125 CR - PC Citations, Judgements PDF

 

8

^crfhd eumocr

8. 

Dfst jb Auilmcets je 8?3 Nr.[.N

NJS_Y 1 Ihtci 9 Bco ?;;3 ?;;3  MSMOHF GFLG NJS_Y

[hlc Eumocr

?-9

Mhfetcehenc ejt lrhetci hs ft fs prjvci tght wfbc whets tj rcsfic scphrhtcdy.  

?. 

MSMOHF GFLG N NJS_Y JS_Y 1 Ihtci Hpr ?;;7. ?;;7. 

3-<

Mhfetcehenc ejt lrhetci hs ft fs prjvci ej rchsje tj dchvc gusoheis.  

>. 

MSMOHF GFLG NJS_Y1 Ihtci ?? Bcoruhry, ?;;7 

7-8;

[craury fe 8?3 nr[n 

9. 

MHLF^Y_HYC, EC\ ICDGF  ICDGF NJS_Y 1 MCY_J[JDFYHE MHLF^Y_HYC,

88-8>

Rcxhtfjus pctftfje, mhfetcehenc, rcdfcb fs icndfeci 

3. 

SYYH_HENGHD GFLG NJS_Y 1 Ihtci?3 Jntjocr ?;8;  

89

Ej Mhfetcehenc u/s8?3Nrpn bjr wjr`fel \jmce  

2. 

SYYH_HENGHD GFLG NJS_Y 1 Ihtci 87Ejvcmocr,?;;6 

83-82

Ej Mhfetcehenc u/s Nrpn 8?3 fb wfbc icscrts gusohei  

?->9

8>. 

^N Auilmcet, Ej mhfetcehenc tj wfbc fb sgc bhfdci tj prjvc hddclhtfjes.

>3-97

89. 

^N Auilmcet , Ej mhfetcehenc tj wfbc Fetcrfm jr Bfehd fb sgc dfcs. , ?;;6

96

83. 

^N Auilmcet \fbc fs ejt cetftdci tj mhfetcehenc wgj ghs icscrtci gcr gusohei,  , Mhrng ?;;;.  

3;-3>

82. 

^N Auilmcet , \fbc must prjvc tght sgc fs uehodc tj mhfethfe gcrscdb fe hiiftfje tj tgc bhnt tght gcr gusohei ghs subbfnfcet mches tj mhfethfe m hfethfe gcr hei tght gc ghs ecldcntci tj mhfethfe gcr., Jnt ?;89

39-32

 

?

MSMOHF GFLG NJS_Y NJS_Y 1 Ihtci 9 Bco ?;;3 ?;;3  Mhfetcehenc ejt lrhetci hs ft fs prjvci tght wfbc whets tj rcsfic scphrhtcdy.  

Mrs. Mcceh Ifecsg [hrmhr vs ^grf Ifecsg Ghstfmhd [hrmhr je 9/?/?;;3 ASILMCEY _.^. Mjgftc, A. 8. Ygfs hppchd ghs occe bfdci oy tgc hppcddhet Mrs. Mcceh Ifecsg [hrmhr (gcrcfehbtcr rcbcrrci tj hs "wfbc") hlhfest tgc rcspjeicet Ifecsg Ghstfmhd [hrmhr (gcrcfehbtcr rcbcrrci tj hs "gusohei") scc`fel tj quhsg hei sct hsfic tgc Auilmcet hei jricr phssci oy tgc Auilc, Bhmfdy Njurt, [uec je ?2.?.?;;8 Fe [ctftfje Ej. H∟>39 jb ?;;; hei [ctftfje Ej. C/78;/8667. [ctftfje Ej. H/>39/?;;; H/ >39/?;;; fs h pctftfje bfdci oy tgc gusohei bjr lrhet jb ifvjrnc je tgc lrjuei jb nrucdty hei icscrtfje ueicr ^cntfje 8>(8)(fh) hei (fo) jb tgc Gfeiu Mhrrfhlc Hnt, 8633. Ygc [ctftfje Ej. C∟78;/8667 whs bfdci oy tgc wfbc ndhfmfel mhfetcehenc ueicr ^cntfje 8?3 jb tgc Njic jb Nrfmfehd [rjnciurc, 86. Oy tgc fmpuleci Auilmcet hei jricr tgc Auilc, Bhmfdy Njurt lrhetci ifssjdutfje jb mhrrfhlc oy icnrcc jb ifvjrnc je ojtg tgc lrjueis hei lrhetci _s. 3;;/∟ pcr mjetg hs mhfetcehenc tj h sje Ogusghe wgj whs ojre jut jb tgc mhrrfhlc, wgfdc rcacntfel tgc ndhfm jb tgc wfbc bjr lrhet jb mhfetcehenc. ?. Ygc nhsc jb tgc gusohei hs mhic jut fe gfs pctftfje bfdci fe tgc Bhmfdy Njurt whs hs ueicr1 h) Yght, ojtg tgc phrtfcs ocdjelfel tj Gfeiu njmmuefty ghi cetcrci fetj he hrrhelci mhrrfhlc je ?9.?.8663. Ygc mhrrfhlc whs pcrbjrmci hs pcr tgc Gfeiu Rcifn rftcs. Ht tgc tfmc jb mhrrfhlc tgc gusohei whs h ohngcdjr hei tgc wfbc whs h spfestcr. o) Hbtcr tgc mhrrfhlc tgc ecwdy wciici njupdc sthrtci rcsfifel fe h bhmfdy rcsficenc jb tgc gusohei ht Ogheiup. H bcw ihys hbtcr tgc mhrrfhlc tgc wfbc sthrtci pfn`fel up quhrrcds wftg tgc gusohei hei jtgcr bhmfdy mcmocrs je trfbdc mhttcrs. ^gc sthrtci fesfstfel bjr scphrhtc hnnjmmjihtfje. Hnnjrifel tj tgc gusohei cvce ocbjrc tgc mhrrfhlc, gc ghi hs`ci gfs wfbc hs tj wgctgcr sgc whs rchiy tj sthy fe h ajfet bhmfdy hei sgc ghi hlrcci tj ij sj. Ygc gusohei rcmfeici gcr jb tgfs njescet lfvce oy gcr out tgc wfbc njetfeuci tj fesfst tght tgcy sgjudi mjvc tj h scphrhtc hnnjmmjihtfje. Ygc gusohei mjvc tj h scphrhtc hnnjmmjihtfje. Ygc gusohei trfci tj pcrsuhic gcr ejt tj oc hihmhet out tgc wfbc rcspjeicet oy iceyfel gfm pgysfnhd njethnt, tgus, nhusfel gfm mcethd hei pgysfnhd tjrturc. Ygc gusohei burtgcr bjuei tght gfs wfbc whs ejt nhrryfel jut gjuscgjdi iutfcs. ^gc usci tj sft fe h njrecr fe tgc rjjm hei whs ejt gcdpfel jtgcr bhmfdy mcmocrs fe nhrryfel jut jtgcr gjuscgjdi iutfcs. n) Yght tgc phrcets jb tgc wfbc usci tj rcsfic ht Vjlfth Oufdifel, Ihudht Ehlhr, Ojrfvhdf (C). Ygc wfbc usci tj brcqucet gcr phrcets gjusc. ^gc ghi h mhtcrehd uendc sthyfel ht [uec. Ygfs mhtcrehd uendc whs h ifvjrncc hei tgc pctftfjecr‖s wfbc usci tj vfsft gcr mhtcrehd mhtcrehd uendc hdsj. Ygc gusohei whs rcqufrci tj lj hei schrng bjr gcr hei gc usci tj bfei gcr ht gcr phrcets‖ gjmc. i) Yght, je 83.3.8662, tgc gusohei scet gfs wfbc tj gcr phrcets‖ gjusc ht Ojrfvhdf bjr icdfvcry hs sgc whs tgce scvce mjetgs prclehet. Gjwcvcr, tj tgc ifsmhy jb tgc gusohei hei gfs bhmfdy, gfs wfbc wcet tj tgc gjusc jb gcr mhtcrehd uendc ht [uec bjr icdfvcry festchi jb sthyfel ht gcr phrcets gjusc ht Ojrfvhdf. ^gc wcet tj tgc gjusc jb gcr mhtcrehd uendc wftgjut febjrmfel tgc gusohei. Fespftc jb sung hntfje oy gfs wfbc, upje mhstcr Ogusghe ocfel ojre ht [uec, tgc gusohei hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs ghi ljec tj scc tgc ecwdy ojre ohoy ht [uec. Ht [uec, tgc gusohei hs`ci tgc wfbc tj rcture wftg gfm tj tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjmc ht Ogheiup out tgc wfbc rcbusci tj ij sj. Gcr mhtcrehd uendc Ohoudhd Igj`c hdsj rcbusci tj scei gcr tj Mumohf hdjelwftg tgc gusohei. Xuhrrcd tjj` pdhnc octwcce tgc wfbc hei gcr mhtcrehd uendc je jec ghei hei tgc gusohei hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs je tgc jtgcr hei tgc wfbc ndchrdy tjdi gcr gusohei tght sgc wfdd ecvcr rcture tj gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc hei sgc wfdd dfvc wftg gcr mhtcrehd uendc ht [uec. ^gc hdsj tjdi tgc gusohei tght sgc whetci h ifvjrnc brjm gfm. Feifhe @hejje ∟ gttp1//feifhe`hejje.jrl/ijn/89;8??;// c) ^fenc tgc gusohei bjuei tght gfs wfbc whs njmpdctcdy hihmhet gttp1//feifhe`hejje.jrl/ijn/89;8??; hojut ghvfel h scphrhtc hnnjmmjihtfje, fe tgc mjetg jb Hprfd, 866 tj 9 jnnhsfjes mhtcrehd uendc cvce hsshudtci tgc gusohei hei trfci tj irfvc gfm jut jb tgc gjusc. b) Je tgc jnnhsfje jb tgc bfrst ofrtg ihy jb tgc ngfdi,mhstcr Ogusghe, gusohei ghi ljec tj [uec wftg sjmc swccts, ndjtgcs hei prcscets. Gjwcvcr, tgc wfbc hei gcr mhtcrehd uendc rcbusci tj hnncpt tgc prcscets hei tgrcw tgc shmc tjwhris tgc gusohei. Gusohei tgce tgce njddcntci tgc shmc hei `cpt tgcm fe h njrecr jb tgc rjjm. Gjwcvcr, Gjwcvc r, tgc wfbc scet ohn` swccts, ndjtgcs hei prcscets tj tgc gusohei oy njurfcr je tgc vcry ecxt ihy. l) Je ?2.6.866< tgc gusohei bfdci h pctftfje fe tgc Bhmfdy Njurt ht [uec bjr rcstftutfje jb Njeaulhd rflgts. g) Hs h njuetcr mjvc tj tgc shfi pctftfje, wfbc bfdci bfdc i pjdfnc njmpdhfet hlhfest tgc gusohei hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs ht [uec (_hmjsgf Lhtc) [jdfnc ^thtfje hei tgc gusohei hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs wcrc rcqufrci tj lj tj tgc pjdfnc sthtfje ht dchst tgcc tfmcs hei iuc tj tgc ghrhssmcet nhusci tj tgcm hei df`cdfgjji jb ghrhssmcet tgcy hdsj hppdfci bjr hetfnfphtjry ohfd wgfng whs lrhetci l rhetci tj tgc gusohei hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs oy tgc njurt. f) Je 8.2.8667 wfbc tgce bfdci h mhfetcehenc hppdfnhtfje fe tgc Bhmfdy Njurt ht [uec. Fe gcr hppdfnhtfje, sgc njetceici tght iuc tj ghrhssmcet nhusci oy gcr gusohei hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs sgc ghi tj dchvc bjr gcr phrcethd gjmc wgce sgc whs prclehet. Out hs tgc ghrhssmcet njetfeuci, gcr phrcets scet gcr tj

 

