Nerwin v Pnoc

TITLE: Nerwin v PNOC, GR no. 167057, April 11, 11, 2012

 Nerwin Industries Corporation Corporation (petitioner) (petitioner) v PNOC-Energy Development Development Corporation, Corporation, and Ester R. uer!on, C"airman, #ids and $wards Committee (respondents) Ponente% &usti'e u'as P. #ersamin Topic: !"n#"$or% or Pro&i'i$or% L"w (oc$rine "n# Proviion Proviion::

$rti'le  o* t"e Civil Code% $'ts e+e'uted against t"e provisions o* mandatory or pro"iitory laws s"all  e void, e+'ept w"en t"e t"e laws itsel* aut"ori!es aut"ori!es t"eir validity. validity. Repuli' $'t No. /0% $n a't to ensure t"e e+peditious implementation and 'ompletion o* government in*rastru'ture pro1e'ts y pro"iiting lower 'ourts *rom issuing temporary restraining orders, preliminary in1un'tions or preliminary mandatory in1un'tions, providing penalties *or violations t"ereo*, and *or ot"er  purposes. Do'trine% $ preliminary preliminary in1un'tion is an order granted at any stage o* an a'tion or pro'eeding prior to t"e  1udgment or *inal order2 order2 It is an an'illary or preventive remedy resorted to y a litigant to prote't or  preserve "is rig"ts or or interests during t"e t"e penden'y o* t"e 'ase. 3or lower 'ourts to issue temporary restraining orders, preliminary in1un'tions or preliminary mandatory in1un'tions against e+peditious implementation and 'ompletion o* government in*rastru'ture  pro1e'ts t"ere must e su**i'ient su**i'ient eviden'e eviden'e t"at t"e matter is o* e+treme urgen'y urgen'y involving involving a 'onstitutional 'onstitutional issue, su'" t"at unless a temporary restraining order is issued, grave in1usti'e and irreparale in1ury will arise. )"c$:

•

•

•

4, NE$ pulis"ed pulis"ed an invitation to pre-5uali*y and to id *or a 'ontra't, ot"erwise 6nown as IP# No. 7 O'toer 8, 9777, In t"e Re'ommendation o* $ward $ward *or IP# No. 7, NE$ administrator Conrado :. Estrella III re'ommended to NE$;s #oard o* Dire'tors t"e approval o* award to Nerwin. De'emer 4, 9777, NE$;s #oard o* Dire'tors passed Resolution No.