Lab Report Shell &Tube Heat Exchanger
Short Description
shell and tube heat exchanger...
Description
1. ABSTRACT/SUMMARY
We have successfully conducted our experiment of Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger by using Heat Exchanger Training Apparatus (Model; HE 158C). A heat exchanger is a device that allows heat from a fluid (a liquid or a gas) to pass to a second fluid (another liquid or gas) without the two fluids having to mix together or come into direct contact. In this experiment, cold water enters the shell at room temperature while hot water enters the tubes in the opposite direction. We then vary the hot water and cold water flow rates and record the inlet and outlet temperatures of both the hot water and cold water streams at steady state. The flow of hot and cold water is counter-current flow. Then the experiment is repeated with co-current shell and tube heat exchanger which is parallel flow of hot and cold water. From the data calculated, shows that counter current flow configuration of heat exchanger is more preferred for practical application.
2. INTRODUCTION
SOLTEQ® Heat Exchanger Training Apparatus (Model: HE 158C) is an apparatus that is used to demonstrate the application of heat exchanger in industries. This apparatus consists of four different type of heat exchanger that is Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger, Spiral Heat Exchanger, Concentric Heat Exchanger and Plate Heat Exchanger. In this experiment, type of heat exchanger used is Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger. Inside the shell and tube heat exchanger, there is shell, tubes, baffles, rear-end header and rear-end header. For shell and tube heat exchanger to operate, valves V4, V5,V19 and V20 are open while V6-V11 and V21-V26 are set to be close.
Shell and tube heat exchanger Flowmeter Contro l panel Pump
Figure 1: SOLTEQ® Heat Exchanger Training Apparatus (Model: HE 158C)
Figure 2: Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger
There are two types of flow in heat exchanger unit which is counter-current flow and cocurrent flow. To set a counter-current flow, valves V1, V12, V15, V18 and V28 are set to open and valves V16, V17, V27, V29 and V30 are set to close. For co-current flow, the valves V1, V12, V16, V17 and V28 are set to open and valves V15, V18, V27, V29 and V30 are set to close. In the control panel, there is main power switch an also a heater switch. Besides, there is also a digital temperature and pressure reader as shown below: a) Flow measurement FT1: Hot water flow rate (LPM) FT2: Cold water flow rate (LPM) b) Temperature Measurement TT1: Hot water inlet temperature (°C) TT2: Hot water inlet temperature (°C) TT2: Hot water inlet temperature (°C) TT2: Hot water inlet temperature (°C) Table 1: Control panel symbol The function of shell is to transport cold water. The water will be inserted into the shell inlet and go out from at the shell outlet whereas tube is used to transport hot water across the tube. Front-end header is where water will enter the tubeside of the heat exchanger. Furthermore, Rear-end header is where the water leaves the heat exchanger. Baffles are installed in order to support the tubes and allow water to flow across the tubes. Besides, baffles also give a higher transfer rate due to the increase of turbulence. The heat exchanger’s dimension is as follows:
Information about the Shell & Tube Heat Exchanger unit Tube O.D. (do)
:
9.53 ×10-3
m
Tube I.D. (di)
:
7.75×10-3
m
Tube Length (L)
:
0.5
m
Tube Count (Nt)
:
10
Tube Pitch (pt)
:
0.018
Tube arrangement
:
Triangle
Shell O.D.
:
0.1
m
Shell I.D. (Ds)
:
0.085
m
Baffle Count
:
8
Baffle Cut (Bc)
:
20 %
Baffle Distance (lB)
:
m
0.05 m 316 L Stainless Steel/Borosilicate Glass
Material of Construction : Table 2: Dimensions of shell and tube heat exchanger
3. OBJECTIVES The objectives for conducting this experiment are : 1) To study the working principle of the concentric heat exchanger operating by using cocurrent flow and counter-current fluid flow. 2) Then, another purpose of this experiment is to demonstrate the effect of hot and cold flow rate variations on the performance of the heat exchanger system.
