Arroyo v Berwin

Ar r oyovBer wi n F:I gnac i oAr r oy oandAl f r edBer wi nar er es i dent sofI l oi l o. Ber wi ni sapr oc ur adorj udi c i al ( aper s ongr ant edper mi s s i ont oappearbef or et he c our t sr el at i ngonbehal fofc l i ent s ,et c .wi t houtbei ngal awy er )i nt hel awoffic eof At t y .J o hnBo r d ma ma n. Ber wi nr epr es ent edMar c el aJ uanez ai nt heJ us t i c eoft hePeac eofI l oi l oi n pr oc eedi ngf orat hef tc as efi l edbypl ai nt i ffI gnac i oAr r oy o.Mar c el aJ uanez al os t t henappeal edatt heCFIofI l oi l o. Ont heda yoft hehear i ngatt heCFI ,Ber wi nr equest edI gnaci oAr r oyot o a gr e et odi s mi mi s st hec r i mi na lpr oc ee di ngand  t her eaf t erst i pul at edi nt he pr esenceofRoqueSams msont hat   " 1 )hi scl i e nt ,Ma r c el awo woul dr e cogni z et he pl ai nt i ff' sowner shi pi nt hel andsi t uat eonCal l eSanJuan,Mol o,I l oi l o asi ns ugarc ane) wher eMa Mar cel aor dr edt hecane(   cut ,whi chl andandwhi ch t her mor e,t he yagr eed cutcanear er ef e r r edt oi nt hec ausef ort het hef t .Fur t hat" 2)t hepl a i nt i ffs houl dobt a i naT or r e nst i t l et os ai dl anda ndMa r c el a woul dnotoppos es uc ha ppl i c at i onf orr e gi s t r a t i on" . PROVI DEDTHAT Ar r oyowoul daskt hatt hecasebedi smi mi ssedagai nstMar cel a Ar r o y oc o mp mp l i e dwi t ht h ea gr e emen t .Th ec a s ea gai ns tMar c el awa sd i s mi mi s s e d. Ber wi ndi dnotwi s ht oc ompl ywi t ht hei ragr eement( Ar r o y odel i v er edt ohi mt he wr i t t enagr eementf orMar c el a' ss i gnat ur ebutBer wi nf ai l edt ogi v ehi m bac kt he s a me me ) . Ar r oy ofi l edf ors pec i fi cper f or manc epr a yi ngt hatj udgme mentber ender ed or de r i ngAr r oy ot oc aus ehi sc l i e ntMa r c el at os i gnt hewr i t t e na gr e eme nt . CFI -di s mi mi s s ed,t heconsi der at i onoft hecont r acti si l l egal . I :   WONBer WO wi nma maybeor der edt ocomp mpl ywi t ht heagr eeme ment ? H:NO.Anagr eementt os t i fl et hepr os ec ut i onoft heper s onc har gedwi t ht hef tf or av al uabl ec ons i der at i oni sma ma ni f e st l ycont r a r yt opubl i cpol i c ya nddue admi ni st r at i onofj ust i ce. Ar t .1255-Thec ont r ac t i ngpar t i esma ma yma mak et heagr eementandes t abl i s ht he

c l a us esan dc on di t i o nwh i c ht he yma yde em a dv i s a bl e ,pr ov i de dt he ya r enoti n cont r a ve nt i onofl a w,mor al sorpubl i cor de r . Ar t .1275-Cont r ac t swi t houtc ons i der at i onorwi t hani l l i ci tonehavenoeffect si ti sc ont r ar yt ol what soever .Ac ons i de r a t i oni l l i ci twheni awandgood mor a l s . Pet i t i ondeni ed.