>

tgc gjusc jb gcr mhtcrehd uendc ht [uec. Fespftc jb gcr icdfvcry je ?6.. Je 7.8;.?;;;, tgc wfbc bfdci gcr wrfttce sthtcmcet. Fe tgc wrfttce sthtcmcet sgc icefci tgc hddclhtfjes mhic oy tgc gusohei. ^gc hdsj nhmc jut wftg h pjsftfvc nhsc tght gcr phrcets ghi lfvce >> tjdhs jb ljdi jrehmcets hei 9∟@.L. jb sfdvcr jrehmcets tj gcr je tgc icmhei mhic oy gcr gusohei. Yght gcr phrcets ghi spcet bjur tj bfvc dhns ht tgc tfmc jb tgc mhrrfhlc. Yght, hbtcr tgc mhrrfhlc mhrrf hlc tgc gusohei hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs ghi hs`ci mjecy brjm tfmc tj tfmc brjm gcr phrcets hei tgcrcbjrc, gcr phrcets wcrc njestrhfeci tj scdd tgcfr bdht bjr budbfddfel tgc icmhei jb gcr gusohei hei gcr bhmfdy mcmocrs. ^gc whs ghrhssci hei fdd∟trchtci oy tgc pctftfjecr hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs. Gcr gusohei tfrci tj njmpcd gcr tj lfvc h ifvjrnc fe wrftfel je sthmp phpcr. Gcr phrcets wcrc ejt fe h pjsftfje tj budbfd sung cxjrofthet hei njetfeujus icmheis ocnhusc tgcy wcrc ejt bfehenfhddy sjuei. Yght, sgc whs ecvcr prjvfici wftg mcifnhd hfi iurfel gcr prcleheny hei tgcrcbjrc, sgc ocnhmc wch`. Yght, hs h rcsudt jb sung ghrhssmcet sgc ghi tj rcture tj gcr phrcets gjusc ht Ojrfvhdf. ^fenc gcr gusohei hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs njetfeuci tj ghrhss gcr, gcr phrcets scet gcr tj [uec bjr gcr shbcty. Ht [uec sgc icdfvcrci gcr ngfdi hei sfenc sgc whs vcry wch` sgc whs himfttci fe Mccrh Gjspfthd wgcrc sgc tjj` trchtmcet bjr ?.8/? mjetgs. Yght, gcr Feifhe @hejje @hejje ∟ gttp1//feifhe`hejje.jrl/ijn/89;8??;/ gusohei ecftgcr pcrbjrmci gfs iuty hs gcr gusohei jr hs bhtgcr jb tgc ngfdi ejr ghi gc vfsftci gcr hbtcr gcr icdfvcry. Yght, gcr gusohei whs mh`fel bhdsc hddclhtfjes hlhfest gcr bjr hiudtcry. Yght, gcr mhtcrehd uendc whs h rcspcnthodc pcrsje fe sjnfcty hei whs aust df`c gcr bhtgcr tj gcr. Gc ghi orjulgt up gcr aust df`c h ihulgtcr. Yght, tgcsc hddclhtfjes mhic oy gcr gusohei hlhfest gcr hei gcr mhtcrehd uendc hmjuetci tj nrucdty tj gcr hei gcr mhtcrehd uendc. ^gc icefci tght sgc ghi mhic hey icmhei bjr h scphrhtc rcsficenc hei icefci tght sgc ghi nhusci hey mcethd hei pgysfnhd tjrturc oy iceyfel pgysfnhd rcdhtfjes tj gcr gusohei. 9. Ht H t tgc trfhd tgc gusohei cxhmfeci gfmscd gfmscdbb hs [.\.Ej. 8, gfs orjtgcr Ir. Ehrcsg [hrmhr hs [.\.? hei jec @hetfdhd _he`h wgj ndhfms tj oc tgc cmpdjycr jb tgc gusohei hs [.\.>. Ygc wfbc cxhmfeci gcrscdb hs _.\.8, gcr mjtgcr Oghvhrfohf ^urheh hs _.\.?, gcr jtgcr uendc Icvrha Igj`h hs _.\.> Ojtg tgc sfics prjiunci ijnumcethry cvficenc. Spje njesficrfel hdd tgc cvficenc je rcnjri, tgc Bhmfdy Njurt, [uec phssci tgc fmpuleci auilmcet hei jricr wgfng fs tgc suoacnt mhttcr jb nghddcelc fe tgfs hppchd. Ft mhy oc sthtci gcrc tght sfenc ej sthy tj tgc icnrcc jb ifvjrnc whs lrhetci pceifel tgfs hppchd, tgc gusohei mhrrfci hlhfe hei ghs oy ejw twj ngfdirce brjm gfs scnjei mhrrfhlc. 3. \c ghvc gchri ojtg tgc sfics cxghustfvcdy. \c ghvc hdsj pcrusci tgc cetfrc cvficenc je rcnjri. \c mhic scrfjus httcmpts tj scc tght tgc phrtfcs tj oc orjulgt tjlctgcr out jur cbbjrts ghvc bhfdci. Ft fs tgc himfttci pjsftfje ocbjrc us tght tgc phrtfcs ghvc occe sthyfel scphrhtcdy sfenc 83.3.8662 f.c. bjr h pcrfji jb mjrc tghe 2 ychrs hei 7 mjetgs. ^fenc hdd httcmpts jb rcnjenfdfhtfje bhfdci, wc ghvc djj`ci fetj tgc cvficenc fe jricr tj icnfic tgc mhttcr je mcrfts. \c bfei brjm tgc cvficenc jb tgc gusohei tght tgc mhfe rchsje rchsj e lfvce oy gfm hs tj wgy gfs wfbc whs ueghppy whs tght sgc whs scc`fel h scphrhtc hnnjmmjihtfje hei icsfrci tj sthy hwhy brjm tgc ajfet bhmfdy. Gc ghs sthtci tght gfs wfbc icefci pgysfnhd rcdhtfjes wftg gfm hei nhusci gfm pgysfnhd hei mcethd tjrturc. Yght,hbtcr sgc dcbt gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc je 83.3.8662, tgjulg sgc feftfhddy wcet tj gcr phrcethd gjusc ht Ojrfvhdf wftgfe twj ihys gc nhmc tj `ejw tght sgc ghi ljec tj gcr mhtcrehd uendc‖s gjusc ht [uec. Gc icpjsci tght gc ghi ljec tj tgc gjusc jb gcr mhtcrehd uendc hei ghi occe housci oy gfm. Gfs wfbc ghi febjrmci gfm tght sgc whetci tj sthy ht [uec. Yght, fe Hprfd, 866< gc ghi mhic hrrhelcmcet bjr h scphrhtc rcsficenc ht Ogheiup hei ghi fetfmhtci hojut ft tj tgc phrcets jb gfs wfbc out fespftc jb tgfs sgc ifi ejt rcture. \c ghvc ejtci tght tgc wfbc tjj` tgc njetcetfje tght sgc whs wfddfel tj sthy fe f e h ajfet bhmfdy. Fb tgfs oc sj, tgce jec jb tgc mhfe rchsje bjr hnrfmjey octwcce tgc phrtfcs wjudi ejt cxfst hei tgcrc whs ej rchsje bjr gcr ejt tj rcture tj gcr gusohei. \c bfei tght sgc ghs njetceici tght sgc whs ghrhssci hei fdd∟trchtci oy tgc pctftfjecr hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs. Gcr njetcetfjes fe tgfs rclhri hrc vhluc. Ygcrc fs ej ihtc mcetfjeci fe rcspcnt jb hey phrtfnudhr fenficet jb ghrhssmcet. ^j hdsj phrtfnudhrs jb ghrhssmcets hrc hdsj ejt lfvce. ^gc ghi sthtci tght sgc whs ecvcr prjvfici wftg hey mcifnhd hfi iurfel gcr prcleheny. Hphrt brjm gcr ohrc sthtcmcet, tgcrc fs ejtgfel je rcnjri tj suosthetfhtc tgfs njetcetfje. Ft fs ejtci tght sgc ghi ljec tj gcr phrcets pdhnc ht Ojrfvhdf bjr icdfvcry gjwcvcr, wftgfe twj ihys sgc dcbt bjr gcr uendc‖s pdhnc ht [uec. Fe tgc pjdfnc cequfry gcr jwe bhtgcr ghi lfvce h sthtcmcet tght gfs njescet hei pcrmfssfje whs ejt th`ce bjr dchvfel gfs gjusc ht Ojrfvhdf. \c bfei ej austfbfnhtfje fe tgc

 

9

njetcetfje jb tgc wfbc bjr sthyfel ht [uec wftg gcr mhtcrehd uendc, cvce tgjulg gcr gusohei ghi purnghsci h scphrhtc pdhnc bjr tgcfr cxndusfvc rcsficenc. ^ung he hnt je gcr phrt jb sthyfel ht [uec hdjelwftg gcr ecwdy ojre sje ijcs hmjuet tj ojtg nrucdty hs wcdd hs icscrtfje hei ej bhudt nhe oc bjuei fe tgc fmpuleci auilmcet hei jricr lrhetfel ifvjrnc je tgc lrjuei jb nrucdty hei icscrtfje. 2. ^j bhr hs qucstfje jb mhfetcehenc fs njencreci, fe vfcw jb jur hbjrcshfi bfeifel, mhfetcehenc nheejt oc lrhetci tj tgc wfbc. Fe sj bhr hs tgc ngfdi fs njencreci, wc bfei tght he hmjuet jb _s. 3;;/∟ wgfng fs hwhrici fs tjj mchlrc djj`fel tj tgc prcscet rcqufrcmcets jb h lrjwfel ngfdi. Ygc cvficenc feifnhtcs tght tgc gusohei ghi subbfnfcet mjecy tj purnghsc gfs jwe bdht. Gc nheejt oc shfi tj oc h pcrsje jb ej mches. Ej ijuot, gc njetceici tght gc ghi ojrrjwci Feifhe @hejje ∟ gttp1//feifhe`hejje.jrl/ijn/89;8??;/ mjefcs brjm gfs brfceis tj purnghsc tgc ecw bdht out gc nheifidy himfttci tght gc ghi ejt th`ce hey sung njetcetfje hojut ojrrjwfel jb mjefcs brjm gfs brfceis fe gfs pctftfje ejr ghi gc dci hey cvficenc fe tgfs rclhri. Yh`fel he jvcr hdd vfcw jb tgc mhttcr, wc bccd tght ceis jb austfnc wfdd oc mct fb he hmjuet jb _s. >;;;/∟ pcr mjetg fs lrhetci hs mhfetcehenc tj tgc ngfdi. Ygc gusohei wfdd ghvc he jptfje jb mh`fel dumpsum phymcet jb _s. 3,;;,;;;/∟ tjwhris tgc mhfetcehenc jb gfs sje hei fb gc mh`cs sung dump sum phymcet fe budd, tgce gfs dfhofdfty tj phy mhfetcehenc ht tgc rhtc jb _s. >;;;/∟ pcr mjetg wfdd nchsc brjm tgc ihtc jb budd phymcet. Gc wfdd hdsj ghvc he jptfje tj mh`c h dumpsum phymcet jb _s. ?,3;,;;;/∟ ht tgc bfrst festhenc hei fb gc ijcs sj tgce tgc tgc mhfetcehenc phyhodc tj tgc sje wfdd sthei rciunci tj _s. 83;;/∟ pcr mjetg brjm tgc ihtc jb sung phymcet. Ygc mhfetcehenc hmjuet/hmjuet fe dfcu jb mhfetcehenc hs hbjrcshfi wjudi oc phyhodc tj tgc sje tfdd tgc sje htthfes tgc hlc jb mhajrfty. Fe tgc nfrnumsthencs, tgc hppchd fs phrtdy hddjwci wftg njsts fe tgc hbjrcshfi tcrms.

 

3

MSMOHF GFLG NJS_Y ?;;7.  NJS_Y 1 Ihtci Hpr ?;;7. Mhfetcehenc ejt lrhetci hs ft fs prjvci ej rchsje tj dchvc gusoheis.  

