Cases Penned by Justice Velasco

CASES PENNED BY JUSTICE VELASCO 1. November 22, 2011. G.R. No. 171101. HACIENDA LUISITA, INCORPORATED, petitioner, LUISITA INDUSTRIAL PARK CORPORATION and RIZAL COMMERCIAL BANKING CORPORATION, petitioners-in-intervention, vs. PRESIDENTIAL AGRARIAN REFORM COUNCIL; SECRETARY NASSER PANGANDAMAN OF THE DEPARTMENT OF AGRARIAN REFORM; ALYANSA NG MGA MANGGAGAWANG BUKID NG HACIENDA LUISITA, RENE GALANG, NOEL MALLARI, and JULIO SUNIGA1 and his SUPERVISORY GROUP OF THE HACIENDA LUISITA, INC. and WINDSOR ANDAYA, respondents. [Hacienda Luisita, Incorporated vs. Presidential Agrarian Reform Council, 660 SCRA 525(2011)] 2. Curata vs. Philippine Ports Authority, 590 SCRA 214, June 22, 2009 3. Philippine Coconut Producers Federation, Inc. (COCOFED) vs. Republic, 663 SCRA 514, January 24, 2012 4. Funa vs. Villar, 670 SCRA 579, April 24, 2012 5. Chavez vs. National Housing Authority, 530 SCRA 235, August 15, 2007 6. SM Land, Inc. vs. Bases Conversion and Development Authority, 733 SCRA 68, August 13, 2014 7. Cojuangco, Jr. vs. Republic, 686 SCRA 472, November 27, 2012 8. Ruzol vs. Sandiganbayan, 696 SCRA 742, April 17, 2013 9. League of Cities of the Philippines (LCP) vs. Commission on Elections, 608 SCRA 636, December 21, 2009 10. Toyota Motor Phils. Corp. Workers Association (TMPCWA) vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 537 SCRA 171, October 19, 2007 11. Metropolitan Manila Development Authority vs. Concerned Residents of Manila Bay, 643 SCRA 90,February 15, 2011 12. Office of the Court Administrator vs. Pardo, 553 SCRA 66, April 30, 2008 13. Bank of the Philippine Islands vs. Sanchez, 741 SCRA 1, November 19, 2014 14. Rubrico vs. Macapagal-Arroyo, 613 SCRA 233, February 18, 2010 15. Philippine Coconut Producers Federation, Inc. vs. Republic, 600 SCRA 102, September 17, 2009 16. Equitable PCI Banking Corporation vs. RCBC Capital Corporation, 574 SCRA 858, December 18, 2008 17. Abundo, Sr. vs. Commission on Elections, 688 SCRA 149, January 08, 2013 18. Celestial Nickel Mining Exploration Corporation vs. Macroasia Corporation, 541 SCRA 166, December 19, 2007 19. Fernan, Jr. vs. People, 531 SCRA 1, August 24, 2007 20. Estate of the Late Encarnacion Vda. de Panlilio vs. Dizon, 536 SCRA 565, October 18, 2007 21. Pilipinas Shell Petroleum Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 541 SCRA 316, December 21, 2007 22. Lee vs. Bangkok Bank Public Company, Limited, 642 SCRA 447, February 09, 2011 23. Soriano vs.Laguardia, 587 SCRA 79, April 29, 2009 24. Heirs of Dr. Jose Deleste vs. Land Bank of the Philippines (LBP), 651 SCRA 352, June 08, 2011 25. Estino vs. People, 584 SCRA 304, April 07, 2009 26. Hanjin Heavy Industries and Construction Co., Ltd. vs. Dynamic Planners and Construction Corp., 553 SCRA 541, April 30, 2008 27. Estate of the Late Jesus S. Yujuico vs. Republic, 537 SCRA 513, October 26, 2007 28. Go vs. Looyuko, 537 SCRA 445, October 26, 2007 29. Vivares vs. St. Theresa's College, 737 SCRA 92, September 29, 2014 30. Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Estate of J. Amado Araneta, 665 SCRA 310, February 08, 2012 31. Aliling vs. Feliciano, 671 SCRA 186, April 25, 2012 32. Manila International Airport Authority vs. Olongapo Maintenance Services, Inc., 543 SCRA 269, January 31, 2008 33. People vs. Quiamanlon, 640 SCRA 697, January 26, 2011 34. Korea Technologies Co., Ltd. vs. Lerma, 542 SCRA 1, January 07, 2008 35. Filipinas (Pre-Fab Bldg.) Systems, Inc. vs. MRT Development Corporation, 537 SCRA 609, November 13, 2007 36. EDI-Staffbuilders International, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 537 SCRA 409, October 26, 2007 37. Cuenca vs. Atas, 535 SCRA 48, October 05, 2007 38. B.E. San Diego, Inc. vs. Alzul, 524 SCRA 402, June 08, 2007 39. Pacific Rehouse Corporation vs. EIB Securities, Inc., 633 SCRA 214, October 13, 2010 40. Metropolitan Manila Development Authority vs. Concerned Residents of Manila Bay, 574 SCRA 661,December 18, 2008 41. Aquino vs. Municipality of Malay, Aklan, 737 SCRA 145, September 29, 2014 42. Solitarios vs. Jaque, 740 SCRA 226, November 12, 2014 43. Gonzales vs. Philippine Commercial and International Bank, 644 SCRA 180, February 23, 2011 44. Poele vs. Bringas, 619 SCRA 481, April 23, 2010 45. Vda. de Ouano vs. Republic, 642 SCRA 384, February 09,

