120904577 Notes in Statutory Construction by Agpalo

CHAPTER ONE: Statutes IN GENERAL c
c
c —c c c  c c c c
c —c ? c c   c  
c
c 
c 
  c c 
c c cc
c —c  c? ccccccc c 
c  c 
c 
c  
c  c   c 
c 
c c 
 
c c 
c c c c 
 c
c —c c
c c 
 c  c  c  c 
 c!


c


c cc —c "c c#
 c cc c c

c
c$%&'c   c —c c c
 c   
 c  c ( c   cc c ÿc  c)c
cc c
c
c —c 
c )c
 c  c c  c 
c
c 
c   c c 
c
*c  c
c   c c
c c
c
c —c 
c)c
c c

c c cc c
c 
c c  c
c 

c    c 
c ccc —c 
c
c )c 
 c c  c  c
c c 
c c 
 c c  
c 
cc ÿc 
c )c
 c  c  c
c c  c c  +cc c 
c
c 
 c
 c —c 
c ,c c  c 
 c c  c c c  
 c c  c  c
c —c Y 
 c ,c  
 c c  c
c c  c c c ccc
 c c c c c
c  cc 
c c
cccc Àc c
 c
c c
c c c c
c c
 c —c  c c
c)c
c c
 
 c —c 

  c  
c 

  c   c  
c
c
c)c
c c 
 cc —c  c c cc Àc 
c Àc m
c c #
c cc c
 c —c  c c )c  c  c
c  c 
 c $%-$,c$%'.c —c  
c c)c$%'/,c$%0/c —c ? c c)c c$%0/,c$%&1c$%2&c3cc —c !

c


c)c!


c


c —c 
 c c
c)c
c  c
4 c c c c c c

c

ENACTMENT OF STATUTES c 
c c
c —c  c c
*c
c
c
c
c —c Xcc c)c$%2&c   cc —c c )c $%&'c 5c ( c c c
c c  c —c 
 
c


c

c 
  c 



c )c  c c c +  c )c 
c —c 
c c c cc —c  
c c —c  c  c
c 
 c  c  c
c c
cc c c 
c c —c Yc 
 c c c 
c   c
c c  
 c
c  
 c
c
cc
c c  c c  c —c 
c  c ,c  
 c c  c  c  c 
 c
c
c ccc   c c   
c
c
c —c  ccc   c c! c? c —c  c c c)c
c c
cc ÿc ? c c c c c c  c  c
 c

cc   cc c 

c c  c —c   c 
c
 c  c c
c c c c c
c c
c —c 
c  
c  c c  +c c 
c c ccc c —c c c
 c —c ( ccc
 c cc6 c —c ! c
c 
c cc c c c6 c —c  c c c c ÿc  
 c ÿc ? 4c
c  c ÿc ! c
 7c
c c c c ÿc ! c c 
c
 
 c ÿc 
c  c —c c 'c
c
 
c c c c c c c/c c1/c$c —c 
 c cc  c cc
c —c (c
c)c
cc  c
c c
c c c
 
c  c  c   c
c  
 c —c c )c  c  c 
c
c  c  c
c  
 c  c 

c c c
cc —c  c
c)c  cc
cc cc
c   c c c  c )c  c  c
c  cc
c c
cccc Àc ! c  c c  +c  c 
c   c
c
c c Àc ! c c c c cc Àc c  c
 c 
c c  c c c 

c c  c c'c
c —c Yc 
c )c  c
 c c 1c 
c  c c  c c
c c c 
c
c
c

—c

—c

—c

—c

! c
 c cc'c
c c c
c c c 8c 6 9c  c   c 
c  c
c cc

cc Àc c c 8c 6 9c
 c  c
ccc
c ccc Àc cc8c6 9c  c
c
c 
c
c c  c c  c cc c c c c  c Àc ? c
c  
 c c c 1c c c  c 
c  c c
 c c c  c c c  c c  c
c c Àc  c
cc Àc X cc'-c
c
cc Àc 
 c ccc c)cc
*c cc6 cc c 
cc 
 cc Àc 14'c c
c c
 cc c cc c c c c c
 
c Àc 14'c c c c  c
 c )c c 
c

 c
c
cc Àc ccc c
c cc  ccc'-c 
c
cc  c  c
c
c  
 c:c'c
c c c
c  c  c
c
c ÿc cc ÿc 
 c cccc'-c
c
cc ÿc  c  cc
c c c c14'c c c
cc c
c c c

 c

c  
 c
c c  c —c 
c
c  c cc
c c 
 c  c —c  ccc
c c
c  c 
c cc c6 c cc
c
c  4c  cc c
c —c 
 c c

