Del Castillo 2009 - 2015.pdf

184 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

2015 G.R. No. 207633 December 9, 2015 People v. Lagangga y Dumpa ...G.R. No. 207633. December 9, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 203397 December 9, 2015 Trinidad II v. Spouses Palad ...G.R. No. 203397. December 9, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 202215 December 9, 2015 Vicmar Development Corp. v. Elarcosa ...G.R. No. 202215. December 9, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 203115 December 7, 2015 Island Overseas Transport Corp. v. Beja ...G.R. No. 203115. December 7, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 197096-97 December 7, 2015 King v. Robles ...G.R. Nos. 197096-97. December 7, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201652 December 2, 2015 Heirs of Latayan v. Tan ...G.R. No. 201652. December 2, 2015.]... ...... G.R. No. 195654 November 25, 2015 Inutan v. Napar Contracting & Allied Services ...G.R. No. 195654. November 25, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 202611 November 23, 2015 Mangubat v. Morga-Seva ...G.R. No. 202611. November 23, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179257 November 23, 2015 United Alloy Phils. Corp. v. United Coconut Planters Bank ...G.R. No. 179257. November 23, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 202859 November 11, 2015 New Filipino Maritime Agencies, Inc. v. Datayan ...G.R. No. 202859. November 11, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197458 November 11, 2015 Pinlac y Resolme v. People ...G.R. No. 197458. November 11, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 192955 November 9, 2015 Etom, Jr. v. Aroma Lodging House ...G.R. No. 192955. November 9, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 211638 October 7, 2015 Saso v. 88 Aces Maritime Service, Inc. ...G.R. No. 211638. October 7, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201535 October 5, 2015 NEC System Integrated Construction Phils., Inc. v. Crisologo ...G.R. No. 201535. October 5, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201359 September 23, 2015 Magsaysay Maritime Corp. v. Mazaredo ...G.R. No. 201359. September 23, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 204835 September 22, 2015 Movertrade Corp. v. Commission on Audit ...G.R. No. 204835. September 22, 2015.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

1

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201945 September 21, 2015 Maersk-Filipinas Crewing, Inc. v. Jaleco ...G.R. No. 201945. September 21, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201793 September 16, 2015 Philippine Transmarine Carriers, Inc. v. Aligway ...G.R. No. 201793. September 16, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197484 September 16, 2015 Carique v. Philippine Scout Veterans Security and Investigation Agency, Inc. ...G.R. No. 197484. September 16, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 202090 September 9, 2015 ICT Marketing Services, Inc. v. Sales ...G.R. No. 202090. September 9, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201536 September 9, 2015 Grace Marine Shipping Corp. v. Alarcon ...G.R. No. 201536. September 9, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 199931 September 7, 2015 INC Shipmanagement, Inc. v. Camporedondo ...G.R. No. 199931. September 7, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197472 September 7, 2015 Republic v. Cortez, Sr. ...G.R. No. 197472. September 7, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198426 September 2, 2015 Republic v. Principalia Management and Personnel Consultants, Inc. ...G.R. No. 198426. September 2, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 203142 August 26, 2015 Philippine Ports Authority v. Coalition of PPA Officers and Employees ...G.R. No. 203142. August 26, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201405 August 24, 2015 Andres v. Sta. Lucia Realty & Development, Inc. ...G.R. No. 201405. August 24, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 200114 August 24, 2015 Social Security System v. Ubaña ...G.R. No. 200114. August 24, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 8084 August 24, 2015 Salabao v. Villaruel, Jr. ...A.C. No. 8084. August 24, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198643 August 19, 2015 Marsman & Co. v. Ligo ...G.R. No. 198643. August 19, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196875 August 19, 2015 Maravilla v. Rios ...G.R. No. 196875. August 19, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 210164 August 18, 2015 Arnado v. Commission on Elections ...G.R. No. 210164. August 18, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.M. No. CA-12-26-P August 17, 2015 Office of the Court Administrator v. Abarintos ...A.M. No. CA-12-26-P. August 17, 2015.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

2

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201822 August 12, 2015 Marina Port Services, Inc. v. American Home Assurance Corp. ...G.R. No. 201822. August 12, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 202967 August 5, 2015 Laurel v. Vardeleon ...G.R. No. 202967. August 5, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 200969 August 3, 2015 Romero v. Singson ...G.R. No. 200969. August 3, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197709 August 3, 2015 Jose Yulo Agricultural Corp. v. Spouses Davis ...G.R. No. 197709. August 3, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175188 July 15, 2015 Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. La Tondeña Distillers, Inc. ...G.R. No. 175188. July 15, 2015.]... ...... A.M. No. P-07-2293 July 15, 2015 Office of the Court Administrator v. Guan ...A.M. No. P-07-2293. July 15, 2015.]... ...... G.R. No. 199660 July 13, 2015 U-Bix Corp. v. Hollero ...G.R. No. 199660. July 13, 2015.]... ...... G.R. No. 196853 July 13, 2015 Chua v. People ...G.R. No. 196853. July 13, 2015.]... ...... G.R. No. 200773 July 8, 2015 Republic v. Dayaoen ...G.R. No. 200773. July 8, 2015.]... ...... G.R. No. 198096 July 8, 2015 Centennial Transmarine, Inc. v. Quiambao ...G.R. No. 198096. July 8, 2015.]... ...... G.R. No. 197731 July 6, 2015 Olarte y Tarug v. People ...G.R. No. 197731. July 6, 2015.]... ...... G.R. No. 201836 June 22, 2015 People v. Britanico ...G.R. No. 201836. June 22, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197923 June 22, 2015 Serrano Mahilum v. Spouses Ilano ...G.R. No. 197923. June 22, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 195513 June 22, 2015 Beduya v. Ace Promotion and Marketing Corp. ...G.R. No. 195513. June 22, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191787 June 22, 2015 Catipon, Jr. v. Japson ...G.R. No. 191787. June 22, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 199568 June 17, 2015 Dohle-Philman Manning Agency, Inc. v. Heirs of Gazzingan ...G.R. No. 199568. June 17, 2015.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196707 June 17, 2015 Spouses Mercado v. Land Bank of the Phils. ...G.R. No. 196707. June 17, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196278 June 17, 2015 CE Casecnan Water & Energy Company, Inc. v. Province of Nueva Ecija ...G.R. No. 196278. June 17, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 720 June 17, 2015 Caoile v. Macaraeg ...A.C. No. 720. June 17, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201042 June 16, 2015 Daraga Press, Inc. v. Commission on Audit ...G.R. No. 201042. June 16, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 200942 June 16, 2015 People v. Wahiman y Rayos ...G.R. No. 200942. June 16, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198515 June 15, 2015 Malabunga, Jr. v. Cathay Pacific Steel Corp. ...G.R. No. 198515. June 15, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 182255 June 15, 2015 Petron Corp. v. Caberte ...G.R. No. 182255. June 15, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198465 April 22, 2015 Litex Glass and Aluminum Supply v. Sanchez ...G.R. No. 198465. April 22, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198012 April 22, 2015 People v. Mateo y Jacinto ...G.R. No. 198012. April 22, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196357 April 20, 2015 Heirs of dela Cruz v. Philippine Transmarine Carriers, Inc. ...G.R. No. 196357. April 20, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198543 April 15, 2015 Republic v. Pasicolan ...G.R. No. 198543. April 15, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 202708 April 13, 2015 People v. Villar ...G.R. No. 202708. April 13, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 5116 April 13, 2015 Davao Import Distributors, Inc. v. Landero ...A.C. No. 5116. April 13, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 193169 April 6, 2015 Roque v. People ...G.R. No. 193169. April 6, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 200759 March 25, 2015 FAJ Construction & Development Corp. v. Saulog ...G.R. No. 200759. March 25, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 202805 March 23, 2015 Banguis-Tambuyat v. Balcom-Tambuyat ...G.R. No. 202805. March 23, 2015.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

