Bail - Nilesh

IN THE HIGH COURT CO URT OF GUJARAT AT AT AHMEDABAD DISTRICT: AHMEDABAD

CRIMINAL MISC.APPLICATION NO.________ OF 2014 (U/s. 43 !" C#$%$&' P#!)*+,#* C!+*13

N$*s'$ C'&+,'$ A#'+$'Male, Aged 40 Years, Religion: Hindu,

R*s$+$& '5: 602, Jai Ambe Society, Canal Road, Sanala Road, Morbi !riginal Resident o" #illage $i%ar, &Ran',  $a%ula  $a%ula Hal#ad, (istrict: (istrict: Morbi &Arrested on 220)20*+ and since ten in  -udicial custody' custody'

P#*s*&5 !+*+ '5 Sabarmati Central Jail, Sabarmati, Amedabad

666666P*5$5$!&*# (O#$. A)),s*+

 //Versus//   //Versus// 

T* S5'5* !" G,7'#'5 (.otice be ser#ed troug te /d , Hig Court o" 1u-arat, Sola, Amedabad 

666666.R*s8!&+*&5

T!: THE HON9BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE AND OTHER HON9BLE JUDGES OF THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARA GUJ ARAT T AT AT AHMEDABAD. AHMED ABAD.  $e umble etition o" te etitioner abo#e named

MOST RESPECTFULL; SHEA, *24 > A o" te ndian enal Code, *60 read it Sections 66 and 66&C' o" n"ormation and  $ecnology Act, 2000, ic is registered as Crime Register .o  > *+6;20*9, erein te etitioner

is

named

in

te

said

5irst

n"ormation Reort and sos as accused .o *

2. $e etitioner states tat te etitioner as arrested "rom Amedabad on 220)20*+ $e 5irst n"ormation Reort being crime Register .o  > *+6;20*+ is no merged it 5irst n"ormation Reort .o 0;20*+ lodged it

te Crime 7ranc olice Station, Amedabad  $e resent alication "or regular bail is ?lled be"ore te ?lling o" te carge seet

3. $e sirt "acts o" te case are as under: 4. $e etitioner states tat te etitioner is residing at te address mentioned in te cause title and e is doing business o" sales and urcase in ceremonies $e etitioner as to minor cildren, a boy and a girl His maternal grand moter &.aani' is e@ired on 2+0)20*+ and te maternal uncle o" te etitioner as e@ired on 260)20*+

=. $e etitioner states tat te 5irst n"ormation Reort being Crime Register o  > 0;20*+ is lodged it te Crime 7ranc olice Station on 0*;0);20*+ $e alleged ic ad alleged to monts rior to te lodging o" te 5irst n"ormation Reort, interalia alleging tat te ersons belonging to te atidar Community

are olding te meetings and ta%ing out rallies and te social media #i, Bat=s a, 5aceboo%

etc,

are

being

utilied

and

deliberately it a #ie to see tat tere is a class conict and are using seeces ic ould instigate te eole at large 5or ic te 5irst n"ormation Reort as been lodged it te Crime 7ranc olice Station, ic is recorded as Crime Register .o  > 0;20*+ t may be noted tat in te said 5irst n"ormation Reort

te

etitioner

as

not

named

Anne@ed ereto and mar%ed as >A&&*?,#* A9 to te etition is a coy o" 5R #ide Crime Register .o  > 0;20*+ registered it te Crime 7ranc olice Station, Amedabad

@. $e etitioner states tat te 5irst n"ormation Reort being Crime Register .o  > *+6; 20*+ is lodged it te Morbi City

*+6;20*+ lodged it te Morbi City 0;20*+

. $e etitioner states tat te etitioner as sent to -udicial custody, te etitioner is tere"ore re"erring te resent etition "or regular bail under Section 49) o" te Code o"  Criminal rocedure, *)E9, on te "olloing amongst oter grounds ic may be urged at te time o" earing o" tis etition

10. $e etitioner submits tat bone o" te ingredients o" te carges Sections against te etitioner as been satis?ed $ere"ore, tere is a ?t case "or tis Hon=ble Court to e@ercise discretionary oer to enlarge te etitioner on bail

11. $e etitioner submits tat it is ertinent to note tat te carging Sections against te etitioner be"ore te said 5irst n"ormation

Reort is merged, Sections *+9, *+9&A' o" te ndian enal Code, *60 and Section 6+ and Section

