Final - Writ - Petition - For - Filing-PB Singh vs. State of Maharashtra
August 29, 2022 | Author: Anonymous | Category: N/A
Short Description
Download Final - Writ - Petition - For - Filing-PB Singh vs. State of Maharashtra...
Description
"
!" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. !"/!0 "#$%&'#( )%*%+ ,-#%.$%)/%"& 1*!$ )&$!$!-" 2,!3!45 "-6 7777777 -. 898: !" $%& +0$$&* -.; 0'#'1 2%# .%&34
506/%/%"&6# *6#.-.
./'/6 "7 1'4'#'.4/#' 8 "#.
5#6.0"&$6&/.
9%/4 %:': &": ;;;; "7 \b_
>]:
'OOFYPRF 0\bZ %&$%'& 0UDVHF .FRMVHF A)LERFB #PDFJZ >_cb #PDF ` 1LKLRLJKIRL .ILIF 0UDVHF 'HIZ >_c> #PDF \_^___^^: /KF
0FIVIVUOFR KLE NFFO JFRMVOX IKF &LIVUOZ IKF .ILIF UG 1LKLRLJKIRL LOE IKF $FWLRITFOI UG 0UDVHF GUR TURF IKLO ]< QFLRJZ LOE VJ RFHVWVFOI UG WRFJIVXVUPJ LeLREJ DV[F @KLEILR .FML 1FELD a &LYLDVIF 'RFLZ $30fJ %OJVXOVL a _c> eVIK IKF RFLJUO IKLI IKF IRLOJGFR eLJ OFHFJJVILIFE NQ mLETVOVJIRLIVMF FYVXFOHVFJn: %I VJ JFIIDFE DLe IKLI IKF "REFRJ KLMF IU JILOE UO IKF RFLJUOJ HUOILVOFE VO IKF JLTF LOE OU RFLJUOJ HLO NF JPWWDFTFOIFE JPWWDFT FOIFE DLIFR: /KF WFIVIVUOFR NFDVFMFJ IKLI IKF RFLJUO GUR IKF IRLOJGFR OUIFE NQ IKF #FJWUOEFOI OU: > VO VIJ GVDF VJ IU FOJPRF L GRFF LOE GLVR VOMFJIVXLIVUO VO IKF 'OIVDVL VOHVEFOI DFLEVOX IU 7%# OU: ]cS_^^: /KF 0FIVIVUOFR VJ JFRMVOX IKF &LIVUOZ
IKF
.ILIF
UG
1LKLRLJKIRL
LOE
IKF
$FWLRITFOI UG 0UDVHF GUR TURF IKLO ]< QFLRJZ LOE VJ RFHVWVFOI UG WRFJIVXVUPJ LeLREJ DV[F @KLEILR .FML 1FELD a &LYLDVIF 'RFLZ $30fJ %OJVXOVL a _cb LJ LTFOEFE VO b: 7PRIKFRZ IKF IRLOJGFR UG IKF 0FIVIVUOFR VJ LDJU HUOIRLRQ IU IKF DLe DLVE EUeO NQ IKVJ 4UOfNDF )UPRI VO "#=# $>+?&*)( -# .+,/+ /0 1+2,)3 (>@/(A>2 ,+ 4567cIK 7DUURZ &FYI IU 1LDLNLR 4VDD 0UDVHF .ILIVUOZ 1PTNLVZ 1LKLRLJKIRL \ b====d 506/%/%"&6# *FRJPJ >: .ILIF UG 1LKLRLJKIRLZ /KRUPXK .FHRFILRQZ 4UTF $FWLRITFOIZ _c> eVIK IKF RFLJUO IKLI IKF IRLOJGFR eLJ OFHFJJVILIFE NQ mLETVOVJIRLIVMF FYVXFOHVFJn: /KF IRLOJGFR UG IKF WFIVIVUOFR VO IKF LGURFJLVE HVRHPTJILOHFJ VJ GUR RFLJUOJ JTFLRFE eVIK TLDVHF: .PHK IRLOJGFR GUDDUeFE NQ LEMFRJF TFEVL WPNDVHVIQ NQ JLVE .KRV 'OVD $FJKTP[KZ VJ VO MVUDLIVUO UG 'RIVHDF >b LOE UG IKF )UOJIVIPIVUO UG %OEVLZ VO IFFIK UG IKF DLe DLVE EUeO NQ IKVJ 4UOfNDF )UPRI VO "#$#%# $&'()*)+,)+ -# .+,/+ /0 1+2,)3 LEK=LGEZ OF 456789 7: $;; _cb LJ LTFOEFE VO b: 7PRIKFRZ IKF IRLOJGFR UG IKF 0FIVIVUOFR VJ LDJU HUOIRLRQ IU IKF DLe DLVE EUeO NQ IKVJ 4UOfNDF )UPRI VO "#=# $>+?&*)( -# .+,/+ /0 1+2,)3 (>@/(A>2 ,+ 4567_cb: /KF )VMVD .FRMVHFJ 2ULREZ NFGURF TL[VOX JPHK L RFHUTTFOELIVUO GUR IRLOJGFR UG UGGVHFR NFGURF IKF HUTWDFIVUO UG TVOVTPT IFOPRF KLJ IU RFHURE VIJ RFLJUOJ GUR JPHK L EFHVJVUO VO eRVIVOX: %I VJ JPNTVIIFE IKLI IKF WRFJHRVNFE WRUHFEPRF KLJ OUI NFFO GUDDUeFE VO IKF HLJF UG IKF 0FIVIVUOFR TL[VOX IKF IRLOJGFR LRNVIRLRQ LOE VDDFXLD LOE VO EVRFHIFE HUOIRLMFOIVUO UG IKF 0FIVIVUOFRfJ RVXKIJ HUOILVOFE POEFR 'RIVHDF >b LOE UG IKF )UOJIVIPIVUO UG %OEVL: %I VJ GPRIKFR JPNTVIIFE IKLI IKF VTWPXOFE IRLOJGFR VJ HDFLRDQ VO HUOIRLMFOIVUO UG IKF DLe DLVE EUeO NQ IKVJ 4UOfNDF )UPRI VO IKF HLJF UG @%9%E% 985/-;-(+-( 2% A(+)( )7 B(=+-! RFWURIFE VO IUVC#K C$ 9RR N#U Z eKFRFVO VI eLJ EVRFHIFE IKLI IKFRF JKUPDE NF GVYFE TVOVTPT IFOPRF GUR HVMVD JFRMLOIJ IU RFEPHF WUDVIVHLD VOIFRGFRFOHF VO IKF