4

3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 197115 & 197267 March 23, 2015 Republic v. Daclan ...G.R. No. 197115. March 23, 2015.]... ...G.R. No. 197267. March 23, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 201427 March 18, 2015 Adolfo v. Adolfo ...G.R. No. 201427. March 18, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 200983 March 18, 2015 Republic v. Huang Te Fu ...G.R. No. 200983. March 18, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198024 March 16, 2015 People v. Cunanan y David ...G.R. No. 198024. March 16, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 205492 March 11, 2015 Republic v. Spouses Benigno ...G.R. No. 205492. March 11, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 192284 March 11, 2015 Tionco y Ortega v. People ...G.R. No. 192284. March 11, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 7158 March 9, 2015 Andres v. Nambi ...A.C. No. 7158. March 9, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197818 February 25, 2015 People v. Diaz y Roxas ...G.R. No. 197818. February 25, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 200308 February 23, 2015 People v. Nielles ...G.R. No. 200308. February 23, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 195774 February 23, 2015 People v. Basilio y Hernandez ...G.R. No. 195774. February 23, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 194606 February 18, 2015 People v. Reyes y Santos ...G.R. No. 194606. February 18, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 193855 February 18, 2015 People v. Perondo ...G.R. No. 193855. February 18, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 195850 February 16, 2015 People v. Bio y Panayangan ...G.R. No. 195850. February 16, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 195245 February 16, 2015 People v. Gabuya y Adlawan ...G.R. No. 195245. February 16, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 194999 February 9, 2015 People v. Nepomuceno y Pedraza ...G.R. No. 194999. February 9, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190348 February 9, 2015 People v. Colentava

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

5

2 2 5 5

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 204 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...G.R. No. 190348. February 9, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 192785 February 4, 2015 People v. Butial ...G.R. No. 192785. February 4, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 207257, 207276, etc. February 3, 2015 Paje v. Casiño ...G.R. No. 207257. February 3, 2015.]... ...G.R. No. 207276. February 3, 2015.]... ...G.R. No. 207282. February 3, 2015.]... ...G.R. No. 207366. February 3, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191060 February 2, 2015 People v. Alvarez ...G.R. No. 191060. February 2, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 200169 January 28, 2015 Aguilar v. Siasat ...G.R. No. 200169. January 28, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 199648 January 28, 2015 First Optima Realty Corp. v. Securitron Security Services, Inc. ...G.R. No. 199648. January 28, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 192270 January 26, 2015 Ofilada v. Spouses Andal ...G.R. No. 192270. January 26, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 200333 January 21, 2015 People v. Dilla y Paular ...G.R. No. 200333. January 21, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191540 January 21, 2015 Spouses Gatuslao v. Yanson ...G.R. No. 191540. January 21, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191710 January 14, 2015 De Guzman v. Filinvest Development Corp. ...G.R. No. 191710. January 14, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 200797 January 12, 2015 People v. Opiana y Tanael ...G.R. No. 200797. January 12, 2015.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... 2014 G.R. No. 192232 December 10, 2014 People v. Prodenciado ...G.R. No. 192232. December 10, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190349 December 10, 2014 People v. Delfin ...G.R. No. 190349. December 10, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 193670 December 3, 2014 People v. Dela Cruz y Sebastian ...G.R. No. 193670. December 3, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 193385 December 1, 2014 People v. Gandawali y Gapas ...G.R. No. 193385. December 1, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196102 November 26, 2014 Government Service Insurance System v. Calumpiano

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

6

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...G.R. No. 196102. November 26, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190322 November 26, 2014 People v. Amora y Viscarra ...G.R. No. 190322. November 26, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197590 November 24, 2014 Bureau of Internal Revenue v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 197590. November 24, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191260 November 24, 2014 People v. Brita ...G.R. No. 191260. November 24, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190863 November 19, 2014 People v. Sato ...G.R. No. 190863. November 19, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184618 November 19, 2014 Peak Ventures Corp. v. Heirs of Villareal ...G.R. No. 184618. November 19, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190623 November 17, 2014 People v. Araza y Sagun ...G.R. No. 190623. November 17, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183872 November 17, 2014 Mackay v. Spouses Caswell ...G.R. No. 183872. November 17, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190175 November 12, 2014 People v. Cabrera ...G.R. No. 190175. November 12, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185449 November 12, 2014 Goodyear Phils., Inc. v. Angus ...G.R. No. 185449. November 12, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 9395 November 12, 2014 Daging v. Davis ...A.C. No. 9395. November 12, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198878 October 15, 2014 Residents of Lower Atab & Teachers' Village v. Sta. Monica Industrial & Development Corp. ...G.R. No. 198878. October 15, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183272 October 15, 2014 Sun Life of Canada (Phils.), Inc. v. Tan Kit ...G.R. No. 183272. October 15, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198528 October 13, 2014 Magsaysay Mitsui OSK Marine, Inc. v. Bengson ...G.R. No. 198528. October 13, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 193650 October 8, 2014 Palileo v. Planters Development Bank ...G.R. No. 193650. October 8, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 193426 September 29, 2014 Subic Bay Legend Resorts and Casinos, Inc. v. Fernandez ...G.R. No. 193426. September 29, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176020 September 29, 2014 Heirs of Julao v. Spouses De Jesus

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

7

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2

...G.R. No. 176020. September 29, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 7337 September 29, 2014 Viray v. Sanicas ...A.C. No. 7337. September 29, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 195289 September 24, 2014 Robinson's Bank Corp. v. Gaerlan ...G.R. No. 195289. September 24, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 189850 September 22, 2014 People v. Torres y Nava ...G.R. No. 189850. September 22, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176121 September 22, 2014 Spouses Rosete v. Briones ...G.R. No. 176121. September 22, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181921 September 17, 2014 InterOrient Maritime Enterprises, Inc. v. Creer III ...G.R. No. 181921. September 17, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178911 September 17, 2014 Monsanto v. Lim ...G.R. No. 178911. September 17, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178733 September 15, 2014 Angeles v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 178733. September 15, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198139 September 8, 2014 National Power Corp. v. Tarcelo ...G.R. No. 198139. September 8, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197329 September 8, 2014 National Power Corp. v. Spouses Samar ...G.R. No. 197329. September 8, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183360 September 8, 2014 De La Paz v. L & J Development Co. ...G.R. No. 183360. September 8, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197336 September 3, 2014 Meyr Enterprises Corp. v. Cordero ...G.R. No. 197336. September 3, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 189812 September 1, 2014 People v. Baturi ...G.R. No. 189812. September 1, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177616 August 27, 2014 Heirs of Spouses Manguardia v. Heirs of Valles ...G.R. No. 177616. August 27, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181541 August 18, 2014 People v. Marcelo ...G.R. No. 181541. August 18, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 171836 & 195213 August 11, 2014 Department of Agrarian Reform v. Galle ...G.R. No. 171836. August 11, 2014.]... ...G.R. No. 195213. August 11, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191015 August 6, 2014

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

8

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

People v. Go ...G.R. No. 191015. August 6, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196219 July 30, 2014 Spouses Tabino v. Tabino ...G.R. No. 196219. July 30, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 195190 July 28, 2014 Royale Homes Marketing Corp. v. Alcantara ...G.R. No. 195190. July 28, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178115 July 28, 2014 People v. Sumilhig ...G.R. No. 178115. July 28, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196786 July 23, 2014 People v. Bunagan y Juan ...G.R. No. 196786. July 23, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 197046 July 21, 2014 People v. Zapata y Viana ...G.R. No. 197046. July 21, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196249 July 21, 2014 Angeles v. Bucad ...G.R. No. 196249. July 21, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 186589 July 18, 2014 Silverio, Sr. v. Silverio, Jr. ...G.R. No. 186589. July 18, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177484 July 18, 2014 Spouses Manzanilla v. Waterfields Industries Corp. ...G.R. No. 177484. July 18, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 169745 & 170091 July 18, 2014 Republic v. Namboku Peak, Inc. ...G.R. No. 169745. July 18, 2014.]... ...G.R. No. 170091. July 18, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173861 July 14, 2014 Candelaria v. RTC, Br. 42, City of San Fernando ...G.R. No. 173861. July 14, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185100 July 9, 2014 Ico v. Systems Technology Institute, Inc. ...G.R. No. 185100. July 9, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 163999 July 9, 2014 Philippine Long Distance Telephone Co. v. Ocampo ...G.R. No. 163999. July 9, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176341 July 7, 2014 Pro-Guard Security Services Corp. v. Tormil Realty and Development Corp. ...G.R. No. 176341. July 7, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 166680 July 7, 2014 Lumauig v. People ...G.R. No. 166680. July 7, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181045 July 2, 2014 Spouses Silos v. Philippine National Bank ...G.R. No. 181045. July 2, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

