42. Cabales vs. CA

FIRST DIVISION

NELSON CABALES and

G.R. No. 162421

RITO CABALES, Petitioners,  

Present:

PUNO, C.J., Chairperso n,   GUTIERREZ,

SANDOVAL-

- verss -

CORONA, AZCUNA, an! GARCIA, JJ.  JJ.

COURT OF APPEALS,  APPEALS,   JESUS FELIANO and

Pro"#$ate!:

ANUNCIACION FELIANO, Respon!ents%

A$st &', ())*

+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

DECISION PUNO, C.J.:

 This is a petition or revie on .ertiorari see/in$ the reversa# o the !e.ision[1 o the Cort o Appea#s !ate! O.to0er (*, ())&, in CA-G%R% CV No% 12&'3 entit#e! “Nelson Cabales and Rito Cabales v. Jesus Feliano and Anunciacion Feliano,”  hi.h a4r"e! ith "o!i5.ation the !e.ision[2 o the Re$iona# Tria# Cort o 6aasin, Sothern Le7te, 8ran.h (9, !ate! A$st '', ())), in Civi# Case No% R-(2*2% The reso#tion o the Cort o  Appea#s !ate! e0rar7 (&, ());, hi.h !enie! petitioners< "otion or re.onsi!eration, is #i/eise herein assai#e!%

 The a.ts as on! 07 the tria# .ort an! the appe##ate .ort are e## esta0#ishe!%

R5no Ca0a#es !ie! on =#7 ;, '311 an! #et a 9,*';-s>are "eter par.e# o #an! #o.ate! in 8r$7% Ri?a#, So$o!, Sothern Le7te, .overe! 07 Ta+ De.#aration No% '*(*) to his srvivin$ ie Satrnina an! .hi#!ren 8onia.io, A#0ino, ran.is.o, Leonora, A#0erto an! petitioner Rito%

On =#7 (1, '3*', 0rothers an! .o-oners 8onia.io, A#0ino an! A#0erto so#! the s[email protected] propert7 to Dr% Ca7etano Corro"pi!o or P(,)))%)), ith ri$ht to repr.hase ithin ei$ht 2B 7ears% The three &B si0#in$s !ivi!e! the pro.ee!s o the sa#e a"on$ the"se#ves, ea.h $ettin$ a share o P111%11%

The o##oin$ "onth or on A$st '2, '3*', A#0erto se.re! a note va#eB ro" Dr% Corro"pi!o in the a"ont o P&))%))%

In '3*(, A#0erto !ie! #eavin$ his ie an! son, petitioner Ne#son%

On De.e"0er '2, '3*9, ithin the ei$ht-7ear re!e"ption perio!, 8onia.io an! A#0ino ten!ere! their pa7"ent o P111%11 ea.h to Dr% Corro"pi!o% 8t Dr% Corro"pi!o on#7 re#ease! the !o."ent o sa#e ith pacto de retro ater Satrnina pai! or the share

o

her

!e.ease! son,

A#0erto,

in.#!in$ his

va#e

o P&))%))%

On even !ate, Satrnina an! her or ;B .hi#!ren 8onia.io, A#0ino, ran.is.o an! Leonora so#! the s[email protected] par.e# o #an! to respon!ents-sposes

=ess

an!

Ann.ia.ion

e#iano

or P2,)))%))% The Dee! o Sa#e provi!e! in its #ast para$raph, ths:

It is here07 !e.#are! an! n!erstoo! that the a"ont o TO  TFOUSAND TO FUNDRED EIGFT SIH PESOS P(,(21%))B .orrespon!in$ an! 0e#on$in$ to the Feirs o A#0erto Ca0a#es an! to Rito Ca0a#es ho are sti## "inors pon the e+e.tion o this instr"ent are he#! in trst 07 the VENDEE an! to 0e pai! an! !e#ivere! on#7 to the" pon rea.hin$ the a$e o ('%

On De.e"0er '*, '329, the Re$ister o Dee!s o Sothern Le7te isse! Ori$ina# Certi5.ate o Tit#e No% '*)&9 over the pr.hase! #an! in the na"es o respon!ents-sposes%

On De.e"0er &), '329, Satrnina an! her or ;B .hi#!ren e+e.te! an a4!avit to the ee.t that petitioner Ne#son o#! on#7 re.eive the a"ont o P'*1%&; ro" respon!ents-sposes hen he rea.hes the a$e o (' .onsi!erin$ that Satrnina pai! Dr% Corro"pi!o P311%11 or the o0#i$ation o petitioner Ne#son