c
cc   c c/cc 1&c1c Àc  c 
c  c 
c c
 
 c  c ccc;;;c Àc 

c
 
 c c Àc   c  c c c c 
c  c
c c 
4c
c   c  c
 c
 
 cc Àc 
c
 
 c )c 
 
c 
 4c  c  
c Àc  c
c c
 
 cc
  c c
c Àc  
 c c)c c c  c Àc 
c
 
 c  c)cc,
c Àc c c c
 c

c4cc
c
 
 c c c
c  c c 
 c c  c —c ! c
c ccc —c 
c —c ! cc c
*c
c
cc —c c c c c "c 
 c c c  c  c c  c c c  
c c c 
>cc  cc c c c
c cc
 
c


c # 
c 
c —c ccc
 
c

c —c #
+  c cc
 c c 
cc
c —c 
c c  c #
c c $-c 
c  c
 
c c  >c c "c 
"c 
 c 
c c

—c

 c
 >cc c
c c c14'c c
c c 
cc
 c  c 
c c 
c  c 
 
c 



c cc Àc =c'-c
c
c

cc c cc 
c
c c
 cc 
>c c "c 
 c c'-c
cccc
c

c  c 
c —c Xcc
 
c
  c —c #
+  c cc
 c c 
cc
c —c  c c#
cc$-c
c Àc  c Àc X c)c14'c c
c c)c
 c Àc 
 c)cc
 c —c c  c c   c  c )c  c  c 
 
c 



c ccc
c
*c
 cc '-c
c cc c cc
c c  
c 
c —c 
 
c 



c )c 
+  c c
 c  c

c c 
c —c ( 
c  c c u  c  c c $.c 
c  c c
c Àc  c Àc X c)c14'c c
c c)c
 c Àc 
 c)cc
 cc c XALIDITY c   c c   
 c —c  c
 cc c
c Àc c c c
c
cc
c Àc  cc cc 
c c
c
c  c c
 c Àc ?    c c  c c    c c  c c c  c
c c c c 
c
c c 
c
c c —c c
 c
c cc c c  c c
c —c Y c 
c
c
c    
c c  
 c c c
c  c c    c  c c  
c
c 
 
c —c c 
 
c  c  c c  c c 
 c c c   
 c c
>c c cc c 
c —c (
c
 c c    
 c c
c c c  c c mc ! m c 
+  c  c  *c 
c
c c c —c m  c 
c  c 
c +  c  c 
c c c  c c    
 c c
c
c c
 
c
c c ?
c cc c+ 
c c —c Ycc c
c
 
c
c —c c  
c
c  

c c c 
 c 
c c   
c
 c —c  
c 
c c   c c c
c c 
 c    c —c m c 
c c    
c
 c c 
c  cc c ccc
cc c

c

 
c
c —c ! 
c c 
c )c c c 
c
c + 
c    c —c  
c  c c c  c  c 
c

c 
c
c
c   c —c   c c + 
c c c c  c 
c c c
 
c  c  c >c 
c  c  c c
c  c   c c c c c c 7c c
c —c c
 c c c8 
c
 9c)c
 c c
c  c c  c c  c c  c c 
 c c
c 

c
c c 
 c

c

 c Àc 8

 c c 9c Àc 6 c   c 
c c  c c + 
c c )c + 
c  c  c c  c cc c c+ c c c

c   c  c c c
c 
c 

c
c  
c
c  c cc c cc
c cu c
 c c
*c cc c+  c c c 
c c c 
c c
 c 
4c  
 c ccu c c 
c c c —c 
c 
c c  c 
c )c  
4c  

c ccc
c c
cc
 c
c 
c c  c  
c c +  c
c
c  c c  
c
c
cc c
c —c 89c)c
ccc c
c ccc —c 7c)c

c
c  ccc
c
c
c c 
c  c  c

c c 
c  c +  c
c
c c cc
 c 
c  c cc  c Àc c 

c )c c c c  c 
c  c  c
c c 
c c —c # c c c 
c c c c 6 c 
c 
c 
c  c
 c c 
 c c c 
c  c c
c   c  c c
c c c
c
 
 c  c —c  c 
c c c  c 
*c  7
c c
c  c c  c  c 
 c c 
c c 
c 
c Àc c 
c c c c  c c  c cc c#
c c+ c cmcc   c
 c
 cc c c =c c
c   
 c —c c
c c 
 c   c    c )c c c c  
c —c c
c c
cc
c  c c 
 c4cc 
ccc c >c c —c c 
c 
c )c
c
 c 
c c c  c c c