4. THEORY The main function of heat exchanger is to either remove heat from a hot fluid or to add heat to the cold fluid. The direction of fluid motion inside the heat exchanger can normally
categorised as parallel flow, counter flow and cross flow. In this experiment, we study only counter-current and co-current flow. For co-current flow, also known as co-current flow, both the hot and cold fluids flow in the same direction. Both the fluids enter and exit the heat exchanger on the same ends. For counter-current flow, both the hot and cold fluids flow in the opposite direction. Both the fluids enter and exit the heat exchanger on the opposite ends. In this experiment, we focused on the shell and tube heat exchanger. Heat exchangers with only one phase (liquid or gas) on each side can be called one phase or single-phase heat exchangers. Two-phase heat exchangers can be used to heat a liquid to boil it into a gas (vapor), sometimes called boilers, or cool a vapor to condense it into a liquid (called condensers), with the phase change usually occurring on the shell side. One of the most common, conductive-convective, heat exchanger types is the concentric tube heat exchanger. These exchangers are built of coaxial tubes placed the ones inside the others. When both the fluids enter from the same side and flow through the same direction we have the parallel flow (concurrent flow), otherwise, if the fluids enter from opposite sides and flow through the contrary direction we have the countercurrent flow. Usually the countercurrent flow is more efficient from the heat transfer point of view. This type of heat exchangers can also be built with the internal tube made with longitudinal fins which could be placed either in its internal surface or in its external one or both. This configuration is useful mainly if one of the fluids is a gas or a liquid with a very high viscosity and it's very difficult to have a good thermal convection coefficient. The heats are transfer between the two fluids by convection mode which is from the hot fluid to the wall and also by conduction which is occur within the wall itself and back to the convection which is from the wall to the cold fluid. This concentric tube heat exchanger is the simplest one of heat exchanger between the other types of heat exchanger. This type mainly used for small flow rates of fluid.
Figure 1 - Diagram of Parallel and Counter Flow Configurations
5. APPARATUS & MATERIALS 1) Concentric Heat Exchanger 2) Water
6. PROCEDURE
GENERAL START-UP PROCEDURE 1
A quick inspection is performed to make sure that the equipment is in proper working
2 3 4
condition All the valves are closed initially except for V1 and V12. Hot water tank is filled up via a water supply hose connected to V27 until it is full. The cold-water tank is filled up by opening V28 and the valve is leaved opened for
5 6
continues water supply. A drain horse is connected to the cold water drain point. The main power is switch on. The heater is switch on for the hot water tank and the
7
temperature controller is set to 50oC. The water temperature in the hot tank is allowed to reach the set-point.
GENERAL SHUTDOWN PROCEDURE 1. 2. 3. 4.
The heater is switched off until the hot water temperature drops below 40oC. Pump, P1 and pump, P2 are switched off. The main power is switched off. All the water in the process line is drained off. The water is retained in the hot and cold
water for the next laboratory session. 5. All the valves are closed.
EXPERIMENT A: COUNTER-CURRENT SHELL AND TUBE HEAT EXCHANGER 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
The general started up is performed. The valves (V) for counter-current Shell & Tube Heat Exchanger are switched on. P1 and P2 are switched on. V3 and V14 are adjusted to obtain the desired flow rates for hot water and cold water. The system is allowed to reach steady state for 10 minutes. FT1, FT2, TT1, TT2, TT3 and TT4 are recorded. The pressure drop measurement for shell-side and tube-side are recorded for pressure
8 9
studies. Steps 4 and 7 are repeated for different combination of flow rate FT1 and FT2. P1 and P2 are switched off after the completion of experiment.
10 The next experiment is preceded.
EXPERIMENT B: CO-CURRENT SHELL & TUBE HEAT EXCHANGER 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
The general start up is performed. The valves (V) for co-current are switched on. P1 and P2 are switched on. V3 and V14 are adjusted to obtain the desired flow rates for hot water and cold water. The system is allowed to reach steady state for 10 minutes. FT1, FT2, TT1, TT2, TT3 and TT4 are recorded. The pressure drop measurement for shell-side and tube-side are recorded for pressure
studies. 8 Steps 4 and 7 are repeated for different combination of flow rate FT1 and FT2. 9 P1 and P2 are switched off after the completion of experiment. 10 The general shut down is performed.
7.RESULT EXPERIMENT A : COUNTER-CURRENT SHELL & TUBE HEAT EXCHANGER
i.
