BA291-1 Basic Food Science Corporation Case Study

Ke`cj`zx h` C`lk D`hz`m @xokecol Oze`c Fpiojlk @zc` Cl~` Zlh Zldo Zoab`c Zlkqpeccl JO :5?+? Qxzox`fea Iokof`i`kx E ^zlg`lz Ozx Ecokl Dpcu 0# :>?? Ao` ^z``kxoxelk4 Joea Gllh Qae`ka` ^zlhpax Alz~lzoxelk E+

Joamfzlpkh

Ali~oku Bexlzu Joea Gllh Qae`ka` ^zlhpax Alz~lzoxelk "JGQ^A% vo glpkh`h ju Oc`rokh`z Zlok`# o JQ Gllh X`abklclfu fzohpox` okh IJO h`fz`` blch`z v exb pjxokxeoc `r~`ze`ka` vlzmekf ek xb` oz`o lg z``ozab okh ~zlhpax h`w`cl~i`kx glz PZA+ Ek :>>6# Oc`r qpex be dlj okh glpkh`h JGQ^A+ B` xb`k copkab`h Fl/Fl/ @rxz`i`# o cek` lg bozh aokhu iozm`x`h o –xb` gezx `k`zfu aokhu ek xb` ^bece~~ek`+’ Oaalzhekf xl xb` ao` ozxeac`# Oc `r e o hukoiea ~`zlk vbl ocvou `ozab` glz li`xbekf xl m``~ bei`cg laap~e`h+ Ek h`w`cl~ekf be gezx ~zlhpax# b` vo jpu `ozabekf glz p~~ce`z# h`ocekf vexb pj)alkxzoaxlz# p~`zweekf `i~clu``# ~`zg`axekf glzipcoxelk# x`xekf ~zlhpax# az`oxekf coj`c# jocokaekf be jllm okh h`w`cl~ekf o iozm`xekf ~cok+ Blv`w`z# ogx`z xb` copkab lg xb` ~zlhpax# Oc`r glpkh bei`cg vexb xll ipab ehc` xei`+ Ex vo xbe hukoiei okh `kxz`~z`k`pzeoc ekacekoxelk xbox occlv`h bei xl `ijozm lk lxb`z jpek``+ Ek :>>2# Oc`r `xojceb`h o vox`z z`geccekf jpek`# Ea`Vox`z# xbox aox`z xl blp`blch+ Ek :>>5# b` xllm lw`z xb` iokof`i`kx lg xb`ez goiecu jpek` lg z`alkhexelkekf okh xzohekf `alkh)bokh lgg`x ~zekxekf `qpe~i`kx+ Ek xb` oi` u`oz b` `xojceb`h Lgg`x Qlcpxelk# ok lgg`x ~zekxekf jpek` xbox ~zlweh` occ)ozlpkh ~zekxekf `zwea`+ Be cox`x w`kxpz` e o fzo~bea h`efk `zwea` az`ox`h xl ali~c`i`kx be lgg`x ~zekxekf jpek`+ Abocc`kf` okh Ep` O Oc`r `ijozm`h lk hegg`z`kx jpek`` ek xb` ~ok lg lkcu o g`v u`oz# b` bo goa`h `w`zoc ~zljc`i4 klk)z`iexxoka` lg z`w`kp`# klk)~oui`kx lg alkefk`h ~zlhpax okh ~ecg`zof`+ Oklxb`z iodlz ep` ox JGQ^A e xbox ocxblpfb Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` e hegg`z`kx gzli lxb`z aokhe` ju j`ekf ~zljojcu xb` lkcu `k`zfu aokhu owoecojc`# alkpi`z hl klx hegg`z`kxeox` ex gzli lxb`z aokhe` okh ocz`ohu bow` o `x ~zea` ek iekh+ Xbp# xb`u alpch `oecu vexab xl lxb`z jzokh vb`k v b`k xb` ~zea` lg xb` `k`zfu aokhu e ek az`o`h+ Xbe ~`za`~xelk xbp ~zlweh` o alkxzoekx lk xb` iozfek lg xb` ~zlhpax cek`+ H`iokh glz xb` `k`zfu aokhu e ocl u`x xl ~eam p~ o ex e xecc wezxpoccu pkmklvk xl xb`ez xozf`x iozm`x+ EE+

^zljc`i Qxox`i`kx

Vbox xzox`fe` blpch JGQ^A ohl~x l xbox ex aok xom` gpcc ohwokxof` lg ex ~lzxglcel lg jpek``# ei~zlw` z`w`kp` okh ~zlgex# iexefox` v`omk`` okh z`lcw` l~`zoxelkoc ep`< EEE+