c —c c  c 
c c c

c  
 c 
c
c 
 c c c
 c c 
 c  c
c  c
cc
ccc cc+  c cc c  cc c c c

m c cc   
 c —c c c    
c
 c c c 

 c  c c
c c c c c c c c   c c  c
 c
c  c c c   
c 

c 
c c 
c
c c  c c c c
c

 ccc
c —c c c
 c c 
 c  c

 c 
c

 c  c 
c  c c 

 c c
c c c 
c  c  c
c  c  c 
 c c  c   c 
c 
c 
c c    
 c c c c Yc c   
 c —c @cc
cc   c cc
 c c
c 
c c
c c c cc
 c
c c c
c c
c c c cc Àc c ccc 
c c c
c Àc c
 c)c    
cc1cc ÿc X
c c c ÿc 
c
c  c   c  c c 
 c c c   c Àc =c "c
c 
c c  
c )c c c
c —c 
cc c
 c
:c Àc c c c 
cc   c c
 c 
 c Àc c c c c 
c c c Àc c c c c

c c
  c Àc c c c  c c
c
c
c Àc c c c
c
c cc c   c Àc c c c c 
 
c c c c    
 c —c c c cc —c  c c c —c  c c  c —c 
c c c —c c
c 
c
ccc
cc c
c —c 1c:c Àc   cc)c    
c
cc c
c
>c c
c c Àc # c c )c c >c c  c c 
c  c c
 c c    
 c  c  c
 c c 
c c 
 c c c c c c   c c c   >c  c
c 
c m Ac
c  c + c

c c 
 >c  c c  c 
c 
c
c
c >c c  c  c 
c  c  *c c
 c c 
 c c 
 c c c
c c  c —c  c
c —c c c c 
c
c c c c c 
c
c
c c c c c —c c  c 
c  c 
c c 
c c   c 
*c c   c 
 c 
c c c   c
c
  cc

 c cc

c

  c  c  c
c c 
c  c c c 
c
ccc
 c  c c 

c
 c —c u
c  :c 
c c 
c c
c 
 c c  c
c  
c  c c   c  c
 c 
c c 
c c 
c   c c 

c  c c 
c 
c
c
c c c —c  c )c 
c c 
c c
c 
 c
c  c  
c c
c  c
c   c  
 c  c c  
 c  c 
c c
c  c 

c
c  c 
c c 
 c c c
c
c  c c  c c c 
c  c 
ccc)c c
ccc
c cY
 



   
c c EFFECT AND OPERATION c =c
c
*cc —c c1c c,c8c
c c cc c c c c c c 
c u
7c c c
c 
c c 
c
 ccc  9c Àc Yc c  cc c
c
 c  c c 
c
c
c  cc
c 
c
c  c
c c  c
c c

c
 c —c c$2c 
c.c! *c$c c 
c c —c  c c
c Àc 
c c)c$.,
c c Àc  c c  c c c c uc c 
c c 
c 
 c c c   >c 
 c c c c —c Yc 
c 8  c c c c  9c )c   c c cc$.,
c c
c c cc
c c 
 c c =c
c
c c
c
 c
*cc —c Yc"c 
c c cc
  c  c cc c 

 c#c# c
c
c cc c —c ?
c c  
 c
 c c c c c  c 
c c 
c c 
 c  c  cc c —c 1c :c Àc Y c  c   c c  c  c c  c c
c  
c  c
c 
c  
 c c c ccc
 c c
c
 >c 
c 
 c Àc Y c c
c  c 
c c 
 c c 
>c  c  c 
c  
 c —c ?
c c c$%2&c 
c :c Àc  c
 c 
c  c c c c c 
 c  c c 
 
c  c 
c  c  c 
c c
c *c *c  c 
c   c 
c c 
c c
 
c
c c —c uc c 
c c 
c 
 c 
c c  cc
c
c c
c
 cc cc c >ccmc
c c 
c
 ccc cYmuc
c c 
c c
c  
c
c c c c  c cc
 
c c cc
c —c ( c  c 
7c
c c   c c
c
 c cc 
cc
 c cc  c
c
c c c cc
c 
c 
cccc
c c 
c
cc
 c 
c c
c
 c Àc 6 c 
7c c)c c 
 c c 1-----c
c c
c

c  c c
c 
c.-#ccc c 
 c  cc c  c
c —c 
4cc)c
c c
c  c  c
c c c 
c cccc c 
c c c 
c c   c c 
c c  
c
 c —c Y 
 c )c c  c  c  c
c c  c
c  c 
c  c 
 c c c c 
c c  c  c c
c>c c
c
 c cc c Y 
c
c 
cc c
 c —c c  ccc+  c cc c c #
c c  cc —c c c$'c —c =c
c 
 c 
c c  c c
c
c c
c c   c c 
c  c
c c 
c  c  c c 
c c 