FT1 (HOT) Constant=5 LPM
FT1
FT2
TT1
TT2
TT3
TT4
DPT1
DPT2
(LPM) 5 5 5 5 5
(LPM) 1 2 3 4 5
(oC) 27.8 27.9 27.9 28.0 28.0
(oC) 38.4 39.3 40.1 40.9 41.6
(oC) 31.6 30.7 29.9 29.3 28.7
(oC) 49.1 50.0 49.1 49.6 49.2
(mmH20) 5 5 5 5 5
(mmH20 5 5 5 5 5
5 40.1
5 40.9
Volumetric Flowrate (LPM) Inlet temperature,TT1
5 38.4
Hot fluid (Tube) 5 39.3
5 41.6
Outlet Temperature,TT2 Mass flow rate (kg/s) Heat transfer rate, W Pressure drop, mm H2O Volumetric Flowrate (LPM) Inlet temperature,TT3 Outlet Temperature,TT4 Mass flow rate (kg/s) Heat transfer rate, W Pressure drop, mm H2O Tlm Heat loss, W Efficiency, % Total exchange area, m2 Overall heat transfer coefficient Cross-section area, m2 No.of tubes Total cross-section area,m2 Mass velocity, kg/m2.s Linear velocity, m/s Reynolds number,Re Prandtl Types of flow Tube coefficient, W.m-2.K Cross-section area, m2 Mass velocity, kg/m2.s Linear velocity, m/s Reynolds number,Re Prandtl Types of flow Shell coefficient, hs
27.8 27.9 29.8 0.1647 0.1647 0.1647 3644.33 3919.37 3575.56 5 5 5 Cold fluid (Shell) 1 2 3 31.6 30.7 29.9 49.1 50.0 49.1 0.033 0.066 0.10 1214.76 2665.53 1332.76 5 5 5 Temperature difference 8.42 2.07 3.59 2429.57 1253.84 1783.26 300 68.00 66.72 Overall heat transfer coefficient 0.15 0.15 0.15 86.3 94.99 86.18 Tube Side 0.0000472 0.0000472 0.0000472 10 10 10 0.000472 0.000472 0.000472 349.13 349.13 349.13 0.3533 0.3533 0.3533 4924.93 4924.93 4924.93 3.56 3.56 3.56 Turbulent turbulent turbulent 2570.30 2570.30 2570.30 Shell Side 0.002 0.002 0.002 8.3 33.189 24.89 0.0083 0.0333 0.025 288.17 1152.31 864.17 5.44 5.44 5.44 Laminar Laminar Laminar 377.72 151.04 1132.73
29.8 0.1647 4435 5
29.9 0.1647 4675.74 5
4 29.3 49.6 0.13 5636.48 5
5 28.7 49.2 0.166 7115 5
3.70 1201.48 126.19
1.93 2439.26 152.17
0.15 106.85
0.15 1222
0.0000472 10 0.000472 349.13 0.3533 4924.93 3.56 turbulent 2570.30
0.0000472 10 0.000472 349.13 0.3533 4924.93 3.56 turbulent 2570.30
0.002 33.189 0.033 1152 5.44 Laminar 1510.41
0.002 41.00 0.0412 1423.50 5.44 Laminar 1865.89
ii.
FT2 (COLD) Constant = 5 LPM
FT1
FT2
TT1
TT2
TT3
TT4
DPT1
DPT2
(LPM) 1 2 3 4 5
(LPM) 5 5 5 5 5
(oC) 28.1 28.1 28.3 28.2 28.2
(oC) 42.1 42.4 42.9 43.3 43.7
(oC) 28.2 27.8 27.5 27.2 27.1
(oC) 50.6 49.8 50.0 49.3 49.8
(mmH20) 5 5 5 5 5
(mmH20 5 5 5 5 5
3 28.3 42.9 0.049 3011.73 5
4 28.2 43.3 0.066 4153.16 5
5 28.2 43.7 0.082 5328.97 5
5 27.5 50.0 0.083
5 27.2 43.9 0.083
5 27.1 49.8 0.083
Volumetric Flowrate (LPM) Inlet temperature,TT1 Outlet Temperature,TT2 Mass flow rate (kg/s) Heat transfer rate, W Pressure drop, mm H2O Volumetric Flowrate (LPM) Inlet temperature,TT3 Outlet Temperature,TT4 Mass flow rate (kg/s)
Hot fluid (Tube) 1 2 28.1 28.1 42.1 42.4 0.016 0.033 962.65 1966.56 5 5 Cold fluid (Shell) 5 5 28.2 27.8 50.6 49.8 0.083 0.083
Heat transfer rate, W Pressure drop, mm H2O
7774.46 7635.63 7809.17 5 5 5 Temperature difference
7670.34 5
7878.58 5
Tlm Heat loss, W Efficiency, %
-75.58 -8737.10 807.61
-137.55 -11823.50 184.69
-145.09 -13207.55 147.84
0.15
0.15
185.56
206.14
244.89
0.0000472 10 0.000472 348.94 0.3533 4924.93 3.56 turbulent 2570.36