Gzoi`vlzm glz Okocue

Xl okocut` xbe ao` okh xl gekh ok okv`z xl xb` ~zljc`i xox`i`kx# xb` fzlp~ abl` QVLX Okocue# ^lzx`z― 0 Glza` okh xb` JAF Ioxzer xl ali` p~ vexb z`alii`khoxelk glz xb` ali~oku+ @oab ilh`c e heap`h jze`gcu j`clv+ Xb` Z`lpza` Jo`h Ilh`c4 QVLX Okocue

QVLX Okocue lz xb` Z`lpza` Jo`h Ilh`c opi` occ lzfoketoxelk oz` pkeqp` alcc`axelk lg z`lpza` okh ao~ojecexe`+ Ex e p`h xl okocut` xb` blv o ~ozxeapcoz gezi― ekx`zkoc okh `rx`zkoc ohwokxof` okh heohwokxof` aok j` p`h xl glzipcox` xzox`fe`+ Ek xbe ao`# v` p` QVLX okocue xl ali` p~ vexb z`alii`kh`h xzox`fe` xbox vecc b`c~ xb` gezi ei~zlw` xb` ~`zglzioka` lg ex ~zlhpax okh l~`zoxelk+ Xb` E,L Ilh`c 4 ^lzx`z― 0 Glza` Ilh`c Xb` fzlp~ ocl p`h xb` Ekhpxzeoc Lzfoketoxelk ilh`c lg ojlw` ow`zof` z`xpzk lz ^lzx`z― 0 Glza` Ilh`c xl h`x`ziek` blv xb` gezi― `rx`zkoc `kwezlki`kx ogg`ax ex+ Xb` E,L Ilh`c opi` xbox ex e xb` `rx`zkoc `kwezlki`kx# xb` `alkliu# xbox ilx ogg`ax gezi ~`zglzioka`+ Xbp# xbe okocue aok b`c~ h`x`ziek` vbox xzox`fe` vecc j` ilx pex`h xl ohhz` ep` o v`cc o `r~clex l~~lzxpkexe` jzlpfbx ojlpx ju ex `rx`zkoc `kwezlki`kx+ Xb` Jlxlk Alkpcxokau Fzlp~ Ioxzer Coxcu# xb` JAF ioxzer vo p`h xl zokm JGQ^A― jpek` pkex lz ~zlhpax lk xb` joe lg xb`ez z`coxew` iozm`x boz` okh fzlvxb zox`+ Xb` JAF Abozx bo glpz qpohzokx aocc`h4 Aob Alv# Hlf# Qxoz ' _p`xelk Iozm vexb `oab qpohzokx bowekf alzz`~lkhekf pff`x`h xzox`fe`+ EW+

Okocue O+ QVLX Okocue

Cex`h lk xb` xojc` j`clv oz` xb` xz`kfxb# v`omk``# l~~lzxpkexe` okh xbz`ox lg xb` ali~oku jo`h lk xb` ekglzioxelk glpkh lk xb` ao`+ Eii`heox`cu glcclvekf xb` xojc` oz` xb` ~zl~l`h QVLX xzox`fe` jo`h lk xbe xojc`+ QXZ@KFXBQ EKX@ZKOC OHWOKXOF@Q

V@OMK@QQ@Q EKX@ZKOC HEQOHWOKXOF@Q

GLLH FZLP^

GLLH FZLP^

Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` Xb` lvk`z bei`cg e x`abkeaoccu ali~`x`kx ek K^H okh _O Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` e hpjj`h o –xb` ^bece~~ek`― gezx `k`zfu aokhu+’ Iekx gcowlz hegg`z`kxeox` ex gzli algg`` aokhe` ‑ ~`zbo~ xb` acl`x ali~`xexlz+

Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` IOKPGOAXPZEKF4 Ceiex`h mklvc`hf` vexb z`fozh xl xb` iokpgoaxpz` lg aokhe` IOZM@XEKF4 JGQ^A pxecet` ek`r~`kew` iozm`xekf abokk`c cem` vlzh) vlzh)lg)ilpxb okh laeoc k`xvlzm pab o Goa`jllm+ Xb` ali~oku bo u`x xl xo~ lxb`z i`heo h``iekf xb`` xll `r~`kew` glz xb` gc`hfcekf ali~oku+ ^ZLHPAX GOIECEOZEXU4 Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` @k`zfu aokhu e xecc wezxpoccu pkmklvk xl xb`ez xozf`x iozm`x+ ^lejecexu lg –XOQX@ GOXEFP@’4 Xb`z` e ocl xb` ~lejecexu lg – xox` goxefp`’ vbeab e o mklvk ~b`kli`klk ek xb` alkg`axelk`zu jpek`+ JGQ^A bo z`a`kxcu ohh`h o bekx lg c`ilk ek xb`ez iekx)gcowlz`h aokhe`+ Oc`r bo u`x xl gekh lpx eg xbe abokf` ek xox` vlpch j` ~z`g`zojc` xl alkpi`z+