Oceng1 R @felhje`hr ^heahy ^uigh`hr Ogjshdc vs @grfstfeh \/J ^heahy Ogjshdc je 7/9/?;;7 ASILMCEY R._. @felhje`hr, A. 8. Oy tgfs rcvfsfje pctftfje, pctftfjecr scc`s fmmuefty brjm dfhofdfty tj phy mhfetcehenc hddjwhenc hs pcr Auilmcet rceicrci fe Nrfmfehd _cvfsfje [ctftfje Ej. 2; jb ?;;;, oy dchreci Hiiftfjehd ^cssfjes Auilc, ^grfrhmpur, tj rcspjeicet. Gc nghddcelcs nghddc elcs tgc shfi Auilmcet rcvcrsfel jricr jb ifsmfsshd jb tgc rcspjeicets hppdfnhtfje bjr mhfetcehenc phssci oy dchreci Auifnfhd Mhlfstrhtc (Bfrst Ndhss), ^grfrhmpur. ?. Ft wjudi oc uscbud tj bfrst ejtc tgc himfttci bhnts. Ygc spjuscs ocdjel tj Ngrfstfhe njmmuefty. Ygcfr mhrrfhlc whs pcrbjrmci je 89.3.8667 fe hnnjrihenc wftg tcects jb Ngrfstfhe rcdflfje. Ygc pctftfjecr fs cmpdjyci hs \hriojy fe Vcrwhih Mcethd Gjspfthd, ht [uec. Gc rcsfics fe jec jb tgc Ljvcremcet quhrtcrs, jut jb efec sung quhrtcrs, wgfng hrc fe jec rjw, sftuhtci ht ohn` sfic jb tgc mcethd gjspfthd. Gc whs h ifvjrncc wgce gc pcrbjrmci mhrrfhlc wftg tgc rcspjeicet. ^gc wcet tj rcsfic wftg gfm hbtcr tgc mhrrfhlc. Gfs phrcets hei twj orjtgcrs rcsfic wftg gfm fe tgc shmc rcsficetfhd quhrtcr. Ygc mhrrfhlc whs sgjrtdfvci. Ygc spjuscs hrc fenjmphtfodc. >. Ygc rcspjeicet (wfbc) bfdci hppdfnhtfje ueicr ^cntfje 8?3 jb tgc Nr.[.N. bjr scphrhtc mhfetcehenc hddjwhenc. ^gc hsscrtci tght bjr hojut sfx mjetgs, sgc whs sjmcgjw trchtci hdrflgt fe tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjmc. Ygcrchbtcr, tgc gusohei sthrtci mcethd hei pgysfnhd ghrhssmcet tj gcr ht festflhtfje jb gfs phrcets phrc ets hei orjtgcrs. Gcr fe∟dhws usci tj cxprcss ifsshtfsbhntfje rclhrifel lfbts lfvce fe tgc mhrrfhlc. Ygcy usci tj housc gcr. Ygc gusohei (pctftfjecr) usci tj ocht gcr fe irue`ce njeiftfje. Gc usci tj mh`c uedhwbud icmhei jb ljdi djn`ct wcflgfel 83 lms., h Y.R. sct hei h mfxcr, wgfng sgc whs hs`ci tj orfel brjm tgc phrcets. Gcr phrcets httcmptci tj njevfenc hei pdchi wftg gcr gusohei. ^tfdd, gjwcvcr, gc hei gfs rcdhtfvcs njetfeuci tgc uedhwbud icmhei, wgfng gcr phrcets wcrc uehodc tj mcct jut. Gc usci tj suspcnt gcr bcifdfty. ^gc hpprcgceici ihelcr tj gcr dfbc fe tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjmc. Gc mcrnfdcssdy ochtce up gcr je ?8.?.8666 hei irjvc gcr jut jb tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjmc. ^gc djilci h njmpdhfet ht tgc [jdfnc ^thtfje. ^gc fs uehodc tj mhfethfe gcrscdb. Ygc gusohei (pctftfjecr) ghs ljt subbfnfcet mches tj prjvfic scphrhtc mhfetcehenc. Njescqucetdy, sgc icmheici scphrhtc mhfetcehenc hddjwhenc ht rhtc jb _s. 8,3;;/∟ (_s. Jec tgjushei bfvc gueirci) brjm gfm. 9. Oy bfdfel wrfttce sthtcmcet (Cxg. 89), tgc gusohei (prcscet pctftfjecr) icefci trutg fetj hdd tgc mhtcrfhd hddclhtfjes mhic oy tgc wfbc. Gc icefci tght sgc whs ocfel fdd∟trchtci jr ghrhssci fe tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjusc. Gc suomfttci tght je 3tg Jntjocr, 8667, mhtcrehd mhtcr ehd uendc jb tgc rcspjeicet (wfbc) vfsftci gfs gjusc hei prctceici tght gcr hejtgcr mhtcrehd uendc, wgj fs feghofthet jb Hgmciehlhr, whs scrfjusdy fdd. Dhtcrje sgc wcet wftg gcr orjtgcr. ^gc ifi ejt rcture gjmc hbtcr ?/> ihys hs pcr tgc hssurhenc hei gcenc, gc vfsftci gcr phrcets gjusc je ?3tg Jntjocr 8667. Ygcy hssurci gfm tj scei gcr hbtcr tgc "Ehthd" bcstfvhd. Ygcrchbtcr, tgcy hvjfici tj scei gcr hei he i sgc rcbusci tj hnnjmphey hnn jmphey gfm. Gc whs rchiy hei wfddfel tj mhfethfe gcr. ^gc icscrtci gfm wftgjut hey suosthetfhd rchsje. Gc icefci tght sgc whs ecldcntci oy gfm. Gc urlci, tgcrcbjrc, tj ifsmfss tgc hppdfnhtfje. 3. Ygc phrtfcs wcet tj tgc trfhd ocbjrc tgc dchreci Auifnfhd Mhlfstrhtc (B.N.), ^grfrhmpur fe tgc prjnccifels (Nrfmfehd M.H. Ej. 73 jb 8666). Ygc rcspjeicet cxhmfeci gcrscdb fe suppjrt jb gcr hppdfnhtfje. Ygc prcscet pctftfjecr hdsj cxhmfeci gfmscdb hei hiiunci cvficenc jb twj ecflgojurs fe suppjrt jb gfs icbcenc. Je hpprcnfhtfje jb tgcfr cvficenc, tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc nhmc tj tgc njendusfje tght tgc rcspjeicet (wfbc) (wfbc ) bhfdci tj prjvc tght sgc whs ecldcntci ecldcn tci hei rcbusci tj oc mhfethfeci oy tgc gusohei. Ygc dchreci Feifhe @hejje ∟ gttp1//feifhe`hejje.jrl/ijn/269?63/ Mhlfstrhtc gcdi tght wftgfe h sgjrt sphe jb bfvc mjetgs jb tgc mhrrfhlc, sgc dcbt gfs njmphey, prjohody ocnhusc sgc whetci scphrhtc rcsficenc wftgjut ijmcstfn ngjrc fe rcspcnt jb gfs phrcets hei tgc orjtgcrs. Ygc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc gcdi tght hddclhtfjes jb mhtrfmjefhd nrucdty hrc fevcetci oy tgc rcspjeicet (wfbc) hei wcrc uehnncpthodc. Fe `ccpfel wftg sung bfeifels, gcr hppdfnhtfje whs ifsmfssci. 2. Bccdfel hllrfcvci, tgc wfbc prcbcrrci rcvfsfje hppdfnhtfje (Nrf. _cvfsfje [ctftfje Ej. 2; jb ?;;;), wgfng whs hddjwci ueicr tgc fmpuleci jricr. Ygc rcvfsfjehd Njurt rcvcrsci bfeifels jb tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc hei nhmc tj tgc njendusfje tght tgc vcrsfje jb tgc wfbc njudi ejt oc ifsnhrici fe tgc sct jb nfrnumsthencs. Ygc rcvfsfjehd Njurt hwhrici mhfetcehenc hddjwhenc ht rhtc rh tc jb _s. ihys. Ygcrchbtcr, je 88tg Jntjocr 8667, gcr orjtgcr tjj` gcr tj Hgmciehlhr. Gfs vcrsfje sgjws tght gc mhic httcmpts tj bctng gcr ohn` out ft whs fevhfe. Ygc vcrsfje jb I\∟^guoghelf rcvchds tght tgc pctftfjecr hei gfs wfbc wcrc ecvcr scce quhrrcddfel wftg chng jtgcr. Gcr vcrsfje rcvchds tght tgc rcspjeicet (wfbc) rcsfici wftg tgc tgc pctftfjecr jedy bjr bfvc mjetgs hbtcr tgc Feifhe @hejje ∟ gttp1//feifhe`hejje.jrl/ijn/269?63/ mhrrfhlc hei gc fs ejt hiifntci tj hey vfnc. Ygcrc fs jedy h mfiidc mf iidc whdd octwcce tgc rcsficetfhd quhrtcr jb tgc pctftfjecr hei I\∟^guoghelf. ^gc ghs ej rchsje ttj j spch` dfc ejr hey thelfodc mhtcrfhd fs lhtgcrci iurfel gcr nrjss∟cxhmf nrjss∟cxhmfehtfje. ehtfje. ^fmfdhrdy, I\∟> Ohsgfi icpjsci tght hbtcr bfvc mjetgs jb tgc mhrrfhlc, tgc wfbc dcbt gjusc jb tgc pctftfjecr ∟ ^heahy. Fe jtgcr wjris, tgc vcrsfje vcrsf je jb pctftfjecr ∟^heahy stheis njrrjojrhtci oy tgc vcrsfjes jb twj ecflgojurs. 8;. Ygcrc fs sjdfthry hei fetcrcstci vcrsfje jb [\∟@grfstfeh fe suppjrt jb gcr hppdfnhtfje bjr scphrhtc mhfetcehenc hddjwhenc. Gcr vcrsfje lfvcs fenjesfstcet hnnjuet hojut sj∟nhddci uedhwbud icmhei. ^gc icvfhtci icvfhtci brjm gcr pdchifels. Ygc bfeifels jb tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc hrc ohsci je iuc hpprcnfhtfje jb tgc cvficenc. Ygc burtgcr icvcdjpmcet mhy oc ejtfnci. Ygc pctftfjecr bfdci he hppdfnhtfje bjr rcstftutfje jb njeaulhd rflgts fe tgc Bhmfdy Njurt ht [uec. Gfs hppdfnhtfje ([.H. Ej. 3;; jb ?;;?) fs hddjwci oy tgc Bhmfdy Njurt je ?8st Audy ?;;>. ^j bhr, tgc rcspjeicet (wfbc) ghs ejt nghddcelci tgc Auilmcet Auilmc et jb tgc Bhmfdy Njurt. Ygc Bhmfdy Njurt rhfsci h spcnfbfn fssuc hs bjddjws1 \gctgcr tgc pctftfjecr prjvcs tght tgc rcspjeicet wftgjut hey rchsjehodc cxnusc ghs wftgirhwe brjm tgc sjnfcty: Ygc dchreci Auilc jb tgc Bhmfdy Njurt rcnjrici he hbbfrmhtfvc bfeifel je tgc shfi fssuc. Ft F t fs mhefbcst, tgcrcbjrc, tght ejt jedy tgc dchreci Auifnfhd Mhlfstrhtc, je hpprcnfhtfje jb tgc cvficenc tceicrci oy tgc spjuscs, nhmc tj tgc njendusfje tght sgc dcbt gfs gjusc, prjohody ueicr ourice jb tgc ijmcstfn ngjrcs, out tgc nfvfd Njurt hdsj bjuei tght sgc fs lufdty jb icscrtfel gfm wftgjut hey rchsjehodc cxnusc. 88. Ygc fmpuleci Auilmcet rcvchds tght tgc dchreci ^cssfjes Auilc ueicrtjj` rchsscssmcet jb tgc cetfrc cvficenc tgjulg gc whs suppjsci tj cxcrnfsc tgc rcvfsfjehd  aurfsifntfje. Ygc dchreci ^cssfjes Auilc ifi ejt bfei hey phrtfnudhr bhudt fe f e tgc prjncss jb hpprcnfhtfje jb cvficenc, hs ijec oy tgc dchreci dc hreci Mhlfstrhtc. Ygc rcdcvhet joscrvhtfjes jb tgc dc dchreci hreci ^cssfjes Auilc mhy oc rcprjiunci hs bjddjws1 89. Je nhrcbuddy snrutfefsfel tgc cvficenc jb tgc hppdfnhet hei jppjecet ft wfdd rcvchd tght tgc mhtrfmjefhd dfbc jb tgc hppdfnhet whs ejt smjjtgdy ljfel je iuc tj sjmc quhrrcd hei udtfmhtcdy, ft whs rcsudtci fetj dchvfel tgc gjusc jb jppjecet, oy tgc hppdfnhet. Joscrvhtfjes mhic oy tgc djwcr Njurt tght tgc hppdfnhet ghi sthyci bjr sgjrt pcrfji fe tgc gjusc jb tgc jppjecet hei tgcrcbjrc, tgcrc fs ej pjssfofdfty jb fdd∟trchtmcet, ijcs ejt hppchr tj oc prjpcr hei dclhd fe tgc nfrnumsthencs jb tgc nhsc. \gce tgc hppdfnhet ghs pjsftfvcdy sthtci tght sgc whs suoacntci tj fdd∟trchtmcet ejt jedy tght out sgc ghs djilci njmpdhfet fe Vcrwhih [jdfnc ^thtfje, tgfs wfdd prfmh∟bhnfc lfvc rfsc tght sgc whs fdd∟trchtci hei, tgcrcbjrc, sgc ghs dcbt tgc gjusc jb tgc jppjecet. [rjvfsfjes jb ^cntfje 8?3 jb Njic jb Nrfmfehd [rjnciurc ecci ejt rcqufrc tght tgcrc must oc h strfnt prjjb jb nrucdty. Ygc hojvc joscrvhtfjes jb tgc dchreci ^cssfjes Auilc wjudi feifnhtc tght gc hnncptci vcrsfje jb tgc wfbc wf bc jedy ocnhusc sgc lhvc pjsftfvc sthtcmcet tght sgc whs suoacntci tj fdd∟trchtmcet hei ghi djilci tgc njmpdhfet ht Vcrwhih [jdfnc ^thtfje. Hs sthtci ocbjrc, tgcrc fs ej snfetfddh jb cvficenc tj sgjw tght rchddy sgc ghi djilci h njmpdhfet

 

<

hojut tgc mhtrfmjefhd nrucdty. Ejr gcr sj∟nhddci pjsftfvc sthtcmcet bfeis suppjrt brjm gcr pdchifels. Fe tgfs vfcw jb tgc mhttcr, ft fs ifbbfnudt tj njuetcehenc tgc bfeifels jb tgc dchreci ^cssfjes Auilc. Gcr mcr mcrc c sthtcmcet njudi ejt ghvc occe th`ce hs ljspcd trutg hs rclhris ecldcnt hei rcbushd jb tgc gusohei tj mhfethfe gcr. Ft fs jvcrdjj`ci oy tgc dchreci ^cssfjes Auilc tght wftgfe h sgjrt sphe jb tgc mhrrfhlc, tgc wfbc dcbt gfs njmphey hei ej ejtfnc whs lfvce wftgfe h rchsjehodc tfmc oy gcr, scc`fel rcstftutfje jb tgc njeaulhd rflgts. 8?. Ygc Hpcx Njurt, fe Ico Ehrhyhe Ghdicr v. ^mt. Heusgrcc Ghdicr ?;;> (>) O Nr N ?72, gcdi tght tgc hppcddhtc Njurt jr rcvfsfjehd Njurt wgfdc scttfel hsfic hsfic Feifhe @hejje ∟ gttp1//feifhe`hejje.jrl/ijn/269?63/ bfeifels rcnjrici oy Njurt ocdjw must ejtfnc tgjsc bfeifels hei wgcrc tgc bfeifels hrc jb bhnts, cvficenc je rcnjri must oc ifsnussci, wgfng sgjudi austfby rcvcrshd jb bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc Njurt ocdjw. Ygc Hpcx Njurt gcdi tght wgce tgc mhfetcehenc hppdfnhtfje jb tgc wfbc whs rcacntci oy tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc, gjdifel tght t ght sgc ghi je gcr jwe dcbt tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjmc, tgc Gflg Njurt whs ejt austfbfci fe rcvcrsfel sung bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc trfhd Njurt hei tj lrhet mhfetcehenc tj tgc wfbc. 8>. Fe vfcw v fcw jb bjrcljfel ifsnussfje, ft wfdd ghvc tj oc shfi tght tgc bfeifels jb tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc sgjudi ejt ghvc occe fetcrbcrci wftg oy tgc rcvfsfjehd Njurt hei bjr tgc rchsjes, wgfng hrc rcnjrici oy ft. Ygc febcrcencs febcr cencs irhwe oy tgc dchreci ^cssfjes Auilc hrc fmprjpcr hei fenjrrcnt. Ygcrc fs mfsfetcrprcthtfje jb tgc cvficenc oy tgc dchreci ^cssfjes Auilc. Seicr S eicr tgcsc nfrnumsthencs, tgc fmpuleci Auilmcet fs uesusthfehodc hei dfhodc tj oc fetcrbcrci wftg. 89. Fe tgc rcsudt, tgc pctftfje fs hddjwci. Ygc fmpuleci Auilmcet fs sct hsfic hei tgc Auilmcet rceicrci oy tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc fe Nrfmfehd Mfsn. Hppdfnhtfje Ej. 73 jb 8666 fs rcstjrci. Ygc wfbcs hppdfnhtfje ueicr ^cntfje 8?3 jb tgc Nr.[.N. fs ifsmfssci. Gjwcvcr, tgc phymcet jb mhfetcehenc hddjwhenc, fb hey, iurfel tgc fetcrvcefel pcrfji, fs ejt rcbueihodc oy gcr. Ej njsts.