2011 46. People vs. Tomas, Sr., 643 SCRA 530, February 16, 2011 47. People vs. Guiara, 600 SCRA 307, September 17, 2009 48. Gobenciong vs. Court of Appeals, 550 SCRA 502, March 31, 2008 49. Tongko vs. The Manufacturers Life Insurance Co. (Phils.), Inc., 570 SCRA 503, November 07, 2008 50. Rivera III vs. Commission on Elections, 523 SCRA 41, May 09, 2007 51. Tan vs. Commission on Elections, 507 SCRA 352, November 20, 2006 52. People vs. Combate, 638 SCRA 797, December 15, 2010 53. Ty vs. De Jemil, 638 SCRA 671, December 15, 2010 54. People vs. Cortez, 593 SCRA 743, July 23, 2009 55. Compania General de Tabacos de Filipinas vs. Sevandal, 593 SCRA 594, July 23, 2009 56. National Union of Workers in the Hotel Restaurant and Allied Industries (NUWHRAIN-APL-IUF) Dusit Hotel Nikko Chapter vs. Court of Appeals, 570 SCRA 598, November 11, 2008 57. Kukan International Corporation vs. Reyes, 631 SCRA 596, September 29, 2010 58. Domingo Realty, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 513 SCRA 40, January 26, 2007 59. People vs. Baga, 634 SCRA 743, November 15, 2010 60. People vs. Feliciano, 634 SCRA 454, October 20, 2010]\ 61. Brown-Araneta vs. Araneta, 707 SCRA 222, October 09, 2013 62. Philippine National Bank vs. Court of Appeals, 576 SCRA 537, January 20, 2009 63. Tanjuatco vs. Gako, Jr., 582 SCRA 200, March 23, 2009 64. Naranjo vs. Biomedica Health Care, Inc., 681 SCRA 438, September 19, 2012 65. Philippine National Bank vs. Perez, 652 SCRA 317, June 15, 2011 66. Bildner vs. Ilusorio, 588 SCRA 378, June 05, 2009 67. Cano Vda. de Viray vs. Usi, 686 SCRA 211, November 21, 2012 68. Eagle Ridge Golf & Country Club vs. Court Appeals, 616 SCRA 116, March 18, 2010 69. Garcia vs. Sandiganbayan, 603 SCRA 348, October 12, 2009 70. People vs. Ng Yik Bun, 639 SCRA 88, January 10, 2011 71. People vs. Ogan, 623 SCRA 479, July 05, 2010 72. People vs. Bautista, 650 SCRA 689, June 06, 2011 73. People vs. Ara, 609 SCRA 304, December 23, 2009 74. Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Mirant Pagbilao Corporation, 565 SCRA 154, September 12, 2008 75. Social Justice Society (SJS) vs. Dangerous Drugs Board, 570 SCRA 410, November 03, 2008 76. Marcos-Araneta vs. Court of Appeals, 563 SCRA 41, August 22, 2008 77. Locsin vs. Sandiganbayan, 529 SCRA 572, August 09, 2007 78. Department of Education, Division of Albay vs. Oñate, 524 SCRA 200, June 08, 2007 79. Gateway Electronics Corporation vs. Asianbank Corporation, 574 SCRA 698, December 18, 2008 80. Coloso vs. Garilao, 506 SCRA 25, October 30, 2006 81. Philippine American Life and General Insurance Company vs. Secretary of Finance, 741 SCRA 579,November 24, 2014 82. Bartolome vs. Social Security System, 740 SCRA 78, November 12, 2014 83. Wesleyan University-Philippines vs. Reyes, 731 SCRA 516, July 30, 2014 84. People vs. Mirto, 659 SCRA 796, October 19, 2011 85. Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Naval, Jr., 720 SCRA 796, April 07, 2014 86. Neri vs. Sandiganbayan (Fifth Division), 703 SCRA 350, August 07, 2013 87. People vs. Mendoza, 575 SCRA 616, December 24, 2008 88. Bayot vs. Court of Appeals, 570 SCRA 472, November 07, 2008 89. Allied Banking Corporation vs. Lim Sio Wan, 549 SCRA 504, March 27, 2008 90. Diesel Construction Co., Inc. vs. UPSI Property Holdings, Inc., 549 SCRA 12, March 24, 2008 91. Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas Monetary Board vs. AntonioValenzuela, 602 SCRA 698, October 02, 2009 92. Sunga-Chan vs. Court of Appeals, 555 SCRA 275, June 25, 2008 93. Aromin vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 553 SCRA 273, April 30, 2008 94. Manotoc vs. Court of Appeals, 499 SCRA 21, August 16, 2006 95. Francisco Motors Corporation vs. Court of Appeals, 505 SCRA 8, October 23, 2006 96. National Power Corporation vs. Dela Cruz, 514 SCRA 56, February 02, 2007 97. People vs. Buban, 512 SCRA 500, January 24, 2007 98. Taguinod vs. Court of Appeals, 533 SCRA 403, September 14, 2007

