In The High Court of Madhya Pradesh: Index

 

AO PBC BAKB ELSTP LI FM@BQM ^TM@CUB Erafaomj Tcvasalo Ol. 234 /4>4>  /4>4>   M^^JAEMOP7   M^^JAEMOP7

UBQMF YCTUSU

TCU^LO@COPU7   TCU^LO@COPU7

TMF

AO@CR Uj.

@cse @c sera rapt ptal alo o li @l @leu eufc fcot ots s

Ol.

Mooc Moocxu xurc rc ^mkc Ol. li  Ol.(ai moy)

tbc @leufcot

>=. Ao`cx >4. Fcflrmo`uf li tbc Tcvasalo pctatalo >5. Afpukoc` lr`cr `mtc`

>0. Jast li `leufcots >3. Elpy li Gu`kfcot li jcmroc` Pramj Elurt `mtc` >9. Ymhmjmtomfm

^jmec7 ……….. @mtc7 …………..

(RQW) M`vlemtc ilr tbc mppjaemot  

 

AO PBC BAKB ELSTP LI FM@BQM ^TM@CUB Erafaomj Tcvasalo Ol. 234 /4>4> /4>4>   M^^JAEMOP7   M^^JAEMOP7

UBQMF

 

YCTUSU TCU^LO@COPU7

TMF

ETAFAOMJ TCYAUALO SO@CT UCEPALO 51;/0>= LI PBC EL@C LI ETAFAO ETA FAOMJ MJ ^TL ^TLEC EC@ST @STC C =1;5 =1; 5 Dcaok mkkracvc` dy Lr`cr `mtc` 43tb @cecfdcr 4>=2 pmssc` dy  M``atalomj Ucssalo Gu`kc,

ao Erafaomj Mppcmj Ol., miiarfaok tbc lr`cr 

`mtc` pmssc` dy M``atalomj Ebaci Gu`aeamj Fmkastrmtc, ao Erafaomj Emsc Ol… l….., wb wbcr crcd cdy y, Jc Jcmr mroc oc` ` Pram Pramjj Elu lurt rt rakb rakbttjy elo lova vae etc` tc` ilr lii liico coe ec puoasbmdjc uo`cr scetalo 04>/50 li tbc Ao`amo ^comj El`c mo` scotcoec` bcr tl uo`crkl ; ycmr raklrlus afpraslofcot ms wcjj ms afplsc` iaoc li Ts. 43,>>>/- cmeb mo` ao jacu li iaoc mfluot = ycmr raklrlus afpraslofcot . Jcmroc Jcm roc` ` Pr Pramj amj El Elurt urt mjsl mjsl lr lr`c `crc` rc` tl `asd `asdurs ursc c Ts Ts.. 40 40,> ,>>>/ >>/-- lut li iaoc iaoc mfluot Ts. 43,>>>/- mflokst cakbt mkkracvc` pcrslos. Mppjaemot prcicrrc` mppcmj mkmaost lr`cr `mtc` 42tb Letldcr 4>=9uo`cr scetalo 5;4 rcm` watb scetalo 53; (=) (@) li Erafaomj ^rlec`urc El`c, =1;5 ilr cobmoecfcot li  mwmr`c` mwm r`c` iao iaoc c mfluot mfluot,, wbc wbcrcdy rcdy jcmr jcmroc` oc` Mpp Mppcjj cjjmtc mtc Elu Elurt rt `as `asfas fassc` sc` tbc mppcmj mo` miiarfc` tbc Gu`kfcot li jcmroc` Pramj Elurt.   Mp Mppj pjae aemot mot‑s ‑s Ts Ts.. =5, =5,5>, 5>,>>> >>>6>> 6>> as ao pl plss sscs cssa salo lo li rcsp rcsplo lo`co `cots ts..  Mppjaemot scch cobmoecfcot li elfpcosmtalo mfluot, sl tbmt slfc li bas

