Is God an Accident - Bloom

5 )&
"5- "/5*$
. 0/5)-:

$ESPITETHEVASTNUMBEROFRELIGIONSINEXISTENCE NEARLYEVERYONEINTHEWORLDBELIEVESINTHE SAMETHINGSTHEEXISTENCEOFASOUL ANAFTERLIFE MIRACLES ANDTHEDIVINECREATIONOFTHEUNIVERSE 2ECENTLYPSYCHOLOGISTSDOINGRESEARCHONTHEMINDSOFINFANTSHAVEDISCOVEREDTWORELATEDFACTS THATMAYACCOUNTFORTHISPHENOMENON/NEHUMANBEINGSCOMEINTOTHEWORLDWITHA PREDISPOSITIONTOBELIEVEINCERTAINSPECIlCSUPERNATURALPHENOMENA!NDTWOTHISPREDISPOSITION ISANINCIDENTALBY PRODUCTOFCOGNITIVEFUNCTIONINGGONEAWRY7HICHLEADSTOTHEQUESTIONx

)3'/$!.!##)$%.4 "9 0!5, " ,//)LLUSTRATIONSBY'REG#LARKE

)' /$ ) 3 . /4 $ %!$ MAGISTERIAvSCIENCEGETSTHE HEN)WASATEENAGER REALMOFFACTS RELIGIONTHE MYRABBIBELIEVEDTHAT REALMOFVALUES THE,UBAVITCH2EBBE &ORBETTERORWORSE THOUGH WHO WAS LIVING IN #ROWN RELIGIONISMUCHMORETHANA (EIGHTS "ROOKLYN WASTHE SETOFETHICALPRINCIPLESORA -ESSIAH ANDTHATTHEWORLD VAGUESENSEOFTRANSCENDENCE WASSOONTOEND(EBELIEVED 4HEANTHROPOLOGIST%DWARD THATTHEEARTHWASAFEWTHOU 4YLORGOTITRIGHTIN WHEN SANDYEARSOLD ANDTHATTHE HENOTEDTHATTHEhMINIMUM FOSSIL RECORD WAS A CONSE DEFINITION OF RELIGIONv IS A QUENCEOFTHE'REAT&LOOD(ECOULDDESCRIBETHEAFTER BELIEFINSPIRITUALBEINGS INTHESUPERNATURAL-YRABBIS LIFE ANDWASABLETOANSWERADOLESCENTQUESTIONSABOUT SPECIlCCLAIMSWEREAMINORITYVIEWINTHECULTUREINWHICH THEFATEOF(ITLERSSOUL )WASRAISED BUTTHOSESORTSOFVIEWSˆABOUTTHECREATIONOF -YRABBIWASNOCRACKPOTHEWASANINTELLIGENTAND THEUNIVERSE THEENDOFTHEWORLD THEFATESOFSOULSˆDElNE AMIABLEMAN ATEACHERANDASCHOLAR"UTHEHELDVIEWSTHAT RELIGIONASBILLIONSOFPEOPLEUNDERSTANDANDPRACTICEIT STRUCKMEASSTRANGE EVENDISTURBING,IKEMANYSECULAR 4HE5NITED3TATESISAPOSTERCHILDFORSUPERNATURAL PEOPLE )AMCOMFORTABLEWITHRELIGIONASASOURCEOFSPIRI BELIEF*USTABOUTEVERYONEINTHISCOUNTRYˆPERCENT TUALITYANDTRANSCENDENCE TOLERANCEANDLOVE CHARITYAND INONEPOLLˆBELIEVESIN'OD7ELLOVERHALFOF!MERICANS GOODWORKS7HOCANOBJECTTOTHEFAITHOF-ARTIN,UTHER BELIEVEINMIRACLES THEDEVIL ANDANGELS-OSTBELIEVEIN +ING*RORTHE$ALAI,AMAˆATLEASTASLONGASTHATFAITH ANAFTERLIFEˆANDNOTJUSTINTHEMUSHYSENSETHATWEWILL GROUNDSMORALPOSITIONSONEALREADYACCEPTS) LIVEONINTHEMEMORIESOFOTHERPEOPLE ORIN 0AUL"LOOM APROFESSOR AMUNCOMFORTABLE HOWEVER WITHRELIGIONWHEN OFPSYCHOLOGYANDLIN OURGOODDEEDSWHENASKEDFORDETAILS MOST ITMAKESCLAIMSABOUTTHENATURALWORLD LETALONE GUISTICSAT9ALE ISTHE !MERICANSSAYTHEYBELIEVETHATAFTERDEATHTHEY AUTHOR OF $ESCAR TES AWORLDBEYONDNATURE)TISEASYFORTHOSEOFUS "ABY(OWTHE3CIENCE WILLACTUALLYREUNITEWITHRELATIVESANDGETTO WHOREJECTSUPERNATURALBELIEFSTOAGREEWITH3TE OF#HILD$EVELOPMENT MEET'OD7OODY!LLENONCESAID h)DONTWANT PHEN*AY'OULDTHATTHEBESTWAYTOACCORDDIG %XPLAINS7HAT-AKES TOACHIEVEIMMORTALITYTHROUGHMYWORK)WANT 5S (UMANAND (OW NITYANDRESPECTTOBOTHSCIENCEANDRELIGIONIS #HILDREN ,EARN THE TOACHIEVEITTHROUGHNOTDYINGv-OST!MERICANS TORECOGNIZETHATTHEYAPPLYTOhNON OVERLAPPING -EANINGS OF 7ORDS HAVEPRECISELYTHISEXPECTATION

7









"UT!MERICAISANANOMALY ISNTIT4HESESTATISTICSARE SOMETIMESTAKENASYETANOTHERINDICATIONOFHOWMUCH THISCOUNTRYDIFFERSFROM FORINSTANCE &RANCEAND'ERMANY WHERESECULARISMHOLDSGREATERSWAY!MERICANSAREFUN DAMENTALISTS THECLAIMGOES ISOLATEDFROMTHEINTELLECTUAL PROGRESSMADEBYTHERESTOFTHEWORLD 4HEREARETWOTHINGSWRONGWITHTHISCONCLUSION&IRST EVENIFAGAPBETWEEN!MERICAAND%UROPEEXISTS ITISNOT THE5NITED3TATESTHATISIDIOSYNCRATIC!FTERALL THEREST OFTHEWORLDˆ!SIA !FRICA THE-IDDLE%ASTˆISNOTEXACTLY lLLEDWITHHARD COREATHEISTS)FONEISTOTALKABOUTEXCEP TIONALISM ITAPPLIESTO%UROPE NOTTHE5NITED3TATES 3ECOND THERELIGIOUSDIVIDEBETWEEN!MERICANSAND %UROPEANSMAYBESMALLERTHANWETHINK4HESOCIOLOGISTS 2ODNEY3TARK OF"AYLOR5NIVERSITY AND2OGER&INKE OF0ENN SYLVANIA3TATE5NIVERSITY WRITETHATTHEBIGDIFFERENCEHASTO DOWITHCHURCHATTENDANCE WHICHREALLYISMUCHLOWERIN %UROPE"UILDINGONTHEWORKOFTHE#HICAGO BASEDSOCI OLOGISTANDPRIEST!NDREW'REELEY THEYARGUETHATTHISISBECAUSETHE 5NITED3TATESHASARIGOROUSLYFREE RELIGIOUSMARKET INWHICHCHURCHES ACTIVELYVIEFORPARISHIONERSAND CONSTANTLY IMPROVE THEIR PROD UCT WHEREAS%UROPEANCHURCHES AREOFTENUNDERSTATECONTROLAND LIKEMANYGOVERNMENTMONOPO LIES HAVEBECOMEINEFlCIENT -OST POLLS FROM %UROPEAN COUNTRIES SHOWTHATAMAJORITYOFTHEIRPEOPLE AREBELIEVERS#ONSIDER)CELAND4O JUDGEBYRATESOFCHURCHGOING )CE LANDISTHEMOSTSECULARCOUNTRYON EARTH WITHAPATHETICTWOPERCENT WEEKLYATTENDANCE"UTFOUROUTOFlVE)CELANDERSSAYTHATTHEY PRAY ANDTHESAMEPROPORTIONBELIEVEINLIFEAFTERDEATH )NTHE5NITED3TATESSOMELIBERALSCHOLARSPOSITADIF FERENTSORTOFEXCEPTIONALISM ARGUINGTHATBELIEFINTHE SUPERNATURALISFOUNDMOSTLYIN#HRISTIANCONSERVATIVESˆ THOSEINFAMOUSLYDESCRIBEDBYTHE7ASHINGTON0OST REPORTER -ICHAEL7EISSKOPFINAShLARGELYPOOR UNEDUCATED ANDEASYTOCOMMANDv-ANYPEOPLESAWTHEPRESI DENTIALELECTIONASPITTING!MERICANSWHOARERELIGIOUS AGAINSTTHOSEWHOARENOT !NARTICLEBY3TEVEN7ALDMANINTHEONLINEMAGAZINE 3LATEPROVIDESSOMEPERSPECTIVEONTHEDIVIDE

