Digest - Camarines Norte Electric Coop. Vs CA

 

Oajarilgs Lnrtg Gkgotrio Onnpgrativg v. OA (XKR) Vgtitinlgr0 Oajarilgs Lnrtg Gkgotrio Onnp. nr OALNRGON Rgspnlhglt0 Ghuarhn Jnrgln, Kt. Onk. Rueiln Omavgz, Oapt. Akerghn Bnr`a, Onlrah Kgvistg alh Uilgs Rgakty Onrp.  

Onlrah K. Kgvistg, nlg ne tmg rgspnlhglts ne tmg oasg, eikgh witm tmg Rgcinlak Xriak Onurt il Hagt, Oajarilgs Lnrtg, a onjpkailt enr onkkgotinl ne a suj ne jnlgy alh  enrgoknsurg   enrgoknsurg ne jnrtcacg acailst Vmikippilg _jgktgr Onrp (V_O). Xmg triak onurt hgokargh V_O il hgeaukt enr eaikurg tn alswgr alh akknwgh Kgvistg tn prgsglt gvihglog. Xmg triak onurt rglhgrgh il eavnr ne pkailtiee Kgvistg alh nrhgrgh tmg hgeglhalt V_O tn pay enr tmg suj ne jnlgy alh hajacgs. Rgspnlhglt smgriee Ghuarhn Jnrgln kgvigh upnl twn parogks ne kalh wmiom wgrg katgr snkh at a pubkio auotinl il eavnr ne Uilgs Rgakty Onrp. Uilgs Rgakty katgr issugh a writ ne pnssgssinl nvgr saih prnpgrty. Gvgltuakky, a onpy ne tmg writ ne pnssgssinl was sgrvgh nl pgtitinlgr (OALNRGON) as nwlgr ne tmg pnwgr kilgs stalhilc nl ogrtail pnrtinls ne tmg sub`got prnpgrty. Katgr, Uilgs Rgakty eikgh al ajglhgh jntinl enr al nrhgr ne hgjnkitinl alh rgjnvak ne ijprnvgjglts (ajnlc wmiom wgrg tmg pnwgr kilgs alh gkgotrio pnsts bgknlcilc tn pgtitinlgr) nl tmg sub`got kalh. Vgtitinlgr nppnsgh tmg jntinl nl tmg crnulh ajnlc ntmgr rgasnls, tmat pgtitinlgr was lnt a party tn tmg oasg, alh was lnt bnulh by tmg `uhcjglt ne tmg triak onurt, alh tmat it mah subsistilc ricmt-ne-way acrggjglts nvgr saih prnpgrty. Xmg XO nrhgrgh tmg issualog ne a writ ne hgjnkitinl. Vgtitinlgr eikgh witm tmg OA a pgtitinl enr prnmibitinl witm rgstraililc nrhgr alh prgkijilary il`ulotinl, arcuilc tmat tmg triak onurt aotgh witmnut nr il gxogss ne its `urishiotinl nr witm cravg abusg ne hisorgtinl. Xmg XO issugh alntmgr nrhgr hirgotilc tmg Latinlak Vnwgr Onrpnratinl sub-ulit il Oajarilgs Lnrtg tn smut nee tmg pnwgr kilgs glgrcizilc tmg Lgw Kuogla Nik Vrnhuots Onrp, nlg ne tmg onlsujgrs sgrviogh by pgtitinlgr. Nl tmg sajg hay, rgspnlhglt Uilgs Rgakty out hnwl pgtitinlgr’s pgtitinl gr’s gkgotrio pnsts. Xmg smgriee, at tmg rgqugst ne Uilgs Rgakty, hgjnkismgh tmg rgjaililc gkgotrio pnsts rgsuktilc il tmg outtilc nee ne pnwgr suppky tn varinus busilgss gstabkismjglts alh baralcays. OA hisjissgh tmg pgtitinl enr kaod ne jgrit.

I__WG0 S/L tmg pgtitinlgr OALNRGON is gltitkgh tn rgtail pnssgssinl ne tmg pnwgr kilgs knoatgh il tmg kalh snkh at pubkio auotinl as a rgsukt ne gxtra-`uhioiak enrgoknsurg ne jnrtcacg>

_O rukgh il tmg aeeirjativg. _O enulh tmat tmg pgtitinlgr was hgligh hug prnogss. _O jailtailgh tmat tmg triak onurt eaikgh tn apprgoiatg tmg laturg ne gkgotrio onnpgrativgs as pubkio utikitigs. Ajnlc tmg pnwgrs craltgh tn gkgotrio onnpgrativgs by virtugs ne VH Ln. 259 arg ‛(d.) Xn gxgroisg tmg pnwgr ne gjilglt hnjail hnj ail il tmg jallgr jall gr prnvihgh by kaw enr tmg gxgroisg ne suom pnwgr by ntmgr onrpnratinls onlstruotilc nr npgratilc gkgotrio cglgratilc pkalts alh gkgotrio tralsjissinl alh histributinl kilgs nr systgjs. Gkgotrio onnpgrativgs, kidg OALNRGON, arg vgstgh witm tmg pnwgr ne gjilglt hnjail. Xmg aoquisitinl ne al gasgjglt ne a ricmt-ne-way ricmt-ne -way eakks witmil tmg purvigw ne tmg pnwgr ne gjilglt hnjail. _uom onlokusinl eilhs suppnrt il gasgjglts ne ricmt-ne-way wmgrg tmg _uprgjg Onurt sustailgh tmg awarh ne `ust onjpglsatinl enr privatg prnpgrty onlhgjlgh enr pubkio usg. Xn lntg, _O rukgh il Rgpubkio v. VKHX0 ‛Lnrjakky, ne onursg, tmg pnwgr ne gjilglt hnjail rgsukts il tmg tadilc nr apprnpriatinl ne titkg tn, alh pnssgssinl ne, tmg gxprnpriatgh prnpgrty4 but ln oncglt rgasnl r gasnl appgars wmy saih pnwgr jay lnt bg avaikgh ne tn ijpnsg nlky a burhgl upnl tmg nwlgr ne onlhgjlgh

 

prnpgrty, witmnut knss ne titkg alh pnssgssinl. It is ulqugstinlabkg tmat rgak prnpgrty jay, tmrnucm gxprnpriatinl, bg sub`gotgh tn al gasgjglt ne ricmt-ne-way.‚ ricmt-ne- way.‚ Vubkio utiktigs’ utiktigs’ pnwgr ne gjilglt hnjail jay bg gxgroisgh aktmnucm titkg is lnt tralsegrrgh tn gxprnpriatnr. Onlsgqugltky, _O rukgh tmat a onurt’s writ ne hgjnkitinl oallnt prgvaik nvgr tmg gasgjglt ne a ricmt -neway wmiom eakks witmil tmg pnwgr ne gjilglt hnjail. Vgtitinl is craltgh. OA hgoisinl is sgt asihg. XO nrhgrs arg allukkgh.