Case Brief Mc Mehta

ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc ccc

c c
c  c c c c cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc ccccccccccccc cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc ccccccccccccccccc cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc ccc c

÷
c cccccccccccc

c  !"c#"c$c! c%"&'(c!')!c*"+c#"c+ $# c,)'(- !c$.c! c/)$.#$/*c'%c ",'*(!c*$",$*$!0
c )$)"&c ''1c".1c )!$*$2)c.1(!)03c"c(,$1$")0c'%c* $c*'! c $**c $&$!13c+"c.-"-1c$.c! c&".(%"#!()c'%c1".-)'(c# &$#"*
c.c#&,)c3c*")-c "&'(.!c'%c'*(&c-"c*"41c%')&c'.c'%c! c(.$!c$.c! c ")!c'%c* $c+ $# c)(*!1c$.c! c 1"! c'%c)"*c/)'.
c c*"4"-3c)(*!1c%)'&c! c,()!$.-c'%c"c!".4c#'.!"$.$.-c'*(&c -"3c+"c#"(1c,0c&# ".$#"*c".1c (&".c))')
c!c#)"!1c"c#")c"&'.-c! c/'/*c )$1$.-c."),0c".1c+$! $.c!+'c1"03c".'! )c*"4"-3c"c&$.')c'.3c,)'4c'(!c"c"c)(*!c'%c '*(&c-"c#"/$.-c%)'&c! c5'$.!c'%c"c/$/
c .c! c#&,)c3c! c$!)$#!c "-$!)"!3c * $c')1)1c )$)"&c!'c!'/c! c&".(%"#!()$.-c".1c/)'#$.-c'%c "2")1'(c# &$#"*c".1c %)!$*$2)c"!c! $)c!",*$ &.!c$.c* $c".1c!'c)&'c(# c# &$#"*c".1c-"c%)'&c* $
c !c! $c/")!$#(*")c/'$.!3c

c  !"c&'1c!'c(/)&c'()!c!'c%$*c6c".1c#*"$&c%')c #'&/."!$'.c%')c! c*'c#"(1c".1c"*'c1&".11c! "!c! c#*'1c!",*$ &.!c '(*1c .'!c)!")!
cc c

c

ccccccccccccc c$(c$.'*1c )c")c 
c 7 "!c$c! c#'/c".1c"&,$!c'%c! c5()$1$#!$'.c'%c! c(/)&c'()!c(.1)c)!$#*cc $.#c! c"//*$#"!$'.c%')c#'&/."!$'.c")c'(- !c!'c,c&"$.!"$.1c(.1)c)!$#*8c 
c 7 ! )c)!$#*cc$c""$*",*c"-"$.!c )$)"&c+ $# c$c'+.1c,0c* $c*'! c $**c $&$!13c"c/(,*$#c#'&/".0c*$&$!1c,0c ")c".1c+ $# c$c.-"-1c$.c$.1(!)0c$!"*c!'c /(,*$#c$.!)!c".1c+$! c/'!.!$"*c!'c"%%#!c! c*$%c".1c "*! c'%c! c/'/*8c 
c 7 "!c$c! c&"()c'%c! c*$",$*$!0c'%c".c.!)/)$c+ $# c$c.-"-1c$.c"c "2")1'(c ')c$. ).!*0c1".-)'(c$.1(!)03c$%c,0c)"'.c'%c".c"##$1.!c'##())$.-c$.c(# c $.1(!)03c/)'.c1$c')c$c$.5()18c c

|
c

cccccccccccccc cc c+)$!c/!$!$'.c(.1)c)!$#*cc'%c! c'.!$!(!$'.c "c#'&c'.c"c)%).#c &"1c,0c"c9.# c'%c! )c(1-
c c)%).#c+"c&"1c,#"(c#)!"$.c:(!$'.c'%c &$."*c$&/')!".#c".1c $- c#'.!$!(!$'."*c$-.$%$#".#c+)c)"$1c$.c! c#'()c'%c ")-(&.!c+ .c! c+)$!c/!$!$'.c+"c')$-$."**0c ")1
c!c$c.'(- c!'c"0c! "!c! c9.# c'%c ! )c(1-c/)&$!!1c )$)"&c!'c)!")!c$!c/'+)c/*".!
c9(!c"%!)c! c*"4"-3c$!c+"c .#")0c!'c-$c! $c)%).#c!'c! c9.# c'%c%$c(1-
ccc c%$)!c$(c+ $# c$c #'.#).1c+$! c! c#'/c".1c"&,$!c'%c! c5()$1$#!$'.c'%c! c(/)&c'()!c(.1)c)!$#*c 3c9 "-+"!$c
3c$.c9".1 ("c (4!$c ')# "c;c .$'.c'%c.1$"3c *1c! "!c! c#'/c".1c"&,$!c '%c)!$#*cc'%c! c'.!$!(!$'.c'%c.1$"c1'c.'!c'.*0c#'.%)c/'+)c'.c! $c'()!c!'c$(c"c 1$)#!$'.3c')1)c')c+)$!c%')c! c.%')#&.!c'%c%(.1"&.!"*c)$- !c,(!c$!c"*'c*"0c"c #'.!$!(!$'."*c',*$-"!$'.c'.c! $c'()!c!'c/)'!#!c! c%(.1"&.!"*c)$- !c'%c! c/'/*c".1c%')c ! "!c/()/'c! c#'()!c "c"**c$.#$1.!"*c".1c".#$**")0c/'+)c$.#*(1$.-c! c/'+)c!'c&"4c ".1c"1'/!c.+c)&1$c".1c%" $'.c.+c!)"!-$c1$-.1c!'c.%')#c! c%(.1"&.!"*c

)$- !
c c#'.1c:(!$'.c+ $# c+"c#'.#).1c+$! c! c""$*",$*$!0c'%c)!$#*c3c! c '.'()",*c'()!c"$1c! "!c! 0c1'c.'!c/)'/'c!'c1#$1c".0c1%$.$!c!"!&.!c"!c! $c!"-c "c$!c.1c1!"$*1c#'.$1)"!$'.
c ')c! c! $)1c$(3c+ $# c+"c#'.#).1c+$! c! c #'&/."!$'.3c! c#'()!c1#$11c!'c1$)#!c* $c-"*c$1c".1c1$#c9'")1c!'c!"4c(/c! c #"c'%c"**c! 'c+ 'c#*"$&c!'c "c,.c(%%)1c,0c! c'*(&c-"c".1c%$*c"#!$'.c'.c! $)c , "*%c$.c! c"//)'/)$"!c#'()!c%')c#*"$&$.-c#'&/."!$'.c"-"$.!c )$)"&c".1c! c* $c 1&$.$!)"!$'.c$c1$)#!1c!'c/)'$1c! c.#")0c%(.1c!'c! c* $c-"*c$1c".1c1$#c 9'")1c%')c! c/()/'c'%c%$*$.-c".1c/)'#(!$.-c(# c"#!$'.
c c

O  
c cccccccccccccccccc  c%$)!c$(c'%c! c#'/c".1c"&,$!c'%c)!$#*cc+"c)%))1c,0c9 "-+"!$c%)'&c 9".1 ("c (4!$c ')# "c
c .$'.c'%c.1$"c".1c$!c