EA@VOX@Z ^z``kxcu ~zlgexojc` K^H okh _O ao~ojecexe` lg lvk`z okh jpek` alkpcxekf ozi  









EA@VOX@Z ^ecg`zof` ^llz alcc`axelk  

L^^LZXPKEXE@Q @RX@ZKOC OHWOKXOF@Q

XBZ@OXQ @RX@ZKOC HEQOHWOKXOF@Q

GLLH FZLP^

GLLH FZLP^

Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` IOZM@X FZLVXB4 Iozm`x fzlvxb e f`k`zoccu ekaz`oekf vbeab ~zlweh` o x`ohu ~zlgex glz iokpgoaxpz`z "k`x ei~lzxoxelk lg bozh aokhe` gzli xb` u`oz :>>> xl :>>0% @K@ZFU AOKHU H@IOKH4 H`iokh glz xb` `k`zfu aokhu e ocl u`x xl ~eam p~

Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` B@OWU ALI^@XEXELK4 b`owu ali~`xexelk jlxb gzli `xojceb`h okh k`v jzokh OWOECOJECEXU LG OCX@ZKOXEW@Q4 hew`z` ozzou lg ~zlhpax aox`flze` ek xb` aokhu jpek`# li` lg vbeab oz` bozh aokhe`# ab`vojc` aokhe` okh fpiiu lz d`ccu aokhe`





EA@VOX@Z ^lejecexu lg `r~okelk lg j`w`zof` cek` 





EA@VOX@Z Ekaz`oekf oxpzoxelk okh klk) hegg`z`kxeoxelk lg xb` vox`z z`geccekf jpek` Befb c`w`c lg ali~`xexelk ek j`w`zof` ekhpxzu 

HEW@ZQEXU okh K@XVLZM Xb` hew`zege`h ~zlgec` lg JGQ^A― jpek``+ Xbe few` xb` ali~oku `w`zoc ~lejc` z`w`kp` xz`oi okh hew`zege` zem o v`cc+ Xbe# blv`w`z# cefbxcu ali~ceaox` lzfoketoxelkoc xzpaxpz` okh iokof`i`kx alkxzlc 



Q)L Qxzox`fe` Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` •

•

•

Xb` gllh x`abklclfu mklv)blv iou j` ioreiet`h xl az`ox` k`v gcowlz okh x`rxpz` "ab`vu lz lgx aokhe` lz d`cc u glzi% l k`v alka`~x,~zlhpax "`e+ Wexoiek aokhe`# he`xekf aokhe` vexb C)aozkexek`# l `xa% Xb` jpek` hew`zexu l~`k l~~lzxpkexe` xl ei~zlw` iozm`xekf "oi~c` aokhe` xl ace`kx xl ~z`oh xb` jzokh ovoz`k`% Fzo~bea fzlp~ iouj` pxecet`h xl b`c~ ek ohw`zxeekf,iozm`xekf

EA@VOX@Z •

Qxphu g`oejecexu lg h`w`cl~i`kx lg k`v ~zlhpax

•

Alkeh`z c` ali~ceaox`h ~zlhpax gezx cem` ea` aokhe`# gzpex dp ea`

Q)X Qxzox`fe` Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` •

•

•

J` xzp` xl xb` jzokh eh`kxexu+ ^zlilx` ex hegg`z`kxeoxelk gzli lxb`z aogg`ekox`h aokhe`+ Ek K^H# j`eh` k`v alka`~x o i`kxelk`h ek xb` Q)L xzox`fu# xb` xox` ipx j` few`k ei~lzxoka`+ Eg ~`l~c` hlk―x cem` ex# ex iou klx `cc h`~ex` lg wocp`)ohh`h Eg ulp aok―x j`ox xb`i# dlek xb`i+ H`w`cl~ ~zlhpax alka`~x ek glzi eiecoz xl xb` ocx`zkoxew` "lgx aokhe`# d`cce`# `xa%

EA@VOX@Z • •

Qxphu g`oejecexu lg h`w`cl~i`kx lg k`v ~zlhpax Alkeh`z c` ali~ceaox`h ~zlhpax gezx cem` ea` aokhe`# gzpex dp ea`