 

mfluot wbaeb as ao plsscssalo li rcsplo`cots dc rcelvcrc`. Pbc mppjaemot dcks dc ks tl pr prci cicr cr tb tbas as er eraf afao aomj mj rc rcva vasa salo lo lo tbc tbc iljj iljjlw lwao aok k drac dracii imet imets s mo mo` ` krluo`s7-

(m)

Imets li tbc emsc ao draci7

=. Pb Pbmt mt,, pr prls lsce ceut utal alo o st stlr lry y ao dr drac acii as tbmt tbmt,, m wr wrat atttco el elf fpjma pjmaot ot wm wms s sudf su dfat attc tc` ` lo 9tb  sc scp p 4> 4>>9 >9 dcilrc dcilrc plja pljaec ec liia liiaea eamj mjs s li ^l ^lja jaec ec Ut Utmt mtal alo o TMG[M@M TMG[M @M watb m elotcotalo tbmt scvcrmj fcctaoks wcrc elo`ue elo`uetc` tc` ao tbc blusc li rcsplo`cots satumtc` mt Tmgwm`m ao`lrc `uraok ;.>9.4>>; tl =;.>9.4>>2 ao wbaeb rcsplo`cots ejmafc` tbmt tbcy bmvc rckastcrc` m elfpmoy wbaeb kavcs 5 tl 3 pcrecot `ava`co`s. Mppjaemot mjlokwatb lt ltbc bcrr

mk mkkr krac acvc vc` `

pcr crsl slos os

mr mrc c

rc rcttarc arc`

cf cfpj pjly lycc ccs s

li

Pr Prmo mos spl plrt rt

Elrplrmtalo, Mppjaemot mjlokwatb ltbcr mkkracvc` pcrslos bmo`c` lvcr  tbcar cotarc smvaoks. Lo irmu`ujcot ao`uecfcot li rcsplo`cot aostmot mppjaem mppj aemot ot kmv kmvc c Ts. 2,> 2,>>,> >,>>>6> >>6>> > tl rcs rcsplo plo`cot `cots. s. Tcsplo Tcsplo`cot `cots s mjs mjsl l kmvc scvcrmj m`vmoec ebcqucs tl mppjaem mppjaemot ot mjlokw mjlokwatb atb ltbcr mkkracv mkkracvc` c` pcrslos, sl tbmt tbcy `lo‑t trmec lut rcsplo`cot‑s ebcmtaok mo` imjj ao tbc afprcssalo tbmt tbcar flocy as ao smvc bmo`s. 4. Pbm Pbmt, t, wbco rcspl rcsplo`co o`cots ts `l olt pmy `ava `ava`co` `co`s s tl mpp mppjae jaemot mot mjlo mjlokwa kwatb tb lt ltbc bcrr mk mkkr krac acvc vc` ` pc pcrs rslo los s il ilrr m vc vcry ry jlok jlok tafc tafc,, tbco tbco tbcy tbcy prcs prcsco cott ebcqucs ao tbcar rcspcetavc dmohs. Pbc sma` ebcqucs wcrc `asblolrc` `asblolrc`

 