9

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

G.R. No. 178055 July 2, 2014 Amecos Innovations, Inc. v. Lopez ...G.R. No. 178055. July 2, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177374 July 2, 2014 Jose v. Novida ...G.R. No. 177374. July 2, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 192011 June 30, 2014 Libcap Marketing Corp. v. Baquial ...G.R. No. 192011. June 30, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177425 June 18, 2014 Gipa v. Southern Luzon Institute ...G.R. No. 177425. June 18, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179914 & A.M. No. RTJ-06-2000 June 16, 2014 Spouses Sombilon v. Garay ...G.R. No. 179914. June 16, 2014.]... ...A.M. No. RTJ-06-2000. June 16, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 194818 June 9, 2014 Bumagat v. Arribay ...G.R. No. 194818. June 9, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179535 June 9, 2014 Espineli v. People ...G.R. No. 179535. June 9, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177592 June 9, 2014 Alilin v. Petron Corp. ...G.R. No. 177592. June 9, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179669 June 4, 2014 SR Metals, Inc. v. Reyes ...G.R. No. 179669. June 4, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 199871 June 2, 2014 People v. Solano, Jr. y Gecita ...G.R. No. 199871. June 2, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191906 June 2, 2014 Jacinto v. Gumaru, Jr. ...G.R. No. 191906. June 2, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169247 June 2, 2014 Nahas v. Olarte ...G.R. No. 169247. June 2, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181949 April 23, 2014 Heirs of Bihag v. Heirs of Bathan ...G.R. No. 181949. April 23, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196753 April 21, 2014 People v. Lalog ...G.R. No. 196753. April 21, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 199442 April 7, 2014 People v. Abaigar ...G.R. No. 199442. April 7, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 198059 April 7, 2014 People v. Lujeco y Macanoquit ...G.R. No. 198059. April 7, 2014.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

10

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196970 April 2, 2014 People v. Santiago ...G.R. No. 196970. April 2, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180496 April 2, 2014 People v. San Gaspar ...G.R. No. 180496. April 2, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191727 March 31, 2014 People v. Aplat y Sublino ...G.R. No. 191727. March 31, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196142 March 26, 2014 Castillo v. Prudentialife Plans, Inc. ...G.R. No. 196142. March 26, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 199740 March 24, 2014 People v. Obogne ...G.R. No. 199740. March 24, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 193516 March 24, 2014 Macedonio v. Ramo ...G.R. No. 193516. March 24, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176055 March 17, 2014 Spouses Dela Cruz v. Spouses Capco ...G.R. No. 176055. March 17, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183034 March 12, 2014 Spouses Santos v. Alcazar ...G.R. No. 183034. March 12, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181806 March 12, 2014 Wesleyan University-Phils. v. Wesleyan University-Faculty and Staff Ass'n. ...G.R. No. 181806. March 12, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191360 March 10, 2014 People v. Bis y Avellaneda ...G.R. No. 191360. March 10, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 193684 March 5, 2014 One Network Rural Bank, Inc. v. Baric ...G.R. No. 193684. March 5, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 193047 March 3, 2014 Fil-Pride Shipping Co., Inc. v. Balasta ...G.R. No. 193047. March 3, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180962 February 26, 2014 Philtranco Service Enterprises, Inc. v. Philtranco Workers Union-Ass'n. of Genuine Labor Organizations ...G.R. No. 180962. February 26, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179625 February 24, 2014 Bucton v. Rural Bank of El Salvador, Inc. ...G.R. No. 179625. February 24, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179031 February 24, 2014 People v. Soria y Gomez ...G.R. No. 179031. February 24, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173523 February 19, 2014 Demaala v. Sandiganbayan ...G.R. No. 173523. February 19, 2014.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

11

2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190524 February 17, 2014 Balasbas v. Monayao ...G.R. No. 190524. February 17, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 171590 & 171598 February 12, 2014 Bignay Ex-Im Phils., Inc. v. Union Bank of the Phils. ...G.R. No. 171590. February 12, 2014.]... ...G.R. No. 171598. February 12, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190621 February 10, 2014 People v. Salvador y Balverde ...G.R. No. 190621. February 10, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 195525 February 5, 2014 People v. Gunda ...G.R. No. 195525. February 5, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185145 February 5, 2014 Spouses Afulugencia v. Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co. ...G.R. No. 185145. February 5, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191215 February 3, 2014 Thenamaris Phils., Inc. v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 191215. February 3, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 196435 January 29, 2014 People v. Crisostomo y Malliar ...G.R. No. 196435. January 29, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191189 January 29, 2014 Manlar Rice Mill, Inc. v. Deyto ...G.R. No. 191189. January 29, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178184 January 29, 2014 Grand Asian Shipping Lines, Inc. v. Galvez ...G.R. No. 178184. January 29, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 194612 January 27, 2014 People v. Manigo y Macalua ...G.R. No. 194612. January 27, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180972 January 20, 2014 Garza v. Coca-Cola Bottlers Phils., Inc. ...G.R. No. 180972. January 20, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 192371 January 15, 2014 Land Bank of the Phils. v. Oñate ...G.R. No. 192371. January 15, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183918 January 15, 2014 Lim v. Equitable PCI Bank ...G.R. No. 183918. January 15, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176043 January 15, 2014 Spouses Vilbar v. Opinion ...G.R. No. 176043. January 15, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 192034 January 13, 2014 Alpha Ship Management Corp. v. Calo ...G.R. No. 192034. January 13, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183204 January 13, 2014 Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co. v. Rosales

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

12

...G.R. No. 183204. January 13, 2014.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... 160 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

2013 G.R. No. 189840 December 11, 2013 People v. Montevirgen y Ozaraga ...G.R. No. 189840. December 11, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 192105 December 9, 2013 Locsin II v. Mekeni Food Corp. ...G.R. No. 192105. December 9, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 194169 December 4, 2013 Araullo v. Office of the Ombudsman ...G.R. No. 194169. December 4, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175356 December 3, 2013 Manila Memorial Park, Inc. v. Secretary of the Department of Social Welfare & Development ...G.R. No. 175356. December 3, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184496 December 2, 2013 Hadji Hashim Abdul v. Sandiganbayan ...G.R. No. 184496. December 2, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 4549 December 2, 2013 Felipe v. Macapagal ...A.C. No. 4549. December 2, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191756 November 25, 2013 People v. Guillen y Atienza ...G.R. No. 191756. November 25, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180200 November 25, 2013 Digital Telecommunications Phils., Inc. v. Cantos ...G.R. No. 180200. November 25, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184565 November 20, 2013 De Leon v. Bank of the Phil. Islands ...G.R. No. 184565. November 20, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 10043 November 20, 2013 Cabauatan v. Venida ...A.C. No. 10043. November 20, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 5239 November 18, 2013 Spouses Warriner v. Dublin ...A.C. No. 5239. November 18, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 8954 November 13, 2013 Rodriguez-Manahan v. Flores ...A.C. No. 8954. November 13, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 192183 November 11, 2013 People v. Zulieta ...G.R. No. 192183. November 11, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181473 November 11, 2013 People v. Gaduyon y Tapispisan ...G.R. No. 181473. November 11, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 9385 November 11, 2013 Agadan v. Kilaan ...A.C. No. 9385. November 11, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191362 October 9, 2013