 

7

MSMOHF GFLG NJS_Y1 Ihtci ?? Bcoruhry, ?;;7  [craury fe 8?3 nr[n 

FE YGC GFLG NJS_Y JB ICDGF HY EC\ ICDGF 8; N_D.M.N. 88>;/?;;7 & N_D.M.H.9?>8/?;;7 AHLIF^G [_H^HI ..... [ctftfjecr Ygrjulg1 Mr._.O. [heicy, Hivjnhtc. vcrsus ^YHYC & J_^. ..... _cspjeicets Ygrjulg1 Mr.Ahficcp Mhdf`,H[[. Mr. _.[. @husgf`, Hivjnhtc bjr _cspjeicet Ej.?. NJ_HM1 GJE'ODC I_. AS^YFNC ^. MS_HDFIGH_ 8. \gctgcr _cpjrtcrs jb djnhd phpcrs mhy oc hddjwci tj scc tgc auilmcet: Ej ?. Yj oc rcbcrrci tj tgc _cpjrtcr jr ejt: Vcs >. \gctgcr tgc auilmcet sgjudi oc rcpjrtci fe Iflcst: Vcs J_IC_ ?>.;>.?;;6 8. Ygfs pctftfje ueicr ^cntfje 97? jb tgc Njic jb tgc Nrfmfehd [rjnciurc (Nr[N) fs ifrcntci hlhfest he jricr ihtci ??ei Bcoruhry ?;;7 phssci oy tgc dchreci Hiiftfjehd ^cssfjes Auilc (H^A) Icdgf hddjwfel Nrd.H.Ej.87 jb ?;;3 bfdci oy tgc _cspjeicet Ej.? hlhfest he jricr ihtci 6 tg ^cptcmocr ?;;3 phssci oy tgc dchreci Mctrjpjdfthe Mhlfstrhtc (MM) Icdgf fe he hppdfnhtfje bfdci oy tgc [ctftfjecr gcrcfe ueicr ^cntfje >9; Nr[N. Oy tgc shfi jricr ihtci 6tg ^cptcmocr ?;;3, tgc dchreci MM nhmc tj tgc prfmh bhnfc njendusfje tght _cspjeicet Ej.? ghi njmmfttci he jbbcenc ueicr ^cntfje 86> jb tgc Feifhe [cehd Njic (F[N) hei julgt tj oc prjscnutci bjr tgc shmc. Ygc dchreci H^A ghs, fe tgc Nrd.M.N.88>;/;7 [hlc 8 jb 88 fmpuleci jricr, sct hsfic tgc jricr ihtci 6 tg ^cptcmocr ?;;3 je tgc lrjuei tght tgc dchreci MM ghi ejt ictcrmfeci fb ft whs cxpcifcet fe tgc fetcrcsts jb austfnc tght he fequfry sgjudi oc gcdi bjr hsncrthfefel wgctgcr tgc _cspjeicet Ej.? sgjudi oc prjscnutci bjr tgc jbbcenc ueicr ^cntfje 86> F[N. ?. Ygc orfcb bhnts dchifel tj tgc bfdfel jb tgc prcscet pctftfje hrc tght _cspjeicet Ej.? wfbc bfdci he hppdfnhtfje ueicr ^cntfje 8?3 Nr[N scc`fel mhfetcehenc brjm tgc [ctftfjecr gusohei bjr gcrscdb hei tgc mfejr bcmhdc ngfdi. Fe gcr pctftfje sgc sthtci fe [hrh 83 tght sgc whs "ejt cmpdjyci heywgcrc hei fs uehodc tj mhfethfe gcrscdb hei gcr shfi mfejr lfrd ^grutf hei tgcy prcscetdy hrc survfvci je tgc mcrny jb phrcets phrc ets jb tgc pctftfjecr Ej.8 (wfbc) wgj tgcmscd vcs ghvc dfmftci rcsjurncs tj mhfethfe tgc dhrlc bhmfdy." >. Hnnjrifel tj tgc [ctftfjecr fe tgc mjetg jb Auec ?;;8, tgc _cspjeicet Ej.? wfbc ghi ajfeci Yfrhtg _hm ^ghg Nghrfthodc Gjspfthd, _hapur _jhi, Icdgf hs h k_cncptfjefst' hei whs rcncfvfel shdhry brjm tgc shfi gjspfthd. Je tgfs ohsfs, [ctftfjecr ghi chrdfcr bfdci bfdc i he hppdfnhtfje ueicr ^cntfje >9; Nr[N wgfng, hnnjrifel tj _cspjeicet Ej.?, whs ifsmfssci je 82tg ^cptcmocr, ?;;>. Ahlifsg [rhshi vs ^thtc & Jrs je ?? Bcoruhry, ?;;7 Feifhe @hejje gttp1//feifhe`hejje.jrl/ijn/ JB I. R. HNY 8. F sghdd ifspjsc jb he hppdfnhtfje bfdci bjr fetcrfm mhfetcehenc ueicr ^cntfje ?> [rjtcntfje jb \jmce ueicr Ijmcstfn Rfjdcenc Hnt, (gcencbjrtg rcbcrrci tj hs tgc I. R. Hnt). ?. Ygc njmpdhfehet ghs hddclci tght sgc ghs occe suoacntci tj vhrfjus bjrms jb ijmcstfn vfjdcenc oy gcr gusohei, tgc rcspjeicet. Ft ghs occe hrluci tght tgc rcspjeicet fs wjr`fel wftg [ftecy Ojsc ^jbtwhrc Njmphey fe ^cntjr ’ 2>, Ejfih hei irhwfel he heeuhd shdhry jb _s. ?; dhns pcr heeum. Ocsfics tgfs, ft fs hdsj hrluci tght gc fs rueefel h prjbfthodc ousfecss jb njmputcr sjbtwhrc fe h phrtecrsgfp hdjel wftg gfs brfcei. Di njuescd bjr tgc njmpdhfehet ghs prhyci tght tgc njmpdhfehet fs bhnfel cxtrcmc ghrisgfp hs tgc phrtfcs hrc ghoftuhd jb ceajyfel h dhvfsg dfbc stydc, hei tgcrcbjrc, sufthodc mhfetcehenc mhy oc lrhetci bjr bjji, ndjtgfel, rcsficenc hphrt brjm jtgcr ohsfn ecncssftfcs fe hnnjrihenc wftg tgc stheihri jb dfvfel jb tgc phrtfcs sung hs icncet ciunhtfje jb tgc ngfdi, ndjtgcs hei tjfdctrfcs jb tgc ngfdi, gcr vhnnfehtfje, mhfi scrvhet hei gcr cxpcescs, nhr pctrjd hei mhfetcehenc nghrlcs, mjofdc ofdds, cdcntrfnfty, whtcr cxpcescs hei sufthodc Dfbc Fesurhenc [jdfnfcs ctn. >. Yj suppjrt tgcfr hvcrmcets ojtg tgc phrtfcs ghvc pdhnci tgcfr shdhry sdfps je rcnjri. Ygc njmpdhfehet ghs hdsj pdhnci gfs FY_s bjr tgc dhst twj ychrs wgcrc gfs fenjmc fs icpfntci tj oc hpprjxfmhtcdy _s. 89 dhns pcr heeum. 9. Fe rcpdy, Fi njuescd bjr tgc rcspjeicet ghs vcgcmcetdy icefci tght hey bjrm jb Ijmcstfn Rfjdcenc ghs occe cvcr njmmfttci upje tgc njmpdhfehet. Hs rclhris rclhr is tgc fenjmc, ft ghs occe icefci tght gc fs chrefel _s. ?; dhns pcr heeum hei himfttci tght gfs mjetgdy fenjmc fs _s. 73,;;;/- pcr mjetg hei hdsj suomfttci tght tgc njmpdhfehet fs prcscetdy wjr`fel wftg Mctdfbc hei lcttfel mjrc tghe _s. 3;,;;;/pcr mjetg fenjmc hei tgcrcbjrc, sgc fs ejt cetftdci tj lct hey mhfetcehenc hs sgc fs chrefel subbfnfcetdy tj susthfe gcrscdb. 3. Ygc prcscet hppdfnhtfje ghs occe bfdci ueicr ^cntfje ?> jb tgc Ijmcstfn Rfjdcenc R fjdcenc Hnt bjr lrhet jb mhfetcehenc. Ft wjudi oc csscetfhd tj mcetfje gcrc tght chrdfcr hppdfnhtfje ueicr ^cntfje ?> whs bfdci hdjel wftg mhfe pctftfje fe wgfng mjecthry rcdfcb whs ejt ndhfmci wgcrc hs fe tgc prcscet hppdfnhtfje wgfng fs hlhfe bfdci ueicr tgc shmc ^cntfje fe wgfng tgc mjecthry rcdfcb ghs occe ndhfmci. Ft ghs occe joacntci tj oy tgc rcspjeicet fe tgc rcpdy tj tgc hppdfnhtfje tght tgc shmc ijcs ejt dfc hei tgc hppdfnhtfje sgjudi ghvc occe bfdci ueicr ^cntfje ?3 (?) jb I. R. Hnt. \ftgjut ljfel fetj tgc tcngefnhdftfcs, tgc hppdfnhtfje mhy oc rchi hs he hppdfnhtfje ueicr tgc rcdcvhet prjvfsfjes jb tgc I. R. Hnt. 2. F ghvc gchri tgc suomfssfje hivhenci oy njuescds bjr ojtg tgc phrtfcs. Ft ghs occe sthtci oy tgc njuescd bjr tgc njmpdhfehet tght tgc njmpdhfehet ghs hdd hdjel occe vcry bhfr hei gjecst fe gcr njmpdhfet oy suomfttfel tght sgc whs wjr`fel hei ghi mches tj susthfe gcrscdb. ^gc ghs ejt bfdci hppdfnhtfje bjr lrhet jb fetcrfm mhfetcehenc bjr gcrscdb hs sgc whs chrefel subbfnfcetdy tj mhfethfe gcrscdb hei th`c nhrc jb gcr ihfdy eccis out tjihy tgc sftuhtfje ghs nghelci hei sgc fs ajodcss hei tjthddy icpceicet je tgc mcrny jb gcr jdi hei hfdfel phrcets. 32 jb ?;8; ^mt. [rhtf`sgh Hryh \/j ^rf Iccph` @umhr Hryh I/j dhtc ^grf ^ grf Mhgcsg Ngheihr Hryh _/j ^thbb Gjusc Njmpjuei, Mhddfthd, Ehfefthd, Ifstrfnt Ehfefthd. ... . Hppcddhet Rcrsus ^rf Iccph` @umhr Hryh ^/j ^rf Ihudht _hm _/j Ychngcrs Njdjey, @fngngh, Ycgsfd @fngngh, Ifstt. Sighm ^felg Ehlhr. ... . _cspjeicet Mr. H`gfd @umhr ^hg, Hivjnhtc, prcscet bjr tgc hppcddhet. Mr. I.^. Mcgth, Hivjnhtc, prcscet bjr tgc rcspjeicet. Njrhm 1 Gje'odc [rhbuddh N. [het, A. Gje'odc R. @. Ofst, A. Gje. [rhbuddh N. [het, A. (Jrhd) Ygfs hppchd, prcbcrrci ueicr ^cntfje 86 jb tgc Bhmfdy Njurts Hnt, 8679, fs ifrcntci hlhfest tgc jricr ihtci 82.;7.?;8;, phssci oy [rfenfphd Auilc, Bhmfdy Njurt, Ehfefthd, fe Nfvfd ^uft Ej. 897 jb ?;;6, wgcrcoy shfi njurt ghs ifrcntci tgc hppcddhet tj phy mhfetcehenc ht tgc rhtc jb k ?,3;;/- pcr mjetg tj gcr gusohei ? (rcspjeicet) ueicr ^cntfje ?9 jb tgc Gfeiu Mhrrfhlc Hnt, 8633. ?) Gchri dchreci njuescd bjr tgc phrtfcs. >) Orfcb bhnts jb tgc nhsc hrc tght phrtfcs tj tgfs hppchd hrc fe dftflhtfje ocbjrc tgc trfhd njurt wgcrc rcspjeicet Iccph` @umhr Hryh ghs bfdci h pctftfje bjr ifvjrnc hlhfest tgc prcscet hppcddhet [rhtf`sgh Hryh. Fe shfi suft, gc mjvci he hppdfnhtfje ueicr ^cntfje ?9 jb tgc Gfeiu Mhrrfhlc Hnt, 8633, bjr mhfetcehenc ht tgc rhtc jb k 8;,;;;/pcr mjetg brjm gfs wfbc [rftf`sgh Hryh. Ygc hppdfnhtfje whs njetcstci oy tgc wfbc, wgj hddclci tght gcr gusohei rues h njmputcr ncetcr ht @fngngh, hei jwes prjpcrty wjrtg dh`gs jb rupccs tgcrc. 9) ^cntfje ?9 jb tgc Gfeiu Mhrrfhlc Hnt, 8633, hppdfcs cquhddy tj ojtg spjuscs. Ft prjvfics tght wgcrc fe hey prjnccifel ueicr tgc Hnt ft hppchrs tj tgc njurt tght t ght cftgcr tgc wfbc jr tgc gusohei, hs tgc nhsc mhy oc, ghs ej feicpceicet fenjmc subbfnfcet bjr gcr jr gfs suppjrt, ft mhy, je tgc hppdfnhtfje jb wfbc jr tgc gusohei, jricr ^mt. [rhtf`sgh Hryh vs ^rf Iccph` @umhr Hryh je 8< Mhrng, ?;88 Feifhe @hejje gttp1//feifhe`hejje.jrl/ijn/88867>2/ 8 tgc jtgcr phrty tj phy mjetgdy mhfetcehenc iurfel tgc prjnccifel feftfhtci ueicr tgc Hnt. Ejrmhddy, fe tgc Feifhe sjnfcty, wc scc gusohei hs he chrefel mcmocr mcm ocr fe tgc bhmfdy hei wfbc icpceicet je gfm. Out ^cntfje ?9 th`cs ejtc jb hdd `feis jb sftuhtfje fenduifel tgc jec fe wgfng gusohei fs uehodc > tj mhfethfe gfmscdb hei icpceicet je gfs wfbc. Hs sung, hs bhr hs mhfethfehofdfty jb tgc hppdfnhtfje mjvci oy tgc gusohei fs njencreci, tgc shmc whs mhfethfehodc, scc`fel mhfetcehenc brjm tgc wfbc. 3) Gjwcvcr, wgctgcr hntuhddy fe tgc prcscet nhsc, tgc gusohei whs cetftdci bjr mhfetcehenc ueicr ^cntfje ?9 jb tgc Gfeiu Mhrrfhlc Hnt, 8633, fs rcqufrci tj oc cxhmfeci. Ygc gusohei ghs mjvci he hppdfnhtfje bjr mhfetcehenc je tgc lrjuei tght gfs wfbc fs h tchngcr hei chrefel k 87,;;;/- pcr mjetg (hntuhddy bjuei k 6,>;;/- pcr mjetg). m jetg). Gc ghs pdchici tght gc fs ejt cmpdjyci heywgcrc. Je tgc jtgcr ghei, fe tgc joacntfjes bfdci ocbjrc tgc trfhd njurt oy tgc prcscet hppcddhet ft fs spcnfbfnhddy pdchici tght gcr gusohei Iccph` @umhr Hryh (prcscet rcspjeicet) rues h njmputcr ncetcr fe @fngngh. Ft fs hdsj pdchici oy gcr tght gcr gusohei jwes prjpcrty wjrtg dh`gs jb rupccs. Ygc trfhd njurt ghs sfmpdy th`ce ejtc jb tgc bhnt tght sfenc tgc prcscet hppcddhet fs h tchngcr fe h prfmhry sngjjd hei lcttfel shdhry jb k 6,>;;/- pcr mjetg, ft ifrcntci tgc hppcddhet tj phy mhfetcehenc ht tgc rhtc jb k ?,3;;/pcr mjetg tj gcr gusohei. Ygc trfhd njurt ghs flejrci tgc cnjejmfn sthtus jb tgc gusohei. Ft fs ejwgcrc nhtcljrfnhddy ifsnussci ejr njenduici oy tgc trfhd njurt tght tgc gusohei ijcs ejt rue tgc njmputcr ncetcr jr ijcs ejt jwe hey prjpcrty, hs hddclci oy gfs wfbc. Ft fs hdsj cvficet brjm tgc fmpuleci jricr tght prcscet hppcddhet 9 (wfbc) fs h tchngcr fe h prfmhry sngjjd ht sjmc fetcrfjr pdhnc jb p pjstfel. jstfel. 2) Ghvfel njesficrci suomfssfjes jb dchreci njuescd bjr tgc phrtfcs hei hbtcr ljfel tgrjulg tgc phpcrs je rcnjri, wc hrc jb tgc vfcw tght tgjulg tgc hppdfnhtfje oy tgc gusohei whs mhfethfehodc ueicr ^cntfje ?9 jb tgc Gfeiu Mhrrfhlc Hnt, 8633, out fe tgc bhnts hei nfrnumsthencs jb tgc prcscet nhsc, ft fs ejt h bft nhsc bjr lrhetfel mhfetcehenc tj tgc gusohei oy tgc wfbc. Ygcrcbjrc, wftgjut joscrvfel hey jpfefje hs tj tgc bfehd mcrfts jb tgc nhsc pceifel ocbjrc tgc trfhd njurt, tgfs hppchd fs hddjwci, hei tgc jricr ihtci 82.;7.?;8;, phssci oy [rfenfphd Auilc, Bhmfdy Njurt, Ehfefthd, fe Nfvfd ^uft Ej. 897 jb ?;;6, fs sct hsfic sj bhr ft rcdhtcs tj tgc ifrcntfje tj tgc prcscet hppcddhet tj phy mhfetcehenc ht tgc rhtc jb k ?,3;;/- pcr mjetg tj gcr gusohei. Njsts chsy. (R.@. Ofst, A.) ([rhbuddh N. [het, A.) It. Mhrng 82/ ?