0.0000472 10 0.000472 345.33 0.3533 4875.70 3.56 turbulent 2462.58
0.0000472 10 0.000472 341.95 0.3533 4826.47 3.56 Turbulent 2437.71
0.002 46.45 0.04670 1612.73 5.44 Laminar 5366.21
0.002 60.55 0.06086 2102.27 5.44 Laminar 6995.11
0.002 75.50 0.07583 2621.33 5.44 Laminar 8722.24
Total exchange area, m2 Overall heat transfer coefficient Cross-section area, m2 No.of tubes Total cross-section area,m2 Mass velocity, kg/m2.s Linear velocity, m/s Reynolds number,Re Prandtl Types of flow Tube coefficient, W.m-2.K Cross-section area, m2 Mass velocity, kg/m2.s Linear velocity, m/s Reynolds number,Re Prandtl Types of flow Shell coefficient, hs
-91.60 -9601.56 388.27
-108.18 -10820.90 259.29
Overall heat transfer coefficient 0.15 0.15 0.15 18.41
143.09
Tube Side 0.0000472 10 0.000472 348.94 0.3533 4924.93 3.56 turbulent 2570.36 Shell Side 0.002 0.002 16.60 31.55 0.01667 0.03173 576.4 1095.40 5.44 5.44 Laminar Laminar 1917.92 3644.84
0.0000472 10 0.000472 348.94 0.3533 4924.93 3.56 Turbulent 2570.36
7.1 EXPERIMENT B : CO-CURRENT CONCENTRIC HEAT EXCHANGER i.
FT1 (HOT) Constant = 5 LPM
FT1
FT2
TT1
TT2
TT3
TT4
DPT1
DPT2
(LPM) 5 5 5 5 5
(LPM) 1 2 3 4 5
(oC) 43.8 44.3 44.3 30.1 29.6
(oC) 44.8 45.4 44.9 33.8 32.9
(oC) 26.6 26.6 26.4 26.2 26.2
(oC) 49.1 50.1 49.4 49.5 50.0
(mmH20) 4 10 5 5 5
(mmH20 5 5 5 5 5
5 44.3 44.9 0.0823 -137.52 5
5 30.1 33.8 0.0823 -1272.08 5
5 29.6 32.9 0.0823 -1134.55 5
3 26.4 49.4 0.0498
4 26.2 49.5 0.0664
5 26.2 50.0 0.0830
Volumetric Flowrate (LPM) Inlet temperature,TT1 Outlet Temperature,TT2 Mass flow rate (kg/s) Heat transfer rate, W Pressure drop, mm H2O Volumetric Flowrate (LPM) Inlet temperature,TT3 Outlet Temperature,TT4 Mass flow rate (kg/s)
Hot fluid (Tube) 5 5 43.8 44.3 44.8 45.4 0.0823 0.0823 -343.80 -378.18 4 10 Cold fluid (Shell) 1 2 26.6 26.6 49.1 50.1 0.0166 0.0332
Heat transfer rate, W Pressure drop, mm H2O Tlm Heat loss, W Efficiency, % Total exchange area, m2 Overall heat transfer coefficient Cross-section area, m2 No.of tubes Total cross-section area,m2 Mass velocity, kg/m2.s Linear velocity, m/s Reynolds number,Re Prandtl Types of flow Tube coefficient, W.m-2.K Cross-section area, m2 Mass velocity, kg/m2.s Linear velocity, m/s Reynolds number,Re Prandtl Types of flow Shell coefficient, hs
1562.35 3263.58 4791.21 5 5 5 Temperature difference 19.05 20.92 18.31 -1905.63 -3607.38 -5135.01 454.28 949.27 1393.60 Overall heat transfer coefficient 0.15 0.15 0.15 120.31 109.56 125.18 Tube Side 0.0000472 0.0000472 0.0000472 10 10 10 0.000472 0.000472 0.000472 174.36 174.36 174.36 0.176 0.176 0.176 2459.57 2459.57 2459.57 3.56 3.56 3.56 Turbulent turbulent turbulent 1498.20 1498.20 1498.20 Shell Side 0.002 0.002 0.002 8.29 16.60 24.9 0.00833 0.0167 0.0250 288.17 576.35 864.52 5.44 5.44 5.44 Laminar Laminar Laminar 377.72 755.46 1133.19
6471.60 5
8263.10 5
28.81 -6815.40 1960.91
24.41 -8606.90 2403.46
0.15 79.56
0.15 93.90
0.0000472 10 0.000472 174.36 0.176 2459.57 3.56 turbulent 1498.20
0.0000472 10 0.000472 174.36 0.176 2459.57 3.56 Turbulent 1498.20
0.002 33.2 0.0333 1152.69 5.44 Turbulent 1510.91
0.002 41.5 0.0417 1440.86 5.44 Turbulent 1888.64
ii.
