Imbo vs. People, G.R. No. 197712, April 20, 2015

 

Aefl vs. ^glpig, O.V. Jl. 81??86, Hprai 6>, 6>87

Chmts0

Lj lr hflut tbg pgrald mleprasgd crle Lmtlfgr 84, 6>>= up tl @hjuhry 67, 6>>4, aj Xugzlj Maty ^baiappajgs, [AeflU, watb clrmg hjd ajtaeadhtalj, dad tbgj hjd tbgrg waiicuiiy, ujihwcuiiy hjd cgiljalusiy mleeat hmts lc ihsmavalusjgss uplj [HHHU, bas lwj dhuobtgr, 88 yghrs lid, h eajlr, fy tbgj hjd tbgrg clrmajo bgr tl rgelvg bgr sblrts, ehsbajo bgr frghsts hjd pravhtg phrts hjd kassajo bgr, tbgrgfy suf`gmtajo shad mlepihajhjt tl sgxuhi hfusg, watb igwd dgsaoj hjd hohajst bgr waii, wbamb hmt dgfhsgs, dgorhdgs lr dgeghjs tbg ajtrajsam wlrtb lc daojaty lc [HHHU hs h buehj fgajo, tl tbg dhehog hjd prg`udamg lc tbg shad lccgjdgd phrty. Aefl mihaegd tbht bas wacg MMM, HHH's eltbgr egrgiy chframhtgd sumb h stlry (Aj HHH's stlry sbg smrghegd clr bgr eltbgr MMM = taegs hjd whs jlt bghrd hjd sbg whs ljiy hfig tl tgii bgr eltbgr hflut tbg ajmadgjt aj tbg cliilwajo elrjajo) tbht bg bhd rhpgd bas dhuobtgr. Witaehtgiy, Aefl mihaegd tbht lj tbg jaobt aj qugstalj, watbaj tbg pgrald crle 84 Lmtlfgr 6>>= tl 67 @hjuhry @ hjuhry 6>>4, jl mraeg lmmurrgd, bas dhys gjdajo hs dad bas wlrkdhy wbamb wgrg crle 20=> h.e. tl 70>> p.e. Tbg VTM mljvamtgd Aefl lc tbg mraeg lc Hmts lc Ihsmavalusjgss hjd whs sgjtgjmgd tl succgr hj ajdgtgreajhtg sgjtgjmg lc CLWVTGGJ (84) QGHV], GAOBT (2) ELJTB] LC VGMIW]ALJ TGE^LVHI H] EAJAEWE TL ]GSGJTGGJ (8?) QGHV], CLWV (4) ELJTB] LC VGMIW]ALJ TGE^LVHI H] EHRAEWE aj hmmlrdhjmg watb ]gmtalj 7 lc Vgpufiam Hmt Jl. ?38>, ?3 8>, ltbgrwasg kjlwj hs tbg ]pgmahi ^rltgmtalj lc Mbaidrgj Hohajst Mbaid Hfusg, Gxpilathtalj hjd Dasmraeajhtalj.

Assug0

_bgtbgr lr jlt Aefl as suf`gmt tl tbg ^gjhity Aeplsgd Wjdgr ]gm 7 lc VH?38> dgspatg tbg chmt tbht tbg ajclrehtalj chaigd tl ajdamhtg ats hppiamhfaiaty

Vuiajo0

Qgs, ]gmtalj 7 lc VH ?38> prlvadgs tbht tbg pgjhity lc rgmiusalj tgeplrhi aj ats egdaue pgrald tl rgmiusalj pgrpgtuh sbhii fg aeplsgd uplj aj mhsgs wbgrg h mbaid whs mlgrmgd fy bgr Chtbgr tl ajduiog aj hmts lc ihsmavalusjgss. Lj tbg assug lc pgjhity, tbg Mlurt clujd tbht tbg VTM's dgmasalj sbluid fg eldacagd fy hppiyajo tbg Ajdgtgreajhtg ]gjtgjmg Ihw. Hmmlrdajo tl tbg Mlurts, tbg Ajdgtgreajhtg ]gjtgjmg Ihw as hppiamhfig tl praslj sgjtgjmg fltb clr hj lccgjsg pujasbgd fy tbg V^M hjd hj lccgjsg pujasbgd "fy hjy ltbgr ihw." Tbg mlrrgmt hppiamhtalj lc tbg Ajdgtgreajhtg ]gjtgjmg Ihw bhs iljo fggj mihracagd aj ^glpig v. ]aelj wbamb ruigd tbht tbg ujdgrsmlrgd plrtalj lc ]gmtalj 8 lc tbg Ajdgtgreajhtg ]gjtgjmg Ihw, a.g. tbg "lccgjsg as pujasbgd fy hjy ltbgr ihw," ajdufathfiy rgcgrs tl hj lccgjsg ujdgr h spgmahi ihw wbgrg tbg pgjhity aeplsgd whs jlt thkgj crle hjd as watblut rgcgrgjmg tl tbg V^M.