 

?8

Mumohf Bhmfdy Njurt Xuhdfbfci wfbc nhe‖t sft fidc hei ndhfm mhfetcehenc1 Mumohf

bhmfdy njurt 1 Bfrijs Mjgi. ^gjco @ghe vs Mjgi. ^gjco Mjgi ^hdfm @ghe  „  Mumohf bhmfdy njurt ?;83 

Budd auilmcet tcxt ocdjw1 

FE YGC BHMFDV NJS_Y MSMOHF HY OHEI_H [CYFYFJE EJ. C 886 JB ?;8> Bfrijs Mjgi. ^gjco @ghe .. [ctftfjecr Rs. Mjgi.^gjco Mjgi.^hdfm @ghe .. _cspjeicet J_IC_ OCDJ\ CWG.?< 8. Ygfs fs he hppdfnhtfje mjvci oy pctftfjecrBfrijz Mjgi. Bjr lrhet jb mhfetcehenc brjm gcr gusohei Mjgi.^gjco, iurfel tgc pceiceny jb pctftfje bjr lrhet jb mhfetcehenc u/s 8?3 jb Nr.[.N. Ft fs suomfttci oy tgc pctftfjecr tght ht tgc tfmc jb Ef`hg Mcgcr hmjuet jb _s.89 dh`gs whs bfxci, yct shfi hmjuet whs ejt phfi oy tgc rcspjeicet. Ygrjulgjut tgcfr njghofthtfje ht tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjusc tgc rcspjeicet hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs ghi fddtrchtci gcr, ghrhssci gcr pgysfnhddy hei mcethddy bjr orfelfel dcss ijwry. Ygc rcspjeicet hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs ghi icmheici mjrc _s.3; dh`g hs ijwry hei ljdi jrehmcets, Mcrncics Ocez Nhr ctn. brjm gcr phrcets. Iuc tj icmhei jb ijwry tgc pctftfjecr whs bjrnci tj dfvc scphrhtcdy brjm Hprfd ?;88, sfenc tgce sgc fs rcsfifel wftg gcr phrcets. ^gc ghs ej sjurnc jb fenjmc hei sgc fs tjthddy icpcei upje tgc mcrny jb gcr phrcets. Ygc rcspjeicet fs nhphodc tj phy mhfetcehenc tj gcr out gc ghs ecldcntci hei rcbusci tj phy mhfetcehenc. ?. Ygc rcspjeicet fs h sunncssbud ousfecssmhe, gfs bhmfdy fs ousfecss bhmfdy. Ygc rcspjeicet hdjelwftg gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs whs ijfel ousfecss ejt jedy fe Feifh out hdsj fe Iuohf hei jtgcr njuetrfcs. Ygcy hrc rueefel tgcfr ousfecss ajfetdy hei chrefel tgc fenjmc mjrc tghe _s.83 dh`g pcr mjetg. Ygc rcspjeicet hei bhmfdy mcmocrs wcrc ghvfel prjpcrty ht Mumohf, Ohelhdjrc, Iuohf hei jtgcr pdhncs. Ygc rcspjeicet fs ghvfel sfx njmphefcs, ?; ohe` hnnjuets ht Mumohf, Iuohf hei Ohelhdjrc. Gfs yjuelcr orjtgcr fs wjr`fel ht Djeije, gfs twj sfodfels hrc fe bhmfdy ousfecss. Ygc rcspjeicet fs trhvcddfel horjhi bjr lhrmcet ousfecss wjr`. Njesficrfel tgc sthtus jb gcr gusohei sgc prhyci bjr lrhet jb mhfetcehenc K _s.? dh`gs pcr mjetg. >. Ygc rcspjeicet ghs bfdci gfs rcpdy ocdjw Cxg.?6. Hnnjrifel tj gfm, tgc pctftfjecrwfbc fs ejt cetftdci tj lct mhfetcehenc hs sgc fs ejt dclhddy wciici wfbc. Ygc mhrrfhlc

 

??

octwcce pctftfjecr hei rcspjeicet whs ifssjdvci oy why jb Yhdhq je ; ihys. Ygc pctftfjecr fs lrhiuhtc hei wjr`fel feicpceicetdy fe h prfmc festftutc df`cdy Ehfr gjspfthd, Dhrsce & Yuorj ctn. [rcscetdy sgc fs prhntfnfel hs h ifctftfhe. Gcr fenjmc fs ejt dcss tghe _s.3;,;;;/pcr mjetg. ^gc fs ghvfel subbfnfcet mches brjm gcr jwe sjurnc, je tght njuet hdsj sgc fs ejt cetftdci bjr lrhet jb mhfetcehenc gcenc, rcspjeicet prhyci bjr rcacntfje jb hppdfnhtfje. 3. Gchri dchreci njuescd bjr pctftfjecr hei rcspjeicet. Ft fs hrluci oy tgc dchreci njuescd bjr rcspjeicet tght je < , (^N), tgc Gje‖odc ^uprcmc Njurt ghs gcdi tght tgc Musdfm Ifvjrncc wfbc fs cetftdci tj lct mhfetcehenc brjm gcr gusohei. ) I.M.N., , tgc Gje‖odc Sttcrh`ghei Sttc rh`ghei Gflg Njurt fe phrh Ej.8? gcdi tght, —Fe vfcw jb prjpjsftfje jb dhw dhfi ijwe fe hbjrcshfi prcncicet, ft fs houeihetdy ndchr tght tgc Musdfm wjmhe nheejt oc bjrnci tj ndhfm mhfetcehenc ueicr tgc Hnt jedy. ^gc fs wcdd cetftdci tj ndhfm ndhf m mhfetcehenc u/s 8?3 jb Nr.[.N. frrcspcntfvc frr cspcntfvc jb bhnt wgctgcr sgc ghs occe ifvjrnci jr ejt prjvfici sgc ghs ejt rcmhrrfci gcrscdb.”  gcrscdb.”   7. Fe tgc hevfd jb hojvc dclhd pjsftfje ft fs ndchr tght tgc Musdfm wjmhe wgj fs cftgcr ifvjrncc jr wgj jothfeci ifvjrnc cetftdci tj lct mhfetcehenc tfdd gcr rcmhrrfhlc. Fe sung nfrnumsthencs tgc stjry orjulgt oy rcspjeicet tght je .?;;8, gc ghi ajfeci @cylfce Ycxtfdc Feiustrfcs [vt.Dti. Je tgc shmc ihy. Gc whs ajfeci tgc @ghe Gjdifels [vt.Dti. Je ?3.>.?;;8. Ygc njmphefcs ajfeci gfm ht sfmfdhr pcrfji. pcrfj i. H sfeldc ijnumcet fs ejt pdhnci je rcnjri rcn jri tj sgjw tgc ect fenjmc lcttfel oy rcspjeicet brjm hojvc njmphey. Ygc pctftfjecr ghs lfvce dfst jb tgc ohe` hnnjuets gjdi oy rcspjeicet hei gfs bhmfdy. bhmfd y. Ygc rcspjeicet fs gjdifel ohe` hnnjuet ocbjrc G^ON, IFO, HIFI (twj hnnjuets), ^.O.F., Jrfcethd ohe` jb njmmcrnc (tgrcc hnnjuets) hei sgc ghs lfvce hnnjuet ejs. ^gc ghi hdsj lfvce tgc icthfds jb ohe` hnnjuet gjdi oy rcspjeicet‖s bhmfdy, fe hdd tjthd sgc ghi prjvfici dfst jb ?; ohe` hnnju ets. Cftgcr jb tgc phrtfcs ghs ejt pdhnci je rcnjri h sfeldc ohe` hnnjuet sthtcmcet jr phssojj` fssuci oy Ohe`. 8;. Ft fs himfttci pjsftfje tght tgc rcspjeicet hei gfs bhmfdy mcmocrs hrc njeecntci wftg bfvc njmphefcs ehmcdy (f)@gwhah Cxpjrts [vt.Dti.(ff) @cylfce Ldjohd Dti.(fff)_hifum Lhrmcets [vt.Dti.(fv) @ghe Gjdifels [vt.Dti. Ygc dcttcr fssuci oy [.D. Ohohrfh &  Hssjnfhtcs Nghrtcr Nghrtcrci ci Hnnjuethet Hnnjuethet ihtci 86.8? 86.8?.?;89 .?;89 sgjws sgjws tght tgc rcspjeic rcspjeicet et fs ghvfel 3;; sghrc fe @ghwhah cxpjrt [vt.Dti. Ghvfel phfi vhduc jb rs.3,;;;/. Fe jtgcr njmphefcs gc ghvc ej sghrc. Ygc hojvc sthtci Nghrtcrci hnnjuet hdsj ncrtfbfci tght fe tgc ychr ?;888? tgc fenjmc jb rcspjeicet whs rs.8,3;,2 ft whs _s.8,78,799/, fe ?;8>89 rs.?,;;;83,/, hei fe tgc ychr ?;8983 gfs fenjmc whs rs.?,8;,;8>/. Ygc fenjmc thx rctures bfdci hdjelwftg rcnjri sgjws shmc stjry. 88. Ygc sthtcmcet mhic oy tgc phrtfcs fe tgcfr chrdfcr prjnccifel fs himfssfod himfssfodc c sthtcmcet. Ft hppchrs brjm tgc rcnjri tght tgc rcspjeicet ghs bfdci rcpdy tj tgc hppdfnhtfje jb pctftfjecr ocbjrc ?6tg Njurt M.M.Ihihr, Mumohf fe nhsc Ej.?3/_H/?;8? E >8 >8 sthtci tght sgc tjdi gcr phrcets hojut gcr ocfel tjrturci oy tgc hppcddhet h ppcddhet 7 ychrs hbtcr tgc mhrrfhlc. Hdd tgfs sgjws tght tgc hddclhtfjes h ddclhtfjes mhic oy tgc rcspjeicet hojut gcr fdd trchtmcet ht tgc gheis jb tgc hppcddhet whs ejt truc. >. Ygjulg tgc cvficenc ifsndjsci tght tgc phrtfcs dfvci ht ifbbcrcet pdhncs hrjuei Nhdnutth iurfel tgc pcrfji jb twcdvc ychrs hbtcr mhrrfhlc, ej wftecss whs cxhmfeci oy tgc rcspjeicet tj prjvc tght sgc ghi occe suoacntci tj tjrturc hei nrucdty ht tgc gheis jb tgc hppcddhet. 9. Hs rclhris tgc scnjei rchsje ehmcdy, tgc uldy hppchrhenc jb tgc rcspjeicet, tgjulg sung he hddclhtfje whs mhic fe tgc njmpdhfet, fe tgc njursc jb gcr icpjsftfje tgc rcspjeicet ifi ejt uttcr jec wjri fe suppjrt jb tgc shfi hddclhtfje. Cvce fe tgc pjdfnc rcpjrt djilci oy gcr, tgcrc fs ej hddclhtfje tght sgc whs ocfel fdd trchtci ocnhusc jb gcr uldy hppchrhenc. 3. Ygcrc fs ej cvficenc tj sullcst tght fe vfcw jb tgcfr strhfeci rcdhtfjesgfp hey cbbjrt whs mhic oy tgc phrcets jr jtgcr rcdhtfvcs tj scttdc tgcfr ifsputc hei tj cbbcnt h njenfdfhtfje. Ft hppchrci tght tgc bhtgcr ghi ej shy fe tgc mhttcr, hei gc whs ejt cvce cxhmfeci hs h wftecss tj suppjrt tgc nhsc jb tgc rcspjeicet. 2. Ygjulg tgc rcspjeicet hsscrtci tght sgc ghi mhic scvcrhd njmpdhfets tj tgc pjdfnc rclhrifel gcr fdd trchtmcet oy tgc hppcddhet ej sung rcpjrt whs prjvci. Ygc jedy rcpjrt prjvci, Cx. 8 whs djilci hbtcr tgc rcspje rcspjeicet icet ghi dcbt tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjmc. 6