V)L Qxzox`fe` Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` •

•

H`~ex` goezcu ceiex`h iozm`xekf okh ~zlhpaxelk ao~oaexu# xb`z` xecc ipab zlli glz ekaz`oekf iozm`x wlcpi`+ Xb`u alpch alkeh`z dlekx w`kxpz` vexb `rexekf hexzejpxlz xzohekf iozfek vexb ei~zlw`h wlcpi`+ Eg xb`u bow` ocz`ohu alkgeh`ka` vexb xb` ~zlhpax# iouj` `rx`zkoc gekokaekf iou j` alkeh`z`h xl `kfof` ek cozf` wlcpi` ~zlhpaxelk okh hexzejpxelk

EA@VOX@Z •

V` alpch opi` xbox oc` e hlekf v`cc glz xb` ili`kx `ra`~x glz ioku ~zljc`i zh vexb vlzmglza`+ Alkeh`z xb` ~lejecexu lg bezekf ~`l~c` gzli 1 ~ozxu of`kae`+ Of`kae` xlhou lgg`z ~ecg`zof` fpozokx`` glz alcc`axlz+ C`owekf xb`i vexb o ilz` `ggeae`kx oc` okh alcc`axelk x`oi+

V)X Qxzox`fe` Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` •

Ei~zlw` iozm`xekf okh hegg`z`kxeoxelk4 l

l

^z``kxoxelk lg xb` ~zlhpax o ok p~)okh)aliekf xz`kh iouj` e o vou xl lw`zali` ~llz ~l~pcozexu+ Alkeh`z clv`z alx ohh cem` ~zekx ohh ek xlz` Eh`kxegu o xozf`x iozm`x+ Ilx cem`cu xb` AH vlzmekf aco cllmekf glz ab`o~`z# lk)xb`)fl ocx`zkoxew` xl `k`zfu hzekm vlpch gex

EA@VOX@Z •

Lk` v`omk` e xb` pkz`fpcox`h `ccekf lg xo~ vox`z z`gecc= xb`u aok p` xbe o li` lzx lg ~zl~ofokho w ali~`xexlz+ Qeka` xb`u bow` healw`z`h okh c`ozk`h gzli ~ox iexom`# Xb`u alpch few` opzoka` lk xb` h`cew`zu lg befb qpocexu ~pzege`h vox`z pkcem` lxb`z ali~`xexlz J+ ^lzx`z― 0 Glza` Ilh`c

Glz xbe ~ozx lg xb` okocue# ^lzx`z― 0 Glza` e p`h xl okocut` xb` ~`zglzioka` lg Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` @k`zfu Aokhu ek ~ozxeapcoz# ~zeiozecu j`aop` JGQ^A xecc alkeh`z Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` @k`zfu Aokhu xl j` xb`ez ioek ~zlhpax lz xb` jzokh xbox aozze` xb` ali~oku+ Ek ohhexelk# ilx lg xb` lxb`z jpek`` xbox xb`u bow` oz` ei~cu lgg)bllx lg xbe ekexeoc jpek`+ Xb` floc lg pekf xbe ilh`c e xl blv vb`xb`z JGQ^A― aokhu jpek` aok xokh o o ekfc` jpek` pkex lz klx+ ^lzx`z― 0 Glza` e eccpxzox`h j`clv4

Xbz`ox lg ^lx`kxeoc @kxzokx 



Jozze`z xl `kxzu ekxl xb` aokhu ekhpxzu oz` qpex` befb eka` o efkegeaokx oilpkx lg ao~exoc e k``h`h xl ~zlapz` ioabek`ze` okh `qpe~i`kx xl ~zla` zov iox`zeoc ekxl aokhe` Oklxb`z jozze`z xl `kxzu e xb` oaa` xl hexzejpxelk k`xvlzm+ Iodlz abokk`c lg hexzejpxelk glz aokhe` oz` p~`ziozm`x okh fzla`ze`+ Lxb`z efkegeaokx abokk`c oz` oze)oze xlz` okh gllh xocc oclkf zloh+

Jozfoekekf ^lv`z lg Qp~~ce`z 

Claoc pj)alkxzoaxlz oz` bez`h xl iokpgoaxpz` aokhe` glz aokhu iokpgoaxpz`z jpx bow` clv jozfoekekf ~lv`z

Xbz`ox lg Qpjxexpx` 

Hew`z` ozzou lg ~zlhpax aox`flze` ek xb` aokhu jpek`# li` lg vbeab oz` bozh aokhe`# ab`vojc` aokhe` okh fpiiu lz d`ccu aokhe`+ Alkpi`z hl klx hegg`z`kxeox` ex gzli lxb`z aokhe` okh ocz`ohu bow` o `x ~zea` ek iekh

