Cpc Pleadings
Short Description
detailed analysis on the same....
Description
SVKM’S NMIMS SCHOOL OF LAW LAW
A PROJECT SUBMITTED ON; PLEADINGS
IN COMPLIANCE COMPLIA NCE TO PARTIAL PARTIAL FULFILLMENT FULFILL MENT OF THE MARKING SCHEME, FOR TRIMESTER VI OF 2015-201, IN THE SUBJECT OF CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE SUBMITTED SUBMITT ED TO FACULT!" FACULT!" P#$%& S'#()*+ A('* FOR EVALUATION SUBMITTED B!" ./+* A( A01 N*+3(+( C'*4*+ A02 D/6'+* G$/7'* A080 A#9+ G/$#:/ A05 RECEIVED B!" #(/6 '/9 '*=/ //+ 4#(/+ *+3 '*=/ /7$/ /7'+(7* /:* 3$7>/+6, 7*#/%>9 %#*/3 9 '/ *$#+/96 $% '/ ?*#(/6& T'/ 7$+/+ $% '/6/ 3$7>/+6 *+3 '/ *++/# (+ 4'(7' '/9 *#/ $ / /?$9/3 (+ '/ ((:*($+ '*=/ /7$/ '/ 6>/7 $% #>/6 (+ :/+/#* $% * '(:'9 #/%(+/3 +*>#/& P/*3(+: (6 '/ +*/ :(=/+ $ '/ /:* 67(/+7/ 4'(7' 3/*6 4(' '/6/ #>/6& T'/ ?/*3(+:6 '/#/%$#/ 6/#=/ '/ ?#(*#9 ?>#?$6/ $% *7>*(+(+: '/ 7$># *+3 '/ ?*#(/6 4(' '/ %*76 (+ 3(6?>/& T'/9 6'$>3 (+ 6$ 3$(+: ?$(+ $> '/ *7>* (66>/6 $ / 6//3& S/=/#* $'/# ?>#?$6/6 *9 *6$ / 6/#=/3 9 '/ ?/*3(+:6& T'>6 * C$(// $% '/ A/#(7*+ B*# A66$7(*($+ 7*66(%(/3 '/ *(+ ?>#?$6/6 $ / *7'(/=/3 9 '/ ?/*3(+:6 *6 %$$46" 1 $ 6/#=/ *6 * %$#* *6(6 %$# '/ >3:/+ $ / /+/#/3; 2 $ 6/?*#*/ (66>/6 $% %*7 %#$ >/6($+6 $% *4; 8 $ :(=/ '/ ((:*+6 '/ *3=*+*:/ $% '/ ?/* $% #/6 *3>3(7** (% *:*(+ $/6/3; $ +$(%9 '/ ?*#(/6 $% '/ 7*(6, 3/%/+6/6 *+3 7#$66-3/*+36 $% '/(# *3=/#6*#(/6& A6 '/#/(+*%/# ?$(+/3 $> (+ '/ 3(67>66($+ $% %>+7($+6 $% P/*3(+:& F>#'/#$#/, ?/*3(+: (6 * #*+7' $% '/ *4 $% #//3(/6 /(6(+: %$# '/ /+%$#7//+ $% '/ 6>6*+(=/ >#* #/*($+6 $% '/ ?*#(/6&
EVOLUTION
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rder 6 of Civil Procedre Code& Rle 1 3/%(+/6 ?/*3(+:, 4'(/ Rle ! *96 3$4+ '/ %>+3*/+* ?#(+7(?/6 $% ?/*3(+:6" Rle # $o Rle 1# #/>(#/ '/ ?*#(/6 $ 6>??9 +/7/66*#9 ?*#(7>*#6& Rle 1% &'d 1( ?#$=(3/ %$# 6(:+(+: *+3 =/#(%(7*($+ $% ?/*3(+:6& R>/ 1 /?$4/#6 * 7$># $ 6#()/ $> >++/7/66*#9 ?/*3(+:6& Rle 1) &'d 1* 7$+*(+ ?#$=(6($+6 #/*(+: $ */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6& SCOPE OF THE TOPIC
P/*3(+:6 3$ +$ $+9 3/%(+/ '/ (66>/6 /4//+ '/ ?*#(/6 %$# '/ %(+* 3/7(6($+ $% '/ 7$># * '/ #(*, '/9 *+(%/6 *+3 //# '/(# (?$#*+7/ '#$>:'$> '/ 4'$/ ?#$7/66 $% '/ ((:*($+& P/*3(+:6 ?#$=(3/ * :>(3/ %$# '/ ?#$?/# $3/ $% #(*& T'/9 3/$+6#*/ >?$+ 4'(7' ?*#9 '/ >#3/+ $% ?#$$% (/6, 4'$ '*6 '/ #(:' $ $?/+ '/ 7*6/& T'/9 *6$ 3//#(+/ '/ #*+:/ $%% *3(66(/ /=(3/+7/ 4'(7' '/ ?*#(/6 6'$>3 *33>7/ * '/ #(*& T'/9 *6$ *9 3$4+ (( $+ '/ #/(/% '* 7*+ / :#*+/3 9 '/ 7$>#& SCHEME OF THE TOPIC CONTENT
T'/ %(#6 (+#$3>7$#9 7'*?/# /:(+6 4(' '/ /=$>($+ $% ?/*3(+:6 *+3 (6 '(6$#(7* $#(:(+& I 34/6 >?$+ '/ 4*9 C#((+* P#$7/3>#/ C$3/ :$ (+#$3>7/3 (+ I+3(* '#$>:' '/ B#((6' 3>#(+: '/(# #>/ *+3 '/ 4*9 '/ 7$3/ 4/+ '#$>:' (6 =*#($>6 */+3/+6 ( (6 7>##/+ %$#& T'/ 7'*?/# *6$ 7$=/#6 '/ 67$?/ $% 6>39 *+3 '/ (66>/6 '* 4$>3 / 3(67>66/3 *6 ?*# $% '/ 6>39& T'/ 6/7$+3 7'*?/# 3(67>66/6 *$> '/ #/6/*#7' /'$3$$:9 (+ 3/*( *+3 /=/+ /+*(6 '/ $/7(=/ $% '/ 6>39 *+3 =*#($>6 ((*($+6 %*7/3 (+ '/ *)(+: $% '(6 ?#$/7&
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
4
CHAPTER !: RESEARCH +ETHODOLO,- ELEVANCE OF THE TOPIC!
