In the Matter of Myron Farber and the New York Times Company

!" $%& '($$&) *+ ',)*" +()-&) (". $%& "&/ ,*)0 $!'&1 2*'3(",4 2%()5&. /!$% 2*"$&'3$ *+ 2*6)$4 .&+&".("$17(33&88("$19 1$($& *+ "&/ :&)1&,4 38(!"$!++4 ;9 '()!* &9 :(12(8&?=@?>A 1BCDEFE 2GBDH GI "EJ :EDKEL => "9:9 MN@O P@Q (9MR PPAO S@=> "9:9 8&T!1 MQ>O @@ (989)9PR SO Q 'ERUV 89 )EC9 SPWA 1ECHEFXED N4 S@=>4 (DYBER 1ECHEFXED MS4 S@=>4 .EZURER

2(1& 16''(), 3)*2&.6)(8 3*1$6)&[   "##$%%&'() *+&%%$',$- & -$($./0'&(01' 12 (+$ 34#$.01. 514.(6 "##$%%&($ 7080)01' 9:$; 6 (+&( (+$= ;$.$ 0' *1'($/#( 12 *14.( 21. 2&0%4.$ (1 -0)*%1)$ 0'21./&(01' )14,+( ?= )4?#1$'&) -4*$) ($*4/ ?= &##$%%$$ 3(&($ 12 :$; &!6 LPK ?0.0 __[6 `I .0 @,0 I_L_6 aa A0 B*0 I- _I_ 9N`bI>6 (+.$$ '$;) /$-0& .$#.$)$'(&(08$) &.,4$- (+&(6 21. (+$ )&/$ .$&)1' +$.$ &-8&'*$-6 (+$= )+14%- '1( ?$ .$Y40.$- (1 &##$&. &'- ($)(02= ?$21.$ ,.&'- F4.0$)6 &'- (+&( (+0) #.080%$,$ (1 .$2.&0' 2.1/ -084%,0', 0'21./&(01'6 &))$.($- (1 +&8$ ?$$' .$*$08$- 2.1/ *1'20-$'(0&% )14.*$)6 -$.08$- 2.1/ (+$ V0.)( "/$'-/$'(@ &!C !"$5( 6 LPK ?0.0 &( bPNMPb6 `I .0 @,0 I___6 _`6 aa A0 B*0  I- &( _[NM[[@ j&(+$.6 14. 0')0)($'*$ 4#1' )4*+ & (+.$)+1%-$($./0'&(01' )#.0',) 2.1/ 14. 1?%0,&(01' (1 ,08$ &) /4*+ $22$*( &) #1))0?%$6 ;0(+0' $8$.M#.$)$'(

*1')(0(4(01'&% %0/0(&(01')6 (1 (+$ 8$.= #1)0(08$%= $G#.$))$- %$,0)%&(08$ 0'($'( (1 #.1($*( (+$ *1'20-$'(0&%0(= &'- )$*.$*= 12 )14.*$) 2.1/ ;+0*+ (+$ /$-0& -$.08$ 0'21./&(01'@ E1 (+0) $'- )4*+ & -$($./0'&(01' ;14%)$$/ & '$*$))0(=@ E+$ (+.$)+1%- -$($./0'&(01' \]]]MQ^ 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

E+$ /&''$. 0' ;+0*+ (+$ 1?%0,&(01' 12 (+$ -$2$'-&'( 0) (1 ?$ -0)*+&.,$- 0' (+$ #.1*$$-0',) %$&-0', (1 (+0) (+.$)+1%- -$($./0'&(01' ;0%% -$#$'- %&.,$%= 4#1' (+$ 2&*() 12 (+$ #&.(0*4%&. *&)$@ X$ ;0)+ (1 /&U$ 0( \]]PP@^ *%$&.6 +1;$8$.6 (+&( (+0) 1#0'01' 0) '1( (1 ?$

(&U$' &) & %0*$')$ 21. & 20)+0', $G#$-0(01' \]]]MN^ 0' $8$.= *.0/0'&% *&)$ ;+$.$ (+$.$ +&) ?$$' 0'8$)(0,&(08$ .$#1.(0',6 '1. &) #$./0))01' 21. &' 0'-0)*.0/0'&($ .4//&,0', (+.14,+ '$;)#&#$. 20%$)@

&))1*0&(01' ;0(+ (+$ h.1)$*4(1.Q) 1220*$ )0'*$ & (0/$ #.$*$-0', (+$ 0'-0*(/$'(@ E+0) ,%&.0', 2&*( 12 (+$0. *%1)$ ;1.U0', .$%&(01')+0# /&= ;$%% )$.8$ (1 -0)(0',40)+ (+0) *&)$ 2.1/ (+$ 8&)( /&F1.0(= 12 1(+$.) 0' ;+0*+ -$2$'-&'() )$$U -0)*%1)4.$ 2.1/ '$;)/$' 0' (+$ 2&*$ 12 (+$ 3+0$%- g&;@ E;1 &'- & +&%2 /1'(+) ?$21.$ +0) d D' (+$ )&/$ 8$0' 0) & %$(($. ?$21.$ (+$ (.0&% *14.( -&($6 (+$ ;0('$)) 0'0(0&%%= .$24)$- (1 ,08$ & )(&($/$'( 9%&($. )4##%0$-> 21. 2$&. (+&( 0( ;14%- *1'2%0*( ;0(+ & ;.0(($' )(&($/$'( #.$8014)%= 24.'0)+$- (1 V&.?$.@ E+$ *.0/0'&% -$2$'-&'( ;0)+$) (1 $G&/0'$ (+0) $&.%0$. )(&($/$'(@ L@ f$./&' V4+. ;&) &' 1#$.&(0', .11/ &(($'-&'( ;+1 1#$'$- 7.@