Case Digest: Pimentel vs Aguirre

PIMENTEL vs. AQUIRRE G.R. No. 132988 19 JULY 2000 FACTS: Sub!"# o$ #%&s '"#&o( &s A)*&(&s#+'#&v! ,+)!+ No. 3-2 A, 3-2/ +!u&+!s o"' ov!+(*!(# u(&#s LGU/ #o +!)u"! #%!&+ !4!()&#u+!s b5 267 o$ #%!&+ 'u#%o+&!) +!u'+ '44+o4+&'#&o(s $o+ (o(4!+so(' s!+v&"!s S!". 1/ '() 'o;s #%! LGUs #o ;&#%%o) ' 4o+#&o( o$ #%!&+ &(#!+(' +!v!(u! 'o#*!(#s. •

P!#&#&o(!+ !"# !!+"&s&( #%! 4o;!+ o$ "o(#+o ov!+ LGUs ? #%'# #%! )&+!"#&v! #o ;&#%%o) ' 4o+#&o( o$ #%!&+ IRA &s &( "o(#+'v!(#&o( o$ S!". 28@ o$ #%! LGC ? S!". @= A+#.  o$ #%! Co(s#&#u#&o(. Co(s#&#u#&o(.

•

ISSU ISSUE: E:

B%!# B%!#%! %!++ S!" S!"s. s. 1 ?  o$ o$ A, A, 3-2 3-2 '+! '+! v' v'&) &) !!+ !!+"& "&s! s!s s o$ o$ #%! #%! P+!s P+!s&) &)!( !(#D #Ds s 4o; 4o;!+ !+ o$ !(!+' su4!+v&s&o( ov!+ LGUs.

EL:

S!". 1  YES S!".   N,

RATI,:  T%! Cou+# %!) %!) #%'# S!". 1 o$ A, 3-2= b!&( b!&( *!+!5 '( ')v&so+5 &s ;! ;&#%&( #%! 4o;!+s o$  o$  #%! P+!s&)!(#. I# &s (o# ' *'()'#o+5 &*4os&#&o(= '() su"% )&+!"#&v! "'((o# b! "%'+'"#!+&!) 's '( !!+"&s! o$ #%! 4o;!+ o$ "o(#+o. •

•

•

•

Lo"'