T'/ /# ?/*3(+: #/%/#6 $ 3$7>/+6 '* *#/ %(/3 4(' * 7$>#, > +$ >6 *+9 3$7>/+ *9 / %(/3& O+9 '$6/ '* 7$+%$# $ '/ #>/6 $% 7(=( ?#$7/3>#/ *+3 '* 6/#=/ * ?*#(7>*# ?>#?$6/ (+ *77$#3*+7/ 4(' '$6/ #>/6 4( / *77/?/3 9 '/ 7$>#& T'>6, '/ %$# * ?/*3(+: *)/6 '*6 *+ /%%/7 $+ '/ ?#$:#/66 $% '/ ((:*($+& S?/7(%(7*9, ?/*3(+:6 '/? $ %#*/ * *4 6>(& T'* (6 '/9 6?/7(%9 4'* :*=/ #(6/ $ '/ 7*6/ *+3 4'* '/ ((:*($+ 4( / *$>, '/ *4 '* 4( '/? $ #/6$=/ (, *+3 '/ /#6 $+ 4'(7' '/ ?*#(/6 /(/=/ ( 6'$>3 / #/6$=/3& S$ ?/*3(+:6 %$# '/ $6 (?$#*+ ?*# $% *+9 *4 6>( *+3 '/#/%$#/, ( (6 +/7/66*#9 '* * *4 6>3/+ (6 '$#$>:' 4(' #>/6 #/:*#3(+: ?/*3(+:6& O"#ECT OF STUD$!
T'/ 6$/ ?>#?$6/ $% 7*##9(+: $> '(6 6>39 (6 $ *7>(#/ (+- 3/?' )+$4/3:/ *$> ?/*3(+:6 (+ * *4 6>( *6 ( (6 '/ %$>+3*($+ $% * /:* 6>( *+3 4('$> (, +$ 6>( 7*+ ?#$:#/66& H$POTHESIS% ESEACH &UESTIONS!
W'* *#/ '/ #//=*+ 6/7($+6 #/*(+: $ ?/*3(+:6 (+ '/ C(=( P#$7/3>#/ C$3/ W'* *#/ '/ (?$#*+ ?#(+7(?/6 '* '/ >3(7(*#9 '*6 6/ $> (+ #/*($+ $ ?/*3(+:6 H$4 '/ #>/6 $+ ?/*3(+:6 (+ I+3(* 3(%%/# $# #/6// $ '* (+ U&S&A *+3 U&K& W'* 7*+ / 7'*+:/3 (+ '/ /(6(+: *4 $ /+6>#/ $#/ /%%(7(/+ $>7$/6 LIMITATIONS OF ESEACH "
T'/ #/6/*#7' '*6 //+ 7*##(/3 $> >6(+: '/ /6 ?$66(/ 4*96 *+3 * *>'/+(7 6$>#7/6 '*=/ //+ #/%/##/3 $, 6$ *6 %*# *6 7$+/+ $% $># 6>39 (6 7$+7/#+/3, (6 =*(3(9 $# *>'/+(7(9 7*++$ / 3(6?>/3& T'/ $+9 7$+6#*(+ (6 '* * '* '*6 //+ (+7>3/3 (+ #/6/*#7' (6 /#*7/3 %#$ 4$#)6 $% $'/# 67'$*#6 *+3 +$ ?#(*#9 #/6/*#7' '*6 //+ 7*##(/3 $> %$# '/ 6>39&
5
CHAPTER #: LE,AL ANAL-SIS
ELEVANT LEGAL "ODIES
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’6 7*6/ (6 *+3 4'* 7*6/ '/ '*6 $ //& T'/ ? *#(/6 6'$>3 :/ * %*(# (3/* %#$ '/ ?/*3(+:6 *6 $ 4'* 3(6?>/6 (+=$=/3 (+ '/ 7*6/ /%%/7>*9 *+3 7$?//9& P#$?/# ?/*3(+:6 4$>3 /+*/ '/ 7$># $ #*(6/ ?#$?/# (66>/ %$# #(*& I 4$>3 /+*/ '/ ?*#(/6 $ *33>7/ ?#$?/# /=(3/+7/& I 4$>3 /+*/ '/ 7$># $ 3/7(3/ '/ 7*6/ /%%/7>*9 *+3 7$?//9& P#$?/# ?/*3(+:6 4$>3 *6$ *=$(3 3/*9 *+3 (+((/ '/ /?/+3(>#/ $% ((:*($+& I (6 '/ 3>9 $% '/ *49/# $ /+6>#/ '* 7$##/7 %*76 *#/ #$>:' /%$#/ '/ 7$>#& H/ 6'$>3 /+6>#/ '* 4#$+: %*76, 7*7>*/3 $ (6/*3 '/ 7$># *#/ +$ ?/*3/3& J>3(7(* P#$+$>+7//+6 *#/ /%%/7 $ '/ /%%/7 '* 4('$> ?#$?/# ?/*3(+:6, *+9 *$>+ $% /=(3/+ 7/ (6 $% +$ >6/ *+3 '* 6>7' /=(3/+7/ 6'* +$ / $$)/3 (+$ 9 '/ 7$>#& T'/ R>/6 #/:*#3(+: ?/*3(+: *#/ ?#$=(3/3 (+ '/ C$3/ $% C(=( P#$7/3>#/ C$3/& C/#*(+ $'/# 6*>/6 *6$ ?#$=(3/ %$# ?*#(7>*# %*76 $ / ?/*3/3& F$# /*?/" S.ecific Relief Ac$/ 0ec$io' 16c2 &'d !!& C/#*(+ 3/%/+6/ 4$>3 / *=*(*/ $ * 3/%/+3*+, (+ '/ (:' $% '/ ?#$=(6($+6 $% 6
* 6*>/& S>7' 3/%/+6/ 6'$>3 +$ / $(/3 $ / *)/+& T'/ 7(/+ 4$>3 / */ $ 6>??9 $+9 %*76& I (6 '/ 3>9 $% '/ *49/# $ ?> %$#' '/ #//=*+ %*76 (+ '/ ?/*3(+:6 6$ *6 $ *)/ * %$>+3*($+ %$# * 7*( $% 3/%/+6/, *)/+ (+$ *77$>+ '/ #//=*+ ?#$=(6($+ $% *4& T'/ #$/ $% '/ *49/# (6 =/#9 (?$#*+ (+ '* 7$+/& Rle # of Order II CPC ?#$=(3/6 %$# $(+3/# $% 7*>6/ $% *7($+ (+ '/ 6*/ 6>(& Rle % of Order II 6(?>*/3 4'* * 7*>6/6 $% *7($+ 7*+ / $(+/3 4(' * 6>( %$# #/7$=/#9 $% ($=*/ ?#$?/#9& Order VI CPC ?#$=(3/6 %$# '/ ?/*3(+:6 :/+/#*9& Order VII 3/*6 4(' '/ ?