Apostolsko Prejemstvo i Pravoslavna Teologija u Pravcu Sinteze Dve Perspektive ( III )

J06a1l

3u3jy Aae

I' II

II

(m)

II

(B) AKO cy XpHCTOC H IJpKBa yorIll1TeHo, TIHeBMaTOAOIIIKHycAOBA>eHH,cTpaxoBH KOjH6H MorAH rrpoHcTerm H3 rroHcTOBeneTha IJpKBe ca IJapcTBoM HecTajy. TaKBH cTpaxoBH, KojH cy y HeKoj MepH 6HAH H3a peaKijHje PecpopMaijHje rrpoTHB Cpe4ThOBeKOBHe IJpKBe, orrpaB4aHH cy je4HHO aKO je TO rrOHCTOBeneThe H3Be4eHO rrpOCTO H3 OHora IIITO CMO OB4e Ha3HBaAH HCTOpHjCKHM rrpHcTyrroM arroCTOAHOCTH (a IIITO je H3rAe4a 6HO rrpHcTyrr Cpe4ThOBeKOBHe IJpKBe). AAH y TIHeBMaTOAOIIIKOM YCAOBA>aBaThY HcTopHje EcxaToAorHjoM, ono rrOHCTOBeneThe He rrpe4CTaBA>aHHKaKBYrrperrpeKY. Pa3Aor je y TOMe IIITO ce OHO 4eIIIaBa eUU1CAeUiu"l{.KU.ErrHKAeTHqKH acrreKT rrpejeMcTBa rrpe4CTaBA>a OCHOBHYKapaKTepHCTHKY O KOjOjcaM OB4e rroKYIIIao 4a rOBopHM, H TheH YTHijaj Mopa 6HTH HCTaKHYT. Y je4HoM errHKAeKTHqKOM KOHTeKCTY, HcTopHja rrpecTaje 4a

I':

II

6Y4e caMoj ce6H jeMaij CHrypHOCTH.EUUKAe3a

"

II

1'1

II

" X "o :::

S

~ Ii" == ~ ~ Ii"

~ :::

~ Ii" eThaHe MOJKe 6HTH jeMcTBa Y ThHMa caMHMa 6e3 4yxa, Ma4a je OHO IIITO 4yx qHHH caMO rrOTBp4a HCTHHHTOCTHXpHCTOBHX peqH, 'Ono je Moje TeAO', Tj. rroTBpi)yje HCTOPHjy, TaKO H y CBOjOj arroCTOAHOCTH, IJpKBa rroTpe6yje 4a ce CijeHa TIe4eceTHHije 4eIIIaBa H3HOBa H H3HOBa, CBaKHrrYT Ka4a JKeAH 4a rrOTBp4H CBOjy arrOCTOAHOCT. ArrOCTOAH cy rrpHMHAH 4yx 04 BacKpcAor XpHCTa H KpIIITeHH cy y I-beMY Ha TIe4eceTHHijy, a rrOTOM, Ka4a cy 6HpaAH ce4MOpHijy,44 rrOHOBOcy ra rrpH3BaAH.45 A oHaj KO MHCAH Y TepMHHHMa HCTopHjcKor rrpejeMcTBa Mopa 036HA>HO 4a ce 3arrHTa: KaKBo 3HaqeThe HMa !IOHaBA>aThe!IpH3HBaTha 4yxa, aKO je HCTOpHjCKHnpHcTyrr arrOCTOACKOM npejeMCTBY jacaH H je4HocTaBaH 3a rrpHXBaTaThe? ErUIKAeKTHqKH JKHBOTIJpKBe noKa3yje caMO je4HY CTBap: 4a 3a ThYHe noCTojH CHrypHOCT HH y je4HoM HCTOpHjCKOM jeMCTBY Kao TaKBOM - 6HAO OHO Y CBell1TeHHqKoj CAYJK6H HAH peqH TajHe HAH qaK y caMOM HCTOpHjCKOM XpHCTY. I-beHa KOHCTaHTHa 3aBHCHOCT 04 4yxa rroKa3yje 4a je TheHa HcTopHja 6HAa CTaAHO ecxaTOAOIIIKa. Y HCTO BpeMe qHTheHHija 4a 4yx YKa3yje Ha XPHCTa rroKa3yje, TaKoi)e, 4a HCTOpHjy He Tpe6a rropHijaTH. '4yx 4HIIIe r4e OH xone',46 aAH MH 3HaMO 4a OH JKeAH 4a 4HIIIe Ka XpHCTy47 EcxaToAorHja H I1CTopHja, 4aKAe, He Mory 3aMeHHTH je4Ha 4pyry. (r) ErrHKAeKTHqKOYCAOBA>aBaThe IJpKBeHor CAe40BaTha ArrOCTOJ\HMa yrrynyje, 4aKAe, Ha MorynHocT CHHTe3e HCTO-

pHjcKe H ecxaTOAOIIIKe rrpe4CTaBe rrpejeMcTBa Ha HaqHH KOjH rrpeBa3HAa3H CBaKH 06AHK HeorrAaTOHCKor 4yaAH3Ma. By 4HMO CHrypHH 4a rrocTojH HarreTOCT H3Mei)y 'Ben' H 'He jOIII' Kao H y rroCTojaThY 'y 4yxy'. AAH OBa HarreTOCT HHje 4yaAHCTHqKa HH y je4HoM CMHCAY KOjH 6H Ha HeorrAaTOHCKHHaqHH rr04pa3YMeBao HeYCKAa4HBOCT H3Mei)y BpeMeHa H BeqHOCTH, HcTopHje H ecxaToAorHje. OBarrAOneThe Bora y XpHCTY qHHH MorynHM 4a ce rrpOTHB HeorrAaTOHCKor 4yaAH3Ma KaJKe 4a je HcTopHja CTBapHH HOCHJ\aij KOHaqHOr, rrpaBor JKHBOTay XpHCTY. I1CTopHja Kao rrocTojaThe y rrpOCTOpy H BpeMeHY HY4H y XpHCTY MorynHocT 3aje4HHije ca ecxaTOHOM. CTora HarreTOCT H3Mei)y HcTopHje H IJapCTBa HHje je4aH 04 OHTOAOIIIKHX4yaAH3aMa. To je, Ha HaqHH Ha KOjHMH MOJKeMOorrHcaTH, Kao JKY4Tha 3a upaMe1-/.0M06AUKa, 3a rrpe06paJKajeM. TIo peqHMa CE. TIaBAa, MH CMO JKeA>HH4a Ca4aIIIThH 06AHK 3aMeHHMO 3a ecxaTOAOIIIKH,48He 3aTO IIITO je Ca4aIIIThH MaThe CTBapaH HAH MaThe ecxaTOAOIIIKH y CBOjOjrrpHp04H - HCTOono TeAO Koje ca4a HMaMO ne 6HTH H BacKpcHYTO, rrpeMa TIaBAY - Ben 36or Tora IIITO rrpHCYCTBO H 4eAOBaThe AHTHxpHCTa y HCTOpHjH qHHH ,'la je Ca4alllThH 06AHK IJpKBeHor rrocTojaTha HecTa6HAaH H Y3pOK rraTThe.49 3a;wz IJapCTBa KOjH je rrpHCYCTBO4yxa50 y HCTOpHjH, TaqHO 03HaqaBa CHHTe3Y HCTOpHjcKor H ecxaTOAOIIIKor. Onaj 3aAoz 1-/.err04pa3YMeBa KaKO TO qeCTO rrpe4CTaBA>ajy HOB03aBeTHH TeOA03H - 04CYCTBOecxaTOAOIIIKor H3 HCTopHjcKor, Tj. y CYIIITHHH, Ha4y H OqeKHBaThe 06enaHe peqH. HarrpOTHB, OH 03HaqaBa CTBapHO rrpHcycTBO ecxaTOAOIIIKor y OCHOBHqHTheHHije ,'la je Bor rrpHCYTaH y HcTopHjCKOM H BaCKpCAOMXpHCTY. EKAHCHOAOIIIKO 3HaqeThe OBara MOJKe 6HTH HAYCTpOBaHO rrpe4CTaBaMa H3 KThHre ArrOKaAHrrCHca, y KOjOjIJpKBa JKHBH y je4Hoj HarAaIIIeHoj errHKAeKTHqKoj aTMoccpepH Ca4pJKaBajynH cnoj /Ina eAeMeHTa: C je4He CTpaHe, cHrypHOCTXpHCTOBor rrpHCYCTBa Ha eBxapHcTHjCKOM CTOJ\Y, H C 4pyre, Y3BHKIJpKBe: '40i)H, rOCI1O4e, 40i)H.'51 Ka4a IJpKBa JKHBHerrHKAeKTHqKH, OHa MOJKecaMO ,'la JKY4H 3a OHHMlllTO Ben jecTe. CHHTe3a HCTopHjcKor H ecxaTOAOIIIKor y OBOM errHKAeKTHqKOM YCAOBA>aBaThYHcTopHje qHHH OHO IIITO MOJKeMOrrpaBHAHO - a He y H3BPHYTOM CMHCA Y - Ha3BaTH C8eillofliaju1-/.CKOM rrpHp04oM IJpKBe. (4) Ono B04H pa3MaTpaThY rrpaKTHqHOr rrHTaTha: KaKo IJpKBa,y ciIl8apu, MOJKe,'la crrojH 4Ba rrpHcTyrra y je4HY ijeAHHY? 4a AH y IJpKBeHoM JKHBOTYrrocTojH Ha 6HAO KOjH HaqHH OCTBapeHa CHHTe3a HCTopHjcKor H ecxaTOAOIIIKor rrpHcTyrra? 113r Ae4a 4a paHa IJpKBa HY4H 04rOBOp Ha ono rrHTaThe yrrynHBaTheM Ha C8eUiy E8xapucUiujy. HeMa, 3aHCTa,