"# eUR[VOX UG HVMVD JFRMLOIJ: 7PRIKFRZ IKF IRLOJGFR UG IKF 0FIVIVUOFR VJ LDJU HUOIRLRQ IU IKF DLe DLVE EUeO NQ IKVJ 4UOfNDF )UPRI VO @%W% 9'(X8;-/ 2% A(+)( )7 B(=+-! /'.)/*'= +( IUVCNK Y 9RR ZVC eKFRFVO VI eLJ KFDE IKLI IRLOJGFR UG LO UGGVHFR GRUT L JFOJVIVMF IFOPRF WUJI RFpPVRFJ JFRVUPJ HUOJVEFRLIVUO LOE XUUE RFLJUOJ IKLI HLO NF IFJIFE:
c:>> %I VJ JPN JPNTVIIFE TVIIFE IKLI IKF EFHVJVUO IU IRLOJGFRZ LWLRI GRUT NFVOX HRQWIVHZ eLJ EUOF VO L KPRRVFE TLOOFR eVIKUPI XVMVOX LOQ RFLJUOJ:
0FRIVOFOIDQZ
IKF
VTWPXOFE
OUIVGVHLIVUO
ELIFE
>`:=]: N&)(2K%H N&)(2K %H
"$
c:>< 9KVDF IKF #FJWUOEFOI &U &U:: > KLJ KLJ UGGVHVLDDQ GLVDFE IU JFI UP UPII LOQ JWFHVGVH RFLJUO GUR RFTUMLDSIRLOJGFR UG IKF 0FIVIVUOFR GRUT KVJ WUJIVOX LJ IKF )UTTVJJVUOFR UG 0UDVHFZ 1PTNLVZ IKFRF LRF MLRVUPJ RFWURIJ EUVOX IKF RUPOEJ VO IKF JIRFLTDVOF TFEVL WPRWURIFEDQ
LDDFXVOX
IKLI
IKF
0FIVIVUOFR
KLJ
NFFO
RFTUMFESIRLOJGFRRFE EPF IU KVJ LDDFXFE RUDF VO IKF O;5-(+ o O;5-(+ S);5 9,-/'f: 9,-/'f:
c:>] ' GFe UG IKF RFDFMLOI FYIRL FYIRLHIJ HIJ GRUT IKFJF TFEVL RFWURIJ LRF FYIRLHIFE KFRFPOEFR GUR RFLEQ RFGFRFOHFC
'L6
'=CLBE
'GIGEDEFG IFZ (*4
"=6 >:
/KF 0RVOI
m&1+3' ;83*+.3' 0)8/,'0 7/); *1' /83+(4 .-/*+'0 0-+= 9+(41^0 */-(07'/ :HTJ HUWSLRIVHDFJKUeS^>cc`^b>:HTJ ' HUWQ UG IKF OFeJ RFWURI ELIFE >`:=]:8'(* -//'0* )7 7)/;'/ .)3+,' )77+,'/ 9-,1+( `-_':n `-_':n KIIWJCSSeee:KVOEPJILOIVTFJ:HUTSHVIVFJSTPTNLV \OFeJSWLRLT\NVR\IRLOJGFRRFE\OLXRLDF\VJ\ TPTNLV\IUW\HUW\>=>d>d==d_=>d>d==d_`:=]:b %I VJ JPNTVIIFE IKL IKLII IKF 4UOfNDF 1VOVJIFR GUR 4UTF 4UTFZZ .ILIF UG 1LKLRLJKIRL a 1R: 'OVD $FJKTP[K KLJ XVMFO L JILIFTFOI IU IKF WRFJJ JILIVOX LJ GUDDUeJC Q\BO b O@9 -/' +(2'0*+4-*+(4 9-,1+( &-_' ,-0' 2'/6 ./)7'00+)(-336% O,*+)( c "O b LOE UG IKF )UOJIVIPIVUO UG %OEVLr
%%%:
9KFIKFR IKF RFTUMLD U UGG L HVMVD JFRMLOI GRUT L WUJI eVIK L TVOVTPT WRFJHRVNFE IFOPRFZ NFGURF IKF FYWVRQ UG JPHK TVOVTPT IFOPRFZ TL[FJ IKF IRLOJGFR VDDFXLD LOE LRNVIRLRQ LOE IKPJ MVUDLIVMF UG 'RIVHDF >b UG IKF )UOJIVIPIVUO UG %OEVLr
%*:
9KFIKFR IKF VTWPXOFE &UIVGVHLIVUO ELIFE >`:=]:`:=]:b LOE UG IKF )UOJIVIPIVUO UG %OEVL VO L TLOVGFJIDQ LRNVIRLRQ TLOOFR:
1:
7UR /KLIZ IKF WRUMVJVUOJ HUOILVOFE VO .PNJFHIVUO A+?&*)( -# .+,/+ /0 1+2,)3 (>@/(A>2 ,+ 4567: &' -/' *1'/'7)/' ,3'-/36 )7 ).+(+)( *1-* *1' /';)2-3 )/ =+0.3-,';'(* )7 -(6 0'(+)/ 3'2'3 )77+,'/ 7/); - *'(8/' -..)+(*;'(* ;80* 5' 7)/ ,);.'33+(4 /'-0)(0 -(= ;80* 5' L80*+7+'= 56 *1' -8*1)/+*6 ,)(,'/('=! +7 ,-33'= 8.)( *) =) 0)! )( ;-*'/+-3 *1-*
#9 ,-( 5' )5L',*+2'36 *'0*'=% @1+0 +0 _cb VJ FYIRLHIFE KFRFVONFDUe GUR RFLEQ RFGFRFOHFC Q 5# 5# O&+PA,/+K I-K
@1'
R+2+3
9'/2+,'0
S)-/=
01-33
;-X'
/',);;'(=-*+)( 7)/ -33 -..)+(*;'(*0 )7 ,-=/' )77+,'/0% I5K @1' R+2+3 9'/2+,'0 S)-/= 01-33 '?-;+(' *1' ,-0'0 )7 )77+,'/0 ELIFE >`:=]:+?&*)( -# .+,/+ /0 1+2,)3 (>@/(A>2 ,+ 4567 01+ G-:6+'+4' D#'1-.&'( ,-. '1+ ;+4+.$% '.$43,+. 31$%% *+ $3 ,-%%-/3< 4$:+%(H I
9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+% G-:6+'+4' D#'1-.&'(
A$C J,,&7+.3 -, '1+ 845&$4 9-%&7+ 2+.@&7+
K G1&+,