*(+& Order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le 1) of Order VI & I (6 #>/ '* '/ 7$># *9 *$4 */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6 * *+9 6*:/& B> *%/# '/ */+3/+ $% CPC 9 ACT 22 $% 2002, '/ 67$?/ $% Rle 1) (6 #/6#(7/3& P/*3(+: 6'$>3 +$ / 67*+3*$>6, %#(=$$>6 $# =/*($>6& I 6'$>3 +$ 7$+*(+ */#6 4'(7' 4$>3 /+3 $ ?#/>3(7/, /*##*66 $# 3/*9 '/ %*(# #(* $% '/ 6>( $% 4'(7' (6 $'/#4(6/ *+ *>6/ $% '/ ?#$7/66 $% '/ 7$>#& T'/ 7$># '*6 >#(63(7($+ $ 6#()/ $> 6>7' ?/*3(+:6 $# ?$#($+ $% '/ 6*/ $# $ 3(#/7 '/ ?*#(/6 $ */+3 '/ ?/*3(+:6& PESENT LEGAL FAME'OK Pre()mp*+on( o, -aw
17
N/('/# ?*#9 +//3 (+ *+9 ?/*3(+: */:/ *+9 */# $% %*7 4'(7' '/ *4 ?#/6>/6 (+ '(6 %*=$# $# *6 $ 4'(7' '/ >#3/+ $% ?#$$% (/6 >?$+ '/ $'/# 6(3/ >+/66 '/ 6*/ '*6 %(#6 //+ 6?/7(%(7*9 3/+(/3 /&:&, 7$+6(3/#*($+ %$# * ( $% /7'*+:/ 4'/#/ '/ ?*(+(%% 6>/6 $+9 $+ '/ ( *+3 +$ %$# '/ 7$+6(3/#*($+ *6 * 6>6*+(=/ :#$>+3 $% 7*(& )-e( reard+n p-ead+n( :
T'/ #>/6 #/:*#3(+: ?/*3(+:6 *#/ *6 >+3/#" 1& A ?/*3(+: >6 6*/ %*76 *+3 +$ *4& 2& I >6 7$+*(+ $+9 */#(* %*76 $+ 4'(7' '/ ?*#9 ?/*3(+: #/(/6 %$# '(6 7*( $# 3/%/+6/& 8& I >6 6*/ $+9 '/ %*76 $+ 4'(7' '/ ?*#9 ?/*3(+: #/(/6 %$# '(6 7*( $# 3/%/+6/, *+3 +$ '/ /=(3/+7/ 9 4'(7' '/9 *#/ $ / ?#$=/3& & T'/ %*76 >6 / (+ '/ %$# $% * 7$+7(6/ 6*//+ > (+ *((+: * 7$+7(6/+/66, ?#/7(6($+ 6'$>3 +$ / 6*7#(%(7/3& T'/ ?/*3(+:6, 4'/+ +/7/66*#9, 6'* / 3(=(3/3 (+$ ?*#*:#*?'6, +>/#/3 7$+6/7>(=/9 *+3 /*7' */:*($+ /(+:, 6$ %*# *6 (6 7$+=/+(/+, 7$+*(+/3 (+ * 6/?*#*/ ?*#*:#*?'& D*/6, 6>6 *+3 %(:>#/6 6'* / /?#/66/3 (+ %(:>#/6& 5& A/:*($+6 (+ *+(7(?*($+ $% '/ $??$+/+’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
11
& F*76 4'(7' '/ *4 ?#/6>/6 (+ $+/’6 %*=$# $# *6 $ 4'(7' '/ >#3/+ $% ?#$$% (/6 >?$+ '/ $??$+/+ +//3 +$ / ?/*3/3& 10& T'/ ?*#9 6'$>3 +$ ?/*3 7$+7>6($+6 $% *4& T'/ ?($>6 $(:*($+ $% * H(+3> 6$+ $ ?*9 '(6 %*'/#’6 3/6 +//3 +$ / ?/*3/3& B> %$#/(:+ *4 *+3 7/#*(+ 7>6$6 *+3 >6*:/6 *#/ +$ >3(7(*9 *)/+ +$(7/ 9 7$>#6 *+3 >6 / ?/*3/3 *6 %*76& 11& L/:* ?/*6 6>7' *6 /6$??/, ((*($+ *+3 #/6->3(7** *9 / ?/*3/3& 12& I+ 7*6/ 4'/#/ '/ ?*#9 ?/*3(+: #/(/6 $+ *+9 (6#/?#/6/+*($+, %#*>3, #/*7' $% #>6, 4(%> 3/%*> $# >+3>/ (+%>/+7/, ?*#(7>*#6 6'* / 6*/3 (+ '/ ?*(+& T'/ ?/#6$+ =/#(%9(+: '/ ?/*3(+: 6'* *6$ %>#+(6' *+ *%%(3*=( (+ 6>??$# $% '(6 ?/*3(+:6& Par*+/)-ar( *o 0e +1en w2ere ne/e((ary
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rder VI/ rle 1) of $3e Code of Civil Procedre" Order VI/ Rle 1) of $3e Code of Civil Procedre 3/*6 4(' */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6& P/*3(+:6 *#/ '/ 7*6/ $% '/ P*(+(%% $# '/ D/%/+3*+ (+ P*(+ *+3 W#(/+ S*//+ #/6?/7(=/9& A+ */+3/+ 7*+ / 9 4*9 $% */#(+: 6$/'(+:, $3(%9(+: 6$/'(+:, 3//(+: 6$/'(+:& Amendmen* o, p-ead+n(
T'/ C$># *9 * *+9 6*:/ $% '/ ?#$7//3(+:6 *$4 $' ?*#9 $ */# $# */+3 '(6 ?/*3(+:6 (+ 6>7' *++/# *+3 $+ 6>7' /#6 *6 *9 / >6 *+3 * 6>7' */+3/+6 6'* / *3/ *6 *9 / +/7/66*#9 %$# '/ ?>#?$6/ $% 3//#(+(+: '/ #/* >/6($+ (+ 7$+#$=/#69 /4//+ '/ ?*#(/6& P#$=(3/3 '* +$ *??(7*($+ %$# */+3/+ 6'* / *$4/3 *%/# '/ #(* '*6 7$/+7/3,
12
>+/66 '/ C$># 7$/6 $ '/ 7$+7>6($+ '* (+ 6?(/ $% 3>/ 3((:/+7/, '/ ?*#9 7$>3 +$ '*=/ #*(6/3 '/ */# /%$#/ '/ 7$/+7//+ $% #(*& Amendmen* and +*( o03e/*+1e(
