City of Taguig v. City of Makati March 8 2017

1

City of Taguig Plaintif-Appellee v. City of Makati Deendants-Appellants CA-G.R. No. 98377 March 8, 2017 FACTS: On November 22, 1993, Taguig filed before the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Pasig, a Comlaint against !a"ati for a #$udi%ial Confirmation of the Territor& and 'oundar& imits of Taguig and a e%laration of the *n%onstitutionalit& and Nullit& of Certain Provisions of Presidential Pro%lamation 2+1 and -1./0 n its %omlaint, Taguig averred that areas %omrising the nlisted !ens 'aranga&s (!'Os) and the nner 4ort in 4ort 5ndres 'onifa%io (4ort 'onifa%io) are 6ithin its territor& and 7urisdi%tion/ !a"ati filed its ans6er, stating that it has %laim rightful o6nershi over the d isuted areas/

RTC:  RTC:  Rendered its de%ision on $ul& .,2811  in favor of Taguig/ The disositive ortion of the de%ision reads: ;;; ;;; ;;; 1/ 4ort 'onifa%io 'onifa%io !ilitar& !ilitar& Reservat Reservation ion is %onfirmed %onfirmed art of of the territor& territor& of the Plaintif Plaintifff Cit& of Taguig: 2/ Pro%la Pro%lamat mation ion No/ 2+-, 2+-, Pro%lamati ation? on? No/ -1.