99. Genuino vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 539 SCRA 342, December 04, 2007 100. Orendain vs. BF Homes, Inc., 506 SCRA 348, October 31, 2006 101. Ng vs. People, 619 SCRA 291, April 23, 2010 102. People vs. Castro, 652 SCRA 393, June 15, 2011 103. Bañares vs. Tabaco Women's Transport Service Cooperative (TAWTRASCO), 694 SCRA 312, April 01, 2013 104. Batalla vs. Commission on Elections, 599 SCRA 761, September 15, 2009 105. People vs. Adrid, 692 SCRA 683, March 06, 2013 106. People vs. Musa, 684 SCRA 622, October 24, 2012 107. Domingo vs. People, 603 SCRA 488, October 12, 2009 108. Laynesa vs. Uy, 547 SCRA 200, February 29, 2008 109. People vs. Apattad, 655 SCRA 335, August 10, 2011 110. Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Ong, 636 SCRA 266, November 24, 2010 111. St. James College of Parañaque vs. Equitable PCI Bank, 627 SCRA 328, August 09, 2010 112. People vs. Barberos, 609 SCRA 381, December 23, 2009 113. Government Service Insurance System vs. City Treasurer of the City of Manila, 609 SCRA 330,December 23, 2009 114. People vs. De Leon, 611 SCRA 118, January 25, 2010 115. Republic vs. Estate of Alfonso Lim, Sr., 593 SCRA 404, July 22, 2009 116. People vs. Arbalate, 600 SCRA 239, September 17, 2009 117. People vs. Cervantes, 581 SCRA 762, March 17, 2009 118. People vs. Malibiran, 581 SCRA 655, March 17, 2009 119. UST FacultyUnion vs. University of Santo Tomas, 584 SCRA 648, April 07, 2009 120. Mendros, Jr. vs. Mitsubishi Motors Phils. Corporation (MMPC), 579 SCRA 529, February 16, 2009 121. Exocet Security and Allied Services Corporation vs. Serrano, 737 SCRA 40, September 29, 2014 122. Sydeco vs. People, 740 SCRA 288, November 12, 2014 123. Villarosa vs. Festin, 732 SCRA 110, August 05, 2014 124. Quintos vs. Nicolas, 726 SCRA 482, June 16, 2014 125. Go, Jr. vs. Court of Apppeals, 626 SCRA 180, July 29, 2010 126. Tantano vs. Espina-Caboverde, 702 SCRA 508, July 29, 2013 127. People vs. Cruz, 608 SCRA 350, December 16, 2009 128. People vs. Tion, 608 SCRA 299, December 16, 2009 129. Almagro vs. Amaya, Sr., 699 SCRA 61, June 19, 2013 130. People vs. Quigod, 619 SCRA 407, April 23, 2010 131. Santiago vs. Court of Appeals, 513 SCRA 69, January 26, 2007 132. Marquez vs. Presiding Judge (Hon. Ismael B. Sanchez), RTC Br. 58, Lucena City, 515 SCRA 577,February 13, 2007 133. Cuenca vs. Presidential Commission on Good Government, 535 SCRA 102, October 05, 2007 134. City Assessor of Cebu City vs. Association of Benevola de Cebu, Inc., 524 SCRA 128, June 08, 2007 135. Iligan Bay Manufacturing Corp. vs. Dy, 524 SCRA 55, June 08, 2007 136. People vs. Tan, 634 SCRA 773, November 15, 2010 137. People vs. Salazar, 634 SCRA 307, October 20, 2010 138. Heirs of Cipriano Reyes vs. Calumpang, 506 SCRA 56, October 30, 2006 139. Salazar vs. Philippine Duplicators, Inc., 510 SCRA 288, December 06, 2006 140. Dela Cruz vs. Court of Appeals, 510 SCRA 103, December 06, 2006 141. Lequin vs. Vizconde, 603 SCRA 407, October 12, 2009 142. Tabasa vs. Court of Appeals, 500 SCRA 9, August 29, 2006 143. People vs. Badriago, 587 SCRA 820, May 08, 2009 144. St. Michael School of Cavite, Inc. vs. Masaito Development Corporation, 547 SCRA 263, February 29, 2008 145. People vs. Cias, 650 SCRA 326, June 01, 2011 146. People vs. Roble, 647 SCRA 593, April 11, 2011 147. People vs. Pambid, 640 SCRA 722, January 26, 2011 148. Adriatico Consortum, Inc. vs. Land Bank of the Philippines, 609 SCRA 403, December 23, 2009 149. Soriano vs. People, 556 SCRA 595, June 30, 2008 150. Edsa Shangri-La Hotel and Resort, Inc. vs. BF Corporation, 556 SCRA 25, June 27, 2008 151. Montanez vs. Provincial Agrarian Reform Adjudicator (PARAD), Negros Occidental, 600 SCRA 217,September 17, 2009 152. Heirs of the Late Jose De Luzuriaga vs. Republic, 591 SCRA 299, June 30, 2009 153. Boac vs. People, 570 SCRA 533, November 07, 2008 154. Mangangey vs. Sandiganbayan, 546 SCRA 51, February 18, 2008 155. People vs. Salonga, 602 SCRA 783, October 02, 2009 156. People vs. Macabare, 597 SCRA 119, August 25, 2009 157. Andrada vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 541 SCRA 538, December 28, 2007 158. Aquino vs. Paiste, 555 SCRA 255, June 25, 2008 159. Ibañez vs. AFP Retirement and Service Benefit System, 555 SCRA 66, June 18, 2008 160. Samahan ng Masang Pilipino sa Makati, Inc. (SMPMI) vs.