c 
c
c mYc c  *c
 —c c$c 
c cc0c$%0/ccc0c$%0& —c c
c
c
c c
c 
c c 
cc
c
c c

c cc c


—c  c c8 ccc cc
9cc mYc  Ac  c c   
 c c c  c c  c c
cccc cc
ccc
c 
ccc c c c c
c  c
c c
c  
c c 
c  
c c  
 c  c 
c  c
 c c c ccc *c
c
c c c
c cc

 c  c c c

c

CHAPTER TWO: Construction and Interpretation NATURE AND PURPOSE c   cc —c   c c c
c c  c c  c
c  c c 
c
c  c c c
 c c c
c c 
c  c c   c 
 c c
   ccc

c c cc
c
c cc
cc c  c c ccc
cc —c   c c 
c c 

c    c

 cc c ccc cc
ccc c cccc —c c 
c c c  c c    c c 
 c c 
c c c —c =
cc c c 
>cc —c =
cc c c c
c —c c
c#
c)c    c —c ccc
   ccc

c cc
c
 c c   c 
c 
c c
c c c

c
c 
c c
cc 
ccc c u

c 
 c)cc c Ñ
 Ñ Ñ  c —c ? cm c2-%cc$c)c8c
c c
cc c
c c c 
+  c c c 
c
c c  c c c  
c
c  c
c
c ,   c
c cc c9cc —c ? c 2-%c c %c )c 8Yc  c c
 c 
c c 

 c
c cc
c cc
c
c
ccc
c
c cc cc 
c
c c
c c c    c c /-Bc
c
c0-Bc
9c —c Y c c 
c  c c c c  c  c  c
cc  c cc c —c Yc  :c Àc  c   c c 
c Àc Y c
cc
c
c
ccc
c 

 c c
ccc 
c  c —c Yc 
ccc c c
*cc
c 
c c c c c c
c  c
c c
c
cc 
c
c c #
c
c cc  c
c
 c —c 8c c  c  c  c

c c  c c c 
 >ccc
 c
 c cccc c c 
c 
c c c c  c
c 
c
c  c cc 
cc c
 9cc —c Y :cYc +c c
 cc c  c c* c 
c c 
 c c   c c 
c 
cYc 
c
cc
c c c1c :cc Àc 
c)c c Àc 
,c c —c (
 c cc
c
c
cc c c c c

c

=c 
ccc

c —c Yc 
 c  c c 
c c c c 
 c  c —c cc
 c
c
c c
 c c
cc 
c c 
c c
   c c  c 
c *c

 cc
 c c
:c Àc 
c   c )c 
c 
c c c 
c c
c c c c 
 c 
c 
>c 
c c  
c >c 
c  c
c
c c ccc Àc   c c c 
 c )c c 
 c c 
c c  c c 
c c c
c c c  c c  c
c c   c c
cc

c Àc c
cc
c
 c *c ccc cc
c ÿc cc'c
cc cc
cc c c c  c c + 
c 
 c c POWER TO CONSTRUE c   cc
c+ 
c  c —c ccc c
c
cc
c c
c c
cc
c 
c —c c   c
c
c c c 
c
c c 
c
c c
c c —c
c
cccc c c
c 
c

c 
 c c
c
c —c  
c c c 
c c  c
c 

 c

c  
c
c
 c

 c  c
c
c c 
c 
c 
c 
*c c 
 c c
c+ c
c c
 
c
c
 c c —c # c
c

c)cc Àc   c
c  c
c Àc m c

c c
c c
c Àc ? c
c c

cc —c u
c c c c)ccc
c Àc  :c ÿc c 

c c  c c 
c c ÿc  cc
cc  c ÿc ?c  c c c c  c c c

c
c c 
c
 c  c+ 
c   c —c c 
 c  c c  c  c c c 
 c c
 c —c 
c)c
c
c —c  ,c c c
c —c  
,c
 c
c
 
 c —c c c 
 c 
c 
c 
c
c
c 
c )c c  c 
c    @c  c c 
c c c  

c  c c c    c c 

 c c —c 
c    c c 
c   c c 

  c
c c c c

  c —c 
c  c 
c 
 c  c  c "c c c | 
  —c c2c c %c$%'.c   c )c  "c 
 :c 8
c c  c  
 c
c 
c c c c
c c 
c  c c c  c c  
cc 9c)cc c c
c —c 
c 
c ? c .%-c c $'c )c 8 c 