8

3

HHje4Hor 4pyror I1cKycTBa y [JpKBeHoM )KI1BOTYy KOMCI1HTe3a I1CTopl1jcKor ca ecxaTOAOIIIKI1M MO)Ke6HTH OCTBapeHa nOTnYHl1je Hero y EBxapl1cTl1jl1. EBxapl1cTHja je, C je4He CTpaHe, 'Tpa4HIJHja' (napa80ov;)52 H 'naMnelbe' (aVa/lVE-

ToKoM 4pyror BeKa 11yrAaBHoM K04 CE. Mpl1Heja 11y lberoBoj anoAorl1jl1 npOTI1B rHOCTI1IJI13Ma, anOCTOACKa nponOBe4, KaKO joj OH npl1cTyna y CBOM Epideixis-u, uogpa3YMesa HeKY spcUly o6jeKUlusU3a1juje y CMUCAY ucUlopujCKU UpeMelltl71eHe HopMe.63 TaKo oBaj HcTopHjCKI1 npHcTyn npeTI1 ,'la ne ,'la caBAa4a ecxaTOAOIIIKI1. OBa onac-

mc;) 53 Kao TaKBa, OHa pa3BHja I1CTOpl1jCKYCBeCT [JpKBe y npaBIJY npOIIIAOCTH. Y I1CTO BpeMe, CBaKaKO, EBxapl1cTl1ja je 11 ecxaTOAOIIIKH TpeHYTaK [JpKBe nap er,reAAeHIJe, cena1-bey 1japcUlsy u 1japcUlsa, Kao wUlo i7ioupegcUlasA:Ja C1jeHa ca6upa1-ba pacejaHoi csux

cUlpaHa

csel71a Ha jegHo

'MHOUITBO' y 'je4Ho'55 ca4a

H OB4e.56

H HY4etm

jHHCKI1',

[JpKBa

npoIIIAocT

HY He4e/bHBY

YKYC BeQHOr )KHBOTa 50)Kjer

yje4Hlbyje

H 6y 4ynHocT,

CTBapHOCT.

Y 11 Kp03

Tj.

CBe

I1CTopl1jcKe

je er3I1CTeHIJl1jaAHa Y CBeCTI1

HarAaUleHO

Kp03 ynoTpe6y

enl1KAe3e

11 QHTaBa aHaMHeTHQKa

CTaBJbeHH

PYKOB04CTBO

ca34aTH

y I1CTOpl1jl1.

OBa

[JpKBa

cxBaTa

Ha 11y npOUlAOCTH

4yxa,

40BOJbHY KopeHH

,CBeTOTa-

'Ben'

.ilOK

H 'He jOUI' OBa je 4aJbe

y EBxapl1cTHjH: 4HMeH3Hja

'peQH

[JpKBe

cy

Kao 4a y CaMI1Ma ce6H

nOTBp4Y

50)Kjer

npHCYCTBa

MOMeHTOM

Tpe6a

11y 6y 4ynHocTH,

4Be

Kao je4-

06AI1Ke,

[JpKBe

QHHH EBxapHcTHjy

4a lbeHH

4eIIIaBa

113MeJjy

OpaBOCAaBHe

ycTaHoB/belba' HHCY MorAH

y EBxapHcTHjH

OBO ce

u

y jegHoM

HCTOBpeMeHO,

11 MaTepl1jaAHe

HaneTOCT

OQYBaHa57

n04

Eo)Kjei ca

yje4Hlbyjytm

Y 11 Kp03 I1CTO HCKYCTBO, cTora,

UCUlOM MoMeHUly, 4HMeH3Hje,

Hapoga

MecUlo,54

y KOM

4a 6y 4y HCTOBpeMey HcTopHjH

H y ecxaTO-

HY.

Mcxo?! cn03HaBalba ORe je4HHcTBeHe YAore EBxapl1cTl1je y PaHoj [JpKBH je 6HO 4a ce 04 eBxapl1cTl1je CTBOpH IJeHTap H KOHTeKCTy KOMne ce 4eCHTH OCHOBHOKOHKpeTHa HCnOJbaBalbe anOCTOACKor npejeMcTBa.58 OBa IJeHTpaAHOCT EBxapHcTHje je OQYBaHa y AHTyprnjcKoj H KaHoHcKoj Tpa411IJHjH OpaBOCAaBHHx [JpKaBa, aAH ce npaBOCAaBHa TeoAorHja QeCTO HHje CAaraAa ca TI1M,IIITO je QHHI1AOCHHTe3Y H3MeJjy 'HCTopHjcKor' H 'ecxaTOAOIIIKor' np06AeMaTHQHOM. 2. Ca OBHM pa3MHllIJbalbHMa y rAaBH, ca4a MO)KeMO 4a pa3MoTpHMO HeKe KoHKpeTHe YTHIJaje OBHX CHHTe3a Ha )KI1BOTH YCTpojCTBO [JpKBe. O?!HOC [JpKBe npeMa AnOCTOM{Ma je Tpa411IJHOHaAHO n04pa3YMeBao CAe4ene OCHOBHe eAeMeHTe: (a)

OponOBe4HHQKa cxBaneHa

npl1pO,'la

Kp03

ecxaTOAOUIKI1M

OKBl1pI1Ma, aAI1

OBa 4Ba cxBaTalba

HY4H TeoAowKoj

CneKTI1BH npHMeHY TI1HYI1TeTa nponOBe4.

Ha

najMa

nepKOH-

anOCTOACKY

Y caMOM HoBOM 3a-

BeTY MO)KeMO Hanl1114ejy

para-

dosis UAU Aoma Koja je UCI710pUjCKU upeMewUlaHa C MecUla Ha MecUlo u U3 speMeHa y

speMe. A

anOCTOACKY

anOCTOACKe

11 y I1CTOpl1jCKI1M 11 Y

TeK CHHTe3a 'y 4yxy'

.