Bases Conversion Development Authority (BCDA), 513 SCRA 88, January 26, 2007 161. Albos vs. Embisan, 743 SCRA 283, November 26, 2014 162. Locsin vs. Hizon, 735 SCRA 547, September 17, 2014 163. People vs. Pagkalinawan, 614 SCRA 202, March 03, 2010 164. Santillano vs. People, 614 SCRA 164, March 03, 2010 165. People vs. Rubio, 667 SCRA 753, March 07, 2012 166. Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Pagayatan, 644 SCRA 133, February 23, 2011 167. People vs. Marcelino, Jr., 652 SCRA 362, June 15, 2011 168. People vs. Sitco, 620 SCRA 561, May 14, 2010 169. Urbano vs. People, 576 SCRA 826, January 20, 2009 170. TSPIC Corporation vs. TSPIC Employees Union (FFW), 545 SCRA 215, February 13, 2008 171. Benguet Corporation vs. Department of Environment and Natural Resources-Mines Adjudication Board,545 SCRA 196, February 13, 2008 172. Steel Corporation of the Philippines vs. Equitable PCI Bank, Inc., 635 SCRA 403, November 17, 2010 173. Señeres vs. Commission on Elections, 585 SCRA 557, April 16, 2009 174. People vs. Maningding, 657 SCRA 804, September 14, 2011 175. People vs. Rosialda, 629 SCRA 507, August 25, 2010 176. People vs. Dela Cruz, 612 SCRA 738, February 16, 2010 177. South African Airways vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 612 SCRA 665, February 16, 2010 178. Abbas vs. Abbas, 689 SCRA 646, January 30, 2013 179. Baculi vs. Belen, 681 SCRA 489, September 24, 2012 180. Aqualab Philippines, Inc. vs. Heirs of Marcelino Pagobo, 603 SCRA 435, October 12, 2009 181. Mocorro, Jr. vs. Ramirez, 560 SCRA 362, July 28, 2008 182. Central Philippines Bandag Retreaders, Inc. vs. Diasnes, 558 SCRA 194, July 14, 2008 183. Temic Semiconductors, Inc. Employees Union (TSIEU)FFW vs. Federation of Free Workers (FFW), 554 SCRA 122, May 20, 2008 184. People vs. Satonero, 602 SCRA 769, October 02, 2009 185. Locsin vs. Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company, 602 SCRA 740, October 02, 2009 186. Capangpangan vs. People, 538 SCRA 279, November 23, 2007 187. Heirs of Maximo Labanon vs. Heirs of Constancio Labanon, 530 SCRA 97, August 14, 2007 188. Republic vs. Luriz, 513 SCRA 140, January 26, 2007 189. Clark Development Corporation vs. Mondragon Leisure and Resorts Corporation, 517 SCRA 203, March 02, 2007 190. Barangay Sindalan, San Fernando, Pampanga vs. Court of Appeals, 518 SCRA 649, March 22, 2007 191. Citizens’ Battle Against Corruption (CIBAC) vs. Commission on Elections (COMELEC), 521 SCRA 254,April 13, 2007 192. Pedrano vs. Heirs of Benedicto Pedrano, 539 SCRA 401, December 04, 2007 193. Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company vs. National Telecommunications Commission, 539 SCRA 365, December 04, 2007 194. Natividad vs. Movie and Television Review and Classification Board (MTRCB), 540 SCRA 124, December 13, 2007 195. People vs. Politico, 633 SCRA 404, October 18, 2010 196. People vs. Sally, 633 SCRA 293, October 13, 2010 197. Bases Conversion and Development Authority vs. Uy, 506 SCRA 524, November 02, 2006 198. Algura vs. The Local Government Unit of the City of Naga, 506 SCRA 81, October 30, 2006 199. Frondarina vs. Malazarte, 510 SCRA 223, December 06, 2006 200. Baltazar vs. Ombudsman, 510 SCRA 74, December 06, 2006 201. M.E. Holding Corporation vs. Court of Appeals, 547 SCRA 389, March 03, 2008 202. Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co. vs. Pascual, 547 SCRA 246, February 29, 2008 203. Manungas vs. Loreto, 655 SCRA 734, August 22, 2011 204. People vs. Maglian, 646 SCRA 770, March 30, 2011 205. People vs. Lindo, 627 SCRA 519, August 09, 2010 206. Violago vs. BA Finance Corporation, 559 SCRA 69, July 21, 2008 207. Eternal Gardens Memorial Park Corporation vs. Philippine American Life Insurance Company, 551 SCRA 1, April 09, 2008 208. De Leon vs. De Leon, 593 SCRA 768, July 23, 2009 209. People vs. Araojo, 600 SCRA 295, September 17, 2009 210. People vs. Domingo, 600 SCRA 280, September 17, 2009 211. Vitangcol vs. New Vista Properties, Inc., 600 SCRA 83, September 17, 2009 212. Macalinao vs. Bank of the Philippine Islands, 600 SCRA 67, September 17, 2009 213. Silverio, Jr. vs. Court of Appeals, 600 SCRA 1, September 16, 2009 214. People vs. Achas, 595 SCRA 341, August 04, 2009 215. D.M. Consunji, Inc. vs. Duvaz Corporation, 595 SCRA 111,