L&4&3'+.M A*C L$1$.$31'.$ 9-%&7+ 2+.@&7+ J,,&7+.3 -, $45 $*-@+ '1+ .$4N -, O+6#'( 2#6+.&4'+45+4' -, 9-%&7+
K P-:+
L&4&3'+.M A7C J,,&7+.3 #6 '' - 9-%&7+ 88436+7'-. 436+7'-. A$C9-%&7+ !3'$*%&31:+4' Q-$.5 ?->R> A*C 9-%&7+ !3'$*%&31:+4' Q-$.5 $' S$4;+ T+@+%> A7C 9-%&7+ !3'$*%&31:+4' Q-$.5 $'
G-::&33&-4+. $'+ T+@+%H 9.-@&5+5 '1$'< '1+ 2'$'+ U-@+.4:+4' :$( '.$43,+. $4( 9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+% 6.&-. '- '1+ 7-:6%+'&-4 -, 1&3 4-.:$% '+4#.+< &,< I $C 5&37&6%&4$.( 6.-7++5&4;3 $.+ &43'&'#'+5 -. 7-4'+:6%$'+5 $;$&43' '1+ 9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+%M -. *C '1+ 9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+% &3 7-4@&7 7-4@&7'+5 '+5 *( $ 7-#.' -, %$/M -. 7C '1+.+ $.+ $%%+;$'&-43 -, 7-..#6'&-4 $;$&43' '1+ 9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+%M -. 5C '1+ 9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+% &3 -'1+./&3+ &&47$6$7&'$'+5 47$6$7&'$'+5 ,.-: ,.- : 5&371$.;&4; 1&3 .+36-43&*&%&'(M -. +C '1+ 9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+% &3 ; ;#&%'( #&%'( -, 5+.+%&7'&-4 -, 5#'(>
ARC 84 $55&'&-4 '- '1+ ;.-#453 :+4'&-4+5 &4 3#*V3+7'&-4 ABC< &4 +=7+6'&-4
%$7$3+3<
&4
6#*%&7
&4'+.+3'
$45
-4
$77-#4'
-,
$5:&4&3'.$'&@+ +=&;+47&+3< '1+ G-:6+'+4' D#'1-.&'( 31$%% :$N+ :&5V '+.: '.$43,+. -, $4( 9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+% -, '1+ 9-%&7+ E-.7+H 9.-@&5+5 '1$'< '1+ G-:6+'+4' D#'1-.&'( :$(< *( ;+4+.$% -. 36+7&$% -.5+.< 5+%+;$'+ &'3 6-/+.3 #45+. '1&3 3#*V3+7'&-4 '- $4( -, &'3 3#*-.5&4$'+ $#'1-.&'(> !=6%$4$'&-4> I E-. '1+ 6#.6-3+3 -, '1&3 3#*V3+7'&-4< '1+ +=6.+33&-4 WG-:6+'+4' D#'1-.&'(X 31$%% :+$4H I
9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+% G-:6+'+4' D#'1-.&'(
A$C J,,&7+.3 -, '1+ 845&$4 9-%&7+ 2+.@&7+
K
G1&+, L&4&3'+.M
A*C L$1$.$31'.$ 9-%&7+ 2+.@&7+ J,,&7+.3 -, $45 $*-@+ '1+ .$4N -, 9-%&7+ 2#*V8436+7'-.
K
P-:+ L&4&3'+.M
A7C 9-%&7+ 9+.3-44+% #6'- '1+ .$4N -, D33&3'$4' 9-%&7+ 2#*V8436+7'-.
>>> O&.+7'-.
U+4+.$% $45 8436+7'-. U+4+.$% -, 9-%&7+
E8-. F 59 &6:+;6 "5-+,. "5-+,. >.)G >.)G+,. +,. @@4;:).B 4;:).B !A.6:A.6* E8-.71 =C/0
HFD "57*+6I7DIABC D%% $66-&4':+4'3 -, 7$5.+ -,,&7+.3 31$%% 3 1$%% *+ :$5+
-4 '1+ .+7-::+45$'&-4 -, '1+ G&@&% 2+.@&7+3 Q-$.5 $3 36+7&,&+5 &4 '1+ 271+5#%+ $44+=+5 '- '1+3+ .#%+3>
ARC D%% $66-&4':+4'3 '- 7$5.+ 6-3'3 .+,+..+5 '- &4 3#*V.#%+ ABC 31$%% *+ :$5+I
A$C &4 '1+ 7$3+ -, $ 2'$'+ G$5.+< *( '1+ 2'$'+ U-@+.4:+4'M $45 >
A*C &4 '1+ 7$3+ -, $ Y-&4' G$5.+< *( '1+ 2'$'+ U-@+.4:+4' 7-47+.4+5H
9.-@&5+5 '1$' '1+ G+4'.$% U-@+.4:+4' -. '1+ 2'$'+ U-@+.4:+4' U-@+.4 :+4' :$( '.$43,+. $ 7$5.+ -,,&7+. ,-. '1+ 6#.6-3+ -, ,&%%&4; %+$@+ @$7$47&+3 -. ,-. :$N&4; '+:6-.$.( $..$4;+:+4'3 ,-. $ 6+.&-5 4-' +=7++5&4; '1.++ :-4'13< 5+%+;$'+ &'3 6-/+. -, :$N&4; $66-&4':+4'3 '- 7$5.+ 6-3'3 '- P+$53 -, O+6$.':+4'3>
AZC D 7$5.+ -,,&7+.< $66-&4'+5 '- $4( 7$5.+ 6-3' 31$%% 1-%5 -,,&7+ ,-. $' %+$3' '/- (+$.3 #4%+33 &4 '1+ :+$4'&:+ 1+ -. 31+ 1$3 *++4 6.-:-'+5< .+'&.+5 -. 3+4' -4 5+6#'$'&-4 -#'3&5+ '1+ 2'$'+ -. '.$&4&4; +=7++5&4; '/- :-4'13>
A[C D 7$5.+ -,,&7+.< $66-&4'+5 '- $4( +=V7$5.+ 6-3' 31$%% 1-%5 -,,&7+ ,-. 3#71 6+.&-5 $3 :$( *+ 36+7&,&+5 *( '1+ 2'$'+ U-@+.4:+4' ,-.