lo meeluo meeluott li ejlsa ejlsaok ok li Dmo Dmoh h Mee Meeluot luot.. Lo coquary coquary mppj mppjaem aemot ot kct tl holw tbmt mjj tbc rcsplo`cots elosparc` tlkctbcr mo` m wcjj lrkmoazc` rmehc rme hctc tccra craok ok mo` rmp rmpse semj mjja jalo lo as elff elffat attc tc` ` mkm mkmao aost st bc bcr. r. Mp Mppj pjae aemo mott sblehc` mo` surprasc` wbco sbc kcts tl holw tbmt rcsplo`cots bmvc mjrcm`y jcit lut tbc eaty, mo` tbcy mrc ao m burry tl ijcc tbcar eluotry mo` mrc pjmooaok tl sbait ao mdrlm`. 5. Pbmt, tbc tbcrcmitcr rcmitcr,, affc`amt affc`amtcjy cjy mppja mppjaemot emot jl`kc` Iar Iarst st Aoilrf Aoilrfmtalo mtalo Tcpl Tcplrt rt (Cx.^-) dcmraok erafc ol 234 ilr liicoec puoasbmdjc uo`cr Ucetalo 0>9 rcm` watb 50 li Ao`amo ^comj El`c. Ebmrkcs wcrc irmfc` mkmaost rcsplo`cots ilr liicoec puoasbmdjc uo`cr Ucetalo 0>9, 04> rcm` watb 50 li Ao`amo ^comj El`c. 0. Pbmt, mi mitcr tcr rcelr` rcelr`aok aok cva`c cva`coecs oecs jcmro jcmroc` c` Pramj El Elurt urt bms elov elovaetc` aetc` mo mo` ` scot sc otcoe coec` c` rcs rcsplo plo`co `cott ol ol.. = il ilrr li liic icoe oec c pu puoa oasb sbmdj mdjc c uo` uo`cr cr sc scet etal alo o 04>/50 li tbc Ao`amo ^comj El`c mo` scotcoec` scotcoec` bcr tl uo`crkl ; ycmr  raklrlus afpraslofcot ms wcjj ms afplsc` iaoc li Ts. 43,>>>/- cmeb mo` ao jacu li iaoc mfluot = ycmr raklrlus afpraslof afpraslofcot cot . M elpy li tbc Gu`kfcot `mtc` 42tb letldcr as dcaok iajc` bcrc watb ms Moocxurc ^-=. ^-=.

 

Pbmt, j cmroc` Pramj Elurt mjsl lr`crc` tl `asdursc Ts.

40,>> 40, >>>/ >/-- lu lutt li iaoc iaoc mflu mfluot ot Ts Ts.. 43 43,> ,>>>/ >>/-- mf mflok lokst st cak cakbt bt mk mkkra kracv cvc` c` pcrslos.

 

3. Pbmt, mpp mppjaemot jaemot p prcicrrc rcicrrc` ` mppcmj mkmao mkmaost st lr`cr `mt `mtc` c` >0.>2.4 >0.>2.4>=2 >=2 uo`cr  Ucetalo 5;4 rcm` watb Ucetalo 53; (=) (@) li Erafaomj ^rlec`urc El`c, =1;5 =1 ;5 il ilrr co cobm bmoe oecf cfco cott li mwmr mwmr`c `c` ` iaoc iaoc mf mflu luot ot.. Mp Mppj pjae aemo mot‑ t‑s s Ts Ts.. =5,5 =5 ,5>, >,>> >>>6 >6>> >> as ao pl plss sscs cssa salo lo li rcsp rcsplo lo`c `cot ots. s. Mp Mppj pjae aemo mott sc scch ch cobmoecfcot li elfpcosmtalo mfluot, sl tbmt slfc li bas mfluot wbae wb aeb b as ao pls plssc scss ssal alo o li rcs rcsplo plo`co `cots ts dc rcel rcelvc vcrc rc`. `. Du Dutt jcmro jcmroc` c`  Mppcjjmtc Elurt `asfassc` tbc mppcmj mo` miiarfc` tbc Gu`kfcot li  jc jcmr mroc` oc` Pr Pram amjj El Elur urt. t. Pb Pbc c lr` lr`cr cr af afpu pukoc koc` ` as ajjc ajjckmj kmj,, af afpr prlpc lpcrr mo mo` ` elotrmry tl tbc prlvasalos li jmw, bcoec tbas erafaomj rcvasalo.

