Enrile vs Amin

FRANCO, MANUEL JOSEPH U. CLAW | JD-1B TTh | 2:30-4:30PM

PONCE ENRILE VS AMIN GR NO. 93335 September 13, 1990

FACTS:

An n!"#$%&"n '%( !)*+ %%n(& J%n P"n* En#)* %( h%/n "$$&&*+ #**))"n "$)**+ '&h $#+*# %n+ h%#n h$ "! /")%&"n "! PD N". 125. 6& '%( %))**+ &h%& P"n* En#)* *n&*#&%n*+ %n+ %"$$"+%&*+ C"). H"n%(%n 7 /n h$ !""+ %n+ "$!"#& n h( h"(*. 8'"'n &h%& C"). H"n%(%n ( % !&/* !#"$ 9(&*, S*n. En#)* %))**+)7 ++ n"& +" %n7&hn &" h%/* H"n%(%n %##*(&*+ "# %#*h*n+*+. An+ *%(* "! (h !%)#* "! &h* *&&"n*# &h%& #*/*n&*+ C"). H"n%(%n( %##*(& %n+ "n/&"n '%( %))**+)7 % /")%&"n "! S*&"n 1 ;< "! PD N". 125. On M%#h 2, 1550, S*n. En#)* !)*+ %n O$n( M"&"n & '%( +*n*+. Th*n, S*n. F)*+ % M"&"n !"# R*"n(+*#%&"n %n+ &" =%(h>D($(( &h* 6n!"#$%&"n & &h*n %%n '%( +*n*+. 6n #*&#n, S*n. En#)* !)*+ !"# *#&"#%# "n &h* SC $&n #%/* %(* "! +(#*&"n %$"n&n &" )%? "# **(( "! 9#(+&"n "$$&&*+ 7 &h* #*("n+*n& "#& "n &h* !"))"'n #"n+(: %. &h* !%&( +" n"& "n(&&&* " n(&&&* %n "!!*n(*@  . &h* %))**+ h%#"#n %n+ "n*%)n "! C"). H"n%(%n ( %("#*+ n "$)**+ #**))"n@ . &h%& 9(&* #*#*( "n)7 "n* #"(*&"n !"# %)) &h* "$"n*n&( "! #**))"n@ +. n" #"%)* %(* !"# &h* /")%&"n "! PD N". 125@ %n+ *. n" #*)$n%#7 n/*(&%&"n '%( "n+&*+ !"# &h* %))**+ /")%&"n "! PD N". 125.

ISSUE:

Wh*&h*# "# n"& S*n. En#)* * (*%#%&*)7 h%#*+ !"# /")%&"n "! PD N". 125 n"& '&h(&%n+n &h* #**))"n %(* *%#)*# !)*+ %%n(& h$.

EL!:

Th* S#*$* C"#& #%n&*+ &h* *&&"n  *&&"n "! S*n. En#)* %n+ %(h*+ &h* n!"#$%&"n. Th* SC #*&*#%&*+ &h* )"n (&%n+n #"(#&"n %%n(& ()&&n &h* "$"n*n& "!!*n(*( "!  #**))"n %n+ (9*&n &h*$ &" (*%#%&* #"(*&"n(. 6& ( H*#n%n+* %(* &h%& #*$%n( n+n +"&# +"&#n* n* &" #"h #"h& & &h* "$)* "$)*n n  "! #**)) #**))"n "n '&h '&h %n7 "&h*# "&h*# "!!*n "!!*n(* (* "$$& "$$&&*+ &*+ "n &h*

"%("n &h*#*"!, *&h*# %( $*%n( n**((%#7 &" &( "$$(("n "# %( %n n&*n+*+ *!!*& "! %n %&/&7 &h%& "n(&&&*( #**))"n. P*&&"n*#( %& "! h%#"#n "# "n*%)n '%( !"# n" "&h*# #"(* & n !#&h*#%n* "! &h* #$* "! #**))"n &h( "n(&&&n % "$"n*n& &h*#*"!. A)) #$*(, 'h*&h*# n(h%)* n+*#  (*%) )%' "# *n*#%) )%', 'hh %#* $*#* "$"n*n&( "# n#*+*n&(, "# "$$&&*+ n &h* !#&h*#%n* &h*#*"!, *"$* %("#*+ n &h* #$* "! #**))"n %n+ %nn"& * (")%&*+ %n+ h%#*+ %( (*%#%&* #$*(. 6& ( &h* #)* &h%& &h* n#*+*n&( "! % #$* !"#$ %#& %n+ %#*) &h*#*"!, %n+ h*n*, %#* %("#*+ 7 &h* (%$* %n+ %nn"& * n(h*+ *&h*# (*%#%&*)7 &h*#*!#"$ "# 7 %)%&"n "! A#&. 4 "! &h* RPC.