'1$' 6-3'< #4%+33 &4 '1+ :+$4'&:+ 1+ -. 31+ 1$3 *++4 6.-:-'+5< .+'&.+5 -. 3+4' -4 5+6#'$'&-4 -#'3&5+ '1+ 2'$'+ -. '.$&4&4; +=7++5&4; '/- :-4'13>
A\C 01+ G+4'.$% U-@+.4:+4' -. '1+ 2'$'+ U-@+.4:+4' $3 '1+ 7$3+ :$( *+< :$( '.$43,+. $ 7$5.+ -,,&7+. *+,-.+ '1+ :&4&:#: 36+7&,&+5 6+.&-5 -4 '1+ .+7-::+45$'&-4 -, '1+ G&@&% 2+.@&7+3 Q-$.5 $3 36+7&,&+5 &4 '1+ 271+5#%+ $44+=+5 '- '1+3+ .#%+3H
9.-@&5+5
'1$'
'1+
G-:6+'+4'
D#'1-.&'(
:$(
.+F+7'
'1+
.+7-::+45$'&-4 -, '1+ G&@&% 2+.@&7+3 Q-$.5 *( .+7-.5&4; '1+ .+$3-43 '1+.+,-.>]>
A*C ,-. '1+ 271+5#%+< '1+ ,-%%-/&4; 271+5#%+ 31$%% *+ 3#*3'&'#'+5< 4$:+%(HI
2GP!O^T!
_2++ .#%+ `ABC $45 A\Ca
B> G-:6-3&'&-4 -, '1+ G&@&% 2+.@&7+3 Q-$.5H
!@+.( 2'$'+ U-@+.4:+4' 31$%% 7-43'&'#'+ $ G&@&% 2+.@&7+3 Q-$.5 /1&71 31$%% 7-43&3' -,V
A&C G1&+, 2+7.+'$.( G1$&.:$4
A&&C 2+4&-. :-3' D55&'&-4$% G1&+, 2+7.+'$.(AD 3
:-#*3
:$%I$F 0(%(#$1
2$%.(F
/*#(+,)# 0(%(#$1 )'
K)55$%.(#D
2)1*+(
2)1*+(
E$%$J*%J
E$-$#$&-,#$
E$-$#$&-,#$
:,$,(
$%. /*#(+,)#D :,$,(
B)5( :(+G#*,F K)#C)#$,*)% EG5O$*
E$%$J(# H$M&-$ /$1 WQ3
:(%*)# 2(#&)%$1 T&&*&,$%, ,) 2#*%+*C$1 :(+#(,$#F
R:C(+*$1SD B)5( /(C$#,5(%,D E*%*&,#FD EG5O$*3 >P3
T..*,*)%$1 /*#(+,)# 0(%(#$1 )' 2)1*+(D ]$L $%.
6#.(#D :,$,( )' E$-$#$&-,#$D EG5O$*3
>\3
T..*,*)%$1 /*#(+,)# 0(%(#$1 )' 2)1*+(D
^&,$O1*&-5(%,D :,$,( )' E$-$#$&-,#$D EG5O$*3 >X3
/*#(+,)#D _)#(%&*+ ]$O)#$,)#FD EG5O$*D
>A3
/(CG,F /*#(+,)# 0(%(#$1D E$-$#$&-,#$ :,$,(
B)5( 0G$#.D EG5O$*D >W3
/(CG,F 0(%(#$1 E$%$J(#D E$-$#$&-,#$ :,$,(
:(+G#*,F K)#C)#$,*)%D EG5O$*3 >Y3
T++)G%,$%, 0(%(#$1 RT++)G%,& $%.