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

13

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

People v. Cial y Lorena ...G.R. No. 191362. October 9, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190622 October 7, 2013 People v. De Jesus y Mendoza ...G.R. No. 190622. October 7, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183110 October 7, 2013 Republic v. Batuigas ...G.R. No. 183110. October 7, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 195011-19 September 30, 2013 Singian, Jr. v. Sandiganbayan ...G.R. Nos. 195011-19. September 30, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167174 September 23, 2013 Spouses Aldover v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 167174. September 23, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 187731 September 18, 2013 People v. Alawig ...G.R. No. 187731. September 18, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 171594-96 September 18, 2013 Asia Brewery, Inc. v. Tunay na Pagkakaisa ng mga Manggagawa sa Asia ...G.R. Nos. 171594-96. September 18, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170388 September 4, 2013 Colegio del Santisimo Rosario v. Rojo ...G.R. No. 170388. September 4, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 189822 September 2, 2013 People v. Suansing ...G.R. No. 189822. September 2, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178031 August 28, 2013 Venzon v. Rural Bank of Buenavista (Agusan del Norte), Inc. ...G.R. No. 178031. August 28, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172293 August 28, 2013 Cabrera v. Francisco ...G.R. No. 172293. August 28, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174727 August 12, 2013 Ining v. Vega ...G.R. No. 174727. August 12, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185549 August 7, 2013 Ang v. San Joaquin, Jr. ...G.R. No. 185549. August 7, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179648 August 7, 2013 Philippine National Bank v. Arcobillas ...G.R. No. 179648. August 7, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181359 August 5, 2013 Spouses Sabitsana, Jr. v. Muertegui ...G.R. No. 181359. August 5, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179326 July 31, 2013 Cañedo v. Kampilan Security and Detective Agency, Inc. ...G.R. No. 179326. July 31, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 182280 July 29, 2013

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

14

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

Aguilar v. O'Pallick ...G.R. No. 182280. July 29, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175666 July 29, 2013 Manila Bankers Life Insurance Corp. v. Aban ...G.R. No. 175666. July 29, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190340 July 24, 2013 People v. Ramos ...G.R. No. 190340. July 24, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172346 July 24, 2013 Spouses Bonrostro v. Spouses Luna ...G.R. No. 172346. July 24, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176111 July 17, 2013 Jose v. Suarez ...G.R. No. 176111. July 17, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173587 July 15, 2013 Zuellig Pharma Corp. v. Sibal ...G.R. No. 173587. July 15, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179638 July 8, 2013 Heirs of Miranda, Sr. v. Miranda ...G.R. No. 179638. July 8, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180281 July 1, 2013 People v. Jalbonian ...G.R. No. 180281. July 1, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177050 July 1, 2013 Lim v. Development Bank of the Phils. ...G.R. No. 177050. July 1, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180476 June 26, 2013 Coderias v. Estate of Chioco ...G.R. No. 180476. June 26, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179736 June 26, 2013 Spouses Hing v. Choachuy, Sr. ...G.R. No. 179736. June 26, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179448 June 26, 2013 Tanenggee v. People ...G.R. No. 179448. June 26, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185719 June 17, 2013 People v. Collado y Cunanan ...G.R. No. 185719. June 17, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175773 June 17, 2013 Mitsubishi Motors Phils. Salaried Employees Union v. Mitsubishi Motors Phils. Corp. ...G.R. No. 175773. June 17, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174908 June 17, 2013 Maslag v. Monzon ...G.R. No. 174908. June 17, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181195 June 10, 2013 Orais v. Almirante ...G.R. No. 181195. June 10, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 189297 June 5, 2013

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

15

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

People v. Lomaque ...G.R. No. 189297. June 5, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171692 June 3, 2013 Spouses Tumibay v. Spouses Lopez ...G.R. No. 171692. June 3, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180843 April 17, 2013 Garcia v. Vda. de Caparas ...G.R. No. 180843. April 17, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171298 April 15, 2013 Spouses Cacayorin v. Armed Forces and Police Mutual Benefit Ass'n., Inc. ...G.R. No. 171298. April 15, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181182 April 10, 2013 Boardwalk Business Ventures, Inc. v. Villareal ...G.R. No. 181182. April 10, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178952 April 10, 2013 Heirs of Gallardo v. Soliman ...G.R. No. 178952. April 10, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.M. No. P-06-2256 April 10, 2013 Gabriel v. Ramos ...A.M. No. P-06-2256. April 10, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176289 April 8, 2013 Moldex Realty, Inc. v. Saberon ...G.R. No. 176289. April 8, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178758 April 3, 2013 Spouses Dalangin v. Perez ...G.R. No. 178758. April 3, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179041 April 1, 2013 People v. Mallari ...G.R. No. 179041. April 1, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178125 March 18, 2013 The Orchard Golf and Country Club v. Francisco ...G.R. No. 178125. March 18, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180636 March 13, 2013 Tangga-an v. Philippine Transmarine Carriers, Inc. ...G.R. No. 180636. March 13, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 9259 March 13, 2013 Rodica v. Lazaro ...A.C. No. 9259. March 13, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179611 March 12, 2013 Almuete v. People ...G.R. No. 179611. March 12, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173622 March 11, 2013 Robern Development Corp. v. People's Landless Ass'n. ...G.R. No. 173622. March 11, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 188841 March 6, 2013 People v. Fernandez y Hertez ...G.R. No. 188841. March 6, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175492 February 27, 2013

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

16

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

Octavio v. Philippine Long Distance Telephone Co. ...G.R. No. 175492. February 27, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178347 February 25, 2013 Villanueva v. Palawan Council for Sustainable Development ...G.R. No. 178347. February 25, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 182358 February 20, 2013 Department of Health v. Phil Pharmawealth, Inc. ...G.R. No. 182358. February 20, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179965 February 20, 2013 Diego v. Diego ...G.R. No. 179965. February 20, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173520 January 30, 2013 National Power Corp. v. Spouses Zabala ...G.R. No. 173520. January 30, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181218 January 28, 2013 Republic v. Heirs of Spouses Bautista ...G.R. No. 181218. January 28, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 189355 January 23, 2013 People v. Cabungan ...G.R. No. 189355. January 23, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173425 January 22, 2013 Fort Bonifacio Development Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 173425. January 22, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184698 January 21, 2013 Spouses Castro v. Palenzuela ...G.R. No. 184698. January 21, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180463 January 16, 2013 Republic v. AFP Retirement and Separation Benefits System ...G.R. No. 180463. January 16, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179628 January 16, 2013 The Manila Insurance Co., Inc. v. Spouses Amurao ...G.R. No. 179628. January 16, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178611 January 14, 2013 Orpiano v. Spouses Tomas ...G.R. No. 178611. January 14, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180919 January 9, 2013 People v. Seraspe ...G.R. No. 180919. January 9, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170770 January 9, 2013 Aguirre II v. FQB+7, Inc. ...G.R. No. 170770. January 9, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177751 January 7, 2013 People v. Agacer ...G.R. No. 177751. January 7, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173559 January 7, 2013 Diona v. Balangue ...G.R. No. 173559. January 7, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172590 January 7, 2013

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

17

2 135 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

Anderson v. Ho ...G.R. No. 172590. January 7, 2013.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... 2012 G.R. No. 177086 December 5, 2012 Ching v. Bantolo ...G.R. No. 177086. December 5, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181138 December 3, 2012 Marquez v. People ...G.R. No. 181138. December 3, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176898 December 3, 2012 Sy v. Autobus Transport Systems, Inc. ...G.R. No. 176898. December 3, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173606 December 3, 2012 Villondo v. Quijano ...G.R. No. 173606. December 3, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184181 November 26, 2012 People v. Robelo y Tungala ...G.R. No. 184181. November 26, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184056 November 26, 2012 People v. Eyam y Watang ...G.R. No. 184056. November 26, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185386 November 21, 2012 People v. Aneslag y Andrade ...G.R. No. 185386. November 21, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180076 November 21, 2012 Mananquil v. Moico ...G.R. No. 180076. November 21, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179754 November 21, 2012 Chung, Jr. v. Mondragon ...G.R. No. 179754. November 21, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175792 November 21, 2012 Spouses Magtoto v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 175792. November 21, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175481 November 21, 2012 Auza, Jr. v. MOL Phils., Inc. ...G.R. No. 175481. November 21, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179031 November 14, 2012 People v. Soria y Gomez ...G.R. No. 179031. November 14, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176791 November 14, 2012 Communities Cagayan, Inc. v. Spouses Nanol ...G.R. No. 176791. November 14, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183827 November 12, 2012 People v. Ending y Onyong ...G.R. No. 183827. November 12, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178622 November 12, 2012 Ladano v. Neri ...G.R. No. 178622. November 12, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

