Platinum Heights Sdn Bhd v Sun Mix Concrete

 1

 2

Malayan Law Journal Reports/1997/Volume 1/PLATINUM HI!HT" "#N $H# % "UN MI& '(N'RT "#N $H# ) *1997+ 1 MLJ ,-9 ) . Mar0 199 . paes *1997] 1 MLJ 409

PLATINUM HEIGHTS SDN BHD v SUN MIX CONCRETE SDN BHD HIGH COURT (KUALA LUMPUR) KAMALANATHAN RATNAM JC ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO D5!44071995 " M#$%& 199' Civil Procedure -- Injunction to restrain winding-up petition -- Ambiguous admission of debt -- Contract to supply goods between debtor and creditor -- Whether non-receipt of final account from third party would  justify non-payment of debt -- Withholding material facts by debtor -- Whether application for injunction should be dismissed  Civil Procedure -- Originating summons -- No cause of action or substantive issue -- Non-compliance with O  r !"#$ of the %ules of the &igh Court #'() -- Whether summons should be rejected -- %ules of the &igh Court #'() O  r !"#$ * O '+ r ! T0e pla3nt344 was awar5e5 6y M3%an ar ast "5n $05 8t0e ma3n ontrator: a ontrat 4or strutural onrete wor;s 4or a on5om3n3um prouant3ty an5 pr3es o4 t0e onrete suppl3e5 6 y t0e 5e4en5ant= Howe%er? a4ter se%eral %ar3at3ons an5 a5uest3ons on w030 t0e pla3nt344 see;s t0e 5eterm3nat3on or 53ret3on o4 t0e H30 'ourt or? as t0e ase may 6e? a on3se statement o4 t0e rel3e4 or reme5y la3me5 3n t0e proee53ns 6eun 6y t0e or33nat3n summons w3t0 su4433ent part3ulars to 35ent34y t0e ause or auses o4 at3on 3n respet o4 w030 t0e pla3nt344 la3ms t0at rel3e4 or reme5y=

Howe%er? t03s or33nat3n summons 43le5 6y t0e pla3nt344 535 not onta3n any su0 statement o4 >uest3ons 4or t0e ourts 5eterm3nat3on or 53ret3on nor was t0ere a on3se statement o4 t0e rel3e4 or reme5y la3me5 an5 ne3t0er was t0ere a statement w3t0 su4433ent part3ulars to 35ent34y t0e ause o r auses o4 at3on 3n respet o4 w030 3t w3s0es to la3m t0at rel3e4 or reme5y? 6ut merely onta3ne5 t0e prayers 3t w3s0e5 4or as 4ollowsD 8a: Penentan 53laran mem4a3l;an 5an/atau menerus;an pet3syen penulunan ter0a5ap pemo0on 03na per3nta0 lan