A6 6*/3 /*#(/#, /66/+(* 3/*(6 '*=/ $ / /+($+/3 (+ '/ ?*(+ *+3 >++/7/66*#9 3/*(6 '*=/ $ / 6#>7) $>& T'/ ?*#*$>+ $/7 /'(+3 A/+3/+ (6 '* '/ 7$>#6 6'$>3 #9 '/ /#(6 $% '/ 7*6/6 '* 7$/ /%$#/ '/ *+3 6'$>3 7$+6/>/+9 *$4 * */+3/+6 '* *9 / +/7/66*#9 %$# 3//#(+(+: '/ #/* >/6($+ (+ 7$+#$=/#69 /4//+ '/ ?*#(/6 ?#$=(3/3 ( 3$/6 +$ 7*>6/ (+>6(7/ $# ?#/>3(7/ $ '/ $'/# 6(3/& U(*/9, '/ 7$>#6 /(6 %$# 3$(+: >6(7/ /4//+ '/ ?*#(/6 *+3 +$ %$# ?>+(6'(+: '/, *+3 '/9 *#/ /?$4/#/3 $ :#*+ */+3/+6 $% ?/*3(+:6 (+ '/ *#:/# (+/#/6 $% 3$(+: %> *+3 7$?// >6(7/ $ ?*#(/6 P#$=(6($+6 %$# '/ */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+: *#/ 7$+*(+/3 $ ?#$$/ /+3 $% >6(7/ *+3 +$ %$# 3/%/*(+: '/& F>#'/# (+ '/ /*3(+: 7*6/ $% C#$??/# =& S(', '/ $/7 >+3/#9(+: '/ */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6 '*6 //+ *(3 3$4+ 9 B$4/+, L&J& (+ '/ %$$4(+: 4$#36" I '(+) ( (6 4//6*(6'/3 ?#(+7(?/ '* '/ $/7 $% '/ 7$>#6 (6 $ 3/7(3/ '/ #(:'6 $% '/ ?*#(/6 *+3 +$ $ ?>+(6' '/ %$# (6*)/6 '/9 *)/ (+ '/ 7$+3>7 $% '/(# 7*6/6 9 3/7(3(+: $'/#4(6/ '*+ (+ *77$#3*+7/ 4(' '/(# #(:'6& Amend+n pe*+*+on( de-ay( 3)(*+/e
I+ * *$# >3:/+ '* *(6 $ '4*# */?6 9 * *#:/ 6/7($+ $% ((:*+6 $7)/3 (+ 7(=( 7*6/6 $ 3/*9 ?#$7//3(+:6 %$# '/(# /+/%(, '/ S>?#// C$># '*6 6*(3 '* '/ ?#$=(6($+ (+ '/ Civil Procedre Code Order VI Rle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enera- Pr+n/+p-e!
T'/ 7$># 3(67>66/3 '/ ?#(+7(?/6 :$=/#+(+: '/ A/+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6 *+3 ' /3 '* I (6 7/*# '* 4'(/ 3/7(3(+: '/ *??(7*($+ %$# */+3/+ $#3(+*#(9 '/ C$># >6 +$ #/%>6/ $+* %(3/, /:((*/, '$+/6 *+3 +/7/66*#9 */+3/+6 *+3 6'$>3 +/=/# ?/#( ** %(3/ *+3 3(6'$+/6 */+3/+6& T'/ ?>#?$6/ *+3 $/7 $% Order VI Rle 1) of $3e Code (6 $ *$4 /('/# ?*#9 $ */# $# */+3 '(6 ?/*3(+:6 (+ 6>7' *++/# *+3 $+ 6>7' /#6 *6 *9 / >6& A/+3/+ 7*++$ / 7*(/3 *6 * */# $% #(:' *+3 >+3/# * 7(#7>6*+7/6, > '/ C$>#6 4'(/ 3/7(3(+: 6>7' ?#*9/#6 6'$>3 +$ *3$? * '9?/#-/7'+(7* *??#$*7'& L(/#* *??#$*7' 6'$>3 / '/ :/+/#* #>/ ?*#(7>*#9, (+ 7*6/6 4'/#/ '/ $'/# 6(3/ 7*+ / 7$?/+6*/3 4(' 7$66& N$#*9, */+3/+6 *#/ *$4/3 (+ '/ ?/*3(+:6 $ *=$(3 >(?(7(9 $% ((:*($+6& G)+de-+ne( ,or Amendmen* o, P-ead+n(
1&
C*>6/ $% *7($+ (+ * 6>( 7*++$ / */#/3 9 */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6& T'/ 7*>6/
%$*7($+ 4( +$ / *$4/3 $ / 6>6(>/3 (+ $*(9 *+3 '/ #/*6$+ /(+: '* '/ 7*>6/ $% *7($+ (6 '/ =/#9 *6(6 $% * 6>(& I% * +/43(6(+7 7*>6/ $% *7($+ (6 '/#/, '/ ?*#(/6 *#/ *4*96 %#// $ :$ $ '/ C$># 4(' 6>7' 7*>6/ $% *7($+ (+ *+ (+3/?/+3/+ 6>(& B> '/#/ 7*+ / 7*6/6 4'/#/ '/ 7*>6/ $% *7($+ '*6 :$ %>#'/# *::#*=*/3 9 *+9 %>#'/# =($*($+ $# 6$/ 7$+(+>(+: 7*>6/ $% *7($+ 4'(7' 7*+ / $(+/3 (+ '/ ?#/6/+ 6>( 3>/ $ 6>6/>/+ 7'*+:/ $% 7(#7>6*+7/6& I+ 6>7' 7*6/6, '/ C$># (+ (6 3(67#/($+ (6 %#// $ * $4 '/ */+3/+ *6 '* 4$>3 +$ / * 7*6/ $% 6>6(>($+ $% 7*>6/ $% *7($+&
1
2&
T'/ A/+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6 6'* / *$4/3 $ #(+: $# $ 7*#(%9 * */# (+ (66>/