2(#5*&&*O*1*,FS ;>D :,$,( )' E$-$#$&-,#$D EG5O$*3 = -)G#& )' hG(&,*)%*%J3 a$b( -$& O((% #(5$%.(. *% 79T +G&,).F ,*11 YYW $%. Y C$%.(5*+D $%. IG&, O(+$G&( )' ,-( L#)%J& +)55*,,(. OF $ '(L C)1*+(5(%D ,-( (%,*#( ( %,*#( ')#+( +$%%), O( -(1. #(&C)%&*O1(3
f:)5( 5(5O(#& )' ,-( EG5O$* 2)1*+( $#( '$+*%J *%4(&,*J$,*)% OF 79T $%. ),-(# $J(%+*(&3 1' ,-(F $#( *%4)14(. *% $%F +#*5( ,-(F L*11 '$+( $CC#)C#*$,( $+,*)%3 9' $%F )' ,-)&( $J(%+*(& L#*,( ,) G& *%')#5*%J $O)G, .(#(1*+,*)% )' .G,F )# 5*&G&( )' C)1*+( #(&)G#+(&D
$CC#)C#*$,( .(C$#,5(%,$1 $+,*)% L)G1. O( ,$M(% $J$*%&, ,-( (##*%J C)1*+(5(%Dg 7$J#$1( $..(.3
B( &$*. ,-( C)1*+( ')#+( L$& J)*%J ,-#)GJ- $ +-$11(%J*%J C-$&( $%. -( L$& $CC)*%,(. ,) 1($. *, ,) ,*.( )4(# ,-( C#(&(%, &*,G$,*)%D L-*+- -$& O#)GJ-, 1), )' (5O$##$&&5(%, ,) ,-( C)1*+( .(C$#,5(%,3 ]($.(# )' )CC)&*,*)%D /(4(%.#$ _$.%$4*&D 5($%L-*1( &,(CC(. GC ,-( $,,$+M )% "-$+M(#$F J)4(#%5(%,3 T..#(&&*%J $ C#(&& +)%'(#(%+( *% /(1-*D -( &$*. ,-( 5(#( ,#$%&'(# )' ,-( +)55*&&*)%(# L)G1. %), -(1C $& ,-( %$5( )' ,-( fC)1*,*+$1 O)&&g L-) L$& )C(#$,*%J `$b( &-)G1. O( (dC)&(.3 B( $1&) .(5$%.(. ,-$, ,-( *%4(&,*J$,*)% *%,) .($,- )' B*#$% &-)G1. $1&) O( -$%.(. )4(# ,) ,-( 79TD &*%+( ,-( &,$,(e& $%,*; ,(##)#*&5 &hG$. RT":S -$& %), O((% $O1( ,) 5$M( C#)J#(&& *% ,-( .($,- +$&(3
B*#$% L$& ')G%. .($. *% "-$%( +#((MD .$F& $',(# $% :[` )L%(. OF -*5 L$& ')G%. $O$%.)%(. L*,- J(1$,*% &,*+M& )G,&*.( T5O$%*e& #(&*.(%+( )% _(O#G$#F YWW;O$,+- 92: )''*+(# -$. C1$F(. $ #)1( *% O#*%J*%J ,-( #$C*.1F L)#&(%*%J G%.(#L)#1. G%.(# +)%,#)1 *% ,-( 1$,( >YY=&3 T& $ /(CG,F K)55*&&*)%(# )' 2)1*+(D E#3 :*%J- -($.(. )%( )' ,-( ,L) &C(+*$1 &hG$.& )' (%+)G%,(# &C(+*$1*&,& ,$&M(. L*,- ,$M*%J &,#)%J $+,*)% $J$*%&, J$%J&,(#&3 :*%+( ,-(% -( -$. &(#4(. & (#4(. 5$%F C#)5*%(%, C)&*,*)%& 1*M( ,-( "-$%( +*,F C)1*+( +-*(' $%. /*#(+,)#
0(%(#$1 )' ,-( :,$,(e& T%,* K)##GC,*)% VG#($G3 9% AD L-(% -( L$& "-$%( 2)1*+( K)55*&&*)%(#D ,-( 1)+$1 +#*5( O#$%+- $##(&,(. J$%J&,(# /$L)). 9O#$-*5e& O#),-(# 9hO$1 N$&M$# ')# $11(J(.1F ,-#($,(%*%J $ OG*1.(#3
E#3 :*%J-e& ')%.%(&& ')# (%+)G%,(# &C(+*$1*&,& &C( +*$1*&,& L$& (4*.(%, L-(% -( &)GJ-, +)%,#)4(#&*$1 (%+)G%,(# &C(+*$1*&, 2#$.((C :-$#5$ ,) O( C)&,(. G%.(# -*5 *% "-$%(3 " -$%(3 T& EG5O$* 2)1*+( K)55*&&*)%(#D -( C)&,(. :$+-*% `$b(D L-) -$& O((% $##(&,(. OF ,-( 7$,*)%$1 9%4(&,*J$,*)% TJ(%+F *% ,-( T%,*1*$ O)5O &+$#( +$&(D ,) ,-( K#*5( 9%,(11*J(%+( [%*,3
7$,*4( )' K-$%.#$CG#
E#3 :*%J-e& &G++(&&)# -$*1& '#)5 K-$%.#$CG# .*&,#*+, )' E$-$#$&-,#$3 T >YWA;O$,+- )''*+(#D E#3 7$J#$1( &,G.*(. *% $ b*11$ C$#*&-$. &+-))1 ,*11 K1$&& `9 O(')#( 5)4*%J ,) 7$JCG# ,) &,G.F $, 2$,L$#.-$% B*J- :+-))13 T',(# CG#&G*%J -*& .(J#(( *% 5(+-$%*+$1 (%J*%((#*%JD -( +)5C1(,(. -*& E$&,(#e& *% '*%$%+( 5$%$J(5(%, $, U$5%$1$1 V$I$I 9%&,*,G,( )' E$%$J(5(%, :,G.*(& *% EG5O$*3 E#3 7$J#$1(e& '*#&, C)&,*%J L$& $& T&&*&,$%,
:GC(#*%,(%.(%, )' 2)1*+( *% ,-( E$*)&,;$''(+,(. K-$%.#$CG# .*&,#*+, '#)5 >YWY ,) >YYYYYYYYW $%. EG5O$* ,(##)# $,,$+M& *% YWA O$,+92: L-) L$& -)1.*%J +-$#J( $& /*#(+,)# 0(%(#$1 )' 2)1*+(D E$-$#$&-,#$D *% $..*,*)% ,) O(*%J ,-( /0D ](J$1 $%. "(+-%*+$13
E$#+- >WD P8>W $5
EGM(&- T5O$%* O)5O &+$#( 7(L EG5O$* 2)1*+( K)55*&&*)%(# B(5$%, 7$J#$1( $, K2 6''*+(3 R^dC#(&& C-),)8 2#$.*C /$&S
9% $ 5$I)# '$11)G, )' ,-( +$&( L-(#( $ :+)#C*) L*,- YWA O$,+- 92: L-) L$& -)1.*%J +-$#J( $& /*#(+,)# 0(%(#$1 )' 2)1*+(D E$-$#$&-,#$D *% $..*,*)% ,) O(*%J ,-( /0D ](J$1 $%. "(+-%*+$13
H$I%((&- :(,-D $ >YWW O$,+- 92: )''*+(# $%. /0D T%,*;K)##GC,*)% VG#($G -$& O((% C)&,(. $& ,-( /02 )' ,-( &,$,(3
"-( #(&-G''1( +$5( ,-#(( .$F& $',(# ,-( 7$,*)%$1 9%4(&,*J$,*)% TJ(%+F R79TS $##(&,(. T&&*&,$%, 2)1*+( 9%&C(+,)# :$+-*% a$b( *% +)%%(+,*)% L*,- ,-( T5O$%* ,(##)# &+$#( +$&(3 "-( 79T -$& $11(J(. a$b( L$& ,-( C(#C(,#$,)# )' ,-*& )''(%+(3 E$-$#$&-,#$ B)5( E*%*&,(# T%*1 /(&-5GM- )% a(.%(&.$F (4(%*%J &$*. )% "L*,,(# 7$J#$1( L)G1. O( ,-( %(L % (L EG5O$* 2)1*+( K)55*&&*)%(#3 :*%J- L$& ,#$%&'(##(. ,) B)5( 0G$#.& $& /0D L-*+- *& +)%&*.(#(. ,) O( $ %)%;(d(+G,*4( C)&,3
:$%I$F 2$%.(FD L-) L$& /0D B)5( 0G$#.&D -$& O((% C)&,(. $& /0D E$-$#$&-,#$ :,$,( :(+G#*,F K)#C)#$,*)%D $ C)&, ,-$, -( L$& J*4(% $..*,*)%$1 +-$#J( )'3 :)G#+(& &$*. 2$%.(FD ,-( 5)&, &(%*)# C)1*+( )''*+(# *% ,-( &,$,(D $CC1*(. ')# 1($4( &))% $',(# ,-( C)&,*%J& L(#( $%%)G%+(.3
64(# ,-( 1$&, ,L) .$F&D 1($.(#& *% E$-$#$&-,#$e& ,-#((;C$#,F +)$1*,*)% E$-$ `*M$& TJ-$.* -$4( O((% *% $ '1G##F )' 5((,*%J& ,) .(+*.( )% ,-( +)G#&( )' $+,*)% ,) O( ,$M(% *% ,-( $',(#5$,- )' a$b(e& $##(&,D $%. ,-( .$5$J( *, -$. O#)GJ-, ,) ,-( +#(.*O*1*,F )' ,-( J)4(#%5(%,3
"-( 6CC)&*,*)%D 1(. OF ')#5(# E$-$#$&-,#$ K-*(' E*%*&,(# $%. VU2 1($.(# /(4(%.#$ _$.%$4*&D -$. .(5$%.(. ,-$, :*%J- $%. B)5( E*%*&,(# T%*1 /(&-5GM- O),- O( ,#$%&'(##(.3
fa$b(D L-) L$& -$%.1*%J &(4(#$1 *5C)#,$%, +$&(&D #(C)#,(. .*#(+,1F ,) ,-( EG5O$* K23 9% &C*,( )' ,-*&D 2$#$5 V*# &((5(. %), ,) M%)L L-$, L$& -$CC(%*%J G%.(# -*& %)&(3 "-*& 5$.( 5$,,(#& L)#&( ')# -*53 "-( (%,*#( (C*&).( .*. %), #('1(+, L(11 )% -*& -$%.1*%J )' ,-( ')#+(Dg $ &(%*)# J)4(#%5(%, )''*+*$1 &$*.3