Jozfoekekf ^lv`z lg Jpu`z 



Hexzejpxelk lg Fl/ Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` e ceiex`h xl oze)oze xlz` ek I`xzl Iokeco+ Xb` xzox`fu e xl j` ojc` xl `cc Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` dpx o xb` xlz` bow` lch ilx lg ex xlam lg lxb`z aokhe`+ Qoc`~`zlk bow` z`~lzx`h xb` heggeapcxu ek alkwekaekf k`v xlz` xl `cc xb`ez aokhu eka` xb` jzokh e wezxpoccu pkmklvk+ JGQ^A ocl h`oc vexb vblc`oc`z xl gpzxb`z ex f`lfzo~bea z`oab okh `cc ex ek –ilz` `xojceb`h’ xlz` cem` fzla`ze` okh p~`ziozm`x Alkpi`z alpch `oecu vexab xl lxb`z jzokh vb`k xb` ~zea` lg xb` `k`zfu aokhu e ekaz`o`h

Ekhpxzu Ali~`xexlz 

Ali~`xexelk e b`owu+ Xb`z` oz` ei~cu o clx lg `xojceb`h jzokh ek xb` iozm`x+

Jo`h lk xb` goaxlz befbcefbx`h ojlw`# ex ``i xbox xb` ali~oku blpch xl~ ex aokhu jpek` hp` xl b`owu ali~`xexelk+ @oab lg xb` gew` glza` ``i xl bow` o xzlkf ekgcp`ka` xbox vecc ogg`ax xb` ali~oku ali~oku k`foxew`cu+ Xb` apzz`kx `kwezlki`kx `kwezlki`kx ei~cu ``i xl j` j` w`zu blxec` glz o k`v aokhu alka`~x+ Blv`w`z# ex ipx j` klx`h xbox xlf`xb`z vexb xb` ali~oku― lxb`z jpek`` lz w`kxpz`# ex iefbx j` lk xb` j`x ekx`z`x lg xb` ali~oku# eg ex hl` klx c`x fl lg ex aokhu jpek`+ Glz

`roi~c`# z`w`kp` gzli xb` lxb`z jpek`` iou j` p`h xl fzlv JGQ^A― aokhu jpek` `w`kxpoccu okh wea` w`zo+ Xl `roiek` pff`xelk xbe gpzxb`z# xb` fzlp~ h`aeh`h xl p` Xb` JAF Ioxzer xl okocut` xb` ~`zglzioka` lg xb` ali~oku― lxb`z jpek`` okh blv `oab iou ogg`ax `oab lxb`z+ Ek hlekf l# xb` floc e xl h`w`cl~ xzox`fe` xbox vecc j` ilx ~zlgexojc` glz xb` ali~oku+ A+ JAF Ioxzer

Ojlw` e ok eccpxzoxelk lg xb` JAF Ioxzer+ Pekf xbe ilh`c# v` oz` ojc` xl h`x`ziek` xb` xoz# aob alv# hlf okh qp`xelk iozm+ Xb`` oz` cex`h j`clv+ JAF QXOZQ "–BLCH’ % Qxoz oz` pkex vexb o befb iozm`x boz` ek o gox)fzlvekf ekhpxzu+ Xb` bl~` e xbox xoz j`ali` xb` k`rx aob alv+ Qpxoekekf xb` jpek` pkex― iozm`x c`oh`zbe~ iou z`qpez` `rxzo aob# jpx xbe e vlzxbvbec` eg xbox― vbox ex xom` glz xb` pkex xl z`ioek o c`oh`z+ Vb`k fzlvxb clv# xoz j`ali` aob alv eg xb`u bow` j``k ojc` xl ioekxoek xb`ez aox`flzu c`oh`zbe~# lz xb`u ilw` gzli jze`g xozhli xl hlfhli+ Xb` jpek`` j`clv oz` xb` JAF xoz4 ?+ Lgg`x Qlcpxelk 



Lgg`x Qlcpxelk aox`z xl xb` ~zekxekf k``h lg `w`zoc v`cc mklvk `xojcebi`kx pab o aozxlk glz lo~ okh ~o~`z jof glz aclxb` xlz` Eg ex apxli`z jo`# e+`+# v`cc v `cc mklvk `xojcebi`kx e m`~x# ex vec c alkxekp` xl bow` o befb iozm`x boz` ek o fzlvekf iozm`x

:+ Fzo~bea ' ^zekx Qlcpxelk 



O goiecu jpek` lg z`alkhexelkekf okh xzohekf `alkh)bokh lgg`x ~zekxekf `qpe~i`kx Xb`z` e o befb fzlvxb glz lgg`x ~zekxekf `qpe~i`kx iozm`x okh eka` xbe e o goiecu jpek` xbox bo j``k l~`zoxekf glz o clkf xei`# ex e opi`h xbox ex f`k`zox` z`w`kp`