KOHUluHyuUleUl

KOHa"iHO, Ifyx

je

Ulaj KOjU O)KUSA:Jasape"iu60 11 caMO y 4 yxy nponOBe4albe Xpl1CTa MO)KeHMaTI1 cMHcAa.61 OoTpe6Ho je 4a anOCTOACKa nponOBe4 6Y4e CTaAHO CMeWTeHa y 4yxy 4a 6H 6HAa )KHBOT, a He caMO peQH. He MO)Ke nocTojaTH je4Ha 06jeKTHBH3Hpajyna HopMa y lboj caMOj, HeWTO UlTO npocyJjyje 3a-

YAore

npOnOBei\.59 MO)Ke 6HTH

je4HHIJY [JpKBe 0403ro HAI1CnOJba62 CaMO Y KOHTeKCTY3aKoja 06YXBaTa KOHKpeTHO cAe40Balbe [JpKBe, AnOCTOACKa nponOBe4 MO)Ke6HTI1 'HenpeKI14Ha' Ha )KI1BOTHI1Haql1H.

jegHU1je4yxa,

HOCTje, I1naK, npeBa3I1JjeHa y Mpl1HejeBoj TeOAOrl1jl1, y3 noMon 4Ba YQKa 4a je, 4a 6H ce ocTBapHAo

arrOCTOACKO rrpejeMcTBo,

pe4

KpllITeHHx

Y Be3H ca ArrOCTOAHMa

Ben H Kp03

AaHKa Heorrx04aH. He caMO Kp03 PYKO-

KpllITelbe.79

(II) I1MajynH ca4a me rrpHMe46e y BH4Y, MO%eMO 4a CXBaTHMO3HaQelbe Koje errHCKorrCKO arrOCTOACKO rrpejeMcTBo MO%e HMaTH 3a rrpaBOCAaBHY TeoAorHjy. Y cAYQajy KOjH CMO OB4e Ha3BaAH HCTOpHjCKHM rrpHcTyrroM rrpejeMCTBY, errHCKorr MO%e 6HTH H34BojeH H3 LJpKBe Kao rroje4HHaIJ KOjH rroce4yje rryHony arrOCTOAHOCTH,a KOjy rrOTOM rrpeHOCH 4pyrHMa Kp03 pYKorroAO%elbe. OTY 4a HeKO MO%e rOBOpHTH O '6HTHOM'

CBellITeHCTBY

H3

Kojer je H3Be4eH OCTaTaK CBellITeHCTBa. 3aHHMA>HBOje 4a je, Ka4a je rpyrra aHrAHKaHCKHx TeoAora 06jaBHAa TaKBe Te3e rrpe rrap r04HHa,80 H4eja Koja je HaljeHa Kao rrOrD4Ha 3a lbHXOBY rr04pllIKY (H3 HOBor 3aBeTa) 6HAa je H4eja arroCTOAHOCTH

4aTHH rrojaM. HeKO 6H Morao rrpeTrrOCTaBHTH 4a je Ha OBOMMeCTY CKpHBeH YTHIJaj HeorrAaTOHH3Ma Ha xpHllInaHCKY TeOAorHjr, MO%4a rrpHAHqHO paHO Y HCTOpHjH75 AAH HCTOpHjCKO rrHTalbe Hac ce OB4e He THqe 4HpeKTHO. Cnap KOjy %eAHM 4a HarAaCHM je cAe4ena: AKO je pYKorroAO%elbe 6Aar04aTHH QHH, OH4a ce Mopa caBpllIaBaTH Y je4HOMecxaTOAOllIKOM KoHTeKcTY. HHje 40BOA>HOpa3MHllIA>aTH o PYKorrO)\O%elbY Kao o HCTOpHjCKOMrrpeHOllIelbY arroCTOAHOCTH.PYKorrOAO%elbe Mopa TaKolje 6HTH rrOKpeT KOjH 40Aa3H 04 cTpaHe ecxaTOAOllIKe cBpllIeHocTH, 04 CBHX ca6paHHx, a He caMO 04 pacejaHor Hap04a Oo%jer. CTora 6H CBa PYKorroAaralba Tpe6aAO 4a ce BpllIe Y je4HoM errHKAeKTHQKOMKoHTeKCTY HAH, jOllI 60A>e, Y KoHTeKcTY 3aje4HHqe LJpKBe oKyrrA>eHe Ent TO aUTO, ca ArrOCTOAHMa, He Kao HH4HBH4yaAHHM 3aQeTHHIJHMa CBellITeHCTBa, Ben Kao rrpe4ce4aBajynHMa y 3aje4HHqH. YrrpaBO H3 OBor pa3Aora ce HHCY caMO CBa 6Aar04aTHa 4ellIaBalba y rrpHMHTHBHHM rraBAOBCKHMLJpKBaMa 04HrpaBaAa TOKOMeBxapHcTHjCKHx oKyrrA>alba,76 Ben ce, TaKolje, Kao llITO je HarOBellITeHO y 4ugaxujy77 H jacHo rrOKa3aHO y I1rroAHToBOM AuocUioACKOM upega1-bY 78, PYKorrOAaralbe Y CBellITeHHKa Y paHoj LJPKBH BpllIHAO Y HCTOMKOHTeKCTY.3HaQaj CMellITalba PYKorrOAO;Kelba Y eBxapHcTHjCKH KOHTeKCTAe;KH YTOMe llITO Ha oBaj HaQHH TaK03BaHH 'HHCTHTYIJHOHaAHH'He CaQHlbaBa caMo04peljeHH 06pa3aIJ. AKO je 3a PYKorrOAO%elbe Y CKAOflY ecxaTOAOllIKe 3aje4HHIJe CTaAHO rroTpe6Ho rrpH3HBalbe 4yxa, cAe4H 4a TO HHje YCTaHOBa Koja 03HaQaBa H onpe4Menyje KOHTHHYHTeT ca ArrocToAHMa. lfHlbeHHqa 4a CBaKO PYKonOAO%elbe Mopa 4a ce 4ecH Y OKBHPYeBxapHcTHjcKor KOHTeKCTa

rrpejeMcTBa

Kp03 QHH PYKorrOAO%elba.

rrOAO%elbe,

(~

arrOCTOACKor

LJpKBa je, cTora,

(I) I1HTalbe Koje OBa CTaBA>a Ha rrpBO MeCTO je MHoro yorrllITeHHje, Y3eBllIH y 063Hp rrOAO%aj KOjH6HAO KOiH 06AHK CBellITeHCTBa MO%e HMaTH y rrpaBHAHoj CHHe3H HcTopHjcKe H ecxaTOAOllIKe rrepcrreKTHBe KOHTHHYHTeTa. Haj036HA>HHjH rrp06AeM KOjH04CYCTBO TaKBe CHHTe3e cTBapa jecTe KOAHKOje yorrllITe 6HAO KOjH CBellITeHHK rroTpe6aH 3a arrOCTOACKO rrpejeMcTBo, Tj. KOAHKO,Y CTBapH, ecxaTOAOllIKH H HCTOpHjCKH acrreKT rrpejeMcTBa KOHaqHO HHCY HeYCKAa4HBH. 4HAeMa: 'HHCTHTYIJHOHaAHa' rrpOTHB 'xapH3MaTHqKe', Koja je TOAHKO pacrrpOCTpalbeHa 4aHac, jecTe }ICTHHCKH rrpOH3B04 He40CTaTKa je4He TaKBe CHHTe3e.

...

4a HCTOpHjCKO HAH HHCTHTYIJHOHaAHO 6HTH YCAOBA>eHO oKyrrA>eHOM OBa 3HaQH 4a cy ycTBapH

caYQeCHHIJH

cxeMa

HopMe

Mopa

3aje4HHqoM.

o KOjOj CMO ro-

arrOCTOACKor

HO noKa3yje Balbe

rrpejeMcTBa

HAH HcTopHjcKa

CTBa Kp03 YCTaHOBA>eHO CBellITeHCTBO. rrpe4CTaBA>a

Y HOBHM 06AHIJHMa Ka 6y 4ynHOCTH.