/%$#/ '/ C$>#& T'/ */# (+ (66>/ (6 /66/+(* %$# '/ 3//#(+*($+ $% '/ 6>( *+3 '/#/%$#/ */+3/+ 7*+ / *3/& S((*#9, #/(/% *6$ 7*+ / */+3/3& I+ 6>7' 7*6/6, (% '/ */+3/+ (6 +$ *$4/3, '/ *# $% #/6->3(7** $# *6 '/ 7*6/ *9 /, '/ *# $% Order II Rle ! of $3e Code of Civil Procedre/ 145* *9 *??9& T'/#/%$#/, '/ C$># 6'$>3 #9 $ #(+: * **+7/ /4//+ '/ (+>6(7/ '* (:' / 7*>6/3 $ '/ *??(7*+ (+ 7*6/ $% #/%>6* $ :#*+ #/(/% *+3 * '/ 6*/ (/, (+ 7*6/ $% *$4(+: '/ *??(7*($+, '/ #/>(#//+ $% (+>6(7/ 7*>6/3 $ '/ $'/# ?*#9 (+ '/ ?#/6/+ 6>(& 8&
I% * #(:' '*6 *#/*39 *77#>/3 (+ ?/*3(+:6 $ '/ $??$6(/ ?*#9, '/+ '/ C$># 6'*
+$#*9 / #/>7*+ $ *$4 '/ A/+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6& H$4/=/#, (+ 6>7' 7*6/6, (% '/ $66 '* 4( / 7*>6/3 $ '/ $'/# ?*#9 7*+ / *3/>*/9 7$?/+6*/3 %$# 9 7$6 '/+ */+3/+ 6'* / *$4/3& &
W'/+ '/ 7$># '/*#6 '/ *??(7*($+ %$# A/+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6 ( 3$/6 +$ :$ (+$ '/
/#(6 $% '/ 7*6/& W'(/ 7$+6(3/#(+: '/ ?#*9/# %$# */+3/+ $% '/ ?/*3(+:6, '/ C$># 7*++$ :$ (+$ '/ (66>/ $% /#(6 =(6--=(6 *(+*(+*((9 $% '/ 6>(, > 7*+ 7$+6(3/# $+9 4'/'/# '/ */+3/+ (6 +/7/66*#9 $ 3//#(+/ '/ #/* 7$+#$=/#69 /4//+ '/ ?*#(/6& 5&
I% '/#/ (6 *+ >+3>/ 3/*9 (+ '/ %((+: $% '/ *??(7*($+ %$# */+3/+, 4('$> '/#/
/(+: 6>%%(7(/+ 7*>6/ 6'$4+ $ 7$+3$+/ '/ 3/*9, '/+ '/ C$># *9 +$#*9 +$ *$4 '/ */+3/+& &
C'*+:/ $% *4" T'/ *4 7*+ / * 7'*+:/ $% 6>6*+(=/ *4 /('/# ?#$6?/7(=/ $#
#/#$6?/7(=/& I% ( (6 * ?#$6?/7(=/ 7'*+:/ '/+ ( +$#*9 +$ /%%/7 7*>6/ $% *7($+ *+3 */# (+ (66>/ (+ '/ ?/+3(+: 6>( *+3 '/#/%$#/, */+3/+ (6 +$ +//3/3& W'/#/*6 ( (6 * #/#$6?/7(=/ 7'*+:/, */+3/+ (:' / +//3/3 *+3 6'* / *$4/3& I% ( (6 * 7'*+:/ $% ?#$7/3>#* *4 '/+ +$#*9 ?/*3(+:6 4( +$ / *$4/3 $ / */+3/3 > '/ 7$># 6'* (6/% *)/ +$/ $% '/ 7'*+:/ $% ?#$7/3>#* *4& F>#'/# / Order VI rle 1* of $3e Code of Civil Procedre/ 145* 7*66 * 3>9 $+ '/ ?*#9 $ 7*##9 $> '/ */+3/+, (% *$4/3 9 '/ C$>#, 4('(+ '/ (/ ((/3 %$# '/ 6*(3 ?>#?$6/ 9 '/ $#3/# *+3 (% +$ (/ (6 '/#/9 6*/3, '/+ 4('(+ 1 3*96 %#$ '/ 3*/ $% '/ $#3/#& I+ 7*6/ '/ ?*#9 %*(6 $ 7*##9 $> */+3/+ 4('(+ '/ 6*(3 ?/#($3, '/ 6'* +$ / ?/#(/3 $ 7*##9 $> 1
'/ */+3/+ *%/# '/ /?(#*($+ $% (/ ((/3, >+/66 '/ (/ (6 %>#'/# / /+3/3 9 '/ C$>#& HIGH COUT AMENDMENT
K*#+**)*" R/-+>/# Rle % &0 Rle % 12 *+3 *33 '/ %$$4(+: *6 Rle % !2: 2 I+ * 6>( %$# (+%#(+://+ $% * ?*/+, '/ ?*(+(%% 6'* 6*/ (+ '(6 ?*(+ $# *++/ '/#/$ '/ ?*#(7>*#6 $% '/ #/*7'/6 #/(/3 >?$+, *+3 '/ 3/%/+3*+ (% '/ 3(6?>/6 '/ =*(3(9 $% '/ ?*/+ 6'* 6*/ (+ '(6 4#(/+ 6*//+ $# *++/ '/#/$ '/ ?*#(7>*#6 $% '/ $/7($+6 $+ 4'(7' '/ #/(/6 (+ 6>??$# $% 6>7' (+=*(3(9; * '/ '/*#(+: $% *+9 6>7' 6>( +$ /=(3/+7/ 6'*, /7/? 4(' '/ /*=/ $% '/ C$># $ / :(=/+ >?$+ 6>7' /#6 *6 $ '/ C$># *9 6// >6, / *3(/3 (+ ?#$$% $% *+9 */:/3 (+%#(+://+ $# $/7($+6 +$ #*(6/3 (+ '/ ?*#(7>*#6 $% #/*7'/6 $# $/7($+6 #/6?/7(=/9& 80&8&1@& STATE AMENDMENT
A6 (+6/#/3 9 S*/6 )-e 45A Mad2ya Prade(2 " A/# R>/ , '/ %$$4(+: 6'* / (+6/#/3, +*/9"
-A& P*#(7>*#6 $% ?/*3(+: %$# *:#(7>>#* *+3& I+ *+9 6>( $# ?#$7//3(+: 7$+/?*/3 >+3/# Rle #B of Order 1, '/ ?*#(/6, $'/# '*+ '/ S*/ G$=/#+/+ 6'* ?/*3 '/ ?*#(7>*#6 $% $* *:#(7>>#* *+3 4'(7' (6 $4+/3, 7*(/3 $# '/3 9 '/ (+ *+9 #(:' *+3 6'* %>#'/# 3/7*#/ 4'/'/# '/ 6>/7 */# $% 6>( $# ?#$7//3(+: (6 $# (6 +$ 7$=/#/3 9 M*3'9* P#*3/6' C/((+: $+ A:#(7>>#* H$3(+:6 A7, 10 N$& 20 $% 10 *+3 4'/'/# *+9 ?#$7//3(+:6 (+ #/*($+ $ 6>7' 6>/7 */# *#/ $ '/ )+$4/3:/ $% '/ ?*#9 ?/+3(+: /%$#/ '/ 7$?//+ *>'$#(9& M&P& A7& N$& 2 $% 1 4&/&%& 1- 1&
