Final Pre-trial Brief

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES SIXTH JUDICIAL REGION REGIONAL TRIAL COURT ILOILO CITY BRANCH 1  JUAN DE LA CRUZ, !"#$%& Plai'(i), /o'e0 i(2

Civil Case No Fo*+

S-

P*a0e* P*eli-i'a*0 #ve*ss#

o.   .o*

A((a32-e'(

 JOSE DE LA CRUZ,   De.e'4a'( 5##################################5 DEFENDANT6S PRE#TRIAL BRIEF DEFE DEFEND NDA ANT, NT, 70 3o's o'sel el a'4 a'4 (o (2i (2is Ho'o o'o*a7l *a7le e Co*( o*(,, *es8e3(.ll0 s7-i(s (2is P*e#T*ial B*ie. 3o-8lia'3e i(2 (2e (*ial 3o*(6s o*4e* 4a(e4, A9s( :, $!1& I De.e'4a'( is illi'9 (o e'(e* i'(o a' a-i3a7le se((le-e'( o.  (2e 3ase 3ase,, '4e '4e** (e*-s (e*-s a'4 a'4 3o'4 3o'4i( i(io io's 's a9*e a9*eea7 ea7le le (o 7o(2 7o(2 8a*(ies a'4 s7-i( (o al(e*'a(ive -o4es o. 4is8(e *esol(io'; II De.e'4a'( a4-i(s o'l0 a4-i(s 8a*a9*a82s 1, $, a'4 < o. (2e 3o-8lai'( III Isses (o 7e *esolve4 a*e (2e .olloi'9+ A =2e(2e* o* 'o( (2e 8lai'(i) 2as 3ase o. a3(io' B =2e(2e* o* 'o( (2e 4e-a'4 (o 8a0 as -a4e (2e 8lai'(i)  8o' (2e 4e.e'4a'( C =2e(2e* o* 'o( 4e.e'4a'( le.( (2e P2ili88i'es i(2 (2e i'(e'( (o 4e.*a4 (2e 8lai'(i) D =2e(2e* o* 'o( 4e.e'4a'( 2as s>3ie'( 8*o8e*(0 8*o8e*(0 (o 3ove* 2is o7li9a(io' (o (2e 8lai'(i) I?  T2e De.e'4a'( i'(e'4s (o 8*ese'( (2e .olloi'9 Do3-e'(a*0 evi4e'3e+

A J4i3ial A>4avi( o. =i('ess A P*8ose+ To 8*ove (2a( 'o 4e-a'4 as -a4e 70 (2e 8lai'(i)+ B J4i3ial A>4avi( o. =i('ess B P*8ose+ To 8*ove (2a( 4e.e'4a'( is (o leave P2ili88i'es .o* o>3ial 7si'ess C S(a(e-e'( o. Ne( =o*(2 3e*(i@e4 70 Ce*(i@e4 P7li3 A33o'(a'( A''e5 A P*8ose+ To 8*ove (2e availa7ili(0 o. 8*o8e*(ies (o 3ove* .o* (2e o7li9a(io' I? De.e'4a'(s *ese*ves (2e *i92( (o 8*ese'( a44i(io'al 4o3-e'(a*0 evi4e'3e a'4 i('esses i' (2e 3o*se o. (2e 8*o3ee4i'9s Res8e3(.ll0 s7-i((e4 Iloilo Ci(0, A9s( 1&, $!1& /ARY GRACE E SE?ILLA Co'sel .o* (2e De.e'4a'( SE?ILLA BERAYE AND ASSOCIATES Se3o'4 Floo*, XYZ Bil4i'9 Rial S(, Iloilo Ci(0  Tele82o'e No !%% %$!#"$#$% E#-ail a44*ess+ -9esevilla0a2oo3oIBP No !!11 Ja' 1!, $!1: Iloilo Ci(0 PTR No !%"1 Ja' :, $!1:Iloilo Ci(0 Roll No "!$!1 /CLE CO/PLIANCE NO ?#!!%$!1"!&#!$#1"