y TepMHHHMa sha-

liach-a. 060 gaAJe uogpJKa6a MOj apZYMeHUi ga MUCUOHapCKa cxeMa 60gU go UHgu6ugyaAu3al$uje AuocUioAaUia. Kao UtUio je A.Ehrhardt81 40Ka3HBao, rrojaM shaliach-a HHje 04 Ba%HOCTH3a CBPXYOCHHBalba errHCKorraAHor rrpejeMcTBa y paHoj LJPKBH. YMecTo lbera, OH CTaBA>aHa BH4eAO Te3Y 4a cy rrpBH errHCKorrCKH crrHCKOBH6HAH Ha4axHYTH crrHCKOBHMa jeBpejcKHx rrpBOCBellITeHHKa H orra%a 4a JeBceBHjeBH crrHCKOBHerrHCKorra He rrOQHlbY rroje4HHaQHHM anOCTOAHMa Ben] aK060M.82 AKO je OBa Te3a rrpHXBaT A>HBa,jacHo je YKa3HBalbe Ha TO 4a je OHO llITO CMOMH OB4e Ha3BaAH ecxaTOAOllIKHMM04eAOM JepycaAHMcKor LJpKBeHor YCTpojcTBa 6HAO rrpeCY4HO Y Y34H3albY errHCKorrCKor arrOCTOACKor rrpejeMcTBa. MO%eMO, 3aTHM, 4a orrHllIeMO errHCKorrCKO rrpejeMcTBo Kao KOHTHHYHTeTLJpKBe He ca je4HHM noje4HHaQHHMArrOCTOAOMBen ca arrOCTOACKHMKoAerHjYMOM Kao IJeAHHOM83 H Kao 3aje4HHqoM LJpKBe y lbeHOM ecxaTOAOllIKOMOKBHpy.84 Ca4a, aKO rrope4 aprYMeHTa A.Ehrhardta Y3HMeMO y 063Hp H 4pyre 40Ka3e paHe LJpKBe, MO%eMO OBe Te3e 06jacHHTH jOllI n04p06HHje. YrrpKOC HejacHonaMa Koje OKpy%yjy H3Bope H paHH pa3Boj errHCKorrCKe CAY;K6e, QHHH ce 4a je Moryne pacrr03Hani 4Ba HaQHHa 3a pa3YMeBalbe errHCKorrCKe YAore y TO BpeMe. C je4He CTpaHe, OH je 6HO CXBaneH Kao 'ca-CBellITeHHKa', Tj. Kao je4aH - BepOBaTHO rrpBH - y 3aje4HHIJH CBellITeHHKa.85 C 4pyre CTpaHe,Halbera ce rAe4aAOKao Ha CAHKYJaKOBa 6paTa focrr04lber,86 Tj. Kao Ha CAHKYXPHCTa - H4eja Koja rrocTojH K04 I1rlbaTHja H y 4PYrHM 40KYMeHTHMa Tor BpeMeHa.87 Kao rrpHp04Ha rrocAe4Hqa OBara

S 5

jaBJba ce 4BocTpYKa cAHKa c KOjOMce IIPBH IIYT jacHo cycpeneMO K04 11IIoAHTa: eIIHcKOII Kao gpYIU XpuCilloc u gpylU auocl71oA. KOpHCHO je 3aYCTaBHTH ce 3a TpeHYTaK Ha 11IIOAHTOBOM CBe40'faHCTBY, jer je OHO, IIO MOMMHIIIJbelbY, IIpBO Koje HY4H CHHTe3Y IIpe4CTaBa eIIHCKOIIaTa Koje caM MaAO'faC nOMeHYO. OBa HIIOAHTOBCKa CHHTe3a 406Hja HapO'fHTY Ba)!(HOCT3a HaIIIY TeMY, jer H3rAe4a 4a je a4eKBaTHa CHHTe3H HCTopHjcKe H ecxaTOAOIIIKe nepcneKTHBe anOCTOACKor IIpejeMcTBa. Pa3MaTpalbe IIorAe4a Ha enHCKonCTBO Koje Ca4p)!(H AIIOCTOACKOnpe4albe, B04H 40 CAe4enHx npHMe46H: (a) EnHcKon je HcToBpeMeHo CAHKa XpHcTa H CAHKa AnOCTOAa.88 OBa KoM6HHagHja 4Be CAHKeje npecy 4Ha 3a HCTOpHjy KoHgenTa anOCTOACKor npejeMcTBa y OKBHpHMa CHHTe3e HCTopHjcKe H ecxaTOAOIIIKe nepcneKTHBe. (6) flpe3BHTepHjYM je cxBaneH Kao 3ajegHU1j,a H y Be3H je ca YAoraMa caBeTOBalba H ynpaBe89 OBa 3Ha'fH 4a je XpHCTOAOIIIKa CAHKa OCTaBJbeHa 3a enHCKona, KOjH caM, Kao XpHCTOC MO)!(egaillu UOcaene1-be9° 40K ra CBeIIITeHHgH OKpy)!(yjy H npaTe y TOM '4aBalby.'91 OBa 3Ha'fH 4a je anOCTOACKO npejeMcTBo OCTBapeHO Kp03 enHCKona, He Kao IIoje4HHga, Ben OHor KojH je oKpy)!(eH 360pOM CBeIIITeHHKa. OBa je Ha'fHH O'fYBalba paBHOTe)!(e H3Mel)y alter Christus H alter apostolus CAHKaenHCKonCTBa. (B) WTa BHIIIe, CBe ORe npeTIIOCTaBKe ca6palba 'fHTaBe 3aje4HHge ETClTO aUTO npHAHKOM 06aBJbalba CBaKe CPYHKgHje enHCKOIICTBa (Hnp.pYKOnO;\O)!(elbe) y Be3H cy ca np04y)!(elbeM anOCTOACKe cAy)!(6e.92 To Mopa 6HTH KOHTeKCTCHHTe3e H3Mel)y HcTopHje H ecxaToAorHje n04 YCAOBOMEBxapHcTHje. 113 OBor pa3Aora EBxapHcTHja je Heonx04aH OKBHppYKonOAO)!(elba. 3aK;LY'faK KOjH npOH3HAa3H H3 11noAHToBe CHHTe3e Tpe6a n04BynH H HapO'fHTO HarAaCHTH. AUOCI710ACKO upejeJ1.tcillao "KpO3 euuc"Koucillao je CYWillUHCKU upejeJ1.tCI71ao 1j,p"KaeHOI ycillpojcillaa. KOHKpeTHe nocAe4Hge OBara cyjacHe: 4p)!(enH ce enHCKonCKor npejeMcTBa, IJpKBa He H34Baja eIIHCKOIICTBO04 OCTaAHX gpKBeHHX pe40Ba (YKJbY'fyjynH H AaHKe) aAH ra, HanpOTHB, 'fHHH aIICOAYTHO 3aBHCHHM 04 lbHX, Kao IIITO cy H OHH Y nOTnYHOCTH 3aBHCHH 04 lbera. 114eja npejeMcTBa Koja PYIIIH ORYMel)paBHcHOCT pe40Ba je Aa)!(Ha, jer y 04CYCTBY nOTIIYHor YCTpojCTBa 3aje4HHge ecxaTOAOIIIKe IIeCIIeKTHBe, Tj. ca6palba pacejaHor Hap04a 50)!(jer, OHa HecTaje y nOTnYHOCTH. MH CMOOH4a OCTaBJbeHH 6e3 jacHor HCTopHjCKor IIpHcTyna npejeMCTBY, npaneHH npe4CTaBaMa CBeToTajHHcTBa, 3aKOHCKHM uoz71ecl71ac H CBHM np06AeMHMa Koje OHH IIOBAa'fe 3a C060M. Y nYHoj CHHTe3H HcTopHjcKe H ecxaTOAOIIIKe nepcneKTHBe, eIIHCKOIICKOIIpejeMcTBo nocTaje HeoIIx04HO caMO 3aTO IIITO Kp03 lbera IIOCTaje jacHo 4a geAa 3aje4HHga IJpKBe OTeAOTBopyje aIIOCTOACKOIIpejeMcTBo. To 4a je eIIHCKOII CXBaneH Kao 4eo CTpYKType 3aje4HHge, a He Kao IIoje4HHag, BH4H ce Kp03 TO IIITO cy lberOBa ynpaBa H Mon BAaCTH AHTyprHjcKH H KaHOHCKHYCAOBJbeHe CBe 40 4aHac, 6apeM Ha 11CTOKY.flpeMa ToMe, (a) HHje4aH eIIHCKOII He MO)!(e 6HTH pYKonOAO)!(eH 6e3 06panalba lberoI