 c c c c
 c  c c c c ? c
c c cc cc c 
c 
c c c c  c 
c  c  c c
c   c c c  
 c c c c   c c c
9cc —c c c c   c —c X
c c c c

 c c c —c ? c.%-cc$'c)c    
c —c c 2c c %c $%'.c )c 
c c c $.c c /c $%&'c   c)c8 c

 c c
 c c c c c
 c  c c c  c  c    
c c 
c c c  c 
c c c
9c —c Y c + 
 c c  c c  c 
c c 
c
  c c =c+ 
c
 c
c cc
c —c 8
 c 
c c c
9c Yc 
 c c
c
 c c
c   
c  c cc c c  c  c 
 
c
c  c c  c  
 c c  
 cc —c Yc  c c  c 
c c
c
 
c 
c 
c c  cc c   c —c Yc c
cc c c
cc
c cc c 
 c c    c c
c 
 c  c 
c
cc 
 c
 c c
c c  c   c c
 c c + 
c    c  c   c c
cc c
 cc
c c c +c c    cc
c
cc
c c c

c
c c
cc
 cc 
c c c c 
c c  c + 
c    c c c
 cc c cc
c
  c c =c c
c  c
 c —c 8Yc  c 
c   c c c
c 
 c c c   c 
c Y6?c c c * c
c c c
c
c  c 
 c 
c
c  
c c cc
c
c%
 c c Y c —c cc c
c
c
cc
c c ccc

c c c   c
c c

c 
c c —c c c 
c c c 
 c c  c  c 
c  c cc c c 
cc   c —c Yc c
c
cc 
cc cc c c c  c c
c
c
c 
 c  c c
c

c c   c  c  c c   c  c   c cc 
cc
c ccc c

—c

—c

—c

? c
c
c
c c c c  c
c  c c 
c c c
c c
c  c c  c c c 
 cc
cc
c c c c
c
c  c  c

c 
c c 
c cccc+  c 
c cc    
c 
c 
c 8 c  c 
c  
c  c c  +c  c 
c c c c c c c Yc    
c +  c 
*c c  c
c 
c
c c
c
 c

c  ! c —c Yc
 c
ccc c cc0-c c c  c c
c c c c c


c c  c  c
c
+ 
c c  c  c c 
 c c  
c c c   c
c
 7c c ? c %'$c  c c
c 
c 
c c c
c  c c 
c
c c  c  
c c  c c + 
c  c c4cc0-c 
ccc c
 
c cc
c —c Yc
 c c
*c c c  c c  c 
c  c c  c  c $1c $%$1c c m  c1.c$%11cc c
c ccc  c c c 
c 
c  c 
c  c c c1.c$%/$c —c Y c cc
c8 c c c
 7cc ccc  c c c
c  c c
c
c c  c  c 
 c c
c 
c 
c c 
c  c
c c c cc
 
c cc
9c —c Yc
c
c

c  c cc c
c  c cc
cc —c c c
cc
c
c c cc ccc 
cc
c c
cc —c cc
cc
 7c c c c
c  c
 c c
c
c c c c c+ 
c  c c c   c 
c c c c
 
c cc
ccc —c Y
c  c c c 

c c c c  >c  c*c c ccc c c c
c c c c c c c  c c
 c 
cccc 
 c
*cc —c = c c  c c + 
c  c c c c  c cc
c
cc

c 
c cc
c c c$c c c  c c+ 
c c  cc —c Yc c c
c
c c c12&0cc
 c 
cc c
 c c c
c  c cc c cc
c

c
c c 
cccc —c m c  c 
c  
c  c 
c c  +c c  +c 
c c c c c  c c c  c c  c
c c c  "c c ccc c 
c c  c  c c  c  c c c 
 c
c 
c c
 c 
c c   cc cc c  ! 
c —c Yc  c c 
c c  c c  c 1/0c  c8c  cc  c cc 
c 
c  c 
c
c  c c   c c
c c c 9cc
 c  c 
c
 c  c c c 
c  c  
 c

c

—c


 c c
c c 
*c c 
 c  c c  c  c c c  c   
c c c c c c  c
 c  c

c
c c  c 
c  
cc Yc c c
*c c  c c
cc

—c c =c c c c c
 7c —c Ycc cc
 cc 
c
cc c ccc  c c c cc c c
*cc  c —c Yc c
c c c cc c c c c c  c
c c c 
 c —c c c
c
c c c 
 c c
 c
c c  c c 
c c   c 
 c  c c 
c cc
c —c