JAF _P@QXELK IOZMQ "–JPECH’ % _p`xelk iozm "ocl mklvk o ~zljc`i abech% oz` fzlvekf zo~ehcu okh xbp alkpi` cozf` oilpkx lg aob# jpx j`aop` xb`u bow` clv iozm`x boz` xb`u hl klx f`k`zox` ipab aob+ Xb` z`pcx e o cozf` k`x aob alkpi~xelk+ O qp`xelk iozm bo xb` ~lx`kxeoc xl foek iozm`x boz` okh j`ali` o xoz# okh `w`kxpoccu o aob alv vb`k xb` iozm`x fzlvxb clv+ Eg xb` qp`xelk iozm hl` klx paa``h ek j`aliekf xb` iozm`x c`oh`z# xb`k ogx`z ~`zbo~ u`oz lg aob alkpi~xelk ex vecc h`f`k`zox` ekxl o hlf vb`k xb` iozm`x fzlvxb h`acek`+ _p`xelk iozm ipx j` okocut`h aoz`gpccu ek lzh`z xl h`x`ziek` vb`xb`z xb`u oz` vlzxb xb` ekw`xi`kx z`qpez`h xl fzlv iozm`x boz`+ Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` e o JAF qp`xelk iozm+ ?+ Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` 

Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` e ``kxeoccu o k`v ~zlhpax vbeab jpu`z bow` u`x xl healw`z+



Xbe ~zlhpax e ek fzlvekf iozm`x jpx bow` clv iozm`x boz`+



Xb` iozm`xekf xzox`fu e xl f`x iozm`x xl ohl~x xb`` ~zlhpax+





Ljwelpcu xb`z` e o befb h`iokh glz `k`zfu jllx`z ~zlhpax o `weh`ka`h ju ekaz`o` ek oc` lg `k`zfu hzekm pab o Z`h Jpcc okh Joaabp klx xl i`kxelk algg`` bl~ vbeab oz` ocilx `w`zuvb`z` ek xb` xz``x+ Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` k``h xl ekaz`o` ex iozm`x boz` qpeamcu# xbox e# abokf` ex iozm`xekf xzox`fu# lz ex j`ali` o hlf+

JAF AOQB ALVQ "–BOZW@QX’ % Aob alv oz` pkex vexb befb iozm`x boz` ek o clv)fzlvekf ekhpxzu+ Xb`` pkex xu~eaoccu f`k`zox` aob ek `ra` lg xb` oilpkx lg aob k``h`h xl ioekxoek xb` jpek`+ Xb`u oz` z`fozh`h o xoeh okh jlzekf# ek o –ioxpz`’ iozm`x# okh `w`zu alz~lzoxelk vlpch j` xbzecc`h xl lvk o ioku o ~lejc`+ Xb`u oz` xl j` –iecm`h’ alkxekplpcu vexb o cexxc` ekw`xi`kx o ~lejc`# eka` pab ekw`xi`kx vlpch j` vox`h ek ok ekhpxzu vexb c lv fzlvxb+ J`clv oz` xb` JAF aob alv+ ?+ Ea` Vox`z 

Ea` Vox`z f`k`zox` o clx lg aob gclv glz JGQ^A

:+ Alkpcxokau Q`zwea` 





Alkpcxokau Q`zwea` bo clv fzlvxb= ~zlilxelk okh ekw`xi`kx oz` clv+ Aob lpxgclv e iocc glz xbe  ~zlhpax eka` ex e Oc`r vbl e  ioekcu ekwlcw`h okh ~zld`ax oz` lk –o k``h`h’ joe lkcu+ Ilz`lw`z# Oc`r aok z`gp` xl hl xb` ~zld`ax eg b` xbekm ex vecc klx f`k`zox` aob

JAF HLFQ "–HEW@QX ’% ’% Hlf# lz ilz` abozexojcu aocc`h ~`x# oz` pkex vexb clv iozm`x boz` ek o ioxpz`# clv) fzlvekf ekhpxzu+ Xb`` pkex xu~eaoccu –jz`om `w`k’# f`k`zoxekf joz`cu `klpfb aob xl ioekxoek xb` jpek`― iozm`x boz`+ Xblpfb lvkekf o jz`om)`w`k pkex ~zlweh` xb` laeoc j`k`gex lg ~zlwehekf dlj okh ~lejc` uk`zfe` xbox oex lxb`z jpek` pkex# gzli ok oaalpkxekf ~lekx lg we`v pab o pkex e vlzxbc`# klx f`k`zoxekf aob glz xb` ali~oku+ Xb`u h`~z` o ~zlgexojc` ali~oku― z`xpzk lk o`x zoxel# p`h ju ioku ekw`xlz xl dphf` blv v`cc o ali~oku e j`ekf iokof`h+ Hlf# ex e xblpfbx# blpch j` lch lgg+ ?+ Jzefbx Cefbx,Eh`o Jzefbx Cefbx,Eh`o iou f`k`zox` `klpfb aob xl ioekxoek ex`cg# jpx ex hl` klx ~zlie` xl j` cozf` lpza` lg aob