66&C'

o"

te

n"ormation

and

 $ecnology Act, 2000 Section *+9 o" te ndian enal Code ro#ides "or te ma@imum unisment o" one year and ?ne Section *+93 A o" te ndian enal Code ro#ides "or ma@imum eriod, ic can e@tend u to tree years and ?ne or bot Section *+9 o"  te ndian enal Code is bailable and triable by te Court o" Magistrate, ereas Section *+93A o" te ndian enal Code is non3 bailable Sections 6+ and 66 &C' o" te n"ormation $ecnology Act also ro#ides te unisment uto tree years, and tere"ore, te said sections ere also bailable o8ence  $e said sections are bailable one

12. $e etitioner submits tat "rom te bare reading o" te 5irst n"ormation Reort, no

ingredients o" Section *+9 o" te ndian enal Code constituting

te

o8ence

unisable

under Section *+9 > A o" te ndian enal Code can be made out .or te ingredients constituting te o8ence unisable under Sections

6+

and

66

o"

te

n"ormation

 $ecnology Act, 2000 are disclosed $ere"ore, te allegations made in te said body o" te 5irst n"ormation Reort "ailed to disclose commission o" any o8ence $e etitioner ould li%e to "urter submit to tis Hon=ble Court tat te resondent as claimed tat te (irector 1eneral o" olice as directed to amalgamate bot te 5irst n"ormation Reort, one recorded in te (C7 olice Station, at Amedabad and second recorded at Morbi olice Station, being Crime Register .o  > *+6;20*+ t is ertinent to note tat Section *243 A o" te ndian enal Code *60 sea%s

about sedition against te 1o#ernment Bit ro"ound resect is is submitted tat te arty in oer in te State and te 1o#ernment rules establised are to di8erent terns and bot are not substituting o" eac oter 7ot terms

are

not

synonymous

also

n

te

democratic country, e#ery erson as rigt to e@ress descent o" #oice against te arty in oer Assuming "or te as%e o" argument itout admitting te same tat te metod and mode o" e@ression #oice o" descent against te arty in oer is not in good taste or good manner Hoe#er, language assuming to a#e been used, ic may be #ery bad in taste ould not constitute te o8ence o"  crating sedation against te State $ere is no allegation at so e#er made tat te resent 1o#ernment o" 1u-arat is to be tron out t is ertinent to note tat en te /ord

Maccula dra"ted te said Section, Section *24 > A as in te dra"t Hoe#er, said section as omitted ile enacting te ndian enal Code, *60 Section *243 A came to be introduced in te ndian enal Code by Act .o FFG o" *0E a"ter te indeendent, te ord A o" te Act $e ell %non

cases

are

ueen

Imresses

 Jogendracandra 7ose &reorted in *)2 *) //R

Calcutta

9+',

ueen

Imresses

7algangadar $ila% &22 /R 7ombay **2' ueen Imresses G;S Ramcandra .arayan > *)E &22' /R 7ombay *+2 5ull 7enc ueen Imresses G;S Ambarasad &*)0' &20' /R Allaabad 5ull 7enc $ese "reedom ?gters and oters ere rosecuted under Section

*243 A o" te ndian enal Code, since te carge against tem as to o#er tro te imerial 1o#ernments Hoe#er, te Section *243A o" te ndian enal Code, *60 cannot be used against te e@ression o" "reedom o"  guarantee under te Constitution o" ndia n"act, "rom coy o" te 5irst n"ormation Reort it is crystal clear tat all suc is against te arty in oer and not against te 1o#ernment $e arty in oer and te 1o#ernment

are

not

synonymous

n

(emocracy, e#ery citien as rigt to e@ress is descent He can be unised, i" suc act is unisable as slender or de"amation 7ut no o8ence can be said to a#e been made out against te State $ere"ore, tere is no case made

out

against

te

etitioner

$e

etitioner is tere"ore, entitled "or regular bail

13. $e etitioner tus being aggrie#ed and dissatis?ed it te imugned !rder dated 0020*4 assed by /d Additional Sessions  Judge,

Amedabad

cancelling

is

bail

alication, assails te same on te "olloing amongst oter grounds

inter alia:



GROUNDS

A.  $e etitioner submits tat te imugned !rder re-ecting te bail o" te etitioner is contrary to la, e#idence on record and is unarranted in te "acts and circumstances o"  te case