6

BOj 3aje4HHgH y Hapo'tuilloj J1.toAuillau PY"KOUOAO)f(e1-ba.93 To ce npHMelbyje H 4aHac 'faK H y nocBenelbY THTYAapHHX enHcKoIIa94 OBa je HapO'fHTO 3Ha'fajHo 3a 11CTOK KOjH HHKa4 HHje CXBaTHO Mon jypHC4HKgHje, 6y 4ynH He3aBHCTaH 04 MOAHTBenocBenelba.95 (6) OBa je II04BY'feHO 3Ha'fajHoM KaHOHCKOM04pe460M Koja CBe 40 4aHac npe)!(HBJbaBa Ha 11CTOKY,npeM4a 6e3 CBeCTH o lbeHOM 3Ha'IelbY, HaHMe 4a je4HHo eIIHCKOIIHKOjHcy IIorAaBapH IIocTojenHx 3aje4HHga Mory Y'IeCTBOBaTH Ha ca60py. 113 OBara je jacHo 4a UCI71uHC"Ka 6Aalogaill enHCKona HHje noje4HHa'IHa HMOBHHa IIpeHeTa Kp03 PYKOIIOAO)!(elbe, Ben je IIOBe3aHa ca

Y enHCKOIICKOMIIpejeMCTBY, 4aKAe, HMaMOCYIIITHHCKOIIpejeMcTBo 3aje4HHga. CBe OBa HaM noMa)!(e 4a 04rOBopHMO Ha HCTOpHjCKOIIHTalbe Koje 06HAyje ca4p)!(ajeM Ba)!(HHM3a eKAHCHoAorHjy: 3aIIITO je IJpKBa H3a6paAa enHCKOIIa Kao cpe4CTBO anOCTO;\CKOr npejeMcTBa? 3aIIITO He nocToje, Hnp. cnHCKOBH CBeIIITeHH'fKOr HacAel)HBalba? AKO je 6pHra IJpKBe HcTopHjCKH 6HAa 4a npeHece aIIOCTOACKO Y'Ielbe, npHp04Ha cTBap 6H 6HAa BHl)elbe OBor IIpeHoca Kp03 cBeIIITeHHKe, YIIpaBo KojHMa je, y CTBapVI, 6HO IIoBepeH 3a4aTaK noY'faBalba Y BepH y TO BpeMe97 3aHCTa, CBaKH 06AHK HCTopHjcKor IIpeHoIIIelba aIIOCTOACKHXCAy;K6H 6H 'IHTaBOM 3aje4HHgoM96

Tpe6ao 4a 6y 4e ocTBapeH Kp03 /!pyre cAy)!(6e BaH enHCKOIICKe98 Je4HHO Ka4 je anOCTOACKO npejeMcTBo CXHaneHO Kao KOHTHHYHTeTycillpojcillaa H Kao IIpejeMcTBo 3ajegHU1j,a, enHCKonCKH KapaKTep anOCTOACKor npejeMcTHa 406Hja CBOjy je4HHcTBeHOCT. AAH eAeMeHTH 'YCTpojcTBa' H '3aje4HHge' ce IIojaBJbyjy caMO oH4a Ka4a ecxaTOAOIIIKa IIepIIeCKTHBa, Kao IIITO CMO je OB4e onHcaAH, YTH'fe Ha HaIIIe CXBaTaIDe aIIOCTO;\CKOr IIpejeMcTBa Ha IIpecy 4aH Ha'IHH. (III) AKO 40 Ba)!(HOCTHeIIHCKOIICKor IIpejeMcTBa 40l)eMo npeKO H4eje KOHTHHYHTeTaYCITlpojci7iaa, MO)!(eMO 3ana3HTH tla ce enHCKOIIY TpatlHIIHOHaAHO 404eJLyje YAora je4HHor PYKOIIOAO)!(eHor." EIIHCKOII je, 360r CHor MeCTa y YCTpOjCTBY 3aje4HHge, HapO'IHTO y lbeHOM eBxapHcTHjCKOM 06AHKY, HeKO Kp03 Kora Mopajy IIponH CBa 6Aar04aTHa HCnOJbaBalba IJpKBe, TaKo 4a OHH Mory 6HTH HCIIOJbaBalba, He HH4HBH4yaAH3Ma, Ben 3aje4HHge 4yxa H 3aje4HHge KOjy OH CTBapa. 113BaHpe4He (Kao IIITO HX 4aHac 30BY) '6Aar04aTHe' cAy)!(6e HMajy cBoje MeCTO y IJPKBH H Mopajy 6HTH nOk CTaKHYTe. AAH caMO OH4a Ka4a cy 4eo YCTpojcTBa 3aje4HHge, OHe HHCYy OIIaCHOCTH4a IIOCTaHY BpCTa HH4HBH4yaAHCTH'IKHX HcnOJbaBalba npOTHB KOjHX ce CE. flaBAe TaKo )!(YCTPO 60pHO Y KOPHHTY. CBe ORe H3BaHpe4He cAy)!(6e, npeMa ToMe, nocTajy caCTaBHH 4eAOBH aIIOCTOACKor IIpejeMcTBa y CHHTe3H KOjy OB4e H3Aa)!(eM, caMO aKo H4Y Kp03 enHCKOIIa, y KOMce 'fHTaBO YCTpojCTBO 36AH)!(aBa H 'MHorH' IIocTajy 'je4Ho' y noje4HHa'IHoj er3HCTeHgHjaAHoj cpe4HHH.

~" .. :=

§ ~ ~ :o!"

(IV)

Ca4a

MO)!(eMO pa3MOTpHTH

IIHTalbe

04Hoca

IJpKBe npeMa aIIOCTOAHMa Ha je4HoM 4pyroM HHBOY, IIIHpeM 04 HHBoa AOKaAHe 3aje4HHge. Je4Ha 04 IIpHp04HHX nocAe4Hga HcTopHjcKor IIpHcTyna anOCTOACKOM IIpejeMCTBY jecTe TO 4a Kp03 lbera OCHUaa1-be 1j,p"Kaaa 406Hja

~

~ :=' ~

~ o -. I ~ "' N o

~

>./

"

...

x."

=

s~

I: I

.

~ := ~ ;.: ~ :s: = ~ ~ ()

'-~ N Q

HapO'-lHTH 3Ha'-laj. OBa, Kao WTO CMOnpHMeTHAH, '-IHHHcacTaBHH ,'leo TeopHje KOHTHHYHTeTa KOjy je pa3pal)eHa Y I KAUMeH171oaoj u y ae3U je ca ugejoM Utupe1-ba u upeHOUte1-ba auocz7loAClce upouoaegu. 113 OBol UpUpOgHO cAegu aa)f(Hocz7l ~J»== ;;? ~ :>-

~ ::: ;;? :>Q II II II

VI I (J)

'N

'Lapostolicite

au lie siecle,' u Verbum

Cara 58 (1961)

68 ITp06AeMM Koje je y paHoj LJPKBMCTBOpMAaynoTpe6a M3pa3a Aoroc y 3Ha'leI-bY 'pe'lM' 3a XpMcTa noKa3yjy KOAMKOMO;Ke6MTM onaCHa npMMeHa najMa 'pe'lM' Kao M3rOBopeHe MAMnMcaHe Ha XPMCTOAOmjy. Y CAe4 peaKl]Mje npOTMB CaBeAMjaHM3MaM ApMjaHM3Ma, O'lM cy 6MAM npMMopaHM /la nOpMQy 6MAO KaKBYBe3Y M3Mel)y oBa 4Ba 3Ha'leIba Aoroca, M CTora cy KOHa'lHO cy 3Ha'leae M3rOBopeHe MAM HarlMCaHe pe'lM 3aMeHMAM3Ha'le~beM AM'lHOCTM,MCK,bY'lMBO. BM4eTM Eusebius, Dem. Evang. 5:5 M HapO'lMTO Atanasija Contra Ar. 2:35 M KMpMAa AAeKcaH4pMjcKOr, De feeta fide ad Theod. 6. CMpMjCKMCMMBOA (351) 'laK npOKAMae OHe KOjMAoroca 50;Kjer Ha3MBajy 'eH4MaTxeToc' MAM'npocj:>opMKOC'. 69 I1HTepecaHTHo je YO'lMTMKaKOcy ce XpMCTOAO!lIKMcnopOBM paHe LJpKBe 04pa3MAM Ha EBxapMcTMjy. BM4eTM H. Chadwick, 'Euch-