FT2(COLD) Constant=5 LPM
FT1
FT2
TT1
TT2
TT3
TT4
DPT1
DPT1
(LPM) 1 2 3 4 5
(LPM) 5 5 5 5 5
(oC) 29.6 30.1 30.1 29.5 29.5
(oC) 31.0 31.8 32.5 32.1 32.4
(oC) 26.2 26.2 26.1 26.1 26.1
(oC) 50.0 50.6 49.6 50.2 50.3
(mmH20) 4 5 8 4 3
(mmH20 5 5 5 5 5
Volumetric Flowrate (LPM) Inlet temperature,TT1 Outlet Temperature,TT2 Mass flow rate (kg/s) Heat transfer rate, W Pressure drop, mm H2O Volumetric Flowrate (LPM) Inlet temperature,TT3 Outlet Temperature,TT4 Mass flow rate (kg/s) Heat transfer rate, W Pressure drop, mm H2O Tlm Heat loss, W
Hot fluid (Tube) 1 2 3 29.6 30.1 30.1 31.0 31.8 32.5 0.0823 0.0823 0.0823 96.27 233.79 495.08 4 5 8 Cold fluid (Shell) 5 5 5 26.2 26.2 26.1 50.0 50.6 49.6 0.0166 0.0332 0.0498 8260.4 8468.6 8156.24 5 5 5 Temperature difference 9.07 9.47 9.02 -8164.13 -8234.8 -7661.16
4 29.5 32.1 0.0823 715.1 4
5 29.5 32.4 0.0823 997.0 3
5 26.1 50.2 0.0664 8364.5 5
5 26.1 50.3 0.0830 8399.2 5
8.79 -7649.4
8.73 -7402.2
Efficiency, % Total exchange area, m2 Overall heat transfer coefficient Cross-section area, m2 No.of tubes Total cross-section area,m2 Mass velocity, kg/m2.s Linear velocity, m/s Reynolds number,Re Prandtl Types of flow Tube coefficient, W.m-2.K Cross-section area, m2 Mass velocity, kg/m2.s Linear velocity, m/s Reynolds number,Re Prandtl Types of flow Shell coefficient, hs
8580.5 3622.3 1647.46 Overall heat transfer coefficient 0.15 0.15 0.15 70.76 164.58 366.03 Tube Side 0.0000472 0.0000472 0.0000472 10 10 10 0.000472 0.000472 0.000472 174.36 174.36 174.36 0.176 0.176 0.176 2459.57 2459.57 2459.57 3.56 3.56 3.56 Turbulent turbulent turbulent 1498.20 1498.20 1498.20 Shell Side 0.002 0.002 0.002 8.29 16.60 24.9 0.00833 0.0167 0.0250 287.79 578.88 863.90 5.44 5.44 5.44 Laminar Laminar Laminar 347.05 755.50 1041.78
1169.70
842
0.15 542.30
0.15 761.36
0.0000472 10 0.000472 174.36 0.176 2459.57 3.56 turbulent 1498.20
0.0000472 10 0.000472 174.36 0.176 2459.57 3.56 Turbulent 1498.20
0.002 33.2 0.0333 1151.50 5.44 Turbulent 1388.6
0.002 41.5 0.0417 1439.48 5.44 Turbulent 1735.88
8
CALCULATION
Sample Calculation : Hot Water Density
988.18 kg/ m
Viscosity Thermal condition Heat Capacity
3
0.0005494 Pa.s 0.6436 W/m.K 4175.00 J/kg.K Cold Water
Density Viscosity Thermal condition Heat Capacity
3 995.67 kg/ m
0.0008007 Pa.s 0.6155 W/m.K 0.0008007 Pa.s
Cold Water Flowrate at TT1 = 40.1 oC Hot fluid (Tube-side) : Water Cold fluid (Shell side ) : Water Volume flow (L/min) 10.0 Volume flow (L/min) 2.0 Inlet Temperature, oC 40.1 Inlet Temperature, oC 47.4 Outlet Temperature, 29.7 Outlet Temperature, 50.2 oC oC 1
Calculation On Heat Transfer using heat balance equation : Heat transfer rate for hot water, Q = mh Cp ∆T 3 kg L 1 min 1m =5 min x 1000 L x 60 s x 988.18 m3 x 4175 = -3644.33 W Heat transfer rate for cold water, Q = mc Cp ∆T kg L 1 min 1 m3 = 1 min x 1000 L x 60 s x 995.67 m3 = -1214.76 W Heat loss
x 4183
J kg .C
x (27.8-38.4) ◦C
J kg .C
x (31.6-49.1) ◦C
= Qhot-Qcold = -3644.33+1214.76 = -2429.57W
Efficiency Qcold x 100 = Qhot =300% 2
Calculation of Log Mean Temperature Difference (LMTD) : ∆Tlm = [( Th,in – Tc,out) – (Th,out – Tc,in)] / ln[( Th,in – Tc,out) /( Th,out- Tc,in)] ( 38.4−49.1 )−(27.8−31.6) (38.4−49.1) = ¿ (27.8−31.6) =8.42◦C
3
Calculation of the tube and shell heat transfer coefficients by Kern’s method : a Heat transfer coefficient at tube side i Cross Flow Area,A di2 =∏ 4 =
3.142 x 0.0077 5 2 4
= 0.0000472 m
2
ii
Total cross Flow Area, At = At x Nt = 0.0000472 x 10 2 =0.000472 m
iii
Mass velocity, Gt mt = At =
0.1647 0.000472