1
CHAPTER %: ROLE OF 7UDICIAR-
I+ * 6/>? ()/ $>#6, 4'/#/ '/#/ (6 +$ 6#(7 6/?*#*($+ $% ?$4/#6, >3(7(*#9 7*+ 6/? (+$ /:(6*>#/’6 6'$/6 (% 6(>*($+6 3/*+3 6$& A77$#3(+:9, 4'/+/=/# '/#/ *#/ *7>+*/ $# :*?6 /% (+ 9 /:(6*>#/, '/ >3(7(*#9 %(6 '* :*? 6$ '* >6(7/ (6 / (+ * ?#$*/ 6(>*($+6& #)d+/+a- Law Ma6+n 7Impor*an* Lea- Pr+n/+p-e( Se* O)* "y #)d+/+ary8! In "2awa*+ Pra(ad 1(. S2r+ C2andrama)- 9" S>?#// C$># #>/3 $> '*
I% * ?/* (6 +$ 6?/7(%(7*9 *3/ *+3 9/ ( (6 7$=/#/3 9 *+ (66>/ 9 (?(7*($+, *+3 '/ ?*#(/6 )+/4 '* '/ 6*(3 ?/* 4*6 (+=$=/3 (+ '/ #(*, '/+ '/ /#/ %*7 '* '/ ?/* 4*6 +$ /?#/669 *)/+ (+ '/ ?/*3(+:6 4$>3 +$ +/7/66*#(9 3(6/+(/ * ?*#9 %#$ #/9(+: >?$+ (% ( (6 6*(6%*7$#(9 ?#$=/3 9 /=(3/+7/& T'/ :/+/#* #>/ +$ 3$> (6 '* '/ #/(/% 6'$>3 / %$>+3/3 $+ ?/*3(+:6 *3/ 9 '/ ?*#(/6& B> 4'/#/ '/ 6>6*+(* */# #/*(+: $ '/ (/ $% $' ?*#(/6 $ '/ 6>( 4*6 $>7'/3, $>:' (+3(#/79 $# /=/ + $67>#/9 (+ '/ (66>/6, *+3 /=(3/+7/ '*6 //+ /3 *$> '/ '/+ '/ *#:>/+ '* * ?*#(7>*# */# 4*6 +$ /?#/669 *)/+ (+ '/ ?/*3(+:6 4$>3 / ?>#/9 %$#* *+3 /7'+(7* *+3 7*++$ 6>77//3 (+ /=/#9 7*6/&
I+ La-+*a Pra(ad 1. Ga3ad2ar :, ( 4*6 $6/#=/3 '* * ?/*3(+: >6 +$ 6/ %$#' * ?>(7 6*>/, %$# '/ 7$># (6 $>+3 $ *)/ >3(7(* +$(7/ $% (& I 6'$>3 6/ $> $+9 %*76, *+3 '/ #/(/% 6$>:', *+3 +$ '/ *4 $# '/ ?*#(7>*# 6/7($+ $% '/ 6*>/ >+3/# 4'(7' '/ 7*( (6 *3/& N$# 6'$>3 '/ ?*#(/6 ?/*3 7$+7>6($+6 $% *4 $# $% (/3 *4 *+3 %*7& I (6 %$# '/ 7$># $ 3/7*#/ *4 *#(6(+: >?$+ '/ %*76 /%$#/ (& T'/ ?*#(/6 6'$>3 6*/ $+9 '/ %*76 $+ 4'(7' '/9 #/9 %$# '/(# 7*( $# 3/%/+7/&
1 AIR 1466 SC )#( 2 AIR 14## All !#(/ &l0o S8ed D&0$&9ir v" ,.&lri03'&/ 14442 6 SCC ##) 14
G)+de-+ne( ,or amendmen* o, p-ead+n( a( (e* 0y 3)d+/+ary +n 1ar+o)( /a(e(!
I+ Han)wan* S+n2 awa* V. M%( a3p)*ana A)*omo0+-e(; A3mer +3/#"(
T'* '/ */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6 6'$>3 $#3(+*#(9 / *$4/3 9 '/ C$>#, $+7/ ( (6 6*(6%(/3 '* '/ */+3/+ (6 +/7/66*#9 %$# '/ >6 *+3 ?#$?/# 3/7(6($+ $% '/ 7$+#$=/#69 /4//+ '/ ?*#(/6;
((
T'/ */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6 6'$>3 +$ $#3(+*#(9 / 3/7(+/3 $+9 $+ '/ :#$>+3 $% 3/*9 $+ '/ ?*# $% '/ *??/*+ (+ 6//)(+: /*=/ $% '/ C$># $ */+3 '/ ?/*3(+:6, (% '/ $??$6(/ ?*#9 7*+ 6>(*9 / 7$?/+6*/3 9 /*+6 $% 7$66 /7& E=/+ (+7$+6(6/+ ?/*6 7*+ / *$4/3 $ / #*(6/3 9 */+3/+ (+ '/ ?/*3(+:6;
(((
H$4/=/#, */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6 7*++$ / *$4/3 6$ *6 $ 7$?//9 */# '/ +*>#/ $% '/ S>(;
(=
A/+3/+ $% '/ ?/*3(+:6 >6 +$ / *$4/3 4'/+ */+3/+ (6 +$ +/7/66*#9 %$# '/ ?>#?$6/ $% 3//#(+(+: '/ #/* >/6($+6 (+ '/ 7$+#$=/#69 /4//+ '/ ?*#(/6;
=
T'/ */+3/+ 6'$>3 / #/%>6/3 4'/#/ '/ ?*(+(%%’6 S>( 4$>3 / 4'$9 3(6?*7/3 9 '/ ?#$?$6/3 */+3/+;
=(
W'/#/ '/ /%%/7 $% '/ */+3/+ 4$>3 / $ *)/ *4*9 %#$ '/ 3/%/+3*+ * /:* #(:' 4'(7' '*6 *77#>/3 $ '( 9 *?6/ $% (/ $# 9 $?/#*($+ $% 6$/ *4;
=((
T'/ */+3/+ (+ '/ ?/*3(+:6 6'$>3 +$ / *$4/3 4'/#/ '/ 7$># %(+36 '* */+3/+ 6$>:' %$# '*6 +$ //+ *3/ (+ :$$3 %*(' $# 6>%%/#6 %#$ *7) $% $+* %(3/6;