August 04, 2009 216. Dreamwork Construction, Inc. vs. Janiola, 591 SCRA 466, June 30, 2009 217. People vs. Basquigin, 591 SCRA 453, June 30, 2009 218. Republic vs. Iglesia ni Cristo, 591 SCRA 438, June 30, 2009 219. People vs. Capalad, 584 SCRA 717, April 07, 2009 220. Heritage Park Management Corporation vs. Construction Industry Arbitration Commission, 568 SCRA 108, October 08, 2008 221. Hur Tin Yang vs. People, 703 SCRA 606, August 14, 2013 222. Chingkoe vs. Republic, 702 SCRA 677, July 31, 2013 223. People vs. De Chavez, 619 SCRA 464, April 23, 2010 224. Yu vs. Reyes-Carpio, 652 SCRA 341, June 15, 2011 225. Transocean Ship Management (Phils.), Inc. vs. Vedad, 694 SCRA 209, March 20, 2013 226. People vs. Sameniano, 576 SCRA 840, January 20, 2009 227. Alabang Country Club, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 545 SCRA 351, February 14, 2008 228. R.B. Michael Press vs. Galit, 545 SCRA 23, February 13, 2008 229. Serrano vs. Ambassador Hotel, Inc., 690 SCRA 226, February 11, 2013 230. People vs. Orje, 657 SCRA 427, September 12, 2011 231. Office of the Ombudsman vs. Sison, 612 SCRA 702, February 16, 2010 232. Philippine Coconut Producers Federation, Inc. vs. Republic, 612 SCRA 255, February 11, 2010 233. People vs. Gutierrez, 607 SCRA 377, December 04, 2009 234. P.L. Uy Realty Corporation vs. ALS Management and Development Corporation, 684 SCRA 453, October 24, 2012 235. Subic Telecommunications Company, Inc. vs. Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority, 603 SCRA 470, October 12, 2009 236. People vs. Dela Cruz, 603 SCRA 455, October 12, 2009 237. People vs. Alipio, 603 SCRA 40, October 05, 2009 238. Del Castillo vs. Orciga, 500 SCRA 498, August 31, 2006 239. Nacnac vs. People, 668 SCRA 846, March 21, 2012 240. People vs. Belo, 623 SCRA 527, July 05, 2010 241. Nicart, Jr. vs. Titong, 744 SCRA 630, December 10, 2014 242. Republic vs. San Mateo, 739 SCRA 445, November 10, 2014 243. MCMP Construction Corp. vs. Monark Equipment Corp., 739 SCRA 432, November 10, 2014 244. Presidential Commission on Good Government (PCGG) vs. Carpio-Morales, 740 SCRA 368, November 12, 2014 245. Solante vs. Commission on Audit, 733 SCRA 266, August 19, 2014 246. Magdala Multipurpose & Livelihood Cooperative vs. Kilusang Manggagawa ng LGS, Magdala Multipurpose & Livelihood Cooperative (KMLMS), 659 SCRA 768, October 19, 2011 247. Tomawis vs. Balindong, 614 SCRA 354, March 05, 2010 248. People vs. Alverio, 645 SCRA 658, March 16, 2011 249. People vs. Paling, 645 SCRA 627, March 16, 2011 250. People vs. Aminola, 630 SCRA 384, September 08, 2010 251. Grande vs. Antonio, 716 SCRA 698, February 18, 2014 252. People's Broadcasting Service (Bombo Radyo Phils., Inc.)vs. Secretary of the Department of Labor and Employment, 667 SCRA 538, March 06, 2012 253. LBL Industries, Inc. vs. City of Lapu-lapu, 705 SCRA 688, September 16, 2013 254. Pua vs. Lo Bun Tiong, 708 SCRA 571, October 23, 2013 255. Malaya Insurance Co., vs. Alberto, 664 SCRA 791, February 01, 2012 256. United Claimants Association of NEA (UNICAN)vs. National Electrification Administration (NEA), 664 SCRA 483, January 31, 2012 257. Nagkahiusang Mamumuo sa PICOP Resources, Inc.Southern Philippines Federation of Labor vs. Court of Appeals, 506 SCRA 542, November 02, 2006 258. King of Kings Transport, Inc. vs. Mamac, 526 SCRA 116, June 29, 2007 259. Ang Kek Chen vs. Calasan, 528 SCRA 124, July 24, 2007 260. Wa-acon vs. People, 510 SCRA 429, December 06, 2006 261. Office of the Court Administrator vs. Lorenzo, 575 SCRA 9, December 23, 2008 262. People vs. Canete, 570 SCRA 549, November 07, 2008 263. Associated Labor Unions (ALU) vs. Court of Appeals, 570 SCRA 332, October 31, 2008 264. Equipment Technical Services vs. Court of Appeals, 568 SCRA 122, October 08, 2008 265. People vs. Bartolome, 557 SCRA 20, July 04, 2008 266. Pactolin vs. Sandiganbayan (Fourth Division), 554 SCRA 136, May 20, 2008 267. Gonzaga vs. Court of Appeals, 546 SCRA 532, February 26, 2008 268. Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 546 SCRA 150, February 18, 2008 269. Hipe vs. Commission on Elections, 602 SCRA 565, October 02, 2009 270. Pobre vs. Defensor-Santiago, 597 SCRA 1, August 25,