18

2 2 2 2 5 5

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

G.R. No. 178431 November 12, 2012 V.C. Ponce Co., Inc. v. Municipality of Parañaque ...G.R. No. 178431. November 12, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172471 November 12, 2012 Perla v. Baring ...G.R. No. 172471. November 12, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 153799, 157169, 157327 & 157506 September 17, 2012 Solidbank Union v. Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co. ...G.R. No. 153799. September 17, 2012.]... ...G.R. No. 157169. September 17, 2012.]... ...G.R. No. 157327. September 17, 2012.]... ...G.R. No. 157506. September 17, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183097 September 12, 2012 People v. Venturina ...G.R. No. 183097. September 12, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184606 September 5, 2012 People v. Fundales, Jr. ...G.R. No. 184606. September 5, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175170 September 5, 2012 Misamis Oriental II Electric Service Cooperative v. Cagalawan ...G.R. No. 175170. September 5, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173425 September 4, 2012 Fort Bonifacio Development Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 173425. September 4, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177137 August 23, 2012 People v. Banig ...G.R. No. 177137. August 23, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 175256 & 179160 August 23, 2012 Lim v. Kou Co Ping ...G.R. No. 175256. August 23, 2012.]... ...G.R. No. 179160. August 23, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173268 August 23, 2012 Fajardo v. Office of the Ombudsman ...G.R. No. 173268. August 23, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 9259 August 23, 2012 Rodica v. Lazaro ...A.C. No. 9259. August 23, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178288 August 15, 2012 Spouses Fortaleza v. Spouses Lapitan ...G.R. No. 178288. August 15, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.C. No. 9074 August 14, 2012 Anacta v. Resurreccion ...A.C. No. 9074. August 14, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175969 August 1, 2012 JARL Construction v. Atencio ...G.R. No. 175969. August 1, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172008 August 1, 2012 Heirs of Isip, Sr. v. Quintos ...G.R. No. 172008. August 1, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

19

2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

G.R. No. 171076 August 1, 2012 Goldloop Properties, Inc. v. Government Service Insurance System ...G.R. No. 171076. August 1, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176251 July 25, 2012 Lagaya y Tamondong v. People ...G.R. No. 176251. July 25, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178477 July 16, 2012 Heirs of Gayares v. Pacific Asia Overseas Shipping Corp. ...G.R. No. 178477. July 16, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 170071 & 170125 July 16, 2012 Heirs of Ochoa v. G & S Transport Corp. ...G.R. No. 170071. July 16, 2012.]... ...G.R. No. 170125. July 16, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174893 July 11, 2012 Reyes-Rayel v. Philippine Luen Thai Holdings, Corp. ...G.R. No. 174893. July 11, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.M. No. P-06-2241 July 10, 2012 Dalmacio-Joaquin v. Dela Cruz ...A.M. No. P-06-2241. July 10, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175851 July 4, 2012 Lim v. Mindanao Wines & Liquor Galleria ...G.R. No. 175851. July 4, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176949 June 27, 2012 Asian Construction and Development Corp. v. Mendoza ...G.R. No. 176949. June 27, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175055 June 27, 2012 Land Bank of the Phils. v. Heirs of Puyat ...G.R. No. 175055. June 27, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174181 June 27, 2012 D' Aigle v. People ...G.R. No. 174181. June 27, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176671 June 20, 2012 Apo Cement Corp. v. Baptisma ...G.R. No. 176671. June 20, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184467 June 19, 2012 Navia v. Pardico ...G.R. No. 184467. June 19, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 182920 June 18, 2012 People v. Biglete y Camacho ...G.R. No. 182920. June 18, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175430 June 18, 2012 Republic v. Ong ...G.R. No. 175430. June 18, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179059 June 13, 2012 Rondina v. People ...G.R. No. 179059. June 13, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175350 June 13, 2012 Equitable Banking Corp. v. Special Steel Products, Inc. ...G.R. No. 175350. June 13, 2012.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

20

2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174937 June 13, 2012 Vda. de Mendez v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 174937. June 13, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173870 April 25, 2012 Del Carmen, Jr. v. Bacoy ...G.R. No. 173870. April 25, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 170865 & 170892 April 25, 2012 Philippine National Bank v. Spouses Cheah ...G.R. No. 170865. April 25, 2012.]... ...G.R. No. 170892. April 25, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175042 April 23, 2012 Du v. Jayoma ...G.R. No. 175042. April 23, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177761 April 18, 2012 People v. Tanchanco y Pineda ...G.R. No. 177761. April 18, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175139 April 18, 2012 Estores v. Spouses Supangan ...G.R. No. 175139. April 18, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173951 April 16, 2012 Ison v. Crewserve, Inc. ...G.R. No. 173951. April 16, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175303 April 11, 2012 Pacific Ace Finance, Ltd. v. Yanagisawa ...G.R. No. 175303. April 11, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174489 April 11, 2012 Baltazar v. Laxa ...G.R. No. 174489. April 11, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175980 February 15, 2012 People v. Cabtalan ...G.R. No. 175980. February 15, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175025 February 15, 2012 Jakosalem v. Barangan ...G.R. No. 175025. February 15, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174445 February 15, 2012 Spouses Guidangen v. Wooden ...G.R. No. 174445. February 15, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173882 February 15, 2012 Julie's Bakeshop v. Arnaiz ...G.R. No. 173882. February 15, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173531 February 1, 2012 Oliveros v. San Miguel Corp. ...G.R. No. 173531. February 1, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173774 January 30, 2012 Manila Electric Co. v. Beltran ...G.R. No. 173774. January 30, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179497 January 25, 2012 People v. Mamaruncas

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

21

3 3

2 2 170 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...G.R. No. 179497. January 25, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 174089 & 174266 January 25, 2012 Orix Metro Leasing & Finance Corp. v. Mangalinao y Dizon ...G.R. No. 174089. January 25, 2012.]... ...G.R. No. 174266. January 25, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173648 January 16, 2012 Pigcaulan v. Security and Credit Investigation, Inc. ...G.R. No. 173648. January 16, 2012.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... 2011 G.R. No. 177751 December 14, 2011 People v. Agacer ...G.R. No. 177751. December 14, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 182915 & 189658 December 12, 2011 Sy v. Fairland Knitcraft Co., Inc. ...G.R. No. 182915. December 12, 2011.]... ...G.R. No. 189658. December 12, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174193 December 7, 2011 Julian v. Development Bank of the Phils. ...G.R. No. 174193. December 7, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172624 December 5, 2011 Polsotin, Jr. v. De Guia Enterprises, Inc. ...G.R. No. 172624. December 5, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181204 November 28, 2011 People v. Concillado ...G.R. No. 181204. November 28, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174143 November 28, 2011 Spouses Hipolito, Jr. v. Cinco ...G.R. No. 174143. November 28, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 165338 & 179375 November 28, 2011 Mahinay v. Gako, Jr. ...G.R. No. 165338. November 28, 2011.]... ...G.R. No. 179375. November 28, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178901 November 23, 2011 Government Service Insurance System v. Besitan ...G.R. No. 178901. November 23, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167140 November 23, 2011 Dela Merced v. Government Service Insurance System ...G.R. No. 167140. November 23, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176884 October 19, 2011 Valenzona v. Fair Shipping Corp. ...G.R. No. 176884. October 19, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176229 October 19, 2011 Ho Wai Pang v. People ...G.R. No. 176229. October 19, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171660 October 17, 2011 Continental Cement Corp. v. Asea Brown Boveri, Inc. ...G.R. No. 171660. October 17, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179195 October 3, 2011 People v. Yanson