arist and Christology in the Nestorian Controversy,' u Journal of Theological Studies 2 (1951) 145--64. 70 Y npaBocAaBHoj AMTypmjM OBa je Ha3Ha'leHO 'lMaeHMl)OM 4a cy 'lMTaaa M3 5M6AMje 6MAa CMe!lITeHa y 40KCOAO!lIKM KOHTeKCT TpMcBjaTor Koje je neBaHO lipe aMx. OBa jacHo nOKY!lIaBa 4a noKa;Ke 4a pe'l 50;Kja HMje 40Aa3MAa y LJpKBY GaMa M3 npO!lIAOCTM Kao K~bMra MAMYTBpl)eHM KaHOH, Ben yrAaBHoM M3 eCXaTOAO!lIKe CTBapHOCTMLJapCTBa, 04 npeCTOAa 50;Kjer KOjMy TOM TpeHYTKY AMTyprMje 3aY3MMaEnMCKon. 113 OBor pa3Aora ce 'lMTa~be Tpa4Ml]MOHaAHOHe 'lMTa 4M4aKTM'lKM, Ben neBa. (HeKM npaBOCAaBHM CBe!lITeHMl)M4aHac, O'lMrAe4HO He YBMl)ajynMDEO,He neBajy 'lMTaaa M3]eBaHl)eA.>a, Ben MX 'lMTajy Kao np03Y y HaMepM 4a MX y'lMHe pa3YMA.>MBMjMM, a TMMeM noY'lHMjMM!) 71 E. Schlink, Der kommende Christus und die kirchliche TraditioDen 0961) je ypa4Mo 3Ha'lajHY KpMmKY 40KCOAO!lIKe npMp04e y'le~ba. CynpoTHoCT M3Mel)y 'nponOBe4HM'lKe' M 'CAaBOCAOBHe' BpCTe TeOAO!lIKMXMCKa3a,Koja ce HaAa3M y OBOjKaM3M, Ta'lHO YKa3yje Ha HeonX04HOCT CMHTe3e 'MCTopMjcKor' M 'eCXaTOAO!lIKOr' npMcTyna anOCTOACKOMnpejeMCTBY. 72]Y4a 3 73 BM4M M3Ha4 Han. 17 M 18. 74 Irinej, Haer. III, 3:1--4; IV, 26:2; Kao M Tertulijan, Praescr. 32 i Ipolit, Philos. I, praem. 75 Ono je, Ha npMMep, npMMeTHO y OpMrHOBOM pa3AMKOBaIbYnOCTOjene CTBapHOCTMMaeHor 3Ha'le~ba, IlITO BOtlMtlO cynpoTHoCTM M3Mel)y 6Aar04aTM M CBe!lITeHCTBa - a 'lMjecy nocAe4Ml)e npMCYTHe Ben y OpMreHoBoj MMCAM,Kao IlITO noKa3yjy IberOBa BMl)eIb anocTOACKor npejeMcTBa. BM4M Han. 35. 76 BM4M I Kop 14. 77 4M4axM 15 (o pYKonoAo;Keay) je nOBe3aH ca 14 (o He4eA.>HojEBxaPMcTMjM)peQMMa 'npeMa ToMe' 78 I1noAMT, AnocT. Tpa4.2 79 B.--D. Dupuy, Te

HOCMAal]

op. cit. CTp. 348: 'BepHM Hap04 y CBOjOjl)eAMHMjecBe3e

CBe!lITeHCTBa

y

anOCTOACKOM

npejeMCTBY.'

06M'lHO ce 3a60paBA.>a 4a je KpllITeI-be cBojeBpcHo pYKonOAO;KeI-be jer ca4p;KM 4Ba aerOBa eAeMeHTa: (a) nOAaral-be PYKYca npM3MBaaeM 4yxa ('lMja je nOTBp4a He04BojMBa 04 Kp!lITe~ba), M(6) y'lAaaeae y noce6aH lJpKBeHMpe4 (TarMa MAMTaKCMCHa rp'lKOM). KacHMje- !lITO je 06M'lHO npeBMl)aHo nO/l YTMI)ajeM TepTYAMjaHa M n03HMjMXAaTMHCKMXnMcalJa- BM4MMOHa npMMep, I MMMeHToBY 40:3--41 r4e ce TarMa npMMe~byje MHa AaMKe.I1oTnYHMja pacnpaBa ce HaAa3My MOM'Same Reflections on Baptism, Confirmation and Eucharist,' u Sobornost 5 (1969) 644--52. 80 K. E. Kirk (ed.), The Apostolic Ministry: Essays on the History and the Doctrine of Episcopacy (1946, second edit. 1957). 81 A. Ehrhardt, The Apostolic Succession in the First Two Centuries of the Church (1953). 82 Ibid, CTp 35-61. 83 F. Dvornik, The Idea of Apostolicity in Byzantinum and the Legend of St. Andrew (1958) str 39f. Y. Congar, L'Eglise une, sain-

te, catholique et apostolique

(Mysterium Salutis 15, 1970), CTp. ,

196. N. Afanassieff, ynpKoc CBOjOjeBxapMcTMjcKOj eKAMcMoAomjM, nOTl]eayje He4e/bMBOCT anOCTOACKor 360pa y npejeMcTBY M 4aje Ba;KHOCT CTaBY KOjMje HecarAaCMB ca ecxaTOAOIllKOM CAMKOM LJpKBe y KOjOj'EnMCKonM M3BMPyM3 cBoje LJpKBe, CAe46eHMIjM cy je4Hor, a He anOCTOAa yonIllTe' U 'Reflexions d'un Ortodoxe sur la collegialite des eveques,' Le Messager Ortodoxe (1965) 7-15. 84 113Bp!lIel-be CBaKor enMCKonCKor pYKonOAO;Keaa y OKBMpMMa40ral)aja I1e4eceTHMlJe (Han. 45) n04pa3YMeBa nocTojaI-be ecxaTOAO!lIKe 3aje4HMl]e OB4e M ca"la ca 4BaHaeCTOpMl)OM Ha CBOM'leAf. 4eAa 1-2 r4e je 40ral)aj I1e4eceTHMIJe y Be3M ca 06a OBa eAeMeHTa (2:17: eCXaTOAO!lIKM40raljaj; 1:13--23: He4eA.>MBa3aje4HMlJa 4BaHaeCTOpMlJe) M KOHa'lHOca EBxapMcTMjoM (2:42). 85 YnoTpe6a M3pa3a CBe!lITeHI1I)M3a enMCKona K04 I1pMHeja (Xaep. IV, 26:2) jacHo YKa3yje Ha DEO.To 6M Tpe6aAo cxBaTMTMKao onpTaHaK je4Hor CTapor 06M'laja Ha 3ana4Y, KaKOce To MO;Ke3aKA.>Y'lMTM Ha OCHOBY

I MMMeHTOBe44, I I1eTp 5:1 MT4.

86 Ono je cAY'laj y paHMMAMCTaMaenMCKona, Hnp. y KaHOHYEusebiusa-Jeroma. BM4em A. Expxap4T, on. l)MT. CTp. 35cj:>cj:>. 87 BM4eTM rore Han. 21. Ha'lMH Ha KOjMja TYMa'lMMM KAaCMcj:>MKyjeM MCTopMjcKe M3Bope o ecxaToAoIllKoj CAMl]MnpejeMcTBa 06yxBaTa cAe4eny cxeMY: 'JaKOB ca CBe!lITeHMl]MMa'(4eAa) 'XpMCTOC ca CBe!lITeHMl]MMa' (AnOKaAMnca) . 'EnMCKon (CAMKaXpMCTa) ca CBe!lITeHMlJMMa'(I1nbaTMje, 4M4acKaAMja, Y CTaHOBe MT4) = 'EnMCKon Kao HaCAe4HMK]aKOBa' (JeBceBMje-]epOHMMOBa AMCTaHaCAe4HMKa).OQMTO je 4a onaj 'lAaHaK HMje MeCTO3a 4eTaA.>HMjenpMKa3M-

.