2009 271. Roman Catholic Archbishop of Caceres vs. Secretary of Agrarian Reform, 541 SCRA 304, December 21, 2007 272. People vs. Valenciano, 573 SCRA 572, December 10, 2008 273. Parma, Jr. vs. Office of the Deputy Ombudsman for Luzon, 553 SCRA 600, April 30, 2008 274. Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Bicolandia Drug Corporation, 496 SCRA 176, July 21, 2006 275. Garong vs. People, 508 SCRA 446, November 29, 2006 276. Samahang Magsasaka ng 53 Hektarya vs. Mosquera, 518 SCRA 668, March 22, 2007 277. Heirs of Pedro Pasag vs. Parocha, 522 SCRA 410, April 27, 2007 278. Casent Realty Development Corp. vs. Philbanking Corporation, 533 SCRA 390, September 14, 2007 279. National Electrification Administration vs. Gonzaga, 539 SCRA 388, December 04, 2007 280. Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Acesite (Philippines) Hotel Corporation, 516 SCRA 93, February 16, 2007 281. People vs. Pachero, 618 SCRA 606, April 20, 2010 282. People vs. Dolorido, 639 SCRA 496, January 12, 2011 283. General Milling Corporation vs. Ramos, 654 SCRA 256, July 20, 2011 284. People vs. Torres, Sr., 655 SCRA 720, August 22, 2011 285. Castro vs. People, 655 SCRA 431, August 15, 2011 286. People vs. Martin, 567 SCRA 42, September 29, 2008 287. People vs. Dela Cruz, 571 SCRA 469, November 20, 2008 288. People vs. Bajada, 571 SCRA 455, November 20, 2008 289. People vs. Amodia, 571 SCRA 444, November 20, 2008 290. People vs. Batoon, 636 SCRA 210, November 24, 2010 291. People vs. Marcelino, 625 SCRA 632, July 26, 2010 292. People vs. Ugos, 565 SCRA 207, September 12, 2008 293. S.S. Ventures International, Inc. vs. S.S. Ventures Labor Union, 559 SCRA 435, July 23, 2008 294. BF Corporation vs. Manila International Airport Authority, 556 SCRA 684, June 30, 2008 295. Nasipit Integrated Arrastre and Stevedoring Services, Inc. vs. Nasipit Employees Labor Union (NELU)-ALU-TUCP, 556 SCRA 206, June 27, 2008 296. People vs. Ofemanio, 611 SCRA 250, February 01, 2010 297. Land Bank of the Philippines, vs. Department of Agrarian Reform Adjudication Board, 611 SCRA 106,January 25, 2010 298. People vs. Wasit, 593 SCRA 721, July 23, 2009 299. People vs. Sabadlab, 600 SCRA 204, September 17, 2009 300. People vs. Cruz, 595 SCRA 411, August 04, 2009 301. Goma vs. Court of Appeals, 576 SCRA 1, January 08, 2009 302. People vs. Abon, 545 SCRA 606, February 15, 2008 303. Vivares vs. Reyes, 545 SCRA 80, February 13, 2008 304. Lim vs. Desierto, 545 SCRA 66, February 13, 2008 305. Forbes Park Association, Inc. vs. Pagrel, Inc., 545 SCRA 39, February 13, 2008 306. Cagayan Valley Drug Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 545 SCRA 10, February 13, 2008 307. People vs. Manulit, 635 SCRA 426, November 17, 2010 308. People vs. Aboganda, 585 SCRA 1, April 08, 2009 309. Asiatico vs. People, 657 SCRA 443, September 12, 2011 310. Conlu vs. Aredonia, Jr., 657 SCRA 367, September 12, 2011 311. Senador vs. People, 692 SCRA 669, March 06, 2013 312. Beckett vs. Sarmiento, Jr., 689 SCRA 494, January 30, 2013 313. Bote vs. Veloso, 686 SCRA 758, December 03, 2012 314. Menchavez vs. Bermudez, 684 SCRA 168, October 11, 2012 315. People vs. Pascua, 656 SCRA 629, August 31, 2011 316. David vs. OSG Shipmanagement Manila, Inc., 682 SCRA 103, September 26, 2012 317. People vs. Pabol, 603 SCRA 522, October 12, 2009 318. People vs. Resurreccion, 603 SCRA 510, October 12, 2009 319. People vs. Rusiana, 603 SCRA 57, October 05, 2009 320. Philippine Coconut Producers Federation, Inc. (COCOFED) vs. Republic of the Philippines, 679 SCRA 604, September 04, 2012 321. Republic vs. Heirs of Spouses Donato Sanchez and Juana Meneses, 744 SCRA 700, December 10, 2014 322. Uyboco vs. People, 744 SCRA 688, December 10, 2014 323. Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Philippine Airlines, Inc., 733 SCRA 741, August 27, 2014 324. Heirs of Simeon Piedad vs. Estrera, 608 SCRA 268, December 16, 2009 325. Heirs of Faustino Mesina vs. Heirs of Domingo Fian, Sr., 695 SCRA 345, April 08, 2013 326. Nollen, Jr. vs. Commission on Elections, 610 SCRA 42, January 11, 2009 327. People vs. Malate, 588 SCRA 817, June 05, 2009 328. Daikoku Electronics Phils. vs. Raza, 588 SCRA 788, June 05, 2009 329. People vs. Anguac, 588 SCRA 716, June 05, 2009