B.  $e etitioner submits tat te 5R in Duestion erein

te o8ence is alleged to

a#e been committed rior to 2 monts "rom te date o" lodging 5R $us en te 5R as been lodged belatedly, te Court belo

ougt to a#e considered te asect o" delay and "alse imlication o" te etitioner "or te alleged o8ences in Duestion

C. $e etitioner submits tat te etitioner as under olice remand till and tat no reco#ery and or disco#ery are made during te course o" remand and tis asect o" matter becomes clear "rom te AKda#it

14. $e etitioner states tat te etitioner as not re"erred any oter alication on te sub-ect matter o" te alication, in any oter Court o" /a in ndia, including te Hon=ble Sureme Court o" ndia, sa#e and e@cet te resent etition

1=. $e etitioner cra#es lea#e to add, alter, amend and rescind in te memo o" te resent etition as and en necessity so

arises, it %ind ermission o" tis Hon=ble Court

1@. n

te

a"ore

mentioned

remises

te

etitioner most umbly rays be"ore tis Hon=ble Court tat:

A.  $is Hon=ble Court may be leased to admit and allo te resent etition

B.  $is Hon=ble Court may be leased to to enlarge te etitioner on regular bail as contemlated by te ro#isions o" Section 49) o"

Criminal

rocedure

Code,

*)E9

in

connection it te comlaint registered it Crime 7ranc, olice Stattion, Amedabad #ide Crime Register .o  > 0;20*+ on any terms and conditions, at ic may be ?r tougt ?t and roer to be imosed uon te etitioner

C. $is Hon=ble Court may be leased to Duas and set aside te imugned !rder dated

09*020*+

mar%ed

and

anne@ed

as

A&&*?,#*C C! o" tis etition in te interest o" -ustice

D.  $is Hon=ble Court may be leased to disense it te AKda#it o" te etitioner as te etitioner is in -udicial custody

E. $is Hon=ble Court may be leased to grant suc oter and "urter relie";s as may be deemed ?r, -ust and roer in te "acts and circumstances o" te case

AND FOR THIS ACT OF INDNESS AND  JUSTICE THE PETITIONER- AS IN DUT;  BOUND SHALL EER PRA;.

_______________________

 JAGRUTI DEAADI;A P')*: A%*+''+ D'5*: __.0.2014

(A+!)'5* "!#

5* P*5$5$!&*#

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD DISTRICT: AHMEDABAD

CRIMINAL MISC.APPLICATION NO.________ OF 2014 (U/s. 43 !" C#$%$&' P#!)*+,#* C!+*13

'&'$'' R'%'#!s* S'#%' 666.P*5$5$!&*# (O#$$&' A)),s*+ //*#s,s// T* S5'5* !" G,7'#'5 666..R*s8!&+*&5

INDE

A&&*?,#* N!9s

P'#5$),'#s

P'* N!9s



M*%! !" P*5$5$!&

A

Coy o" 5R being CR .o9);*4

B

Coy o" te AKda#it dated 0020*4

C C!

Coy

o"

Alication

Criminal .o9**0

Misc o" 

20*4 along it te !rder dated

0020*4 assed

tereon belo I@* D C!

Coies o" AKda#it dated 900+20*9 and Alication dated 2)0620*9

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD DISTRICT: AHMEDABAD

CRIMINAL MISC.APPLICATION NO.________ OF 2014

(U/s. 43 !" C#$%$&' P#!)*+,#* C!+*13

'&'$'' R'%'#!s* S'#%' 666.P*5$5$!&*# (O#$$&' A)),s*+ //*#s,s// T* S5'5* !" G,7'#'5 666..R*s8!&+*&5

C.R. N!: P!$)* S5'5$!&:

39);20*4

Meganinagar,

Amedabad

S*)5$!&s:

Sec 406, 46+ and 46 o"

C, *60 Sec46E L 4E* o" C came to be added subseDuently in "ace o" !rder dated 0020*4

C!%8'$&5 !+*+ !&: *60920*4 D'5* !" !*&)*: "rom te lodging

rior to ) monts

o" 5R on *60920*4

9*0E20*4 at 20:*+

D'5* !" '##*s5: Hrs

R*,'# B'$:

7e"ore Carge3Seet

O#+*# 8'ss*+ !&:

0020*4 by te

Addtl Sessions  Judge, Amedabad in Criminal Misc Alication .o9**0;20*4 re-ecting te same