8

9

lJafbe OBara (OBOhe ce nojaBf1Tf1 y je4Hoj Hape4Hoj ny6J\f1KaIJf1jf1). OB/je je ,]OBO,bHO nOKa3aTf1 ,]a je ecxaTOJ\OWKf1 M04eJ\ ]epycaJ\MMCKel.JpKBe npeHeT Ha eBxapMcTMjCKY CTpYKTYPYCBaKe J\OKaJ\He l.JpKBe M 4a je Ha aera 6MTHOYTMIJaJ\aM4eja anOCTOJ\CKor npejeMcTBa. Hecpeha je TO WTO je KJ\aCMqHMnajaM anOCTOJ\CKor npejeMCTBa CTBOpeH 6e3 Y3MMaaa OBOl'pa3Boja Y 063Mp. 88 I1noJ\MT, AnOCT. Tpa4. 3 (MoJ\MTBa3a nocBeheae enMcKona) 89 Ibid. 8 (MoJ\f1TBa 3a nocBeheae cBewTeHMKa) 90 Ono je I1nOJ\MTOIJaprYMeHT 3a noJ\araae PYKY CBeWTeHMKaHa KaH4M4aTa 3a nocBeheae Y CBeWTeHf1qKMpe4: 'Presbyter enim solius habet potestatem ut accipiat, clare autem non habet potestatem. Quapropter clerum non ordinal; super presbyteri vera ordinatione consignat episcopo ordinate' (ibid. 9; tekst u B. Botte, Hippolyte de Rome, La Tradition Apostolique (=Sources chretiennes 11, 1946), CTp. 40). 91 BM4eTM np06J\eM CBeWTeHMqKOr 6J\arOCJ\OBa Y EBxapMcTMjM Y MCTOMTeKCTY M Y Bottovom TYMa'lel~Y (ibid, CTp. 30), KOjOjN. Afanasieff (Tpne3a focn04aa, 1952, CTp. 3) npM!'OBapa n03MBajyhM ce Ha I1nOJ\f1TOB aprYMeHT HaBe4eH Y npeTx04Hoj HanOMeHf1. 92 Ha OBa je YKa3aHO 04pe460M AnOCTOJ\CKor npe4aaa 4a PYKOnOJ\OJKeae Tpe6a 06aBJbaTM TOKOMeBXapMCTf1jcKor 360pa. Hnp. Y3Bf1K'axios' Y npaBocJ\aBHMM cJ\YJK6aMa nocBeheaa. Kao je4aH paHf1 f13BOpone npaKce nf14eTM I KJ\MM.45:3. 9304 f13nOpa BM4eTf1'L'eveque d'apres les prieres d'ordination' par que!ques chanones de Mondaye, u L'Episcopat et L'Eglise universelle (rope, Han. 2I), CTp. 739--780. 3a6paHa PYKOI1oJ\OJKeaa in absoluto (KaHoH 15 I Hf1KejcKor ca60pa; KaHOH6. XaJ\KM,]OHCKor MT4. je Y Be3f1caMor npMHIJMna. 94 nocTojaIi>e TMTYJ\apHMX enMCKona y npaBOCJ\aBHf1M l.JpKBaMa ynyhyje Ha 036H/bHY HenpaBl1J\HocT. AKO je em1CKon nocBeneH 3a 04pe!jeHY 3aje4HMIJY, OH Mopa 6MTM cJ\0604aH 4a noTnYHo ynpaJKfbaBa CBOjyCJ\YJK6yY TOj 3aje4Hf1IJH. CaMO aKOje 04BojeH 04 cBoje naCTBe 3601' f1CTopMjCKf1X OKOJ\HOCTM, MOJKe6MTHYBaJKaBaH Kao KaHOHCKHenMCKon ynpKoc CBOM04CYCTBYM33aje4HMIJe. AJ\f1 pYKonOJ\araae enf1CKOna ca IJM/beM4a OHM6y 4y enMCKonM ca 3aBMCHOMnJ\awny (noMohHMIJM enMCKona HT4J jecTe Hana4 Ha OCHOBHeeKJ\MCMOJ\OWKenpMHIJMne n04 YTMIJajeMJ\aJKHe npe4CTaBe CBeToTajMHcTBa f1npeHoweaa enMCKonCTBa 04 je4Hor noje4HHya 40 4py!'Or. V. problem episcopi vagantes. Videti Y. Congar, L'Eglise une... str. 205f.: 'Ce que la succession apostolique n'est pas'

H OIllTpa

Liturgy,' 18cjJ 95 Bf14eTf1

aJ\H npaBe4Ha

u Concilium npeTX04HO

npHMe46a

C. Voge!a 'An Alienated

voI. 2, br. 8 (Feb. 1972) y Han.

11--25,

HapOqMTO

110.

96 Bf14f1 3Ha'lajaH pa4 V. Fuchsa, Der Ordinationstite! von seiner Entstehung bis aut Innozenc III (1930) passim, HapO'lMTO CTp. 61cjJcjJ. 97 CBe40qaHCTBO je 60!'aTO, npeM4a qeCTO 3aHeMapf1BaHO 04 cTpaHe MCTOpf1Qapa.Npr. ]ermin pastir 3 :4, Tertulian, De Praes. 2; Origen, In Ezekie!2:2 H I1nOJ\MTOBOAnOCT. npe4. 8 (peKoHcTpYf1caD ra je G. Dix, The Treatise on the Apostolic Tradition of Saint Hippolytus of Rome (1937) CTp. 13). Ono je 4aJbe noTBp!jeHo nocTojaaeM CBeWTeHMKa n03HaTHX Kao YQMTeJbH (KJ\HMeHT AJ\eKcaH4pMjcKH, OpMreH MT4J. O 4aJbMM40Ka3f1Ma f1 n04p06HMjoj 4MCKYCMjM BH4eTH y MOjOjKaf13f1 The Unity... str. 160f. CBe OBa noKa3yje ,]a je l.JPKBa npBf1X BeKOBaHf1je CXBaTaJ\a anOCTOJ\CKOnpejeMcTBo Kao npejMcTBo YQelba. OHa je, 3anpaBO, npe3HpaJ\a H4ejy 4a 6f1l.JpKBa MorJ\a 6f1Tf1nojM/beHa Kao 'IllKOJ\a'. V. Ipolita, Phil os. 9:12:21. 98 3awTo He 6f1, Ha npf1Mep, npM3HaJ\f1 npejeMcTBo 6J\ar04aTM MT47 OBa nMTaIi>e ce nOCTaBJba HapO'lMTO 4aHac. 105 BM4em Han. 103 106 Ono TaKo!je n04pa3YMeBa BMcaH

M 4MpeKTHO

04rOBopaH

npMHIJMn 4a je CBaKMenMCKon He3anpe4

50f'OM

3a CBOjy

3aje4HMYY.

O

onOMe KMnpHjaH, En. 55 (52}21. 3a pacnpaBY o nOCJ\e4MIJaMa OBOl' npMHIJMna BM4eTH E. Lanne, Pluralisme et Unite' y I1cTMHa 140969) 178cjJ. 107 Kao WTO je TO YQMHHOHnp. N. Afanasieff, 'La doctrine de la primaute a la lumiere de la ecclesilogie,' y I1cTMHa 2 (1957) 401420. 108 Ep. 3:3 (Hane!, 471): 'apostolus, id est episcopus.' 109 '1.f1HMMMce 4a je ono 04CY4HM TpeHYTaK y HCTOpHjMKoHlJenT anOCTOJ\CKor npejeMcTBa H enHCKonCTBa yonulTe. npe4J\aJKeM 4a pa3MaTpafba OBliK KOHLJenaTa nOQHeMOynpaBo 04 OBOl'MeCTa.

