=> >2:21=5 A9C HC=2I8 9A I946C2I6 9A 1=:=46 H34>341N  +45E   +45E  #678J088768? 8E=022768 46 0C7/28 45 9757/90/2? C=7828 46 42I76 411=J0/28 45 2I7 J67H3878 N32I J76H38834/ 45 9757/90/2 ^ 260/857677 J7/97/27 >327^ 8=70878^ 8=70878 ^ H7H: ?67>023M78 0/9 42I76 J63M378 45 9757/90/28 V. !97=C 9A 68= I9DC6 34 =W=I6:=46 I25=5 69 >=I3>= 355D= 9A HD3=C 34 199> A2368. F 08 0/ 3/1397/2 24 2I7 H03/ 388=7 45 J48878834/ 97 50124 2I7 3/576346 14=62 10/ 971397 35 2I7 9757/90/2 I08 2 4/ 2I7 >0/9 0 8= 0/9 M0>=07 93/C 0/9 2I767 38 /4 938J=27 0/9 0/9 93/C ? 2I736 63CI28 0114693/C 24 2I7 13M3> 1497G

!"#$ 67$ 855"-0.+" "9"#:;)1 )< =:-/"5"1+ > ?)@ +) (+.3 (.5"

/. G826 2C= 68= C=LD3536=5 69 569? =X=ID6394 N  +45E 0G O765712 0JJ70> 24 (#. 7 8=J76879708 8 46 67084/07 14HJ7/80234/ 546 2I7 =87 0/9 411=J0234/ 45 2I7 J67H3878G #!; J7/97/1: 45 0/42I76 01234/ 38 /42 0 C64=/9 24 J67M7/2 7B71=234/

GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 23

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

V. "XI=?63945 69 68= 1=4=C2< CD=4IM 9A 24968=C 2I6394 35 496 1C9D4> 69 ?C=Y=46 =X=ID6394.  +45E 0G '+)$ ` 560=9 ? 011397/2? H3820W746 7B1=807 /7C>3C7/17a 7/2 4/ 67/20>8 H 9757/90/2 38 /42 >7C0234/8 546 2I7 H=/313J0> 14=62 24 01E=367 D=638931234/; J>03/2355 H=82 0>>7C7 J6346 JI:8310> J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64J762:^ 0/9 2I02 I7 N08 97J63M79 45 J48878834/ 2I^ 3/ 6784>=234/ 2I76745 NI02 38 3HJ4620/2 38 97276H3/3/C NI4 38 7/232>79 24 2I7 JI:8310> J48878834/ 45 2 I7 J64J762:^ J>03/2355 /7798 H767>: 24 J64M7 J6346 JI:8310> J48878834/ 97 50124 0/9 =/9=7 97J63M0234/ 2I76745G `)=/4[ M8G +22:G \07 38 /7M76 0/ 388=7 3/ 546137 7/26:^ 2I7 14=62 8I4=>9 J48878834/G KG'46 546137 7/26: 24 J648J76? J>03/23558 H=82 0>>7C7 0/9 J64M7 2I02 2I7: I0M7 J6346 JI:8310> J48878834/ 45 J64J762:^ 2I02 2I7: N767 97J63M79 45 J48878834/ 2I^ 2I02 01234/ N08 A3>79 N32I3/ 4/7 :706 564H 2I7 23H7 2I7 4N/768 46 >7C0> J488788468 >706/79 45 2I736 97J63M0234/ 45 JI:8310> J48878834/G `)0/C0876 M8G _C0:? SXRKa QG+1234/ 546 =/>0N5=> 97203/76 38 0/ 3HJ64J76 67H79:G @=2 2I7 01234/ 10//42 >7C0234/ 3/ 2I7 14HJ>03/2 2I02 2I7 7/26: 45 2I7 9757/90/2 N08 2IG `i=3D0/4 MG +22:G +H0/27? SXRKa PG_/>0N5=> 97203/76 38 2I7 N32II4>93/C 0/9 46 93/C 24 NI31I 2I7 >02276 38 7/232>79 05276 2I7 7BJ360234/ 46 276H3/0234/ 45 2I7 546H76h8 63CI2 24 I4>9 J48878834/ 379G `#0C0>4C MG Y4/[0>7[? SXRKa TG.4HJ>03/2 3/ =/>0N5=> 97203/76 H=82 0>>7C7 2I02 9757/90/2 463C3/0>>: I09 =/>0N5=> J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64J762:? 732I76 03/2355^ 9757/90/2h8 J48878834/ 45 J64J762: 7M7/2=0>>: >7C0> 46 =/>0N5=> =J4/ /42317 03/2355 24 9757/90/2 45 2I7 7BJ360234/ 46 276H3/0234/ 45 9757/90/2h8 63CI2 45 J48878834/^ 9757/90/2 67H03/79 3/ J48878834/ 45 2I7 J64J762: 0/9 2I76703/2355 45 2I7 7/D4:H7/2 2I76745^ J>03/2355 3/8232=279 2I7 01234/ N32I3/ 4/7 :706 564H =/>0N5=> GLORIA