330. Tejada vs. Palaña, 530 SCRA 771, August 23, 2007 331. Baylosis, Sr. vs. People, 530 SCRA 32, August 14, 2007 332. Bacsin vs. Wahiman, 553 SCRA 137, April 30, 2008 333. Ogalisco vs. Holy Trinity College of General Santos City, Inc., 529 SCRA 672, August 09, 2007 334. Obra vs. Badua, 529 SCRA 621, August 09, 2007 335. Summerville General Merchandising & Co., Inc. vs. Eugenio, Jr., 529 SCRA 274, August 07, 2007 336. Santos vs. Parañaque Kings Enterprises, Inc., 505 SCRA 48, October 23, 2006 337. Gotis vs. People, 533 SCRA 441, September 14, 2007 338. St. Martin Funeral Homes vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 507 SCRA 500, November 22, 2006 339. Asejo vs. People, 528 SCRA 114, July 24, 2007 340. Nerpio vs. People, 528 SCRA 93, July 24, 2007 341. People vs. Garbida, 625 SCRA 98, July 13, 2010 342. People vs. Zulueta, Sr., 565 SCRA 199, September 12, 2008 343. People vs. Teczon, 565 SCRA 182, September 12, 2008 344. Salomon, Jr. vs. Frial, 565 SCRA 9, September 12, 2008 345. Dela Cruz vs. Dimaano Jr., 565 SCRA 1, September 12, 2008 346. People vs. Bunagan, 556 SCRA 808, June 30, 2008 347. Delgado vs. People, 611 SCRA 649, February 05, 2010 348. Philippine British Assurance Company, Inc. vs. Republic, 611 SCRA 429, February 02, 2010 349. People vs. Barba, 593 SCRA 711, July 23, 2009 350. Dalmacio-Joaquin vs. Dela Cruz, 586 SCRA 344, April 24, 2009 351. People vs. Orbita, 550 SCRA 535, March 31, 2008 352. People vs. Cuasay, 569 SCRA 870, October 17, 2008 353. De Guzman vs. People, 569 SCRA 452, October 17, 2008 354. Blue Angel Manpower and Security Services, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 560 SCRA 157, July 28, 2008 355. Garay vs. Bartolome, 554 SCRA 492, June 17, 2008 356. People vs. Bucayo, 554 SCRA 483, June 13, 2008 357. Bildner vs. Roxas, 554 SCRA 234, June 12, 2008 358. People vs. Neverio, 597 SCRA 149, August 25, 2009 359. People vs. Capwa, 541 SCRA 516, December 27, 2007 360. People vs. Ela, 541 SCRA 508, December 27, 2007 361. Office of the Court Administrator vs. Siwa, 739 SCRA 471, November 11, 2014 362. Lozado vs. Zerrudo, 695 SCRA 374, April 10, 2013 363. Tiggangay vs. Wacas, 694 SCRA 264, April 01, 2013 364. Rombe Eximtrade (Phils.), Inc. vs. Asiatrust Development Bank, 545 SCRA 253, February 13, 2008 365. People vs. Berondo, Jr., 582 SCRA 547, March 30, 2009 366. Qui vs. People, 682 SCRA 94, September 26, 2012 367. People vs. Mara, 587 SCRA 839, May 08, 2009 368. People vs. Cadap, 623 SCRA 655, July 05, 2010 369. People vs. Paler, 623 SCRA 469, July 05, 2010 370. Semblante vs. Court of Appeals, 19th Division, 655 SCRA 444, August 15, 2011 371. Tenorio vs. Perlas, 640 SCRA 496, January 26, 2011 372. Gaisano vs. Akol, 652 SCRA 378, June 15, 2011 373. Tuballa Heirs vs. Cabrera, 547 SCRA 289, February 29, 2008 374. Leyba vs. Rural Bank of Cabuyao, Inc., 571 SCRA 160, November 14, 2008 375. Flore s vs. Quitalig, 557 SCRA 334, July 04, 2008 376. Office of the Court Administrator vs. Quilatan, 631 SCRA 425, September 28, 2010 377. Dalida vs. Naguit, 526 SCRA 172, June 29, 2007 378. Gamboa-Hirsch vs. Court of Appeals, 527 SCRA 380, July 11, 2007 379. Francisco, Jr. vs. Toll Regulary Board, 633 SCRA 470, October 19, 2010 380. E.Y. Industrial Sales, Inc. vs. Shen Dar Electricity and Machinery Co., Ltd., 634 SCRA 363, October 20, 2010 381. People vs. Vicente, Jr., 641 SCRA 186, January 31, 2011 382. People vs. Sobangee, 641 SCRA 164, January 31, 2011 383. Pantilo 111 vs. Canoy, 642 SCRA 301, February 09, 2011 384. Rodriguez vs. People, 684 SCRA 580, October 24, 2012 385. Philippine National Bank vs. Reblando, 680 SCRA 531, September 12, 2012 386. People vs. Yoon Chang Wook, 603 SCRA 24, October 05, 2009 387. Philippine National Bank vs. Tria, 671 SCRA 440, April 25, 2012 388. Nevada vs. Casuga, 668 SCRA 441, March 20, 2012 389. People vs. Aure, 639 SCRA 570, January 17, 2011 390. People vs. Manlangit, 639 SCRA 455, January 12, 2011 391. Re: Letter-Complaint of Atty. Ariel Samson C. Cayetuna, et al., All Employees of Asso. Justice Michael P. Elbinias against Asso. Justice Michael P. Elbinias, CA-Mindanao Station, 639 SCRA 220, January 11, 2011 392. People vs. De la Cruz, 651 SCRA 597, June 08, 2011 393. People vs. Banan, 646 SCRA 420, March 23, 2011 394. Naguiat vs. Capellan, 646 SCRA 122, March 23, 2011 395. People vs. De Jesus, 640 SCRA 660, January 26, 2011 396. People vs. Alfredo, 638 SCRA 749, December 15, 2010 397. People vs. Omictin, 625 SCRA 611, July 26, 2010