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

22

2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...G.R. No. 179195. October 3, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177218 October 3, 2011 People v. Sales ...G.R. No. 177218. October 3, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170404 September 28, 2011 Cruz v. Gingoyon ...G.R. No. 170404. September 28, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 178699 & 178735 September 21, 2011 BPI Employees Union-Metro Manila v. Bank of the Phil. Islands ...G.R. No. 178699. September 21, 2011.]... ...G.R. No. 178735. September 21, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 166357 September 19, 2011 Kalaw v. Fernandez ...G.R. No. 166357. September 19, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173038 September 14, 2011 Duarte v. Duran ...G.R. No. 173038. September 14, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170486 September 12, 2011 Swift Foods, Inc. v. Spouses Mateo, Jr. ...G.R. No. 170486. September 12, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169331 September 5, 2011 Rom v. Roxas & Co., Inc. ...G.R. No. 169331. September 5, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175991 August 31, 2011 Catacutan v. People ...G.R. No. 175991. August 31, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175289 August 31, 2011 Villarin v. People ...G.R. No. 175289. August 31, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174980 August 31, 2011 Aurelio y Reyes v. People ...G.R. No. 174980. August 31, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172660 August 24, 2011 Basbas v. Sayson ...G.R. No. 172660. August 24, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174654 August 17, 2011 Abellana v. People ...G.R. No. 174654. August 17, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167545 August 17, 2011 Atiko Trans, Inc. v. Prudential Guarantee and Assurance, Inc. ...G.R. No. 167545. August 17, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169901 August 3, 2011 Philippine National Bank v. Jumamoy ...G.R. No. 169901. August 3, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171569 August 1, 2011 Union Bank of the Phils. v. Juniat ...G.R. No. 171569. August 1, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180390 July 27, 2011

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

23

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

Prudential Bank v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 180390. July 27, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172506 July 27, 2011 Mapili v. Philippine Rabbit Bus Lines, Inc. ...G.R. No. 172506. July 27, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168251 July 27, 2011 Montemayor v. Millora ...G.R. No. 168251. July 27, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173259 July 25, 2011 Philippine National Bank v. F.F. Cruz & Co., Inc. ...G.R. No. 173259. July 25, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167284 July 6, 2011 Estate of Maninang v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 167284. July 6, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176061 July 4, 2011 People v. Campos ...G.R. No. 176061. July 4, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172227 June 29, 2011 Spouses Palada v. Solidbank, Corp. ...G.R. No. 172227. June 29, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174158 June 27, 2011 Barroga v. Data Center College of the Phils. ...G.R. No. 174158. June 27, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176740 June 22, 2011 People v. Dumadag y Romio ...G.R. No. 176740. June 22, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170658 June 22, 2011 Calubaquib v. Republic ...G.R. No. 170658. June 22, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170646 June 22, 2011 Santos v. Litton Mills, Inc. ...G.R. No. 170646. June 22, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170416 June 22, 2011 University Plans, Inc. v. Solano ...G.R. No. 170416. June 22, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170292 June 22, 2011 Home Development Mutual Fund v. Spouses See ...G.R. No. 170292. June 22, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181126 June 15, 2011 Umale v. ASB Realty Corp. ...G.R. No. 181126. June 15, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171628 June 13, 2011 Alano v. Planter's Development Bank ...G.R. No. 171628. June 13, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 164153 June 13, 2011 Espiritu v. Tankiansee ...G.R. No. 164153. June 13, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175834 June 8, 2011

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

24

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

People v. Asetre y Duran ...G.R. No. 175834. June 8, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171972 June 8, 2011 Rodriguez v. Salvador ...G.R. No. 171972. June 8, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170575 June 8, 2011 Spouses Del Rosario v. Gerry Roxas Foundation, Inc. ...G.R. No. 170575. June 8, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168382 June 6, 2011 Airline Pilots Ass'n. of the Phils. v. Philippine Airlines, Inc. ...G.R. No. 168382. June 6, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 160506 June 6, 2011 Aliviado v. Procter & Gamble Phils., Inc. ...G.R. No. 160506. June 6, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170914 April 13, 2011 Miñoza v. Lopez ...G.R. No. 170914. April 13, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175831 April 12, 2011 People v. Relanes ...G.R. No. 175831. April 12, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174861 April 11, 2011 People v. Olesco y Andayang ...G.R. No. 174861. April 11, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171129 April 6, 2011 Santos v. NSO ...G.R. No. 171129. April 6, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169564 April 6, 2011 Jerusalem v. Keppel Monte Bank ...G.R. No. 169564. April 6, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171406 April 4, 2011 Asian Terminals, Inc. v. Malayan Insurance Co., Inc. ...G.R. No. 171406. April 4, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169766 March 30, 2011 Juliano-Llave v. Republic ...G.R. No. 169766. March 30, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169575 March 30, 2011 Pantollano v. Korphil Shipmanagement and Manning Corp. ...G.R. No. 169575. March 30, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170195 March 28, 2011 Social Security Commission v. Favila ...G.R. No. 170195. March 28, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172678 March 23, 2011 Sea Lion Fishing Corp. v. People ...G.R. No. 172678. March 23, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169260 March 23, 2011 Sanden Aircon Phils. v. Rosales ...G.R. No. 169260. March 23, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167518 March 23, 2011

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

25

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2

Bank of the Phil. Islands v. Coquia, Jr. ...G.R. No. 167518. March 23, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174504 March 21, 2011 People v. Sandiganbayan ...G.R. No. 174504. March 21, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169717 March 16, 2011 Samahang Manggagawa sa Charter Chemical-Super v. Charter Chemical and Coating Corp. ...G.R. No. 169717. March 16, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 191388 March 9, 2011 Asia United Bank v. Goodland Co., Inc. ...G.R. No. 191388. March 9, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 170071 & 170125 March 9, 2011 Heirs of Ochoa v. G & S Transport Corp. ...G.R. No. 170071. March 9, 2011.]... ...G.R. No. 170125. March 9, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168523 March 9, 2011 Spouses Edralin v. Philippine Veterans Bank ...G.R. No. 168523. March 9, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.M. No. RTJ-08-2149 March 9, 2011 Benancillo v. Amila ...A.M. No. RTJ-08-2149. March 9, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181371 March 2, 2011 Central Luzon Drug Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 181371. March 2, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181298 March 2, 2011 Belle Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 181298. March 2, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167751 March 2, 2011 Harpoon Marine Services, Inc. v. Francisco ...G.R. No. 167751. March 2, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169754 February 23, 2011 Legend International Resorts Ltd. v. Kilusang Manggagawa ng Legenda ...G.R. No. 169754. February 23, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 166109 February 23, 2011 Exodus International Construction Corp. v. Biscocho ...G.R. No. 166109. February 23, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 171328 & 171335 February 16, 2011 Sy Franco v. People ...G.R. No. 171328. February 16, 2011.]... ...G.R. No. 171335. February 16, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172203 February 14, 2011 Lopez y Aberasturi v. People ...G.R. No. 172203. February 14, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168240 February 9, 2011 Go v. Sunbanun ...G.R. No. 168240. February 9, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168501 January 31, 2011 Islriz Trading/Victor Hugo Lu v. Capada ...G.R. No. 168501. January 31, 2011.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