2 = 349.13 kg/ m s
iv
Linear velocity, ut
=
¿ p
=
349.13 988.18
= 0.3533 m/s
v
Renolds Number, Re ¿ x de = µ =
vi
x
1 1000
= 4924.93 Value shows in range of turbulent flow Prandtl No, Pr µ x Cp = k =
vii
349.13 x 7.75 0.0005494
0.0005494 x 4175 0.6436
= 3.56 Tube Side Coefficient, hi jh ℜ P r 0.33 k = di 0.33
=
0.004 x 4924.93 x 3.56 0.00775 −2
= 2570.36 W m
x 0.6436
K
b Heat transfer coefficient at shell side i Cross flow area, As = Shell diameter x (Tube pitch-Tube OD) x Baffle distance / Tube pitch = [0.085 x ( 0.018 – 0.0953) x 0.05 ] / 0.018 2 = 0.002 m ii
Mass velocity, Gs Ws = As
=
0.0166 0.002
= 8.3 kg/ m iii
2
s
Linear velocity, us Gs = p =
8.3 995.67
= 0.0083 m/s
iv
Equivalent diameter, de 1.1 = d 0 (pt2 - 0.917d02 ) =
v
8.3 x 27.80 0.0008007
x
1 1000
= 288.17 Value shows in range of laminar flow Prandtl No, Pr µ x Cp = k =
vii
[ 182 - 0.917 (9.53)2]
= 27.80 mm Reynolds number, Re Gs x de = µ =
vi
1.1 9.53
0.0008007 x 4183 0.6155
= 5.44 Shell Side Coefficient, hs jh ℜ P r 0.33 k = de =
0.025 x 288.17 x 5.440.33 x 0.6155 0.02053
−2
= 377.72 W m c i
ii
K
Overall Heat transfer Coefficient Total exchange area, A = Number of tube x ∏ x Tube OD x Length of Tubes = 10 x ∏ x 0.00953 x 0.5 = 0.15 m2 Overall heat transfer coefficient,U Qhot = A ∆ Tlm = 86.33 W/ m
2
K
1.Temperature Profile for counter-current shell and tube heat exchanger
Temperature Profile 45 40
39.3
40.1
40.9
41.6
38.4 31.6
30.7
29.9
29.3
28.7
35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0
2. Heat Transfer Coefficient Study
Cold water Hot water
Relationship between Heat Transfer Coefficient and Cold Water Flowrate 3000 2570.3 2570.3 2570.3 2570.3 2500 2570.3 2000 Heat Transfer Coefficient (W/m2K)
1865.89 Tube side 1510.41 Shell side 1132.73
1500 1000 500 0
377.72 151.04 1 2 3 4 5
Cold Water Flow rate (LPM)
Overall Heat Transfer Coefficient vs Cold Water Flowrate 1400 1200 1000 800 Overall Heat Transfer Coefficient(W/m2.k)
600 400 200 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 Cold Water Flowrate(LPM)
9
DISCUSSION The experiment was carried out to study the working principle of parallel flow and
counter flow heat exchangers and also to investigate the effect of fluid temperature on counter and parallel flow heat exchanger performance. There are two types of experiment which is counter-current shell and tube heat exchanger and co-current shell and tube heat exchanger. The different between these two experiments are the counter-current flow is when hot water and cold water flow in opposite direction to each other while co-current flow is where hot and cold water flow in the same direction and also known as parallel flow. For counter-current flow and cocurrent flow, the experiment is run and all of the temperature and pressure data is recorded From the data collected, the counter-current and co-current heat exchanger’s exit temperature of the hot fluid is higher than the exit temperature of the cold fluid but due to the equipment error during experiment is done, exit temperature becomes lower than temperature inlet for parallel flow . This cause the experiment cannot be done practically. Instead of equipment and human error, this may because of the heat loss to the surrounding that can reduce the temperature itself and the flow rates which always easily change during the experiment may also cause this problem. This shows that heat may not spontaneously transfer from a colder body to a hotter body. The increase in flow rate of one of the stream will results in an increase in the rate of heat transfer. But from calculation, results show that the increase of flow rate, the lower the heat transfer. This is contra to the theoretical result but due to big error from the unit and since the unit does not function properly, we cannot able to avoid this mistake. Theoretically, the amount of heat loss form the hot water should be equal to the heat gain by the cold water.