"-( .(+*&*)% ,) ,#$%&'(# 2$#$5 V*# :*%J- L$& ,$M(% "G(&.$F %*J-, ')11)L*%J &(4(#$1 5((,*%J& O(,L((% K-*(' E*%*&,(# [..-$4 "-$+M(#$F $%. 7K2 +-*(' :-$#$. 2$L$#3 fB)L(4(#D .(+*&*)%& $O)G, -*& #(C1$+(5(%, $%. #(1$,(. ,#$%&'(#& L(#( O(*%J L)#M(. )% )4(# ,-( C$&, YWA O$,+- )''*+(#D :(,-D L-) -$& O((% $CC)*%,(. ,-( /02D O(1)%J& ,) ,-( >YWW O$,+-3 fa-*1( J(%(#$11F ,-( /02 *& )' $ &(%*)# O$,+- ,-$% ,-( EG5O$* 2)1*+( K)55*&&*)%(#D *% ,-*& +$&(D &*%+( *, *& IG&, $% $..*,*)%$1 +-$#J( O(*%J J*4(%D *, *& %), $ O*J *&&G(Dg $% )''*+(# &$*.3
**+&%# +.(#> ,-(.**
!""#$%&# (H
**+&%# ,-(.**
Param Bir Singh
Annexure P9
(I.P.S. 1th Floor, Neelima, B.G. Kher Marg, Malabar Hill, Mumbai – 00 00.
20th March 2021 To, The Hon’ble Chief Minister, Maharashtra State, Mumbai. Respected Sir, Re: Untruthful statements by the Hon’ble Home Minister, Maharashtra in
relation to the transfer of o f Shri Param Bir Singh, IPS as Commandant General of Home Guards, Maharashtra State from the post of Commissioner of Police, Mumbai. 1. With all humility at my command and as a true citizen of the Nation who has stood by his oath as a Police Officer for 2 years, I urge you to take note of the below mentioned facts and stand by the Constitutional Constituti onal values that guide the actions of the high seat you occupy. 2. In deference to transfer order dated 1th March 2021 of the Home Department, Govt. of Maharashtra, I have taken charge of the office of the Commandant General of Home Guards, Maharashtra State on the very next date i.e. 1th March 2021. Prior thereto, I have handed over charge of the affairs of the office of the Commissioner Comm issioner of Police, Mumbai. . My transfer was effected under section 22N(2) of the Maharashtra Police Act, 11 with the reason that my transfer was necessitated by administrative exigencies. I believe that the reason for the transfer noted by the Govt. in my file is to ensure a free and fair investigation in the Antilia incident. . On 2th February 2021, a case bearing no. / 2021 was registered with the Gamdevi Police Station Statio n as a result of a car with explosives being found
1
at Altamount Road near Antilia, the residence of Shri Mukesh Ambani. The said case is thereafter being investigated by the ATS and the NIA. All necessary assistance had been rendered by my office and my officers for the conduct of a free and fair investigation by the ATS and the NIA into the Antilia incident. . Shri Anil Deshmukh, Hon’ble Home Minister, Maharashtra has stated in an interview conducted under the aegis of ‘Lokmat’ and extensively reported on 1th March 2021 that: (a) there were serious lapses committed at my office, by the Mumbai Police Poli ce and me in the investigation of the Antilia incident; (b) my serious lapses are not pardonable; and, (c) my transfer is not on administrative grounds. . At one of the briefing sessions in the wake of the Antilia incident held in mid-March 2021 when I was called late evening at Vaha to brief you, I had pointed out several misdeeds and malpractices being indulged into by the Hon’ble Home Minister. I have similarly briefed the Hon’ble Deputy Chief Minister, Maharsahtra, the President of the Nationalist Congress Party, Shri Sharad Pawar and other senior Ministers also about the misdeeds and malpractices. On my briefings, I noticed that some of the Ministers were already aware about some aspects mentioned by me to them. . In the aforesaid context, Shri Sachin Vaze who was heading the Crime Intelligence Unit of the Crime Branch of the Mumbai Police was called by Shri Anil Deshmukh, Hon’ble Home Minister, Maharashtra to his official residence Daeha several times in last few months and repeatedly instructed to assist in collection of funds for the Hon’ble Home Minister. In and around mid-February and thereafter, the Hon’ble Home Minister had called Shri Vaze to his official residence. residence . At that time, one or two staff members of the Hon’ble Home Minister including his Personal Secretary, Mr. Palande, were also present. The Hon’ble Home Minister expressed to Shri Vaze that he had a target to accumulate Rs. 100 crores a month. For achieving the aforesaid target, the Hon’ble Home Minsiter told Shri Vaze that there are about 1,0 bars, restaurants and other establishments in Mumbai and if a sum of Rs. 2- lakhs each was collected from each of
2