Fe vfcw jb tgcsc bfeifels tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc nhmc tj njendusfje tght tgc rcspje rcspjeicet icet ghi dcbt gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc je gcr jwe hei tght sgc whs ejt njmpcddci oy tgc hppcddhet tj dchvc gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc, ejr ghi gc gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  ^S[_CMC NJS_Y JB FEIFH [hlc 9 jb 8;   gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  tgrchtceci tgc rcspjeicet wftg ifrc njescqucencs fb sgc ifi  

ejt dchvc gfs gjusc. Ygcrc whs ej lrjuei bjr tgc rcspjeicet tj hpprcgcei tght fb sgc dfvci wftg tgc hppcddhet gcr dfbc wjudi oc fe ihelcr hei tght sgc wfdd oc o c suoacntci tj tjrturc jr nrucdty. Fe sum hei suosthenc sgc ghi ej austfbfhodc rchsje tj icscrt tgc hppcddhet. Ygc bhnt tght tgc hppdfnhtfje bjr lrhet jb mhfetcehenc whs bfdci wftgfe bjur ihys jb gcr dchvfel gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc wftgjut hey cbbjrt bjr rcnjenfdfhtfje, whs hdsj sflefbfnhet. Ygc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc tgcrcbjrc gcdi tght tgc rcspjeicet ghvfel dcbt gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc wftgjut hey austfbfhodc lrjuei whs ejt cetftdci tj tgc lrhet jb mhfetcehenc. Gjwcvcr, sfenc gcr sje whs rcsfifel wftg gcr, tgc hppcddhet whs dfhodc tj t j phy mhfetcehenc bjr gfs sje. Gc, tgcrcbjr t gcrcbjrc, c, jricrci tght tgc hppcddhet sghdd phy h sum jb rupccs 83;; pcr mjetg mjetg oy why jb mhfetcehenc tj gfs sje. Hllrfcvci oy tgc jricr jb tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc tgc rcspjeicet prcbcrrci prcbcrrci h _cvfsfje [ctftfje ocbjrc tgc Gflg Njurt jb Nhdnutth. H dchreci Auilc jb tgc Gflg Njurt oy gfs jricr ihtci ?2tg Ejvcmocr, ?;;8 hddjwci tgc _cvfsfje [ctftfje hei ifrcntci tgc hppcddhet tj phy h sum jb _s.83;;/pcr mjetg tj tgc rcspjeicet hdsj bjr gcr mhfetcehenc brjm tgc ihtc jb bfdfel jb tgc mhfetcehenc m hfetcehenc nhsc hei hdsj hwhrici njsts. Ygc auilmcet hei jricr jb tgc t gc Gflg Njurt dchvcs mung tj oc icsfrci. Ygc sjdc vfrtuc jb tgc auilmcet hppchrs tj oc fts orcvfty. o rcvfty. Ygc dchreci Auilc Auilc hddjwci tgc _cvfsfje Hppdfnhtfje hei sct hsfic tgc jricr jb tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc wftgjut cvce ejtfnfel tgc bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc Mhlfstrhtc, ejr fs tgcrc hey ifsnussfje fe tgc auilmcet jb tgc cvficenc je rcnjri. Ygc jedy rcdcvhet joscrvhtfje fe tgc auilmcet fs tgc bjddjwfel 1” F ghvc pcrusci tgc  cvficenc jb [.\.8 (tgc

[ctftfjecr gcrscdb) hei tgc cvficenc jb [\ ?, gcr Mjtgcr hei F bfei tght tgc [ctftfjecr njudi prjvc gcr nhsc quftc prjpcrdy. Ft trhespfr trhespfrcs cs brjm tgc shfi cvficenc tght tgc [ctftfjecr ghi subbfnfcet rchsje bjr sthyfel hwhy brjm gcr mhtrfmjefhd m htrfmjefhd gjmc hs sgc whs suoacntci tj tjrturc hei ecldcnt. Je tgc

 

9;

njetrhry, tgc cvficenc jb tgc Jppjsftc [hrty whs h bccodc httcmpt tj whri jbb tgc hddclhtfjes mhic hlhfest gfm hei wcrc ejt quftc njevfenfel. Ygc cvficenc jb J.[.\. Ej. ? wgj wcet tj mh`c phymcet pursuhet tj tgc ifrcntfjes jb J.[.\. Ej. 8 ijcs ejt hdsj hppchr tj oc quftc q uftc njevfenfel. njevfenfel. Ygc cvficenc jb J.[.\. Ej. > fe wgjsc gjusc tgc Jppjsftc [hrty ghs occe rcsfifel whs tgc t gc Bhtgcr jb gfs brfcei burtgcr hppchrs tj ghvc occe tueci tj suft tgc nhsc jb tgc Jppjsftc [hrty. ^j, hdsj tgc cvficenc jb Jppjsftc [hrty Ej. 9. Hnnjrifeldy, F hm jb tgc vfcw tght tgc t gc bfeifel jb tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc rcbusfel tgc prhycr jb tgc [ctftfjecr bjr mhfetcehenc nheejt sthei hei sgc fs cetftdci tj he h e jricr jb mhfetcehenc hs jtgcrwfsc sgc ghs occe hodc tj prjvc gcr nhsc hei tgc bfeifel jb tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc tght sgc  —ghs dcbt tgc gjusc gjusc jb J.[. J.[. wftgjut wftgjut hey aust lrj lrjuei uei 

hei ghs ejt occe sunnccici tj csthodfsg tgc hpprcgcesfje jb ihelcr ihelcr tj gcr dfbc sgc fs ejt cetftdci tj lct mhfetcehenc brjm tgc J.[.” nheejt  gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  ^S[_CMC NJS_Y JB FEIFH [hlc 3 jb 8;   oc hnncptci.” 

Ygc hppcddhet ghs fmpuleci tgc hbjrcshfi auilmcet jb tgc Gflg Njurt ocbjrc us. \c ghi summjeci tgc phrtfcs tj cxpdjrc tgc pjssfofdfty jb h njenfdfhtfje out njuescd bjr tgc phrtfcs febjrmci us tght tgc rcspjeicet whs ejt wfddfel tj dfvc wftg tgc hppcddhet. Dchreci njuescd bjr tgc hppcddhet suomfttci ocbjrc us, hei wftg austfbfnhtfje, tght tgc auilmcet hei jricr jb tgc Gflg Njurt ijcs ejt ifsndjsc hppdfnhtfje jb mfei tj tgc cvficenc je rcnjri, jr tj tgc bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc Yrfhd Njurt, wgfng wcrc sjulgt tj oc sct hsfic oy tgc fmpuleci  auilmcet hei hei jricr. Ygc Ygc bfeifel jb tgc Gflg Njurt fs hs vhluc hs ft nhe oc hei ft fs ejt pjssfodc p jssfodc tj nudd jut tgc rchsjes wgfng pcrsuhici tgc dchreci Auilc tj sct hsfic tgc bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc Yrfhd Njurt. \c ghvc chrdfcr qujtci tgc rcdcvhet phrt jb tgc t gc auilmcet wgfng austfbfcs tgc nrftfnfsm jb tgc dchreci njuescd. Ft fs wcdd sc ttdci tght tgc Hppcddhtc jr _cvfsfjehd Njurt wgfdc scttfel hsfic tgc bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc Njurt ocdjw must ejtfnc tgjsc bfeifels, hei fb tgc Hppcddhtc jr _cvfsfjehd Njurt njmcs tj tgc njendusfje tght tgc bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc Yrfhd Njurt

 

98

hrc uetcehodc, rcnjri fts rchsjes bjr njmfel tj tgc shfi njendusfje. \gcrc \gcrc tgc bfeifels hrc bfeifels jb bhnt ft must m ust ifsnuss tgc cvficenc je rcnjri wgfng austfby tgc rcvcrshd jb tgc bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc Njurt ocdjw. Ygfs fs phrtfnudhrdy sj wgce bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc Yrfhd Njurt hrc sjulgt tj oc sct hsfic oy he h e Hppcddhtc jr _cvfsfjehd Njurt. Jec nheejt th`c cxncptfje tj h auilmcet mcrcdy je tgc lrjuei jb fts orcvfty, out fb tgc auilmcet hppchrs tj oc nryptfn hei njendusfjes hrc rchngci wftgjut cvce rcbcrrfel tj tgc cvficenc c vficenc je rcnjri jr ejtfnfel tgc bfeifels jb tgc Yrfhd Njurt, tgc phrty hllrfcvci fs cetftdci tj hs` bjr scttfel hsfic jb sung h auilmce auilmcet. t. Fe ejrmhd njursc wc wjudi ghvc rcmheici tgc mhttcr tj tgc Gflg Njurt bjr h brcsg njesficrhtfje jb tgc cvficenc je rcnjri, out ghvfel rclhri tj tgc ehturc jb tgc ifsputc, wc ij ejt njesficr ft ecncsshry tj prjdjel tgc prjnccifel hey burtgcr, phrtfnudhrdy wgce tgc cvficenc ghs occe pdhnci ocbjrc us, hei wftg tgc hssfsthenc jb njuescd hppchrfel bjr tgc phrtfcs wc ghvc ljec tgrjulg tgc cvficenc je rcnjri. \c, tgcrcbjr t gcrcbjrc, c, prjncci tj njesficr tgc cvficenc je rcnjri hei ifspjsc jb tgc mhttcr bfehddy. Ygc rcspjeicet whs cxhmfeci hs [\-8. Fe gcr icpjsftfje, sgc sthtci tght wftgfe 83 tj ?; ihys jb tgc mhrrfhlc tgc hppcddhet sthrtci fdd trchtfel gcr wftgjut hey rchsje hei cvce wcet tj tgc cxtcet jb sdhppfel hei `fn`fel gcr. Ygfs whs ocnhusc tgc hrtfndcs lfbtci tj tgcm wcrc ejt tj gfs df`fel hei gc eccici mjrc. Gc usci tj quhrrcd wftg gcr bjr pctty rchsjes hei hsshudtci gcr je mhey jnnhsfjes cvce tgjulg gc ifi ejt hrrhelc bjr gcr bjji hei ndjtgfel. Mhey h tfmcs gc irjvc gcr hwhy h why brjm gfs gjusc hbtcr hsshudtfel gcr hei sgc usci tj njmc tj gcr bhtgcr‖s gjusc bjr sgcdtcr.  

Gjwcvcr, gcr phrcets usci tj pcrsuhic pcrsuhic gcr tj lj ohn` tj tgc hppcddhet. Hdd tgfs gcr gusohei ifi ocnhusc jb lrcci. ^gc rcbcrrci tj tgc pjdfnc rcpjrts tght sgc djilci, out tgcy wcrc ejt prjiunci ocbjrc tgc Njurt. ^gc himfttci tght tgc hppcddhet ghi th`ce he hlceny jb Seft Yrust jb Feifh fe gcr ehmc hei bjr tght purpjsc gc ghi h ajfet hnnjuet wftg gcr fe tgc ohe`. \c mhy jedy ejtfnc ht tgfs sthlc tght tgcrc fs ejt cvce gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  ^S[_CMC NJS_Y JB FEIFH [hlc 2 jb 8;   gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  h wgfspcr oy tgc rcspjeicet hojut tgc scnjei lrjuei  

mcetfjeci fe tgc hppdfnhtfje ehmcdy tght tgc hppcddhet ifsdf`ci gcr je hnnjuet jb gcr uldy hppchrhenc. hppchrhenc. ^gc ghs rcbcrrci tj h bcw fenficets wgfng rcsudtci fe gcr djilfel

 

9?

rcpjrts ocbjrc tgc pjdfnc hei gcr trchtmcet fe h gjspfthd, out ej cvficenc whs prjiunci tj prjvc sung bhnts ejr ghvc tgc phrtfnudhrs occe mcetfjeci oy gcr. ^gc, gjwcvcr, himfttci tght sgc phssci gcr O.H. hbtcr gcr mhrrfhlc wgfdc sgc whs dfvfel wftg gcr gusohei. ^gc hdsj himfttci tght sgc hei gcr gusohei jbtce wcet tj ifbbcrcet pdhncs sung hs ^gfmdh, Ehfefthd, @jushef ctn. cvcry twj ychrs. ^jmc pgjtjlrhpgs wcrc sgjwe tj gcr brjm wgfng ft hppchrci tght je sjmc jnnhsfjes gcr cdicr sfstcr s fstcr hei orjtgcr-fe-dhw hnnjmphefci tgcm. ^gc hdsj himfttci fe tgc njursc jb gcr nrjsscxhmfehtfje tght gcr gusohei usci tj prhfsc gcr ocbjrc jtgcrs hei lfvc gcr nrcift bjr tgc ljji pcrbjrmhenc jb gcr sje fe stuifcs. Gc usci tj shy tght tgcfr sje pcrbjrmci wcdd ocnhusc jb tgc nhrc ocstjwci oy gcr. ^gc hdsj himfttci tght sgc httceici Vjlh ndhsscs wgfdc ht Ium Ium. ^gc hdsj himfttci tght wgce sgc whs th`fel tgc O.H. cxhmfehtf c xhmfehtfje je gcr gusohei usci tj hnnjmphey gcr tj tgc cxhmfehtfje ncetcr. ^gc sthtci fe gcr icpjsftfje tght sgc whs jbtce hsshudtci hei whs mhic tj dchvc tgc t gc mhtrfmjefhd gjmc hei ghi tj scc` sgcdtcr fe tgc gjusc jb gcr phrcets out sgc ghs ejt sthtci wgce sgc bfrst febjrmci gcr phrcets hojut sung ocghvfjur jb tgc hppcddhet. Ygcrc fs jedy sjmc feifnhtfje fe tgc njmpdhfet Cx. 8 djilci oy gcr hbtcr sgc dcbt gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc wgcrcfe sgc ghi sthtci tght sgc ghi tjdi gcr phrcets hojut tgc ocghvfjur jb tgc hppcddhet hojut ho jut cflgt ychrs hbtcr gcr mhrrfhlc. Hnnjrifel tj [\-?, gcr mjtgcr, tgc rcspjeicet ghi tjdi gcr hojut sung bhnts sjmc 3 tj 2 ychrs hbtcr mhrrfhlc. Ej dcttcr wrfttce oy tgc rcspjeicet tj heyjec ghs occe prjiunci tj prjvc tght sgc ghi cvcr njmpdhfeci tj heyjec hojut gcr fdd trchtmcet. trch tmcet. Fe suosthenc tgcrc fs ej cvficenc c vficenc jb njetcmpjrhecjus njetcmpjrhecjus ehturc tj suosthetfhtc tgc hddclhtfjes rclhrifel fdd trchtmcet jb tgc t gc rcspjeicet. Ygc jedy njmpdhfet wgfng ghs occe orjulgt je rcnjri fs tgc Lcecrhd Ifhry Cetry Cx. 8 rcnjrici je 8?tg Mhrng, 866