26

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 250 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169942 January 24, 2011 Barangay Dasmariñas v. Creative Play Corner School ...G.R. No. 169942. January 24, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168757 January 19, 2011 Real v. Sangu Phils., Inc. ...G.R. No. 168757. January 19, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165423 January 19, 2011 Padre v. Badillo ...G.R. No. 165423. January 19, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172378 January 17, 2011 Silicon Phils., Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 172378. January 17, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 168646 & 168666 January 12, 2011 Luzon Development Bank v. Enriquez ...G.R. No. 168646. January 12, 2011.]... ...G.R. No. 168666. January 12, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181298 January 10, 2011 Belle Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 181298. January 10, 2011.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... 2010 G.R. No. 174251 December 15, 2010 Palomata v. Colmenares ...G.R. No. 174251. December 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 149261 December 15, 2010 Corpuz v. Del Rosario ...G.R. No. 149261. December 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177779 December 14, 2010 People v. Nachor y Omayan ...G.R. No. 177779. December 14, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 189366 December 13, 2010 Philippine Long Distance Telephone Co. v. Honrado ...G.R. No. 189366. December 13, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168325 December 13, 2010 Tuazon v. Del Rosario-Suarez ...G.R. No. 168325. December 13, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 163293 & 163297 December 13, 2010 Equitable PCI Bank v. Dompor ...Nos. 163293 & 163297. December 13, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179948 December 8, 2010 People v. Barcela y Medina ...G.R. No. 179948. December 8, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172139 December 8, 2010 Toledo v. Hyden ...G.R. No. 172139. December 8, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168840 December 8, 2010 Lacson v. MJ Lacson Development Co., Inc. ...G.R. No. 168840. December 8, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183709 December 6, 2010

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

27

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

People v. Pojo ...G.R. No. 183709. December 6, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179044 December 6, 2010 People v. Lucero y Paw-as ...G.R. No. 179044. December 6, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173021 October 20, 2010 Lamsis v. Dong-e ...G.R. No. 173021. October 20, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170073 October 18, 2010 Spouses Pudadera v. Magallanes ...G.R. No. 170073. October 18, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 164757 October 18, 2010 Cebu Metro Pharmacy, Inc. v. Euro-Med Laboratories, Phils., Inc. ...G.R. No. 164757. October 18, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 161431 October 13, 2010 Calibre Traders, Inc. v. Bayer Phils., Inc. ...G.R. No. 161431. October 13, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184952 October 11, 2010 People v. Gonzaga y Jomaya ...G.R. No. 184952. October 11, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177127 October 11, 2010 J.R.A. Phils., Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 177127. October 11, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184823 October 6, 2010 Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Aichi Forging Co. of Asia, Inc. ...G.R. No. 184823. October 6, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167810 October 4, 2010 Republic v. Rambuyong ...G.R. No. 167810. October 4, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165923 September 29, 2010 Shimizu Phils. Contractors, Inc. v. Callanta ...G.R. No. 165923. September 29, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170685 September 22, 2010 Land Bank of the Phils. v. Livioco ...G.R. No. 170685. September 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167567 September 22, 2010 San Miguel Corp. v. Puzon, Jr. ...G.R. No. 167567. September 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175195 September 15, 2010 Bug-atan v. People ...G.R. No. 175195. September 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168715 September 15, 2010 Medline Management, Inc. v. Roslinda ...G.R. No. 168715. September 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 164913 September 8, 2010 St. Mary's Academy of Dipolog City v. Palacio ...G.R. No. 164913. September 8, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181829 September 1, 2010

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

28

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

People v. Villanueva ...G.R. No. 181829. September 1, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171526 September 1, 2010 Crisostomo v. People ...G.R. No. 171526. September 1, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 179045-46 August 25, 2010 Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Smart Communication, Inc. ...G.R. Nos. 179045-46. August 25, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168387 August 25, 2010 Marquez v. Espejo ...G.R. No. 168387. August 25, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 182094 August 18, 2010 People v. Alfonso ...G.R. No. 182094. August 18, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175315 August 9, 2010 People v. Beduya ...G.R. No. 175315. August 9, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171115 August 9, 2010 Nagkakaisang Lakas ng Manggagawa sa Keihin v. Keihin Phils. Corp. ...G.R. No. 171115. August 9, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165770 August 9, 2010 Heirs of Medrano v. De Vera ...G.R. No. 165770. August 9, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 164538 August 9, 2010 Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co. v. Reynado ...G.R. No. 164538. August 9, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 166236 July 29, 2010 Alfonso v. Spouses Andres ...G.R. No. 166236. July 29, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165976 July 29, 2010 Sonic Steel Industries, Inc. v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 165976. July 29, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165569 July 29, 2010 University of Santo Tomas v. Sanchez ...G.R. No. 165569. July 29, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173150 July 28, 2010 Gelig v. People ...G.R. No. 173150. July 28, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169999 July 26, 2010 New Puerto Commercial v. Lopez ...G.R. No. 169999. July 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168583 July 26, 2010 Montaño v. Verceles ...G.R. No. 168583. July 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165554 July 26, 2010 Pasco v. Heirs of De Guzman ...G.R. No. 165554. July 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 162608 July 26, 2010

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

29

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

Adrian Wilson International Associates, Inc. v. TMX Phils., Inc. ...G.R. No. 162608. July 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185215 July 22, 2010 Bautista v. Civil Service Commission ...G.R. No. 185215. July 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170464 July 12, 2010 Lambert Pawnbrokers and Jewelry Corp. v. Binamira ...G.R. No. 170464. July 12, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172611 July 9, 2010 Spouses Valenzuela v. Spouses Mano, Jr. ...G.R. No. 172611. July 9, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171873 July 9, 2010 Municipality of Tiwi v. Betito ...G.R. No. 171873. July 9, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165168 July 9, 2010 Spouses Montecalvo v. Heirs of Primero ...G.R. No. 165168. July 9, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175730 July 5, 2010 Disini v. Sandiganbayan ...G.R. No. 175730. July 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175700 July 5, 2010 Rebellion v. People ...G.R. No. 175700. July 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168960 July 5, 2010 Hebron v. Loyola ...G.R. No. 168960. July 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168164 July 5, 2010 Adriano v. Tanco ...G.R. No. 168164. July 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 165036 & 175705 July 5, 2010 Antolin v. Domondon ...G.R. No. 165036. July 5, 2010.]... ...G.R. No. 175705. July 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 164402 July 5, 2010 Vda. de Aguilar v. Spouses Alfaro ...G.R. No. 164402. July 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179710 June 29, 2010 People v. Berdadero y Armamento ...G.R. No. 179710. June 29, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168062 June 29, 2010 Victorias Milling Co., Inc. v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 168062. June 29, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167942 June 29, 2010 Asian Construction and Development Corp. v. Cathay Pacific Steel Corp. ...G.R. No. 167942. June 29, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 166134 June 29, 2010 Angeles City v. Angeles Electric Corp. ...G.R. No. 166134. June 29, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

30

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

G.R. No. 164791 June 29, 2010 Lao v. Special Plans, Inc. ...G.R. No. 164791. June 29, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185209 June 28, 2010 People v. Baron y Tangarocan ...G.R. No. 185209. June 28, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167678 June 22, 2010 Southeastern Shipping v. Navarra, Jr. ...G.R. No. 167678. June 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169135 June 18, 2010 Delos Reyes v. Ramnani ...G.R. No. 169135. June 18, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 164443 June 18, 2010 Masangkay v. People ...G.R. No. 164443. June 18, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170956 May 12, 2010 Ferrer v. Carganillo ...G.R. No. 170956. May 12, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 160718 May 12, 2010 Bustillo v. People ...G.R. No. 160718. May 12, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178087 May 5, 2010 Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Kudos Metal Corp. ...G.R. No. 178087. May 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 174719 May 5, 2010 Heirs of Pacres v. Heirs of Ygoña ...G.R. No. 174719. May 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172708 May 5, 2010 People v. Amper y Repaso ...G.R. No. 172708. May 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 163267 May 5, 2010 Evangelista v. People ...G.R. No. 163267. May 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 162230 April 28, 2010 Vinuya v. Romulo ...G.R. No. 162230. April 28, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 182341 April 23, 2010 Go v. Chaves ...G.R. No. 182341. April 23, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167237 April 23, 2010 Associate Anglo-American Tobacco Corp. v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 167237. April 23, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165300 April 23, 2010 Ferrer v. Spouses Diaz ...G.R. No. 165300. April 23, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 163554 April 23, 2010 Pantoja v. SCA Hygiene Products Corp. ...G.R. No. 163554. April 23, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