BELIEVE'ODGAVE)SRAELTOTHE*EWSANDTHATITSEXISTENCE FULlLLSTHEPROPHECYABOUTTHESECONDCOMINGOF*ESUS

4HEGROUPTHAT7ALDMANISTALKINGABOUTIS$EMOCRATSTHE HARD CORESUBGROUPIS!FRICAN !MERICAN$EMOCRATS &INALLY CONSIDERSCIENTISTS4HEYARELESSLIKELYTHANNON SCIENTISTSTOBERELIGIOUSˆBUTNOTBYAHUGEAMOUNT! POLLASKEDSCIENTISTSWHETHERTHEYBELIEVEDIN'OD ANDTHE POLLSTERSSETTHEBARHIGHˆNOMEALY MOUTHEDEVASIONSSUCH ASh)BELIEVEINTHETOTALITYOFALLTHATEXISTSvORhINWHAT ISBEAUTIFULANDUNKNOWNvRATHER THEYINSISTEDONAREAL BIBLICAL'OD ONEBELIEVERSCOULDPRAYTOANDACTUALLYGET ANANSWERFROM!BOUTPERCENTOFSCIENTISTSSAIDYESTOA BELIEFINTHISKINDOF'ODˆABOUTTHESAMEPERCENTAGEFOUND INASIMILARPOLLIN/NLYWHENWELOOKATTHEMOSTELITE SCIENTISTSˆMEMBERSOFTHE.ATIONAL!CADEMYOF3CIENCESˆ DOWElNDASTRONGMAJORITYOFATHEISTSANDAGNOSTICS 4HESEFACTSAREANEMBARRASSMENTFORTHOSEWHOSEE SUPERNATURALBELIEFSASACULTURAL ANACHRONISM SOONTOBEERODED BYSCIENTIlCDISCOVERIESANDTHE SPREADOFCOSMOPOLITANVALUES 4HEYREQUIREANEWTHEORYOFWHY WEARERELIGIOUSˆONETHATDRAWS ONRESEARCHINEVOLUTIONARYBIOL OGY COGNITIVENEUROSCIENCE AND DEVELOPMENTALPSYCHOLOGY )) / 0)!4%3!.$ & 2!4%2.)4)%3 NETRADITIONALAPPROACH TOTHEORIGINOFRELIGIOUS BELIEF BEGINS WITH THE OBSERVATIONTHATITISDIFlCULTTO BEAPERSON4HEREISEVILALLAROUNDEVERYONEWELOVEWILL DIEANDSOONWEOURSELVESWILLDIEˆEITHERSLOWLYANDPROB ABLYUNPLEASANTLYORQUICKLYANDPROBABLYUNPLEASANTLY&OR ALLBUTAPAMPEREDANDLUCKYFEWLIFEREALLYISNASTY BRUTISH ANDSHORT!NDIFOURLIVESHAVESOMEGREATERMEANING ITIS HARDLYOBVIOUS 3OPERHAPS AS-ARXSUGGESTED WEHAVEADOPTEDRELI GIONASANOPIATE TOSOOTHETHEPAINOFEXISTENCE!STHE PHILOSOPHER3USANNE+,ANGERHASPUTIT MANhCANNOTDEAL WITH#HAOSvSUPERNATURALBELIEFSSOLVETHEPROBLEMOFTHIS CHAOSBYPROVIDINGMEANING7EARENOTMERETHINGSWE ARELOVINGLYCRAFTEDBY'OD ANDSERVEHISPURPOSES2ELI GIONTELLSUSTHATTHISISAJUSTWORLD INWHICHTHEGOODWILL BEREWARDEDANDTHEEVILPUNISHED-OSTOFALL ITADDRESSES OURFEAROFDEATH&REUDSUMMEDITALLUPBYDESCRIBINGA hTHREE FOLDTASKvFORRELIGIOUSBELIEFShTHEYMUSTEXORCISE THETERRORSOFNATURE THEYMUSTRECONCILEMENTOTHECRUELTY OF&ATE PARTICULARLYASITISSHOWNINDEATH ANDTHEYMUST COMPENSATETHEMFORTHESUFFERINGSANDPRIVATIONSWHICH ACIVILIZEDLIFEINCOMMONHASIMPOSEDONTHEMv

%NTHUSIASMISBUILDING AMONGSCIENTISTSFOR THEVIEWTHATRELIGION EMERGEDNOTTOSERVEA PURPOSEˆNOTASAN OPIATEORASOCIALGLUEˆ BUTBYACCIDENT )TISABY PRODUCTOF BIOLOGICALADAPTATIONS GONEAWRY

!SYOUMAYALREADYKNOW ONEOF!MERICASTWOPOLITI CALPARTIESISEXTREMELYRELIGIOUS3IXTY ONEPERCENTOF THISPARTYSVOTERSSAYTHEYPRAYDAILYORMOREOFTEN!N ASTOUNDINGPERCENTOFTHEMBELIEVEINLIFEAFTERDEATH !NDTHERESAHARD CORESUBGROUPINTHISPARTYOFSUPER RELIGIOUS#HRISTIANZEALOTS6ERYCONSERVATIVEONGAYMAR RIAGE HALFOFTHEMEMBERSOFTHISSUBGROUPBELIEVE"USH USESTOOLITTLERELIGIOUSRHETORIC ANDPERCENTOFTHEM



5)&
"5- "/5*$
.0/5)-:


/

%&$&.#&3



2ELIGIONSCANSOMETIMESDOALLTHESETHINGS ANDIT WOULDBEUNREALISTICTODENYTHATTHISPARTLYEXPLAINSTHEIR EXISTENCE)NDEED SOMETIMESTHEOLOGIANSUSETHEFOREGO INGARGUMENTSTOMAKEACASEFORWHYWESHOULDBELIEVE IFONEWISHESFORPURPOSE MEANING ANDETERNALLIFE THERE ISNOWHERETOGOBUTTOWARD'OD /NEPROBLEMWITHTHISVIEWISTHAT ASTHECOGNITIVE SCIENTIST3TEVEN0INKERREMINDSUS WEDONTTYPICALLYGET SOLACEFROMPROPOSITIONSTHATWEDONTALREADYBELIEVETOBE TRUE(UNGRYPEOPLEDONTCHEERTHEMSELVESUPBYBELIEV INGTHATTHEYJUSTHADALARGEMEAL(EAVENISAREASSURING NOTIONONLYINSOFARASPEOPLEBELIEVESUCHAPLACEEXISTS ITISTHISBELIEFTHATANADEQUATETHEORYOFRELIGIONHASTO EXPLAININTHElRSTPLACE !LSO THERELIGION AS OPIATETHEORYlTSBESTWITHTHE MONOTHEISTICRELIGIONSMOSTFAMILIARTOUS"UTWHATABOUT THOSEPEOPLEMOSTOFTHERELIGIOUSPEOPLEINTHEWORLD WHODONOTBELIEVEINANALL WISE AND JUST 'OD %VERY SOCIETYBELIEVESINSPIRITUAL BEINGS BUT THEY ARE OFTEN STUPIDORMALEVOLENT-ANY RELIGIONSSIMPLYDONTDEAL WITHMETAPHYSICALORTELEO LOGICALQUESTIONSGODSAND ANCESTOR SPIRITS ARE CALLED UPONONLYTOHELPCOPEWITH SUCHMUNDANEPROBLEMSAS HOW TO PREPARE FOOD AND WHATTODOWITHACORPSEˆNOT TOELUCIDATETHE-EANINGOF )T!LL!SFORTHEREASSURANCE OFHEAVEN JUSTICE ORSALVA TION AGAIN ITEXISTSINSOME RELIGIONSBUTBYNOMEANSALL )NFACT EVENTHOSERELIGIONS WEAREMOSTFAMILIARWITHARENOTALWAYSREASSURING) KNOWSOMEOLDER#HRISTIANSWHOWEREMADEMISERABLEAS CHILDRENBYWORRIESABOUTETERNALDAMNATIONTHEPROSPECT OFOBLIVIONWOULDHAVEBEENFARPREFERABLE 3OTHEOPIATE THEORYISULTIMATELYANUNSATISFYINGEXPLANATIONFORTHE EXISTENCEOFRELIGION 4HEMAJORALTERNATIVETHEORYISSOCIALRELIGIONBRINGS PEOPLETOGETHER GIVINGTHEMANEDGEOVERTHOSEWHOLACK THISSOCIALGLUE3OMETIMESTHISARGUMENTISPRESENTEDIN CULTURALTERMS ANDSOMETIMESITISSEENFROMANEVOLU TIONARYPERSPECTIVESURVIVALOFTHElTTESTWORKINGATTHE LEVELNOTOFTHEGENEORTHEINDIVIDUALBUTOFTHESOCIAL GROUP)NEITHERCASETHECLAIMISTHATRELIGIONTHRIVES BECAUSEGROUPSTHATHAVEITOUTGROWANDOUTLASTTHOSE THATDONOT )NTHISCONCEPTIONRELIGIONISAFRATERNITY ANDTHEANAL OGYRUNSDEEP*USTASFRATERNITIESUSEDTOPADDLEFRESHMEN ONTHEREARENDTOINSTILLLOYALTYANDCOMMITMENT RELIGIONS *4
(0%
"/
"$$*%&/5


HAVEPAINFULINITIATIONRITESˆFOREXAMPLE SNIPPINGOFFPART OFTHEPENIS!LSO CERTAINPUZZLINGFEATURESOFMANYRELI GIONS SUCHASDIETARYRESTRICTIONSANDDISTINCTIVEDRESS MAKEPERFECTSENSEONCETHEYAREVIEWEDASTOOLSTOENSURE GROUPSOLIDARITY 4HEFRATERNITYTHEORYALSOEXPLAINSWHYRELIGIONSARE SOHARSHTOWARDTHOSEWHODONOTSHARETHEFAITH RESERV INGPARTICULARIREFORAPOSTATES4HISISCLEARINTHE/LD 4ESTAMENT INWHICHhAJEALOUS'ODvISSUESCOMMANDS SUCHAS 3HOULDYOURBROTHER YOURMOTHERSSON ORYOURSONORYOUR DAUGHTERORTHEWIFEOFYOURBOSOMORYOURCOMPANION WHOISLIKEYOUROWNSELFINCITEYOUINSECRET SAYING@,ET USGOANDWORSHIPOTHERGODSxYOUSHALLSURELYKILLHIM 9OURHANDSHALLBEAGAINSTHIMlRSTTOPUTHIMTODEATH ANDTHEHANDOFALLTHEPEOPLELAST!NDYOUSHALLSTONEHIM ANDHESHALLDIE FORHESOUGHTTOTHRUSTYOUAWAYFROMTHE ,/2$YOUR'ODWHOBROUGHT YOUOUTOFTHELANDOF%GYPT FROM THE HOUSE OF SLAVES ˆ$EUTERONOMY n

4 H IS T HEOR Y EX PLA I NS ALMOSTEVERYTHINGABOUTRELI GIONˆEXCEPT THE RELIGIOUS PART)TISCLEARTHATRITUALS ANDSACRIlCESCANBRINGPEO PLETOGETHER ANDITMAYWELL BETHATAGROUPTHATDOESSUCH THINGSHASANADVANTAGEOVER ONETHATDOESNOT"UTITISNOT CLEARWHYARELIGIONHASTOBE INVOLVED7HYAREGODS SOULS ANAFTERLIFE MIRACLES DIVINE CREATIONOFTHEUNIVERSE AND SOONBROUGHTIN4HETHEORY DOESNTEXPLAINWHATWEARE MOSTINTERESTEDIN WHICHISBELIEFINTHESUPERNATURAL )))" /$)%3!.$ 3 /5,3 NTHUSIASMISBUILDINGAMONGSCIENTISTSFORAQUITE DIFFERENTVIEWˆTHATRELIGIONEMERGEDNOTTOSERVEA PURPOSEBUTBYACCIDENT 4HISISNOTAVALUEJUDGMENT-ANYOFTHEGOODTHINGS INLIFEARE FROMANEVOLUTIONARYPERSPECTIVE ACCIDENTS 0EOPLESOMETIMESGIVEMONEY TIME ANDEVENBLOODTO HELPUNKNOWNSTRANGERSINFARAWAYCOUNTRIESWHOMTHEY WILLNEVERSEE&ROMTHEPERSPECTIVEOFONESGENESTHISIS DISASTROUSˆTHESUICIDALSQUANDERINGOFRESOURCESFORNO BENElT"UTITSORIGINISNOTMAGICALLONG DISTANCEALTRUISM ISMOSTLIKELYABY PRODUCTOFOTHER MOREADAPTIVETRAITS SUCHASEMPATHYANDABSTRACTREASONING3IMILARLY THERE ISNOREPRODUCTIVEADVANTAGETOTHEPLEASUREWEGETFROM PAINTINGSORMOVIES)TJUSTSOHAPPENSTHATOUREYESAND BRAINS WHICHEVOLVEDTOREACTTOTHREE DIMENSIONALOBJECTS

%

5)&
"5- "/5*$
.0/5)-:




INTHEREALWORLD CANRESPONDTOTWO DIMENSIONALPROJEC TIONSONACANVASORASCREEN 3UPERNATURALBELIEFSMIGHTBEEXPLAINEDINASIMILARWAY 4HISISTHERELIGION AS ACCIDENTTHEORYTHATEMERGESFROMMY WORKANDTHEWORKOFCOGNITIVESCIENTISTSSUCHAS3COTT!TRAN 0ASCAL"OYER *USTIN"ARRETT AND$EBORAH+ELEMEN/NEVER SIONOFTHISTHEORYBEGINSWITHTHENOTIONTHATADISTINCTION BETWEENTHEPHYSICALANDTHEPSYCHOLOGICALISFUNDAMENTAL TOHUMANTHOUGHT0URELYPHYSICALTHINGS SUCHASROCKSAND TREES ARESUBJECTTOTHEPITILESSLAWSOF.EWTON4HROWA ROCK ANDITWILLmYTHROUGHSPACEONACERTAINPATHIFYOU PUTABRANCHONTHEGROUND ITWILLNOTDISAPPEAR SCAMPER AWAY ORmYINTOSPACE0SYCHOLOGICALTHINGS SUCHASPEOPLE POSSESSMINDS INTENTIONS BELIEFS GOALS ANDDESIRES4HEY MOVEUNEXPECTEDLY ACCORDINGTOVOLITIONANDWHIMTHEY CANCHASEORRUNAWAY4HEREISAMORALDIFFERENCEASWELL AROCKCANNOTBEEVILORKINDAPERSONCAN 7HEREDOESTHEDISTINCTIONBETWEENTHEPHYSICALAND THEPSYCHOLOGICALCOMEFROM)S ITSOMETHINGWELEARNTHROUGH EXPERIENCE ORISITSOMEHOWPRE WIREDINTOOURBRAINS/NEWAY TOlNDOUTISTOSTUDYBABIES)TIS NOTORIOUSLYDIFlCULTTOKNOWWHAT BABIESARETHINKING GIVENTHAT THEYCANTSPEAKANDHAVELITTLE CONTROLOVERTHEIRBODIES4HEY ARE HARDER TO TEST THAN RATS OR PIGEONS BECAUSETHEYCANNOTRUN MAZESORPECKLEVERS "UTRECENTLY INVESTIGATORSHAVEUSEDTHETECH NIQUEOFSHOWINGTHEMDIFFERENT EVENTSANDRECORDINGHOWLONG THEYLOOKATTHEM EXPLOITINGTHE FACTTHATBABIES LIKETHERESTOF US TENDTOLOOKLONGERATSOMETHINGTHEYlNDUNUSUALOR BIZARRE 4HISHASLEDTOASERIESOFSTRIKINGDISCOVERIES3IX MONTH OLDSUNDERSTANDTHATPHYSICALOBJECTSOBEYGRAVITY )FYOUPUTANOBJECTONATABLEANDTHENREMOVETHETABLE ANDTHEOBJECTJUSTSTAYSTHEREHELDBYAHIDDENWIRE BABIESARESURPRISEDTHEYEXPECTTHEOBJECTTOFALL4HEY EXPECTOBJECTSTOBESOLID ANDCONTRARYTOWHATISSTILLBEING TAUGHTINSOMEPSYCHOLOGYCLASSES THEYUNDERSTANDTHAT OBJECTSPERSISTOVERTIMEEVENIFHIDDEN3HOWABABYAN OBJECTANDTHENPUTITBEHINDASCREEN7AITALITTLEWHILE ANDTHENREMOVETHESCREEN)FTHEOBJECTISGONE THEBABY ISSURPRISED &IVE MONTH OLDSCANEVENDOSIMPLEMATH APPRECIATINGTHATIFlRSTONEOBJECTANDTHENANOTHERIS PLACEDBEHINDASCREEN WHENTHESCREENDROPSTHERESHOULD BETWOOBJECTS NOTONEORTHREE/THEREXPERIMENTSlND THESAMENUMERICALUNDERSTANDINGINNONHUMANPRIMATES INCLUDINGMACAQUESANDTAMARINS ANDINDOGS 3IMILARLYPRECOCIOUSCAPACITIESSHOWUPININFANTS

UNDERSTANDINGOFTHESOCIALWORLD.EWBORNSPREFERTO LOOKATFACESOVERANYTHINGELSE ANDTHESOUNDSTHEYMOST LIKETOHEARAREHUMANVOICESˆPREFERABLYTHEIRMOTHERS 4HEYQUICKLYCOMETORECOGNIZEDIFFERENTEMOTIONS SUCH ASANGER FEAR ANDHAPPINESS ANDRESPONDAPPROPRIATELY TOTHEM"EFORETHEYAREAYEAROLDTHEYCANDETERMINE THETARGETOFANADULTSGAZE ANDCANLEARNBYATTENDING TOTHEEMOTIONSOFOTHERSIFABABYISCRAWLINGTOWARDAN AREATHATMIGHTBEDANGEROUSANDANADULTMAKESAHOR RIlEDORDISGUSTEDFACE THEBABYUSUALLYKNOWSENOUGH TOSTAYAWAY !SKEPTICMIGHTARGUETHATTHESESOCIALCAPACITIESCAN BEEXPLAINEDASASETOFPRIMITIVERESPONSES BUTTHERE ISSOMEEVIDENCETHATTHEYREmECTADEEPERUNDERSTAND ING&ORINSTANCE WHENTWELVE MONTH OLDSSEEONEOBJECT CHASINGANOTHER THEYSEEMTOUNDERSTANDTHATITREALLYIS CHASING WITHTHEGOALOFCATCHINGTHEYEXPECTTHECHASER TOCONTINUEITSPURSUITALONGTHEMOSTDIRECTPATH ANDARE SURPRISEDWHENITDOESOTHERWISE )NSOMEWORK)VEDONEWITHTHE PSYCHOLOGISTS6ALERIE+UHLMEIER OF1UEENS5NIVERSITY AND+AREN 7YNN OF 9ALE WE FOUND THAT WHENBABIESSEEONECHARACTERIN AMOVIEHELPANINDIVIDUALANDA DIFFERENTCHARACTERHURTTHATINDI VIDUAL THEYLATEREXPECTTHEINDI VIDUALTOAPPROACHTHECHARACTER THATHELPEDITANDTOAVOIDTHEONE THATHURTIT 5NDERSTANDINGOFTHEPHYSICAL WORLDANDUNDERSTANDINGOFTHE SOCIALWORLDCANBESEENASAKINTO TWODISTINCTCOMPUTERSINABABYS BRAIN RUNNINGSEPARATEPROGRAMS ANDPERFORMINGSEPARATETASKS4HEUNDERSTANDINGSDEVELOP ATDIFFERENTRATESTHESOCIALONEEMERGESSOMEWHATLATER THANTHEPHYSICALONE4HEYEVOLVEDATDIFFERENTPOINTSIN OURPREHISTORYOURPHYSICALUNDERSTANDINGISSHAREDBY MANYSPECIES WHEREASOURSOCIALUNDERSTANDINGISARELA TIVELYRECENTADAPTATION ANDINSOMEREGARDSMIGHTBE UNIQUELYHUMAN 4HATTHESETWOSYSTEMSAREDISTINCTISESPECIALLYAPPAR ENTINAUTISM ADEVELOPMENTALDISORDERWHOSEDOMINANT FEATUREISALACKOFSOCIALUNDERSTANDING#HILDRENWITH AUTISMTYPICALLYSHOWIMPAIRMENTSINCOMMUNICATION ABOUTATHIRDDONOTSPEAKATALL INIMAGINATIONTHEY TENDNOTTOENGAGEINIMAGINATIVEPLAY ANDMOSTOFALLIN SOCIALIZATION4HEYDONOTSEEMTOENJOYTHECOMPANYOF OTHERSTHEYDONTHUGTHEYAREHARDTOREACHOUTTO)N THEMOSTEXTREMECASESCHILDRENWITHAUTISMSEEPEOPLEAS NOTHINGMORETHANOBJECTSˆOBJECTSTHATMOVEINUNPRE DICTABLEWAYSANDMAKEUNEXPECTEDNOISESANDARETHERE FOREFRIGHTENING4HEIRUNDERSTANDINGOFOTHERMINDSIS

7ESEETHEWORLDOF OBJECTSASSEPARATEFROM THEWORLDOFMINDS ALLOWINGUSTOENVISION SOULSANDANAFTERLIFE ANDOURSYSTEMOF SOCIALUNDERSTANDING INFERSGOALSANDDESIRES WHERENONEEXIST MAKINGUSANIMISTS ANDCREATIONISTS




5)&
"5- "/5*$
.0/5)-:


%&$&.#&3


IMPAIRED THOUGHTHEIRUNDERSTANDINGOFMATERIALOBJECTS ISFULLYINTACT !TTHISPOINTTHERELIGION AS ACCIDENTTHEORYSAYSNOTHING ABOUTSUPERNATURALBELIEFS"ABIESHAVETWOSYSTEMSTHAT WORKINACOLD BLOODEDLYRATIONALWAYTOHELPTHEMANTICI PATEANDUNDERSTANDˆAND WHENTHEYGETOLDER TOMANIPU LATEˆPHYSICALANDSOCIALENTITIES)NOTHERWORDS BOTHTHESE SYSTEMSAREBIOLOGICALADAPTATIONSTHATGIVEHUMANBEINGSA BADLYNEEDEDHEADSTARTINDEALINGWITHOBJECTSANDPEOPLE "UTTHESESYSTEMSGOAWRYINTWOIMPORTANTWAYSTHATARE THEFOUNDATIONSOFRELIGION&IRST WEPERCEIVETHEWORLDOF OBJECTSASESSENTIALLYSEPARATEFROMTHEWORLDOFMINDS MAK INGITPOSSIBLEFORUSTOENVISIONSOULLESSBODIESANDBODILESS SOULS4HISHELPSEXPLAINWHYWEBELIEVEINGODSANDAN AFTERLIFE3ECOND ASWEWILLSEE OURSYSTEMOFSOCIALUNDER STANDINGOVERSHOOTS INFERRINGGOALSANDDESIRESWHERENONE EXIST4HISMAKESUSANIMISTSANDCREATIONISTS )6. !452!, "/2. $ 5!,)343 ORTHOSEOFUSWHOARE NOTAUTISTIC THESEPAR ATENESS OF THESE TWO MECHANISMS ONEFORUNDER STANDINGTHEPHYSICALWORLD ANDONEFORUNDERSTANDING THESOCIALWORLD GIVERISETO ADUALITYOFEXPERIENCE7E EXPERIENCETHEWORLDOFMATE RIALTHINGSASSEPARATEFROM THEWORLDOFGOALSANDDESIRES 4HEBIGGESTCONSEQUENCEHAS TODOWITHTHEWAYWETHINK OFOURSELVESANDOTHERS7E AREDUALISTSITSEEMSINTUI TIVELYOBVIOUSTHATAPHYSICAL BODYANDACONSCIOUSENTITYˆAMINDORSOULˆAREGENUINELY DISTINCT7EDONTFEELTHATWEAREOURBODIES2ATHER WE FEELTHATWEOCCUPYTHEM WEPOSSESSTHEM WEOWNTHEM 4HISDUALITYISIMMEDIATELYAPPARENTINOURIMAGINATIVE LIFE"ECAUSEWESEEPEOPLEASSEPARATEFROMTHEIRBODIES WEEASILYUNDERSTANDSITUATIONSINWHICHPEOPLESBODIES ARERADICALLYCHANGEDWHILETHEIRPERSONHOODSTAYSINTACT +AFKAENVISIONEDAMANTRANSFORMEDINTOAGIGANTICINSECT (OMERDESCRIBEDTHEPLIGHTOFMENTRANSFORMEDINTOPIGS IN3HREKANOGREISTRANSFORMEDINTOAHUMANBEING AND ADONKEYINTOASTEEDIN3TAR4REKASCHEMINGVILLAINFORC IBLYOCCUPIES#APTAIN+IRKSBODYSOASTOTAKECOMMAND OFTHE%NTERPRISEIN4HE4ALEOFTHE"ODY4HIEF !NNE2ICE TELLSOFAVAMPIREANDAHUMANBEINGWHOAGREETOTRADE BODIESFORADAYANDIN'OINGONATEENAGERWAKESUP ASTHIRTY YEAR OLD*ENNIFER'ARNER7EDONTTHINKOFTHESE EVENTSASREAL OFCOURSE BUTTHEYAREFULLYUNDERSTANDABLE ITMAKESINTUITIVESENSETOUSTHATPEOPLECANBESEPARATED

&

*4
(0%
"/
"$$*%&/5


FROMTHEIRBODIES ANDSIMILARTRANSFORMATIONSSHOWUPIN RELIGIONSAROUNDTHEWORLD 4HISNOTIONOFANIMMATERIALSOULPOTENTIALLYSEPA RABLEFROMTHEBODYCLASHESSTARKLYWITHTHESCIENTIlC VIEW&ORPSYCHOLOGISTSANDNEUROSCIENTISTS THEBRAINIS THESOURCEOFMENTALLIFEOURCONSCIOUSNESS EMOTIONS ANDWILLARETHEPRODUCTSOFNEURALPROCESSES!STHECLAIM ISSOMETIMESPUT 4HEMINDISWHATTHEBRAINDOES)DONT WANTTOOVERSTATETHECONSENSUSHERETHEREISNOACCEPTED THEORYASTOPRECISELYHOWTHISHAPPENS ANDSOMESCHOL ARSARESKEPTICALTHATWEWILLEVERDEVELOPSUCHATHEORY "UTNOSCIENTISTTAKESSERIOUSLY#ARTESIANDUALISM WHICH POSITSTHATTHINKINGNEEDNOTINVOLVETHEBRAIN4HEREIS JUSTTOOMUCHEVIDENCEAGAINSTIT 3TILL ITFEELSRIGHT EVENTOTHOSEWHOHAVENEVERHAD RELIGIOUSTRAINING ANDEVENTOYOUNGCHILDREN4HISBECAME PARTICULARLYCLEARTOMEONENIGHTWHEN)WASARGUINGWITH MYSIX YEAR OLDSON -AX) WASTELLINGHIMTHATHEHADTO GOTOBED ANDHESAID h9OU CANMAKEMEGOTOBED BUT YOUCANTMAKEMEGOTOSLEEP )TSMYBRAIN
v4HISPIQUED MYINTEREST SO)BEGANTOASK HIM QUESTIONS ABOUT WHAT THEBRAINDOESANDDOESNOT DO(ISANSWERSSHOWEDAN INTERESTINGSPLIT(EINSISTED THATTHEBRAINWASINVOLVEDIN PERCEPTIONˆINSEEING HEAR ING TASTING ANDSMELLINGˆ ANDHEWASADAMANTTHATIT WASRESPONSIBLEFORTHINKING "UT HESAID THEBRAINWASNOT ESSENTIALFORDREAMING FOR FEELINGSAD ORFORLOVINGHIS BROTHERh4HATSWHAT) DO v-AXSAID hTHOUGHMYBRAIN MIGHTHELPMEOUTv -AXISNOTUNUSUAL#HILDRENINOURCULTUREARETAUGHT THATTHEBRAINISINVOLVEDINTHINKING BUTTHEYINTERPRET THISINANARROWSENSE ASREFERRINGTOCONSCIOUSPROBLEM SOLVING ACADEMICRUMINATION4HEYDONOTSEETHEBRAIN ASTHESOURCEOFCONSCIOUSEXPERIENCETHEYDONOTIDEN TIFYITWITHTHEIRSELVES4HEYAPPEARTOTHINKOFITASA COGNITIVEPROSTHESISˆTHEREIS-AXTHEPERSON ANDTHEN THEREISHISBRAIN WHICHHEUSESTOSOLVEPROBLEMSJUSTAS HEMIGHTUSEACOMPUTER)NTHISCOMMONSENSECONCEP TIONTHEBRAINIS AS3TEVEN0INKERPUTSIT hAPOCKET0# FORTHESOULv )FBODIESANDSOULSARETHOUGHTOFASSEPARATE THERE CANBEBODIESWITHOUTSOULS!CORPSEISSEENASABODY THATUSEDTOHAVEASOUL-OSTTHINGSˆCHAIRS CUPS TREESˆ NEVERHADSOULSTHEYNEVERHADWILLORCONSCIOUSNESS!T LEASTSOMENONHUMANANIMALSARESEENINTHESAMEWAY 5)&
"5- "/5*$
.0/5)-:




ASWHAT$ESCARTESDESCRIBEDAShBEAST MACHINES vORCOM PLEXAUTOMATA3OMEARTIlCIALCREATURES SUCHASINDUSTRIAL ROBOTS (AITIANZOMBIES AND*EWISHGOLEMS AREALSOSEEN ASSOULLESSBEINGS LACKINGFREEWILLORMORALFEELING 4HENTHEREARESOULSWITHOUTBODIES-OSTPEOPLE) KNOWBELIEVEINA'ODWHOCREATEDTHEUNIVERSE PERFORMS MIRACLES ANDLISTENSTOPRAYERS(EISOMNIPOTENTANDOMNI SCIENT POSSESSINGINlNITEKINDNESS JUSTICE ANDMERCY"UT HEDOESNOTINANYLITERALSENSEHAVEABODY3OMEPEOPLE ALSOBELIEVEINLESSERNONCORPOREALBEINGSTHATCANTEMPO RARILYTAKEPHYSICALFORMOROCCUPYHUMANBEINGSORANI MALSEXAMPLESINCLUDEANGELS GHOSTS POLTERGEISTS SUCCUBI DYBBUKS ANDTHEDEMONSTHAT*ESUSSOFREQUENTLYEXPELLED FROMPEOPLESBODIES 4HISBELIEFSYSTEMOPENSTHEPOSSIBILITYTHATWEOUR SELVESCANSURVIVETHEDEATHOFOURBODIES-OSTPEOPLE BELIEVETHATWHENTHEBODYISDESTROYED THESOULLIVESON )TMIGHTASCENDTOHEAVEN DESCENDTOHELL GOOFFINTOSOME SORTOFPARALLELWORLD OROCCUPY SOMEOTHERBODY HUMANORANI MAL)NDEED THEBELIEFTHATTHE WORLDTEEMSWITHANCESTORSPIR ITSˆTHESOULSOFPEOPLEWHOHAVE BEENLIBERATEDFROMTHEIRBODIES THROUGHDEATHˆISCOMMONACROSS CULTURES7ECANIMAGINEOURBOD IESBEINGDESTROYED OURBRAINS CEASINGTOFUNCTION OURBONES TURNINGTODUST BUTITISHARDERˆ SOMEWOULDSAYIMPOSSIBLEˆTO IMAGINETHEENDOFOURVERYEXIS TENCE4HENOTIONOFASOULWITHOUT ABODYMAKESSENSETOUS /THERSHAVEARGUEDTHATRATHER THAN BELIEVING IN AN AFTERLIFE BECAUSEWEAREDUALISTS WEAREDUALISTSBECAUSEWEWANTTO BELIEVEINANAFTERLIFE4HISWAS&REUDSPOSITION(ESPECU LATEDTHATTHEhDOCTRINEOFTHESOULvEMERGEDASASOLUTIONTO THEPROBLEMOFDEATHIFSOULSEXIST THENCONSCIOUSEXPERI ENCENEEDNOTCOMETOANEND/RPERHAPSTHEMOTIVATION FORBELIEFINANAFTERLIFEISCULTURALWEBELIEVEITBECAUSE RELIGIOUSAUTHORITIESTELLUSTHATITISSO POSSIBLYBECAUSEIT SERVESTHEINTERESTSOFPOWERFULLEADERSTOCONTROLTHEMASSES THROUGHTHECARROTOFHEAVENANDTHESTICKOFHELL"UTTHERE ISREASONTOFAVORTHERELIGION AS ACCIDENTTHEORY )NASIGNIlCANTSTUDYTHEPSYCHOLOGISTS*ESSE"ERING OFTHE5NIVERSITYOF!RKANSAS AND$AVID"JORKLUND OF &LORIDA!TLANTIC5NIVERSITY TOLDYOUNGCHILDRENASTORY ABOUTANALLIGATORANDAMOUSE COMPLETEWITHASERIESOF PICTURES THATENDEDINTRAGEDYh5HOH
-R!LLIGATORSEES "ROWN-OUSEANDISCOMINGTOGETHIM
v;4HECHILDREN WERESHOWNAPICTUREOFTHEALLIGATOREATINGTHEMOUSE= h7ELL ITLOOKSLIKE"ROWN-OUSEGOTEATENBY-R!LLIGATOR "ROWN-OUSEISNOTALIVEANYMOREv

4HEEXPERIMENTERSASKEDTHECHILDRENASETOFQUESTIONS ABOUTTHEMOUSESBIOLOGICALFUNCTIONINGˆSUCHASh.OW THATTHEMOUSEISNOLONGERALIVE WILLHEEVERNEEDTOGO TOTHEBATHROOM$OHISEARSSTILLWORK$OESHISBRAIN STILLWORK vˆANDABOUTTHEMOUSESMENTALFUNCTIONING SUCHASh.OWTHATTHEMOUSEISNOLONGERALIVE ISHESTILL HUNGRY)SHETHINKINGABOUTTHEALLIGATOR$OESHESTILL WANTTOGOHOMEv !SPREDICTED WHENASKEDABOUTBIOLOGICALPROPERTIES THECHILDRENAPPRECIATEDTHEEFFECTSOFDEATHNONEEDFOR BATHROOMBREAKSTHEEARSDONTWORK ANDNEITHERDOES THEBRAIN4HEMOUSESBODYISGONE"UTWHENASKED ABOUTTHEPSYCHOLOGICALPROPERTIES MORETHANHALFTHE CHILDRENSAIDTHATTHESEWOULDCONTINUETHEDEADMOUSE CANFEELHUNGER THINKTHOUGHTS ANDHAVEDESIRES4HE SOULSURVIVES!NDCHILDRENBELIEVETHISMORETHANADULTSDO SUGGESTINGTHATALTHOUGHWEHAVETOLEARNWHICHSPECIlC AFTERLIFEPEOPLEINOURCULTUREBELIEVEINHEAVEN REINCAR NATION ASPIRITWORLD ANDSOON THENOTIONTHATLIFEAFTERDEATHIS POSSIBLEISNOTLEARNEDATALL)TIS ABY PRODUCTOFHOWWENATURALLY THINKABOUTTHEWORLD

.OBODYISBORNWITH THEIDEATHATHUMANITY STARTEDINTHE'ARDEN OF%DEN ORTHATMARTYRS WILLBEREWARDEDIN HEAVENTHESEIDEAS ARELEARNED"UTTHE UNIVERSALTHEMESOF RELIGIONARENOT LEARNED4HEYAREPART OFHUMANNATURE




5)&
"5- "/5*$
.0/5)-:


6 7 %6% % 6/,6%$ 4/ " % # 2%!4)/.)343

4

HISISJUSTHALFTHESTORY/UR DUALISMMAKESITPOSSIBLE FORUSTOTHINKOFSUPERNAT URALENTITIESANDEVENTSITISWHY SUCHTHINGSMAKESENSE"UTTHERE ISANOTHERFACTORTHATMAKESTHE PERCEPTIONOFTHEMCOMPELLING OFTENIRRESISTIBLE7EHAVEWHAT THEANTHROPOLOGIST0ASCAL"OYER HASCALLEDAHYPERTROPHYOFSOCIALCOGNITION7ESEEPUR POSE INTENTION DESIGN EVENWHENITISNOTTHERE )NTHESOCIALPSYCHOLOGISTS&RITZ(EIDERAND -ARY !NN3IMMELMADEASIMPLEMOVIEINWHICHGEOMET RIClGURESˆCIRCLES SQUARES TRIANGLESˆMOVEDINCERTAIN SYSTEMATICWAYS DESIGNEDTOTELLATALE7HENSHOWNTHIS MOVIE PEOPLEINSTINCTIVELYDESCRIBETHElGURESASIFTHEY WERESPECIlCTYPESOFPEOPLEBULLIES VICTIMS HEROES WITH GOALSANDDESIRES ANDREPEATPRETTYMUCHTHESAMESTORY THATTHEPSYCHOLOGISTSINTENDEDTOTELL&URTHERRESEARCHHAS FOUNDTHATBOUNDEDlGURESARENTEVENNECESSARYˆONECAN GETMUCHTHESAMEEFFECTINMOVIESWHERETHEhCHARACTERSv ARENOTSINGLEOBJECTSBUTMOVINGGROUPS SUCHASSWARMS OFTINYSQUARES 3TEWART'UTHRIE ANANTHROPOLOGISTAT&ORDHAM5NIVER SITY WASTHElRSTMODERNSCHOLARTONOTICETHEIMPORTANCE OFTHISTENDENCYASANEXPLANATIONFORRELIGIOUSTHOUGHT)N HISBOOK&ACESINTHE#LOUDS 'UTHRIEPRESENTSANECDOTES ANDEXPERIMENTSSHOWINGTHATPEOPLEATTRIBUTEHUMAN %&$&.#&3


