CEBU COUNTRY CLUB, INC. V ELIZAGAQUE

CEBU COUNTRY CLUB, INC. (CCCI) v Elizagaque Facts: Sa !iguel C"#$"#ati" is a s$ecial c"%$a& $#"$#ieta#& $#"$#ieta#& %e%'e# " $etiti"e# CCCI a esigate Elizagaque as a s$ecial "*$#"$#ieta#& %e%'e#. Elizagaque +le a a$$licati" "# $#"$#ieta#& %e%'e#si$ a te $#esiet " CCCI "-e#e a /.0! $#"$#ieta#& sa#e 'ut Elizagaque 1as a'le t" $u#case a sa#e #"% a i-e#et %e%'e# "# "l& /!, a #"$#ieta#& O1e#si$ ce#ti+cate 1as te issue i av"# "  #es$" es$" e et. t. 2te# te# $"st $"st$" $"e e%e %et ts s " is is a$$l a$$lic icat ati" i"3 3s s acti acti" " '& te te '"a# '"a#, , #es$"et #eceive a lette# #"% CCCI3s c"#$"#ate sec#eta#& i"#%ig i% tat is a$$l a$$lic icat ati" i"  "# "# $#"$ $#"$#i #iet eta# a#& & %e%' %e%'e# e#s si$ i$ 1as 1as isa isa$$ $$##"ve "ve.. 2te# te# / lett lette# e#s s "  #ec" #ec"si sie# e#ati ati" " a iqui# iqui#& & 1et 1ete# e# a& %e%'e# %e%'e# " te '"a# '"a# "'4ect "'4ecte e t" is a$$licati" 1it " #es$"se #"% CCCI, #es$"et +le "# a%ages 1it asig Cit& RTC. RTC #ee#e a ecisi" a1a#ig actual, %"#al a e5e%$la#& a%ages as 1ell as att"#e&3s ee a c"sts. C2 a6#%e RTC3s +igs 'ut elete te actual a%ages a eie !FR " CCCI. 7ece tis $etiti". Issue: 89N CCCI a $#ivate $etiti"e#s a#e lia'le "# a%ages, 4"itl& "# seve#all&. Rulig: CCCI3s a#ticles " ic"#$"#ati" give te '"a# " i#ect"#s te #igt t" a$$#"ve "# isa$$#"ve a a$$licati" "# $#"$#ieta#& %e%'e#si$ 'ut suc #igt s"ul "t 'e e5e#cise e5e#cise a#'it#a#il&. a#'it#a#il&. I F Equit& Ic. v ;alez"a, 2#t. < 1as e5$"ue. 2#t. < %a& 'e te $#"$e# #ec"u#se.  Te 'lac@ 'all s&ste% " v"tig '& eac %e%'e# " te '"a#3s c""#%it& c""#%it& 1it te a$$licati" vi"late 2#t.