3 144#2 1 ;LC 6!( 15
=(((
A+3 $#3(+*#(9, '/ */+3/+ >6 +$ / *$4/3 4'/#/ * ?*#9 4*+6 $ 4('3#*4 %#$ '/ *3(66($+ *3/ 9 ( (+ '/ $#(:(+* ?/*3(+:6&
S((*#9, (+ '/ 7*6/ $% Pee*2an+ S)ryanarayana 1. epa6a Ven6a*a amana K+(2ore 4; ( 4*6 '/3 '* '/ C$>#6 '$3 '/ ?$4/# $ *$4 6>7' */+3/+ ?#$=(3/3" * A??(7*($+ (6 $+*%(3/ D$/6 +$ 7*>6/ (+>6(7/ $ '/ $'/# 6(3/ 7 D$/6 +$ *%%/7 '/ #(:'6 *#/*39 *77#>/3 $ '/ $'/# 6(3/& Amendment should not change the basic structure of the Suit:-
I+ Sampa* K)mar V. Ayya6ann) = Anr.>; '/ S>?#// C$># '/3 '* *+9 */+3/+ 6//)(+: $ (+#$3>7/ * 7*>6/ $% *7($+, 4'(7' *#$6/ 3>#(+: ?/+3/+79 $% '/ S>(, *9 / ?/#(/3 (+ $#3/# $ *=$(3 >(?(7(9 $% S>(& B>, ( 6'$>3 +$ 7'*+:/ '/ *6(7 6#>7>#/ $% '/ S>(& M$#/ 6$, '/ 7$># 6'$>3 / (/#* $ *$4 */+3/+ * '/ (/ $% ?#/-#(* $% * S>( > >6 / 6#(7 *+3 /*(+/ '/ (66>/ $% 3/*9 4'/#/ '/ *??(7*($+ %$# */+3/+ (6 %(/3 * * >7' /*/3 6*:/ $% 7$/+7//+ $% '/ #(*& I+ "2ara* Kar(onda( T2a66ar V. M%( K+ran Con(*r)/*+on Co. = Or(. ?, '/ S>?#// C$># '/3 '* */+3/+ (6 +$ ?/#(66(/ (% ( 7'*+:/6 '/ +*>#/ $% 6>(& In A3endrapra(ad3+ N. Pande = Anr. V. Swam+ Ke(2a1pra6e(2da(3+ N. = Or(.; @ '/ S>?#//
C$># 7$+6(3/#/3 '/ 67$?/ $% */+3/+ (+ Order VI Rle 1) C"P"C & 9 *33(+: * ?#$=(6$ $ '/ /%%/7 '* */+3/+ *??(7*($+ 6'$>3 / %(/3 ?#($# $ 7$/+7//+ $% '/ #(*& T'/ A?/ C$># '/3 '* #(* 7$/+7/6 4'/+ '/ (66>/6 *#/ 6//3 *+3 7*6/ (6 6/ 3$4+ %$# #/7$#3(+: $% /=(3/+7/& T'/ A?/ C$># $6/#=/3 '* >+/66 '/ ?*#9 6*(6%(/6 '/ C$># '* (+ 6?(/ $% 3>/ 3((:/+7/, '/ (66>/ 7$>3 +$ / #*(6/3 (+ '/ 6>( $# ?#$7//3(+:6 /%$#/ '/ 7$/+7//+ $% !5542 11 SCC #5* !55!2 ) SCC ((4 !55* AIR SC; #14! 4 !55) AIR SC; (1# 16
#(*, '/ */+3/+ 6'$>3 +$ / *$4/3& W'(/ 3/7(3(+: '/ 6*(3 7*6/, '/ A?/ C$># 7$+6(3/#/3 * *#:/ +>/# $% (6 /*#(/# >3:/+6 ?*#(7>*#9 B&K& N*#*9*+* P(*( V& P*#/6'4*#*+ P(*( A+#& ; K*(*6' V& N*+)'> O#6&; B*3/= S(+:' O#6& M*+$'*#
S(+:' A+# &10, 4'/#/(+ ( '*3 //+ '/3 '* '/ 3/*9 $% (6 $4+, >+$>7'/3 9 %#*>3 (6 +$ * :#$>+3 %$# #//7(+: '/ *??(7*($+ %$# */+3/+& T'/ ?#$=(6($+6 *#/ ?#$7/3>#*, *+3 '/#/%$#/, 6'$>3 / 7$+6#>/3 (/#*9 $ *3=*+7/ '/ 7*6/ $% >6(7/ *+3 +$ $ #/*#3 $# $ 3/%/* >6(7/&
Landmar6 Ca(e! Sa-em Ad1o/a*e "ar A((o/+a*+on 1. Un+on o, Ind+a 7:>8 ? SCC +3/# '/ C$3/ $% C(=( P#$7/3>#/ *+3 * 4#( ?/(($+ $# * 7$>+/# *%%(3*=(& I+ ?/*3(+:6 (&/&, '/ ?*(+ $# * 4#(/+ 6*//+, '/ %*76 *+3 +$ /=(3/+7/ *#/ #/>(#/3 $ / ?/*3/3& H$4/=/# (+ * 4#( ?/(($+ $# (+ '/ 7$>+/# *%%(3*=( +$ $+9 %*76 *#/ $ / ?/*3/3 > *6$ '/ /=(3/+7/ (+ ?#$$% $% 6>7' %*76 '*=/ $ / *++//3 $ (& 12
S#(7 #>/6 $% ?/*3(+: *9 +$ *??9 $ P>(7 I+/#/6 L((:*($+ PIL > '/#/ >6 / 6>%%(7(/+ */#(* (+ ?/(($+ $+ '/ *6(6 $% 4'(7' '/ 7$># *9 ?#$7//3& T'/ PIL ((:*+ '*6 $ *9 * %*7>* %$>+3*($+ %$# '(6 *=/#/+6 $+ '/ *6(6 $% 4'(7' #/(/% (6 7*(/3& T'/ (+%$#*($+ %>#+(6'/3 9 '( 6'$>3 +$ / =*:>/ *+3 (+3/%(+(/& P#/%/# ?/*3(+:6 *#/ +/7/66*#9 $ // '/ #/>(#//+6 $% ?#(+7(?/6 $% */#(* >6(7/& 18 D+(*+n/*+on amon 1ar+o)( /o)n*r+e( w+*2 re(pe/* *o p-ead+n(