COPY FURNISHED :

CRIS T CASIPLE Co'sel .o* (2e Plai'(i)  CASIPLE PADILLA AND ASSOCIATES G*o'4 Floo*, AT/ Bil4i'9  Jala'4o'i S(, Iloilo Ci(0  T2e .o*e9oi'9 P*e#(*ial B*ie. as se*ve4 70 *e9is(e*e4 -ail, 8e*so'al se*vi3e 'o( 7ei'9 8*a3(i3al 4e (o (2e la3 o.  -esse'9e*ial 8e*so''el

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES SIXTH JUDICIAL REGION REGIONAL TRIAL COURT ILOILO CITY BRANCH 1  JUAN DE LA CRUZ, !"#$%& Plai'(i), /o'e0 i(2

Civil Case No Fo*+

S-

P*a0e* P*eli-i'a*0 #ve*ss#

o.   .o*

A((a32-e'(

 JOSE DE LA CRUZ,   De.e'4a'( 5##################################5 PLAINTIFF6S PRE#TRIAL BRIEF PLAINTIFF, 70 3o'sel a'4 (o (2is Ho'o*a7le Co*(, *es8e3(.ll0 s7-i(s (2is P*e#T*ial B*ie. 3o-8lia'3e i(2 (2e (*ial 3o*(6s o*4e* 4a(e4, A9s( :, $!1& I Plai'(i) is illi'9 (o e'(e* i'(o a' a-i3a7le se((le-e'( o. (2e 3ase, '4e* (e*-s a'4 3o'4i(io's a9*eea7le (o 7o(2 8a*(ies a'4 s7-i( (o al(e*'a(ive -o4es o. 4is8(e *esol(io'; II Plai'(i) a4-i(s o'l0 a4-i(s 8a*a9*a82s : o. (2e a'se* III Isses (o 7e *esolve4 a*e (2e .olloi'9+ A =2e(2e* o* 'o( (2e 4e-a'4 (2e*e is .ail*e o' (2e 8a*( o.  (2e 4e.e'4a'( (o 2ee4 4e-a'4 o. (2e 8lai'(i) B =2e(2e* o* 'o( 4e.e'4a'( le.( (2e P2ili88i'es i(2 (2e i'(e'( (o 4e.*a4 (2e 8lai'(i) C =2e(2e* o* 'o( 4e.e'4a'( 2as s>3ie'( 8*o8e*(0 (o 3ove* 2is o7li9a(io' (o (2e 8lai'(i)

D =2e(2e* o* 'o( 8lai'(i) is lia7le .o* a((o*'e06s .ees, li(i9a(io's e58e'ses a'4 3os(s I?  T2e 8lai'(i) i'(e'4s (o 8*ese'( (2e .olloi'9 Do3-e'(a*0 evi4e'3e+ A P*o-isso*0 No(e A''e5 as E52i7i( A P*8ose+ To 8*ove (2a( 4e.e'4a'( e5e3(e4 (2e 8*o-isso*0 'o(e a'4 (2e o7li9a(io' is 9e'i'e B De-a'4 Le((e* A''e5 as E52i7i( B P*8ose+ To 8*ove (2a( 8lai'(i) -a4e a *i((e' 4e-a'4 8o' (2e 4e.e'4a'( I? Plai'(i) *ese*ves (2e *i92( (o 8*ese'( a44i(io'al 4o3-e'(a*0 evi4e'3e a'4 i('esses i' (2e 3o*se o. (2e 8*o3ee4i'9s Res8e3(.ll0 s7-i((e4 Iloilo Ci(0, A9s( 1&, $!1& CRIS T CASIPLE Co'sel .o* (2e Plai'(i)  CASIPLE PADILLA AND ASSOCIATES G*o'4 Floo*, AT/ Bil4i'9  Jala'4o'i S(, Iloilo Ci(0  Tele82o'e No !%% %%