Atlanta Industries, Inc. v. Sebolino, G.R. No. 187320, June 26, 2001

 

Otiolto Jleustrjhs, Jleustrjhs, Jlm. v. ]habijlb, C.Q. Lb. ?73=1;, Nulh 14, 1;;?

Domts> Mbfpiojlolts djihe shvhroi mbfpiojlts dbr jiihcoi ejsfjssoi, rhcuiorjzotjbl, ulehrpoyfhlt, lbl poyfhlt bd wochs ole btghr fblhy miojfs, os whii os miojfs dbr fbroi ole hxhfpiory eofochs ole ottbrlhy‚s dhhs ocojlst tgh phtjtjblhrs Otiolto Jleustrjhs, Jlm. (Otiolto) ole jts [rhsjehlt ole Mgjhd Mgj hd Bphrotj Bphrotjlc lc Bddjmh Bddjmhrr Qbahrt Qbahrt Mgol. Mgol. Otiolt Otioltoo js o ebfhst ebfhstjm jm mbrpbr mbrpbrotj otjbl bl hlc hlcoche oche jl tgh foludomturh bd sthhi pjphs. Ughy oiihche tgot tghy goe ottojlhe rhcuior stotus os tghy whrh oiibwhe tb wbr` wjtg Otiolto dbr fbrh tgol sjx (4) fbltgs drbf tgh stort bd o purpbrthe opprhltjmhsgjp ocrhhfhlt ahtwhhl tghf ole tgh mbfpoly. Ughy miojfhe tgot tghy whrh jiihcoiiy ejsfjsshe wghl tgh opprhltjmhsgjp ocrhhfhlt hxpjrhe. Otiolto ole Mgol orcuhe tgot tgh wbr`hrs whrh lbt hltjtihe tb rhcuiorjzotjbl ole tb tghjr fblhy miojfss ahmoush tghy whrh hlcoche os opprhltjmhs miojf opprhltjmhs ulehr o cbvhrlfhlt-op cbvhrlfhlt-opprbvhe prbvhe opprhltjmhsgjp opprhltjmhsgjp  prbcrof. Ugh mbfpoly bddhrhe tb gjrh tghf os rhcuior hfpibyhhs jl tgh hvhlt vomolmjhs dbr  rhcuior pbsjtjbls bmmur jl tgh shmtjbl bd tgh piolt wghrh tghy goe trojlhe. Ughy oisb miojfhe tgot tghjr lofhs eje lbt opphor jl tgh ijst bd hfpibyhhs (Fosthr Ijst) prjbr tb tghjr hlcochfhlt os opprhltjmhs. Jssuh> Sghtghr Jssuh> Sghtghr br lbt tgh opprhltjmhsgj opprhltjmhsgjp p ocrhhfhlt ahtwhhl ahtwhhl Mbstoihs, Mbstoihs, Oifbjth, Oifbjth, ]habijlb ]habijlb ole ]ocul ole tgh phtjtjblhr wos voije. Ghie>  Lb. Ugh domts sgbw tgot Mbstoihs, Oifbjth, ]habijlb ]ha bijlb ole ]ocul whrh oirhoey rhlehrjlc shrvjmh tb tgh mbfpoly wghl tghy whrh foeh tb ulehrcb opprhltjmhsgjp rhlehrs tgh opprhltjmhsgjp ocrhhfhlts jrrhihvolt os dor os tgh dbur orh mblmhrlhe. Ugjs rhoijty js gjcgijcgthe ay tgh MO djlejlc tgot tgh rhspblehlts bmmupjhe pbsjtjbls sumg os fomgjlh bphrotbr, smoihfol ole hxtruehr  bphrotbr - tos`s tgot orh usuoiiy lhmhssory ole ehsjroaih jl Otiolto‚s usuoi ausjlhss br troeh os foludomturhr bd piostjm aujiejlc fothrjois. Ughsh tos`s ole tghjr loturh mgoromthrjzhe tgh dbur os rhcuio rhc uiorr hfpiby hfpibyhhs hhs ulehr ulehr Ortjmi Ortjmihh 17; bd tgh Ioabr Ioabr Mbe Mbeh. h. Ugus, Ugus, wgh wghl l tghy tghy whrh whrh ejsfjs ejsfjsshe she wjtgbut nust br outgbrjzhe moush, wjtgbut lbtjmh, ole wjtgbut tgh bppbrtuljty tb ah ghore, tghjr  ejsfjssoi wos jiihcoi ulehr tgh iow. Hvhl jd wh rhmbcljzh tgh mbfpoly‚s lhhe tb trojl jts hfpibyhhs tgrbucg opprhltjmhsgjp, wh mol bliy mblsjehr tgh djrst opprhltjmhsgjp ocrhhfhlt dbr tgh purpbsh. Sjtg tgh hxpjrotjbl bd tgh djrst oc ocrh rhhf hfhlt hlt ole tgh tgh rh rhth thlt ltjb jbl l bd tgh tgh hfpi hfpibyh byhhs hs,, Ot Otio iolt ltoo go goe, e, tb oi oiii jl jlth thlt ltss ol ole e purpb purpbsh shs, s, rhmbcljzhe tgh mbfpihtjbl bd tghjr trojljlc ole tghjr omqujsjtjbl bd o rhcuior hfpibyhh stotus. Ub dbjst upbl tghf tgh shmble opprhltjmhsgjp ocrhhfhlt dbr o shmble s`jii wgjmg wos lbt hvhl fhltjblhe jl tgh ocrhhfhlt jtshid, js o vjbiotjbl bd tgh Ioabr Mbeh‚s jfpihfhltjlc ruihs ole js ol omt foljdhstiy uldojr tb tgh hfpibyhhs, tb soy tgh ihost. Ugjs wh mollbt oiibw.

Oihm Fortl F. Oisjsb

Aibm` - O