them, a monthly collection of Rs. 0-0 crores was achievable. The Hon’ble Home Minister added that the rest of the collection could be made from other sources. . Shri Vaze came to my office the same day and informed me of the above. I was shocked with the above discussion and was mulling over how to deal de al with the situation. . A few days later, Shri Sanjay Patil, ACP, Social Service Branch, was called by the Hon’ble Home Minister at his official residence to hold discussions about the hookah parlours in Mumbai. The meeting was attended by other officers and Shri Palande, Personal Secretary to the Hon’ble Home Minister. Two days later, Shri Patil along with DCP Bhujbal were called at the official residence of the Hon’ble Home Minister for a meeting. While ACP Patil and DCP Bhujbal were made to wait outside the Hon’ble Home Minister’s cabin, Mr. Palande went inside the chamber of the Hon’ble Home Minister and after coming out took ACP Patil and DCP Bhujbal on the side. Mr. Palande informed ACP Patil that the Hon’ble Home Minister was targeting a collection of Rs. 0-0 crores which was possible through an approximate 1,0 bars, restaurants and establishments operating in Mumbai. I was informed by ACP Patil about the demand to make collections for the Hon’ble Home Minister. 10. The The aforesaid meeting at the official residence of the Hon’ble Home Minister with Shri Patil and Shri Bhujbal occurred on th March 2021 as informed to me by Shri Patil. In order to remind myself about the exact conversation that I had with ACP Patil, I messaged ACP Patil on 1 th March 2021. Shri Patil has reconfirmed the aforesaid date and details to me on message on 1th March 2021 & 1th March 2021 and I am reproducing the text of my messages with ACP Patil: Me (1th March 2021, : pm): Pail h ma ba ad he eablihme did HM i ad Palade mei he had me hem i Feb Ad ha a al eeced clleci he meied
Me (1th March 2021, :00 pm): Uge leae ACP Patil (1th March 2021, :1 pm): ba he eablihme i Mmbai Pe eablihme R hee lakh Tal clleci R ce e mh aimael a e hei ifmai
ACP Patil (1th March 2021, :2 pm): M Palade meied befe DCP Bhjbal Efceme h Mach Me (1th March 2021, :2 pm): Ad he did mee HM i befe ha ACP Patil (1th March 2021, :2 pm): Befe da f Hkka biefig Me (1th March 2021, :2 pm): Ad ha i dae f Wae meeig HM i ACP Patil (1th March 2021, : pm): Si I d emid he eac dae Me (1th March 2021, :0 pm): Y aid i a a fe da befe meeig ACP Patil (1th March 2021, : pm): Ye i b i i i ed f Feba Me (1th March 2021, :02 pm): Pail I a me me ifmai Me (1th March 2021, :02 pm): Did Wae mee afe he me HM i ACP Patil (1th March 2021, : pm): Ye i Wae me me afe afe hi meeig ih HM i Me (1th March 2021, :01 pm): Did he ell ahig h HM i had called him
ACP Patil (1th March 2021, :12 pm): The e f meeig a he ld me ha eablihme i Mmbai he hld cllec lakh e eablihme f him al hich ill be ad c Me (1th March 2021, :1 pm): Oh Thi a ame a ha HM i ld ACP Patil (1th March 2021, :1 pm): O h Mach hi PS Palade ld me he ame Me (1th March 2021, :1 pm): Oh e Y me Palade h h ACP Patil (1th March 2021, :1 pm): Ye i I a called 11. After After the meeting of Shri Vaze with the Hon’ble Home Minister, he had discussed the instructions of the Hon’ble Home Minister with Shri Patil and both of them had approached me with their predicaments. 12. The The Hon’ble Home Minister has as a regular practice been repeatedly calling my officers and giving them instructions in respect of the course to be followed by them in performance of their official duties. The Hon’ble Home Minister has been calling my officers at his official residence bypassing me and other superior officers of the Police Department to whom those respective Police Officers report to. The Hon’ble Home Minster has been instructing them to carry out official assignments and collection schemes including financial transactions as per his instructions based on his expectations and targets to collect money. These corrupt malpractices have been brought to my notice by my officers. 1. In In the present context, I may add that late Shri Mohan Delkar, Member of Parliament, Dadra & Nagar Haveli was found dead at Hotel Sea Green on 22nd February 2021. The Marine Drive Police Station recorded ADR No. / 21 in relation to the suicide. A suicide note was found in the course of investigation. The said suicide note blamed senior officials of Dadra & Nagar Haveli and the trouble inflicted by them on Shri Delkar being the
cause of suicide. An appropriate investigation was being undertaken by the Marine Drive Police Department in the said ADR. 1. However, However, from day one, the Hon’ble Home Minister desired a case of abetment of suicide to be registered at Mumbai. My professional view after seeking appropriate legal advice was that while the suicide had occurred in Mumbai, all the alleged acts of abetment had taken place in Dadra & Nagar Haveli. Thus, the abetment of suicide, if any, was required to be investigated by the Police at Dadra & Nagar Haveli who would have jurisdiction in that regard. You will recollect that in a briefing held at Vaha soon after the incident in the presence of a Hon’ble Minister and