I+ *4 *6 ?#*7(7/3 (+ 7$>+#(/6 '* %$$4 '/ E+:(6' $3/6, * ?/*3(+: (6 * %$#* 4#(/+ 6*//+ $% * ?*#96 7*(6 $# 3/%/+7/6 $ *+$'/# ? *#96 7*(6 (+ * 7(=( *7($+& T'/ ?*#(/6 ?/*3(+:6 (+ * 7*6/ 3/%(+/ '/ (66>/6 $ / *3>3(7*/3 (+ '/ *7($+& T'/ C(=( P#$7/3>#/ R>/6 CPR :$=/#+ ?/*3(+: (+ E+:*+3 *+3 W*/6& F/3/#* R>/6 $% C(=( P#$7/3>#/ :$=/#+ ?/*3(+: (+ U+(/3 S*/6 %/3/#* 7$>#6& E*7' 6*/ (+ '/ U+(/3 S*/6 '*6 (6 $4+ 6*>/6 *+3 #>/6 '* :$=/#+ ?/*3(+: (+ '/ 7$>#6 $% '* 6*/& UNITED STATES" P/*3(+: (+ U+(/3 S*/6 F/3/#* 7$>#6 (6 :$=/#+/3 9 '/ F/3/#* R>/6 $% C(=( P#$7/3>#/& A77$#3(+: $ Rle ) , $+9 '/6/ ?/*3(+:6 *#/ *$4/3" 12 Ranjit Constructions Co. Ltd. v. National Highways Authority of India Ltd., A.I.R.2004 !l. "4. 13 Narmada Ba$hao Andoan v. State o/ P+ A0) 2711 S" 1656+ Order + )#e 2. 22
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
23
W'/+ >6/3 (+ 7(=( ?#$7//3(+:6 (+ E+:*+3 *+3 W*/6, '/ /# 7$?*(+ #/%/#6 $ '/ /7'*+(6 9 4'(7' 7(=( ?#$7//3(+:6 *#/ (+6(>/3 (+ '/ *:(6#*/6 7$># *+3 *9 / /('/# 4#(/+ $# $#*&
2
CHAPTER 6: CONCLUSION P/*3(+:6 ?#$=(3/ * :>(3/ %$# '/ ?#$?/# $3/ $% #(*& I *6(7*9 /6*(6'/6 '/ (66>/6 /4//+ '/ ?*#(/6 %$# '/ %(+* 3/7(6($+ $% '/ 7$># * '/ #(*, '/9 *+(%/6 *+3 /'(( '/(# 6(:+(%(7*+7/ '#$>:'$> '/ 4'$/ ?#$7/66 $% '/ ((:*($+& F>#'/#$#/, ( /=/+ 3/$+6#*/6 >?$+ 4'(7' ?*#9 '/ >#3/+ $% ?#$$% (/6 *+3 4'$ '*6 '/ #(:' $ $?/+ '/ 7*6/& T'/9 *6$ 3//#(+/ '/ #*+:/ $%% ?/#(66(/ /=(3/+7/ 4'(7' '/ ?*#(/6 6'$>3 *3 3>7/ * '/ #(*& M$#/$=/#, *9 3$4+ (( $+ '/ #/(/% '* 7*+ / :#*+/3 9 '/ 7$>#& T'>6, ?/*3(+:6 %$# *+ (+/:#* *+3 '/ $6 =(* ?*# $% '/ /+(#/ *4 6>(& H$4/=/# ( 6'$>3 / +$/3, '/ C$># *9 * *+9 6*:/ $% '/ ?#$7//3(+:6 ?/#( $' '/ ?*#(/6 $ */# $# */+3 '(6 ?/*3(+:6 (+ 6>7' *++/# *+3 $+ 6>7' /#6 *6 *9 / >6 *+3 * 6>7' */+3/+6 6'* / *3/ *6 *9 / +/7/66*#9 %$# '/ ?>#?$6/ $% 3//#(+(+: '/ #/* >/6($+ (+ 7$+#$=/#69 /4//+ '/ ?*#(/6& P#$=(3/3 '* +$ *??(7*($+ %$# */+3/+ 6'* / *$4/3 *%/# '/ #(* '*6 7$/+7/3, >+/66 '/ C$># 7$/6 $ '/ 7$+7>6($+ '* (+ 6?(/ $% 3>/ 3((:/+7/, '/ ?*#9 7$>3 +$ '*=/ #*(6/3 '/ */# /%$#/ '/ 7$/+7//+ $% #(*& T'(6 ?#$=(6($+ %$# */+3/+ $% '/ ?*(+ (6 7$+*(+/3 (+ R>/ 1@ $% O#3/# VI& V*#($>6 7*6/ *46 '*=/ //+ 3(67>66/3 (+ '(6 ?#$/7 4'(7' 6?/7(%(7*9 3/* 4(' */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6& F$# /*?/ (+ '/ 7*6/ H&'# *(3 3$4+ '/ :>(3/(+/6 %$# */+3/+ $% ?/*3(+:6& F>#'/#$#/, (+ '/ 7*6/ $% L&li$& Pr&0&d v" ,&>&d3&r , ( 4*6 $6/#=/3 '* * ?/*3(+: >6 +$ 6/ %$#' * ?>(7 6*>/, %$# '/ 7$># (6 $>+3 $ *)/ >3(7(* +$(7/ $% (& I 6'$>3 6/ $> $+9 %*76, *+3 '/ #/(/% 6$>:', *+3 +$ '/ *4 $# '/ ?*#(7>*# 6/7($+ $% '/ 6*>/ >+3/# 4'(7' '/ 7*( (6 *3/& N$# 6'$>3 '/ ?*#(/6 ?/*3 7$+7>6($+6 $% *4 $# $% (/3 *4 *+3 %*7& I (6 %$# '/ 7$># $ 3/7*#/ *4 *#(6(+: >?$+ '/ %*76 /%$#/ (& T'/ ?*#(/6 6'$>3 6*/ $+9 '/ %*76 $+ 4'(7' '/9 #/9 %$# '/(# 7*( $# 3/%/+7/&
2
2
SU,,ESTIONS
24
BIBLIO,RAPH- "OOKS EFEED
C#((+* P#$7/3>#/ C$3/ C#&P&C& 9 T*+3$+, #/=(6/3 9 S'*(/+3/# M*(), 1' /3(($+,#/?#(+ 2012 C#((+* P#$7/3>#/ C$3/ T'/$#9 4(' Q&A& 9 A6'$) K&J*(+ C#((+* P#$7/3>#/ C$3/, 1@8 I+ 2 V$6& 9 D>#:* D*6 B*6>, 5' /3(($+, 201 'E"SITES EFEED •
'?"7(=(?#$7/3>#/&>6/:*&7$'/-7$>#6/-$%-*-7(=(-*46>('/-?/*3(+:6-6*:/-$%-*-
•
7*6/ '?"3(:(*7$$+6&*4&9*/&/3>7:(=(/47$+/+&7:(
•
*#(7/227$+/%66
View more...
Comments