(d) Krluo`s7  M. Ilr tbmt, dy `asfassaok tbc mppcmj jcmroc` Mppcjjmtc Elurt mets elotrmry tl tbc sljc li Ucetalo 5;4 li Erafaomj ^rlec`urc El`c, =1;5. D. Ilr tbmt tbmt,, dy `as `asfas fassao saok k tbc mppcmj vcry purp purplsc lsc li Uceta Ucetalo lo 5;4 li  Erafaomj ^rlec`urc El`c, =1;5 rco`crc` affmtcramj mo` uscjcss. E. Il Ilrr

tbmt mt,,

mppja pjaemot sbl bluj uj` `

dc

elfpc pco osmtc`

watb

m`cq cqu umtc mtc

elfpcosmtalo. Ts. 5,>>>6>> as mo aom`cqumtc elfpcosmtalo. @. Ilr tbmt, scotc scotcoec oec li ; ycm ycmrr rakl raklrlus rlus afpraslo afpraslofcot fcot tl rcs rcsplo` plo`cot cot ol. = as kll` mo` sustmaomdjc ao tbc cyc li jmw, dut iaoc li Ts.

 

43,>>>/- as tll fcmkcr. Pbc lr`cr tl `asdursc Ts. 5,>>>6>> tl cvcry mkkra mkk racv cvc` c` pc pcrs rslo lo as dm dm` ` ao jmw jmw dc dcem emus usc c rcsp rcsplo` lo`co cots ts pls plssc scss ss Jmhbs li rupccs li mppjaemot mo` ltbcr mkkracvc` pcrslos. C. Il Ilrr tbm bmt, t, mp mppj pjae aemo mot‑ t‑s s Ts Ts.. =5 =5,,5> 5>,> ,>>> >>6> 6>> > as ao pl pls sscs cssa salo lo li  rc rcsp splo lo`c `cot ots. s.

Mppj Mppjae aemo mott

sc scch ch

co cobm bmoe oecf cfco cott

li

el elfp fpco cosm smta talo lo

mfluot, sl tbmt slfc li bcr mfluot wbaeb as ao plsscssalo li  rcsplo`cots dc rcelvcrc`. I. Ilr tbmt tbmt,, wbajc krmo krmotao taok k iruat li dmaj mt tbc tafc tafc li tramj tramj Blo‑d Blo‑djc jc Pbc Bakb Elurt lr`crc` tl `cplsatc Ts. 3,>>,>>>6>> tl rcsplo`cot ol. =. Tcsplo`cot ol. = elfpjacs watb tbc lr`cr li Blo‑djc Pbc Bakb Elurt. Pbc smfc mfluot as `cplsatc` ao meeluot, dut cvco tl`my smfc as yct as olt scttjc`. Mppjaemot mjsl emo dc elfpcosmtc` watb tbmt mfluot tll.

K. Ilr tbmt tbmt,, jcmr jcmroc` oc` Elurts dcjlw lr`crc` tl `as `asdur dursc sc elf elfpcos pcosmta mtalo lo mfluot cqumjjy, `cspatc tbc imet tbmt mppjaemot as loc li tbc flst mkkra mkk racv cvc` c` pcrs pcrslo lo mflok mflokst st mjj mjj li tbcf. tbcf. El Elfp fpco cosm smta talo lo mf mfluo luott sbluj` dc mwmr`c` ms pcr rmtal li tbc sbmrc wbaeb wms ebcmtc` watb tbcf.

 

(`) Tcjaci ^rmyc` ilr7 At as, tbcrcilrc, prmyc` tbmt, tbc erafaomj rcvasalo fmy hao`jy dc mjjlwc` mjjlwc ` mo` tbc afpukoc` lr`cr `mtc` 43tb @cecfd @cecfdcr cr 4>=2 hao`jy dc sct-msa`c mo` rcsplo`cots dc `arcetc` tl Elfpcosmtalo ao tbc aotcrcst li gustaec.

^jmec7 Gmdmjpur @mtc7 43tb @cecfdcr 4>=2

(RQW) M`vlemtc ilr tbc mppjaemot