CHARACTERISTICSTOASTRIKINGRANGEOFREAL WORLDENTITIES INCLUDINGBICYCLES BOTTLES CLOUDS lRE LEAVES RAIN VOLCA NOES ANDWIND7EAREHYPERSENSITIVETOSIGNSOFHUMAN AGENCYˆSOMUCHSOTHATWESEEINTENTIONWHEREONLYARTI lCEORACCIDENTEXISTS!S'UTHRIEPUTSIT THECLOTHESHAVE NOEMPEROR /UR QUICKNESS TO OVER READ PURPOSE INTO THINGS EXTENDSTOTHEPERCEPTIONOFINTENTIONALDESIGN0EOPLE HAVEATERRIBLEEYEFORRANDOMNESS)FYOUSHOWTHEMA STRINGOFHEADSANDTAILSTHATWASPRODUCEDBYARANDOM NUMBERGENERATOR THEYTENDTOTHINKITISRIGGEDˆITLOOKS ORDERLYTOTHEM TOOORDERLY!FTERPEOPLECLAIMEDTO SEE3ATANINTHEBILLOWINGSMOKEFROMTHE7ORLD4RADE #ENTER"EFORETHATSOMEPEOPLEWERESTIRREDBYTHE.UN "UN ABAKEDGOODTHATBOREANEERIERESEMBLANCETO -OTHER4ERESA)N.OVEMBEROFSOMEONEPOSTEDON E"AYATEN YEAR OLDGRILLED CHEESESANDWICHTHATLOOKED REMARKABLYLIKETHE6IRGIN -ARYITSOLDFOR )N RESPONSEPRANKSTERSPOSTED A GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH BEARINGIMAGESOFTHE/LSEN TWINS -ARY +ATE AND !SH LEY 4HEREARETHOSEWHOLIS TENTOTHESTATICFROMRADIOS ANDOTHERELECTRONICDEVICES ANDHEARMESSAGESFROMDEAD PEOPLEˆAPHENOMENONPRE SENTEDWITHGREATSERIOUSNESS INTHE-ICHAEL+EATONMOVIE 7HITE .OISE /LDER READERS WHO LIVED THEIR FORMATIVE YEARSBEFORE#$SAND- 0%'S MIGHT REMEMBER LISTENING INTENTLYFORTHESIGNIFICANT ANDSOMETIMESSCATOLOGICAL MESSAGESTHATWERESAIDTOCOMEFROMRECORDSPLAYED BACKWARD 3OMETIMESTHEREREALLYARESIGNSOFNONRANDOMAND FUNCTIONALDESIGN7EARENOTBEINGUNREASONABLEWHEN WEOBSERVETHATTHEEYESEEMSTOBECRAFTEDFORSEEING ORTHATTHELEAFINSECTSEEMSCOLOREDWITHTHEGOALOF LOOKINGVERYMUCHLIKEALEAF4HEEVOLUTIONARYBIOLOGIST 2ICHARD$AWKINSBEGINS4HE"LIND7ATCHMAKERBYCON CEDINGTHISPOINTh"IOLOGYISTHESTUDYOFCOMPLICATED THINGSTHATGIVETHEAPPEARANCEOFHAVINGBEENDESIGNED FORAPURPOSEv$AWKINSGOESONTOSUGGESTTHATANYONE BEFORE$ARWINWHODIDNOTBELIEVEIN'ODWASSIMPLY NOTPAYINGATTENTION $ARWINCHANGEDEVERYTHING(ISGREATINSIGHTWASTHAT ONECOULDEXPLAINCOMPLEXANDADAPTIVEDESIGNWITHOUT POSITINGADIVINEDESIGNER.ATURALSELECTIONCANBESIMU LATEDONACOMPUTERINFACT GENETICALGORITHMS WHICH MIMICNATURALSELECTION AREUSEDTOSOLVEOTHERWISEINTRAC *4
(0%
"/
"$$*%&/5


TABLECOMPUTATIONALPROBLEMS!NDWECANSEENATURAL SELECTIONATWORKINCASESTUDIESACROSSTHEWORLD FROMTHE EVOLUTIONOFBEAKSIZEIN'ALÉPAGOSlNCHESTOTHEARMSRACE WEENGAGEINWITHMANYVIRUSES WHICHHAVEANUNFORTUNATE CAPACITYTORESPONDADAPTIVELYTOVACCINES 2ICHARD$AWKINSMAYWELLBERIGHTWHENHEDESCRIBES THETHEORYOFNATURALSELECTIONASONEOFOURSPECIESlN ESTACCOMPLISHMENTSITISANINTELLECTUALLYSATISFYINGAND EMPIRICALLYSUPPORTEDACCOUNTOFOUROWNEXISTENCE"UT ALMOSTNOBODYBELIEVESIT/NEPOLLFOUNDTHATMORETHAN ATHIRDOFCOLLEGEUNDERGRADUATESBELIEVETHATTHE'ARDEN OF%DENWASWHERETHElRSTHUMANBEINGSAPPEARED!ND EVENAMONGTHOSEWHOCLAIMTOENDORSE$ARWINIANEVOLU TION MANYDISTORTITINONEWAYORANOTHER OFTENSEEINGIT ASAMYSTERIOUSINTERNALFORCEDRIVINGSPECIESTOWARDPER FECTION$AWKINSWRITESTHATITAPPEARSALMOSTASIFhTHE HUMANBRAINISSPECIlCALLYDESIGNEDTOMISUNDERSTAND $ARWINISMv !NDIFYOUARE TEMPTEDTOSEETHISASARED STATEnBLUESTATEISSUE THINK AGAINALTHOUGHITSTRUETHAT MORE"USHVOTERSTHAN+ERRY VOTERSARECREATIONISTS JUST ABOUTHALFOF+ERRYVOTERS BELIEVE THAT 'OD CREATED HUMANBEINGSINTHEIRPRES ENTFORM ANDMOSTOFTHE RESTBELIEVETHATALTHOUGHWE EVOLVEDFROMLESS ADVANCED LIFEFORMS 'ODGUIDEDTHE PROCESS-OST+ERRYVOTERS WANTEVOLUTIONTOBETAUGHT EITHERALONGSIDECREATIONISM ORNOTATALL 7HATSTHEPROBLEMWITH $ARWIN(ISTHEORYOFEVOLU TIONDOESCLASHWITHTHERELIGIOUSBELIEFSTHATSOMEPEOPLE ALREADYHOLD&OR*EWSAND#HRISTIANS 'ODWILLEDTHE WORLDINTOBEINGINSIXDAYS CALLINGDIFFERENTTHINGSINTO EXISTENCE/THERRELIGIONSPOSITMOREPHYSICALPROCESSESON THEPARTOFTHECREATORORCREATORS SUCHASVOMITING PRO CREATION MASTURBATION ORTHEMOLDINGOFCLAY.OTMUCH ROOMHEREFORRANDOMVARIATIONANDDIFFERENTIALREPRODUC TIVESUCCESS "UTTHEREALPROBLEMWITHNATURALSELECTIONISTHATIT MAKESNOINTUITIVESENSE)TISLIKEQUANTUMPHYSICSWE MAYINTELLECTUALLYGRASPIT BUTITWILLNEVERFEELRIGHTTO US7HENWESEEACOMPLEXSTRUCTURE WESEEITASTHE PRODUCTOFBELIEFSANDGOALSANDDESIRES/URSOCIALMODE OFUNDERSTANDINGLEAVESITDIFlCULTFORUSTOMAKESENSEOF ITANYOTHERWAY/URGUTFEELINGISTHATDESIGNREQUIRESA DESIGNERˆAFACTTHATISUNDERSTANDABLYEXPLOITEDBYTHOSE WHOARGUEAGAINST$ARWIN )TSNOTSURPRISING THEN THATNASCENTCREATIONISTVIEWS 5)&
"5- "/5*$
.0/5)-:




AREFOUNDINYOUNGCHILDREN&OUR YEAR OLDSINSISTTHAT THINKOFHEAVENNOTASANACTUALPLACEBUT RATHER ASAFORM EVERYTHINGHASAPURPOSE INCLUDINGLIONShTOGOINTHE OFEXISTENCEˆTHATOFBEINGINRELATIONTO'OD ZOOv ANDCLOUDShFORRAININGv 7HENASKEDTOEXPLAIN $ESPITEALLTHIS MOST*EWSAND#HRISTIANS ASNOTED WHYABUNCHOFROCKSAREPOINTY ADULTSPREFERAPHYSI BELIEVEINANAFTERLIFEˆINFACT EVENPEOPLEWHOCLAIMTO CALEXPLANATION WHILECHILDRENCHOOSEAFUNCTIONALONE HAVENORELIGIONATALLTENDTOBELIEVEINONE/URAFTERLIFE SUCHAShSOTHATANIMALSCOULDSCRATCHONTHEMWHENTHEY BELIEFSARECLEARLYEXPRESSEDINPOPULARBOOKSSUCHAS4HE GETITCHYv!NDWHENASKEDABOUTTHEORIGINOFANIMALS &IVE0EOPLE9OU-EETIN(EAVENAND!4RAVEL'UIDETO(EAVEN ANDPEOPLE CHILDRENTENDTOPREFEREXPLANATIONSTHAT !STHE'UIDEPUTSIT INVOLVEANINTENTIONALCREATOR EVENIFTHEADULTSRAISING (EAVENISDYNAMIC)TSBURSTINGWITHEXCITEMENTAND THEMDONOT#REATIONISMˆANDBELIEFIN'ODˆISBRED ACTION)TSTHEULTIMATEPLAYGROUND CREATEDPURELYFOR INTHEBONE OURENJOYMENT BYSOMEONEWHOKNOWSWHATENJOYMENT MEANS BECAUSE(EINVENTEDIT)TS$ISNEY7ORLD (AWAII 6) 2 %,)')/.!.$ 3 #)%.#% 0ARIS 2OME AND.EW9ORKALLROLLEDUPINTOONE!NDITS 7 ),, ! ,7!93 # ,!3( FOREVER
(EAVENTRULYISTHEVACATIONTHATNEVERENDS OMEMIGHTARGUETHATTHEPRECEDINGANALYSISOF RELIGION BASED AS IT IS ON SUPERNATURAL BELIEFS 4HISSOUNDSABITLIKEHELLTOME BUTITISAPPARENTLY DOESNOTAPPLYTOCERTAINNON 7ESTERNFAITHS)N TOSOMEPEOPLESTASTE 2ELIGIOUSAUTHORITIESANDSCHOLARSAREOFTENMOTIVATED HISRECENTBOOK4HE%NDOF&AITHTHENEUROSCIENTIST3AM (ARRISMOUNTSAlERCEATTACKON TOEXPLOREANDREACHOUTTOSCIENCE RELIGION MUCHOFITDIRECTEDAT ASWHENTHEPOPEEMBRACEDEVOLU #HRISTIANITY AND )SLAM WHICH TIONANDTHE$ALAI,AMABECAME HECRITICIZESFORWHATHESEESAS INVOLVEDWITHNEUROSCIENCE4HEY RIDICULOUSFACTUALCLAIMSANDGRO DO THIS IN PART TO MAKE THEIR TESQUEMORALVIEWS"UTTHENHE WORLDVIEWMOREPALATABLETOOTH TURNSTO"UDDHISM ANDHISTONE ERS ANDINPARTBECAUSETHEYARE SHIFTSTOADMIRATIONˆITIShTHE LEGITIMATELYCONCERNEDABOUTANY MOSTCOMPLETEMETHODOLOGYWE CLASHWITHSCIENTIlClNDINGS.O HAVEFORDISCOVERINGTHEINTRINSIC HONESTPERSONWANTSTOBEINTHE FREEDOMOFCONSCIOUSNESS UNEN POSITIONOFDEFENDINGAVIEWTHAT CUMBEREDBYANYDOGMAv3URELY MAKESMANIFESTLYFALSECLAIMS SO THISRELIGION IFONEWANTSTOCALL RELIGIOUSAUTHORITIESANDSCHOLARS ITARELIGION ISNOTROOTEDINTHE OFTENMAKESERIOUSEFFORTSTOWARD DUALISTANDCREATIONISTVIEWSTHAT RECONCILIATIONˆFORINSTANCE TRYING EMERGEINOURCHILDHOOD TOINTERPRETTHE"IBLEINAWAYTHAT &AIRENOUGH"UTWHILEITMAY ISCONSISTENTWITHWHATWEKNOW BETRUETHAThTHEOLOGICALLYCORRECTv"UDDHISMEXPLICITLY ABOUTTHEAGEOFTHEEARTH REJECTSTHENOTIONSOFBODY SOULDUALITYANDIMMATERIAL )FPEOPLEGOTTHEIRRELIGIOUSIDEASFROMECCLESIASTICAL ENTITIESWITHSPECIALPOWERS ACTUAL"UDDHISTSBELIEVEIN AUTHORITIES THESEEFFORTSMIGHTLEADRELIGIONAWAYFROMTHE SUCHTHINGS(ARRISHIMSELFRECOGNIZESTHISATONEPOINT SUPERNATURAL3CIENTIlCVIEWSWOULDSPREADTHROUGHRELI HECOMPLAINSABOUTTHEMILLIONSOF"UDDHISTSWHOTREATTHE GIOUSCOMMUNITIES3UPERNATURALBELIEFSWOULDGRADUALLY "UDDHAASA#HRISTlGURE &ORTHATMATTER ALTHOUGHMANY DISAPPEARASTHETHEOLOGICALLYCORRECTVERSIONOFARELIGION #HRISTIANTHEOLOGIANSAREWILLINGTOENDORSEEVOLUTIONARY GRADUALLYBECAMECONSISTENTWITHTHESECULARWORLDVIEW BIOLOGYˆANDITWASLEGITIMATELYFRONT PAGENEWSWHEN0OPE !S3TEPHEN*AY'OULDHOPED RELIGIONWOULDSTOPSTEPPING *OHN0AUL))CONCEDEDTHAT$ARWINSTHEORYOFEVOLUTION ONSCIENCESTOES "UTTHISSCENARIOASSUMESTHEWRONGACCOUNTOFWHERE MIGHTBECORRECTˆTHISSHOULDNOTDISTRACTUSFROMTHEFACT THATMANY#HRISTIANSTHINKEVOLUTIONISNONSENSE SUPERNATURALIDEASCOMEFROM2ELIGIOUSTEACHINGSCERTAINLY /RCONSIDERTHENOTIONTHATTHESOULESCAPESTHEBODY SHAPEMANYOFTHESPECIlCBELIEFSWEHOLDNOBODYISBORN ATDEATH4HEREISLITTLEHINTOFSUCHANIDEAINTHE/LD WITHTHEIDEATHATTHEBIRTHPLACEOFHUMANITYWASTHE'AR 4ESTAMENT ALTHOUGHITENTERSINTO*UDAISMLATERON4HE DENOF%DEN ORTHATTHESOULENTERSTHEBODYATTHEMOMENT .EW4ESTAMENTISNOTORIOUSLYUNCLEARABOUTTHEAFTERLIFE OFCONCEPTION ORTHATMARTYRSWILLBEREWARDEDWITHSEXUAL ANDSOME#HRISTIANTHEOLOGIANSHAVEARGUED ONTHEBASIS ACCESSTOSCORESOFVIRGINS4HESEIDEASARELEARNED"UTTHE OFSOURCESSUCHAS0AULSLETTERSTOTHE#ORINTHIANS THAT UNIVERSALTHEMESOFRELIGIONARENOTLEARNED4HEYEMERGE THEIDEAOFASOULSRISINGTOHEAVENCONmICTSWITHBIBLICAL ASACCIDENTALBY PRODUCTSOFOURMENTALSYSTEMS4HEYARE AUTHORITY)NTHEPOPEHIMSELFCAUTIONEDPEOPLETO PARTOFHUMANNATURE

3

4HETHEORYOFNATURAL SELECTIONISAN EMPIRICALLYSUPPORTED ACCOUNTOFOUREXISTANCE "UTALMOSTNOBODY BELIEVESIT7EMAY INTELLECTUALLYGRASPIT BUTITWILLNEVERFEEL RIGHT/URGUTFEELING ISTHATDESIGN REQUIRESADESIGNER




5)&
"5- "/5*$
.0/5)-:


%&$&.#&3