1-21 How to Avoid Torsion

› Note 21 Level 1

36

TheStructuralEngineer December 2012

Technical Technical Guidance Note

How to avoid torsion Introduction

The twisting of elements within structures due to eccentric loading is something that is best avoided as far as is possible. Such actions develop torsion forces in elements against which they were not designed to withstand. This Technical Guidance Note concerns this buildability and detailing issue that structural engineers must become familiar with in order to avoid otherwise unforeseen problems that can lead to significant remedial works on site and in some cases failures.

Original layout

Principles of torsion The rotation of a structural member along its axis is something that should be avoided as much as possible. It generates forces within the element that it is rarely efficient at resisting and can result in a significant increase in member size and even change in form. Some structural shapes such as steel channels are more susceptible to torsion where the shear centre is outside the web (Figure 1).

ICON LEGEND

W Further reading

Original detail

Revised layout

Cantilevering section of structure partially removed, leaving two cantilevering beams supporting one another

Inner skin of blockwork wall moved outwards, while the primary structure remains in place

usually occurs due to changes being made to the structure to accommodate services or in respect to the form of the building that has been established during the design process. Figure 2 shows typical examples of structural frame layouts that have been altered to the point where a member becomes subject to torsion.

Other examples are twin beams with unequal loading, curved beams on plan and angles. This note shows how to avoid torsion in structural members and what needs to be done when it becomes necessary for elements to resist torsion.

Original detail

It is possible to inadvertently develop torsion in structural elements depending on the structural framing layout adopted. This

TSE12_36-37.indd 36

Revised detail

It is important to understand that when a member is subject to torsion, this force occurs simultaneously to all other forces, i.e. shear and bending. With this cumulative effect, it is possible that the member may need to be increased in size to resist these additional forces. To prevent torsion from developing, the following rules should be followed when devising and revising a frame layout to a structure: Lateral support system to cladding altered from being fixed to centroid of primary element to being eccentric

• Consider how the forces are transferred Torsion induced by framing layout

Revised detail

Secondary beams shifted along a primary supporting beam, removing continuity

Figure 2 Revision to frame layout resulting in torsion in a member

Figure 1 A steel beam in torsion

Principles of torsion

W Applied practice

N

N

W

from one element to another • Avoid change in direction of forces from within a frame • Ideally, cantilevers should not intersect

N

Figure 3 Detailing examples of eccentrically loaded beams

22/11/2012 15:22

www.thestructuralengineer.org

37

Torsion induced via eccentric loading Considering more local effects, it is possible for structural elements to be subjected to torsion through the introduction of eccentric loads. While they were originally designed with the assumption that the load placed upon them would be largely within their centroid, changes to the form of the building or passage of services can result in an eccentric load being generated, which leads to torsion. Figure 3 is a pair of examples of such details which have been revised to the point where an eccentric load is being applied to the structural member. It is usually very difficult to avoid such occurrences as the reasons for the alterations are normally sound. Nevertheless there are measures the structural engineer can take to counter these changes:

• When developing cladding interface details, set parameters for the rest of the design team with respect to what can and cannot be altered • Highlight the consequences of inducing eccentric loads onto structural members to the design team. This includes an increase in member size, change in form and more complex connections Torsion induced during construction Structural engineers are required to consider the temporary works condition during the design of any element within the structure. While they are ultimately seeking to design a structural element for the permanent condition, some cognisance must be given to the possibility of a member being subject to torsion during construction. If there is such a possibility then the structural engineer is required to alert the contractor of this possibility and they can then carry out mitigation measures to avoid torsion being induced into the member for which it was not designed. This will include temporary propping of the member or altering the

Floor slab installed on one side of a beam that would fail due to eccentric loading condition

N

It is uncommon for the design of such elements to be designed for torsion as the contractor is alerted to the issue. The measures they employ can then be implemented to negate the need to design the element to resist a torsional load. When considering the likelihood of torsion being developed during construction, the structural engineer must:

• Consider alternative design solutions to prevent this from occurring • Assuming no viable alternatives exist, identify the member to the contractor and advise how they can prevent the member from being subjected to torsion • Advise the contractor at what point during the construction sequence the member will be subject to torsion Designing and detailing for torsion There are instances when torsion cannot be avoided and the designer’s only course of action is to allow for it. In such instances there are essentially two approaches: provide an arrest that prevents the element from being subject to torsion in the first place or design the element to resist torsion. If a restraint cannot be provided, then the member must be designed for torsion. For concrete elements this is relatively straight forward as the designer is required to provide additional closed links throughout the length of the beam that are installed in addition to any shear links (Figure 5). For steel elements the design to resist torsion is somewhat complex. This is especially with regard to open sections such as I beams and angles. To find out

more on this, you are directed to The Steel Construction Institute’s Design of Steel Beams in Torsion. Closed sections such as rectangular hollow elements are less susceptible to torsion but they are not as stiff as their open section counterparts. Additionally, the designer must pay particular attention to the end connections of steel members that are designed to withstand torsional moments. Simple fin plate connections are not robust enough to support such twisting forces, hence the need to provide end plate connections for members subject to torsion (Figure 6).

Eurocode 0.

Applied practice BS EN 1992-1-1 Eurocode 2: Design of concrete structures – Part 1-1 General rules and rules for buildings BS EN 1992-1-1 UK National Annex to Eurocode 2: Design of concrete structures – Part 1-1 General rules and rules for buildings

Glossary and further reading Permanent condition – The state of an element at the completion of construction Temporary condition – The state of an element during construction

Torsion – Rotational force along the axis of a member Further Reading Iles, D. C., Hughes, A. and Malik, A. (2011) Design of Steel Beams in Torsion Ascot: Steel Construction Institute

Masonry cladding constructed prior to floor construction, thus preventing restraint to primary support beam

Figure 4 Structural elements in torsion during construction

TSE12_36-37.indd 37

sequence of construction to prevent the torsion from occurring. Figure 4 shows two examples of elements that are subjected to torsion during construction.

N

Figure 5 Shear links vs. closed links

N

Figure 6 Fin plate connection vs. end plate connection

22/11/2012 15:22