t jrturci. Ft hppchrs rhtgcr tght gcr ihulgtcr whs ocfel tjrturci. surprfsfel tght fb sung jnnurrcencs tjj` pdhnc ht rcludhr fetcrvhds, hei sthrtci wftgfe 83 ihys jb tgc mhrrfhlc, tgc mjtgcr jb tgc rcspjeicet wjudi ghvc njmc tj `ejw hojut ft 3 jr 2 ychrs hbtcr tgc mhrrfhlc. Gjwcvcr, Gjwcvcr, fe tgc Lcecrhd Ifhry Cetry ljt rcnjrici oy [\-8 sgc ghi sthtci tght sgc tjdi gcr mjtgcr hojut sung jnnurrc jnnurrcencs encs cflgt ychrs hbtcr tgcfr mhrrfhlc. Ygcrc fs ejtgfel fe tgc cvficenc jb [\-? tj suppjrt tgc nhsc tght tgc hppcddhet cvcr icmheici ijwry. Je tgc jtgcr ghei [\-? himfttci tght tgc hppcddhet ecvcr icmheici hey ijwry cvce hbtcr mhrrfhlc, out hiici tght tgjulg gc ecvcr mhic hey icmhei ft whs fe gfs mfei. Brjm tgc cvficenc je rcnjri ft hppchrs tght tgc lfbts lfvce ht tgc t gc tfmc jb mhrrfhlc wcrc tgc usuhd lfbts wgfng hrc lfvce je sung jnnhsfjes sung hs oci, hdmfrhg, ircssfel i rcssfel thodc, whtng, thpc rcnjricr hei jrehmcets bjr tgc orfic. Ygcrc fs ej cvficenc wghtsjcvcr je rcnjri tj sullcst tght ocbjrc tgc mhrrfhlc, ht tgc sthlc jb ecljtfhtfjes, hey icmhei whs mhic gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  ^S[_CMC NJS_Y JB FEIFH [hlc < jb 8;   gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  jr hey phrtfnudhr hmjuet jr tgfel whs hs`ci bjr oy tgc  

hppcddhet. Je tgc jtgcr ghei tgc hppcddhet ghs cxhmfeci gfmscdb hs J[\ ïT?;;T??>8 hei icefci hdd tgc hddclhtfjes mhic hlhfest gfm. Gc hsscrtci tght gc ghi ecvcr icmheici hey ijwry ht tgc tfmc jb mhrrfhlc jr tgcrchbtcr. Fe bhnt gfs rcdhtfvcs hei brfceis `ecw tght gc whs fe prfenfpdc hlhfest tgc ijwry systcm. Ygcrc whs, tgcrcbjrc, ej qucstfje jb gfs tjrturfel gfs wfbc bjr ejt orfelfel subbfnfcet ijwry jr bjr ejt ocfel ghppy wftg tgc lfbts orjulgt oy gcr. Gc hsscrtci tght gc tjj` ljji nhrc jb gfs wfbc hei cvce hbtcr mhrrfhlc gc pcrmfttci gcr tj njetfeuc gcr stuifcs hei sgc jothfeci gcr O.H. iclrcc hbtcr mhrrfhlc. Gc ghi h ajfet hnnjuet wftg gcr wgfng sgc njudi jpcrhtc hei gc ghi scnurci he hlceny jb Seft Yrust jb Feifh bjr gcr sj tght ft njudi `ccp gcr celhlci. Je tgc njetrhry, gc sthtci tght ft whs fe tgc ychr 8662 tght sjmc uetjwhri fenficet tjj` pdhnc hei tght whs ocnhusc gfs mjtgcr-fe-dhw hs wcdd hs tgc rcspjeicet fesfstci tght gc sgjudi sgfbt gfs rcsficenc tj Nhdnutth. Hojut sung fenficet gc djilci h rcpjrt ht tgc pjdfnc p jdfnc sthtfje. Gc burtgcr sthtci tght je 88.?.866< tgc phrcets jb rcspjeice rcspjeicett ghi njmc tj gfs gjusc hei hs`ci gfm tj dfvc fe tgcfr gjusc jr tj th`c h rcetci gjusc echr tgcfr gjusc fe Nhdnutth. Hbtcr sjmc hrlumcet tgcy wcet hwhy. Hlhfe je 82tg Bcoruhry, 866 tj [hengmhrgf, [htef, Ahohdpur ctn. Ygcy ghi ljec tj ^gfmdh, @udu, Mhehdf fe 8663. ^jmc pgjtjlrhpgs wcrc prjiunci wgfng wcrc th`ce wgce gc hei gfs wfbc ghi vfsftci sung pdhncs. Ygc hppcddhet hdsj cxhmfeci wftecsscs tj prjvc tght gc hei gfs wfbc ceajyci njrifhd rcdhtfjesgfp hei tgfs bhnt whs `ejwe tj rcdhtfvcs hei bhmfdy brfceis. Gc cxhmfeci wftecsscs tj prjvc tght wgfdc tgcy wcrc tjlctgcr tgcrc whs ej ifsturohenc fe tgcfr bhmfdy dfbc hei tgcfr rcdhtfjesgfp whs njrifhd. Ygc wftecsscs hdsj suppjrt gfs nhsc tght cvce hbtcr tgc rcspjeicet dcbt gfs gjusc gc ghi scet gfs brfceis tj gcr wftg mjecy bjr gcr ecncsshry cxpcescs. J[\-?, fs h bhmfdy brfcei. Gc icpjsci tght gc ghi httceici tgc buentfje wgce tgc hppcddhet hei rcspjeicet ljt mhrrfci. Gc hdsj sthtci tght gc ifi ejt bfei hey ifsturohenc ifsturohenc fe tgcfr bhmfdy dfbc out gc nhmc tj `ejw hojut ft fe mfi 866, fs h dheidhiy jb tgc hppcddhet. Hnnjrifel Hnnjrifel tj gcr tgc hppcddhet tjj` nhrc jb gfs wfbc hei sje hei ifi ejt tjrturc gcr cvce tgjulg tgc rcspjeicet whs ejt vcry jocifcet. ^urprfsfeldy, tj tgfs wftecss h sullcstfje whs mhic oy tgc nrjss ïT?;;T?? ïT?;;T??>cxhmfefel >cxhmfefel njuescd njuescd tght tgc hppcddhet whs fe djvc wftg gcr ihulgtcr-fe-dhw hei tght fs wgy gc usci tj lj tj gcr gjusc. Ygfs whs jb njursc stjutdy icefci oy J[\->. Ygfs bhnt ghs occe ejtfnci oy tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc out njuescd bjr tgc rcspjeicet fe tgc njursc jb gfs hrlumcet ocbjrc tgc Mhlfstrhtc ifi ejt pursuc p ursuc tgfs dfec hey burtgcr hei sthtci tght tgc t gc rcspjeicet rcspjeicet ghi ej lrfcvhenc hojut tgc nghrhntcr jb tgc hppcddhet. \c hrc surprfsci tght njuescd bjr tgc rcspjeicet put sung h qucstfje tj tgc wftecss wgce sung gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  ^S[_CMC NJS_Y JB FEIFH [hlc 7 jb 8;   whs ejt tgc njmpdhfet fe tgc hppdfnhtfje ueicr ^cntfje 8?3  

Nr. [.N. ejr ghi tgc rcspjeicet hs [\-8 jr gcr mjtgcr hs [\-? sthtci heytgfel tj tgc cbbcnt tght tgc hppcddhet ghi he

 

93

hbbhfr wftg hey jtgcr dhiy. \ftgjut tgcrc ocfel hey ohsfs fe tgc pdchifels, jr cvce fe tgc cvficenc cxhmfeci oy tgc hppdfnhet, tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc sgjudi ejt ghvc pcrmfttci sung h qucstfje tj oc put tj tgc wftecss, phrtfnudhrdy wgce ft rcbdcntci ejt jedy je tgc nghrhntcr jb tgc hppcddhet out hdsj je hejtgcr dhiy wgj whs ejt h phrty tj tgc prjnccifel. prjnccifel. Fe jur vfcw, dchreci Mhlfstrhtc whs rcmfss fe pcrmfttfel sung h qucstfje tj oc put tj tgc t gc wftecss hei fe rcnjrifel rcnjrifel tgc heswcr lfvce oy tgc wftecss. Gc sgjudi ejt ghvc pcrmfttci sung mhttcrs tj lj je rcnjri. Ygfs gjwcvcr, ifsndjscs tgc httftuic jb tgc rcspjeicet hei tgc cxtcet tj wgfng sgc njudi lj tj mhdfle tgc hppcddhet hei threfsg gfs fmhlc. J[\-9, fs h ngfdigjji brfcei jb tgc hppcddhet hei whs prcscet wgce tgc ecljtfhtfje bjr tgc mhrrfhlc tjj` pdhnc. Hnnjrifel tj gfm, tgcrc whs ej icmhei bjr ijwry jr hey phrtfnudhr hrtfndc. Hbtcr tgc mhrrfhlc gc usci tj vfsft tgc gjusc jb tgc hppcddhet hei gc bjuei tght tgcfr rcdhtfjesgfp whs vcry ljji. Gc ghi hdsj ljec twj tfmcs tj tgc t gc gjusc jb tgc rcspjeicet hbtcr sgc dcbt gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc ht tgc ocgcst jb tgc hppcddhet tj lfvc sjmc mjecy tj gcr out sgc ifi ejt hnncpt ft. J[\ ïT?;;T ï T?;;T??>2 ??>2 sthtci tght gc whs `ejwe tj tgc phrtfcs hei gc ghi jenc ljec tj tgc gjusc jb tgc bhtgcr jb tgc rcspjeicet tj ghei jvcr h dcttcr hei sjmc nhsg hei ojj`s ctn., out tgc rcspjeicet ifi ejt hnncpt tgcm. Ygfs wftecss hdsj sthtci tght mjecy jricrs wcrc scet oy tgc hppcddhet tj tgc rcspje rcspjeicet. icet. Brjm tgc cvficenc je rcnjri wc hrc shtfsbfci tght tgc bfeifels rcnjrici oy tgc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc wcrc buddy  austfbfci hs tgcy wcrc ohsci ohsci je tgc tgc cvficenc je je rcnjri hei hppchr tj us tj oc rchsjehodc. Fe gcr hppdfnhtfje tgc rcspjeicet ghi lfvce twj rchsjes bjr gcr fdd trchtmcet t rchtmcet oy tgc hppcddhet ehmcdy gfs lrcci bjr ijwry hei tght sgc whs ejt ljji djj`fel. ^j bhr tgc scnjei rchsje fs njencreci, fe tgc njursc jb gcr icpjsftfje, tgc rcspjeicet ghs ejt shfi sh fi h wjri hojut ft. ^j bhr hs tgc bfrst rchsje fs njencreci, je h nhrcbud snrutfey jb tgc cvficenc je rcnjri, wc ghvc hdsj njmc tj tgc njendusfje tght ej ijwry whs cvcr icmheici cftgcr ocbjrc tgc mhrrfhlc jr hbtcr tgc mhrrfhlc. Cvce [\-?, tgc mjtgcr jb tgc rcspjeicet ghi tj himft tght tgc hppcddhet ghi ecvcr icmheici hey ijwry jr lfbt. Jb njursc sgc hiici tght hdd tgfs whs fe gfs mfei. \c hrc, tgcrcbjrc, shtfsbfci tght tgc Yrfhd Njurt prjpcrdy hpprcnfhtci tgc cvficenc je rcnjri

 

92

t gcrc whs ecvcr hey icmhei wgfdc rcnjrifel tgc bfeifel tght tgcrc bjr ijwry oy tgc hppcddhet. Ygcrc whs, tgcrcbjrc, ej rchsje bjr gfm tj fdd-trcht gfs wfbc bjr tgfs rchsje. \c, tgcrcbjrc, bfei tght ojtg tgc rchsjes lfvce fe tgc hppdfnhtfje bjr gcr fdd trchtmcet hrc eje-cx eje-cxfstcet. fstcet. \c ghvc hdsj pcrusci pc rusci tgc cvficenc je rcnjri wftg h vfcw tj hsncrthfe wgctgcr bjr hey jtgcr rchsje tgc rcspjeicet whs fdd trchtci oy tgc hppcddhet. \c ghvc bjuei brjm tgc cvficenc je rcnjri tght tgc t gc ocghvfjur jb tgc hppcddhet ghs occe tgrjulgjut ejrmhd. ejrmhd. Ft fs himfttci oy tgc phrtfcs tght tgcy brcqucetdy wcet iurfel iurfel vhnhtfjes tj vfsft ifbbcrcet pdhncs. Je sjmc jnnhsfjes tgcy wcrc cvce hnnjmphefci oy tgc rcdhtfvcs jb tgc rcspjeicet. rcspjeicet. Ygc hppcddhet pcrmfttci tgc rcspjeicet tj njetfeuc gcr stuifcs cvce hbtcr gcr mhrrfhlc hei tght fs gjw sgc scnurci gcr O.H. iclrcc hbtcr mhrrfhlc. Gc hdsj hrrhelci he hlceny jb tgc SYF tj `ccp gcr celhlci hei hdsj jpceci h ajfet hnnjuet fe gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  ^S[_CMC NJS_Y JB FEIFH [hlc 6 jb 8;   h ohe` wgfng sgc njudi jpcrhtc. Hdd tgcsc bhnts lj tj  

feifnhtc tght bjr scvcrhd ychrs hbtcr tgcfr mhrrfhlc tgcy ceajyci ejrmhd mhrfthd rcdhtfjesgfp. Fe bhnt, tgcrc fs

cvficenc tj sgjw tght tgc hppcddhet usci tj prhfsc gfs wfbc fe tgc prcscenc jb jtgcrs oy njmpdfmcetfel gcr hei h ei lfvfel gcr nrcift bjr tgc ljji pcrbjrmhe pc rbjrmhenc nc jb tgcfr sje fe gfs stuifcs. Ygfs cvce tgc rcspjeicet ghs himfttci fe tgc njursc jb gcr icpjsftfje. Hphrt brjm tgcsc wc bfei ft ifbbfnudt tj ocdfcvc tght fb tgc hppcddhet sthrtci tjrturfel tgc rcspjeicet wftgfe 83 ihys jb tgc t gc mhrrfhlc, tgc rcspjeicet wjudi ejt ghvc rcpjrtci tgfs mhttcr ht dchst tj gcr mjtgcr. Hnnjrifel Hnnjrifel tj gcr mjtgcr, sgc nhmc tj `ejw hojut gcr fdd trchtmcet 3 tj 2 ychrs hbtcr mhrrfhlc. Hnnjrifel tj tgc rcspje rcspjeicet icet fe gcr njmpdhfet Cx. 8 sgc s gc ghi mcetfjeci hojut sung ghppcefels tj gcr mjtgcr hojut cflgt ychrs hbtcr gcr mhrrfhlc. \gfdc tgcrc fs rcbcrcenc tj rcpjrts djilci oy tgc rcspjeicet tj tgc pjdfnc rclhrifel tjrturc oy tgc hppcddhet, ejt jec sung rcpjrt ghs occe orjulgt je rcnjri wgfng mhy ghvc occe djilci ocbjrc tgc rcspjeicet dcbt gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc. Cvce rcdcvhet phrtfnudhrs hrc ejt ifsndjsci. Ygc jedy pjdfnc rcpjrt orjulgt je rcnjri fs jec djilci hbtcr tgc rcspjeicet dcbt gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc. \c ij ejt htthng mung fmpjrthenc tj tgfs rcpjrt. Ygcrc fs ej njetcmpjrhecjus njetcmpjrhecjus ijnumcet fe tgc bjrm jb dcttcrs wgfng mhy ghvc occe wrfttce oy tgc rcspjeicet tj gcr brfceis jr rcdhtfvcs mcetfjefel hojut gcr