Based on the calculation done, it is found out that the values of LMTD, which is log mean temperature difference for co-current flow is higher than the counter-current flow. But, the
overall heat transfer coefficient for counter-current flow is higher than the co-current flow. This mean that counter current flow heat exchanger has a higher effectiveness rather than parallel flow heat exchanger.
10 CONCLUSION So, overall in conclusion, shell and tube heat exchanger follows the basic law of Thermodynamics and fulfilled the study of Heat Transfer. In parallel (co-current) flow configuration, the exit temperature of the hot fluid is always higher than the exit temperature of the cold fluid. In countercurrent flow configuration, the exit temperature of the hot fluid is also higher than the exit temperature of the cold fluid. But then, in the configuration of counter current flow, the exit temperature of the cold fluid is higher than the exit temperature of the cold fluid in co-curent configuration. So, this stand the statement that counter current flow heat exchanger has a higher effectiveness than the parallel flow configuration. Besides, the experiment shows that the flow rate of one of the stream is directly proportional to the rate of heat transfer since the rate of heat transfer is increases as the flow rate of fluid increases. Futhermore, the amount of heat loss form the hot water is not equal to the heat gain by the cold water due to the heat loss to the surrounding. From the calculations done, the LMTD (log mean temperature difference) for co-current flow is higher than the counter-current flow. In a nut shell, counter current flow configuration of heat exchanger is more preferred for practical application. One of the application of heat exchanger is oil cooler.
11 RECOMMENDATION Based on the experiment, there are a few recommendations that can be suggested in order to increasing the performance of the concentric heat exchanger and to avoid from the error while recorded the data thus can affect the calculation outwards. Firstly, the most importance is to make sure that the equipment is in good condition so that the flow of the experiment does not disturbing by the inconstant data. Then, while conducting the experiment, make sure that the time taken to collect the data is punctually followed. The relay of the time can affect the data recorded. It is suggested that, the alert alarm system is placed so that it can be easier to record the data on time. Then, while recording the data, make sure that the pressure and temperature is at constant value because this can affect the calculation made.
12 REFERENCES Yunus A.Cengel, 2006, Heat and Mass Transfer: A Practical Approach. Mc Graw Hill,, 3 rd Edition Christie John Geankoplis, Transport Process AND Separation (includes unit operations) , 4thEdition Heat
Exchanger
Lab
Report,
by
Ram
Krishna
Singh,
retrieved
from
https://www.scribd.com/doc/23106551/Heat-Exchanger-Lab-Report CONCENTRIC TUBE HEAT EXCHANGER, by amirhazwan, Retrieved from https://www.scribd.com/doc/27156908/CONCENTRIC-TUBE-HEATEXCHANGER
APPENDIX
View more...
Comments