MALAZARTE

WEE

— 24

PROVISIONAL REMEDIES 2018-2019

97J63M0234/ 46 N32II4>93/C 45 J48878834/G `O7/20 O013A31 (70>2: .46J460234/ MG ,7: .4/826=1234/ 0/9 *7M7>4JH7/2 .46J460234/? SXRKa UGZ/ 7D712H7/2 10878? 2I7 6=>3/C 45 2I7 14=628 067 3HH793027>: 7B71=246: 0/9 10/ 4/>: 30/17 N32I %71234/ RV 45 (=>7 TX 45 2I7 (=>78 45 .4=62? 3G7G `0a ^ `3/C 0 8=J76879708 46 67084/07 14HJ7/80234/ 546 2I7 =87 0/9 411=J0/1: 45 2I7 J64J762: 9=63/C 2I7 J7/97/1: 45 2I7 0JJ70>^ 503>=67 24 14HJ>: N32I 0/: 45 2I787 14/93234/8 38 C64=/9 546 4=263CI2 7B71=234/ 45 2I7 D=9CH7/2^ 9=2: 45 2I7 14=62 38 H3/3827630> 0/9 3HJ76023M7^ 8=J76879708 9 79 N32I3/ 2I7 J76349 546 2I7 J76571234/ 45 2I7 0JJ70>G `+>14/760 MG O03>0/0/? SXRKa VG(=>7 TX? %71234/ RV 0JJ>378 4/>: NI7/ 2I7 D=9CH7/2 45 0 H=/313J0> 2630> 14=62 BBB 3/ 0/ 7D712H7/2 1087 J7/93/C 0JJ70> 6709: 6784>M79 2I7 0JJ70> 0/9 328 D=9CH7/2? 3/ 2=6/ 38 J7/93/C 0JJ70> 8? 2I7/ (=>7 TX? %71234/ SR? 45 2I7 (=>78 C3M7/^ 0=2I463878 2I7 (#. 24 3HH793027>: 388=7 0 N632 45 7B71=234/ N32I4=2 J67D=9317 24 2I7 0JJ70> 20W3/C 9=7 14=687G `(7J=31 M8G d4/G )0/C42060? SXRXa RXG%=J67H7 .4=62h8 4J3/34/ 2I02 4/ 0JJ70>? 2I7 0JJ7>>027 14=62 H0: 820: 8039 N632 8I4=>9 1361=H820/178 84 67E=367G `(7J=31 M8G )0/C42060a RRG$M7/ 35 (#. D=9CH7/28 3/ =/>0N5=> 97203/76 10878 067 3HH793027>: 7B71=246:? J67>3H3/06: 3/D=/1234/ H0: 823>> : 706 8I4N3/C 2I02 2I767 7B3828 0 63CI2 24 45 2I7 D=9CH7/2 3/ 0/ 7D712H7/2 1087? 8I0>> /42 14/9=12 0 67I7063/C 46 2630> 97 /4M4G `)0/0>0/C MG @010/3? `@7680H3/aa RLG+: 3/ 6067 3/820/178 38 8=8J7/834/ 0>>4N79 24 0N032 2I7 4=214H7 45 0 J7/93/C 13M3> 01234/G RVG Z/ e*+ 0/9 0H0C0/ M )060:0C ? 2I7 %. 4697679 2I7 8=8J7/834/ 45 2I7 7D712H7/2 J6417793/C8 4/ 14/839760234/ 45 7E=32:G F 83/17 2I7 7D712H7/2 45 J723234/768 N4=>9 H70/ 97H4>3234/ 45 2I736 I4=87 0/9 N4=>9 167027 14/5=834/ ? 9382=69 =83M7 D=638931234/ 45 2I7 A368 >7M7> 14=628 0234/ 45 %71G R 45 (=>7 TX SRG #I7 388=7 45 4N/768I3J H0:M79 3/ 971393/C 2I7 388=7 45 J48878834/ 35 2I7 E=78324/ 45 J48878834/ 38 3/2762N3/79 N32I 2I7 388=7 45 4N/768I3JG SSG + D=9C7H7/2 67/97679 3/ 0 '$ 1087 N3>> /42