 

9<

ocfel suoacntci tj tjrturc jr ghrhssmcet oy tgc hppcddhet. Ygc rcspjeicet ocfel he ciunhtci ciunhtci dhiy, ft fs ifbbfnudt tj ocdfcvc tght sgc wjudi ejt ghvc wrfttce dcttcrs tj gcr brfceis hei rcdhtfvcs iurfel tgc twcdvc ychrs tght sgc dfvci wftg tgc hppcddhet hs gusohei hei wfbc. Hphrt brjm gcr mjtgcr, tgc rcspjeicet ghs prjiunci prjiunci ej cvficen c vficenc c jb prjvc tght t ght sgc whs tjrturci hei ghrhssci oy tgc hppcddhet. Ygc dchreci Mhlfstrhtc hdsj ejtfnci tght tgjulg tgcy dfvci ht ifbbcrcet pdhncs hrjuei Nhdnutth iurfel tgc pcrfji jb twcdvc ychrs hbtcr tgcfr mhrrfhlc, ejt jec wftecss whs cxhmfeci oy tgc rcspjeicet tj prjvc tght tgc hppcddhet h ppcddhet trchtci tgc rcspjeicet wftg nrucdty. Je tgc jtgcr ghei, sjmc wftecsscs ghvc occe cxhmfeci oy tgc hppcddhet tj prjvc tght tgcy dfvci h ejrmhd dfbc hei tgcrc whs ej qucstfje jb tgc rcspje rcspjeicet icet ocfel tjrturci oy tgc hppcddhet bjr hey rchsje wghtsjcvcr. Cvce tgc jtgcr bhnts wgfng wc ghvc bjuei suppjrt suppjrt tgc nhsc jb tgc hppcddhet tght gc ghi ejt trchtci tgc rcspjeicet wftg nrucdty bjr hey rchsje wghtsjcvcr. Dchreci njuescd bjr tgc rcspjeicet dhfi lrcht cmpghsfs je tgc joscrvhtfje jb tgc Mhlfstrhtc tght tgc hppcddhet ocfel h ohe` cmpdjycc dchvfel bjr gfs wjr` fe tgc mjrefel hei rcturefel dhtc fe tgc cvcefel ghridy ghi hey tfmc tj fdd trcht t rcht tgc rcspjeicet. Ej ijuot, tgcrc fs sung he joscrvhtfje fe tgc jricr jb tgc Mhlfstrhtc, out tght fs ejt tgc ohsfs jb gfs bfeifels. Yjj mung cmpghsfs je sung h strhy joscrvhtfje fe tgc jricr fs ejt austfbfci. \c tgcrcbjrc gjdi tght tgc Gflg G flg Njurt whs ejt  austfbfci fe scttfel hsfic tgc bfeifels bfeifels rcnjrici rcnjrici oy tgc dchreci Auifnfhd Mhlfstrhtc. \c ghvc rchngci tgfs njendusfje hbtcr hpprcnfhtfel tgc cvficenc je rcnjri sfenc tgcrc fs ej ifsnussfje jb tgc cvficenc fe tgc auilmcet jb tgc Gflg Njurt. Njuescd bjr tgc rcspjeicet pjsci ocbjrc us h qucstfje hs h phrt jb gfs suomfssfje hs tj wgy tgc rcspjeicet rcspjeicet sgjudi dchvc gcr mhtrfmjefhd gjmc wftgjut hey rchsje rchsje.. Fe nhscs wgcrc tgcrc fs h ifsputc octwcce gusohei hei wfbc ft fs vcry ifbbfnudt tj uerhvcd tgc truc rchsje bjr tgc ifsputc. Hbtcr scphrhtfje wgce tgc rcdhtfjesgfp tures sjur, hdd sjrts jb hddclhtfjes hei njuetcr hddclhtfjes hrc mhic hlhfest h lhfest chng jtgcr. Cvficenc jb njetcmpjr njetcmpjrhecjus hecjus ehturc tgcrcbjrc pdhys he fmpjrthet rjdc fe sung nhscs hs ft mhy rcvchds tgc tgfe`fel gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  gttp1//ASIF^.EFN.FE  ^S[_CMC NJS_Y JB FEIFH [hlc 8; jb 8;   hei httftuic jb tgc phrtfcs tjwhris chng jtgcr ht tgc rcdcvhet  

tfmc. ^ung cvficenc fs usuhddy bjuei fe tgc bjrm jb dcttcrs wrfttce oy tgc phrtfcs tj chng jtgcr jr tj tgcfr brfceis hei

 

97

rcdhtfvcs jr rcnjrici fe hey jtgcr ijnumcet jb njetcmpjrhecjus njetcmpjrhe cjus ehturc. Fb rchddy tgc rcspjeicet whs suoacntci tj nrucdty hei ghrhssmcet fe tgc t gc mheecr hddclci oy gcr, wc ghvc ej ijuot sgc wjudi ghvc wrfttce hojut sung trchtmcet tj gcr brfceis hei rcdhtfvcs wftg wgjm sgc mhy ghvc njrrcspjeici. njrrcspjeici. Ygc rcpjrts hddclcidy h ddclcidy mhic oy gcr tj tgc pjdfnc mhy ghvc tgrjwe sjmc dflgt je tgfs hspcnt jb tgc mhttcr. ^ung cvficenc fs njmpdctcdy hoscet fe tgfs nhsc. Ft hppchrs tj us tght tgc phrtfcs dfvci ghppfdy bjr mhey ychrs hbtcr tgc mhrrfhlc tfdd hojut tgc ychr 8662, wgcrchbtcr wgcrchbtcr tgcrc whs sjmc mfsueicrstheifel wgfng udtfmhtcdy rcsudtci fe tgcfr scphrhtfje. \gy tgfs ghppceci, ghppceci, ft fs ifbbfnudt tj bhtgjm, out tgc cvficen c vficenc c je rcnjri ijcs ejt njevfenc us tght tgc rcspjeicet whs suoacntci tj tjrturc hei ghrhssmcet oy tgc hppcddhet, hei ncrthfedy ejt bjr tgc rchsjes hddclci oy gcr. Ygc Njurt fs ejt pcrmfttci tj njeacnturc hei surmfsc. Ft must ohsc fts bfeifels je tgc cvficenc prjiunci prjiunci ocbjrc ft oy tgc phrtfcs. Ygc cequfry oy tgc Njurt fs rcstrfntci tj tgc cvficenc je rcnjri hei tgc nhsc pdchici oy tgc phrtfcs. Ft fs ejt pcrmfssfodc tj tgc t gc Njurt tj njeacnturc hei surmfsc hei mh`c jut h tgfri nhsc ejt pdchici p dchici oy tgc phrtfcs jedy tj heswcr tgc qucry sung hs tgc jec pjsci tj us. Fe tgc rcsudt tgfs hppchd fs hddjwci hei tgc fmpuleci  auilmcet hei hei jricr jb tgc Gflg Njurt fs sct hsfic. hsfic. Iurfel tgc pceiceny jb tgc prjnccifel ocbjrc tgfs Njurt ft whs njetceici oy tgc rcspjeicet tght tgc hppcddhet ghi ejt phfi tgc hmjuet wgfng whs phyhodc oy why jb mhfetcehenc tj tgc sje. \c ghi ifrcntci tgc hppcddhet tj phy up tgc hrrchrs jb mhfetcehenc hei hnnjrifel tj tgc hppcddhet tgc hmjuet ghs occe phfi. Ygc rcspjeicet, gjwcvcr, ghs rhfsci sjmc ifsputc hojut tgc hmjuet phyhodc hei hnnjrifel tj gcr sjmc hmjuet fs stfdd iuc. \c ij ejt wfsg tj cxprcss hey jpfefje je tgfs ifsputc hei dchvc ft tj tgc phrtfcs tj t j th`c hpprjprfhtc prjnccifel ocbjrc ocbjrc tgc hpprjprfhtc bjrum, fb sj hivfsci.

 

96

 

3;

 

38

 

3?

 

3>

 

39

^uprcmc Njurt jb Feifh ^uefth @hngwhgh Hei Jrs vs Hefd @ungwhgh je ?7 Jntjocr, ?;89  Hutgjr1 ………………………..A. ………………………..A.   Oceng1 Y.^. Ygh`ur, _. Oheumhtgf EJE_C[J_YHODC

FE YGC ^S[_CMC NJS_Y JB FEIFH N_FMFEHD H[[CDDHYC AS_F^IFNYFJE

N_FMFEHD H[[CHD EJ. ?>8; JB ?;89 (Hrfsfel jut jb ^D[ (Nrd.) Ej. ?236/?;8?)

^uefth @hngwhgh & Jrs.

..Hppcddhets

Rcrsus

Hefd @hngwhgh

.._cspjeicet

A S I L M C E Y

_. OHESMHYGF, A. Icdhy fe bfdfel hei rcbfdfel ^D[ njeijeci hei dchvc lrhetci. ?. Ygfs hppchd fs prcbcrrci hlhfest tgc Jricr ihtci ?2.;2.?;;7 phssci oy tgc Gflg Njurt jb Mhigyh [rhicsg ht Ahohdpur fe Nrfmfehd _cvfsfje Ej.?>;>/?;;,;;;/- hwhrici tj tgc wfbc wgfdc hbbfrmfel tgc jricr jb mhfetcehenc hwhrici tj tgc twj ihulgtcrs. >. Mhrrfhlc jb tgc bfrst hppcddhet whs sjdcmefzci wftg rcspjeicet je 3.;?.8662 hs pcr Gfeiu rftcs hei tgc spjuscs hrc odcssci wftg twj ihulgtcrs. Ygc bfrst ihulgtcr He`fth fs hlci 8? ychrs hei scnjei ihulgtcr H`sgfth fs 7 ychrs jdi hs je tgc ihtc jb bfdfel jb ^D[. Nhsc jb tgc hppcddhet-wfbc fs tght wgce sgc whs dfvfel fe tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjusc, tgc rcspjeicet hei gcr fe-dhws wcrc ghrhssfel gcr je tgc lrjuei tght sgc ghs ejt orjulgt subbfnfcet ijwry. Ygc hppcddhet-wfbc fs hddclci tj ghvc occe suoacntci tj pgysfnhd hei mcethd nrucdty, icmheifel nhr hei ijwry. Hs tgc tjrturc ocnhmc fetjdcrhodc, tgc hppcddhet-wfbc ghi njethntci gcr orjtgcrs fe tgc ychr ?;;2, hei gcr orjtgcrs nhmc tj @jth tj th`c tgc hppcddhets ohn` je ?9.;9.?;;2. Ygc mhttcr whs rcpjrtci tj tgc ^GJ

 

33

[jdfnc ^thtfje, Mhghvccr Ehlhr, @jth hojut tgc nrucd trchtmcet mctci jut tj tgc hppcddhet-wfbc oy tgc rcspjeicet hei fe-dhws. 9. Ocnhusc jb tgc ghrhssmcet, ft fs sthtci tght tgc hppcddhet-wfbc njudi ejt njetfeuc tj rcsfic fe tgc mhtrfmjefhd gjusc, hei tgc hppcddhet- wfbc hdjel wftg gcr ngfdirce wcet tj gcr phrcets gjusc ht Ahohdpur. Ygc hppcddhets ndhfmci mhfetcehenc oy bfdfel pctftfje ueicr   ^cntfje 8?3  ueicr 8?3  Nr.[.N. ocbjrc tgc ^cnjei Hiiftfjehd [rfenfphd Auilc, Bhmfdy Njurt, Ahohdpur. @ccpfel fe vfcw tgc ecci jb tgc hppcddhets, tgc Bhmfdy Njurt oy fts Jricr ihtci ?6.8;.?;;< ifrcntci tgc rcspjeicet tj phy _s.>,;;;/- pcr mjetg hei _s.?,3;;/- pcr mjetg tj tgc hppcddh hppcddhet-wfbc et-wfbc hei tj chng jb tgc ihulgtcrs rcspcntfvcdy. 3. Hllrfcvci oy tgc hwhri jb mhfetcehenc, rcspjeicet prcbcrrci rcvfsfje pctftfje ueicr   ^cntfje >6< ueicr >6,;;;/- pcr mjetg hwhrici tj tgc wfbc hppchrs tj oc mfefmhd hei fe jur vfcw, tgc Gflg Njurt julgt ejt tj ghvc sct hsfic tgc hwhri jb mhfetcehenc. Ygc dchreci njuescd bjr tgc hppcddhets prhyci bjr ceghencmcet jb tgc quhetum jb mhfetcehenc tj tgc hppcddhet-wfbc. \c hrc ejt fendfeci tj lj fetj tgc shfi suomfssfje, out dfocrt dfocrty y fs rcscr rcscrvci vci tj tgc hppcddhet- wfbc tj scc` rcmciy  ocbjrc tgc hpprjprfhtc hpprjprfhtc njurt. 88. Ygc fmpuleci fmpu leci jricr jb tgc Gflg Njurt ihtci ?2.;2.?;;7 phssci fe Nrfmfehd _cvfsfje Ej. ?>;>/?;;< fs sct hsfic hei tgfs hppchd fs hddjwci. Ygc rcspjeicet fs ifrcntci tj phy tgc mhfetcehenc jb _s.>,;;;/- pcr mjetg tj tgc hppcddhet-wfbc hs jricrci oy tgc Bhmfdy Njurt hei hdsj phy tgc hrrchrs jb mhfetcehenc phyhodc tj tgc hppcddhet-wfbc wftgfe tgc pcrfji jb cflgt wcc`s. ………………………..A.   ………………………..A. (Y.^. Ygh`ur) ……………… ………………………..A. ………..A.   (_. Oheumhtgf) Ecw Icdgf0 Jntjocr ?7, ?;89 -----------------------