several other officials, after I drew attention of all concerned about my view, there was general agreement that the alleged acts of abetment could only be investigated by the Police at Dadra & Nagar Haveli. 1. Dutybound Dutybound to do so, I held to my professional view as advised by legal experts. The Hon’ble Home Minister kept insisting otherwise despite having been informed by me about the opinion of legal experts on this issue. Due to my resistance, the Hon’ble Home Minister was unhappy with me as the political mileage desired to be derived from the registration of the abetment of suicide case in Mumbai in the death of Shri Mohan Delkar, Member of Parliament against senior officials of Dadra & Nagar Haveli was not being achieved. 1. Despite Despite being fully aware of the opinion of the legal experts, the general opinion and the reasons behind it, the Hon’ble Home Minister announced the setting up of a Special Investigation Team (SIT) and registration of an FIR into the alleged case of abetment of suicide of late Shri Mohan Delkar, Member of Parliament, Dadra & Nagar Haveli, on the floor of the Maharashtra Assembly on th March 2021. 1. It It has been my experience during the last more than one year as Commissioner of Police, Mumbai that the Hon’ble Home Minister has on numerous occasions called several officers from the Mumbai Police to his official residence at Daeha for for giving instructions to adopt a specific course of action in police investigations. These acts of political
interference are illegal & unconstitutional and Courts in our country including the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India have in the past come down heavily on such acts of interference in police investigations. In the event of my expressing reservations against the interference from the Hon’ble Home Minister and resistance from me in that regard, the Hon’ble Home Minister has found my reservations and resistance undesirable. 1. I may humbly submit that I take full responsibility of my police force. However, the instances of interference make it clear that the responsibility of wrongdoings may lie somewhere else – at the door of the wrongdoers. 1. On On a collective appraisal of events that have transpired and what is being pointed out by me makes it clear that I have been made a scapegoat to divert attention from the actual wrongdoers. 20. It It is not out of place to mention that there is no iota of material or evidence – far from proof – found against me or even imputed against me. Except for conjectures, surmises and pure speculation, no detail of any sort against me has been noticed by anybody. The call records and phone data of Shri Sachin Vaze be examined to ascertain the truth of the allegations qua me and for the truth to emerge insofar as his association with political functionaries is concerned. 21. In In these circumstances, the assertions of the Hon’ble Home Minister to the effect that my transfer is not for administrative or routine reasons, I have conducted serious lapses and the serious lapses in the investigation committed by me are unpardonable are all statements contrary to the record and seem to be for extraneous and vindictive reasons. 22. As As a civil servant serving the Nation & the State for more than 2 years, the people of Mumbai and the Department of Police, I have been recipient of prestigious awards like Khadtar Seva Medal – Naxalite Area, DGP’s Insignia – 200, Special Service Medal – 200 and Police Medal for Meritorious Services.
2. I have humbly apprised you of the true picture in order to place before you for consideration and corrective action, being fully cognizant to the retaliation that is likely against me for placing the true picture on record. Sincerely yours,
sd/Param Bir Singh I.P.S. Commandant General of Home Guards, Maharashtra State
Copy submitted to: 1. The Hon’ble Deputy Chief Minister Government of Maharashtra Mumbai 2. The Additional Chief Secretary, Home Department Government of Maharashtra Mumbai . The Principal Secretary to the Hon’ble Governor State of Maharashtra Mumbai
//TRUE TYPED COPY//
!""#$%&# ()* !"#$ &'()*+,) )-*' *#"#(.'/ 0-1'/"*'". -2 *!)!/!()./! 34566 /575865 &!.'&9 :;W L5846<
! !77 JH5 8775G8JCKF6 A8N5 BL *4< 3848ABC4 (CFGH 845 M8765E H5 6HK@7N O4KQ5 JH5A< #IA MC7CFG 8 N5M8A8JCKF P865 8G8CF6J HCA<
! *4< 3848ABC4 (CFGH H86 A8N5 JH565 8775G8JCKF6 JK 68Q5 H HCA657M< CA657M< ! #M *4< (CFGH C6 P78CACFG JH8J (8PHCF T8U5 G8Q5 HCA 877 JHC6 CFMK4A8JCKF CF ]8F@84L JH5F SHL NCNFIJ H5 B4CFG JHC6 CFMK4A8JCKF MK4S84N B8PR JH5FV T86 H5 6C75FJ MK4 6K A8FL N8L6V K N5M75PJ JH5 8JJ5FJCKF ! *4< (CFGH H86 P458J5N JHC6 PKF6OC48PL JJK M4KA 5?O7K6CQ56 P865 8FN *8F6@RH )C45FI6 N58JH<
! # 86 86R R JH5 DHC5M *CFC6J54 JK PKFN@PJ 8F @FBC865N ^ M8C4 5FY@C4L KM *4< (CFGHI6 8775G8JCKF6<
++,&%# ,-(#. /0(-++
"# !" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. !"/!0
!"#$%&"' )$*$+ ,-"$.#$)/$!% !101 "21 3333 24 5657 !" 8*!$ )&$!$!-" 9,!:!;< "-1 3333333 -. 5657 !" $%& +0$$&* -.=
0&"&1 2$" .$%34
506/$/$!%6" *6".-.
./&/6 !7 1&4&"&.4/"& 8 !".9 5"6.0!%#6%/.
0));!,0$!-" 0));!,0$!" .-* !"$&*!+ *&;!&.
/: /46 4!%;2+6 )4$67 ,-./$)6 !7 $%#$& &%# 4$. )!10&%$!% ,-./$)6. !7 /46 4!%;2+6 .-0"616 )!-"/ !7 $%#$& /46 4-12+6 &00+$)&/$!% !7 /46 06/$/$!%6" &2!*6%&16# &2!*6% &16# +-'$ *&')&,$.(;;> '%-8&$%=
1.
/ >@>@:A?B @>@:A HAF?B &B>@IE? JK :D >
View more...
Comments