398. People vs. Martinez, 593 SCRA 732, July 23, 2009 399. Romero II vs. Estrada, 583 SCRA 396, April 02, 2009 400. Paloma vs. Philippine Airlines, Inc., 558 SCRA 94, July 14, 2008 401. Oriental Shipmanagement Co., Inc. vs. Bastol, 622 SCRA 352, June 29, 2010 402. Orduña vs. Fuentebella, 622 SCRA 146, June 29, 2010 403. Hacienda Luisita, Incorporated vs. Presidential Agrarian Reform Council, 670 SCRA 392, April 24, 2012 404. People vs. Gabrino, 645 SCRA 187, March 09, 2011 405. Surviving Heirs of Alfredo R. Bautista vs. Lindo, 718 SCRA 321, March 10, 2014 406. Gupilan-Aguilar vs. Office of the Ombudsman, 717 SCRA 503, February 26, 2014 407. Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Fortune Tobacco Corporation, 705 SCRA 430, September 11, 2013 408. Regio vs. Commission on Elections, 711 SCRA 448, December 03, 2013 409. Heenan vs. Espejo, 711 SCRA 290, December 03, 2013 410. Viray vs. People, 709 SCRA 227, November 11, 2013 411. Parel vs. Heirs of Simeon Prudencio, 644 SCRA 496, March 02, 2011 412. People vs. Lucero, 644 SCRA 457, March 02, 2011 413. Mendoza vs. Villas, 644 SCRA 347, February 23, 2011 414. Hacienda Luisita, Incorporated vs. Presidential Agrarian Reform Council, 653 SCRA 154, July 05, 2011 415. People vs. Lagarde, 576 SCRA 809, January 20, 2009 416. People vs. Court of Appeals (12th Division), 545 SCRA 52, February 13, 2008 417. People vs. Francio, 635 SCRA 440, November 17, 2010 418. Roque, Jr. vs. Commission on Elections, 599 SCRA 69, September 10, 2009 419. Salapuddin vs. Court of Appeals, 691 SCRA 578, February 25, 2013 420. Bayan Muna vs. Romulo, 641 SCRA 244, February 01, 2011 421. Yongco vs. People, 731 SCRA 544, July 30, 2014 422. Tujan-Militante vs. Cada-Deapera, 731 SCRA 194, July 28, 2014 423. People vs. Abetong, 725 SCRA 304, June 04, 2014 424. Resbusquillo vs. Gualvez, 725 SCRA 259, June 04, 2014 425. Alconera vs. Pallanan, 714 SCRA 204, January 20, 2014 426. Umali vs. Commission on Elections, 723 SCRA 170, April 22, 2014 427. Narra Nickel Mining and Development Corp. vs. Redmont Consolidated Mines Corp., 722 SCRA 382, April 21, 2014 428. People vs. Llanas, Jr., 622 SCRA 602, June 29, 2010 429. People vs. Le, 622 SCRA 571, June 29, 2010 430. People vs. Sanchez, 622 SCRA 548, June 29, 2010 431. People vs. Baustista, 622 SCRA 524, June 29, 2010 432. People vs. Tibon, 622 SCRA 510, June 29, 2010 433. Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation (PAGCOR) vs. Fontana Development Corporation, 622 SCRA 461, June 29, 2010 434. People vs. Gallo, 622 SCRA 439, June 29, 2010 435. 435.People vs. Orias, 622 SCRA 417, June 29, 2010

MARCH 2015 G.R. No. 209843 March 25, 2015 TAIWAN KOLIN CORPORATION, LTD., Petitioner, vs.KOLIN ELECTRONICS CO., INC., Respondent. G.R. No. 203655 March 18, 2015 SM Land, Inc. vs Bases Conversion and Development Authority and Arnel Paciano D. Casanova, Esp., in his official capacity as President andn CEO of BCSA G.R. No. 206019 March 18, 2015 Philippine National Bank vs Commissioner of Internal Revenue G.R. No. 205300 March 18, 2015 Fonterra Brands Phils., Inc. vs Leonardo Largado and Teotimo Estrellano FEBRUARY 2015 JANUARY 2015 G.R. No. 210760 January 26, 2015 Kyle Anthony Zabala vs. People of the Philippines G.R. No. 195580 January 28, 2015 Narra Nickel Mining and Development Corp., Tesoro Mining and Development, Inc. and McArthur Mining, Inc. vs. Redmont Consolidated Mines Corp. DECEMBER 2014 G.R. No. 212388 December 10, 2014 Republic of the Philippine vs. Heirs of Spouses Donato Sanchez and Juana Meneses, represented by Rodolfo S. Aguinaldo G.R. No. 211703 December 10, 2014 Edelbert C. Uyboco vs. People of the Philippines G.R. No. 207682 December 10, 2014 Conrado B. Nicart, Jr. as

Provincial Governor of LGU-Eastern Samar vs. Ma. Josefina C, Titong and Joselito M. Abrugar, Sr.