LABREL Digests Week 4 COMPLETE

----------------------------------------------CASE 091 Faculty Association of Mapua vs. Mapua G.R. No. 164060  June 15, 2007 Digest by: Angelo Lope ----------------------------------------------Topic: !"#g"ining $#o%e&u#e ' Duty to !"#g"in

 by t/e p"#ties "n& eCp"n&s t/e 1 "%ulty #"ns to 2@. pon le"#ning o t/e %/"nges, A+ oppose& t/e o#)ul". 5. A+ A+ b#oug/ b#oug/tt t/e )"tte# )"tte# to N+!. t #ule& "g"ins "g"instt +"pu". +"pu". A #e*e#se&. Issue: WON MITs ne! p"oposal# "e$a"%in$ faculty "an&in$ an% evaluation# la!ful an% consistent !it' t'e "atifie% C(A

$onente: J. (uisi)bing

)ulin$:

Facts: 1. $#i*"te $#i*"te #espon&en #espon&entt +"pu" nstitute nstitute o e%/nol e%/nology ogy + /i#e& /i#e& A#t/ A#t/u# u# An&e# n&e#se sen n to &e*e &e*elo lop p " "%u "%ult lty y #"n #"nin ing g "n& "n& %o)pens"tion syste). 3n J"nu"#y 2, 2001, in t/e 5t/ !A negoti"tion )eeting, + p#esente& t/e ne "%ulty #"ning inst#u)ent to petitione# "%ulty Asso%i"tion o +"pu" nstitute o e%/nology A+. /e l"tte# "g#ee& to t/e "&option "n& i)ple)e i)ple)ent"ti nt"tion on o t/e inst#u)en inst#u)ent, t, it/ t/e #ese#*"t #ese#*"tion ion t/"t t/e#e s/oul& be no &i)inution in #"n "n& p"y o t/e "%ulty )e)be#s. 3n Ap#il 17, 2001, A+ "n& + ente#e& into " ne !A ee%ti*e June 1, 2001.4 t in%o#po#"te& t/e ne #"ning o# t/e %ollege "%ulty in 8e%tion 9 o A#ti%le  o  !A. 2. ;/en t/e !A too too ee%t, ee%t, t/e i%e i%e $#esi&ent $#esi&ent o# A%"&e A%"&e)i% )i% A"i#s issue& " )e)o#"n&u) )e)o#"n&u) to "ll &e"ns "n& sub