110 YnpaBo y noCBeneli>Y CBaKor enHCKOlla HaJ\a3e ce KOpeHf1 CMHOi!aJ\He f1HCTHTYYf1je.KaKo je CBaKH enf1CKon (ca 3aje4Hf1IJOM) MMao npaBo 4a y'IecTByje y ca60pCKMM aKTMBHOCTMMal.JpKBe, nocpe4CTBOM CBor nocBeheI~a. npaKca Koja je npeOBJ\a4aJ\a y y HeKMMnpaBOCJ\aBHMM l.JpKBaMa y 4aHawae BpeMe, jecTe 4a aMMa ynpaBJbajy 'pe40BHH ca60pM' 3aCHOBaHMHa H360py noje4HHMx enHCKona, 40K cy 4pyrM MCKJbYQeHM, npe4CTaBJba 4MpeKTHaH Hana4 Ha oBaj BaJKaHeKJ\MCMOJ\OWKMnpMHIJMn. l11l1noJ\f1T, Anoc. npe4. 2; Ca60p y ApJ\Y, K. 20; I HMKejcKMK. 4 f16 MT4. 3a noTnYHo pa3MaTpaae f13BOpa BM4eTf1L. Mortari, Consacrazione episcopale e Collegialita. La testimonianza della Chiesa antica (1969). 112 J. Meyendorff, Ortodoxie et Chatolicite (1965), CTp. 147, H 4pyrf1 npaBOCAaBHf1TeO,\03H, TeJKe 4a 4ajy llpe4HOCT ellHCKoncKOMMeCTYy l.beroBoj J\OKaJ\Hoj l.JPKBe f14a 04 aera cTBope OCHOBY enMCKonaJ\He KOJ\erf1jaJ\HOCTMHa IllHpeM HHBOY.MHCJ\HM (ja oBaj npMcTyn, npeM,1a IJf1,ba M HarJ\aIllaBa npaBf1J\HY CTBap 4a 6M enf1CKOn Tpe6ao 4a 6y 4e y 04HOCY ca noje4MHoM l.JPKBOM,nOMaJKe oncTajaae

J\aJKHe He(joYMMLJe 'J\OKaJ\Ha

nponm

ca60pHe'

-

He40YMf1IJe Koja je npeBa3f1!jeHa HapO'lMTOMnpf1p040M EBXapf1CTMje (B. MOj'La communaute eucharistique...' Han. 55). CaMO Kp03 MCTOBpeMeHOCTone 4Ba 4MMeH3f1je - f1CTOBpeMeHOCT Koja je cBojCTBeHa caMOM enf1CKonCKOMnocBeneay - MOJKeMO 40nM 40 jacHe nepCneKTMBe. B. Hape4HY HanOMeHY. 113 Y pf1MOKaToJ\f1QKOj TeoJ\orHjM je QeCTO nocTojaJ\a TeH4eHIJHja (ja ce 4a npBeHCTBO enHcKoncKoj npf1na.1HOCTf1 ca60pHoj 3aje4Hf1lJH y 04HOCY Ha fbef'OBYnpf1na4HOCT noje4HHaQHoj J\OKa,\Hoj l.JPKIJH. O onOM, Hnp, paHHje f1A. Grea, L'eglise et sa divine constitution (1884, 1965) i CKOpf1jeE. Schillebeeckhx, L'Eglise du Christ et I'homme d'aujourd'hui se!on Vatican II (1965), CTp. 99ff.; J. CoIson, Les fonctions ecclesiales (1956), CTp. 341; K. Rahner, 'De I'episcopat' u Eglises chretiennes et Episcopat (1966), CTp. 209 f1T4, H. De Lubac, Les eglises particulieres daus I'Eglise universelle (1971), CTp. 82, rJ\e4ajy Ha nHTaIbe Kao OTBOpeHO. Y CBaKOMcJ\YQajy, 4pyrf1 pHMOKaTOJ\HQKHTeOJ\03H HHCHcTMpajy Ha TOMe 4a je CHHTe3a OBOl' 4Bora 046aLJMJ\a M npeMeCTf1J\a npec]HOCT ca60pHe 3aje4HMIJe Ha4 J\OKaJ\HOMl.JPKBOM.O onOM, H. M. Legrand, 'Nature de I'Eglise particuliere et role de 1 'eveque daus I'Eglise,' u La Charge pastoral des eveques... Decret 'Christus Dominus' (1969) CTp. 118cjJ. MHapO'lf1TO Y. Congar, Ministeres.., CTp. 123--140. HenoTpe6Ho je rOBOpMTf1KOJ\f1KOje OBa nMTal.be

BaJKHO 3a npaBOCJ\aB,be.

E. Lanne, 'To What Extent is

Roman Primacy unacceptable to the Eastern Church?' y Concilium 4/7 (ApriI1971) 62--67, HapOQf1TOCTp. 66. 114 OCHOBHf1He,10CTaTaK je, no MOMrv!f1IlI,beIi>YTO IlITO je XPf1CTOJ\OIllKa 4HCKYCMja O enf1CKOnCTBY 01!'IbaTMje, I1nOJ\f1T HT4J f1WQe3J\a, M3aMelbeHa je anOCTOJ\CKOM3aje4HMLJOMy KOjOj,YCTBapf1, Xpf1CTOC HMjenpMCYTaH. Ono He caMO 4a YHMIlITaBa Bf1!jelbe l.JpKBe Kao CJ\MKel.JapcTBa - Bf1!jeae O(j CYWTf1HCKOr3HaQaja f13a EBxapMcTMjy f13a ecxaTOJ\orMjy- Ben B04M Ka TpaJKeH,y 'vicarius Christi'

BaH f1J\f1 H3Ha4 anOCTOJ\CKe

-

M anf1CKonCKe

- 3aje4HHIJe.

O np06J\eMf1Ma Koje je OBa CTBOpf1J\Oy cpe4aeBeKoBHoj

eKJ\f1Cf10-

Y. Congar, Ministeres...,CTp.112cjJ. 115 J. - J. von Allmen, 'L'EgliseIDealeparmi les autresEglises locaJ\ornjf1,

BM(jeTM

les,' y I1peHf1KOH 43 0970) 512--37. )KeJ\eo 6f1X HapOQMTO(ja HarJ\aCMM li>erOBOMHUJ;beli>e(CTp. 529cjJ) t1a ce XpMCToBe peQH fleTpy, Y3HMajynf1y 063Mp fbHXOBnoje4f1HaQHf13a(jaTaK y l.JPKBM,

HaAa3eKO(jAYKe -

H MOJK,]a

y ocTaJ\MM]eBaH!je,bMMa - y KOHTeK-

CTYT ajHe Be'lepe. Onaj CTaBHMa (jOCTa YTMIJajaHa CTaB/balbe fleTpOBor 3a(jaTKa y nepcneKTMBY CJ\HQHYje(jHoj M3 caBpeMeHMX CTY(jHja, a MOJK(jaraQMHMM KOHaQHOnpMXBaTJbMBMM3aOHe KOjM n04pJKaBajy M eBXapf1CTf1jCKMM MCTOpMjCKHnpMCTyn l.JpKBeHoM KOHTf1HYf1TeTY. AJ\M ono 3aXTeBa 4a,bY pa3pa4Y. 116 npMHYMn CYUlfi1uHcKe jegHaKocfi1u C6UX eUUCKoua- M J\OKaAHMX l.JpKaBa - nOTMQe ynpaBo H3 ecxaTOJ\OIlIKe CJ\MKe anocTOJ\CKe 3aje4Hf1LJe Kao He(jeJbMBe LJeJ\MHe, Koja je y nOTnYHOCTM cxBaheHa M M3paJKeHa Kp03 CBaKor enHCKona y cBaKoj l.JPKBM. OTy 4a BaJKHOCTOBOl' npMHIJHna y PaHoj l.JPKBM(Hnp. Kf1npMjaH, Han. 106) MY npaBOCJ\aBHOMKaHOHCKOM npaBY. Ono He 6f1 Tpe6aJ\O Hf1Y je4HoM McTopMjCKOMcJ\YQajy 3aKJ\OHMTHynyhMBalbeM Ha cynpoTHO. O OBOMnpMHIJMny y KOHTeKCTYII BaTMKaHa Bf14eTf1 H. - M. Legrand, op.cit. CTp. 122, r(je je HanpaBJbeHa pa3J\MKa M3Me!jy eKJ\MCHOJ\OIllKor onpaB(jaBaaa 'ocHoBHe je,]HaKOCTM Me!jy CBMMnOMeCHHMl.JpKBaMa' M 'CTBapHe xMjepapxMje' y MMe '(j06pe 3aje(jHMye.' O

~ ~ :::

S

~ .. =: >i ~ ..

~ ::: >i ..() 'f

q; "-

N o Z

10 I