31

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3

G.R. No. 179935 April 19, 2010 People v. Asis y Lacson ...G.R. No. 179935. April 19, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175532 April 19, 2010 Basay v. Hacienda Consolacion ...G.R. No. 175532. April 19, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172896 April 19, 2010 Seguritan y Jara v. People ...G.R. No. 172896. April 19, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 166829 April 19, 2010 TFS, Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 166829. April 19, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165155 April 13, 2010 Regional Agrarian Reform Adjudication Board v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 165155. April 13, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190582 April 8, 2010 Ang Ladlad LGBT Party v. Commission on Elections ...G.R. No. 190582. April 8, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170289 April 8, 2010 Quidet v. People ...G.R. No. 170289. April 8, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 160825 March 26, 2010 Rovira v. Heirs of Deleste ...G.R. No. 160825. March 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 159381 March 26, 2010 Ansaldo v. People ...G.R. No. 159381. March 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 158104 March 26, 2010 De Guzman v. Gonzalez III ...G.R. No. 158104. March 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181247 March 19, 2010 People v. Napalit y De Guzman ...G.R. No. 181247. March 19, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172873 March 19, 2010 People v. Morales y Midarasa ...G.R. No. 172873. March 19, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172357 March 19, 2010 People v. Bustamante y Zapanta ...G.R. No. 172357. March 19, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.M. No. P-08-2559 March 19, 2010 Plaza v. Amamio ...A.M. No. P-08-2559. March 19, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 173854 March 15, 2010 Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Far East Bank & Trust Company ...G.R. No. 173854. March 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. Nos. 173510 & 174099 March 15, 2010 Diega y Pajares v. Court of Appeals ...G.R. No. 173510. March 15, 2010.]... ...G.R. No. 174099. March 15, 2010.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

32

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171092 March 15, 2010 Lhuillier v. British Airways ...G.R. No. 171092. March 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169548 March 15, 2010 Titan Construction Corp. v. David, Sr. ...G.R. No. 169548. March 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 164016 March 15, 2010 Reno Foods, Inc. v. Nagkakaisang Lakas ng Manggagawa-Katipunan ...G.R. No. 164016. March 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 160506 March 9, 2010 Aliviado v. Procter & Gamble Phils., Inc. ...G.R. No. 160506. March 9, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190078 March 5, 2010 Spouses Certeza, Jr. v. Philippine Savings Bank ...G.R. No. 190078. March 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185012 March 5, 2010 People v. Villarino y Mabute ...G.R. No. 185012. March 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179792 March 5, 2010 LNS International Manpower Services v. Padua, Jr. ...G.R. No. 179792. March 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 158627 March 5, 2010 People v. Martinez y Dulay ...G.R. No. 158627. March 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176518 March 2, 2010 PTA of St. Mathew Christian Academy v. Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co. ...G.R. No. 176518. March 2, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183505 February 26, 2010 Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. SM Prime Holdings, Inc. ...G.R. No. 183505. February 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 167415 February 26, 2010 Gubat v. National Power Corp. ...G.R. No. 167415. February 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 164141 February 26, 2010 Tiger Construction and Development Corp. v. Abay ...G.R. No. 164141. February 26, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 184546 February 22, 2010 People v. Suan y Jolongon ...G.R. No. 184546. February 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169481 February 22, 2010 Republic v. Heirs of Ramos ...G.R. No. 169481. February 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181809 February 17, 2010 Doromal v. Biron ...G.R. No. 181809. February 17, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 190156 February 12, 2010 Dangan-Corral v. Commission on Elections ...G.R. No. 190156. February 12, 2010.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

33

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168967 February 12, 2010 City of Iloilo v. Contreras-Besana ...G.R. No. 168967. February 12, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 158385 February 12, 2010 Palali v. Awisan ...G.R. No. 158385. February 12, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180302 February 5, 2010 Areno, Jr. v. Skycable PCC-Baguio ...G.R. No. 180302. February 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179717 February 5, 2010 People v. Alberto y de Nieva ...G.R. No. 179717. February 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175097 February 5, 2010 Allied Banking Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 175097. February 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 169706 February 5, 2010 Spouses Genato v. Viola ...G.R. No. 169706. February 5, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 182221 February 3, 2010 Saño, Jr. v. Commission on Elections ...G.R. No. 182221. February 3, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 183577 February 1, 2010 People v. Escoton ...G.R. No. 183577. February 1, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177361 February 1, 2010 Vidar v. People ...G.R. No. 177361. February 1, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 162336 February 1, 2010 Soriano v. People ...G.R. No. 162336. February 1, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 182722 January 22, 2010 Dumaguete Cathedral Credit Cooperative v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue ...G.R. No. 182722. January 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180870 January 22, 2010 Cacao y Prieto v. People ...G.R. No. 180870. January 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 180374 January 22, 2010 Buada v. Cement Center, Inc. ...G.R. No. 180374. January 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179161 January 22, 2010 Philippine National Bank v. DKS International, Inc. ...G.R. No. 179161. January 22, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... A.M. No. RTJ-08-2152 January 18, 2010 Delos Reyes v. Cruz ...A.M. No. RTJ-08-2152. January 18, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178318 January 15, 2010 People v. Estrada ...G.R. No. 178318. January 15, 2010.]...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

34

2 2 2 2 2 2 46 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175319 January 15, 2010 People v. Noque y Gomez ...G.R. No. 175319. January 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 163271 January 15, 2010 Spouses Bernales v. Heirs of Sambaan ...G.R. No. 163271. January 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 157095 January 15, 2010 Dazon v. Yap ...G.R. No. 157095. January 15, 2010.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... 2009 G.R. No. 174480 December 18, 2009 People v. Albalate, Jr. ...G.R. No. 174480. December 18, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 172822 December 18, 2009 MOF Co., Inc. v. Shin Yang Brokerage Corp. ...G.R. No. 172822. December 18, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171023 December 18, 2009 Quiambao v. Manila Electric Co. ...G.R. No. 171023. December 18, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 166570 December 18, 2009 Herrera v. National Power Corp. ...G.R. No. 166570. December 18, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 160367 December 18, 2009 Cabungcal v. Lorenzo ...G.R. No. 160367. December 18, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165109 December 14, 2009 Mamba v. Lara ...G.R. No. 165109. December 14, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 147951 December 14, 2009 Olegario v. Mari ...G.R. No. 147951. December 14, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 177384 December 8, 2009 Wee v. Republic ...G.R. No. 177384. December 8, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 175994 December 8, 2009 Campos v. Pastrana ...G.R. No. 175994. December 8, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 161929 December 8, 2009 Dela Cruz v. Sandiganbayan ...G.R. No. 161929. December 8, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 178527 November 27, 2009 Yuki, Jr. v. Co ...G.R. No. 178527. November 27, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 170906 November 27, 2009 Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co. v. Lamb Construction Consortium Corp. ...G.R. No. 170906. November 27, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 168940 November 24, 2009 Spouses Castro v. Tan

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

35

2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2

...G.R. No. 168940. November 24, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 164886 November 24, 2009 Loy, Jr. v. San Miguel Corp. Employees Union-Phil. Transport and General Workers Organization ...G.R. No. 164886. November 24, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 163406 November 24, 2009 Power Sites & Signs, Inc. v. United Neon ...G.R. No. 163406. November 24, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 179370 November 18, 2009 Capablanca v. Civil Service Commission ...G.R. No. 179370. November 18, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165679 October 5, 2009 Dueñas v. Guce-Africa ...G.R. No. 165679. October 5, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 181559 October 2, 2009 Nazareno v. City of Dumaguete ...G.R. No. 181559. October 2, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 176070 October 2, 2009 People v. Madeo ...G.R. No. 176070. October 2, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 165332 October 2, 2009 Republic v. Yang Chi Hao ...G.R. No. 165332. October 2, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J. p ... G.R. No. 161952 October 2, 2009 Sagana v. Francisco ...G.R. No. 161952. October 2, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 185001 September 25, 2009 Lumayna v. Commission on Audit ...G.R. No. 185001. September 25, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:... G.R. No. 171340 September 11, 2009 Hallasgo v. Commission on Audit ...G.R. No. 171340. * September 11, 2009.]... ...DEL CASTILLO, J p:...

Copyright 1994-2016

CD Technologies Asia, Inc.

The Bench Companion Supreme Court Rulings 1901-2015

36