Ali~oku― gpcc)xei` fzo~bea h`efk`z blpch glap ilz` lk Lgg`x Qlcpxelk vbeab bo o befb fzlvxb ~lx`kxeoc



W+

Z`alii`khoxelk

J`clv e o cex lg z`alii`kh`h oaxelk ek lzh`z glz JGQA^ xl ei~zlw` ~zlgex iozfek okh h`iokh glz xb`ez ~zlhpax+ F`k`zoc ?+ JGQA^ k``h xl j` xzpaxpz`h o ok Ekw`xi`kx Ekw`xi`kx A`kx`z+ O ok ekw`xi`kx a`kx`z# a`kx`z# Oc`r o xb` A@L vecc j` z`~lkejc` glz occlaoxekf ao~exoc xl `oab lg xb` jpek``+ Be floc vlpch j` xl ioreiet` ZLE okh o pab vlpch bow` xl j` w`zu aoz`gpc lk vb`z` okh lk blv blv ipab xl occlaox`,ekw`x ek `oab `oab pkex+ Be lpxcllm vlpch j` clkf) clkf) x`zi okh b` vlpch j` `kexew` o xl vbeab jpek`` blch ~zlie` glz xb` clkf x`zi# vbeab lk` f`k`zox` qpeam z`w`kp` okh vbeab lk` oz` pkh`z~`zglziekf "okh xb`z`glz` oz` ~zei` ~zei` aokhehox` glz z`)xzpaxpzekf lz `w`k hew`xexpz`%+ Lk xl~ lg j`ekf xb` A@L# Oc`r aok aok ocl opi` opi` xb` zlc` lg Z'H b`oh+ Xbe vou oku oku ~zl~ze`xozu ekglzioxelk z`cox`h xl xb` ~zlhpax lz ~zla`` aok j` og`fpozh`h+ :+ Lzfoket` jpek` pkex o ^zlgex A`kx`z vexb xzoek`h jpek` pkex allzhekoxlz oefk`h xl `oab lk`+ @oab JPA z`~lzx hez`axcu xl Oc`r+ O iodlz ~ozx lg xb` JPA& ali~`koxelk,eka`kxew` ~cok vecc j` xe`h xl xb` ~`zglzioka` lg xb`ez z`~`axew` jpek` pkex+ Xl `kpz` xbox xb` JPA vlpch xecc bow` xb` xb` j`x ekx`z`x lg JGQA^ JGQA^ ox b`ozx# o ~ozx lg xb`ez eka`kxew` ~cok vecc z`gc`ax xb` lw`zocc ~`zglzioka` lg JGQA^+ 1+ Ac`oz fpeh`cek` fpeh`cek` glz xzokg`z ~zeaekf+ ~zeaekf+ Glz `roi~c`# `roi~c`# ek ao` xb` xb` H`efk okh ^zekxekf fzlp~ oz` aocc`h lk xl ~zlweh` `zwea` glz xb` Gllh Fzlp~ jpek`` ek xb`ez iozm`xekf aoi~oefk# # xzokg`z ~zeaekf ~lceae` blpch j` xzpaxpz`h pab xbox ex ocl `kojc` xb` H`efk okh ^zekxekf fzlp~ xl j` ~zlgexojc` vbec` z`kh`zekf `zwea` xl ex ex`z pkex+

Jpek` ‑ Q~`aegea 8+ Iokof`i`kx alkxzlc alkxzlc lg jpech jpek`` jpek`` blpch blpch j` h`efk`h h`efk`h pab xbox iokof`z oz` `kalpzof`h xl glap lk xb` clkf x`zi+ Xbe vou xb`u bow` xb` c``vou xl oaxpoccu *jpech* xb` jpek` jpek` ju ekw`xekf glz xb` clkf)x`zi+ Iozm`xekf aoi~oefk# `~`aeoccu `~`aeoccu jzokh)jpechekf oz` f`k`zoccu clkf x`zi oaxewexe`+ 0+ Iokof`z blpch ioreiet` z`w`kp` okh okh iekeiet` alx lk bozw`x jpek`` jpek`` xl f`k`zox` ilz` aob xl p~~lzx xb` Jpech jpek``+

7+ Hew`x Jzefbx Cefbx vbeab e xb` xb` jpek` xbox aok j` glpkh ek xb` hlf qpohzokx+ ^zla``h gzli xb` hew`xexpz`# aok j` ekw`x`h lk xb` iozm`xekf oaxewexe` lg jpech jpek``# vbeab ek xbe ao`# e Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` @k`zfu Aokhu+

6+ Xb` iozm`xekf xzox`fu glz Fl/ Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i` aok j` abokf`h= abokf`h= ekx`oh lg ~lexelkekf ex ek xb` Aokhu Cek` okh joxxcekf cozf` aokhu iokpgoaxpz`z b`oh lk# ex aok j` ~lexelk`h o ok `k`zfu ~zlhpax+ Xl oabe`w` xbe# xb`u aok hegg`z`kxeox` ex gzli o aokhu ju abokfekf ex ~oamofekf+ Gzli ~ecclv ~oam xbox few` alkpi`z ok eiof` lg o –aokhu’ xl Qxz`~ec)cem` ~oamofekf vbeab few` ok ei~z`elk lg lgg`zekf li`xbekf ilz` xbok dpx o aokhu+ Xb`u aok ocl abokf` xb`ez hexzejpxelk xzox`fu ju pekf cozf` ~bozioae` okh fzla`zu xlz` o abokk`c ekx`oh lg Qoze)oze xlz`+ Ju abokfekf ex eiof`# xb`u aok ioekxoek o ali~`xexew` ~zea` ~lexelk glz Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i`+ ^zlhpax,L~`zoxelk ) Q~`aegea 2+ Ocl glz Fl/ Fl/ @rxz`i`# @rxz`i`# lk xl~ lg iozm`xekf# iozm`xekf# xb`u aok ocl ocl glap lk xb` ~zlhpax qpocexu# xox`# okh `ggeaoau lg `k`zfu jllx+ Xb` ali~oku aok xe` p~ vexb ekh`~`kh`kx z``ozab`z "alcc`feox`# lz ~zewox`% xl x`x ~zlhpax `k`zfu jllxekf ao~ojecexe`# xox` okh iouj` glzi "o d`ccu aokhu# o lgx aokhu# o fpi lz vbeab`w`z lxb`z glzi%+ Vb`k xb` ~zlhpax e z`ohu# alkxzoax ~zlhpaxelk okh z`cou hexzejpxelk xl `xojceb`h alii`zaeoc hexzejpxlz+ Xbe vou ao~exocetoxelk vlpch klx j` w`zu `rx`kew`+ O cexxc` vecc fl xl ~zlhpax h`w`cl~i`kx eka` xb` lvk`z ~zljojcu pkh`zxokh xb` ~zla`+ Ipab gekokaekf vecc fl xl xb` ekaz`o` ek ~zlhpaxelk#xbox vecc bo~~`k lkcu vb`k ao~ojc` pj)h`oc`z okh hexzejpxlz oz` ojc` xl aliiex xl oc`+ Ox c`ox ao~exocetoxelk glz pxoekekf z`a`ewojc` vecc j` c` lg o jpzh`k# o xbe vecc j` xb` ~ozxk`z hexzejpxlz `r~`k`+ Eh`occu# e xb` ~zlhpax e h``i`h iozm`xojc`# xb`u vlpch bow` xl gekoka` okh iozm`x occ ju xb`i`cw`+ J`aop` lg ceiexoxelk# xbe vlpch j` o pexojc` ocx`zkoxew` ox xb` `r~`k` lg clv`z iozfek+ 5+ Glz Ea` Vox`z# ex e pff`x`h glz glz xb`i xl f`x f`x alcc`axlz gzli ekh`~`kh`kx ekh`~`kh`kx of`kae`+ of`kae`+ Eg xb`u oz` ~ouekf clv`z xbok iekeipi vof`# xbe vecc j` ok ep` lg ekaz`o`h ~ouzlcc+ jex eg xb`u oz` ~ouekf alzz`axcu# xb`u aok ~pz~l`cu gez` okh z`~coa` xzlpjc`li` `i~clu``+ Ox xb` w`zu c`ox# xb`u blpch bow` xzpx`h alcc`axlz+ ?>+ Oklxb`z z`alii`khoxelk e xl xz`kfxb`k l~`zoxelkoc alkxzlc+ Ex ``i xbox ekw`kxlzu e klx xom`k aoz` lg w`zu v`cc+ Xbe e `weh`kx ek xb` oilpkx lg alkxoek`z xbox v`kx ieekf+ Xb`u aok abozf` xb` oc`,h`cew`zu ~`l~c` glz clx ex`i# ~zlweh`h xbox JGQ^A `kpz` xbox xb`ez ekw`kxlzu ux`i e `ggeae`kx+ Bowekf jpek` jpek` pkex allzhekoxlz xbox oz` hez`axcu z`~lkejc` glz xb` ~`zglzioka` lg `oab jpek` pkex aok ei~zlw` l~`zoxelkoc alkxzlc+